Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reaction Essay:
Taimi Fernandez
November 7, 2021
2
clear that our development in life ultimately comes down to the age-old dichotomy of nature
versus nurture. What can be understood from the video is that epigenetics is the science that
lurks behind the mystery of why two genetically identical organisms may diverge in their
development in life. Although we might be inclined to attribute certain diseases to our "bad
genes," the video explains that certain habits and behaviors we carry throughout our life can
ultimately result in our genetic markers being affected, causing irreversible damage to our
bodies. The discussion of nature vs. nurture is not new to me. I have taken several science classes
that explain both phenomena; however, finding out that epigenetic mutations can be passed
down to a person's offspring completely surprised me. Understandably, a mother's unhealthy life
choices affect the development of a fetus, potentially causing irreversible damage to it; but to
learn that it can inherit faulty genes that the mother did not inherit herself from the grandparents
puts in perspective just how important it is to always lead a healthy lifestyle, not only when one
is planning a pregnancy. Simple, everyday choices can have an enormous effect on how our
bodies develop throughout our lives, and although it is true that as children, we have little to no
choice on the food we eat, the amount of exercise we do, or whether we are exposed to smokers,
as adults the sole responsibility of those choices falls on our shoulders. We might not realize it,
especially as young adults, but the cumulative effects of those small choices through the years
While filling out the family history questionnaire, it became evident that genetically, the
disease I am most at risk of, given my family history, is undoubtedly diabetes. Both of my
grandmothers and my father suffer from diabetes, albeit each of them exhibited different
complications. The worst of all three is my paternal grandmother, who has suffered from
3
diabetes for more than three decades and has had to undergo a double amputation of her lower
limbs due to tissue necrosis on her legs. Although she was the first one to be diagnosed, she
refused to get treatment for a long time, so the damaging effects of her constant hyperglycemia
took a significant toll on her health. My maternal grandmother exhibited milder symptoms than
my paternal grandmother, and unlike the latter, she got treatment right away once she was
diagnosed with diabetes. Perhaps that decision helped her to live well past her eighties, and her
death had no correlation to her diabetes, according to the doctors. My father's diabetes onset
about five years ago, and much like his mother, he refused to start treatment. Initially, he resorted
to a strict diet until he got his glucose levels under control. Then he returned to old unhealthy
eating habits, heavy smoking, and frequent drinking, which inevitably resulted in his symptoms
making a comeback. He repeated that cycle a few times for three years until the doctor gave him
an ultimatum on his health: either he started medication, or his life expectancy would be reduced
to a few short years. He reluctantly started medication and has been stable since, although his
bad habits are still lingering. Looking at my upbringing through the lens of epigenetics is very
clear that I am at a very high risk of developing diabetes. My house was never one to have many
vegetables on the daily menu. On the contrary, we mainly ate fried food, plenty of carbohydrates,
and sweets were readily available whenever we wanted to. As I grew up, I had to consciously
start making healthier choices, which is very difficult when nobody has taught you how to do
that.
The effects of an unbalanced diet and malnutrition during pregnancy can cause increased
methylation of genes and histone-induced gene over or under expression (Malcomson and
Mathers, 2017). In the Epigenetics video, De Grasse-Tyson explains how these two factors cause
our genome to vary the proteins it produces, both quantity and quality, potentially affecting our
4
health. In addition, a particular nutrient has been found to have a considerable effect on
epigenetic mutations when it is not readily available during pregnancy. That nutrient, according
to studies, is folate (Johnson and Belshaw, 2014). When I think about my mother’s pregnancy
and her nutrition during that time, I realize that it cannot have been even close to the
recommended diet for a pregnant woman. My mother was pregnant with me in the nineties in
Cuba, during a period known as “the special period” because of the scarcity of resources and
severe food shortages on the island. Many families survived with what little food they could get
on the black market because store shelves were barren. Given that my sister was a child at the
time, the most nutritious items were given to her, and my parents made do with whatever was
left. That means that my mother most definitely did not get the recommended nutrition while
pregnant with me, which translates to me possibly developing a barrage of epigenetic mutations
detrimental to my health in future years. My mother’s malnutrition during pregnancy and the
Thankfully, scientists have discovered that epigenetic changes are – unlike genetic
unsure my life expectancy would surpass that of my mother (she died at age 54); however, it
seems that the few positive changes I have incorporated in my life (like weekly exercise and a
more balanced diet) have gained me almost three extra decades, as the test suggested I might live
until age 82. Considering that the average Hispanic woman in the United States lives to 81.1
(Arias, 2016), I could say that there is nothing extraordinary about my life expectancy.
Regardless, I would still prefer to live longer than that, so long as I can maintain my
independence and not burden my future children. It is clear to me now that the possibility of
5
increased longevity lies primarily with me and my daily choices. Most questions on the test
referred mainly to my habits, more so than my family history, indicating that the most significant
impact on how long an individual lives is determined more by their nurture than by their nature.
Despite the hardships my grandparents endured in Cuba, they all lived well past 80, which leads
me to believe that there have been other contributing factors to their longevity. After some
research, I discovered that another critical factor dramatically affects the life expectancy of a
person. Although it is more conspicuous than the food we eat or the amount of exercise we do, it
carries as heavy a burden as those factors; some people call it the silent killer – stress (Keating
and El-Osta, 2013). The fast-paced, ever-evolving nature of our society forces us to be in a
constant state of alert, which in turn causes our bodies to struggle to enter the resting stage
during which we heal and recover at a cellular level. That is not something our grandparents had
to deal with, as life back then ran on a much calmer pace. Therefore, even if they did not get the
best nutrition, their stress levels were significantly lower than ours, thus contributing to a
I still have a long way to go to achieve an ideal and healthy lifestyle, but I have made
some progress. My good habits fluctuate considerably, there are periods where I consistently
exercise and eat well, and there are times where I go on a bender and eat nothing but fast food
for days. To me, consistency is where I have the most room for improvement. Unlike my parents,
I get regular medical checkups to ensure nothing out of the ordinary is going on in my body,
which is more than can be said about my parents. Ironically, my mother was a doctor, and one
would think she knew better than perpetuating unhealthy habits at home; however, the little time
she and my father spent with us after working long hours made it difficult to prepare healthy and
wholesome meals. Instead, she would often resort to quick dinners, the not-so-occasional fast-
6
food run, delay doctors’ appointments for months at a time, and she completely obviated mental
health and stress levels. As a result, my mother died eight years ago, and my father suffers from
several health conditions (diabetes, high blood pressure, and arthritis). The least I can do for my
habits that prevent epigenetic aberrations in my body. By doing so, not only will I prevent them
from potentially inheriting those faulty genes, but I will also have created a healthy routine for
References
Arias, E. (2016). Changes in life expectancy by race and hispanic origin in the united
Malcomson, F. C., & Mathers, J. C. (2017). Nutrition, epigenetics and health through
from https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?
direct=true&AuthType=shib&db=nlebk&AN=1686935&site=ehost-live&custid=mdcc