DATE

Norma Dizpn- Pamintuan_V: ople

CR. No.JI42G, Julyl, Y
FACT
tncarnacion Nad in hir_house heA fire uniden-
tihed mated men QApeaned om the lothenicd hif
house anc pokad their gun to his diive and heket
AIL He oCcupafi inGUdng_ÉNCOnacionÍ iHe , maid
CMd drie nere_Made to e on_the tloor: /e menran
acked the houe and bok anay peonl pApsrtie,
EnCormgcha imeciatly_egortd fhemottet to
The police e nasgty tyd Ho}_the /out iem nere in
Chnatown Orea, and hequentiy,an_eth0fpnent a
Conductcd

The tial Gou fund iha he pQoreuion_Ma obe

toproye tha he fcmp Orerad hee_t Hhe gouEC'
lod fem: Norma_appecicd tcat_tMejuMent_naLhGd
Onaiec pieumphL

Nheier fhe_poecufon prored he praNTE 4

He hird elemett of the Chine ofthe
knen or hauld hare kohn_G
fncig:
it
hot he azued
ecorecO Kon
Der_ere_es O£He_Crine tohbeY/Hef

HELD
echon T PD No-lo12_Cxpedy noice
thCt'mere psgosn ay god ide kn_okjed merit
 DATE

anythinq yaluç which har hee the hjec_of£

bbey or heyeyhal he_pima facie_eudence c
fencing
feACing Noma noa_pregumed_to haA knonkao
OFHe f t that iten_were urtalen Uhe honever
fauled ty cbut the peumption nd reled uolely on
fhetshmony_a he brohep mhich Ma in uficienf4
Oyercone the preumphion
 aime ong Peaple af the Philippine
GR: No 9O Y2 April 0 201

TACT
Aqja bought and a te owmerg 4Y Firetoe
tructhrey nhich he acquind fho hiltrood hs acqu-
ition na eyckrc by a ualer n volce adan Inven fony
Lit ALoqjar markai he firer nith chalk_pefore to mq
hem In_the rNGchaue. He uokd Gfire Gnd 3ehres
nere Ltoen frm He nachouse Nth fhe gat tocibly
qgNed The robbeny na repatd to the piCe hse
qUently A2ajar cnVaKI from_Aumerous busines
&tablshments and he chanced u ubagt Marketq
which brought af a ire fting ihe discipion_of tHe
lat ie _Mgria uing q CiaK, The_buy-huLt_tcom
proceeckd p he tre and aed a hy-bust
gmd
b out o the _32 tden_tire here ecocd

Whether allhe Clenenk af he cine af ftAg

ee_pre se

HELO:

R: First A2qjar pa ake fo orore his OnneI

ofthe ytoen itm qnd tho a Crime_cf fchbery na
Committed Jecad athaugh fhere na_n0 eikALtO thza
Liak Ong fo the cime he neer Onad the fàct
1) of the ia gfALCNr eye finci n his psaI.
Thid Ong nho_na on the buey of buying
ellng of fres shoud hare kAMn_the nj OUig mer
 DATE

thee nar n abvou ntatfugain Conidering ta

buy-hud qehon Ong naCoyht (elWng
dunag the
the udolen firtf:
 DATE
Ireaeo Cahudagon_y. Leople af the Fhilippineg
FCI

Tan_jastaAGked Lope2aMi_lariosQ_fo detyer 20

Cuesof Ceca- Cau_producds norh_I2, 41 o lecing
Atore buA na od.corerdthat_Logez cnd LariasKa
delileat he ame_fu lahulogan s StC Ton nent
to he aHc/i Upye fo pull Out_the itemi nlo ee
delered hy mitake b ntogan rehuej ckimig
at he bough! Hhe itm fron Loriug Rneer hecud
no_preserCny ccep lan negottd wth Cahulgan
tonuteckd deier fp him 20.w0 north_ofenpty botHeJ
ntcaseLevldenced hy her agrecnGy
NoneHeles, Tan hlad acare against Cahulagan
for fhe Crime af FenChg

ISSUE

Whefhe a Cnme_of tnclag_nar committed

Yes A he e/emest of fencing here proed

oythe osecuion Fir Laiog odthe ies ny/o
Conen_for his peLsogain. Jecord, (ohulogan
bought_the nmy Cnd_aLin posseKton of fhe AE,
hic, Chatgan Uhoud hae been forenaned that he
fCm came rom O_ilegaso becaue of he
Jack qf ecep amd laily, Lahuagan' Mtcnt: to
ganba Ccen hy the facdh he kogh} the_
nerit
 DATE

Mariono Lim eple f the Philppn

FACIS
Cunmgico UAht the oLiutance of UPDY Sohlana
In the recoray O a KomatU Road Grakr nd he
aff na infumed thaf fhe Ame Could be fourd
Ofuca Metal Gulnatico testfied tiat he nal ofumed
INt equpment na rcmored frm th CompSund ang
aded into a tack to_Daoo Cihy

Ihe defae praientd Un_ayng thaf he boughy

He equpNent fon nosiKg_ and that he lattr shoned
him a Cer thcaic o OnAcKhijp

JSUE

hhethe the elemestj of the Ccaime a facng mere

&tablished
hy the precuton
HELO

No. The pDseaufan_failed t eutalplin al Hie element

The Caufhed thay the poecuion nQ 0at ble tn_pae
DPNH DNnership fhe equimienf DEN4 ii pEd
hareg dakabare of all eguipmert 2 foilure to praseni ach-
placey dbub} on their chino onnershpp

1he_prosecufion alo faled to ptue to the eup:

Ment a tolen. &unntal fRtinony o he t df

thefka not glrel ny negl de to him having no

eLSNGknkuge_ Hhe ac
erk