Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—Space-vector pulse-width modulation (SVPWM) the power circuit. This problem has motivated researchers to
computations are complex particularly for multilevel converters. develop more advanced multilevel VSI circuits which have
This paper introduces a novel SVPWM computation method for a lower number of semiconductors to reduce the converter
multilevel converters. General formulas for the region identifi-
cation as well as for PWM intervals calculation are proposed. complexity and cost. Some enhancements have been developed
Then, the proposed formulas are applied to the advanced dual for the multilevel converter power circuits.
three-level T-type converter topology. The operation of this The T-type three-level converter is one of the advanced DCC
advanced topology applied to an open end winding induction topologies, that has the advantages of a lower amount of
machine (OEWIM) is discussed in more details. A simulation switching devices and a higher efficiency compared to con-
study for the proposed AC drive system is performed by using
MatlabTM /Simulink⃝R
. A hardware implementation based on a ventional neutral point clamped (NPC) converters [15]–[18]. In
field-programmable gate array (FPGA) for the advanced topology [19], [20], modified five-level T-type converters with a reduced
supplying an OEWIM is presented, discussed and analysed. number of switches are introduced. In [5], [19], the five-
The computation algorithm is built within the FPGA digital level T-type as well as the dual three-level T-type advanced
controller. A comparison between experimental and simulation converter topologies have been studied and compared to the
results is performed. It is observed that the simulation and
the experimental results are agreed and verified the proposed conventional five-level DCC. It has been proved that the
algorithm. two T-type topologies have higher efficiency compared to
Index Terms—SVPWM, Multilevel converter, harmonic anal- the conventional DCC. For this purpose, the dual three-level
ysis. T-type converter is studied in this paper to test the novel
I. I NTRODUCTION SVPWM computations.
The two-level voltage source inverter (VSI) is a cheap con- There are several techniques can be used to control multi-
verter and has spread in industry particularly low-voltage AC level converter; i.e. sinusoidal PWM, selective-harmonic elim-
drive applications. However, this converter produces a large ination PWM, space-vector control and space vector PWM
harmonic content to the connected machine, which increases (SVPWM). The last technique has been introduced in the mid-
the machine losses and also affects its lifetime [1]. This 80s [21]. Its advantages include a good utilization of the DC
problem can be solved by using a harmonic filter to reduce the link voltage and generating waveforms with low harmonic
output harmonic content. However, this solution is considered distortion. As a result, the SVPWM technique is of interest
expensive and increases the converter size. Also, the connected for AC drive applications [22]–[27]. The main problem of the
filter will have its own losses [2]–[6]. Another solution is to SVPWM is the complexity of the required calculations partic-
increase the frequency of the steering pulses, which is the ularly for multilevel converters with high number of voltage
switching frequency of the pulse-width modulation (PWM) levels. Several calculating techniques have been introduced in
technique. However, this way increases the converter switching order to simplify the SVPWM calculations in [28]–[30]. A
loss [5], [6]. The multilevel VSI is a better alternative to the different technique will be introduced, discussed and verified
two-level VSI in AC drive and renewable energy integration practically in this study.
applications. It has the advantage of delivering AC power The target of this paper is to propose a simple method for
including low harmonic content and reducing the stress on the the SVPWM computations for multilevel converters. Then,
semiconductor switches. Moreover, it can reduce the coupling proposing a generalized model for N-level converter SVPWM
filter size which is used for grid-tie converter in renewable computation. Moreover, studying this technique for the dual
energy applications [7]–[11]. three-level T-type converter advanced topology when supply-
The most well known multilevel converters are the diode- ing an open-end winding induction machine (OEWIM). For
clamped converter (DCC), the flying capacitor converter this purpose, a novel technique for the voltage vector operating
(FCC), and the cascaded H-bridge (CHB) converter. Each region is proposed. Then, the switching time periods are
one of these converters has its own advantages and draw- calculated using a general formula for any region within the
backs [12]–[14]. However, a common drawback of multilevel vector diagram. A switching pattern is designed to reduce the
converters is the large amount of semiconductors used in converter switching-stress. An evaluation for the converter and
978-1-4673-9063-7/16/$31.00 ⃝IEEE
c
the proposed algorithm is performed in this study by analysing on the converter switching states, the space vector is calculated
the output waveforms and its harmonic contents at different by using (1) [21], [31].
switching frequency values i.e. 2.5 kHz, 5 kHz, and 10 kHz
in order to show the effect of this frequency on the voltage 2
V= (v ′ + ej2𝜋/3 .vVV′ + e–j2𝜋/3 .vWW′ ) (1)
and current harmonic contents. 3 UU
II. O PERATION OF A D UAL T HREE -L EVEL T- TYPE For a three-level T-type converter, the number of possible
T OPOLOGY switching states is 27. By applying the space-vector relation
It is important to analyse the performance of the dual to the 27 switching states (i.e. state 1:27). By applying these
T-type converter topology in a complete AC drive system. switching states to the space vector relation (1), the vector
An induction machine (IM) mechanically connected to a DC diagram of the three-level T-type converter can be represented
machine is selected as load. This setup allows to measure the as in Fig. 2. This vector diagram consists of 19 different
performance of the system at different loading conditions. Due vectors i.e. O, a1 – A6 , b1 – b12 . This vector diagram can be
to the limited space, the study in this paper will focus on described by (2) where 𝛼 is the sector angle.
the operation of the proposed AC drive system at full load.
Fig. 1 shows the wiring diagram for the dual T-type converter vax = 0.5 e(–i𝛼) ;x = 1 : 6
topology, supplied by isolated DC sources, and connected to an (–i𝛼)
vbx = 1 e ; x = 1 : 2k – 1; k = 1 : 6 (2)
OEWIM. The following subsection describes the operation of √ ( )
the proposed converter topology by using SVPWM technique. 3 –i(𝛼+ 𝜋 )
vby = e 6 ; y = 2m; m = 1 : 6
The possible switching states and the output voltages of phase- 2
U are summarised in Table 1.
Unlike the conventional five-level converter which has
Table 1: The possible switching states and the output voltage
for a single phase of a dual three-level T-type converter. b5 b4 b3
12
11 10
Converter-1 Converter-2 Connected points VUU′ b6 13 a3 a29 b2
Q3U , Q4U Q1U′ , Q2U′ P-N’ + Vdc 14 2 8
Q3U , Q4U Q4U′ , Q2U′ P-O’ + Vdc /2 b7 15 a4
3
o1 a17 b
1
Q2U , Q4U Q1U′ , Q2U′ O-N’ 16 4 5 6 24
23
Q3U , Q4U Q3U′ , Q4U′ P-P’ 17 a5 a6
Q2U , Q4U Q2U′ , Q4U′ O-O’ 0 b8 b12
18 20 22
Q1U , Q2U Q1U′ , Q2U′ N-N’ 19 21
Q2U , Q4U Q3U′ , Q4U′ O-P’ - Vdc /2 b9 b10 b11
Q1U , Q2U Q2U′ , Q4U′ N-O’
Q1U , Q2U Q3U′ , Q4U′ N-P’ - Vdc Fig. 2. Vector diagram for three-level converter.
P
i1 converter-1 125 switching states, the dual three-level T-type topology is
Q3U Q3V Q3W
Vdc/4 Q4U Q2U considered as a five-level converter and has 729 switching
U
Q4V Q2V iu states (which results from squaring the 27 switching states of
i2 V
O each three-level T-type converter), and produces 61 different
Q4W Q2W iv
W vectors, i.e. O, A1 –A6 , B1 –B12 , C1 –C18 , D1 –D18 as described
Vdc/4
iw in Fig.3. These vectors can be described by (3); where 𝛼 is
N i3 Q1U Q1V Q1W the sector angle which equals 0, 𝜋3 , 2𝜋 3𝜋 5𝜋
3 , 𝜋, 2 , and 2 for
Three-phase sectors 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 respectively.
open-end winding IM
P'
i' 1 Q3U' Q3V' Q3W' D9 D8 D7 D6 D5
Vdc/4 Q4U' Q2U'
D10 C7 C4 D4
U'
i' 2 Q4V' Q2V'
O' V' D11 D3
Q4W' Q2W'
Vdc/4 W' D12 D2
D14 D24
Fig. 1. Dual T-type multilevel converter C C18
D15 17 D23
8 7 26 56 Vx
1
V t1
By analysing the vector-diagram and its corresponding 25 55
O A1 D1
switching states, it is observed that the ’A’ vectors can be Θ
(a) (b)
achieved by 216 switching states, the set of ’B’ vectors can
be achieved by 264 switching states, the set of ’C’ vectors Fig. 4. (a) Region-border calculation for sector-1, (b)
can be achieved by 156 switching states, and the set of D Example for one-region intervals calculation
vectors can be achieved by 48 switching states. Therefore, the
total number of switching states which produce a non-zero
vector is 684. The zero-vector O can be achieved by 45 passive
switching states. Another view, the hexagonal vector diagram
in Fig. 3 can be divided in six equilateral triangles (which are
called sectors): (OD1 D5 ), (OD5 D9 ), (OD9 D13 ), (OD13 D17 ),
(OD17 D21 ) and (OD21 D1 ). Each of these sectors includes
16 smaller triangles which called regions. After defining
the vector diagram of the proposed converter topology, the
next subsections describe the proposed SVPWM computation
method.
1) Region and Sector Identification: The complexity of
the SVPWM calculations is a result of the high number of
voltage levels particular as to the region identification. In the
sequel we proposed a general form for multilevel converter
region identification and sector identification. To determine the
triangular region in which a vector is located, it is essential
to determine the region borders that can be computed by the
straight lines xi ; for i=1:m+1; where m is the number of levels.
The loci for xi are shown in Fig.4-a. The value of xi can be
calculated as the intersection between the rotating vector V Fig. 5. Region identifier function, part 1
and the region borders as a function of the vector angle 𝜃. For
example, the locus of x1 is the straight line A1 – A2 . The loci 2) Time Interval Calculation: In this subsection, a general
values for the region boundaries of a five-level converter can formula is used to calculate the pulse-width time intervals for
be calculated by: any region within the hexagon. Assume a vector V located
in a specific region that has a boundary vectors Vx , Vy and
[x1 x3 x5 ] = K csc(𝜋/3 – 𝜃), [x2 x4 x6 ] = K csc(2𝜋/3 – 𝜃) Vz as shown in Fig. 4-b. The voltage-second relation during
√ a switching period Tc can be written as a function of the
; K = 3/2 [|OA1 ||OB1 ||OC1 |] (4) surrounding vectors and corresponding time durations as
A general form for the region boundaries for an m level follows [31]:
converter can be described by:
V.Tc = Vx .t1 + Vy .t2 + Vz .t3 (6)
[x1 x3 ......xm ] = K csc(𝜋/3 –𝜃) , [x2 x4 ......xm+1 ] = K csc(2𝜋/3 –𝜃)
√
3 where Tc = t1 + t2 + t3 = 1/2 Ts , and where Ts is the inverse of
;K = [1 2 ....m – 1] (5)
2(m – 1) the switching frequency. By analysing (6) in Cartesian form,
The first bullet is important to reduce the switching stress, and
hence the converter switching loss. This is obtained by keeping
two phases out of three at their previous switching states and
alter the third phase only. The second bullet is important to
cancel the even harmonic contents in the generated voltage
waveforms. The third bullet is the criterion to keep the dual
three-level T-type topology at a minimum switching stress and
to reduce the converter switching loss. By analysing the 729
switching states of this converter, it is concluded that there
are common switching states which can be used to keep one
converter is working at a common switching state, while the
other converter is varying its switching state. This is valid for
dual converters. Two regions switching patterns are show in
Fig. 6. Region identifier function, part 2 Fig. 8.
Vector C1 D2 C2 C1 C1 C2 D2 C1 Vector C4 D4 D5 C 4 C 4 D5 D4 C4
Intervals t1/2 t2 t3 t1/2 t1/2 t3 t2 t1/2 Intervals t1/2 t2 t3 t1/2 t1/2 t3 t2 t1/2
State 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 State 13 22 25 26 26 25 22 13
U
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
ωt U 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 1
V ωt
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ωt V 1 1 2 2 2 2 1 1
ωt
W
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ωt W 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 ωt
State 5 6 15 18 18 15 6 5 State 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
U' U'
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 0 0
ωt ωt
V' 2 2
V'
1 1 1 1 1 1
ωt
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ωt
W' 2 2 2 2 2 2
W'
1 1 ωt 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ωt
Tc Tc Tc Tc
Ts Ts
(a) (b)
Fig. 8. Pulses for (a) region no. 56 switching-pattern, (b)
region no. 61 during Ts time interval.
% Hf
% Hf
5 5
to output the desired pattern.
The results for a dual three-level T-type converter can be 0 0
0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200
summarised as follows. The measured and simulated voltages harmonic order harmonic order
and currents are shown in Fig. 9. This figure shows that the (b) Mesaured current, 2.5 kHz (h) Simulated current, 2.5 kHz
2 1
current ripple decreases by increasing the switching frequency.
% Hf
% Hf
A harmonic analysis is performed on the full-load measured 1 0.5
voltages and currents and the harmonic analysis at 2.5 kHz, 0 0
5 kHz and 10 kHz switching frequencies are performed and 0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200
harmonic order harmonic order
summarised in Fig. 10 for both measured and simulated
(c) Mesaured voltage, 5 kHz (i) Simulated voltage, 5 kHz
waveforms as shown in Fig. 10- a,b,g,h, It has been observed
10 10
that the voltage harmonic orders around the order number 50
% Hf
% Hf
(corresponding to 𝜔=2.5 kHz) have relatively high amplitudes 5 5
(maximum amplitude is 5%) compared to the fundamental 0 0
voltage value. The corresponding current harmonic amplitude 0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200
harmonic order harmonic order
is 0.9% of the fundamental current value. For the harmonic (d) Mesaured current, 5 kHz (j) Simulated current, 5 kHz
1 1
orders greater than or equal 2𝜔, the current harmonic contents
% Hf
% Hf
are damped more due to the machine impedance. A similar 0.5 0.5
remark is observed for the harmonic spectra at 𝜔=5 kHz and 0 0
𝜔=10 kHz. A summary for the THD factors is listed in Table 0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200
harmonic order harmonic order
2. The results clarify that the THD factors for the measured
(e) Mesaured voltage, 10 kHz (k) Simulated voltage, 10 kHz
signals are well matched the simulation results and with a 10 10
small error. This error results from the semiconductor turn-on
% Hf
% Hf
5 5
and turn-off delay.
0 0
0 50 100 150 200 0 50 100 150 200
v
UU'
[V] 20i
U
[A] harmonic order harmonic order
(f) Mesaured current, 10 kHz (l) Simulated current, 10 kHz
(a) Measured, 2.5 kHz (a) Simulated, 2.5 kHz 1
200 1
200
% Hf
% Hf
0 0 0.5 0.5
-200 -200
0.02
0 0
0 0.01 t [s] 0.02 0 0.01 t [s] 50 100 150 200
0 0 50 100 150 200
(b) Measured, 5 kHz (b) Simulated, 5 kHz harmonic order harmonic order
200 200
V. C ONCLUSION R EFERENCES
The harmonic and the performance analysis of the dual [1] Buccella, C., Cecati, et al. "Harmonic mitigation technique for multilevel
inverters in power systems." Power Electronics, Electrical Drives, Au-
three-level T-type converter topology applied to an OEWIM is tomation and Motion (SPEEDAM), 2014 International Symposium on.,
presented in this paper. A simple method for n-level converter Ischia, June 2014.
[2] C. Buccella, C. Cecati, et al. "Analytical Method for Pattern Generation Clamped Converter." IEEE Trans. on Ind. Electron., vol. 60, no. 5, pp.
in Five Levels Cascaded H-bridge Inverter using Selective Harmonics 1919 – 1935, May 3013.
Elimination." IEEE Transaction on Ind. Electron., vol. 61, no. 11, pp. [18] T. B. Soeiro, et al. " Comparison of 2-and 3-level active filters with
5811 – 5819, Nov. 2014. enhanced bridge-leg loss distribution." Power Electronics and ECCE Asia
[3] N.A. Azeez, K. Gopakumar, J. Mathew, and C. Cecati" A Harmonic (ICPE & ECCE), 2011 IEEE 8th International Conference on, pp. 1835
Suppression Scheme for Open-End Winding Split-Phase IM Drive Using – 1842, Jeju, 2011.
Capacitive Filters for the Full Speed Range." IEEE Transaction on Ind. [19] A. Salem, et al. "An Advanced Multilevel Converter Topology with
Electron., vol. 61, no. 10, pp. 5213 – 5221, Nov. 2014. Reduced Switching Elements." Industrial Electronics Society, IECON
[4] T. Strasser, F. Andren, J. Kathan,C. Cecati, et al." A Review of Architec- 2014-40th Annual Conference of the IEEE..pp. 1201 – 1207 Dallas, TX,
tures and Concepts for Intelligence in Future Electric Energy Systems." Nov. 2014.
IEEE Transaction on Ind. Electron., vol. PP, no. 99, pp. 1 – 16, 2014. [20] H. Vahedi, et al. "Pinned Mid-Points Multilevel Inverter (PMP): Three-
[5] A. Salem, F. D. Belie, et al. "Evaluation of a dual-T-type converter sup- Phase Topology with High Voltage Levels and One Bidirectional Switch."
plying an open-end winding induction machine." Industrial Electronics Industrial Electronics Society, IECON 2013-39th Annual Conference of
Society, IECON 2013-39th Annual Conference of the IEEE..pp. 749 – 754 the IEEE..pp. 102 – 107 Vienna, 2013.
Vienna, 2013. [21] Holmes, D.G., Lipo, T.A.," Pulse Width Modulation for Power Convert-
[6] Elsied, M., et al. "Efficient power-electronic converters for electric vehicle ers: Principles and Practice," Book, USA: Wiley-IEEE Press, John Willy
applications." Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conference (VPPC), IEEE, and Sons, Inc., Oct. 2003
Nov. 2015. [22] S. Das, et al. " Analytical Closed-Form Expressions for Harmonic
[7] J. Wang, et al." Multimodular matrix converters with sinusoidal input and Distortion Corresponding to Novel Switching Sequences for Neutral-
output waveforms." IEEE Transaction on Ind. Electron., vol. 59, no. 1, Point-Clamped Inverters," In Ind. Electron. Transaction on pp. 4485 –
pp. 17 – 26, 2012. 4497, Sept. 2014.
[8] H. Abu-Rub, et al. "Medium-voltage multilevel converters - State of the [23] L. Sun, et al. " A fast multi-level space vector PWM method based
art, challenges, and requirements in industrial applications," IEEE Trans. on sequence cyclic shift," In Industrial Electronics (ISIE), 2012 IEEE
on Ind. Electron., vol. 57, no. 8, pp. 2581 – 2596, Aug. 2010. International Symposium on pp. 40 – 45, May 2012.
[9] S. Kouro, et al. "Recent advances and industrial applications of multilevel
[24] V. Blasko, et al. " Analysis of a hybrid PWM based on modified space-
converters," IEEE Trans. on Ind. Electron., vol. 57, no. 8, pp. 2553 – 2580,
vector and triangle-comparison methods," Industry Applications, IEEE
Aug. 2010.
Transactions on, vol. 33, no. 3, pp. 756 – 764, 1997.
[10] Rasilo, P., et al. "Effect of Multilevel Inverter Supply on Core Losses in
[25] J. W. Kelly, et al. " Multiphase space vector pulse width modulation,"
Magnetic Materials and Electrical Machines." IEEE Energy Conversion
Energy Conversion, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 259 – 264,
Transaction On. (in press), 2014.
2003.
[11] A. Salem, A. A. Abou-Elyazied, et al. "A comparative study of the effect
[26] O. Lopez, et al. " Multilevel multiphase space vector PWM algorithm
of different converter topologies on the iron loss of nonoriented electrical
with switching state redundancy," Industrial Electronics, IEEE Transac-
steel." IEEE Magnetic Transaction On. vol. 50, Nov. 2014.
tions on, vol. 56, no. 3, pp. 792 – 804, 2009.
[12] A. M. Ghias, et al. " Voltage Balancing Method Using Phase-Shifted
PWM for the Flying Capacitor Multilevel Converter." IEEE transaction [27] A. Hernandez, et al. " Comparison of SVPWM and SPWM Techniques
on Power Electron., vol. 29, no. 9, pp. 4521 – 4531, Sept. 2014. for Back to Back Converters in PSCAD." Proceedings of the World
Congress on Engineering and Computer Science, vol. 1, Oct. 2013.
[13] A. M. Ghias, et al. " Initial Capacitor Charging in Grid-Connected Flying
Capacitor Multilevel Converters." IEEE transaction on Power Electron., [28] Liu, Zhan, et al. "A Novel SVPWM Algorithm for Five-Level Active
vol. 29, no. 7, pp. 3245 – 3249, July 2014. Neutral-Point-Clamped Converter." IEEE Transactions on Power Elec-
tronics, vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 3859 – 3866, 2016.
[14] F Salinas, et al. " Voltage Balancing Scheme for Flying Capacitor
Multilevel Converters ." Power Electronics, IET, vol. 6, no. 5, pp. 835 – [29] Piao, Chengzhu, and John Y. Hung. "A novel SVPWM overmodula-
842, 2013. tion technique for three-level NPC VSI." Transportation Electrification
Conference and Expo (ITEC), IEEE, 2015.
[15] M. Schweizer, et al. " Design and implementation of a highly efficient
three-level T-type converter for low-voltage applications." IEEE Trans. [30] Mahmoud, Zouhaira Ben, Mahmoud Hamouda, and Adel Khedher.
on Power Electron., vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 899 – 907, Feb. 2013. "Implementation of a fast and simple space vector modulation scheme
for a three-phase five-level neutral point clamped inverter." 2015 16th In-
[16] M. Schweizer, et al. " High efficiency drive system with 3-level T-type
ternational Conference on Sciences and Techniques of Automatic Control
inverter." Power Electronics and Applications (EPE 2011), Proceedings
and Computer Engineering, STA, IEEE, 2015.
of the 2011-14th European Conference on., pp. 1 5 – 10, Birmingham,
2011. [31] B. K. Bose, " Modern power electronics and AC drives " , Vol. 123.
[17] T. B. Soeiro, et al. " The New High-Efficiency Hybrid Neutral-Point- USA: Prentice Hall, 2002.