Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lactancia Materna, Desarrollo Motor y Obesidad - Compressed
Lactancia Materna, Desarrollo Motor y Obesidad - Compressed
2017;88(4):451-457
Clinical Overview
DOI: 10.4067/S0370-41062017000400002
a
Institute of Nutrition and Food Technology, Universidad de Chile
b
Clínica Alemana-Facultad de Medicina, Universidad del Desarrollo
Abstract Keywords:
Motor development,
Childhood obesity is the main nutritional and public health problem in Chile, being the princi- obesity,
pal causes, the increase in energy dense foods and the decline of physical activity. Interventions to overweight,
Breastfeeding
prevent obesity at infancy are focused mainly in improving quality and quantity of dietary intake,
without taking into account physical activity, which is expressed under two years of age, mainly by
motor development. Some studies have proven that motor development at early age, may influence
the ability to perform physical activity. Thus, infants scoring a lower motor development may have
a greater risk of becoming obese. It isn’t know if childhood obesity causes lower motor development
(given that children may have greater difficulty to move), or on the contrary, it is the lower ability to
move, which increases the obesity risk. The objective of this manuscriptis analize the evidence regards
the relation between breastfeeding, motor development and obesity in the childhood.To be able to
understand this asocation and casual mecanism, it is important to develop stategys focused in early
infancy to promote breastfeeding, healthy eating and early stimulation, starting in pediatric office.
Correspondence:
Gerardo Weisstaub N.
gweiss@inta.uchile.cl
451
Clinical Overview
Breastfeeding, gross motor development and obesity - G. Weisstaub N et al
452
Clinical Overview
Breastfeeding, gross motor development and obesity - G. Weisstaub N et al
level that mothers might have in order to detect any children with high BMI versus eutrophic, Nervik D et
psychomotor problem of their children and a greater al. reported that the former have more difficulties in
orentation and stimulous to the development of the their gross motor skills at the age of 3 and 5 years old47,
infant37. and according to D’Hondt E et al., they would have
lower motor coordination skills between 6 and 10 years
of age52.
Early motor development and obesity Cheng and Cols, in a cohort of 668 healthy chil-
dren in the city of Santiago de Chile, investigated the
Physical activity and sports provide several health temporal relationship between the acquisition of gross
benefits. Physical condition in childhood and adoles- motor skills and the anthropometric evolution. These
cence is vital for their present and future health, with authors reported that the highest BMI at 5 years of age
an inverse relationship between physical activity, cen- was associated with lower motor proficiency between
tral adiposity and cardiovascular risks38. the ages of 5 and 10 years old; however, lower motor
It seems to be known that motor domain in chil- skills at 5 years were not related to a higher BMI, which
dhood is inversely associated with the sedentary lifes- suggests that obesity is a predictor of lower physical ca-
tyle39 and the improvement of aerobic capacity in ado- pacity, but not vice versa53.
lescents40, so it could be a protection for obesity, indi-
rectly. In a finish cohort, Ridgway et al. described that
early developmental achievements, such as walking or Conclusions
standing without support, were important predictors
of sports participation at around 14 years old, as well as Childhood obesity and sedentary lifestyle are very
increasing their muscle strength and aerobic capacity important problems in the public health system in our
during adulthood41,42. Barnett et al. showed in a sys- country. Although the scheme is not yet clear, there
tematic review that in children from 3 to 18 years old, are several studies supporting the hypothesis that BF
that the correlation between development and physical protects against obesity and, at the same time, promo-
capacity depends on which is the development dimen- tes children’s complete development, with a “dose-
sion evaluated, finding that there is a positive correla- response” relationship. Considering that the develo-
tion with coordination, without being able to determi- pment of motor skills is one of the many items con-
ne the association with other gross motor skills43. ditioning sports participation in the future (with the
Regarding motor development and obesity, the obesity’s long-term protective effect), to promote the
evidence is even less obvious, and it is difficult to es- evolution of children is a responsibility that goes be-
tablish that there is a causal relationship. Currently, yond fulfilling what is considered ‘Normal’ (Figure 1).
it is accepted to think that an infant is overweighted It seems that evidence is increasingly inclined to sup-
because they move less and have worse physical con- port a kind of relationship between early motor skills’
dition in the long term, or that those who later acquire development and physical composition, even though
motor skills, such as independent walking, would tend it is not complete, probably due to the wide heteroge-
to a higher BMI. Table 1 summarizes the articles that neity of available studies and the lack of longer-term
analyze the relationship between motor skills develop- prospective investigations (Table 1).
ment and obesity. You would be able to observe great Regarding the treatment of childhood obesity, re-
heterogeneity between the methodologies and ages sults remain very poor. Additional efforts are needed
evaluated. to fight agaisnt this epidemic of the 21st century. In
There are some studies which conclude that order to prevent overweight , main precautions should
overweight and obese children have lower cognitive be initiated at an early stage54, from the earliest pedia-
and motor skills development. These conclusions are tric health supervision activities, reinforcing healthy
due to the use standardized tests, measuring develo- habits, not only related to food, but also in physical
pment coefficients44-48, while others studies that ques- activity and motor skills development.
tion this association are based on the age of acquisition
of some gross motor skills, related to the acquisition of
independent gait49-51. Conflicts of Interest
Other authors have studied the relationship among
anthropometry, motor skills and physical activity in Authors declare no conflict of interest regarding the
preschoolers and schoolchildren. When comparing present study.
453
Clinical Overview
Breastfeeding, gross motor development and obesity - G. Weisstaub N et al
Table 1. Analysis of studies analyzing the association between motor development and obesity
Articles supporting the association between obesity and gross motor development in infants
Camargos Brazil, Cross- 28 Ow/Ob infants Bayley-III 1) Compare the Ow/Ob infants showed
ACR et al.44 2016 sectional and 28normal- cognitive and motor lower cognitive and motor
weight peers development in composite scores
between 6 and 24 overweight/obese than their normal-weight
months of age infants versus normal- peers:
weight peers Cognitivo composite score
2) To investigate the 100.89 + 9.72 vs 106.25 +
correlation of body 8.35, p 0.03
mass index with Motor composite score
cognitive and motor 96.43 + 10.75 vs 102.14 +
development. 9.386, p 0.04
A significant negative asso-
ciation was found of BMI
with motor development
(r = 0.29, p 0.03)
Andres A USA, Prospective, 469 infants were Bayley-II To characterize total There is negatively relations-
et al. 46 2013 longitudinal assessed at 3, 6, 9, body fat mass and hip between total body FM
cohort study 12, and 24 months motor development and PDI scores was signifi-
of age during the first 2 cant starting at 9 months
years of life in healthy Infants with high total body
infants FM (≥ 31%) scored 1.96
points lower on concurrent
PDI and 3.05 points lower
on subsequent PDI.
Neither anthropometric
measures nor total body FM
was associated with the cli-
nical diag-nosis of delayed
motor development
Nervik D USA, Cross- 50 children who Peabody Develo- To investigate the 58% of the Ow/Ob group
et al.47 2011 sectional were healthy aged 3 pmental Motor relationship bet- scored below average
to 5 years Scales, 2nd edition ween Ow and gross compared to 15% of the
(PDMS-2) motor development in nonoverweight group. As-
children who are de- sociation between BMI and
veloping typically and gross motor quotients was
determine whether identified significant
body mass index (BMI) (p 0.002)
predicts difficulty in
gross motor skills
Slining M USA, Prospective, 217 infant of low- Bayley-II To examine how Motor delay was 1.80
et al. 48 2010 longitudinal income assessed infant Ow and high times as likely in Ow infants
study from 3 to 18 subcutaneous fat compared with non-Ow
months of age relate to infant motor infants (95% CI,1.09-2.97)
development and 2.32 times as likely in
infants with high subcu-
taneous fat compared
with infants with lower
subcutaneous fat (95%CI,
1.26-4.29)
Shibli R. Israel, Cross- 79 infants with Ow/ Parents of infants To assess the preva- Ow infants had significantly
et al.45 2008 sectional Ob and 144 infants were interviewed by lence of morbidity more gross motor deve-
in the control group using a structured in Ow infants in a lopmental delay problems
questionnaire that community-based 7/79 (8.9%) vs 1/144 (0.7),
sample p 0.002
454
Clinical Overview
Breastfeeding, gross motor development and obesity - G. Weisstaub N et al
455
Clinical Overview
Breastfeeding, gross motor development and obesity - G. Weisstaub N et al
456
Clinical Overview
Breastfeeding, gross motor development and obesity - G. Weisstaub N et al
DR. The Health Benefits of Muscular 44. Camargos ACR, Mendonça VA, Andrade in the WHO Child Growth Standards.
Fitness for Children and Adolescents: A CA de, Oliveira KSC, Lacerda ACR. Acta Paediatr Suppl. 2006;450:96-101.
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Overweight and obese infants present 50. Schmidt Morgen C, Andersen AMN,
Sport Med. 2014;44(9):1209-23. lower cognitive and motor development Due P, Neelon SB, Gamborg M,
39. Williams HG, Pfeiffer KA, O’Neill JR, scores than normal-weight peers. Res Dev Sørensen TIA. Timing of motor
Dowda M, McIver KL, et al. Motor skill Disabil. 2016;59:410-6. milestones achievement and
performance and physical activity in 45. Shibli R, Rubin L, Akons H, Shaoul R. development of overweight in childhood:
preschool children. Obesity 2008;16: Morbidity of overweight (>or=85th A study within the Danish National
1421-6. percentile) in the first 2 years of life. Birth Cohort. Pediatr Obes.
40. Barnett LM, Van Beurden E, Morgan PJ, Pediatrics. 2008;122(2):267-72. 2013;9(4):239-48.
Brooks LO, Beard JR. Does childhood 46. Andres A, Casey PH, Bellando J, Cleves 51. Neelon SEB, Oken E, Taveras EM,
motor skill proficiency predict adolescent MA, Badger TM. Effects of Fat Mass on Rifas-Shiman SL, Gillman MW. Age of
fitness? Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2008; 40: Motor Development During the First 2 achievement of gross motor milestones
2137-44. Years of Life. ICAN Infant, Child, Adolesc in infancy and adiposity at age 3 years.
41. Ridgway CL, Ong KK, Tammelin TH, et Nutr. 2013;5(4):248-54. Matern Child Health J. 2012;16(5):1015-
al. Infant Motor Development Predicts 47. Nervik D, Martin K, Rundquist P, Cleland 20.
Sports Participation at Age 14 Years: J. The Relationship Between Body Mass 52. D’Hondt E, Deforche B, Gentier I, et al.
Northern Finland Birth Cohort of 1966. Index and Gross Motor Development in A longitudinal analysis of gross motor
PLoS ONE. 2009;4(8):e6837. Children Aged 3 to 5 Years. Pediatr Phys coordination in overweight and obese
42. Ridgway CL. Birth size, infant weight Ther. 2011;23(2):144-8. children versus normal-weight peers. Int J
gain, and motor development influence 48. Slining M, Adair LS, Goldman BD, Obes. 2013;37:61-7.
adult physical performance. Med Sci Borja JB, Bentley M. Infant overweight 53. Cheng J, East P, Blanco E, et al. Obesity
Sports Exerc. 2009; 41(6): 1212-21. is associated with delayed motor leads to declines in motor skills across
43. Barnett LM, Lai SK, Veldman SLC, et al. development. J Pediatr. 2010;157(1): childhood. Child Care Health Dev.
Correlates of Gross Motor Competence in 20-5. 2016;42(3):343-50.
Children and Adolescents: A Systematic 49. WHO Multicentre Growth Reference 54. Gillman MW, Ludwig DS. How early
Review and Meta-Analysis. Sport Med. Study Group. Relationship between should obesity prevention start? N Engl J
2016;46(11):1663-88. physical growth and motor development Med. 2013;369(23):2173-5.
457