Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Impact of Telemedicine Support by Remote Pre-Hospital
Impact of Telemedicine Support by Remote Pre-Hospital
Impact of Telemedicine Support by Remote Pre-Hospital
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijcard.2015.06.124
0167-5273/© 2015 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
Descargado para Anonymous User (n/a) en University of Antioquia de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en noviembre 13, 2021. Para uso
personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2021. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados.
216 Letter to the Editor
Fig. 1. Emergency medical service 118 staff personnel age and years of experience with telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram support.
sent by EMS personnel from all over Apulia. In case of STEMI, the hospital telemedicine electrocardiogram was administrated to all
patients are immediately addressed to the nearest cath-lab for the participants in the study.
appropriate treatment. The study was authorized by local Health Authority and agrees with
Fifty consecutive EMS 118 staff personnel randomly selected in the the declaration of Helsinki.
Bari/Barletta/Andria/Trani districts in Apulia were enrolled in the Continuous variables were reported as mean ± standard deviation
study. A questionnaire with 19 items exploring age, gender, personal and compared with Student's t-test or ANOVA, dichotomic variables as
qualification (paramedic, physician), years of use of telemedicine pre- percentages and compared with χ2 test. Correlations were tested with
hospital electrocardiogram support, town's population and ER prompt Pearson's test.
availability, personal satisfaction with telemedicine electrocardiogram A p value b 0.05 was considered as statistically significant.
support, individual indications to pre-hospital telemedicine electrocar- Questionnaires were returned in 43 subjects of 50 interviewed.
diogram adopted in everyday clinical practice, and clinical impact on Mean age of subjects enrolled in the study was 44 ± 7 years, 72% of
hospitalization decisions and diagnoses possibly changed after pre- EMS 118 staff were males; 42% were younger than 40-year old, 35%
Fig. 2. Emergency medical service staff personnel appreciation of telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram support and remote cardiologist consultation (upper panel). Frequency and
indications to telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram by suspected acute cardiovascular disease (lower panel).
Descargado para Anonymous User (n/a) en University of Antioquia de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en noviembre 13, 2021. Para uso
personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2021. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados.
Letter to the Editor 217
Fig. 3. Frequency of changed diagnosis after telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram and changed diagnosis according to suspected acute cardiovascular disease.
were 40 to 50-year old, 23% were older than 50-year old (Fig. 1). pre-hospital telemedicine electrocardiogram in 84% of suspected
Experience with pre-hospital telemedicine electrocardiogram support tachycardias, 81% of bradycardias, 95% of suspected acute coronary
was longer than 5 years in 67% of EMS 118 staff members. syndromes, 91% of syncope, 21% of uncertain cardiovascular
Thirty percent were paramedics vs 70% physicians, 37% were EMS diagnoses.
118 staff personnel from towns with a population N15,000 inhabitants, Hospitalization or ER evaluation was avoided in 54% of cases of
37% were located in towns without an emergency room promptly suspected acute cardiovascular disease after pre-hospital telemedicine
available. electrocardiogram, while was decided, although unplanned, after pre-
According to interviewed EMS staff members, pre-hospital telemed- hospital telemedicine electrocardiogram in 47% of suspected acute
icine electrocardiogram was considered not much useful in just 2.3% of cardiovascular disease (Fig. 4).
cases, almost useful in 2.3%, very useful in 2.3% and extremely useful in Pre-hospital electrocardiogram should have been repeated some-
93%; cardiologist telemedicine consultation was reported not much times by 74.4% of interviewed EMS 118 staff members, almost every
useful in just 2.3% of cases, almost useful in 2.3%, very useful in 2.3% day by 21%; optimal quality for pre-hospital telemedicine electrocardio-
and extremely useful in 93% (Fig. 2, upper panel). gram was achieved within 1 or 2 attempts by 91% of interviewed EMS
Pre-hospital telemedicine electrocardiogram was performed often 118 staff personnel (Fig. 5).
in a week by 2.3% of interviewed EMS 118 staff personnel, every day Overall satisfaction rate about pre-hospital telemedicine electrocar-
by 88.4% of subjects, more than one in a day by 9.3% (Fig. 2 lower diogram support was good in 7% of interviewed EMS 118 staff members,
panel), in 98% of suspected tachycardias, 100% of suspected bradycar- excellent in 86% (Fig. 6).
dias, acute coronary syndromes and syncopes, 91% of uncertain cardio- No significant correlations were found between age, gender, person-
vascular diagnosis, in 2% as routine examination (Fig. 2 lower panel). al qualification and other items included in the interview. Telemedicine
After pre-hospital telemedicine electrocardiogram diagnosis changed pre-hospital electrocardiogram support was more appreciated by emer-
sometimes in 79% of cases, often in 21% (Fig. 3); diagnosis changed after gency medical service staff personnel located in towns without an
Fig. 4. Avoided hospitalization or emergency room evaluation after telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram in the case of suspected acute cardiovascular disease (left) or indication to
hospitalization unplanned prior to telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram (right).
Descargado para Anonymous User (n/a) en University of Antioquia de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en noviembre 13, 2021. Para uso
personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2021. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados.
218 Letter to the Editor
Fig. 5. Technical issues: need of repeat telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram for an optimal interpretation and number of repeat pre-hospital electrocardiograms required to
achieve an optimal quality for remote cardiologist interpretation.
Fig. 7. Telemedicine pre-hospital electrocardiogram support was more appreciated by emergency medical service staff personnel located in towns without an emergency room promptly
accessible and requiring longer transfer (p b 0.001 and p b 0.01 respectively).
Descargado para Anonymous User (n/a) en University of Antioquia de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en noviembre 13, 2021. Para uso
personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2021. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados.
Letter to the Editor 219
department delay [19]. Several studies showed a dramatic reduction in M. Valgimigli, A. van 't Hof, P. Widimsky, D. Zahger, ESC Guidelines for the man-
agement of acute myocardial infarction in patients presenting with ST-segment
STEMI mortality with a pre-hospital triage strategy [20,21]. elevation, Eur. Heart J. 33 (2012) 2569–2619.
Data on pre-hospital electrocardiogram triage for the treatment of [3] E.M. Antman, M. Hand, P.W. Armstrong, E.R. Bates, L.A. Green, L.K. Halasyamani,
AMI are currently available also from our country [22,23], Italy; lower et al., 2007 focused update of the ACC/AHA 2004 guidelines for the management
of patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarction: a report of the American
rates of cardiovascular mortality in subjects with STEMI triaged with College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines:
pre-hospital telemedicine electrocardiograms have been also recently developed in collaboration with the Canadian Cardiovascular Society, endorsed by
shown [24]. However, the perceived clinical support of telemedicine as- the American Academy of Family Physicians: 2007 writing group to review new
evidence and update the acc/aha 2004 guidelines for the management of patients
sistance has not been extensively evaluated so far. with ST-elevation myocardial infarction, writing on behalf of the 2004 writing
Clinical usefulness of pre-hospital electrocardiogram assessment has committee, Circulation 117 (2008) 296–329.
been already in the management and diagnosis of arrhythmias [25,26], [4] J.L. Garvey, B.A. MacLeod, G. Sopko, M.M. Hand, on behalf of the National Heart
Attack Alert Program (NHAAP) Coordinating Committee, Pre-hospital 12-lead
in primary [27,28] and secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease
electrocardiography programs. a call for implementation by emergency medical
[29,30], fast track emergency room triage [31], in climate emergencies services systems providing advanced life support — National Heart Attack Alert
[32] or for the assistance of detainees [33,34]. Program (NHAAP) Coordinating Committee; National Heart, Lung, and Blood
We show for the first time the very high appreciation by EMS staff Institute (NHLBI); National Institutes of Health, J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 47 (2006) 485–491.
[5] D.B. Diercks, M.C. Kontos, A.Y. Chen, C.V. Pollack, S.D. Wiviott, J.S. Rumsfeld, D.J.
personnel. Ninety-three percent of interviewed subjects found telemed- Magid, W.B. Gibler, C.P. Cannon, E.D. Peterson, M.T. Roe, Utilization and impact of
icine pre-hospital electrocardiogram support extremely useful and prehospital electrocardiograms for patients with acute ST-segment elevation myo-
about the same percentage used pre-hospital electrocardiogram cardial infarction: data from the NCDR (National Cardiovascular Data Registry)
ACTION (Acute Coronary Treatment and Intervention Outcomes Network) Registry,
support every day or more than once in a day. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 53 (2009) 161–166.
In spite of this, telemedicine support was not perceived as a routine [6] J.P. Curtis, E.L. Portnay, Y. Wang, R.L. McNamara, J. Herrin, E.H. Bradley, D.J. Magid, M.E.
tool to be used in every case of EMS dispatch, and was actually used just Blaney, J.G. Canto, H.M. Krumholz, National Registry of Myocardial Infarction-4., The
pre-hospital electrocardiogram and time to reperfusion in patients with acute myo-
in the case of suspected acute cardiovascular disease. cardial infarction, 2000–2002: findings from the National Registry of Myocardial
The perceived extremely high usefulness of telemedicine pre- Infarction-4, J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 47 (2006) 1544–1552.
hospital electrocardiogram support was probably based on the impres- [7] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, G. Amodio, G. Dellegrottaglie, P.L. Pellegrino, M. Di
Biase, G. Antonelli, Telecardiology improves quality of diagnosis and reduces delay
sively high rates of diagnoses changed thus leading to an initially to treatment in elderly patients with acute myocardial infarction and atypical
unplanned or avoiding an unnecessary although initially planned hospi- presentation, Eur. J. Cardiovasc. Prev. Rehabil. 17 (2010) 615–620.
talization or ER evaluation. Probably such extremely higher (perceived, [8] N.D. Brunetti, G. Amodio, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, P.L. Pellegrino, M. Di
Biase, G. Antonelli, Telecardiology applied to a region-wide public emergency
not necessarily real) rates of diagnoses changed after telemedicine pre-
health-care service, J. Thromb. Thrombolysis 28 (2009) 23–30.
hospital electrocardiogram testify a great dependence on remote [9] M.R. Le May, D.Y. So, R. Dionne, C.A. Glover, M.P. Froeschl, G.A. Wells, R.F. Davies, H.L.
cardiologist confirmation developed by EMS personnel when remote Sherrard, J. Maloney, J.F. Marquis, E.R. O'Brien, J. Trickett, P. Poirier, S.C. Ryan, A. Ha,
cardiologist accessibility is so promptly available. P.G. Joseph, M. Labinaz, A citywide protocol for primary PCI in ST-segment elevation
myocardial infarction, N. Engl. J. Med. 358 (2008) 231–240.
The great appreciation of telemedicine support in not flawed neither [10] J.G. Jollis, M.L. Roettig, A.O. Aluko, K.J. Anstrom, R.J. Applegate, J.D. Babb, P.B. Berger, D.J.
by very small technical limitations observable in this study. Even though Bohle, S.M. Fletcher, J.L. Garvey, W.R. Hathaway, J.W. Hoekstra, R.V. Kelly, W.T. Maddox
repeat electrocardiogram is sometimes required, in the vast majority of Jr., J.R. Shiber, F.S. Valeri, B.A. Watling, B.H. Wilson, C.B. Granger, Reperfusion of Acute
Myocardial Infarction in North Carolina Emergency Departments (RACE) Investigators,
cases an optimal pre-hospital electrocardiogram quality is achieved Implementation of a statewide system for coronary reperfusion for ST-segment eleva-
after just one repetition, without significant practical limitations, or, at tion myocardial infarction, JAMA 298 (2007) 2371–2380.
least, with practical limitations widely counterbalanced by diagnostic [11] J.P. Brown, E. Mahmud, J.V. Dunford, O. Ben-Yehuda, Effect of prehospital 12-lead
electrocardiogram on activation of the cardiac catheterization laboratory and
impact on clinical management of EMS patients with suspected acute door-to-balloon time in ST-segment elevation acute myocardial infarction, Am. J.
cardiovascular disease. Cardiol. 101 (2008) 158–161.
No significant difference in terms of appreciation of telemedicine [12] M. Sejersten, M. Sillesen, P.R. Hansen, S.L. Nielsen, H. Nielsen, S. Trautner, D.
Hampton, G.S. Wagner, P. Clemmensen, Effect on treatment delay of prehospital
support is detectable according to EMS staff personnel age and gender. teletransmission of 12-lead electrocardiogram to a cardiologist for immediate triage
Expectably, telemedicine support is mostly appreciated by EMS staff and direct referral of patients with ST-segment elevation acute myocardial infarc-
members far from an ER which should cover longer drive distance for tion to primary percutaneous coronary intervention, Am. J. Cardiol. 101 (2008)
941–946.
ER transfer.
[13] C.J. Terkelsen, J.F. Lassen, B.L. Nørgaard, J.C. Gerdes, S.H. Poulsen, K. Bendix, J.P.
Further confirmations in larger populations, however, are warranted Ankersen, L.B. Gøtzsche, F.K. Rømer, T.T. Nielsen, H.R. Andersen, Reduction of
to confirm such positive preliminary results. treatment delay in patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarction: impact of
This is an observational, non-randomized study, enrolling a limited pre-hospital diagnosis and direct referral to primary percutaneous coronary
intervention, Eur. Heart J. 26 (2005) 770–777.
number of subjects. [14] J.T. Sørensen, C.J. Terkelsen, B.L. Nørgaard, S. Trautner, T.M. Hansen, H.E. Bøtker, J.F.
In conclusion, telemedicine support by pre-hospital electrocardio- Lassen, H.R. Andersen, Urban and rural implementation of pre-hospital diagnosis
gram is extremely appreciated and utilized by EMS staff personnel. and direct referral for primary percutaneous coronary intervention in patients
with acute ST-elevation myocardial infarction, Eur. Heart J. 32 (2011) 430–436.
Clinical impact in terms of avoided unnecessary hospitalizations or [15] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, D. Amoruso, G. Antonelli, M. Di Biase,
wrong diagnoses in the case of suspected acute cardiovascular disease A regional prehospital electrocardiogram network with a single telecardiology
perceived by EMS staff is extremely relevant. “hub” for public emergency medical service: technical requirements, logistics,
manpower, and preliminary results, Telemed. J. E Health 17 (2011) 727–733.
[16] N.D. Brunetti, G. Di Pietro, A. Aquilino, A.I. Bruno, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe,
Conflict of interest C. Lopriore, L. De Gennaro, S. Lanzone, P. Caldarola, G. Antonelli, M. Di Biase, Pre-
hospital electrocardiogram triage with tele-cardiology support is associated with
shorter time-to-balloon and higher rates of timely reperfusion even in rural areas:
The authors report no relationships that could be construed as a data from the Bari-Barletta/Andria/Trani public emergency medical service 118 reg-
conflict of interest. istry on primary angioplasty in ST-elevation myocardial infarction, Eur. Heart J.
Acute Cardiovasc. Care 3 (2014) 204–213.
[17] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, G. Antonelli, M. Di
References Biase, All for one, one for all: remote telemedicine hub pre-hospital triage for the
public Emergency Medical Service 118 in a regional network for primary PCI in
[1] N.D. Brunetti, S. Scalvini, F. Acquistapace, G. Parati, M. Volterrani, F. Fedele, G. Apulia, Italy, Eur. Res. Telemed. 3 (2014) 9–15.
Molinari, Telemedicine for cardiovascular disease continuum: a position paper [18] S. Carstensen, G.C.I. Nelson, P.S. Hansen, L. Macken, S. Irons, M. Flynn, et al., Field tri-
from the Italian Society of Cardiology Working Group on Telecardiology and age to primary angioplasty combined with emergency department bypass reduces
Informatics, Int. J. Cardiol. 184C (2015) 452–458. treatment delays and is associated with improved outcome, Eur. Heart J. 28
[2] P.G. Steg, S.K. James, D. Atar, L.P. Badano, C. Blömstrom-Lundqvist, M.A. Borger, (2007) 2313–2319.
C. Di Mario, G. Ducrocq, F. Fernandez-Aviles, A.H. Gershlick, P. Giannuzzi, S. [19] G. Sivagangabalan, A.T.L. Ong, A. Narayan, N. Sadick, P.S. Hansen, G.C.I. Nelson, G.C.
Halvorsen, K. Huber, P. Juni, A. Kastrati, J. Knuuti, M.J. Lenzen, K.W. Mahaffey, Nelson, M. Flynn, D.L. Ross, S.C. Boyages, P. Kovoor, Effect of prehospital triage on
Descargado para Anonymous User (n/a) en University of Antioquia de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en noviembre 13, 2021. Para uso
personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2021. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados.
220 Letter to the Editor
revascularization times, left ventricular function, and survival in patients with [26] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, P.L. Pellegrino, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Antonelli, M. Di
ST-elevation myocardial infarction, Am. J. Cardiol. 103 (2009) 907–912. Biase, Atrial fibrillation with symptoms other than palpitations: incremental diag-
[20] A.W. Chan, J. Kornder, H. Elliott, R.I. Brown, J.F. Dorval, J. Charania, R. Zhang, L. Ding, nostic sensitivity with at-home tele-cardiology assessment for emergency medical
A. Lalani, R.A. Kuritzky, G.J. Simkus, Improved survival associated with pre-hospital service, Eur. J. Prev. Cardiol. 19 (2012) 306–313.
triage strategy in a large regional ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction [27] N.D. Brunetti, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, C. Lopriore, G. Gardini, S. Patruno, T.
program, JACC Cardiovasc. Interv. 5 (2012) 1239–1246. Loiacono, L. De gennaro, M. Di Biase, YOUng Football Italian amateur players,
[21] R. Estévez-Loureiro, R. Calviño-Santos, A. López-Sainz, J.M. Vázquez-Rodríguez, M.R. Remote electrocardiogram screening with telemedicine (YOU FIRST) study:
Soler-Martín, O. Prada-Delgado, E. Barge-Caballero, J. Salgado-Fernández, G. preliminary results, Int. J. Cardiol. 176 (2014) 1257–1258.
Aldama-López, P. Piñón-Esteban, X. Flores-Ríos, M. Barreiro-Díaz, J. Varela-Portas, [28] N.D. Brunetti, A.R. Conoscitore, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, L. De Gennaro, G.
M. Freire-Tellado, M. García-Guimaraes, N. Vázquez-González, A. Castro-Beiras, Antonelli, A. Bruna, M. Di Biase, Exercise training and obesity in Italian children
Long-term prognostic benefit of field triage and direct transfer of patients with directly assessed by primary school teachers with tele-cardiology support: a pilot
ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction treated by primary percutaneous experience, Int. J. Cardiol. 168 (2013) 1699–1702.
coronary intervention, Am. J. Cardiol. 111 (2013) 1721–1726. [29] N.D. Brunetti, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, M. Di Biase, Remote tele-medicine
[22] A. Martinoni, S. De Servi, E. Boschetti, R. Zanini, T. Palmerini, A. Politi, G. Musumeci, cardiologist support for care manager nursing of chronic cardiovascular disease:
G. Belli, M. De Paolis, F. Ettori, E. Piccaluga, D. Sangiorgi, A. Repetto, M. D'Urbano, B. preliminary report, Int. J. Cardiol. 176 (2014) 552–556.
Castiglioni, F. Fabbiocchi, M. Onofri, N. De Cesare, G. Sangiorgi, C. Lettieri, F. Poletti, S. [30] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, E. Straziota, V. Novielli, G. Antonelli, M.
Pirelli, S. Klugmann, Lombardima Study Group, Importance and limits of pre- Di Biase, Rationale and design for a cardiovascular screening and prevention study
hospital electrocardiogram in patients with ST elevation myocardial infarction un- with tele-cardiology in Mediterranean Italy: The CAPITAL study (CArdiovascular
dergoing percutaneous coronary angioplasty, Eur. J. Cardiovasc. Prev. Rehabil. 18 Prevention wIth Telecardiology in ApuLia), Int. J. Cardiol. 149 (2011) 130–133.
(2011) 526–532. [31] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, V. Procacci, M. Di Biase, Fast and
[23] R. Zanini, M. Aroldi, S. Bonatti, F. Buffoli, A. Izzo, C. Lettieri, M. Romano, L. Tomasi, furious: telecardiology for acute myocardial infarction triage in emergency room,
M.R. Ferrari, Impact of prehospital diagnosis in the management of ST elevation Eur. Res. Telemed. 2 (2013) 75–78.
myocardial infarction in the era of primary percutaneous coronary intervention: [32] N.D. Brunetti, D. Amoruso, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, G.
reduction of treatment delay and mortality, J. Cardiovasc. Med. 9 (2008) 570–575. Antonelli, M. Di Biase, Hot Spot: Impact of July 2011 heat-wave in southern Italy
[24] N.D. Brunetti, L. Bisceglia, G. Dellegrottaglie, A.I. Bruno, G. Di Pietro, L. De Gennaro, (Apulia) on cardiovascular disease assessed by Emergency Medical Service and
M. Di Biase, Lower mortality with pre-hospital electrocardiogram triage by telemed- tele-medicine support, Telemed. J. E Health 20 (2014) 272–281.
icine support in high risk acute myocardial infarction treated with primary angio- [33] N.D. Brunetti, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, L. De Gennaro, M. Di Biase, Prison
plasty: preliminary data from the Bari-BAT public Emergency Medical Service 118 break: remote tele-cardiology support for cardiology emergency in Italian
registry, Int. J. Cardiol. 185 (2015) 224–228. penitentiaries, Int. J. Cardiol. 168 (2013) 3138–3140.
[25] N.D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Antonelli, D. Amoruso, M. Di Biase, [34] N.D. Brunetti, G. Dellegrottaglie, L. De Gennaro, M. Di Biase, Telemedicine pre-
Prevalence of cardiac arrhythmias in pre-hospital tele-cardiology electrocardio- hospital electrocardiogram for acute cardiovascular disease management in
grams of emergency medical service patients referred for syncope, J. Electrocardiol. detainees: an update, Eur. Res. Telemed. 4 (2015) 25–32.
45 (2012) 727–732.
Descargado para Anonymous User (n/a) en University of Antioquia de ClinicalKey.es por Elsevier en noviembre 13, 2021. Para uso
personal exclusivamente. No se permiten otros usos sin autorización. Copyright ©2021. Elsevier Inc. Todos los derechos reservados.