Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MR Imaging of the
. Posterior Cruciate
Ligament: Normal,
Abnormal, and Associ-
ated Injury Patterns1
Andrew H. Sonin, MD
Steven WFitzgerald, MD
Frederick L. Hoff MD
Harold Friedman, MD
Michael E. Bresle, MD
The posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) of the knee has received little at-
tention in the radiology literature, but its importance in knee stability
has come under close scrutiny in recent years. Unrepaired injury of the
PCL can lead to chronic instability and early joint degeneration. Three
major mechanisms of trauma that involves the PCL are posterior dis-
placement of the tibia in a flexed knee, hyperextension, and rotation
combined with an adduction or abduction force. The spectrum of PCL
injuries includes partial tear or intrasubstance injury, complete ligamen-
tous rupture, and avulsion of the PCL insertion site on the posterior
tibia. Associated injuries include injury of other ligaments, meniscal tear,
bone injury, and joint effusion. PCL rupture is easily identified with mag-
netic resonance (MR) imaging by using simple signal intensity and struc-
tural characteristics. Because clinical and arthroscopic assessment of the
PCL can be difficult, MR imaging can be valuable for evaluating the acute-
ly injured knee when operative repair of the PCL is being considered.
U INTRODUCTION
Injury of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) occurs less frequently than injury of the
anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) (1,2). Historically, isolated PCL tears were thought to
be relatively insignificant and were usually not treated unless associated with bone
avulsion of the tibial insertion (2-6). As the potential for chronic instability leading to
Abbreviations: ACL = anterior cruciate Iigarncnt, PCL = posterior cruciate ligamcnt. STIR = short inversion time inver-
sion recovery, TE = echo time. TR = repetition time
u From the Department of Radiology. Northwestern University Medical School, Olson Pavilion, 710 N Fairbanks Court,
Chicago. IL 6061 1 (A.H.S.. S.W.F., FLIt); Northeast Illinois MRI. Lincolnshire. Ill (HF.); and I3erwyn Radiology, Chicago,
Ill (M.E.B.). Presented as a scientific exhibit at the 1993 RSNA scientific assembly. Received April 18. 1994: revision re-
questedjune 9 and received November 18; accepted November 21. Address reprint requests to A.H.S.
, RSNA. 1995
551
early degenerative changes becomes more rec- of the PCL and can accurately demonstrate the
ognized, increasing emphasis is being placed on presence and degree of injury to the PCL as
primary repair of acute PCL tears (7-9). More well as associated ligamentous, meniscal, and
complex injuries involving multiple knee liga- bone abnormalities (2,7-9). This article de-
ments, particularly the posterolateral complex, scribes the normal appearance of the PCL on
which includes the lateral collateral ligament, MR images and the mechanisms of PCL injury,
popliteal tendon, posterior horn of the medial illustrates the spectrum of appearances in PCL
meniscus, lateral head of the gastrocnemius injury, and discusses the types and frequencies
muscle, and posterior joint capsule, are less of associated knee injuries.
likely to result in a functionally satisfactory re-
sult without surgical intervention (3). U NORMAL ANATOMY AND MR
Attention has recently been
focused on the IMAGING PROTOCOL
integrity of the posterior joint
capsule and its The PCL is a spirally oriented fiber bundle that
effect on the success of repair
or augmentation courses from the lateral aspect of the medial
of the PCL (9). Because clinical
evaluation is of- femoral condyle to its insertion in a depression
ten difficult or has misleading
results, the diag- in the posterior aspect of the intraarticular
nosis of PCL tear can be missed ( 1 0); for in- tibia, approximately 1 cm below the articular
stance, the ACL is often torn in conjunction surface. The PCL is thicker (thickness, 1 .3 cm)
with the PCL, and physical examination find- and stronger than the ACL and has twice the
ings of tibial laxity may not be correctly as- tensile strength of any other knee ligament
cribed to rupture of the PCL (1 ,2,7). In addi- (15). Like the ACL, the PCL is extrasynovial but
tion, the PCL can be difficult to evaluate arthro- intracapsular. It is taut in flexion and becomes
scopically when the ACL is intact, and it usually predominantly lax in extension, with tension
cannot be directly visualized from the anterior retained in the posterior aspect. The ligament
approach unless the ACL is torn ( 1 1 ,12). Fur- subtends a vertical angle of 30#{176}-45#{176},
depending
ther, an intact meniscofemoral ligament of on the degree of flexion. Its blood supply is
Humphry can simulate an intact PCL even if the more abundant than that of the ACL (1). The
PCL is ruptured (13). Thus, an isolated partial P(:L serves as the major stabilizing structure in
tear of the PCL is often not confirmed at arthro- the knee, preventing posterior translation of
scopy even when suspected clinically on the the tibia on the femur and working in concert
basis of posterior tibial laxity. with the ACL and collateral ligaments to limit
Orthopedic management of acute PCL inju- rotatory motion.
ries has traditionally depended on the presence Imaging of the PCL is accomplished with
and severity of associated ligamentous injury standard knee protocols. At Northwestern Uni-
(1 -4,9). A marked increase in degenerative ar- versity Medical School, PCL imaging requires a
thritis and chronic instability of the knee has dedicated surface coil. We employ Ti-weighted
been noted in patients with PCL tears who re- sagittal images oriented along the long axis of
ceive conservative therapy and who have inju- the ACL, a 3-mm section thickness, a 0.6-mm
ries of the ACL, collateral ligament, or posterior gap, a 16-cm field of view, a repetition time
capsule (1 ,3,4,8, 14). The orthopedic literature (TR) msec/echo time (TE) msec of 500-600/15,
has advocated an approach to acute PCL injury and one signal. We also use coronal and axial
that specifies conservative treatment for iso- turbo spin-echo dual-echo sequences with a 4-
bated PCL injury and operative therapy for PCL mm section thickness; a 0.8-mm gap; a 14-16-
tears associated with other knee injuries cm field of view; an effective TRTFE of 4,000-
(1 ,4,5). However, controversy has recently 5,000/22, 90; one signal; and an echo train
arisen regarding the treatment of isolated acute length of seven. Additional sequences, such as
PCL rupture, with some authors advocating ag- turbo short inversion time inversion recovery
gressive surgical repair (3,8,14). (STIR), are used at the discretion of the super-
In contrast to the amount of attention de- vising radiologist.
voted to magnetic resonance (MR) imaging of On MR images, the normal PCL appears as a
the ACL in the radiology literature, surprisingly well-defined band of very low signal intensity
little has been written about MR imaging of the that courses between the medial femoral
PCL (7,8). In particular, the various types of condyle and the posterior tibia. In the sagittal
PCL injury and the frequency of associated biga- plane, the normal PCL is essentially always visu-
mentous and cartilaginous injuries in patients alized, appearing near the midline of the joint
with PCL tears have not been well described on two or three consecutive images. In exten-
(8). MR imaging provides reliable visualization sion (the usual imaging position), the PCL is lax
and describes a thick, gentle arc posteroinferi-
orly from the femur to the tibia (Fig la). The
b. C.
meniscofemoral ligaments of Humphry and cab portion of the PCL from its tibial insertion to
Wrisberg are often seen immediately adjacent the genu, where it is seen as an ovoid signal
to the PCL as they course from the medial void (Fig id, le).
femoral condyle to the posterior horn of the lat-
eral meniscus; they are situated anterior and U MECHANISMS OF INJURY
posterior to the PCL, respectively (Fig la). On According to the orthopedic literature, injuries
coronal images, the posterior vertical portion of of the PCL represent 2%-23% of all knee inju-
the PCL is seen in the intercondylar notch, adja- ries (3, i6). In 30% of cases, PCL injury is iso-
cent to the lateral aspect of the medial femoral bated; in the remaining cases, there is some co-
condyle (Fig 1 b). The ligament curves forward existent ligamentous injury (2). The two most
anteriorly, and the horizontal portion appears common causes of PCL injury are motor vehicle
as a circular or ovoid area of low signal inten- accidents and sports activity. Three common
sity within the intercondylar notch (Fig ic). mechanisms of PCL injury are as follows
Axial images are useful in visualizing the verti- (2,6,7):
1 A direct
. blow to the proximal anterior
tibia in a flexed knee, forcefully displacing the
tibia posteriorly and usually resulting in a
midsubstance tear of the PCL and often in in-
jury to the posterior joint capsule. This mecha- 3. Severe abduction or adduction forces,
nism is often seen in the setting of motor ye- when associated with rotational forces, may
hide accidents, where impact with the dash- rupture the cruciate ligaments after the colbat-
board results in posterior tibial displacement. eral ligaments fail. The ACL tends to rupture be-
Alternatively, a fall a hyperfiexed
Ofl knee can fore the PCL, particularly under valgus stress.
drive the tibia posteriorly, tearing the PCL. Internal rotation increases the tension on the
Tibial translation is limited by contact of the cruciate ligaments and is more likely to result in
calf and posterior thigh muscles, and the poste- injury of these ligaments. Meniscal tears are
rior joint capsule is less likely to be damaged. seen in conjunction with this mechanism ow-
With posterior tibial displacement, the collat- ing to torsional and distraction forces and can
eral ligaments usually remain intact. Bone con- involve either the medial or lateral meniscus.
tusions tend to occur at the site of impact be- Bone contusions occur at sites of impaction; in
tween the anterior tibial plateau and the poste- valgus or internal rotation injuries, for example,
rior femoral condybes (Fig 2). they are usually seen in the posterolateral as-
2. Hyperextension may cause avubsion of the pect of the tibia and in the articubar surface of
tibial attachment of the PCL, with preservation the medial femoral condyle.
of the bigamentous substance. With continued
extension, particularly when associated with U MR IMAGING FINDINGS
anterior tibial translation, the ACL may rupture Signs of a complete PCL tear include (a) failure
as well (Fig 3a). When PCL rupture is associ- to identify the PCL, (b) amorphous high signal
ated with varus or valgus force, collateral liga- intensity in the region of the PCL on Ti- and T2-
ment disruption is not uncommon. Contusions
are commonly identified in the anterior portion
of the tibiab articular surface and in the anterior
aspects of the femoral condyles (Fig 3b).
5a.
Figures 4, 5. (4) Complete rupture of the PCL. (a) Sagittal Ti-weighted image through the expected region
of the PCL reveals an ill-defined mass of intermediate signal intensity that roughly conforms to the shape of the
ICL (arrow). Normal PCL fibers were not identified. (b) Corresponding turbo T2-weighted image shows discon-
tifluitv of the PCL, with a focal fluid collection at the point of rupture (arrow). (5) Partial rupture of the PCL.
(a) Sagittal Ti-weighted image demonstrates a well-defined region of abnormal intermediate signal intensity
within the proximal aspect of the PCL (open arrow); however, intact fibers are noted superiorly (solid arrow).
These findings are consistent with a partial tear of the PCL. (b) Coronal turbo spin-echo proton-density-
weighted image shows an enlarged horizontal portion of the PCL that contains abnormal intermediate signal in-
tcflsitv (large arrow), consistent with a partial tear. The ACL is ruptured (small arrow).
weighted images without definable ligamentous high signal intensity within the substance of the
fibers, or (c) visualization of PCL fibers with fo- PCL in the elderly (17); in such cases, findings
cal discrete disruption of all visible fibers (Fig of intrasubstance injury must be correlated
4). A partial PCL tear or intrasubstance injury with an appropriate history of trauma.
does not meet these criteria but demonstrates We retrospectively reviewed the results of
significant abnormal signal intensity within the 2,739 consecutive MR imaging examinations of
substance of the PCL or has some fibers that ap- the knee performed at Northwestern University
pear intact and some that appear discontinuous Medical School from January 1 990 through Feb-
(Fig 5). Eosinophilic degeneration can produce ruary 1994. Seventy-one patients (2.6%) met the
MR imaging criteria for a partial or complete
tear of the PCL. The approximate site of a com-
plete or partial tear was subjectively catego-
[‘h. :,
j -
a. b.
Figure 7. Collateral ligament injury associated with PCL rupture. (a) Coronal turbo spin-echo proton-density-
weighted image through the posterior knee shows intermediate signal intensity within the vertical portion of
the PCL, representing an intrasubstance injury (large arrow). The lateral collateral ligament, fibular collateral
ligament, and biceps femoris muscle tendon are ruptured (small arrows). RT = right. (b) Coronal turbo spin-
echo proton-density-weighted image obtained more anteriorly shows that the medial collateral ligament is dis-
rupted (arrowheads).
a. b.
Figure 8. Greater conspicuity of PCL intrasubstance injury on coronal images. (a) Sagittal Ti-weighted image
does not clearly demonstrate a normal proximal (horizontal) portion of the PCL (arrow); adjacent images ap-
peared similar. (b) Coronal turbo spin-echo proton-density-weighted image demonstrates abnormal intermedi-
ate signal intensity within the corresponding horizontal portion of the PCL (arrow), consistent with a partial
tear. Similar advantages are found when axial images are used to visualize the vertical portion of the PCL.
c.t_
4. (-. . ...
i#{149} “
Figure 10. Use of STIR imaging for improved visualization of associated bone contusions in an 18-year.old
man with a partial PCL tear secondary to a hyperextension injury. (a) Sagittal Ti-weighted image demonstrates
amorphous low signal intensity in the marrow of the anterior tibia and femur, consistent with contusions (ar-
rows). (b) On a corresponding turbo STIR image, the contusions are more conspicuous. The linear zone of very
high signal intensity represents a fracture (arrow).
In our experience, sagittab MR images are the detected on sagittab MR images, can often be
most important in the diagnosis of PCL injury. confirmed more readily on coronal or axial im-
Their importance is due primarily to the fact ages (Fig 8). Long TRITE images are often use-
that the majority of PCL injuries occur in the ful for accurate grading of PCL injury (Fig 9),
midsubstance of the PCL, an area not well dem- and Ti-weighted or STIR images are valuable in
onstrated on coronal or axial MR images. The assessment of associated bone marrow injury
horizontal and vertical portions of the PCL are (Fig 10).
better depicted in the coronal and axial planes;
injuries involving these regions, although often