Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction 1
Chris Hodgson and Matt Berry
v
Contents
9 Adventure education and disaffected youth 166
Ed Christian
11 Values in adventure education: happy and wise through hands-on learning 206
Pete Allison, Malcolm Thorburn, John Telford and Aaron Marshall
14 Conclusion 256
Chris Hodgson and Matt Berry
Index 258
vi
Contents
CONTRIBUTORS
Pete Allison is Deputy Head of the Institute for Sport, Physical Education and Health
Sciences at the University of Edinburgh. He is a fellow of the Royal Geographical Society
and founder of the Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning. He has also
served on the board of directors of the Association for Experiential Education.
Marcus Bailie is Head of Inspection at the Adventure Activity Licensing Service. Previously,
he worked as an instructor at Plas y Brenin (the National Mountain Centre), where he had
specific responsibility for mountain leadership, and as director of Tiglin (the Irish National
Adventure Centre).
Simon Beames is a lecturer at the University of Edinburgh. His outdoor instructing
experience has mainly been gained in North America and Asia, where he has worked with
Outward Bound, Project DARE, the YMCA and the Hong Kong International School.
Matt Berry is a lecturer at the University of Chichester, where he teaches on both the
Adventure Education and the Physical Education degree programmes. He is a keen
whitewater kayaker and has been active in adventure education through teaching and
research for fifteen years, with a special interest in teacher and coach education.
Pete Bunyan is Head of the Department of Adventure Education at the University of
Chichester. Previously, he ran the PGCE in Outdoor Education at the University of Exeter.
Ed Christian is a lecturer at the University of Chichester. He has worked with young people
excluded from mainstream education for the Devon Youth Service and has taught at Skern
Lodge, Devon, where he had responsibility for working with disaffected young people.
Suzanne Everley is a lecturer at the University of Chichester, where she specialises in
participants’ perceptions of physical education and physical activity.
Johannes Felter is a research student at Liverpool John Moores University. He has taught
Religious, Moral and Philosophical Studies in combination with Outdoor Education for ten
years at various schools and centres.
Joseph Gibson is Outdoor Education Coordinator for Sense Scotland, where he specialises
in work with participants with dual sensory impairments.
vii
List of contributors
Paul Gray is a lecturer at the University of Central Lancashire, where he teaches on both
the Outdoor Leadership and Adventure Sports Coaching degree programmes. Previously
he was Operations and Centre Manager for numerous adventure education companies
throughout the UK and Europe.
Chris Heaney is a lecturer at the University of Chichester. Previously, he was Managing
Director for Life Gateway – a provider of experiential educational and respite services for
looked-after children – prior to which he was a course director for Outward Bound in
Utah, USA.
Chris Hodgson is a lecturer at the University of Chichester, where he teaches Adventure
Education and Physical Education. He has been involved in the delivery of adventure
education for over twenty years. Professional experience includes the delivery of adventure
programmes to a wide range of participants, from young children through to adults and from
performance-based adventure sports programmes through to management training as well
as personal and social education.
John Kelly is a lecturer at the University of Chichester, where he specialises in physiology
and competitive adventure sports. Previously, he was a physical training instructor for the
military and worked in cardiac rehabilitation for the National Health Service.
Jane Lomax is Programme Coordinator for Sports Coaching and PE at the University of
Chichester. Her previous experience includes management training and snow sports
instruction.
Aaron Marshall is a research student at the Institute for Sport, PE and Health Sciences, the
University of Edinburgh, where he specialises in experiential education as a framework for
character formation.
Julia Potter is a lecturer at the University of Chichester. She specialises in children’s health
and fitness in relation to lifestyle and physical activity.
Tim Stott is Professor of Physical Geography and Outdoor Education at Liverpool John
Moores University, where he teaches earth science, geomorphology, weather and
atmospheric processes, mountains and upland landscapes, natural hazards and applied
geomorphology, fluvial processes and outdoor pursuits (kayaking, mountain leadership,
orienteering, skiing).
John Telford recently completed a longitudinal sociological study of residential outdoor
education for which he gained a Ph.D. at the Institute for Sport, PE and Health Sciences,
the University of Edinburgh. He has fifteen years’ experience of working with adults and
children in various contexts, ranging from residential outdoor education centres to
community projects to higher education institutions.
Malcolm Thorburn is a lecturer in Physical Education at the University of Edinburgh. His
research interests include knowledge representation in practical learning environments, and
the goals of physical education in schools.
viii
List of contributors
INTRODUCTION
Chris Hodgson and Matt Berry
Recent years have seen a sustained growth in interest in outdoor and adventure-based
learning. From a discipline with a relatively short history we are now part of a world which
sees adventure ever more prominent in media, lifestyles and mainstream education. Even
television programming is rich with images of adventure and themes that we can see are
linked to adventure and outdoor education philosophies. This is interspersed with
advertisements that also often borrow from typical adventure themes and portray the
characteristics commensurate with desirable traits and healthy living. In some ways it may
seem strange that we ever have to justify adventure-based programmes since it is so often
implied that there is an automatic benefit from participation. However, whilst superficially
this may all appear good, it is still necessary to differentiate between real, meaningful
education with profound benefits for participants and society, and activities that seem
adventurous in nature but offer little quality learning potential. Otherwise, we may miss an
opportunity to achieve broader educational goals and enrich the lives of participants. Of
course, it is always possible to learn from an adventurous experience in an incidental or
accidental way, but adventure education essentially should have clear purposes and seek
to move learners actively in a direction that is likely to meet their specific needs.
The purposeful use of adventure has now reached the point where there is a significant
degree of interest in studying the subject at academic and professional levels. This is
reflected in the large number of opportunities to study adventure and outdoor-related
disciplines at post-sixteen, undergraduate and postgraduate levels in the UK, the USA,
Australia, Canada, New Zealand and elsewhere. Such a development would not have
seemed likely even as recently as the 1980s.
This book is intended to appeal to a range of readers from varying backgrounds. Primarily
we expect that students studying at undergraduate level will find it particularly useful as a
guide to the processes and practical aspects of adventure education that will support their
intellectual understanding of our ever-developing discipline. We also expect that pro-
fessional adventure educators will find that the book supports them as they develop an
understanding of what we do and why we do it, which can go hand in hand with knowledge
of technical skills. If we want credibility as professionals in education, it is imperative that
1
Introduction
we move beyond purely sports- and technical-based knowledge, which is already well
catered for by the governing body and activity instructor award schemes. As yet, this
educational knowledge base and skills set have not had the recognition and emphasis that
they deserve. This may be due partly to our preoccupation with safety-based skills, which,
although vital, do not constitute the complete understanding that is necessary to plan and
deliver educational experiences. Organisations like the UK-based Institute of Outdoor
Learning are now making inroads in this area with an accreditation scheme that aims to
recognise and validate an educational skills set that is equal to technical and safety skills.
This book can provide a valuable resource for professionals hoping to develop their
educational skills.
The philosophy of our approach is that we aim to complement existing texts within the field
of adventure and outdoor education. Rather than see ourselves as an exclusive group, or
our approach as an alternative to other forms of education, we feel we belong to a large
and diverse community of educational professionals. As such, we need to embrace the
lessons that we can learn from these colleagues and related educational disciplines. We
also have a responsibility to engage with these disciplines. This is a two-way process with
mutual benefits for all concerned. Whilst mainstream education has much to gain from
experiential disciplines of education, we can also make use of decades of research and
development in more formal education methods. Importantly, we see our role as com-
plementary to other educational experiences, rather than an alternative. Whilst it may be
theoretically possible to learn all we need to know in adventure education, practicalities
dictate that adventure education often performs a vital but supporting role in a fully rounded
education.
In the past, some adventure educators have been very concerned about the label we attach
to ourselves. This means some professionals refer to themselves as ‘facilitators’ and actively
avoid terms like ‘teacher’, believing that the latter somehow limits their engagement with
clients. In this book, we see rounded educators as changing the emphasis of their delivery
to suit the needs of the learner. We have not attached a strong value to one label and we
do not see a hierarchy in such descriptors as ‘facilitator’, ‘teacher’, ‘instructor’, ‘educator’
and ‘guide’. In fact, we have often used these terms interchangeably or have assumed that
a single person can fulfil all of these roles – although not necessarily at the same time! We
do not assume that any such titles automatically mean formal qualifications or a particular
educational standpoint or setting.
We hope you enjoy this book, which has been written by a diverse and very experienced
team. It would probably have been impossible for one person to have articulated all of the
ideas found here, so we feel the number of contributors is one of the book’s key strengths.
In Chapter 1 Pete Bunyan presents his view of the theorists and models that have shaped
the way in which most of us understand adventure education. This is a good starting point
for anyone wishing to engage in adventure as an educational tool. Pete is particularly
interested in the development of self-esteem through adventure.
2
Chris Hodgson and Matt Berry
In Chapter 2 Matt Berry looks at how we might justify the approaches that we take in
planning adventure experiences. He presents a summary of what we know participants can
gain, and the chapter concludes with some practical approaches to planning. Matt believes
that we need to make the best possible use of the experiential learning philosophy. As a
science teacher, adventure sports coach, adventure educator and now university lecturer,
he draws on wide learning experience.
In Chapter 3 Chris Hodgson and Marcus Bailie examine risk management from the
perspective that risk is a defining feature that needs to be respected and is vital to the
learning experience. The chapter takes a practical approach to these issues and asks the
reader to examine their standpoint on safety and justifiable risk, dynamic risk management
and participants’ responsibilities. Chris is an adventure sports coach with a broad experience
base within coach education and now higher education, while Marcus performed a number
of roles in national mountain training centres before becoming head of the inspection team
for the UK’s statutory adventure activities licensing scheme.
In Chapter 4 Matt Berry presents the learning philosophies central to experiential and
adventure education. This chapter explores the nature of ‘experientiality’ and draws upon
other teaching and learning strategies that adventure educators may find useful at a practical
level.
In Chapter 5 Jane Lomax presents the notion that adventure educators coach as well as
facilitate. She draws upon established theories and research within sports coaching and
suggests the potential advantages of using coaching concepts to enhance learning
opportunities. As a highly experienced sports psychologist and coach, Jane has used many
of these concepts in her working life.
In Chapter 6 Malcolm Thorburn and Aaron Marshall explore why and how we might go
about evaluating learning in adventure education. They argue that we need to make
genuine efforts to demonstrate efficacy or success if we wish to be taken more seriously as
professional educators.
In Chapter 7 Suzanne Everley explores how we might encourage reflection to enhance
learning from experience. She presents the idea that participants’ reflections can assist us
in evaluating the impact of an experience in order to inform us about future practice.
In Chapter 8 John Kelly and Julia Potter cover the use of adventure as a targeted intervention
for the prevention of the lifestyle-based illnesses that are becoming increasingly common
in the Western world. In the future, adventure educators may well find themselves working
alongside health professionals to address this issue.
In Chapter 9 Ed Christian explores what we mean by the commonly used but largely
misunderstood term ‘disaffection’. He uses his considerable experience of working with
young people to explore the causes of disaffection and the role that adventure education
can play in addressing this significant issue.
3
Introduction
In Chapter 10 Pete Allison and colleagues discuss the benefits and history of overseas youth
expeditions. This has been a main component of many UK adventure education pro-
grammes and it seems to be a growing phenomenon.
In Chapter 11 Pete Allison and another set of colleagues present the idea that adventure
education can be a powerful mechanism to explore ethics, values and moral behaviour.
In Chapter 12 Joseph Gibson outlines the growing field of inclusive adventure, with specific
reference to disability. He presents some basic guidance on inclusive philosophy and
provides real-world examples and practical advice on working with participants with
disabilities. Joe is an expert in the field of adaptive adventure, with more than fifteen years’
experience of and research in the provision of adventure experiences for participants with
profound sensory impairments.
In Chapter 13 Paul Gray, Chris Hodgson and Chris Heaney suggest how we might develop
as adventure educators through the use of personal profiling, goal setting and targeted
activities. They argue that if we wish to pursue meaningful careers, we need to plan more
robustly for our own futures as learners.
Finally, in the conclusion, we consider possible directions that the adventure education
sector might take. Whether charitable, private or public sources of funding drive our work,
we suggest that it will become increasingly important that we strive to be seen as a
profession. Moreover, managers and practitioners should embrace stronger links between
research and practice, and should take every opportunity for ongoing professional
development within a philosophy of lifelong learning.
4
Chris Hodgson and Matt Berry
References
ORGANISATIONS’ WEBSITES