Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stanley Maloy, San Diego State University, San Diego, CA, USA
r 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Mutations and Mutagenesis into two categories based on the phenotypes of the corres-
ponding mutants: nonessential gene products are only re-
A powerful feature of bacterial genetics is the ability to quired under specific growth conditions, whereas essential
examine very large populations of cells (typically 41010) for gene products are required under all conditions. The genes of
extremely rare types of mutants. Mutations can arise in a lactose catabolism are nonessential because they are only re-
variety of ways, including rare errors in DNA synthesis or DNA quired for growth on medium with lactose as the sole carbon
repair. The probability that a spontaneous mutation will affect source. In contrast, the genes encoding RNA polymerase are
a particular base pair varies from about 107 to 1011 per essential because they are required for growth on all media.
generation. Thus, in a population of bacteria, about 1 in 109 Null mutations in a nonessential gene will prevent growth on
cells may have a mutation in a particular gene. The frequency a medium that requires that gene product but such mutants
of mutations can be increased by certain chemical or physical will still grow on other media. In contrast, null mutations in
agents called mutagens. Mutagens may act by increasing the an essential gene are lethal. Consequently, such mutants
frequency of errors during DNA synthesis or repair or by dir- cannot be recovered from haploid bacteria. Nevertheless, it is
ectly altering the DNA. Direct exposure of bacteria to a possible to isolate more subtle mutations in essential genes.
mutagen may increase the frequency of mutations in a For example, it is possible to isolate mutations that alter a
population of cells from 103- to 106-fold. Thorough genetic subunit of RNA polymerase that make the organism resistant
analysis requires many types of mutations, but each particular to the antibiotic rifampicin. It is also possible to isolate mu-
method of mutagenesis yields different subsets of mutations. tations where some phenotype is observed under certain
‘nonpermissive’ conditions but not under other ‘permissive’
conditions (Table 1).
Effects of Mutations Because not all mutations have an observable effect, it is
important to distinguish the genotype from the resulting
Bacterial mutants are typically described by comparison to a phenotype. In bacterial genetic nomenclature a three-letter
standard, well-characterized, reference strain called the ‘wild- mnemonic refers to a pathway or discrete cluster of physio-
type’ strain. Bacterial mutants have often lost some growth logically connected systems. A fourth, capitalized letter repre-
property (e.g., failure to utilize a particular carbon or nitrogen sents a particular gene of that set. The genotype is written in
source or failure to grow without a particular nutrient), or lower case letters and italicized (e.g., purB), with a plus
acquisition of some new growth property (e.g., ability to grow superscript indicating the wild-type genotype. (The purB gene
in the presence of some toxic substance). Genes can be divided encodes one of the enzymes required for purine biosynthesis.)
The phenotype is indicated by the same mnemonic but the streptomycin-sensitive bacteria are killed by the antibiotic and
first letter is upper case and it not italicized (e.g., PurB), with a resistant mutants grow.
plus superscript indicating the functional phenotype and a The ability to grow bacteria on solid media (i.e., agar
minus indicating a mutant phenotype. The genotype of a cell plates) under conditions where each cell forms a single col-
is usually inferred from its phenotype but may also be deter- ony allows one to carry out screens that distinguish a par-
mined indirectly by recombination experiments or directly by ticular mutant from other bacteria in the population. If the
DNA sequencing mutation is relatively common and no direct selection for the
mutant phenotype is available, it is possible to screen for
mutants on media where both the mutant and parental cells
Isolation and Characterization of Bacterial Mutants grow, but where the mutant has a readily scorable phenotype.
For example, mutants of Escherichia coli unable to degrade
Genetic analysis begins with the isolation of mutants that af- lactose can be identified on indicator media, such as Mac-
fect some property of the bacteria. Since mutations are very Conkey-lactose color indicator plates. MacConkey-lactose
rare, mutants must be isolated from large populations of wild- plates contain a carbon source that can be used by Lac þ cells,
type cells. Thus, some tactic is needed to find the rare mutants and peptides that can be used as a carbon source by both
within a vast excess of parental bacteria. It is possible to Lac þ and Lac cells. Both the Lac mutant and the Lac þ
identify mutations by physical methods such as DNA se- parental cells can therefore grow on MacConkey-lactose me-
quencing, but because mutations are so rare this approach is dium. However, MacConkey-lactose medium also contains a
not usually practical. Instead, mutants are usually identified pH indicator that is colorless at high pH but red when the pH
on the basis of an observable effect on the physiology of the decreases owing to fermentation of the lactose, so Lac þ
cell. Detection of mutants requires a genetic selection or bacteria form red colonies and Lac bacteria form white
screen (Table 2). colonies. Hence, it is possible visually to screen for Lac
A selection is an experimental arrangement that allows mutants by looking for rare white colonies on MacConkey-
specific mutants, but not the parental cells, to grow. Genetic lactose plates.
selections are very powerful because they allow the direct Screens for other types of mutants are not this simple. For
isolation of rare mutations from a very large population of example, when mutations disrupt a biosynthetic pathway, the
cells. Some useful selections include resistance to antibiotics, bacteria cannot grow unless the endproduct of the pathway is
resistance to phage, or the ability to grow on a medium where provided in the medium (permissive medium). It is not pos-
the parental cells cannot grow. For example, selection for sible to isolate such ‘auxotrophic mutants’ by directly screen-
streptomycin-resistant (StrR) mutants simply requires ex- ing for growth on media lacking the endproduct because the
posing a large number of bacteria to medium containing desired mutants will not grow (nonpermissive medium).
However, auxotrophs are readily identified by replica plating.
The bacteria are grown on permissive medium at a density of
Table 1 Some types of conditional mutations used in bacterial several hundred colonies per plate. Each of these ‘master
genetics plates’ is then replicated onto two other plates, containing
either the permissive medium or the nonpermissive medium.
Conditional Permissive conditions Nonpermissive
mutation conditions The bacteria are transferred to an identical position on each of
the replica plates. Once colonies are identified that grow only
Temperature 30 1C 42 1C on the permissive medium, the mutants can be isolated from
sensitive (Ts) the master plate (Figure 1).
Cold sensitive (Cs) 42 1C 30 1C The difference between a selection and a screen has im-
Osmoremedial High osmotic strength Low osmotic strength portant practical consequences. Compare the selection for a
Suppressor Host with suppressor Host lacking suppressor
StrR mutant with a screen for a His mutant. Isolation of a StrR
sensitive mutation mutation
colony is a direct selection because as many as 1010 cells can be
Medium #1
Press surface of
Petrie dish with
bacterial colonies
onto velvet
Medium #2
Medium #3
Figure 1 Replica plating. This simple technique makes it possible to test many individual mutants for their ability to grow on a variety of
different types of media. After pressing the sterile plates to the velvet replica of an original (‘master’) plate, the newly inoculated plates are
incubated to allow the colonies to grow.
spread on a single plate containing streptomycin and only StrR Genetic Exchange
mutants will form colonies. Thus, StrR mutants as rare as 1 in
1010 can be isolated easily. In contrast, finding an auxotrophic Exchange of DNA between bacteria plays an important role in
mutant involves screening through a large number of colonies evolution. Gene transfer in nature can result in the acquisition
for one that fails to grow in the absence of the required nu- of antibiotic resistance and new virulence traits. Gene transfer
trient. To score the growth behavior of individual colonies, is also a useful tool in the laboratory, allowing genetic map-
only a few hundred colonies can be examined on any given ping and complementation tests, and the construction of
plate. Thus, if 1 in 105 cells in the population were a particular bacterial strains with multiple mutations. The three most
auxotrophic mutant, thousands of plates would be needed to common methods of gene transfer between bacteria are
find a single mutant. Treating populations of cells with a transformation, conjugation, and transduction (Table 3). A
mutagen may increase the fraction of mutants to 1 in 103, suitable selectable marker is required to identify recipients
allowing screening for the desired mutant on a reasonable that have inherited the desired region of donor DNA.
number of replica plates. Nevertheless, random mutagenesis
may not increase the mutant fraction sufficiently to screen
easily for the desired mutants, and mutagenesis may lead to Transformation
other, undesirable mutations as well.
Isolating rare mutants is generally achieved by using some The uptake of naked DNA is called transformation. Some
sort of enrichment, a method that favors the growth of the species of bacteria are naturally transformable. At some stage
desired mutants relative to nonmutant bacteria. Penicillin during growth they express gene products that facilitate the
enrichment is a classical example of this approach. This anti- uptake of exogenous DNA, a condition called ‘competence.’
biotic disrupts the synthesis of the bacterial cell wall. Non- The physiological conditions required to induce competence
growing bacteria do not engage in cell wall synthesis, so differs for different species of bacteria. However, most natural
penicillin only kills actively growing bacteria. The differential transformation seems to involve the degradation of one strand
survival of growing versus nongrowing bacteria can be used to of the exogenous DNA during the transfer of the other strand
enrich for a desired mutant. For example, penicillin enrich- of DNA into the cell. Stable inheritance of the donor DNA
ment can be used to isolate a rare auxotrophic mutant from a requires either that it be replicated (e.g., some plasmids and
population of bacteria. If a mixture of wild-type and auxo- phage) or that it integrate into the recipient chromosome via
trophic bacteria are suspended in the nonpermissive medium homologous recombination.
containing penicillin, the auxotrophic mutants do not grow Many types of bacteria are not naturally transformable but
and thus will survive, whereas 99% of the wild-type bacteria can be induced to take up DNA by treatment with specific
will grow and be killed by the penicillin. When the surviving chemicals or by electric shock, processes that are mech-
bacteria are washed free of the penicillin, and resuspended in anistically different from natural transformation. A common
permissive medium, both the mutant and wild-type bacteria method of chemical transformation in E. coli uses hypotonic
will grow, but the ratio of mutant to wild-type bacteria will be Ca2 þ shock. To prepare competent bacteria by this method,
enriched 100-fold. Repeating this procedure multiple times an early-exponential phase culture of cells is suspended in a
eventually increases the proportion of mutants in the popu- cold hypotonic CaCl2 solution. When DNA is added to these
lation (Figure 2). bacteria it forms a calcium–DNA complex that adsorbs to the
320 Bacterial Genetics
cell surface. The bacteria are then briefly warmed (heat only seem to work in certain bacteria, a wide range of bacteria
shocked), which allows the DNA to enter the cell. In electro- can be transformed by electroporation.
poration, cells are exposed to an electric field, so that a voltage
potential develops across the membrane, transiently forming
small pores that allow entry of exogenous DNA. In contrast to Conjugation
natural transformation and chemical transformation, which
DNA can also be transferred between bacteria by a process
called conjugation. Conjugation occurs via cell–cell contact
Population of 108 cells and the formation of a mating channel. This structure is
Grow in minimal medium + supplement
formed by specific proteins that form a pore between the
Outgrowth juxtaposed membranes through which single-stranded DNA
Both aux+ and aux− cells grow
and some associated proteins are transferred into the recipient
Ratio of mutant to wild-type unchanged
cell. Conjugation requires four events: (1) contact between
donor and recipient cells and formation of a mating ap-
Grow in minimal medium − supplement + Penicillin
Enrichment pendage; (2) nicking of the donor DNA at specific sites; (3)
aux+ cells grow and 99% die
translocation of the nicked strand of donor DNA to the mat-
aux− cells cannot grow so they survive ing bridge and into the recipient cell; and (4) replication of
Ratio of mutant to increases 100 ×
the transferred DNA in the recipient cell. The proteins required
Population of cells with auxotrophs enriched by 102 for conjugation are usually encoded on specific plasmids or
transposons. These conjugal plasmids or transposons can
Grow in minimal medium + supplement transfer themselves or, if integrated into another region of the
Outgrowth genome, any adjacent genomic sequence. Thus, conjugation
Both aux+ and aux− cells grow
Ratio of mutant to wild-type unchanged can result in the transfer of very large DNA fragments – even
chromosome length DNA fragments. Furthermore, some
Grow in minimal medium − supplement + Penicillin conjugal plasmids are quite promiscuous. In addition to
transferring DNA into a wide variety of bacteria, some con-
Enrichment aux+ cells grow and 99% die
jugal plasmids can transfer DNA into Archaea and eukaryotes
aux− cells cannot grow so they survive
as well (Figure 3).
Ratio of mutant to increases 100 ×
Transformation – Uptake of naked DNA from environment; recipient cell must be competent
Conjugation Conjugal plasmid or Requires cell-to-cell contact; very long fragments of DNA can be transferred to recipient cell
transposon
Generalized Phage Phage-length fragments of chromosomal DNA transferred to recipient cell; phage head only carries
transduction host DNA
Specialized Lysogenic phage Short fragments of chromosomal DNA transferred to recipient cell; phage head carries host DNA
transduction covalently attached to phage DNA
Bacterial Genetics 321
F-Plasmid F-Plasmid Figure 3 Conjugation is a process of DNA transfer via direct contact
between a donor cell that carries a conjugal plasmid such as the
F-plasmid, and a recipient cell that lacks the conjugal plasmid. A
pilus protruding from the surface of the donor cell recognizes the
recipient cell and promotes close contact between the two cells,
forming a bridge through which DNA is transferred. On cell–cell
contact the conjugal plasmid is nicked at a specific site called oriT
(indicated by the arrowhead), and the DNA is transferred from this
site into the recipient cell. After conjugation is complete, both cells
have a complete copy of the conjugal plasmid.
322 Bacterial Genetics
Enzyme a Enzyme c
W X
(b)
Enzyme a Enzyme c
No complementation
W X (because mutations
affect same function)
Enzyme a Enzyme c
If the cell has at least one good copy of each gene, it will
be able to make all the necessary intermediates and, thus,
will be able to make the product Z.
Enzyme a Enzyme c
Complementation
W X Y Z (because mutations
affect different function)
Enzyme b Enzyme c
Figure 5 Complementation analysis provides a genetic test for particular functions encoded by different genes. (a) Assume that in a cell
substrate W is converted in three enzymatic steps to the endproduct Z, and that each of these enzymatic steps is encoded by a different genes
(a, b, and c). (b) If any one of these genes is defective in a haploid bacterial cell, then that cell will be unable to make the endproduct. (c) If two
copies of these genes are placed in a single bacterial cell, and if both copies are defective for the same gene, then the cell will be unable to
make the endproduct. In this case, we say that the second copy did not complement the original mutation. (d) If the two copies of the genes are
defective for different genes, then at least one functional gene is present for each step in the pathway, and the endproduct will be made. If the
second copy compensates for the defective function, then we say that the mutation was complemented.
inexpensive way to determine rapidly the location of mu- from a donor to an appropriate recipient strain. If the mutation
tations in bacteria. cannot be directly selected, linkage to an adjacent, selectable
Recombination also provides an invaluable tool for con- marker can be used to move the mutation into a recipient
structing strains with multiple mutations. If a mutation involves strain. For example, an auxotrophic mutation may be trans-
a directly selectable phenotype, it can be transferred with ease ferred by selecting for coinheritance of a nearby gene.
324 Bacterial Genetics
...TACGCCATTAGCTA...
Complementation Analysis ...ATGCGGTAATCGAT...
Transposable elements play an important role in bacterial Although a wide variety of genetic tricks have been developed
evolution, including the transfer of antibiotic resistance genes for specific purposes in particular bacteria, bacterial genetics
between bacteria and promoting chromosome rearrange- relies on a relatively small core of tools for dissection of the
ments. In addition, transposable elements are useful tools in structure and function of genes. The essential tools include the
bacterial genetics because they provide selectable markers and isolation of mutations, the ability to transfer genes between
portable regions of homology that can be used to facilitate bacterial strains, the ability to isolate recombinants, and the
genetic recombination. ability to do complementation tests. These tools have been
finely honed for a select group of model bacteria, including
E. coli, Salmonella enterica, and Bacillus subtilis. The concepts
Integration of Circular DNA Molecules developed for these model bacteria are readily applicable to
other bacteria as well, although the experimental details
In addition to transposons, it is possible to construct small typically require adaptation for each particular species of
repeats of homologous DNA by integration of a circular DNA bacteria.
molecule with a cloned fragment of chromosomal DNA. This
approach is useful for construction of defined duplications for
complementation analysis and for construction of insertion
mutations on the chromosome. Recombination between the References
homologous sequences of the resulting duplication can result
Hughes K and Maloy S (eds.) (2007) Advanced Bacterial Genetics. Methods
in allele exchange, moving a mutation from a cloned sequence
Enzymology, vol. 421. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
onto the chromosome DNA. Maloy S, Cronan J, and Freifelder D (1995) Microbial Genetics. 2nd edn. Boston,
MA: Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
Maloy S, Hughes K, and Casadesus J (2011) The Lure of Bacterial Genetics.
Summary Washington, DC: ASM Press.
Maloy S, Stewart V, and Taylor R (1996) Genetic Analysis of Pathogenic Bacteria.
Plainview, New York: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.
A hallmark of bacterial genetics is the ability to analyze very Miller JH (1992) A Short Course in Bacterial Genetics. Plainview, New York: Cold
large populations of cells to identify rare genetic events. Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.