Professional Documents
Culture Documents
London, 2Public Health Directorate, NHS Surrey, Kingston Upon Thames, and 3Southside Partnership, London, UK
Abstract
Rates of mental illness and self-harm are very high among women prisoners. Questionnaires assessed prisoners’ knowledge
of and attitudes towards mental health problems, and relevant behavioural intentions before and after the intervention, to
evaluate the effectiveness of a comedy show in a women’s prison to reduce mental health stigma and improve coping and
help-seeking for mental health problems. The intervention appeared to have been successful in improving some aspects of
prisoners’ knowledge about the effectiveness of psychotherapy (Z 2.304, p 0.021) and likelihood of recovery from
mental health problems (Z 2.699, p 0.007). There were significant post-intervention increases in the proportion who
stated they would discuss or disclose mental health problems with all but one of the sources of help in the questionnaire,
which was consistent with the increases in the number of prisoners who rated themselves as likely to start using different
sources of help or prison activities. There was no improvement in intentions to associate with people with a mental health
problem. The intervention appeared effective in improving factors that might increase help-seeking and improve coping,
but not those that would change behaviour towards others with a mental health problem.
Introduction
on help-seeking. A small-scale qualitative study of
The prison population has a very high level of men- male prisoners found a combination of high levels
tal health need, with as many as 12–15% of prisoners of distrust towards authority and ‘the system’ in
having four or five co-existing mental disorders, and general, a perception that healthcare professionals
30% of all prisoners having a history of self-harm (usually doctors) ‘just don’t care’, and high levels
(Brooker et al., 2003). A more recent review of stigma surrounding mental problems (Howerton
(Sirdifield et al., 2009) found that the prevalence of et al., 2007). Most of the respondents reported
mental disorders, substance use, and suicide remain that they would not seek help from any healthcare
high in prison populations around the world, and professional if experiencing mental distress, despite
reiterates findings that the incidence of mental dis- the fact that many had considerable emotional
order is often higher for women. While women problems (indeed, a quarter of them were flagged
account for only approximately 5% of prisoners in as being at risk of self-harm).
England and Wales (Ministry of Justice, 2009), they This paper reports the results of an evaluation of
have very high levels of mental health problems, for a novel psychoeducational intervention, in which
example between 2004 and 2009; 20–24% of female prisoners watched a comedy performance (entitled
inmates self-harmed every year (Hawton et al., 2013). ‘Cracking up’) which explored mental health and
Imprisonment is a stressful experience, and the levels race-related issues including mental health-related
of psychosocial stress engendered by overcrowding stigma, and encouraged seeking and accessing well-
may exacerbate the distress of prisoners suffering being and support services. Performing arts classes
from mental health problems. and performances for both recreational and educa-
There is evidence that stigma and discrimination tional purposes are by no means uncommon in pris-
can limit access to mental healthcare (Clement ons, and there is research interest in the effectiveness
et al., 2014). However, there is a lack of evidence of novel interventions in supporting mental health
concerning the effects of multiple sources of stigma in vulnerable populations (Shandley et al., 2010).
(such as, for example, mental health problems, Our evaluation is based on a conceptual framework
coming from an ethnic minority, and criminality) that describes stigma as consisting of difficulties of
Correspondence: Dr Claire Henderson, Health Service & Population Research Department, Institute of Psychiatry, King’s College London, De Crespigny
Park, Denmark Hill, London SE5 8AF, UK. Tel: 0207 848 5075. Fax: 0207 848 1462. E-mail: Claire.1.henderson@kcl.ac.uk
ISSN 0954–0261 print/ISSN 1369–1627 online © 2014 Institute of Psychiatry
DOI: 10.3109/09540261.2014.924096
424 S. Wright et al.
knowledge (ignorance or misinformation), attitudes emerge (Bhui & Bhugra, 2007). This was considered
(prejudice), and behaviour (discrimination) necessary because of the over-representation of
( Thornicroft, 2006). We therefore hypothesized that people from ethnic minority backgrounds in the
questionnaires completed post-performance would prison population. Attitudes to mental illness were
show improved stigma-related mental health knowl- assessed using items relevant to the intervention
edge, more positive attitudes to mental illness, and content selected from the Community Attitudes
more positive behavioural intentions in terms of toward the Mentally Ill scale (CAMI) (Taylor &
contact with people with mental health problems, Dear, 1981). Intended behaviour was assessed
compared to pre-performance ratings. Because the by applying the concept of social distance to this
show addressed help-seeking directly as well as setting; we asked about the extent to which the
stigma as a barrier to help-seeking, we also hypoth- participant was willing to spend time with someone
esized that intended help-seeking and use of other with a mental health problem, in comparison with
positive coping strategies would be higher post- people with other types of disorder. One of the
performance. comparison items, People with cancer was included,
because cancer, like mental health problems, is a
stigmatized illness (Rosman, 2004).
Method In an effort to reduce participant burden and there-
fore improve response rates, the post-performance
Site
questionnaire did not include the data concerning
The evaluation was conducted at a closed prison for closeness of relationship with people with mental
sentenced adult women prisoners in the south of health problems, education, and ethnicity, as this
England, with an operational capacity of 358 pris- data would have been already collected in the pre-
oners. The ethnic minority population for prisons performance questionnaire.
in the county was approximately 55%, compared to
approximately 5% in the local general population.
Intervention
The comedy performance (entitled ‘Cracking up’)
Participants
explored mental health and race-related issues,
The participants were adult sentenced prisoners who and encouraged seeking and accessing well-being
had consented to take part in the evaluation. and support services. In addition to the stand-up
comedian, there were contributions from two
inmates in the form of poetry they had written –
Measures
as social contact between people with experience
A pre-performance evaluation questionnaire was of mental health problems and those who have
developed which collected socio-demographics, not, is an effective way of promoting more posi-
degree of previous familiarity with people with men- tive attitudes and reducing stigma (Corrigan
tal health problems, whom the participant would feel et al., 2012). The key issues addressed in the per-
comfortable disclosing and discussing mental health formance were why mental health problems and
problems with, participation in prison activities, race equality issues are important in prisons, the
and help-seeking and coping in prison. In the pre- nature of mental health problems and risk factors
performance questionnaire, participants were asked for developing them, addressing myths and stigma
to record whether or not they presently took part in (for example, myths concerning mental health
or used each of eight different activities, sources of problems and violence, recovery from mental
help, or methods of coping that were presented. In health problems, cultural beliefs concerning men-
the post-performance questionnaire, participants tal health problems, and misperceptions around
were presented with the same list, and asked to indi- cultural issues), protective factors, sources of
cate whether they intended to start, stop, or do or help, and coping.
use each activity, source of help, or coping method Material for the performance was researched
more or less frequently, or whether they had no via the comedian talking both to ex-offenders and
intention to change their current frequency of use or to inmates through focus groups in three adult pris-
involvement. Stigma-related mental health knowl- ons (two of which were for male offenders, the
edge items were taken from the Mental Health other being a women’s prison, where the interven-
Knowledge Schedule (MAKS) (Evans-Lacko et al., tion was performed and evaluated). This prepara-
2010), with two additional items intended to reflect tory research explored inmates’ and ex-offenders’
research findings concerning ethnic differences in experiences, knowledge of and attitudes towards
the prevalence of some mental disorders and in pat- mental health issues, help-seeking, coping strategies
terns of mental healthcare usage which consistently and stigma.
Prison mental health intervention 425
Data collection The ratings for current use of activities, sources of
help, and coping methods in the pre-performance
The original intention was to use a repeated-
group differed from those for planned future use of
measures design, with prisoners who agreed to
activities, sources of help, and coping methods in the
participate in the evaluation completing question-
post-performance group, so direct comparison using
naires before and after viewing the performance.
a statistical test was not possible. Instead, the net
However, after the prisoners had been informed
positive or negative effects of the performance on
about the evaluation and consent had been given by
intended future behaviours in the post-performance
prisoners who wished to participate in it, and the
group were calculated in the following way. The per-
pre-performance questionnaires were completed,
centage of participants who rated themselves as using
it became necessary to postpone the performance
or being involved with the listed activities and help-
for five weeks. Given that the turnover of a prison
seeking and coping methods in the pre-performance
population can be higher than 10% per week,
questionnaire was considered to be a base rate, and
this meant that most of the prisoners who had
the percentage of participants who rated themselves
completed the questionnaires were no longer there to
as planning to either start or already do or use more
see the performance. It was therefore decided to
of the item was added to this figure, while the per-
collect post-performance evaluation questionnaires
centage of participants rated as either planning to
from prisoners after they had seen it, whether or
stop or already do or use less of the item were sub-
not they had completed the pre-performance
tracted. If the resulting total was higher than the base
questionnaire.
rate figure, then the performance was judged to have
had a positive effect for that item, and vice versa.
Analysis
Because the data distributions for the pre- and post Ethics
performance groups were non-normal for knowl-
edge, attitudes, willingness to associate, and disclo- Permission to run the intervention and evaluation
sure and discussion of mental health problems, was given by the Ministry of Justice and the three
the scores of the groups were compared using the prisons where work was done to develop the inter-
Mann-Whitney test, and median values are presented vention, including the prison where the intervention
in Tables 1, 2 and 3. Because the MAKS knowledge was delivered. The King’s College London Research
items address different knowledge domains rather Ethics Committee deemed the evaluation exempt
than forming a scale, a correction for multiple testing from research ethics approval on the basis that it was
was not used. a service evaluation.
Pre-performance Post-performance
% agreeing strongly/ % agreeing strongly/
slightly (median) slightly (median) Z P
Knowledge items
Most people with mental health problems want to have paid 75% (2.0) 84% (2.0) 1.720 NS
employment
If a friend had a mental health problem, I know what advice to 78% (2.0) 82% (2.0) 0.561 NS
give them to get professional help
Medication can be an effective treatment for people with mental 71% (2.0) 86% (2.0) 1.110 NS
health problems
Psychotherapy (e.g. talking treatment or counselling) can be an 76% (2.0) 91% (1.0) 2.304 0.021
effective treatment for people with mental health problems
People with severe mental health problems can fully recover 46% (3.0) 84% (2.0) 2.699 0.007
Most people with mental health problems go to a healthcare 47% (2.0) 38% (2.0) 0.556 NS
professional to get help
Black people get worse mental healthcare than white people 20% (5.0) 50% (2.5) 3.013 0.003
Black people have more mental illness than white people 14% (5.0) 48% (3.0) 3.336 0.001
Attitude items
Virtually anyone can become mentally ill 91% (1.0) 100% (1.0) 1.480 NS
People with mental health problems are far less of a danger than 39% (3.0) 48% (3.0) 0.821 NS
most people suppose
People with mental health problems should not be given any 9% (4.5) 35% (4.0) 1.743 NS
responsibility
426 S. Wright et al.
Table 2. Pre-and post-performance ratings of willingness to associate, and comfort in disclosing and discussing mental health problems
with others.
Pre-performance % Post-performance %
very/moderately very/moderately
willing to associate willing to associate
(median) (median) Z P
Pre-performance Post-performance
comfortable/slightly comfortable/slightly
comfortable rating comfortable rating
(median) (median)
Results
Regarding ethnicity, 47 participants (67%) were white
Seventy prisoners (20% of the prison’s operational British, white Irish, or White other, 11 (16%) were
capacity) completed pre-performance questionnaires. Black Caribbean, two (3%) were Black African, three
Mean pre-performance age was 32.6 years (range 18 (4%) were Chinese or other south-east Asian, and
to 63 years, standard deviation (SD) 11.4 years). four (6%) were of mixed ethnicity. These totals give
Table 3. Pre- and post-performance ratings of current and planned future use of activities, sources of
help, and coping methods.
Yes No