You are on page 1of 13

R E C O V ER Y A N D R E H A B I L I T A T I O N

Working the way up in neurological rehabilitation: the holistic


approach of nursing care
Mari Carmen Portillo and Sarah Cowley

Aim. To provide understanding of the nurses’ role in neurological holistic rehabilitation and identify strategies for the
enhancement of rehabilitation services.
Background. Although acute and chronic neurological patients and relatives experience emotional and social changes, most
rehabilitation programmes do not deal with non-physical needs or involve nurses, leading to a poor definition and specialisation
of the nursing role.
Design. Action research.
Method. The project took place in two neurological wards of a highly specialised hospital in Spain and lasted 30 months. An
individualised nurse-led social rehabilitation programme was planned, implemented and evaluated. The nursing role and care in
rehabilitation were explored with 37 nurses and 40 neurological patients and 40 relatives (convenience sampling). Semi-
structured interviews and participant observations were developed. Content (QSR NUDIST Vivo v.2.0) and statistical
(SPSS v. 13.0) analyses were run.
Results. The lack of time, knowledge and experience, the poor definition of the nursing role and ineffective communication with
users limited holistic care in the wards. Some enhancing nursing strategies were proposed and explored: promotion of accep-
tance/adaptation of the disease through education, reinforcement of the discharge planning and planning of emotional and
social choices based on the assessment of individual needs and resources at home.
Conclusions. Nursing professionals are in a privileged position to deal with neurological patients’ and carers’ holistic needs.
Several attributes of the advanced nursing role in rehabilitation teams have been proposed to deal with non-physical aspects of
care.
Relevance to clinical practice.
• Rehabilitation needs of neurological patients and carers at hospital have been described.
• Nurses’ perceptions of their work and role in rehabilitation have been presented.
• Clinical strategies to develop the advanced nursing role in holistic neurological rehabilitation have been highlighted.

Key words: advanced nursing practice, carers, neurology, nurses, nursing role, rehabilitation

Accepted for publication: 8 May 2010

literature in neurological care advocates the importance of


Introduction
physical and cognitive changes at short term and of psycho-
Neurological diseases such as cerebro-vascular accidents social needs at long term, patients and relatives have referred
(CVA), Parkinson’s disease (PD) and multiple sclerosis (MS) to the experience of non-physical needs with more or less
are a priority for health care in the Western World (Lackey & intensity at all stages of the disease (McKeown et al. 2003,
Gates 2001, Merino & Hachinski 2003). Although the Bakas et al. 2004, Mackenzie et al. 2004).

Authors: Mari Carmen Portillo, PhD, MSc, BSc, RGN, Associate Correspondence: Mari Carmen Portillo, Associate Lecturer, Escuela
Lecturer, School of Nursing, University of Navarre, Navarre; Spain, Universitaria de Enfermerı́a. Universidad de Navarra. C/Irunlarrea, s/
Sarah Cowley, BA, PhD, PGDE, RGN, RHV, HVT, Professor of n, Edificio Los Castaños, 31008 Pamplona (Navarra), Spain.
Community Practice Development, Florence Nightingale School of Telephone: 0034 948 42 56 00 ext. 6535.
Nursing and Midwifery, King’s College London, London, UK E-mail: mportillo@unav.es

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1731
doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2702.2010.03379.x
MC Portillo and S Cowley

To achieve holistic outcomes, rehabilitation programmes time with the patient and carer, establish close relationships
need to reinforce aspects such as the promotion of acceptance and can determine holistic needs without planning specific
and adaptation to the disease and care process (Noble 1998/ sessions. Nurses, however, do not seem to be actively involved
99, Long et al. 2002), information (Watson & Quinn 1998, in the rehabilitation programmes. There is limited published
Wiles et al. 1998, Forbes et al. 2003), social problem solving knowledge about professionals’ perceptions of clients’ needs
(Grant 1999) or the involvement of users in decision making and holistic care and there are very few rehabilitation
(Edwards and Ruettiger 2002, Portillo et al. 2002, Ross et al. programmes led by nurses (Rawl et al. 1998, Forster et al.
2005). Therefore, it is important to determine what charac- 1999, Boter 2004, Nir et al. 2004, Burton & Gibbon 2006).
teristics rehabilitation programmes could have to cover these This is related to the lack of definition of the nursing role in
needs and what professionals are in a good position to neurological rehabilitation and the secondary role of nurses
provide long-term holistic rehabilitation. in rehabilitation programmes. Several authors have explored
the nursing role in neurological rehabilitation (Nolan &
Nolan 1998a,b, Thorn 2000, Long et al. 2002, Burton 2003,
Background
Kvigne et al. 2005) and have underlined that nurses promote
coordination, multidisciplinary care and personal recovery.
The type and contents of the rehabilitation programmes
Nevertheless, the nursing role needs to contemplate psycho-
Very few programmes have attempted to promote social/ social coping strategies to achieve long-term recovery, further
emotional rehabilitation through psychosocial interventions work on sexuality and the interpersonal relationship between
(Glass et al. 2000, Knapp et al. 2000, Ojeda del Pozo et al. nurses–patients–carers and more multidisciplinary work
2000, Pacchetti et al. 2000, Grant et al. 2006). In these through consultation.
programmes, some issues can be underlined: (1) the expected The promotion of more defined roles in rehabilitation
outcomes were the increase of leisure activities, social skills directly relates to advanced practice nursing, quality and
and functioning, effective social problem solving, community safety of care and cost-effectiveness (Forbes et al. 2003).
independence, emotional well-being and communication According to Hamric et al. (2009), the core competences of
skills; (2) the authors said that the interventions of the advanced practice nursing are expert coaching and guidance,
programmes were individually tailored, even if no concrete consultation, research skills, clinical and professional leader-
forms of social assessment were used to individualise care and ship, collaboration, ethical decision-making skills and direct
promote effective social problem solving (Lui et al. 2005, clinical practice. Some of these competences can be identified
Grant et al. 2006); (3) the programmes were successful at in the literature regarding the nursing role in neurological
improving motivation, anxiety and communication, although rehabilitation, and others need further development as it will
there was no clear improvement of attitudes and long-term be shown in this study.
social life; and (4) the interventions of the programmes
focused on the active involvement of patients and in some
Objectives
cases, carers and the definition of choices. The involvement of
patients and relatives in setting care goals supports the need The objectives of this paper are:
to promote the planning of individually tailored programmes 1 To describe the clinical nurses’ role and practice in neu-
through the assessment of needs which is a strategy to rological rehabilitation.
develop patients’ self-control, positivism and skills in dealing 2 To determine neurological patients’ and carers’ needs in
with delicate and private issues like social and sexual life rehabilitation at hospital at short and long term.
(Koch & Kralik 2001, Calne 2003, Palmer et al. 2004, Kralik 3 To define strategies that could be planned to develop
et al. 2006). This is a neglected area as many neurological holistic nursing rehabilitation and advanced practice
rehabilitation programmes are protocol based. nursing at neurological wards.

The professional contribution Methods


Individualised rehabilitation programmes would include long
Design
sessions with patients and carers, involving several specialists
and outcomes would not be always positive, then, this might Data from a larger action research (AR) project are presented
not be cost effective. This could be solved by developing the in this paper. Three cycles of stages of Lewin (1946) including
nurses’ role in non-physical care because nurses spend more stages of planning, executing and evaluation were completed.

1732  2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743
Recovery and rehabilitation Nursing care in holistic rehabilitation

Additionally, the experimental and professionalising typolo- criteria established in the project through a convenience
gies of Hart and Bond (1995) were applied (Portillo 2009, sampling method (Bowling 2002).
Portillo et al. 2009). Ethical approval was obtained from the
Ethics Committee of the hospital, and consent forms were
Data collection
signed by all participants for all the instruments. Two wards
of a highly specialised hospital in Spain were accessed for the To fully understand holistic care and, plan strategies for
study. The groups of participants (Table 1) were all nurses developing the nurses’ role and enhance the validity of data,
working in the wards and neurological patients and relatives multiple triangulation of data-sources, instruments (between/
who were admitted in the wards and met the inclusion within methods), unit of analysis and investigators (Denzin

Table 1 Inclusion/Exclusion criteria for patients and relatives and nurses

Inclusion criteria Description Explanation/Exceptions

Patients and carers


Diagnosis for admission Patients should have a stroke for first time Patients could have had a Transient Ischemic Attack
(TIA) before this stroke, or a previous stroke at
least 4–6 months before this admission because
symptoms of that TIA or stroke could have
recovered
PD and MS patients could be admitted PD and MS patients could have been diagnosed
because of other reason rather than the during the hospitalisation they were accessed
disease
Communication Patients with aphasia/dysarthria should Speech could be recovered after treatment if we
disorders be included but their participation needed them to participate in later stages of the
would consist of completing the ADLs study
Scales and personal data forms at
hospital
Caring situation Relatives should be the main carers of When patients did not have relatives, their main
those patients included in the study carers at home were approached
Place of residence Patients and carers should live in If not possible, patients whose home was at not
Pamplona (Navarra) where the data more than 4–6 -hour distance (return trip) in
collection took place means of transport such as coach, train or car,
were also included
Home care Relatives should take care of patients at If any patient was transferred to another health
home Institution, relatives had to be the main carers for
the patient in such health institutions
Language Patients and relatives should not have When Spanish was not possible, English
problems in speaking and understanding
Spanish
Length of hospitalisation Patients should stay in hospital at least Time was needed to properly access them and give
four days them time to decide on their participation and
undertake an interview
Nurses
Nurses’ work contract Nurses should have a stable work This criterion was established to facilitate the
situation (contracts longer than continuity of the research process and ensure the
15 months) in the wards permanence of the change in the wards (for later
Nurses doing speciality in the wards that stages of the study). This was possible if nurses
are expected to be contracted in a near remained in the wards after the study finished
future
Nurses’ shifts Nurses should not do night shifts Changes were planned to be mainly implemented in
exclusively day shifts and nurses were expected to collaborate
in such changes (later stages of the study) what
would be impossible during night shifts
Reasons for exclusion for Incapacity, unwillingness, impossibility
all groups of participants for access

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1733
MC Portillo and S Cowley

1970, Waterman 1998) and a complete review of the Participant observations


literature (Portillo Vega 2006) took place. Participant observations (Gold 1958) were carried out and
roles of Full Participant and Participant as Observer were
Nurses’, patients’ and relatives’ interviews combined (Polit-O’Hara & Hungler 1997, Turnock & Gib-
Semi-structured interviews (Bowling 2002) were undertaken son 2001) to avoid conflicts with the participative nature of
with nurses during shifts and patients’ hospitalisation. AR. The observation instrument contained structured, semi-
Interviews lasted from 30–50 minutes and were recorded and structured and unstructured items (Table 3). A total of
fully transcribed. All interviews with all participants were 66 hours and 10 minutes were recorded in early shifts and
carried out in a one-to-one basis. Interviews were conducted 68 hours and 30 minutes in late shifts (70 interactions were
separately and lasted from 32–77 minutes. The interviews observed).
schedules are outlined in Table 2.

Analysis of data
Socio-demographic forms and the 10-Barthel Index of
Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) (modified version) Data from interviews and open questions from observations
Participants also completed a socio-demographic form, were content analysed (Miles & Huberman 1994) using QSR
which included aspects such as age, gender, marital status, NVivo for Windows XP. To ensure objectivity, two research-
work experience, level of education, working and household ers analysed data from interviews simultaneously and
status and presence of hazards at home. The Barthel Index achieved high concordance (Sandelowski 1986). When there
of ADLs (Wade & Langton Hewer 1987) was also com- was no agreement, a third researcher was consulted. Only
pleted with patients to determine their level of functional minor disagreements of the statement of some categories
independence in personal care and mobility at hospital. occurred, not affecting the whole sense of the built categories.
Validity and internal consistency coefficients of this Index For the analysis, transcripts from interviews and open
have been already reported (Wade & Langton Hewer 1987, answers of observations were coded (i.e. Nurse 1, N1,
Shah et al. 1989). Patient/Relative 1 Parkinson disease group 1, P/R1pdg1) and

Table 2 Nurses’ and patients’ and relatives’ interviews main contents

Interview applied to nurses Interview applied patients and relatives

Issue 1 Issue 1
Nursing role in working with stroke/Parkinson/Multiple Sclerosis The impact of the disease and the admission experience/and the
patients and relatives diagnosis
Issue 2 Issue 2
Changes caused by Stroke/Parkinson/Multiple Sclerosis in patients The disease process and information issues
and relatives
Issue 3 Issue 3
Changes occurred in social life Family involvement in care
Issue 4 Issue 4
Stroke/Parkinson/Multiple Sclerosis rehabilitation Rehabilitation issues
Issue 5 Issue 5
Attitudes towards social life after Stroke/in Parkinson/Multiple The disease and changes caused by it
Sclerosis
Issue 6 Issue 6
Alternatives in social life after stroke/in Parkinson/Multiple Sclerosis Changes in social life
Issue 7 Issue 7
Nursing role in promoting social life after stroke/in Parkinson/ Attitudes towards having social life
Multiple Sclerosis
Issue 8 Issue 8
Nursing role in informing patients and relatives after stroke/about Possible alternatives for social life (only if social life affected)
Parkinson/Multiple Sclerosis
Issue 9 Issue 9
Nursing role in promoting lay participation in care Opinions and perceptions about professionals
Issue 10
Nurses encouraging patients and relatives to increase social life

1734  2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743
Recovery and rehabilitation Nursing care in holistic rehabilitation

Table 3 Participant observations

Details Explanation

Items Structured Distribution of the wards


Semi-structured Nurse-patient ratio
Unstructured Shift, length of interactions with patients and relatives
Type of information, type of care, response of patients
and relatives in interactions
Event Every time that participant nurses interacted with
stroke, PD and MS patients and/or their relatives
during the observational interval
Interval Early shift: Range of time was not defined until a deeper knowledge
(1) 9Æ00–10Æ30 of the routines of the wards was gained
(2) 11Æ30–13Æ30
Late shift: 16Æ00–19Æ00

organised. Although after the analysis of all transcripts interviews and observations have been integrated in three
several major themes emerged, for the focus of this paper the main topics:
most relevant themes have been covered. A statistical package 1 The nursing role in health education and information.
SPSS 13.0 for Windows (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) was 2 The need for acceptance and adaptation.
used. Descriptive (quantitative variables) and frequencies 3 Holistic assessment and life choices.
(qualitative variables) analyses were run with some items of These topics were considered the most representative of the
the observations, the socio-demographic forms and the nursing role in holistic rehabilitation from data and will be
Barthel Index of ADLs (Bowling 2002). For the comparison developed to describe the nature of the nurses’ role in
of data obtained from the samples of patients and relatives neurological rehabilitation and identify some strategies and
and observations non-parametric analyses were undertaken. limitations for the enhancement of rehabilitation services.
Significance was established at 0Æ05.
The nursing role in education and information
In observations only 35 of 70 interactions involved infor-
Results
mation or education. Among them, 14 of 35 informative
interactions were initiated by doctors and the same number
Participant nurses
by nurses. Most educative interactions (27/35) focused on the
A total of 37 all eligible nurses, female and with an average disease, treatment and physical aspects of care and only two
working experience with neurological patients of 8Æ14 years of 35 interactions focused on lay participation in care, one on
participated in the study. rehabilitation, one on social issues and three on discharge
planning.
Despite what was observed, patients and relatives did not
Patients and carers
feel educated by nurses and did not consider that informa-
Forty patients and 40 relatives were accessed (see their tion-education was a nursing duty. There seemed to be a lack
sociodemographic characteristics in Table 4). Generally, of patients’ and relatives’ initiative to demand information as
carers were the patients’ partners. Patients’ median level of it is illustrated in the following:
disability was moderate (scores of 0 indicated total depen-
R18msg1: … I don’t like going into information in any depth because
dence and of 20 total autonomy).
I wouldn’t understand, I am not curious… I have enough with basic
information… an explanation of the disease… I trust doctors, I don’t
Data from interviews and observations ask more…

Twenty-three of 37 interviewed nurses were observed at In general, clients said that they only needed information and
least once when interacting with patients and relatives. Four advice to deal with formal and informal help in care giving,
patients had speech problems at this stage and could not be guidelines about day centres, care management and courses
interviewed but were recruited with their carers anyway as for carers. Twelve patients and nine relatives search for
they could recover and participate in later stages of the information in Internet, mass media and magazines. Further-
study. For this paper, findings from the analysis of more, they said that these not always reliable sources of

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1735
MC Portillo and S Cowley

Table 4 Demographic data and score in ADLs Index for patients and standing of the information provided and did not know about
carers societies of patients with PD and MS.
Patients Relatives Finally, most nurses (35/37) were aware of their important
Variables (n = 40) (n = 40) p-value role providing or clarifying information or in health educa-
tion but they recognised that this role was underdeveloped.
Age 64Æ5 (56, 70) 55Æ5 (41, 67Æ7) 0Æ01*
Gender Nurses believed that patients at early stages of the disease
Male 25 (62Æ5%) 11 (27Æ5%) 0Æ014** could be orientated towards societies (10/37) or other
Female 15 (37Æ5%) 29 (72Æ5%) professionals or health disciplines in the postdischarge
Barthel score patients 13Æ5 (6Æ2, 17) – period. The problem was that their experience and resources
Patients’ disease
doing this were limited and nurses did not know how to put
Stroke 14 (35%)
PD 17 (42Æ5%)
patients and relatives in contact with other professionals for
MS 9 (22Æ5%) social resources (22/37):
Marital status
N13: I don’t have any experience in holistic rehabilitation, I think
Single 6 (15%) 4 (10%) 0Æ748*
Married/living with 29 (72Æ5%) 32 (80%) that when somebody works in a hospital it is important to have
partner contacts with other services to know what the patient’s status is after
Widower/widow 3 (7Æ5%) 2 (5%) discharge.
Separated/divorced 1 (2Æ5%) 1 (2Æ5%)
Nun/priest 1 (2Æ5%) 1 (2Æ5%) In 31 of 35 observed educative interactions during hospi-
Educational background talisation, no written resources were used. The only written
No reading and writing 1 (2Æ5%) 0 (0%) 0Æ064* information patients and relatives received was the medical
Reading and writing 6 (15%) 3 (7Æ5%)
report when they were at home, and it was not explained to
Primary school 14 (35%) 15 (37Æ5%)
Secondary school 9 (22Æ5%) 6 (15%)
them personally. Considering this evidence, most nurses
First degree 7 (17Æ5%) 13 (32Æ5%) (36/37) suggested that handling leaflets and brochures could
Postgraduate studies 2 (5%) 3 (7Æ5%) be helpful and supportive because that would ease the
Musical career 1 (2Æ5%) 0 (0%) process of information, new questions would arise and
Working status patients and relatives would better retain written than
Full time (30h+/week) 10 (25%) 14 (35%) 0Æ007*
verbal information.
Part time (8–30 0 (0%) 4 (10%)
hours/week)
Housewife 12 (30%) 14 (35%) The need for acceptance and adaptation
Student 0 (0%) 1 (2Æ5%) Nurses believed that ‘acceptance’ and ‘adaptation’ to the
Permanent 1 (2Æ5%) 1 (2Æ5%) disease were essential for patients and relatives and were part
unemployment
of holistic rehabilitation. Thirteen nurses thought of making
(disability)
Retired 16 (40%) 6 (15%)
patients aware of their own limitations, assessing the level of
Pre-retired 1 (2Æ5%) 0 (0%) acceptance of the disease and being realistic about the situ-
Care situation ation were key strategies to implement. Most nurses (26/37)
No carer 9 (22Æ5%) 10 (25%) 0Æ102* were concerned about the need to intensify these activities in
Partner and/or 24 (60%) 23 (57Æ5%) denying patients that needed more time to accept and adapt
son/daughter as
to global changes and faced more difficulties during the
carers
Paid carer and/or 6 (15%) 6 (15%) transition process:
nursing home
N18: First of all, they have to assume it, it has to be very, very hard
Parents as carers 1 (2Æ5%) 1 (2Æ5%)
and then, I don’t know if it would be good to organise meetings with
Age and Barthel Index values: Median and Interquartile Range other people in a similar status to make them see they are not alone
(IQR): Percentile 25/75 (P25, P75).
out there.
Other variables: Frequency (percentage).
Tests: *Wilcoxon signed rank test, **Mc-Nemar. Some patients (13/40) felt useless and a burden for relatives
and this could limit the process of adaptation. Patients felt
they bothered the carer with their needs and wanted to be
information provided them with the information-education self-sufficient. During hospitalisation, patients and relatives
they longed. Nevertheless, 11 patients and 15 carers did not were asked about their expectations of life after discharge
even know what their disease consisted of, lacked under- and there were positive and negative answers. Six patients

1736  2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743
Recovery and rehabilitation Nursing care in holistic rehabilitation

and eight carers believed that life could improve if leisure cases this was an aspect that needed reinforcement to get to
activities were distributed over time so as not to exhaust the know the patient and the carer.
patient and only once they overcome the acute exacerbation
of the disease. From interviews, it could be deduced that 13 Holistic assessment and life choices
patients and 15 carers did not have realistic views of the Nurses did not seem to realise how important life changes
changes and expectations for life after discharge, affecting were for patients and relatives and what exactly they con-
their level of adaptation and acceptance. This was perceived sisted of. This was related to the lack of follow-up of the
in the following case of a severely disabled stroke patient who disease process and the discontinuity between clinical and
was at a reluctance stage of the disease and did not accept its primary nursing. Hospital health professionals seemed to
consequences: work in isolation, as illustrated:

P1stg1: I think that my social life will improve after discharge. I will P6stg1: … there are no problems during the stay in hospital, even
have to take work easy but I will do the same quietly. I might only more, people are charming, there is this environment…, positive, you
need to avoid travelling to contact clients… don’t have any problem. Problems arise when one is out… out of the
comfort… … maybe one is overprotected in the hospital and lost at
Furthermore, other relatives suffered the patients’ reluctance
home.
to socialise because of embarrassment (10/40). In other cases,
acceptance had become conformity (six patients and four For most nurses (34/37), the assessment of holistic needs
relatives). This and the fact that these patients and relatives and the provision of life choices were considered the
mainly focused their answers on life changes instead of backbone of holistic rehabilitation. The need to assess the
solutions indicated that adaptation was not taking place. family situation to find a balance between ‘overprotective’
Encouragement was a key strategy for nurses to promote and ‘barely involved’ families was stated. Nurses suggested
acceptance. In 27 of 70 observed interactions (38Æ6%), that friends and relatives could encourage patients to be
nurses provided emotional support. Accordingly, some active, relate to others from the time of hospitalisation, meet
patients and carers felt emotionally supported or expected other people and entertain and go out with them even if the
emotional support from nurses (27/80). This support was patient refused to do so. The assessment of patients’ and
also provided by the family. In 85Æ7% of observations, relatives’ needs and possibilities at home was another point
patients were accompanied by at least one relative, and in to be approached, when planning a rehabilitation pro-
30% of the observations there was more than one carer gramme based on individual needs. Nurses clearly stated
with the patient. However, the emotional support as an that they needed to know what social life, emotional needs,
isolated activity did not seem to work for holistic rehabil- hobbies or work patients and relatives had before the
itation. This was also perceived during observations disease and could develop afterwards, to diagnose, inter-
because 57 of 70 (81Æ4%) interactions involved physical vene, delegate and evaluate any problem and develop their
care, 12 (17Æ1%) cognitive care and only two (2Æ9%) social role. The problem posed was that nurses only used verbal
care. Regarding this data, most nurses (35/37) said that communication with clients to obtain this type of informa-
dealing with psychosocial needs was a community staff’s tion and that nurses felt afraid of the patients’ and relatives’
responsibility. Their lack of knowledge and experience response towards the assessment and socialisation because
about this issue mainly caused the denial of the responsi- nurses could be intruding into a private ‘ambit’ and lacked
bility. Nurses felt poorly involved in rehabilitation, skills to obtain this type of information.
depended on other professionals and saw themselves as Patients and relatives felt that their life had changed as a
coordinators of rehabilitation services. Only seven nurses result of the disease and most changes related to social and
had some experience in this type of rehabilitation, espe- family life and work. Some patients forecast changes such as
cially gained from their own family environment and not in the culinary adaptation, the change of unhealthy habits or
the ward. social changes (travelling, group activities, sports…). Rela-
The involvement of patients and carers in the decision tives felt that the indirect repercussions of the disease; the
making was also important in the process of transition. Some alcohol restrictions, the role changes or their fear of being
relatives (18/40) did feel involved in care because they were rejected (19/40) led to changes in friendships and a decrease
consulted about the decisions made, were asked about in hobbies and intellectual activities. Most times all this was
changes in the patient’s condition, informed about the influenced by the patients’ reluctance (15/40) to socialise. Life
different procedures and instructed in very specific aspects predisease had to be assessed to evaluate the magnitude of the
of care such as insulin administration. However, in most change:

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1737
MC Portillo and S Cowley

R13pdg1: I used to walk in the morning, especially because my was 3Æ94, the mean ratio nurse/patient was 1/9Æ93 and the
cholesterol is high, but then as I could not leave him (the patient) mean length of the observed interactions of nurses with
alone, I stopped going for a walk. I started to go shopping in the patients or relatives in minutes was 6Æ79. Therefore, even
closest groceries. At present, he can’t move and then I have to hurry though nurses had an important load of patients to care, they
up and finish everything in 5 or 10 minutes. spent enough time with patients and relatives to undertake an
adequate assessment.
To promote holistic rehabilitation emotional and social
choices had to be set. Some participants (39/80) felt they
could not find solutions for life changes. To develop their role
Discussion
consequently, most nurses (34/37) agreed that social and
emotional advice could be provided to face life and potential To meet objective 3, strategies which could be planned to
problems, such as adapting activities to the new situation, or develop holistic nursing rehabilitation and advanced practice
looking for other ways to relate to others. nursing at neurological wards have been defined and discussed
Most patients and relatives (50/80) wanted to have their (Fig. 1). It has been stated that although the nursing discipline
individual needs assessed and be better prepared for the is expected to establish its basis on holistic care, nursing
discharge; therefore, the problem/solving strategy seemed sometimes remained task orientated and neglected some non-
adequate for a rehabilitation programme. Patients and physical aspects of care. The literature repeatedly supported
relatives were also asked about choices for social life, their this (Gage & Storey 2004, Booth et al. 2005) and the fact that
expectations of professional advice and about the choices patients and relatives had emotional and social needs at
they had already considered: different stages (Makenzie et al. 1998, McKeown et al. 2003,
Bakas et al. 2004).
R14stg1: I don’t know what social life is good for my husband (the
Education and information were relevant to rehabilitation
patient). I would like somebody to tell me if going to certain places or
owing to the feelings of security that being informed/involved
eating certain things is harmful for him. I don’t take any risk, I stay at
could mean for patients and carers. This was related to the
home.
fact that patients’ and in fewer cases relatives’ information
Introducing this type of assessments in the wards could be needs about psychosocial care were not always satisfied. This
limited by the perception of overburden. This was supported could be related to the nurses’ belief that when patients
by patients’ and relatives’ testimonies as they considered that experienced a chronic process such as PD and MS, informa-
nurses could not do much better because they were ‘running tion should only focus on treatment, home care and medicine
up and down’. Observation data showed that during the 70 advances, which were what they thought patients and
observed interactions the mean number of nurses per shift relatives seemed to be interested in. There seemed to be

Education
Awareness of holistic needs of Importance of nursing More active role
patients and carers contribution in detecting and Nursing written information
dealing with holistic needs Acceptance and adaptation

Consultation &
Delegation
Levels of care
Attitudes Other services
Networking
Role attributes

Development of instruments for Holistic care


holistic assessment Individual holistic assessments
Holistic assessments Family assessments
Experience in assessments Communication skills
Knowledge Empathy
& clinical
Social advice, networks, experience Research skills/use
emotional support, of evidence
resources, life choices. Decision-making
Delegation, contacts Education
Innovation and development
of service

Collaboration/leadership
Within/between disciplines
Lay carers
Patient

Figure 1 Analysis of holistic rehabilitation and the nursing role. Strategies for enhancement.

1738  2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743
Recovery and rehabilitation Nursing care in holistic rehabilitation

differences between patients’ and relatives’ and professionals’ An attempt has been made to find connections between
perceptions of information needs and this requires further rehabilitation and family support and information. Essen-
exploration. In the literature, several studies have included tially, it could be said that the more the patient and the family
written information in the rehabilitation packs and proved its know about the disease and how to manage its holistic
effectiveness with also chronic neurological patients and repercussions, the more the disease would be accepted and
carers (Grant 1999, Mant et al. 2000, Forster et al. 2001) they could co-exist with the disease. The three groups of
and this could be considered in future rehabilitation pro- participants highlighted the need for ‘acceptance’ and ‘adap-
grammes and integrated in daily practice. Nursing profes- tation’ (Rawl et al. 1998, Boter 2004) as these constituted the
sionals need to be seen as consultors or coaches and this first step towards reintegration in these neurological diseases
could prevent patients and relatives from searching for (Nolan & Nolan 1997, O’Connor 2000), Advanced practice
information in sources of doubtful reliability (Hamric et al. nursing in rehabilitation could be also developed taking this
2009). Furthermore, handling written information before into account as ‘being a coach’ for patients and carers starts
discharge could solve the lack of understanding of informa- from understanding the disease process from their perspective
tion because misconceptions and doubts about the disease, its (Palmer et al. 2004, Grant et al. 2006, Kralik et al. 2006).
repercussions and prognosis could be approached. This could The difficulties found in the process of ‘acceptance’ and
be a solution to promote coaching and consultation, which ‘adaptation’ in acute and chronic disorders and the planning
were attributes of the nursing role that emerged in this study. of coping strategies could be overcome by undertaking
However, the coaching attribute of advanced practice nursing careful ‘social, emotional and family assessment’ with
was limited because nurses did not use evidence to support patients and carers, which could constitute the mainstays of
their role and did not consult other professionals or levels of nurses’ practice. Several studies have recommended to
care. include assessments in rehabilitation programmes to base
Other attributes that needed reinforcement were ‘consul- education on assessment results (Koch & Kralik 2001, Grant
tation’ and ‘collaboration’. According to the results, nurses et al. 2006). Nevertheless, this has been carried out on few
in this study were aware of the need to improve their work occasions (Trend et al. 2002, Wade et al. 2003). The use of
with carers in the promotion of rehabilitation. This is a key evidence could also support nurses in their decision making
point to consider in a holistic rehabilitation programme as and in the introduction of new holistic models of care in the
normally patients’ social life relies on carers (Portillo Vega wards (Bryant-Lukosius & DiCenso 2004).
2006). Kellett (1999) also underlined the benefits of family Reflecting on data from interviews and observations, social
involvement and of the assessment of home environment for and family life needed to be assessed to make the process of
patients’ recovery. Likewise, Nolan and Nolan (1997) care individual and evidence based. This could also provide
highlighted the importance of the role of a supportive nurses with rich information to develop coaching and
person in the adaptation to MS and the benefits of a collaboration skills. Consequently, patients and relatives
supportive family environment on the improvement of QoL could also benefit from these care plans being actively
of MS suffers. involved, developing positive attitudes and recognising own
Identifying and approaching supportive siblings and pro- needs, strengths and limitations. The importance of the
fessionals is also a key nursing strategy. Rehabilitation assessment of psychosocial issues, domestic housework and
services should also search for cooperation between hospital social and family life in capturing the disease impact and
and other community-based centres, i.e. societies. Interview developing a care plan has also been stated by Fawcett
data supported the importance of societies in the provision of Vickers and O’Neill (1998) and Gottberg et al. (2002). The
social support and information especially at early stages of inclusion of psychosocial assessments in daily care plans
the disease. Watson and Quinn (1998) and Wiles et al. (1998) could help to overcome myths about social life being a taboo
also encouraged professionals to give patients with stroke and for patients and relatives and to undertake non-physical care
carers information about societies of patients to ensure they naturally, because this was a limitation nurses felt in this
retained information especially after the initial shock. study. Additionally, nurses could be provided with forms and
Although in our study many patients at an advanced stage computer resources to collect and register this type of
of their disease and their carers were not even aware of information making the social assessment a formal activity
societies, these centres seem to be valuable to promote carers’ in the shift. Nevertheless, this assessment strategy could help
self-care and more intense involvement in the decision nurses develop their role as leaders in collaboration by
making (Burks 1999) and as a source of emotional support gaining self-confidence and communication skills with
(Edwards & Ruettiger 2002). patients and carers. As mentioned before, integrating social

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1739
MC Portillo and S Cowley

assessments in daily care would also have important limita- literature. Results from this study support the literature with
tions regarding workload and time schedule which should regard to the lack of development of the nursing role in
also be considered, explored and evaluated by organisations. holistic and neurological rehabilitation.
The provision of life choices also emerged from findings as The possibility of assessing patients’ and relatives’ holistic
an innovative intervention of future rehabilitation pro- needs, providing life choices and giving information about
grammes. There are very few studies where individual other health professionals before discharge has important
assessment of needs has been followed by the provision/ implications for practice as many daily problems could be
planning of coping strategies (Ojeda del Pozo et al. 2000, detected earlier and referred to a more specialised discipline.
Grant et al. 2006). Through the assessment, clinical nurses In consequence, this could enhance clients’ feelings of safety
felt they could understand life changes and set life choices and and adaptation and increase social life in the community,
patients’ and relatives’ unrealistic expectations could be which is the real aim of rehabilitation. These activities would
unveiled and reoriented. Patients’ and carers’ adaptation also be good strategies to develop the nurses’ role in
could happen as they would be actively involved in the rehabilitation and some attributes of advanced practice
process and would learn how to cope with daily problems. nursing such as coaching, collaboration, evidence-based
The provision of choices could give identity to nurses in practice and consultation could be reinforced.
holistic rehabilitation as they could be considered leaders by
other professionals, coaches by patients and carers and would
Relevance to clinical practice
learn to collaborate, consult and use evidence. In this paper, it
has been attempted to analyse the situation regarding the This work is relevant to clinical practice because rehabilita-
nursing role in holistic rehabilitation as seen by professionals, tion needs of neurological patients and carers at hospital have
patients and carers and set guidelines for advanced practice, been described. Furthermore, some conceptual and practical
considering context-related circumstances. strategies to develop the nursing role in holistic neurological
rehabilitation have been set at hospital levels.

Reflections on the methods


Acknowledgements
The triangulation of sources and instruments increased the
validity of data and ensured that data were sound, rich and We are grateful to the people who contributed to the
saturated. Additionally, the high correlation of our results development of this project: nurses and other health profes-
with the literature increases the representativeness of the sionals working in the wards of the hospital and other
nurses’, patients’ and relatives’ samples. This representa- community centres and patients’ societies for their valuable
tiveness could have been weakened by the nature of the and active collaboration, and patients and relatives selflessly
sample of patients and relatives which included patients at participating in the project.
very different stages of the disease process. What could Research funding was obtained from the Department of
have been a limited sample in the beginning resulted in a Health of the Government of Navarre, Spain. Financial
very rich source of information for the purposes of this support was also provided by the School of Nursing of the
project, because short and long-term needs could be University of Navarre.
defined.

Contributions
Conclusion
Study design: MCP, SC; data collection and analysis: MCP,
Clinical nurses’ perceptions and suggestions about their role SC and manuscript preparation: MCP, SC.
in rehabilitation, neurological patients’ and relatives’ needs
and perceptions of the nursing role in holistic care and data
Conflict of interest
observed directly in the setting have been triangulated.
Most statements on education and information and None.
discharge planning were presented in conjunction with the

1740  2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743
Recovery and rehabilitation Nursing care in holistic rehabilitation

References
Bakas T, Austin JK, Jessup SL, Williams LS Forster A, Dowswell G, Young J, Sheard J, psychosocial difficulties after stroke.
& Oberst MT (2004) Time and Diffi- Wright P & Bagley P (1999) Effects of a Age and Ageing 29, 23–30.
culty of tasks provided by family care- physiotherapist-led stroke training pro- Koch T & Kralik D (2001) Chronic illness,
givers of stroke survivors. Journal of gramme for nurses. Age and Ageing 28, reflections on a community-based ac-
Neuroscience Nursing 36, 95–106. 567–574. tion research programme. Journal of
Booth J, Hillier VF, Waters KR & Davidson Forster A, Smith J, Young J, Knapp P, Advanced Nursing 36, 23–31.
I (2005) Effects of a stroke rehabilita- House A & Wright J (2001) Informa- Kralik D, Visentin K & van Loon A (2006)
tion education programme for nurses. tion provision for stroke patients and Transition: a literature review. Journal
Journal of Advanced Nursing 49, 465– their caregivers. The Cochrane Data- of Advanced Nursing 55, 320–329.
473. base of Systematic Reviews 3 (Art. No. Kvigne K, Kirkevold M & Gjengedal E
Boter H (2004) Multicenter randomised CD001919). DOI: 10.1002/14651858. (2005) The nature of nursing care and
controlled trial of an outreach nursing CD.001919. rehabilitation of female stroke survi-
support program for recently discharged Gage H & Storey L (2004) Rehabilitation vors: the perspective of hospital nurses.
stroke patients. Stroke 35, 2867–2872. for Parkinson’s disease: a systematic Journal of Clinical Nursing 14, 897–
Bowling A (2002) Research methods in review of available evidence. Clinical 905.
health. Investigating Health and Health Rehabilitation 18, 463–482. Lackey N & Gates MF (2001) Adults’
Services, 2nd edn. Open University Glass TA, Dym B, Greenberg S, Rintell D, recollections of their experiences as
Press, Berkshire, UK. Roesch C & Berkman LF (2000) Psy- young caregivers of family members
Bryant-Lukosius D & DiCenso A (2004) A chosocial intervention in stroke: fami- with chronic physical illnesses. Journal
framework for the introduction and lies in recovery from stroke trial of Advanced Nursing 34, 320–328.
evaluation of advanced practice nursing (FIRST). American Journal of Ortho- Lewin K (1946) Action research and
roles. Journal of Advanced Nursing 48, psychiatry 70, 169–181. minority problems. Journal of Social
530–540. Gold RL (1958) Roles in sociological field Issues 2, 34–46.
Burks KJ (1999) A nursing practice model observations. Social Forces 36, 217– Long AF, Kneafsey R, Ryan J & Berry J
for Chronic illness. Rehabilitation 223. (2002) The role of the nurse within the
Nursing 24, 197–200. Gottberg K, Einarsson U, Fredrikson S, vo- multi-professional rehabilitation team.
Burton CR (2003) Therapeutic nursing in nKock L & Widén Holmqvist L (2002) Journal of Advanced Nursing 37, 70–78.
stroke rehabilitation, a systematic re- Multiple Sclerosis in Stockholm Coun- Lui MHL, Ross FM & Thompson DR
view. Clinical Effectiveness in Nursing ty. A pilot study of utilization of health- (2005) Supporting family caregivers in
7, 124–133. care resources, patient satisfaction with stroke care. A review of the evidence for
Burton C & Gibbon B (2006) Expanding the care and impact on family caregivers. problem solving. Stroke 36, 2514–
role of the stroke nurse: a pragmatic Acta Neurologica Scandinavica 106, 2522.
clinical trial. Journal of Advanced 241–247. Mackenzie AE, Holroyd EE & Lui MHL
Nursing 52, 640–650. Grant JS (1999) Social problem-solving (1998) Community nurses’ assessment
Calne SM (2003) The psychosocial impact of partnerships with family caregivers. of the needs of Hong Kong family
late-stage Parkinson’s disease. Journal of Rehabilitation Nursing 24, 254–260. carers who are looking after stroke
Neuroscience Nursing 35, 306–313. Grant JS, Elliott TR, Weaver M, Glandon patients. International Journal of
Denzin N (1970) Strategies of multiple tri- GL, Raper JL & Giger JN (2006) Social Nursing Studies 35, 132–140.
angulation. In The Research Act (Den- support, social problem-solving abilities Mackenzie AE, Lee DTF & Ross FM (2004)
zin N ed). McGraw-Hill, New York, and adjustment of family caregivers of The context, measures and outcomes of
pp. 297–313. stroke survivors. Archives of Physical psychosocial care interventions in long-
Edwards NE & Ruettiger KM (2002) The Medicine Rehabilitation 87, 343–350. term health care for older people.
influence of caregiver burden on patients’ Hamric AB, Spross JA & Hanson CM International Journal of Nursing Prac-
management of Parkinson’s Disease, (2009) Advanced Practice Nursing. An tice 10, 39–44.
Implications for rehabilitation nursing. Integrative Approach, 4th edn. Saun- Mant J, Carter J, Wade Dt & Winner S
RehabilitationNursing27,182–198. ders Elsevier, Missouri. (2000) Family support for stroke: a
Fawcett Vickers LF & O’Neill CM (1998) Hart E & Bond M (1995) Action Research randomised controlled trial. The Lancet
An interdisciplinary home healthcare for Health and Social Care. A guide to 356, 808–813.
program for patients with Parkinson’s Practice. Open University Press, Buck- McKeown LP, Porter-Amstrong AP &
disease. Rehabilitation Nursing 23, ingham. Baxter GD (2003) The needs and
286–289. Kellett UM (1999) Searching for new pos- experiences of caregivers of individuals
Forbes A, While A, Dyson L, Grocott T & sibilities to care, a qualitative analysis with multiple sclerosis: a systematic
Griffiths P (2003) Impact of clinical of family caring involvement in nursing review. Clinical Rehabilitation 17,
nurse specialists in multiple sclerosis- homes. Nursing Inquiry 6, 9–16. 234–248.
synthesis of the evidence. Journal of Knapp P, Young J, House A & Forster A Merino JG & Hachinski V (2003) Demencia
Advanced Nursing 42, 442–462. (2000) Non-drug strategies to resolve e ictus, la importancia de la enfermedad

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1741
MC Portillo and S Cowley

cerebral coexistente. Revista de Neu- lowing stroke: a model for psychosocial Sandelowski M (1986) The problem of rigor
rologı́a 36, 61–63. service during inpatient rehabilitation. in qualitative research. Advances in
Miles MB & Huberman AM (1994) Quali- Rehabilitation Psychology 49, 338– Nursing Science 8, 27–37.
tative Data Analysis, An Expanded 343. Shah S, Vanclay F & Cooper B (1989)
Sourcebook, 2nd edn. Sage publica- Polit-O’Hara D & Hungler BP (1997) Improving the sensitivity of the Barthel
tions, London. Métodos de observación. In Essentials Index for stroke rehabilitation. Journal
Nir Z, Zolotogorsky Z & Sugarman H of Nursing Research: Methods, of Clinical Epidemiology 42, 703–709.
(2004) Structured nursing intervention Appraisals and Utilization, 4th edn Thorn S (2000) Neurological rehabilitation
versus routine rehabilitation after (Polit-O’Hara D & Hungler BP eds). nursing: a review of the research.
stroke. American Journal of Physical Pa: Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia, Journal of Advanced Nursing 31,
and Medicine Rehabilitation 83, 522– pp. 307–326. 1029–1038.
529. Portillo MC (2009) Understanding the Trend P, Kaye J, Gage H, Owen C & Wade
Noble C (1998/99) Parkinson’s disease and practical and theoretical development D (2002) Short-term effectiveness of
the role of nurse specialists. Elderly of social rehabilitation through action intensive multidisciplinary rehabilita-
Care 10, 43–44. research. Journal of Clinical Nursing tion for people with Parkinson’s disease
Nolan M & Nolan J (1997) Rehabilitation 18, 234–245. and their carers. Clinical Rehabilitation
in multiple sclerosis, the potential Portillo MC, Saracı́bar MI & Wilson-Bar- 16, 717–725.
nursing contribution. British Journal of nett J (2002) Estudio desde la percep- Turnock C & Gibson V (2001) Validity in
Nursing 6, 1292–1310. ción de pacientes y familiares del action research: a discussion on theo-
Nolan M & Nolan J (1998a) Stroke 1, a proceso de participación informal en el retical and practice issues encountered
paradigm case in nursing rehabilitation. cuidado después de un Ictus, met- whilst using observation to collect data.
British Journal of Nursing 6, 316–321. odologı́a y primeros resultados. En- Journal of Advanced Nursing 36, 471–
Nolan M & Nolan J (1998b) Stroke 2, fermerı́a Clı́nica 12, 94–103. 477.
expanding the nurse’s role in stroke Portillo MC, Corchon S, Lopez-Dicastillo O Wade DT & Langton Hewer R (1987)
rehabilitation. British Journal of Nurs- & Cowley S (2009) Evaluation of a Functional abilities after stroke: mea-
ing 7, 388–392. nurse-led social rehabilitation pro- surement, natural history and progno-
O’Connor SE (2000) Nursing interventions gramme for neurological patients and sis. Journal of Neurological and
in stroke rehabilitation: a study of carers: an action research study. Inter- Neurosurgical Psychiatry 50, 177–182.
nurses’ views of their pattern of care in national Journal of Nursing Studies 46, Wade D, Gage H, Owen C, Trend P, Gros-
stroke units. Rehabilitation Nursing 25, 204–219. smith C & Kaye J (2003) Multidisci-
224–230. Portillo Vega MC (2006) Social Rehabilita- plinary rehabilitation for people with
Ojeda del Pozo N, Ezquerra-Iribarren JA, tion from a hospital ward: an action Parkinson’s disease: a randomised con-
Urruticoechea-Sarriegui I, Quemada- research study with nurses, neurological trolled study. Journal of Neurology and
Ubis JI & Muñoz-Céspedes JM (2000) patients and their carers. doctoral the- Neurosurgery Psychiatry 74, 158–162.
Entrenamiento en habilidades sociales sis. King’s College Department of Waterman H (1998) Embracing ambiguities
en pacientes con daño cerebral adquir- Nursing and Midwifery Studies, Lon- and valuing ourselves: issues of validity
ido. Revista de Neurologı́a 30, 783– don. in action research. Journal of Advanced
787. Rawl S, Easton KL, Kwiatkowski S, Zemen D Nursing 28, 101–105.
Pacchetti C, Mancini F, Aglieri R, Fundarò & Burczyk B (1998) Effectiveness of a Watson LD & Quinn DA (1998) Stages of
C, Martignoni E & Nappi G (2000) nurse-managed follow-up program for stroke, a model for stroke rehabilita-
Active music therapy in Parkinson’s rehabilitation patients after discharge. tion. British Journal of Nursing 7, 631–
disease: an integrative method for mo- Rehabilitation Nursing 23, 204–209. 640.
tor and emotional rehabilitation. Psy- Ross F, O’Tuathail C & Stubberfield D Wiles R, Pain H, Buckland S & McLellan L
chosomatic Medicine 62, 386–393. (2005) Towards multidisciplinary (1998) Providing appropriate informa-
Palmer S, Glass TA, Palmer JB, Loo S & assessment of older people: exploring tion to patients and carers following a
Wegener ST (2004) Crisis intervention the change process. Journal of Clinical stroke. Journal of Advanced Nursing
with individuals and their families fol- Nursing 14, 518–529. 28, 794–801.

1742  2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743
Recovery and rehabilitation Nursing care in holistic rehabilitation

The Journal of Clinical Nursing (JCN) is an international, peer reviewed journal that aims to promote a high standard of
clinically related scholarship which supports the practice and discipline of nursing.

For further information and full author guidelines, please visit JCN on the Wiley Online Library website: http://
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jocn.

Reasons to submit your paper to JCN:


High-impact forum: one of the world’s most cited nursing journals and with an impact factor of 1Æ194 – ranked 16 of 70
within Thomson Reuters Journal Citation Report (Social Science – Nursing) in 2009.
One of the most read nursing journals in the world: over 1 million articles downloaded online per year and accessible in over
7000 libraries worldwide (including over 4000 in developing countries with free or low cost access).
Fast and easy online submission: online submission at http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/jcnur.
Early View: rapid online publication (with doi for referencing) for accepted articles in final form, and fully citable.
Positive publishing experience: rapid double-blind peer review with constructive feedback.
Online Open: the option to make your article freely and openly accessible to non-subscribers upon publication in Wiley
Online Library, as well as the option to deposit the article in your preferred archive.

 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20, 1731–1743 1743

You might also like