Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ankle instability: ankle. Freeman introduced the term “functional instability” for a
group of patients who complain of giving way but do not have
M Hossain PG Cert MSc (Orth Eng) MSc (Oxon) FRCSGlasg (Tr and Orth) Senior Foot
and Ankle Fellow, Cardiff Regional foot and ankle unit, University
Hospital of Llandough, Llandough, UK. Conflicts of interest: none
declared.
R Thomas BSc (Hons) FRCS (Tr and Orth) FFSEM(UK) Consultant Orthopaedic
Surgeon, Cardiff Regional foot and ankle unit, University Hospital of
Llandough, Llandough, UK. Conflicts of interest: none declared. Figure 1 Interplay of factors in chronic ankle instability.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 145 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
FOOT AND ANKLE
CFL
The CFL is angulated posteriorly in the neutral position of the
ankle but becomes more vertical in ankle dorsiflexion and in this
position acts as a true collateral ligament. It spans both the ankle
and the subtalar joints. The CFL resists ankle inversion with the
ankle in neutral to dorsiflexion and is an important stabiliser of
the subtalar joint. It is relaxed in a valgus ankle and stressed in a
varus position.
It is therefore apparent that throughout the arc of ankle mo-
tion either the ATFL or the CFL acts as a true collateral ligament
of the ankle (ATFL in plantarflexion and CFL in dorsiflexion).
There is a window in this range of movement where neither of
the two ligaments is able to support the ankle. The mean normal
angle between the two ligaments is 105 (range 70 e140 ). If the
angle between the two ligaments is increased then the window of
instability also enlarges. Individuals with such an anatomical
Figure 2 Anatomy of the ankle: lateral ligaments and the anterior inferior variation may be more prone to develop ankle instability.
tibio-fibular ligament.
CFL: the CFL is a distinct structure. It is not a capsular thickening Practice point 1
but is extra-capsular. It is in close proximity to the peroneal
tendons. During surgical exploration these tendons act as a C ATFL stabilises the ankle in PF
landmark for the CFL. It is found immediately deep to, and runs C CFL stabilises the ankle in DF
at right angles to, the peroneal tendons. The CFL originates from C ATFL is the weakest of the lateral ligaments and is the most
the tip of the fibula and runs downwards and backwards to frequently injured
attach to a tubercle situated on the postero-lateral surface of C Individuals who have widely spaced ATFL and CFL may be more
calcaneus. It’s footprint on the calcaneus is around 3 cm poste- prone to chronic ankle instability
rior and superior to the peroneal tubercle. There is some varia- C Varus hindfoot and tight tendo Achilles both predispose to ankle
tion in its proximal attachment. Instead of attaching proximally instability
to the tip of the fibula, the CFL can be attached to the ATFL or
have attachments to both fibula and ATFL.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 146 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
FOOT AND ANKLE
observed that the dominant ankle is more prone to injury than ankle dorsiflexion represents a positive impingement test. This
the non-dominant side. could be due to a meniscoid lesion from injury to the AITFL as
described above. Tenderness over the talar dome that is worse on
Clinical features palpation but not on dorsiflexion might be due to an osteo-
chondral injury. Tenderness posterior to the fibula suggest
Patients may present with pain, swelling, giving way, activity
peroneal tendon pathology. Peroneal tendons are frequently
limitation etc. It is important to elicit in the history how long ago
injured in ankle sprains. If the peroneal tendons are unstable
the first acute event occurred, what treatment was offered, how
there may be obvious prominence at the back of the fibula or this
frequently the ankle gives way and what are the precipitating
may be brought about by resisted eversion with the ankle.
factors. Pain at rest, between episodes of giving way, may sug-
gest underlying chondral injury.
Move: the range of movement of the ankle should be ascertained
Clinical examination and the strength of the peroneal muscles tested. Tests for
Look: examination commences with the patient standing with generalised joint laxity (Beighton score) should also be per-
both knees exposed to allow lower limb assessment. As dis- formed to rule out systemic instability.
cussed earlier, subtle varus of the foot is a known risk factor for Silfverskiold test e tightness in gastrocnemius muscles and
ankle instability (Figure 3). This requires a subjective assess- tendo Achilles should be sought by assessing ankle range of
ment, as there is no evidence-based guideline regarding what motion with the knees extended and flexed. If ankle dorsiflexion
constitutes the threshold for diagnosis of a “subtle varus is limited on knee extension but improved on knee flexion this
ankle”. Normal hindfoot alignment is few degrees of valgus. suggests gastrocnemius tightness. Alternatively, if ankle dorsi-
Assessing gait also gives an opportunity to observe whether the flexion is limited on knee extension but not improved on knee
peroneal tendons dislocate during gait. Some patients with flexion, this suggests that the tendo Achilles may be tight.
complaints of ankle instability actually have peroneal insta- Anterior draw test e this test (Figure 4) evaluates the ATFL.
bility that gives a perception of the ankle giving way. The site The patient needs to be relaxed, seated with the knee flexed and
and size of any swelling is also noted. Swelling can be present the ankle plantar flexed around 10e20 . One of the examiner’s
over the lateral malleolus, lateral gutter, peroneal tendons or hands stabilises the tibia and, with the other hand, the foot is
the ankle joint. If pain is present it is useful to ask patients if pulled forwards. An alternative way to perform this test is to
they can identify the site of pain with a single finger. Patients stabilise the heel on the bed with one hand and pull tibia for-
with chronic ankle instability frequently have concomitant wards with the other hand. The test should be compared with
injury and the site of pain they identify may be indicative of the contralateral ankle. Although different grades of positivity
this. Muscular and proprioceptive control of the leg is assessed are described, the inter- and intra-observer reliability are likely
by asking the patient to stand on one leg at a time with eyes to be low. A recent consensus statement has therefore recom-
open and then with them closed. Patients who are unable to mended that positive tests be described as stable, unstable or
remain steady on their ankle with the eyes closed have a pro- unstable with a sulcus sign.5 A sulcus sign is present when a
prioceptive deficit.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 147 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
FOOT AND ANKLE
dimple is seen in the lateral gutter on testing. It is not External rotation stress test e this test is performed to assess
commonly seen in practice. for syndesmosis injury. The knee is flexed and the leg stabilized
An anterolateral draw test has also been described in the with one hand, while the other hand externally rotates the foot. A
literature that is claimed to be more sensitive and specific in positive test reproduces pain over the syndesmosis. The external
detecting ATFL injury but has not been clinically validated or rotation stress test has a low sensitivity but high specificity to
widely adopted.6 detect syndesmotic injury.7 This means that many injuries remain
undetected by this test but there are few false positive cases.
Practice point 2
Talar tilt test e this test (Figure 5) evaluates the CFL. With the Radiology
ankle plantigrade the hindfoot is tilted one way then the other to Weight bearing AP, mortise and lateral views of the ankle are
assess for asymmetric movement. Palpation over the talar neck standard images. Plain films may show syndesmotic injury,
helps to differentiate movement of the ankle from the subtalar osteochondral fracture of the talus or avulsion fracture of fibula
joint. It is often difficult to compare between sides. Tilting both (Figure 6). An ossicle at the tip of the lateral malleolus is also
heels simultaneously with the patient prone may allow better
comparison between the two sides.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 148 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
FOOT AND ANKLE
Stress views
Ultrasound
Stress views (Figures 7 and 8) allow objective assessment of
Ultrasound is useful in skilled hands, particularly to assess the
displacement under load. These views should be performed with
peroneal tendons, but has been made redundant by the wide-
comparative views of the normal side. It is useful to understand that
spread availability of MRI scanning.
there is no consensus in the published literature, or good evidence,
to indicate the true cut-off for a positive test. More than 4 mm MRI
anterior displacement is considered positive in the anterior draw MRI (Figure 9) allows not only the assessment of the ATFL and
test. Talar tilt is measured by drawing a line tangential to the CFL but also of local tendons and bones. The diagnostic accuracy
articular surfaces of the distal tibia and talus. The talar tilt angle is of MRI has been widely investigated. The ATFL is best seen in
formed by the convergence of these two lines. More than 6 differ- axial cuts at a level where the fibula appears as a comma shaped
ence between the two sides is considered positive and more than 15 structure. At this level the ATFL bridges the anterior margin of
difference indicative of injury to both the ATFL and the CFL.8 distal tibia and fibula. High signal or disruption is suggestive of
injury.
Treatment
Conservative
All patients should have an initial trial of conservative treat-
ment.5 Treatment following acute ankle injury consists of rest,
elevation, ice packs and some form of ankle immobilisation for a
short period. There is evidence that any type of immobilisation:
such as taping, functional bracing, Aircast walker or short leg
cast may be more helpful than no support.9 Therefore patient
compliance and preference may be taken into account in
choosing a form of immobilisation. Once the acute episode has
resolved it is important to organize physiotherapy for appropriate
rehabilitation. This consists of proprioception training, peroneal
tendon strengthening, tendo Achilles stretching and balance
training. Proprioceptive training is imparted with the wobble
board and peroneal strengthening with Theraband exercises.
Data is available for short term efficacy following neuromuscular
rehab but long term follow up results are not known.10 Taping of
the ankle reduces mechanical instability and has also been pro-
posed as a prophylactic intervention, especially in athletes.11
Patients who fail to improve with conservative treatment may
Figure 8 EUA: talar tilt. benefit from surgical intervention.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 149 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
FOOT AND ANKLE
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 150 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
FOOT AND ANKLE
REFERENCES 9 Lamb SE, Marsh JL, Hutton JL, Nakash R, Cooke MW, Collaborative
1 O’Loughlin PF, Murawski CD, Egan C, Kennedy JG. Ankle instability in Ankle Support Trial (CAST Group). Mechanical supports for acute,
sports. Phys Sportsmed 2009 Jun; 37: 93e103. severe ankle sprain: a pragmatic, multicentre, randomised controlled
2 Yeung MS, Chan KM, So CH, Yuan W. An epidemiological survey on trial. Lancet 2009 Feb 14; 373: 575e81.
ankle sprain. Br J Sports Med 1994 Jun; 28: 112e6. 10 de Vries JS, Krips R, Sierevelt IN, Blankevoort L, van Dijk CN. In-
3 Hertel J. Functional anatomy, pathomechanics, and pathophysiology terventions for treating chronic ankle instability. Cochrane Database
of lateral ankle instability. J Athl Train 2002 Dec; 37: 364e75. Syst Rev 2011 Aug 10. Issue 8. Art. No.:CD004124.
4 Golano P, Vega J, de Leeuw PA, et al. Anatomy of the ankle ligaments: 11 Hubbard TJ, Cordova M. Effect of ankle taping on mechanical laxity in
a pictorial essay. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2010 May; 18: chronic ankle instability. Foot Ankle Int 2010 Jun; 31: 499e504.
557e69. 12 Petersen W, Rembitzki IV, Koppenburg AG, et al. Treatment of acute
5 Guillo S, Bauer T, Lee JW, et al. Consensus in chronic ankle instability: ankle ligament injuries: a systematic review. Arch Orthop Trauma
aetiology, assessment, surgical indications and place for arthroscopy. Surg 2013 Aug; 133: 1129e41.
Orthop Traumatol Surg Res 2013 Dec; 99(suppl 8): S411e9. 13 Rogers M, Park D, Singh D, eds. Consensus of the 3rd round table.
6 Phisitkul P, Chaichankul C, Sripongsai R, Prasitdamrong I, Barcelona: Ortho solutions Ltd., June 2013.
Tengtrakulcharoen P, Suarchawaratana S. Accuracy of anterolateral 14 Nery C, Raduan F, Del Buono A, Asaumi ID, Cohen M, Maffulli N.
drawer test in lateral ankle instability: a cadaveric study. Foot Ankle Arthroscopic-assisted Brostro€m-Gould for chronic ankle instability: a
Int 2009 Jul; 30: 690e5. long-term follow-up. Am J Sports Med 2011 Nov; 39: 2381e8.
7 de C esar PC, Avila EM, de Abreu MR. Comparison of magnetic reso- 15 Miller AG, Raikin SM, Ahmad J. Near-anatomic allograft tenodesis of
nance imaging to physical examination for syndesmotic injury after chronic lateral ankle instability. Foot Ankle Int 2013 Nov; 34:
lateral ankle sprain. Foot Ankle Int 2011 Dec; 32: 1110e4. 1501e7.
8 Gaebler C, Kukla C, Breitenseher MJ, et al. Diagnosis of lateral ankle 16 Donahue M, Simon J, Docherty CL. Critical review of self-reported
ligament injuries. Comparison between talar tilt, MRI and operative functional ankle instability measures. Foot Ankle Int 2011 Dec; 32:
findings in 112 athletes. Acta Orthop Scand 1997 Jun; 68: 286e90. 1140e6.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 29:2 151 Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.