Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L E S B I A N
G A Y
BISEXUAL
TRANSGENDER
C E N T E R
2
NARRATIVE
Societal views have shifted dramatically over
recent years towards the acceptance of LGBT
citizens. Though it may seem counter-intuitive,
along with this rapid growth towards equality, the
severity of hate-crime related incidents has also
increased. For many of those that have fallen victim to
discrimination or physical harassment, there are far too
few safety enclaves available that can provide adequate
security conditions that afford the victim a sense of safety.
{Education} In order to ascertain the improvement of quality of life for LGBT citizens, a
specialized education center comprises a portion of the building program.
Research Study:
The facility has the ability to inform the community at large of distinct issues
New Mexico Highland
relevent to the LGBT community. The center will educate those interested
University Student Center
in topics regarding the adversities that must be faced as an LGBT citizen.
6
Fg. 7.1
entre ]
untu C
[ Ub
]
Ri ghts
man
d Hu
il an
or Civ
nter f
[ Ce
Fg. 7.2
]
Center
ent
Stud
sity
iver
nd Un
H i ghla
o
M exic
[ New Fg. 7.3
TYPOLOGICAL
RESEARCH
National Center for Civil and Human Rights
Atlanta, Georgia
{Museum}
Ubuntu Centre
Port Elizabeth, South Africa
{Healthcare}
New Mexico Highland University Student Center
Las Vegas, New Mexico
{Education}
Fg. 9.1
National Center for
Civil and Human Rights
Fg. 11.2
Common characteristics shared between
the National Center for Civil and Human
Fg. 12.1 Rights and the other typological research
studies is their common goal of bringing users
together. The overarching goal for the
National Center for Civil and Human Rights
is for museum occupants to gain a better
understanding of various rights movements
and acknowledge the fight that had to take
place in order to be in the social climate of today.
Fg. 12.3
12
Fg. 12.4
Fg. 13.1
Ubuntu Centre
14
The Ubuntu Centre employs several
sustainable practices which involve
both the function of the facility and the
manner in which the occupants use it. These
strategies include a rooftop garden,
whose vegetation serves as a meal Fg. 15.1
source for the areas local school children.
The functionality of the building though,
is what makes the center noteworthy.
16
Fg. 16.2
Fg. 17.1
New Mexico Highlands
University Student Center
There are hints around the building that suggest the structure is
under consideration for LEED Gold certification. Perhaps the most
noticeable feature of the structure is the sun-tracking louver system
located on three major facades of the building. Another indication is
the subtle setback of the third floor, giving passersby the impression
that the student center is not as large and overscaled as it truly is.
Fg. 19.2
Common characteristics shared between
the New Mexico Highland University
Student Center and the other
typological research studies is the
abundance of services provided for
the building’s occupants. Though each
structure serves a different purpose, the
amount of space needed to satifsy occupancy
requirements involves a great deal of
homogenous spaces, enabling
the footprint of the building to be
significantly smaller than needed.
20
Fg. 20.1
MAJOR
ELEMENTS
Building Components:
{Museum}
Exhibition Space
{Healthcare}
Laboratory
{Education}
Lecture Hall
{Museum}
Exhibition Space
{Healthcare}
Laboratory
{Education}
Lecture Hall
A lecture hall is required for the building program. Perhaps the most versatile
of spaces, the lecture hall will provide the facility with ample space for various
activities when not being used as a space to educate the public on gay-related issues.
The opportunities include ballroom, movie theatre, reception space, and lounge.
22
{ }
Vision Statement
{ }
Mission Statement
28
Fg. 28.1
Project Site:
3835 Cedar Springs Rd
Oak Lawn, Dallas, TX
75219
Fg. 29.1
3835 Cedar Springs Road, located in the Oak Lawn
neighborhood of Dallas, Texas, is an ideal location for
a Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Center.
Positioned in the heart of Dallas’ thriving gay community,
the site is situated on one of the neighborhoods major
thoroughfares. Though Oak Lawn alone is generally
considered a hub of gay activity, Cedar Springs Road
between Oak Lawn and Wycliff avenues is a densely
populated area of gay-owned establishments
including bars, restaurants, retail, and general
business. The culture of the neighborhood is
intensified every summer with the Gay Pride Festival
and parade en route immediately adjacent to the site.
Utilizing the vacant lot for an LGBT center will not only
provide an idyllic location for the facilities occupants, but
also add to the flourishing community of which it is apart.
30
PROJECT
EMPHASIS
{Architecture as Didacticism}
The primary emphasis of the design
intervention is to consider the role that
architecture plays on our perception of
societal beliefs as a whole. The built environment
becomes a propagandist landscape that
dictates our fundamental way of life, influencing our
stances on social issues particular to
our society. To emphasize the need for
social acceptance of the nations lesbian, gay,
bisexual, and transgender community, the
thesis communicates through a design
intervention persuasive building vernacular,
ideals of respect, regard, and acceptance.
32
GOALS
{Academic}
{Professional}
{Personal}
{Academic} Personal goals that I have set for
myself regarding my thesis year are to
be more open to others opinions and
understand that their crtiticism is not
to be ill-mannered or mean, but not be
Academic goals that I have set for myself constructive. This is a skill I feel that even
with the thesis project include becoming the best of the class has difficulty grasping.
more well-equipped with various com-
puter programs that include, but are not Another personal goal is to be
limited to Revit, AutoCAD, and Rhino. My able to speak about a design
abilities in each are a bit rusty, but as I outside of the design critique. Far too
have become more familiar with Rhino often I catch myself thinking back to a
3D Software, I have learned that the presentation where I left with more
computer programs are relatively similar. questions than answers.
I believe that better end
As well, becoming more articulate in my products will be created if we were more
opinions is a skill that I have have always open to each other about varying opinions.
had difficulty with, but I wish to become
more thorough and strong with that skill.
38
PLAN FOR
PROCEEDING
{Historical Context}
The Oak Lawn neighborhood of Dallas,
Texas has a rich and vibrant history not
only pertaining to the LGBT population
currently present there, but also to the
Mexican culture that was prevelant in
the are in the not so distant past. The
layering of these minority groups is what
makes up the rich character of the sur-
rounding area. I hope to impliment histori-
cal precedents in my design intervention.
PLAN FOR
PROCEEDING
{Project Typology}
Because the building typology of the
thesis project is decidedly not one
typology but multiple grouped
together, my plan is to research all of the
components and find if particular elements
in various typologies will allow themselves
to work in other building types. This is in
agreement to my hope that I creat a project
that has the ability to adapt for futre uses.
40
PLAN FOR
PROCEEDING
{Site Analysis}
My intent is to gather as much information
on the logistics of the chosen site before
I visit in late November. This was, I feel
that I will be better equipped to look for
certain aspects that may not be completely
obvious to the naked eye. I will investigate
previous structures that were once on the
site, as well as the possibility that the
location may in fact be a brownfield site.
PLAN FOR
PROCEEDING
{Programmatic Requirements}
Program requirements for the
thesis design intervention include site
integration, best allowing the
building to react to the location through
building materials and passive systems.
The temperare weather will be a new
consideration I take into account, having
never designed a project for such a climate.
42
DESIGN
METHODOLOGY
{Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis}
44
DESIGN
METHODOLOGY
{Digital Analysis}
46
DOCUMENTATION
{Design Process}
Since I will most likely be utilizing digital
tools for my analysis and design, I will
organize a specific folder on my
computer to easily store and access various
files that I find crucial to the design process.
september
december
november
february
october
january
august
march
may
april
proposal DRAFT
thesis PROPOSAL
thesis PROGRAM
DESIGN
thesis EXHIBIT
thesis REVIEWS
thesis BOOK
48
RESEARCH OF
THEORETICAL
PREMISE
50
From the earliest of times in architecture, the
pursuit to instill a perceived message in an
audience has dictated the shape and
evolution of the built environment for millennia.
Great civilizations of our distant past perfected
the use of architecture as propaganda, as a
way to convince their adherents of a particular
message. Ancient governing bodies understood
the mighty effect that our built accomplishments
can have on our perception of life. Phillip Tay-
lor describes in his book British Propaganda in
the 20th Century: Selling Democracy (2010) that
Fg. 51.1
Ancient theories that explain our cause for
existence continue to this day in the form of
organized religion. Though the titles we have
given to these entities have largely changed over
the course of recorded history, the presence of
deities and their importance to justify our actions
have been an unwavering drive in our effort
to improve our lives through the built environ-
ment. Intended to give the inhabitant a celestial
experience in the presence of their deity,
ancient and modern architects alike have used
the concept of light to persuade a believer
of a given message. As Kirill Postoutenko
explains in his book Totalitarian
Communication: Hierarchies,
Codes and Messages (2010),
“Jefferson’s understanding of
the power of imitation could be
considered his most successful
architectural accomplishment. He may
not have been the first to notice that
architecture had
didactic uses, but he perfected
the use of didactic architecture.”
Fg. 59.1
68
HISTORICAL
SOCIAL
CULTURAL
CONTEXT
Evidence of homosexuality in the civilized The current dialogue regarding homosexuality
world can be traced back to the first and the legality of social issues related to
great civilizations of antiquity. Preserved such has only become less pervasive within
mosaics from this time depict sexualized the last 225 years, most notably in western
relationships between members of the countries where secularity has become the
same sex, indicating that homosexuality ubiquitous form of government. The present
was not only an acknowledged but accepted public discourse pertaining to homosexuality
societal phenomenon. Observance of finds its origins in revolutionary France with
homosexuality as an established convention the 1791 adoption of a new penal code. The
in ancient life is evinced with the same-sex reformed code decriminalized acts of sodomy
relationships of various Roman emperors between consenting adults, becoming
including Nero, Trajan, and Hadrian. The the first of it’s kind to do so in the western
heterosexual marriages of these ancient world in over a millennium. Notwithstanding,
emperors ensured a male heir to their an organization dedicated to further the
dynastic lineage, whereas their homosexual public acceptance of homosexuality was
relationships were characterized as not formally established until 1897, Berlin.
loving, lustful bonds between two men.
Magnus Herschfeld, as a vehicle to
promote sexual minorities, founded the
A steep decline in public acceptance of Wissenschaftlich-humanitares Komitee, or
homosexual relationships occurred after the The Scientific-Humanitarian Committee.
fall of the Roman Empire and the onset of the The organizations objective was to
Middle Ages, oft recognized as the era that scientifically substantiate the intrinsic nature
legitimized Christianity as a western religion. of homosexuality, thus to postulate grounds
During this period, homosexuality became for the expulsion of Paragraph 175 from the
synonymous with sodomy and bestiality, German Criminal Code. This legislative
acts punishable by castration and execution. provision prohibited sexual acts between
Acknowledgement of homosexuality became consenting males adults. Herschfeld
a cultural taboo and effects of this continue and his Wissenschaftlich-humanitares
to hold great significance to this day. Komitee (WhK) would later inspire the
work of Henry Gerber, founder of the measures was customary policy employed
Chicago-based Society for Human Rights. by the group. Historian Michael Sibalis
described that the hemophilic attitude as
In 1924, German-born Henry Gerber
established the Society for Human Rights, “…public hostility to homosexuals
the first American group tasked to foster the resulted largely from their outrageous
emancipation of homosexuals in government and promiscuous behaviour;
and society. Though the group dissolved homophiles would win the good
shortly after its inception, the transcribed opinion of the public and the
objectives would later assimilate into various authorities by showing themselves
organization platforms associated with to be discreet, dignified, virtuous
the United States Homophile Movement. and respectable” (Sibalis, 2005).
As a result of member diaspora, a lineal
connection exists between the Society for
Human Rights and the Mattachine Society, These passive guidelines would soon become
formed 26 years after the former in 1950. wildly unpopular among members, as police
brutality and governmental treatment of
Motivated by Gerber’s Society for Human homosexuals worsened in 1950s America.
Rights, the Mattachine Society grew to be The apex of disapproval for these docile
one of the largest homophile organizations in dogmas amongst the homosexual community
the United States, though it too, existed for transpired in the 1969 New York Stonewall
little more than a decade. From inception to Riots. These protests deemed the attitudes of
dissolution, this Los Angeles-based society the homophile movement as ineffective and
grew exponentially from 7 founding members gave birth to the Gay Liberation Movement.
to over 2,000 men and women, each concerned
with the societal treatment of homosexuals. More unmistakably clear than ever before,
Representative of the Homophile the voice of the homosexual community
Movement, assimilation of homosexuals echoed across the nation as public
into the hetero-normative society of post- demonstrations advocating for the social and
war America through non-confrontational political acceptance of the community played
played out in the streets of major American a tumultuous time for the gay community
cities. The Gay Liberation Movement and a true sense of solidarity would come
pressed members of the homosexual in succeeding years as more individuals
community to publicly disclose their sexual out-ed themselves to the general public.
orientation and live an openly homosexual Married fathers and mothers, politicians, and
lifestyle. During this time as well, the celebrities discovered a new support system
understanding of homosexuality and the for which they could live their lives openly
false dichotomy perpetuated by the use without the fear of requiring to do so solitarily.
such a term aided in the development of As gay culture solidified, the archaic methods
exercising new lexicon to associate with of the Gay Liberation Movement yielded to
the homosexual community in an expanded new structured methods associated with
manner. The expression ‘gay’ was viewed the systematized Gay Rights Movement.
to be more inclusive in meaning than that of
the ‘homosexual-heterosexual’ dichotomy, It has happened during this Gay Rights
offering the opportunity to express one’s Movement that the first openly gay
sexual orientation in a more specific fashion. public officials have been elected into
The terminologies gay, lesbian, bisexual, and representative office, that same-sex marriage
transgender became widely used amongst has gained momentum the world round, that
the ‘gay’ and heterosexual communities alike. discrimination based on sexual orientation
has been outlawed in several jurisdictions,
The formation of a solidified cultural identity for and that same-sex couples have partially
the gay community continued to flourish with gained access to spousal privileges. These
planned demonstrations that promoted the advancements in the social acceptance of
expression of ones sexual orientation in the the gay community would not have been
public realm. These demonstrations continue possible without the acknowledgement
annually to this day, habitually known as Pride of homosexual status in recorded history.
Parades. The Gay Liberation Movement was
LAGLC
The first documented center specifically
established to suit the needs of the
lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender
(LGBT) communities was founded as the
Los Angeles Gay and Lesbian Center
(LAGLC) in 1969. Now known as the Los
Angeles LGBT Center, this organization
is largest in the world of its kind, offering
services ranging from social services and
healthcare to leadership and education to
Los Angeles and surrounding communities.
FUN FACT
74
Fg. 74.1
THE CENTER
The Resource Center, established in 1983 as The San Diego LGBT Community Center is
the Foundation for Human Understanding, the second oldest LGBT resource center in
is the Dallas metropolitan area’s largest the United States having been established
service center dedicated to promoting gay as The Center for Social Services in 1973.
rights and education to the surrounding The Center for Social Services changed its
community. Incorporated in 1994, the Phil legal title to The San Diego LGBT Community
Johnson Historic Archives was added Center in 1980 to reflect the true nature of the
to the Resource Center as an archival organizations mission in aiding the well being
entity tasked with preserving documents and promotion of lesbians, gays, bisexuals
and artifacts important the history of the and transgender in American society.
Dallas gay and national communities.
Over 1,100 citizens volunteer each year In 1971, Jess Jessop, a registered nurse
for the Resource Center, making it one of and LGBT rights activist set up an
the largest resource centers of its kind in answering machine in a service closet
the United States. 60,000+ LGBT people used as a literal lifeline for the LGBT
and their allies use services provided community in need of support, marking
by the Resource Center every year. the beginning of what would later become
The San Diego LGBT Community Center.
Fg. 76.1
CENTER ON
HALSTAD
In 1973 Chicago, a group of volunteers
interested in providing support services for
area LGBT citizens decided to establish
Gay Horizons, later changed to Horizons
Community Services. Horizons Community
Services became the regions foremost
service center for the LGBT community after a
group of gay medical students decided to offer
their medical expertise to combat sexually
transmitted diseases in the community.
FUN FACT
Exhibition Space
The exhibition space is vital to the overall success fo the building. This space will offer large
gallery partitions that allow various works of the archival library to be displayed for the center visitors.
This space may also be utilized as a meeting space/conference room during low-occupancy hours of
the day.
Classrooms
The educational wing of the building is important to ensure the advancement of the peoples
for which the center is in honor of. The classrooms will be available for various meetings of groups
that are in relation to the LGBT community of Dallas and surrounding area.
Waiting Room
A separate waiting space is desired for the healthcare facilities housed within the building.
The waiting room will be a quite space to offer comfort before, during and after healthcare visits
pertaining to sexually transmitted diseases and viruses particular to the LGBT community.
Examination Rooms
These rooms will offer sterile, safe places for the patient and doctor to interact without fear of
cross contamination. These spaces will be designed to offer the best healthcare available, yet also
create a safe atmosphere for doctor/patient conversation to take place.
Storage
Storage for all occuants of the building is needed. Each activity will be reserved their own
storage spaces throughout the building, whether it be for the medical facilities, the museum/gallery
space or for the short-term occupants such as homeless LGBT youth.
Medical Laboratory
The medical laboratory will offer a clean and safe work environment for the testing of blood-
work and various other practices that take place within the clinic. This space is highly important to
ensure that correctly tested blookwork is examined and the results be carefully relayed to the medi-
cal patients.
Restrooms
These utilitarian spaces are a necessity for all occupants of the building. The restrooms
willbe separate for each function of the building, to ensure cleanly, safe environments are provided
for when nature calls.
Lounge
A loung space will be utilized more often by short-term housing occupants than any other oc-
cupant of the building. This space will offer a constructve envirnment to sneure to safety of the youth
that will be staying there.
Meeting Rooms
Meeting rooms, along with classrooms, will provide a work environment that allows for the
development of new ideas, especially ones that wil further the social acceptance of the LGBT com-
munity.
Kitchen
An eating facility will be provided for the various functions of the building, though more often
than not, the kitchen will be used by the short-term housing occupants.
Dormitory
The dormitory portion of the building will offer safe, warm beds to those of the LGBT youth
community that do not have another place to go, wether it be because thye do not feel safe in their
familial homes, or that they have been outcast by their community.
Process
Documentation
The design process began with examining the
theoretical premise studies conducted in the
fall semester. Included in these studies were
monumental works of architecture including the
Great Pyramids of Giza (pg. 51, 52), the U.S.
Capitol Building (p. 58), as well as the Cathedral of
Lights in Nuremburg (p. 61). What struck me in the
latter was the use of light as a form of propogranda,
which ultimately became my design inspiration.
85
Using my initial drawings as a reference, a series of 9
bay models (Fig. 86.1, 86.2) were constructed to further
along the thesis’ design development. Several light
studies were conducted on these models to determine
which section best suited my design intention, but I
later found that none of my initial drawings were
quite portraying the message I wished to evoke.
86
Digital
Presentation
Fg. 89.1 Ground Level Plan
91
Fg. 92.1 Exhibition Hall Section
92
Fg. 93.1
Fg. 93.2
93
Fg. 94.1
Fg. 94.2
94
Response to
Site
As an attemp to incorporate the significance of the site,
I began building a rip-and-tear model whose angles
paid homage to various points of interest located on
and nearby the site. Some walls pointed in the direction
of local landmarks, whereas others took advantage of
natural ventilation patterns. At this point in the design
process, I was attempting to address all internal and
external influences that impact the site. Ways of
vehicle traffic, ways of pedestrian traffic, surrounding
structures and all of their respective vantage points,
wind, solar, and noise patterns, as well as topographical
Fg. 97.1 attributes of the site. What came of this was the
realization that I was overcomplicating what to focus
on. Though all of these influences are important and
need to be addressed, I decided to take step back and
pinpoint what was essential to my idea and inspiration.
97
Ultimately, this design dilemma strengthened my
idea of creating an exhibition hall that is integrated
with the rest of the building, yet unique because of
design/orientation. The entirety of the exhibition
hall and parts of the archival library and communal
lobby run along the North-South axis, leaving
the rest of the utilitarian structure to be in unison
with the Northwest-Southeast axis of the site.
98
Response to
Theoretical
Premise
Throughout the entire design process, I consistently seems to be eskew and cut-off completely from all
thought back to the use of didacticism in monumental surrounding spaces. This space, the exhibition hall,
architecture. My goal was to use architectural has been intentionally left apart from all other spaces.
didacticism in a nuanced way that would carry the Access into the exhibition hall is limited to a bridge that
same principles as the monumental achievements, but spans over a downward staircase leading to the base
employ them in a way that was less intimidating. I found level of the central courtyard. All other walls adjoining
that this goal was a tough issue to tackle, given the shear the exhibition space are left to deny direct accessibility.
monumentality of projects that engage didacticism.
What becomes realized is that these hinderances are
I decided to focus primarily on the progression of completely an illusion. Each hinderance except for the
spaces as an inhabitant would experience them. courtyard curtain walls, are pivoting doors.The wall
What could happen as an occupant moved through which hinders direct access into the building is a wall
the various spaces that would subtly portray the of doors that, when opened, offer direct access into the
message I wished to convey? What materials could building. These doors are again utilized in the walls
I use? How could I use them? These questions separating the exhibition hall from the rest of the strucure.
were answered as the semester progressed. Once opened, the ground level spaces are completely
accessible to one another. This was meant to parallel the
The ceremonial procession of spaces begins day when all rights and privileges are offered to LGBT
immediately once the occupant enters the site. The citizens- hinderances that are shifted to allow access.
natural path leading into the structure is seemingly
hindered by a transparent wall. The occupant must The second most important space in the center is
then shift paths and enter the building through a set of the central courtyard which hinders all movement
unassuming side doors. Upon entering the building, the throughout the structure. Whether the occupant wishes
occupant is greeted with a vista of the archival library that to access the archival library, exhibition space or
sits immediately beyond a central courtyard. The path educational facilites located on the lower level, indirect
by which the occupant is to take is hindered yet again. paths must be taken in order to achieve such goals. The
These hinderances throughout the building are meant central courtyard is found as a void in building circulation
to parallel the struggle that LGBT citizens experience but also in the ground itself. The base level of the
daily in regards to rights and privilege inequality. Just courtyard is located beneath ground-level, symbolizing
as LGBT citizens can view the rights that are offered this great void in society for which LGBT citizens must
to others but are denied based on orientation, views of endure. It is a space that is unadorned, devoid of
various spaces are offered, but direct access is denied. decoration and utilitarian purpose. This space is deep
and lonely- separating an occupant from their goal.
Realized in the center’s lobby is a component which
102
Digital
Presentation
SOURCES
Bartolacci, J. (2013, September 11). Architizer. Retrieved December 5, 2014, from http://architizer.com/
blog/the-architecture-of-banking/
Cartwright, M. (2013, October 5). Roman Architecture. Retrieved November 19, 2014, from http://www.
ancient.eu/Roman_Architecture/
Chapman, G. (2014, July 28). Center for Civil and Human Rights Opens Its Doors to Atlanta. Retrieved
October 4, 2014, from http://archrecord.construction.com/news/2014/07/140728-Center-for-Civil-and-
Human-Rights-Opens-Its-Doors-to-Atlanta.asp
Contributing Editor. (2014, June 24). Center for Civil and Human Rights Opens in Downtown Atlanta.
Retrieved October 4, 2014.
Contributing Editor. (2014, June 23). National Center for Civil and Human Rights. Retrieved October 4,
2014.
Contributing Editor. (2011, April 7). New Mexico Highlands University Responds to Design. Retrieved
October 6, 2014, from http://inhabitat.com/new-mexico-highlands-university-student-centre-responds-
to-desert-climate-with-a-sun-tracking-louvered-facade/nmhu-student-centre-diamond-schmidt-architects-
3/?extend=1
Jowett, G., & Donnell, V. (1986). Propaganda & Persuasion. Newbury Park, Calif.: Sage
McDonald, R. (2012). Light and Liberty: Thomas Jefferson and the Power of Knowledge. Charlottesville,
Virginia: University of Virginia Press.
Narver, J. (1992). The Cultural Production of Domination in Nazi Germany: Architecture as Propaganda.
Ottawa: Bibliothèque Nationale du Canada
O’Dell, H. (2013, August 5). Diamond Schmitt Architects Completes Student Center at New Mexico
Highlands University. Retrieved October 6, 2014, from http://www.contractdesign.com/contract/news/
Diamond-Schmitt-Arch-9346.shtml
Taylor, P. (1999). British Propaganda in the 20th Century: Selling Democracy. Edinburgh, England:
Edinburgh University Press.