Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This paper was first presented at the Corrosion Control 007 conference in Sydney on the 25 - 28 November 2007.
A single coat inorganic zinc silicate coating system has proven to be repaired and should be removed if degraded, as summarised in a
to provide excellent performance in a range of applications for paper comparing IZS to thermal spray coatings:
over sixty years. However, like all coating systems, maintenance is “When used as a stand alone system, eg as a tank lining or on a
sometimes required. Because of its unique composition and special chimney stack, repairs to damaged IZS require reblasting and reapplica-
application requirements, inorganic zinc has been considered as a tion. … Thermal spray coatings can be applied to itself which simplifies
difficult coating to repair. As a result, a number of different methods repairs where underbuilt areas are found.” (1)
for repair and maintenance of inorganic zinc coatings have been However, others have not required such drastic preparation as re-
suggested. This paper describes the structure of inorganic zinc quiring complete removal of the old coating. One repair procedure (2)
coatings, how they degrade and the issues that must be considered recommends spot blasting to near white metal, although “small areas can
when repairing them. It looks at the results of some repair trials that be cleaned with needle guns. Reapplication may be by spray or brush,
have been carried out. Examples of repair methods used on above but spray is preferred. Freshly applied material can be overlapped onto
ground water pipelines in South Australia and on an overpass in existing inorganic coating. The existing coating must be clean and free
Victoria are given. The work shows that, contrary to some claims, from all organic and inorganic contamination to ensure proper adhesion
repair of inorganic zinc is not difficult and normal surface prepara- between coats.”
tion and application methods can be used. There is no reason why AS/NZS 2312 (3) provides guidance on the maintenance of pro-
such coating systems cannot be simply and economically repaired tective coating systems, but little specific advice for IZS coatings. For
and continue to provide excellent long-term performance. the breakdown of an inorganic zinc silicate coating (not top-coated),
repainting or repair is recommended when about 2% of the surface in
1 INTRODUCTION any particular area shows signs of rusting. The recommended pre-treat-
A single coat inorganic zinc silicate (IZS) coating system has been ment before repainting depends on the amount of breakdown, without
recommended and specified in a range of applications for over sixty distinguishing between different coating types. The standard nominates a
years. In many situations, its performance has been shown to be superior number of coatings (not including IZS) which are compatible with aged
to multi-coat systems. However, like all coating systems, maintenance IZS, but notes there are precautions required for surface preparation
is sometimes required. Because of its unique composition, inorganic and application when recoating inorganic zinc rich coatings. However,
zinc has been considered as a difficult coating to repair. This paper it does not detail repair coating systems nor the specific precautions
looks at issues regarding repair of IZS coatings, including: required for the repair coating.
• Existing views and opinions on IZS system repair The Coatings Guide for New Steel Bridges (4), which recommends
• Results of fundamental studies into breakdown of IZS a single coat water-borne inorganic zinc coating as the optimum coating
coatings carried out in the 1970s for steel bridges, states that these coatings “should never need complete
• The results of trials on recoating IZS removal provided that adequate maintenance is carried out to ensure that
• Case studies of IZS repairs in South Australia and in coating breakdown and rusting does not exceed 5% of the total surface
Victoria area at any stage.” The Guide briefly covers recoatability in Appendix
5, listing manufacturer’s recommendations. Interestingly, different
2 VIEWS ON REPAIR OF IZS COATINGS coating suppliers recommend completely different surface preparation
A number of different methods for repair and maintenance of inor- procedures for applying a new coat of water-borne IZS over an old coat
ganic zinc coatings have been suggested and there is a wide variation of IZS. Two companies recommend high pressure water cleaning only,
in opinions. At one extreme, the view is that basically they are not able one company recommends a brush blast, and two companies require a
Figure 2: Inorganic zinc silicate coating after 2 years exposure to sea water at low tide. (Ref 5)
These investigators also looked at the same type of coating exposed An owner would probably not require repair of an IZS coated struc-
to a low tide sea water environment for comparison. This is not an ture unless there were regions showing red rust, that is having affected
environment where IZS would be specified, but enabled rapid degrada- regions showing a local structure similar to that obtained after marine
tion of the coating to occur, perhaps equivalent to decades of exposure exposure. Red rust starts forming when the corrosion “front” reaches
in a normal atmosphere. As expected, in this case the zinc particles the steel surface and the steel starts corroding forming ferrous ions.
were extensively corroded in the entire layer although, as shown in Regions of low coating thickness will be the first to show this affect.
Figure 2, zinc particles still exist. Dissolution of the iron substrate had The steel surface reacts with the oxygen and moisture causing the rust
commenced but the corrosion has not undercut the coating, as would to form. Unlike zinc corrosion products, rust has a distinctive orange
occur in conventional coatings, and iron corrosion products were colour, and the steel corrosion products start filling the gaps within the
largely retained within the coating. Visually, the deterioration of the silicate matrix. This gives the appearance that the surface is rusting, but
coating seems worse than it really is. The presence of the rust within in fact the rust is bound within the silicate matrix and is not the loose
the silicate matrix tended to reduce leaching of zinc corrosion products powdery material usually seen when steel corrodes. The amount of steel
from the original sites of metallic zinc particles. With exposure to sea corrosion is quite small, and no pitting is apparent if this rusty region is
water, the zinc corrosion products that provided barrier protection with blast cleaned from the surface. These patches of rust tend to grow very
atmospheric exposure are lost by leaching and dissolution. Neither the slowly as the coating weathers.
marine environment nor the atmospheric environment appeared to have So, even if at first glance a degraded IZS coating looks like a badly
attacked the glassy silicate matrix. rusted paint film, in fact there are features that mean the surface is in
7 CONCLUSIONS
A single coat inorganic zinc silicate can provide excellent protec-
tion in a range of atmospheric environments. However, repair will be
required at some stage. This paper has looked at how such coatings
Figure 9: Duncans Road beams after patch repair. degrade, the results of trials to determine appropriate repair procedures,
and successful repair case studies in Victoria and South Australia. These
show that repair of single coat inorganic zinc can be carried out suc-
cessfully and economically.
The key aspects of inorganic zinc silicate coating degradation and
its repair are:
The existence of red rust within a degraded inorganic zinc silicate
coating does not necessarily indicate significant steel corrosion and the
percentage breakdown that can be tolerated before repair is required is
greater than for other coatings.
Surface preparation of corroded areas before application of repair
coating requires removal of the degraded coating and other contami-
nants. Brush blasting or power tool cleaning combined with a thorough
pressure water wash are ideal. The actual extent of surface preparation
and cleaning depends on the degree of coating breakdown.
Either solvent borne or water borne coatings can be applied as
repair coats, with selection depending on expected weather conditions
Figure 10: Adhesion testing of repaired regions on and applicator skill.
Duncans Road beams.
The initial adhesion of a repair coating is often only moderate, but
will increase significantly with ageing and weathering. Adhesion of
the repair coat after a year or so will usually be excellent with proper
surface preparation and application.
8 REFERENCES
1. W L Mandeno & T A Sutherland, Inorganic zinc silicates vs
metal spray in industrial applications, Seminar on Inorganic
Zinc, Auckland, 18 Sept 1997.
2. TPC2 “Coatings and Linings for Immersion Service”,
Revised edition (1998), NACE, Houston, Chapter 15.
3. AS/NZS 2312 – Guide to the protection of structural steel
against atmospheric corrosion by the use of protective
coatings, Standards Australia, Sydney; 2002
4. A Szokolik & F Rappatoni, Coatings Guide for New Steel
Bridges, BHP Integrated Steel, Wollongong, November
1998.
5. H Jaeger & R G Sherwood, The structure of inorganic
Figure 11: Severe mudcracking in corner regions.
Munters can offer short term or long-term climate control for any industrial or commercial application. Contact us: