Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
REACTIVE
&
FUNCTIONAL
Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482
POLYMERS
www.elsevier.com/locate/react
Received 20 June 2007; received in revised form 29 October 2007; accepted 31 October 2007
Available online 6 November 2007
Abstract
Cation-exchange adsorbent based on a nonwoven polypropylene fabric carrying sulfonate functional groups was syn-
thesized by a one-step graft copolymerization of sodium styrenesulfonate and acrylic acid monomers from binary mono-
mer mixtures using the electron beam pre-irradiation method in air. The effect of various polymerization parameters
(absorbed dose, reaction temperature and time, monomer ratio, Mohr’s salt additive) on the degree of grafting was stud-
ied. It was found that the copolymerization process begins with the primary grafting of acrylic acid monomers on the
nonwoven polypropylene fabric and continues by cografting of sodium styrenesulfonate and acrylic acid monomers. Total
ion-exchange capacity and sulfonate group density were evaluated to vary within 3.5–5.5 and 1.0–2.16 mEq/g, correspond-
ingly, for synthesized fabrics with a medium grafting degree (70–220%). These values are similar to those of sulfonated
membranes obtained by radiation-induced graft polymerization of styrene with subsequent sulfonation of polystyrene
chains. The main advantage of the studied approach is a one-step process of synthesis.
Ó 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Radiation-induced grafting; Electron beam; Polypropylene; Sodium styrenesulfonate; Acrylic acid; Binary monomer mixture
1381-5148/$ - see front matter Ó 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.reactfunctpolym.2007.10.036
S.W. Lee et al. / Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482 475
the last two approaches can be considered as the mercially available membranes with sulfonate
most promising [8]. groups.
For practical purposes the production of cation- In the present work, we examined how some
exchange polymer materials bearing strong acid experimental parameters (absorbed dose, reaction
functional groups, such as sulfonic acid groups, is temperature and time, monomer ratio and Mohr’s
an object of intense interest due to their possible salt additive) affected grafting of AA and SSS
application over a wide pH range [4,9]. Radiation monomers onto nonwoven polypropylene fabrics
graft polymerization can be used in different modes upon irradiation with an electron accelerator in
for this purpose: radiation-induced graft polymeri- air. The aim was to find optimal parameters for
zation of styrene with subsequent sulfonation of the synthesis of cation-exchange fabrics with sulfo-
polystyrene chains [4,10–12], or immediate radia- nate groups. To gain better understanding of the
tion-induced grafting of sulfonate group-containing copolymerization process from binary monomer
monomers. The former mode has been successfully mixtures the relationship between grafting degree
developed for production of proton-exchange and reaction time at 50 and 70 °C was studied and
membranes for fuel cells. The latter is under study. the FTIR spectra of the appropriate samples were
There are a few reports on the immediate radia- analyzed. Such an investigation allowed us to find
tion-induced grafting of sodium styrenesulfonate that the copolymerization process begins with graft-
(SSS) – a vinyl monomer with a sulfonate group ing of acrylic acid monomers and continues by
[9,13–15]. The first attempts to graft SSS on high- cografting of sodium styrenesulfonate and acrylic
density polyethylene (HDPE) membrane failed acid monomers. Since the synthesized fabric was a
due to the incompatibility between highly ionized bi-functional cation-exchanger with two types of
sulfonic acid groups bordered by a large hydration functional groups (carboxylic and sulfonic acid
sphere and a hydrophobic polymer backbone [13]. groups), both total ion-exchange capacity and sulfo-
To overcome this difficulty the authors used a nate group densities were evaluated. The final
two-step process: preliminary grafting of poly- results are represented in terms of density of func-
(acrylic acid) chains to improve hydrophilic tional groups (in terms of mEq/g).
properties of a polymer surface and then graft poly-
merization of SSS after another round of irradia- 2. Experimental
tion. The results of SSS grafting on polyethylene
sheets after two low-doses of irradiation are pre- 2.1. Materials
sented in [14].
In a practical aspect, a one-step grafting process Commercial nonwoven polypropylene fabric –
has some economic advantages. Satoshi et al. [9] PP (120 g/m2, degree of crystallinity of 65%, thick-
reported a one-step irradiation process that allowed ness of 1 mm, Toray-Saehan Co., Ltd.) was used
them to synthesize ion-exchange membranes with for grafting. Reagent grade acrylic acid
sulfonate groups by graft copolymerization of SSS (CH2@CHCOOH, Junsei Chemical Co., Ltd.),
in the presence of acrylic acid (AA). However, sodium styrenesulfonate (CH2@CHC6H4SO3Na,
despite their initial claims of successfully synthesiz- Tokyo Kasei Kogyo Co., Ltd.), Mohr’s salt
ing a polyethylene membrane with an ion-exchange ((NH4)2Fe(SO4)2 6H2O, Merck, Germany) were
capacity of 2.5 mEq/g, little data on the peculiarities used as received.
of the copolymerization process from binary mono-
mer mixtures as well as SSS monomer grafting were 2.2. Method
given in that paper. More extensive information
regarding the grafting of SSS and AA onto HDPE 2.2.1. Graft copolymerization procedure
membranes after one-step irradiation is presented The pre-irradiation grafting technique was
in [15]. However, the authors did not disclose any employed for graft copolymerization of the
reasons for the graft copolymerization process. In SSS + AA monomer mixture. Polypropylene fabric
addition, they gave their results in terms of grafting was irradiated in air at ambient temperature by an
degree (a percentage of sample weight increase) electron beam from an ELV-04 electron beam accel-
which allows only indirect evaluation of the effi- erator with an accelerated energy of 1 MeV for dif-
ciency of the grafting of both AA and SSS chains, ferent time periods. After irradiation, the PP fabric
and forbids any comparison with properties of com- was stored at room temperature in a dessicator. The
476 S.W. Lee et al. / Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482
irradiated fabric (about of 0.5 g) was weighed and metal ions adsorbed per gram of dry weight of the
immersed in 100 ml glass flask with a solution of modified PP fabric (mg/g) was calculated by the
AA and SSS monomers in water (AA:SSS = 0.1 M following:
(7.2 g):0.1M (20.6 g) in 100 ml of water; the total
monomer content was a little less than 2 mol l1) Metal ions adsorbed ¼ ðC 0 CÞ V =W
and Mohr’ salt additive. Then, the flask was purged Where, C0 and C are the Cu2+ ion concentrations in
by bubbling nitrogen, sealed up, and placed in a the solution before and after the incubation period,
water bath maintained at a constant temperature respectively (mg/ml); V is the volume of the solution
for different time periods. When the stipulated time (ml); W is the weight of the dried adsorbent used
period was over the grafted PP fabric samples were (g). Calculation of sulfonate group density (in terms
removed from the solution, washed thoroughly with of mEq/g) was based on the adsorption text’s results
hot distilled water and methanol to remove homo- considering a gram-equivalent value of Cu2+ ions.
polymers and unreacted monomers, and dried in a
vacuum oven at 80 °C until constant weight. The
degree of grafting (DG) was calculated from the 3. Results and discussion
weight gain:
3.1. Copolymerization process
DG% ¼ ½ðW 1 W 0 Þ=W 0 100
where W0 and W1 are the weights (g) of the original When polypropylene fabric is irradiated in air,
and grafted fabric, respectively. mainly hydroperoxides are formed onto the poly-
meric backbone. These hydroperoxides decompose
2.2.2. FTIR analysis upon heating to give rise to hydroxyl radicals
To justify the introduction of functional groups (OH) and macroradicals (PPO). Macroradicals
onto the PP fabric, infrared spectroscopy analysis offer a site for grafting, while hydroxyl radicals ini-
was carried out using a FTIR spectrometer (Per- tiate undesirable homopolymerization, which usu-
kin–Elmer, 1725 with a golden gate single reflection ally leads to a decrease in grafting degree. To
ATR system). The spectra of dried grafted and ori- overcome homopolymerization a small amount of
ginal samples were measured directly without transition metal ions are commonly used as inhibi-
treatment. tors [16].
Just as other investigators [13,14] we were unable
2.2.3. Ion-exchange characteristics to graft SSS monomers onto PP fabric in aqueous
Total ion-exchange capacity (mEq/g) of the mod- solutions; however copolymerization of SSS with
ified fabric exhibiting the actual number of acidic AA was successfully done. Many factors affect the
functional groups grafted onto the PP trunk was radiation grafting process of binary monomer mix-
determined by backward titration experiments. tures. The ones investigated here, are absorbed
For this purpose the grafted PP fabric (about dose, reaction time and temperature, monomer
0.5 g) was completely converted to the H+ form ratio, and concentration of inhibitor (Mohr’s salt).
by treatment with an excess solution of 0.1 M HCl
for 12 h. The washed, dried and weighted sample 3.2. Effect of absorbed dose
in the H+ was put into a flask with 20 ml of stan-
dard 0.5 M NaOH solution, stopped down and sha- The influence of the absorbed dose on the degree
ken for about 12 h. Aliquot solutions (2 ml) were of SSS + AA monomer mixture grafting is pre-
titrated to the phenolphthalein end point with a sented in Fig. 1. As it can be seen, the degree of
standard 0.1 M HCl solution. grafting slowly increases to 40.3 kGy, and then
Adsorption of Cu2+ ions onto synthesized PP fab- begins to rise significantly up to 70.5 kGy. The
ric from an aqueous solution (pH 3.8) was inves- authors in [15] demonstrated similar nonlinear
tigated by contacting 0.5 g of grafted PP fabric with behaviors of the DG-absorbed dose in relation to
50 ml solution of CuCl2 salt at 22 °C under stirring the monomer molar ratio of AA:SSS = 2:1.
(140 rpm). One millilitre solution was collected at In the FTIR spectra of grafted samples, irradi-
appropriate time intervals for metal ion determina- ated with doses less than 40.3 kGy, only a character-
tion by using an atomic absorption spectrophotom- istic band at 1715–1730 cm1 assigned to the –C@O
eter (Model UNICAM 989, UK). The quantity of group of acrylic acid was observed, while the FTIR
S.W. Lee et al. / Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482 477
Fig. 1. Effect of absorbed dose on the degree of SSS + AA Fig. 2. Curves of SSS + AA monomer mixture grafting processes
monomer mixture grafting. Reaction temperature 50 °C, reaction at 50 °C (1) and 70 °C (2). Absorbed dose 70.5 kGy; Mohr’s salt
time 12 h, Mohr’s salt 102 wt%. 102 wt%.
spectra of the samples, irradiated with higher doses, The fourth sample with DG = 73.0% corre-
also exhibited characteristic absorption bands sponds to the next fast-growing section of the graft-
attributed to the SSS group. ing curve (within grafting time of 10–12 h). Its FTIR
In order to clarify some peculiarities of the graft spectrum (Fig. 3, spectrum 7) shows the characteris-
copolymerization of SSS + AA monomers from tic absorption bands of the sulfonic acid group
binary monomer mixtures onto the PP fabric sur- (1150 cm1 (asymmetric stretch), 1030 cm1 (sym-
face the degree of graft copolymerization as a func- metric stretch), 670 cm1) together with the adsorp-
tion of time was investigated at 50 and 70 °C, and tion band of the carboxylic group.
the FTIR spectra of the appropriate samples were The next sample with DG = 98.6% corresponds
analyzed. to the next middle-growing section of the grafting
curve. Its FTIR spectrum (Fig. 3, spectrum 8) also
3.3. Effect of reaction time shows the characteristic absorption bands of a sul-
fonic acid group together with the adsorption band
The variation in the degree of monomer mixture of a carboxylic group. Comparing spectra 7 with 8 it
grafting with the reaction time at 50 °C is shown in is possible to note the growth of intensity of the
Fig. 2 (line 1). The curve of the grafting process con- characteristic peaks both for sulfonic acid and of
sists of a few sections that may denote a stepwise acrylic acid with an increase in the degree of mono-
development of the grafting process. To understand mer mixture grafting.
some of the peculiarities of the grafting process The variation in the degree of monomer mixture
from binary monomer mixtures, the FTIR spectra grafting with the reaction time at 70 °C is shown in
of several modified PP samples were investigated Fig. 2 (line 2). The FTIR spectra of studied samples
(Fig. 3). with a DG less than 32% contain the peak at 1715–
Three samples with a low degree of grafting 1730 cm1 attributed to the carboxyl group of
(DG = 2.9%, 7.3%, 8.6%, 17.8%) correspond to acrylic acid. The characteristic peaks of the sulfonic
the initial part of the grafting curve (within grafting acid group appear at the FTIR spectra of grafted
time of 10 h). Their FTIR spectra (Fig. 3, spectra samples with higher values of DG. Their intensity
3–6) exhibit a peak at 1715–1730 cm1 due to car- as well as the intensity of the carboxyl group peak
bonyl stretching absorption of the carboxyl group. increases with an increase in the grafting degree just
The presence of the above peak indicates the graft- as in the case of grafting at 50 °C.
ing of AA monomers onto the PP fabric. The inten- The above results confirm our assumption of a
sity of this absorption band grows with an increase stepwise graft copolymerization process: it is obvi-
in the degree of grafting. ous that the process begins with grafting of acrylic
478 S.W. Lee et al. / Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482
Fig. 3. IR-spectra of original PP fabric (1); AA-g-PP fabric with DG = 95% (2); AA-SSS-g-PP fabric with DG = 2.9% (3); 7.7% (4); 8.8%
(5); 17.8% (6); 73.0% (7); 98.6% (8). Absorbed dose 70.5 kGy, reaction temperature 50 °C.
acid monomers onto the PP backbone (as the first mer mixture grafting begins with AA monomer
step) and then goes on by cografting of SSS and grafting (as the first stage) and then continues with
AA monomers. the grafting of SSS and AA monomers to the
A few possible mechanisms of the copolymeriza- poly(AA) chains already grafted onto the PP fabric.
tion process can be considered. First, AA monomers We carried out the following test experiment: (1) the
graft onto the PP backbone via macroradicals irradiated samples were immersed into an oxygen
formed during irradiation as discussed above. As a free flask with an aqueous solution of Mohr’s salt
result, the hydrophilic properties of the PP fabric (102 wt%) and heated at 50 °C for 12 h; (2) the
improve and SSS monomers can easily diffuse to AA monomer solution was added to the flask, and
the fabric’s surface and also graft directly by the the grafting reaction was allowed to proceed for
remaining macroradicals. 5 h at 50 °C. The absence of AA characteristic peaks
This mechanism fits well with conclusions from in the FTIR spectrum of the control samples indi-
authors who studied the two-step process of cated that all active species which could initiate
SSS + AA monomer mixture grafting [13,14]. For the graft polymerization process, were deactivated
example, authors [14], when carrying out grafting prior to adding of the AA monomers to the flask.
of SSS monomers on modified polyethylene-g-AA However, to find the intrinsic mechanism of the
sheets with a AA grafting degree of 60%, 80% and copolymerization process additional investigations
120%, obtained SSS grafting degrees of 4.5%, are required.
15.1%, 17.2%, respectively, after the second irradia-
tion. One can see that the higher degree of AA pre- 3.4. Effect of monomer ratio
grafting results in a higher degree of SSS grafting.
This fact can be ascribed to the improvement of The relation of the degree of SSS + AA mono-
the hydrophilic properties of the polymer surfaces mer mixture grafting and monomer molar ratio in
[13,14] owing to the grafting of hydrophilic acrylic the reaction solution over the reaction time of 21 h
acid monomers. (the total concentration of monomers in the reac-
Another mechanism for the copolymerization tion solution was about 2 mol l1; it was 1 mol l1
process is possible. The process of SSS + AA mono- for grafting SSS or AA individually) is shown in
S.W. Lee et al. / Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482 479
performed. Since carboxyl groups of AA weakly tion in comparison with the contrary case is
dissociate in the acidic solution, they are not avail- increased.
able for the exchange. In this case only sulfonate The results obtained are of practical significance.
groups, which are highly dissociated and exchange- Apparently, to prepare an effective cation-exchan-
able, will adsorb Cu2+ ions. ger with a high density of sulfonate groups, it is nec-
Sulfonate group density (in terms of mEq/g) was essary to take into account the duration of the
calculated on the base of adsorption tests taking reaction time (because of primary grafting of AA
into account a gram-equivalent value of Cu2+ ions. monomers) and Mohr’s salt additive.
Such evaluation is not exactly quantitative, because It should be noted that the cation-exchange
extraction of Cu2+ ions from studied solutions adsorbents synthesized according to the above
could occur both due to chemical binding by sulfo- approach have sulfonate group densities similar to
nate groups and due to physical adsorption. Never- those of sulfonated polymer membranes and textiles
theless this gives a general idea of the adsorption which have been obtained by radiation-induced
properties of synthesized PP fabric. graft polymerization of styrene with the subsequent
Cation-exchange PP fabrics synthesized at 70 °C sulfonation of polystyrene chains (0.5–3.0 mEq/g)
without Mohr’s salt (line 1) as well as with Mohr’s [4,12,20]. The main advantage of the approach pre-
salt (line 2) were objects of such investigations. sented above is that it is a one-step process of
The calculated densities of sulfonate groups are synthesis.
denoted in the rectangular frameworks above the
studied samples in Fig. 7. 4. Conclusion
It can be seen that the density of sulfonate groups
of fabrics with medium grafting degrees (70–155%) Radiation-induced graft copolymerization of
synthesized without Mohr’s salt varies from 1.10 sodium styrenesulfonate and acrylic acid monomers
to 1.56 mEq/g. However, the value of fabrics syn- onto nonwoven polypropylene fabrics by electron
thesized with Mohr’s salt within the same interval beam pre-irradiation was studied. The influence of
varies from 0 to 1.57 mEq/g. The latter case reflects grafting parameters, namely, adsorbed dose, time
the results of the primary grafting of AA monomers and temperature of the reaction, monomer molar
(0 mEq/g of sulfonate groups) as well as subsequent ratio, and concentration of Mohr’s salt additive
cografting of AA + SSS monomers. on the degree of grafting was examined.
It follows from Fig. 7 that the rate of sulfonate The degree of grafting from binary monomer
group accumulation in the case of Mohr’s salt addi- mixtures is considerably influenced by the adsorp-
482 S.W. Lee et al. / Reactive & Functional Polymers 68 (2008) 474–482