Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Correspondence: Dr. Musthafa Chalikandy Peedikayil · Section of Gastroenterology, Department of Medicine, King Faisal Specialist Hospital
and Research Center, Riyadh, MBC 46, PO Box 3354 Riyadh 11211 Saudi Arabia · musthafacpdr@gmail.com
DOI: 610.5144/0256-4947.2012.623
Background and objectives: Wilson disease (WD) is a rare autosomal recessive disease. Our objective
was to describe the diverse patterns, therapies, and outcomes of this disease.
DESIGN AND SETTING: A retrospective study over two decades on WD patients in a tertiary care center in
Saudi Arabia.
Patients and Methods: Clinical and laboratory findings of 71 patients with WD were retrieved from their
charts, referral notes and our hospital electronic records and were analyzed.
Results: The mean age and standard deviation was 16.8 (10.7) years and 56.5% were males. The main mani-
festations of WD were hepatic, neurological, and mixed in 39 (54.9%), 12 (16.9%), and 20 (28.2%) patients,
respectively, and 11 (15.5%) were asymptomatic cases detected by family screening. A family history of WD was
positive in 41 (57.7%) patients, and consanguinity of parents was found in 26 (36.6%) patients. The mean (SD)
follow-up period was 92.2 (72.9) (range, 1-320) months. Ten (14.1%) patients died during follow up, while 45
(63.4%) and 16 (22.5%) were still on or lost from follow-up, respectively. The mean (SD) age at the end of fol-
low-up was 25.3 (12) (range, 4-62) years. Hepatoma was discovered in 5 (7.0%) patients. Penicillamine therapy
was used by 58 (81.7%) patients, while zinc and trientine were given to 32 (45.1%) and 11 (15.5%) patients,
respectively. Sixteen (22.5%) patients underwent liver transplantation and one died (1.4%) on the waiting list.
The liver condition remained stable or improved in 35 (49.3%), and the neurological status showed improve-
ment in 11 (34.4%) of the 32 patients who had neurological involvement.
Conclusions: This is the biggest cohort to be reported from the Middle East. WD presentation and outcome
of WD are very diverse, and its diagnosis still depends on clinical, laboratory, and radiological evidence of
abnormal copper metabolism. WD should be considered in patients of any age with obscure hepatic and/or
neurological abnormalities.
W
ilson disease (WD) or hepato-lenticular WD may present at any age and was described in ev-
degeneration is a rare autosomal recessive ery region of the world. Its incidence was estimated at 1
inborn error of copper metabolism that in 30 000 in countries like the United States, Germany,
results from mutations of the ATP7b gene on chromo- and Japan.3 However, WD incidence is more common
some 13.1 The ATP7b gene product, a P-type ATPase (1 in 3 000 to 10 000) in communities where consan-
transporter, is responsible for incorporation of cop- guineous marriages are prevalent such as the Druze,
per with apoceruloplasmin and its excretion into bile. Yemenite, Iranian Jews, and Palestinians.4 Confirming
Faulty P-type ATPase transporter leads to accumula- the diagnosis of WD is usually straightforward late in
tion of free copper within hepatocytes, its slow release the course of the disease if both the major clinical and
into the blood stream, and its accumulation in extra-he- laboratory features are present, namely, typical hepatic
patic tissues mainly the liver, brain, cornea, skin, joints, and/or neurological findings, Kayser-Fleischer (KF)
and kidneys.2 rings, low serum levels of ceruloplasmin, and increased
urinary copper excretion. However, KF rings are often brain, liver imaging (ultrasound and/or computed to-
absent in patients who present with liver disease alone. mography scan) and liver enzymes. The patients were
In addition, ceruloplasmin levels may be normal,5 or considered to have a neurologic presentation if they
even low together with high urinary copper excretion had tremor, dysarthria, gait disturbance, or ataxia in
in patients with fulminant hepatic failure secondary addition to the dystonic, Parkinsonian syndromes,
to WD.6 Moreover, asymptomatic siblings of patients and psychiatric symptoms such as anxiety, depression,
with WD, in whom the diagnosis needs to be confirmed behavioral disturbances, and cognitive impairment.
or ruled out, may also present with diagnostic uncer- Patients who were diagnosed with WD as part of their
tainties.7 investigation of abnormal liver enzyme were consid-
A review revealed only a few studies, of small sample ered to have a hepatic presentation even if they were
size, on WD in Saudi Arabia,8-10 where consanguineous symptomatic. For mixed-type patients, the neurologic
marriages exceed 50%.11 Little is known about the long- symptoms were apparent with liver involvement. In pa-
term follow-up outcomes of patients with WD in our tients without KF rings or those with normal serum ce-
geographic locality especially with current advances in ruloplasmin, confirmation of the diagnosis of WD was
the diagnosis and management of liver disease includ- based mainly on: 1) high hepatic copper content (>250
ing liver transplantation. Therefore, this study presents µg/g dry weight of liver),2 2) exclusion of other causes
the experience of a tertiary care center in Saudi Arabia, of chronic liver disease, 3) magnetic resonance findings
with 71 patients with WD for over two decades ito il- in the basal ganglia compatible with WD, and 4) clini-
lustrate the pattern of disease presentation, diagnosis, cal and biochemical response to medical therapy. Liver
therapies, and outcomes. function tests and other routine laboratory data were
performed using standard methods. Serum ceruloplas-
PATIENTS AND METHODS min was measured by immunoprecipitation, or oxidase
The medical records of 71 consecutive patients diag- activity. Liver copper concentration in dried liver tissue
nosed as WD at a tertiary care center in Saudi Arabia was measured by flame atomic absorption spectroscopy
between January 1987 and June 2008 were retrospec- in a center in the United States.
tively reviewed. The center is a major tertiary care cen- Data were collected in a preformatted data collec-
ter in the central region of Saudi Arabia that receives tion form before being transferred to a Microsoft Excel
referrals of patients with neurological and hepatic dis- Sheet, and underwent descriptive and analytical statis-
orders of unknown etiology for advanced care. Liver tics using SPSS; version 15 (IBM Corp, Armonk, New
transplantation began at this institution in 1996 for York, United States). Data are presented as means (SD)
some time, and then restarted again in 2001.12 or number (percentage) as appropriate. The means of
The patients’ files were studied for various clinical, continuous variables were compared using the t tests,
laboratory, and radiological features at initial presenta- non-parametric tests (Wilcoxon and Mann Whitney),
tion and during follow-up. Data pertaining to disease or one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with post-
course, medications used, need for transplantation, hoc test (Tukey) as appropriate. A Kaplan-Meier curve
response to treatment, and complications such as de- with the log rank test were used to test cumulative sur-
velopment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) as well vival. A P value of <.05 was considered statistically sig-
as survival were obtained. Institutional approval of the nificant.
study, and informed written consent for liver biopsy was
obtained from patients or their parents. All patients RESULTS
were cared for by one of the authors at a time period of The epidemiological features of the 71 patients with
their follow-up. WD are shown in Table 1. Most were Saudis (93%).
The diagnostic criteria of WD included at least two The other 5 patients were Yemenis (n=3) and Syrians
of the following: 1) evidence of liver disease and/or neu- (n=2). Regional distribution and the occupation at
ropsychiatric illness, 2) presence of Kayser-Fleischer the time of presentation of the 71 cases are shown in
(KF) rings by slit lamp examination, 3) low serum ceru- Figures 1 and 2. As expected, most (n=26, 36.6%)
loplasmin level <200 mg/L, and 4) elevated pre-treat- were from the central region of Saudi Arabia. A posi-
ment 24-hour urinary copper excretion >100 µg/24- tive family history of WD was found for in 41 (57.7%)
hour.2 The 24-hour urine excretion after challenge by patients, and consanguinity of parents was reported in
D-penicillamine was performed when required. 26 (36.6%) patients. Definite nonconsanguinity was re-
Symptomatic patients with WD were classified as ported by 29 (40.8%) patients, and in the remaining 16
neurologic, hepatic or mixed depending on their clini- (22.5%), parental consanguinity was not documented
cal presentation, magnetic resonance imaging of the
Consanguinity 26 (36.6)
Variable Result
Gender
Male 32 (54.2)
Female 27 (45.8)
Presentation
Screening 10 (17.5)
FHF 4 (6.8)
Mortality
Yes 10 (16.9)
Variable Result
Follow up (months)
Mean (SD) 92.2 (72.9)
Medical therapya
Penicillamine 58 (81.7)
Trientin 11 (15.5)
Zinc 32 (45.1)
Hepatoma 5 (7)
in better long-term outcome, but also to prevent or It was also argued that the HCC may develop in WD
avoid marriage to other undetected cases or carriers in patients secondary to associated hepatitis B or C virus
the same or other families. In our cohort, 41 (57.7%) (HBV, HCV) infection. However, none of our patients
patients had a positive family history of WD, and 11 had positive HCV and only 2 were positive for HBV;
(15.5%) of our cases were asymptomatic and initially none of them developed HCC.
diagnosed by screening. Many of those family members Patients with chronic or fulminant liver failure with-
who had WD were either not alive or on follow up at out urgent transplantation have a dismal prognosis.
other hospitals. Many recent reports have demonstrated the beneficial
Our patients did not undergo haplotype analysis to role of liver transplantation in patients with predomi-
identify any specific mutations that may help in estab- nantly hepatic WD.27-30 In our cohort, 16 patients un-
lishing the diagnosis of WD. If available such testing derwent liver transplantation, and 15 (93.8%) of them
might have been helpful, particularly in determining the were still alive and on regular follow up, a better out-
disease status in patients who were asymptomatic sib- come compared to medical treatment in one aspect, and
lings of index cases and in those who did not have KF in another aspect when compared to transplantation
rings.5,19 It is possible that without haplotype analysis, for other chronic liver disease. On-treatment survival
clinicians may still miss asymptomatic WD cases with of patients with WD has improved. Only 10 patients
normal laboratory findings. We do not believe, however, died in our cohort within 20 years from their initial
that the risk of routine liver biopsy of siblings is jus- diagnosis. When including patients lost to follow up
tified if there is no clinical or biochemical evidence of (n=16), a cumulative 20-year survival of around 60%
WD. A recent genetic analysis in 56 Saudi patients with can be achieved.
WD showed disease causing mutations in three exons The retrospective nature of any study is an inher-
(exons 8, 19 and 21) of the ATP7B gene in 28 patients ent limitation. However, this is not the case in rare
(50%). Such mutations were not detected in 60 control metabolic diseases such as WD. Obviously, prospective
Saudi subjects.11 Interestingly, mutations in exons 21 observational or interventional studies in WD are not
(18 cases) and 19 (one case) were reported to be unique feasible unless a worldwide study involving numerous
for Saudis. These data need to be confirmed by another high referral centers is organized. Also, our study still
larger study. provides more information about disease presentation
The results of medical therapy for patients who and outcomes in our locality, and provides the base for
presented in fulminant hepatic failure was rather dis- future genetic studies.
appointing as none of our patients with FHF survived In conclusion, the diagnosis of WD still depends on
while liver transplantation was being awaited. This clinical, laboratory, and radiological evidence of abnor-
(100%) mortality rate of patients with FHF in WD mal copper metabolism with no single test sufficient to
warrants an early consideration of liver transplantation make the diagnosis. WD should be considered in pa-
and early referral to a transplant center. Sepsis was a tients of any age with obscure hepatic and/or neurolog-
leading cause of mortality in all patients. ical abnormalities. Both a high index of suspicion and
HCC is a rare complication of WD, published family screening are essential for early diagnosis and
mainly as case reports.20-22 This lead to the impres- hence early effective therapy. Long-term treatment of
sion that copper and its receptors has a protective role patients with D-penicillamine/trientine along with di-
against hepatic carcinogenesis.23 However, Long-Evans etary copper restriction is effective in resolving clinical
cinnamon (LEC) rats with partial deletion of the cop- and biochemical markers of the disease and improves
per transporting ATPase gene homologous to the WD prognosis and possibly survival. Patients who meet cur-
gene were found to develop HCC despite the presence rent criteria for liver transplantation should be trans-
of excess copper in their livers.24 Moreover, copper-che- planted especially if they present as fulminant liver fail-
lating agents were found to inhibit the development of ure, and if they deteriorate while on medical treatment.
liver tumors in the same rat model.25 The incidence of Further study on the genetic mutations that occurred
HCC in patients with WD was attributed to the short- in the patients who are still on follow-up as well as the
ened life expectancy of untreated cases.26 The develop- impact of consanguinity is warranted. Moreover, a na-
ment of HCC in 5 (7%) of our cohort suggests that this tionwide registry for metabolic liver disease including
complication is not uncommon in patients with WD. WD needs to be established.