You are on page 1of 11

Ecological Research (2001) 16, 497–507

century ecosystem model application for quantifying vege-


tation dynamics in shifting cultivation areas: A case study
from Rampa Forests, Eastern Ghats (India)
V. Krishna Prasad, Yogesh Kant and K. V. S. Badarinath*
IGBP Section, Applications, National Remote Sensing Agency, Department of Space, Government of
India, Balanagar, Hyderabad 500 037, India

In India, slash and burn agriculture is one of the major factors contributing to deforestation, espe-
cially in the hilly north-eastern region and Eastern Ghats. Studies on vegetation dynamics associ-
ated with slash and burn agricultural practices have been intensively studied in the north-eastern
part of India. These have covered semi-evergreen/evergreen vegetation, but similar studies on tropi-
cal mixed dry deciduous ecosystems are not as common. In the present study, we used the century
ecosystem model to study vegetation dynamics in shifting cultivation areas on the mixed dry
deciduous forests covering the Eastern Ghats of India. The site-specific parameters, temperature,
precipitation, biomass and nutrient pools were used, and, by collecting information from local man-
agement practices, a 12-year shifting cultivation cycle during a 70-year period from 1960 to 2030
was simulated. century estimated a total loss of 239 tonnes carbon (tC) in soil organic matter over
the simulation period, and the total nitrogen content of the soil organic matter showed an initial
increase followed by a decline (344.3 g m2 during 1960 to less than 318.3 g m2 during 2030).
century estimated that 66 tC ha-1 would be lost from the forest system, reducing the initial forest
system carbon level from 118.5 tC ha-1. An increase in productivity from 0.49 tC ha-1 during 1960
to 1.2 tC ha-1 during the initial forest slash and burn in 1962 was observed, but thereafter produc-
tivity declined to 0.7 tC ha-1 during the year 2030. Results obtained in other studies of similar types
of agricultural practices are also reviewed.

INTRODUCTION tivation in India annually (Task Force 1983).


Further, in Andhra Pradesh, the rapid loss of
The United Nations Conference on Environment forests in recent times, from 1993 to 1995, esti-
and Development (UNCED) identified tropical mated to be 3822 km2, is mainly due to deforesta-
deforestation in general, and slash and burn agri- tion and shifting cultivation (SFR 1997). There is
culture in particular, as global environmental con- uncertainty about carbon stocks in plants and soils
cerns. Biomass burning associated with shifting in terrestrial ecosystems (Post et al. 1990). Tropi-
cultivation in the tropics is a major contributor cal forests hold 20–100 times more carbon per unit
of greenhouse gases (Andreae 1991). Some 240 area than agricultural lands (Houghton 1991).
million ha of closed forests and 170 million ha of Changes in land use, such as clearing forests
open forests are thought to be associated with some of existing vegetation or savanna, contributes to
form of shifting cultivation. This is approximately the carbon release in two ways: (i) decomposi-
30% of global arable land, which gives an idea of tion and oxidation of biomass from aboveground
the enormous size of the area affected. It is esti- and belowground materials; and (ii) oxidation
mated that 10 000 km2 is affected by shifting cul- and mineralization of soil organic carbon and
humic substances contained in the soil (Lal et al.
1996). The carbon released through oxidation of
*Author to whom correspondence should be the biomass makes a direct contribution to
addressed. total CO2 emissions. Carbon dioxide is released
Received 19 April 2000. by subsequent decay of trees and other unburnt
Accepted 14 February 2001. debris and, with soil organic matter (SOM),
498 V. Krishna Prasad et al.

accounts for about one-quarter of the total carbon water balance. The submodels provide information
released in deforested areas (Detwiler & Hall on plant litter inputs and climatic variables for
1988). soil organic matter computations. Plant growth
Forest clearing also has several ecological is expressed as a function of growing season
implications. Forest clearing uncouples the nutri- precipitation. Details of the century agroeco-
ent cycle resulting in potentially large nutrient system model are discussed by Metherell et al.
losses from forests. Although there has been a (1993).
large amount of data collected with respect to lab-
oratory and field studies on ecosystem dynamics
following fire and shifting cultivation (from
METHODS
different types of ecosystems all over the globe),
in India such studies are limited to a particular
Study area
type of ecosystem (Ramakrishnan 1992). In
order to explore the possible responses of forest The study area forms the hilly northern part of the
ecosystems to various land use practices, such as East Godavari District (Eastern Ghats), Andhra
shifting cultivation, simulation models play an Pradesh, India (Fig. 1). The area is popularly called
important role. Studies with respect to modeling Agency and constitutes the Rampa Revenue Divi-
ecosystem dynamics caused by shifting cultivation sion with seven ‘mandals’. A mandal is a political
over different ecosystems gain importance in boundary of an area below the district level,
the context of increasing deforestation rates and consisting of a few hundred square kilometers.
reduced revisit periods during shifting cultivation The forests of the study area are southern dry
cycles. mixed deciduous forests (type 5A/C3; group 5,
In the present study, an attempt has been made subgroup 5A) and southern tropical forests (group
to study forest cover dynamics over shifting culti- 6, subgroup 6A) as classified by Champion &
vation areas in tropical dry deciduous forests using Seth (1968). Of the 30 series recognized and
the century agroecosystem model (version 4.0). described by Gaussen’s holistic system of vegeta-
The century ecosystem model was developed tion (Gaussen 1959; 1973), the dominant forests
by Parton et al. (1987) for simulation of produc- of the study area correspond to the Terminalia-
tion, decomposition and carbon storage in grass- Anogeissus-Cleistanthes collinus series (series 9). The
lands, with a major focus on soil organic matter other major species include Xylia xylocarpa
dynamics, carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus and (Roxb.) Taub., Dillenia pentagyna (Roxb.),
sulfur biogeochemistry. The century model has Mangifera indica L., Strychnos nuxvomica L., Ptero-
been modified for forests by Sanford et al. (1991) carpus marsupium Roxb., Ficus tinctoria Forst.f.,
and has been well applied over different forest Pavetta indica L., Canthium parviflorum Lam.,
ecosystems to simulate forest cover dynamics Chloroxylon swietenia DC, Lannea coromandelica
(Pulliam et al. 1997). The model is composed of (Houtt.) Merr., Macaranga peltata (Roxb.) Muell-
five organic matter pools, two of which represent Arg., Mitragyna parviflora (Roxb.) Korth. and
litter or crop residues and the remaining three Grewia tilaefolia Vahl. In addition, scrub forests
representing soil organic matter. The soil organic contain species of Carissa spinarum L., Zizyphus
matter is divided into three fractions: (i) an active oenoplia (L.) Mill., Phoenix loureirii Kunth.,
fraction, which has a rapid turnover rate and con- Dichrostachys cinerea (L.) Wt. &.Arn., Prosopis
sists of microbial biomass and metabolites; (ii) a cineraria L.Druce., Acacia nilotica (L.) Willd.ex
slow fraction, with an intermediate turnover time, Del., Randia dumetorum (Retz.) Poir. and Cordia
which represents stablized decomposition prod- dichotoma Forst. f. The parent rocks of the study
ucts; and (iii) a passive fraction, which represents area are khondalites and charnockites. The soils are
the highly stablized, recalcitrant organic matter. classified as fine loamy typic haplustalfs at the sites
First order rate constants, depending on soil of moderately dense vegetation and loamy skeletal
temperature and moisture, are used to represent lithic/typic ustochrepts at the sites of sparse vege-
the decomposition rates. The century model has tation (NRSA 1994). The terrain is hilly and the
submodels for estimating plant growth and soil elevation ranges from 150 m to 1600 m.
Century ecosystem modelling 499

INDIA

ANDHRA PRADESH

Hyderabad

Rampa Agency
1 1. Y.Ramavaram Mandal
2. Maredumulli Mandal
3. Devipatnam Mandal
2
4. Rampachodavaram Mandal
6
1 5. Addaugala Mandal
4
3 6. Gangavaram Mandal
5
7. Rajavommangl Mandal

Fig. 1. Location map. East Godavari District

Shifting cultivation in the study area parameters used for the initialization are shown in
Tables 1–3. The maximum and minimum tem-
The local inhabitants of the study area practice
peratures were obtained by averaging the daily
shifting cultivation locally known as ‘podu’. The
maximum and minimum temperature for individ-
practice consists of clearing the forests during
ual months over a period of 50 years (which were
November and December, allowing the felled
available for the study area from the Indian
biomass to dry until early March or the end of May.
Meteorological Department). Data pertaining to
The biomass is consequently burnt for clearing of
site-specific parameters for soil and plant values,
land before sowing. Mixed cropping is preferred
including litter, above and belowground carbon
and harvesting starts by October. After harvesting,
and nitrogen, and leaf, branch and stem carbon and
the plot is abandoned and another patch is selected
nitrogen were obtained from previous studies
to start the cycle again. The average shifting cul-
(Krishna Prasad et al. 1998a,b,c, 2000). Since data
tivation cycle in the study area is approximately
with respect to fine root and coarse root compo-
12 years; however, at some of the sites the cycle has
nents were not available for the study area, we used
been reduced down to less than 2.5–3.0 years.
data obtained from the studies of Singh et al.
(1992) for typical dry deciduous forests. The adop-
Model initiation
tion of these values in the present study area is jus-
The model was initialized using site-specific infor- tifiable, as the other parameters, such as above and
mation on climate, soils and forest ecosystems. The belowground biomass and nutrient components,
500 V. Krishna Prasad et al.

Table 1 Climate inputs Table 3 Tree parameters used for dry deciduous
forests in century model simulation
Temperature Precipitation
Maximum Minimum (cm month–1) Carbon : nitrogen ratios for different components
Min Max Initial
January 30.2 26.5 1.15 Leaves 30 40.0 40.6
February 31.0 21.4 1.60 Branch 120 180.0 84.0
March 33.6 24.2 1.15 Stem 150 300 155
April 36.7 25.6 1.44 Fine root 40.0 60.0 76.0
May 37.8 27.8 6.78 Coarse root 150 300 155
June 37.7 28.3 1.56
Carbon allocation fraction
July 33.0 26.2 9.79
Juvenile Mature
August 32.5 26.0 21.8
Leaves 0.25 0.34
September 32.2 25.3 14.4
Branch 0.10 0.11
October 31.9 24.9 17.1
Stem 0.30 0.22
November 30.2 22.1 8.94
Fine root 0.25 0.25
December 28.5 19.8 0.29
Coarse root 0.10 0.08
Monthly death rate fraction for forest components
Leaves 0.95
Table 2 Site-specific parameters used for dry decidu- Fine roots 0.030
ous forests in century model simulation Fine branches 0.014
Large wood 0.0010
Soils Coarse roots 0.0020
Sand 0.24
Silt 0.22
Clay 0.54
Bulk density (gm-2) 1.3
pH 5.1
the initial amounts of carbon, nitrogen and soil
Initial plant values organic matter (SOM) pools (Parton et al. 1989
Surface litter (carbon : nitrogen ratio) 43.0 Burke et al. 1990). In the model it has been
Surface residue (gm-2) 230 assumed that the initial cycle of shifting cultiva-
Aboveground nitrogen (gm-2) 83.2 tion started in 1961, with a repeated revisit cycle
Belowground carbon (gm-2) 2693
of every 12 years up to 2030. The management
Belowground nitrogen (gm-2) 17.8
Live leaf carbon (gm-2) 375 history of shifting cultivation followed in the
Live leaf nitrogen (gm-2) 12.02 present study is based on information from local
Live branch carbon (gm-2) 3702 tribes in the study area and historical land use
Live branch nitrogen (gm-2) 60.3 records. The results simulated in 1960 were taken
Live stem carbon (gm-2) 6400 as a starting point for future simulations. The base-
Live stem nitrogen (gm-2) 49.1 line changes in forest dynamics have been modeled
Live fine root carbon (gm-2) 540.0 without changing the CO2 and climate conditions,
Live fine root nitrogen (gm-2) 49.1 and have been modeled using the site-specific para-
Live coarse root carbon (gm-2) 2010 meters (Tables 1–3). In the present study, we did
Live coarse root nitrogen(gm-2) 27.2 not consider the climatic variability due to the low
levels of variability in the meteorological datasets
over a period of years. Based on meteorological
records maintained during 1901–1982 for 73 sta-
agreed well with the studies of Singh et al. (1992). tions in India, studies by Lal et al. (1993) suggest
The monthly death rate fractions reported for that there is no regular warming or regular cooling
typical dry deciduous forests by Metherell et al. trend for the entire region. Of the 73 stations, 30
(1993) have been adopted. Using long-term cli- stations have shown warming trends and 6 have
matic averages, the model has been run to equi- shown significant cooling trends. Interestingly,
librium under forest vegetation, so as to establish most of the areas have shown no significant trend
Century ecosystem modelling 501

in temperature change, and the study area is one during 1960. One of the important features
of them. Field studies on the response of forest noticed in the simulation study was the initial
parameters to changing climatic variables in increase in soil organic carbon, followed by a
general, and responses due to elevated CO2 condi- decline during all the shifting cultivation cycles
tions, have not been attempted for tropical decid- (Fig. 2). The century model results suggested
uous forests, and these are needed for validation of that during the 70-year period there was an
the model outputs. Considering this, in the approximately 239 tC loss in soil organic matter.
present study we ignore climatic variability and Although in between every cycle there was an
possible effects on simulating forest cover dynam- increase in soil carbon due to fallow regrowth, the
ics over a period of time. effect of repeated shifting cultivation was a con-

RESULTS

Nifrogen (g/m2)
We simulated the forest cover dynamics of tro-
pical deciduous forests under the influence of
repeated shifting cultivation practices from 1961
onwards, with a repeated revisit cycle of every 12
years up to 2030 (Figs 2–8). Baseline changes in
forest cover dynamics that were predicted to occur
over every 12 year period were caused mainly by
repeated disruption of the plant–soil ecosystem. Fig. 4. Total nitrogen in the forest system (projected
The steady state equilibrium was assumed to occur figures).
Carbon (g/m2)
Carbon (g/m2)

Fig. 5. Total carbon in the forest system (projected


figures).

Fig. 2. Soil organic matter: carbon (projected figures).


Carbon (g/m2) per month
Nifrogen (g/m2)

Fig. 3. Nitrogen in the forest system live components Fig. 6. Monthly carbon production in the forest
(projected figures). system (projected figures).
502 V. Krishna Prasad et al.

according to the 12 year revisit cycle meant that


the total forest carbon showed an overall loss of
more than 78 tC ha-1 up to the year 2030.
Carbon (g/m2)

Carbon in the forest system live components,


which was approximately 63.4 tC ha-1 during
1960, was reduced to 17.8 tC ha-1 in 2030,
suggesting a loss of approximately 45.6 tC ha-1
(Fig. 7). From the results, it can be seen that due
to the repeated agricultural cycle at the sites,
carbon and nitrogen levels in the soil and the forest
Fig. 7. Carbon in the forest system live components never returned to the initial levels, probably due
(projected figures). to the repeated disruption of plant soil dynamics.
In contrast to carbon in the soil organic matter,
total nitrogen and forest system carbon, the net
carbon production (Fig. 7) and nitrogen uptake
Nitrogen (g/m2) per month

in the forest system (Fig. 8) showed an overall


increase over the simulation period. An increase
in carbon productivity from 49 g m-2 month-1
during 1960 to 120 g m-2 month-1 during
the initial forest cut and burning in 1962
was observed. However, carbon productivity stabi-
lized at 70 g m-2 month-1 during the year 2030, at
a slightly higher level than the initial value.
This is similar to the levels of nitrogen uptake
in the forest ecosystem, which increased up to
Fig. 8. Monthly nitrogen production in the forest 1.7 g m-2 month-1 from an initial level of
system (projected figures). 0.7 g m-2 month-1, and stabilized to approximately
of 0.9 g m-2 month-1. This slight increase in carbon
stant overall decline in soil carbon. This continu- productivity and nitrogen uptake in the forests
ous loss may be attributed to increased decompo- has been attributed to the increased availability
sition due to forest clearing and increased leaching of soil organic carbon during the initial forest
in the active pool. clearing and to the nutrients made available
Nitrogen in live forest system components and during the clear cuts and burning.
total nitrogen in the forest system showed an
initial increase(Figs 3 and 4) followed by a decline.
DISCUSSION
The total nitrogen, which was 344.3 g m-2 during
1960, dropped to less than 318.3 g m-2 during
Soil organic carbon dynamics
2030 (Fig. 3).
The total carbon stock of the original forest in The initial increase in soil organic carbon when the
the study area was 63.56 tC ha-1 in 1960. Most of forests are initially cut and burnt has been attr-
the loss in carbon stock results from land prepara- ibuted to various causes. Nutrients are stored in
tion prior to the first cultivation for the shifting organic forms (nitrogen, phosphorus and sulfur)
cultivation practice, during which forests are and held in the mineral form on the exchange sites
cleared. The century model predicted a loss of of the SOM (Palm et al. 1996). After the slash and
66 tC ha-1 from the total forest from the initial burn, the organic inputs to the soil come from the
forest of 118.5 tC ha-1. During the initial forest cut dead roots of the cut vegetation and the above-
and burn the loss was approximately 52.0 tC ha-1 ground biomass that is partially burnt or unburnt.
(Fig. 5). Although secondary successional species Furthermore, decaying roots from felled and
grew during the years following a slash and burn, burned forest vegetation may contribute to
the cropping and abandonment of the fallow land initial increase in soil organic matter following
Century ecosystem modelling 503

agricultural practices and subsequent fallows. cylindrica, and also to faster decomposition due to
Similar results were reported by Ewel et al. (1981) the openness of these sites.
from a carefully controlled slash and burn experi- The decline in carbon content following forest
ment in Costarica, and by Araki (1993) in clearing for cultivation may occur due to three
Northern Zambia. The fine roots decompose factors: (i) high topsoil temperature leading to
rapidly, producing an immediate effect on nutri- higher decomposition rates; (ii) lower inputs; and
ent release and labile fractions of soil organic (iii) increased soil organic carbon oxidation caused
matter (Veldcamp 1994). by tillage (Tinker et al. 1996). In addition to the
The general model of the slash and burn system in situ oxidation of soil organic carbon, accelerated
is that decomposition increases following forest erosion increases soil organic carbon loss from the
clearing because of changes in microclimate (Palm site by selectively removing the carbon rich surface
et al. 1996). The soil organic submodel of the horizon. Several studies (Ayanaba et al. 1976; Ewel
century is based on multiple compartments of et al. 1981; Bonde et al. 1991a; Ramakrishnan
soil organic matter, and include three soil organic 1992) have followed changes in soil organic matter
matter pools: (i) active; (ii) slow; and (iii) passive. following conversion of tropical forests to agricul-
The active pool represents soil microbes and ture. A synthesis of these studies indicates a
microbial products and has a turnover time of decrease of 17–27% in soil organic matter in the
months to a few years, depending on the environ- top 40 cm during the cropping phase of shifting
ment and sand content. The slow pool includes cultivation, and estimates that it would take 35
resistant plant material derived from the structural years to recover the SOM content of the primary
pool, and soil-stablized microbial products derived forest (Detwiler 1986). A carbon loss of 19.38%
from active and surface microbial pools, and has a predicted by the century model for tropical dry
turnover time of 20–50 years. The passive pool is deciduous forests is in accordance with these
very resistant to decomposition and includes phys- results.
ically and chemically stablized soil organic matter, Declines in soil organic carbon and microbial
with a turnover time of 400–2000 years (Parton biomass carbon associated with land clearing and
et al. 1989). In addition to these pools, there are subsequent management have been reported in
others, which include above- and belowground several studies (Lal et al. 1986; Persson & Mattson
litter pools and a surface microbial pool that is 1988; Follett & Schimel 1989; Srivastava &
associated with decomposing surface litter. Singh 1989; Post & Mann 1990). In addition, a
In the century model, the major impact of literature review suggests that the observed losses
fire is to increase the root to shoot ratio and the of soil organic carbon from managed ecosystems
carbon : nitrogen ratio of the live shoots and roots, are greater in semi arid environments than in
remove vegetation, and to return nutrients during humid lowlands. At various Tropical Soil Bio-
the years when fires occur (Ojima et al. 1990). The logical and Fertility (TSBF) program sites,
fraction of products from the decomposition of the Woomer et al. 1994) noted that land disturbance
active pool is lost as leached organic matter, and resulted in decreased soil microbial biomass and
leaching of organic matter is a function of the rate increased turnover rates of soil organic matter.
of decay for active soil organic matter and the clay Although most studies report a general trend in
content of the soil. The decreasing levels of soil loss of soil carbon following the use of a shifting
organic carbon during the fallow regrowth period cultivation cycle (Srivastava & Singh 1989; Post &
predicted in the present study by the century Mann 1990; Ramakrishnan 1992), it is difficult
model are consistent with the results obtained by to generalize the status of soil organic matter soil
Ramakrishnan 1992) in a study of shifting culti- carbon. With respect to the dynamics of soil
vation ecosystems in early successional fallows up organic carbon in the shifting cultivation sites,
to approximately 5 years, at Burnihat in north- many variations have been reported, and stability
eastern India. This trend is attributed to a low in soil organic matter within such sites is not uni-
return of litter during the initial colonization and versal. A detailed comparison of different cycles
regrowth of the vegetation, due to successional under different ecosystems was discussed by Palm
species such as Eupatorium odoratum and Imperata et al. (1996) and Kotto-Same et al. (1997). Ayanaba
504 V. Krishna Prasad et al.

et al. (1976) found losses of 10–30% in soil organic leaching and denitrification are few because
matter following two years of maize cultivation, of methodological difficulties. Leaching and
with and without return of residues, compared denitrification have been measured as 43 kg ha-1
with a bush fallow. Andriesse & Schelhaas (1987) year-1 and 50 kg ha-1 year-1, respectively, in
reported soil carbon losses from slash and burn to cleared areas as opposed to 14 kg ha-1 year-1 and
a depth of 75 cm as high as 21 t ha-1 in Thailand 4 kg ha-1 year-1 in an undisturbed forest (Jordan et
and 15 t ha-1 in Sri Lanka. Woomer et al. (1994) al. 1983).
reported soil carbon losses of 8 t ha-1 year-1 due to Therefore, it is clear that any predictive under-
slash and burn of coastal sand dunes in Mozam- standing of the losses or gains in SOM must, in
bique. Ramakrishnan & Toky (1981) reported that addition to amounts of inputs, take in to account
soil organic carbon contents were greater in 30 year clay content, soil type, climatic conditions and
fallows than in plots affected by 5 year shifting management following clearing (e.g. length of
cultivation in north-east India, and that the soil cropping and fallow stages, tillage and residue
carbon in the longer fallows was subject to greater management), which are all incorporated in the
losses during land clearing and cultivation. century ecosystem model.
Sanchez et al. (1983) found a decrease of 30% in
soil organic carbon in one year following clearing
Nitrogen dynamics
and burning an ultisol in the Amazon. Bonde et al.
(1991a) in contrast found increase in total soil Although forest soils contain large amounts of
carbon after years under tropical pasture in the nitrogen, it is generally in an unavailable form,
Brazilian Amazon. A detailed study in equatorial and must first be mineralized (i.e. converted
forest zones of west and central Africa, particularly to nitrate nitrogen or ammonia). Pioneering
in Southern Cameroon, comparing different land researchers like Eneroth (1928) proposed that
uses along slash and burn chronosequences illus- burning has a favorable effect on nitrification.
trate that bulk carbon loss in the forests resulted During the process of burning, only the microbes
from the clearing of natural vegetation, and that in the surface soil are destroyed, while those at
during traditional long fallows, the soil organic greater depths survive and soon repopulate the
matter content was not greatly affected (Woomer surface soil. As a result of burning, the number
et al. 1996). Woomer et al. (1996), observed that of microbes in the surface layers of the soil
soil carbon pools remained relatively stable increases (Ahlgren & Ahlgren 1965). Burning also
throughout a slash and burn cycle, decreasing from has a favorable effect on the acidity and tempera-
76 to 67 t ha-1, within four years in primary forest ture of the soil, activating microbial activity. In the
and young fallow, and returning to initial levels century model, the nitrogen submodel has the
within 13 additional years of natural regrowth. same structure as that of carbon submodel. The net
They also noted that, without appreciable loss of mineralization of nitrogen results mainly from the
soil organic carbon from the soils, the forest ecosys- decomposition of metabolic residues and from
tem carbon losses might be massive. active, slow and passive pools, based on the
Differences in SOM soil carbon levels in differ- carbon : nitrogen ratio of the state variables and the
ent land use practices are partially attributable to microbial respiration loss for each flow. Similar to
differences in the amounts of inputs and soil tex- soil organic carbon, a review of the literature sug-
tural properties, such as variations in clay content. gests that there are large variations in nitrogen
The Brazilian oxisol has a clay content of more mineralization rates following forest clearing
than 60% (Bonde et al. 1991a), while that of during different phases of cultivation. Several
Nigerian alfisol (Ayanaba et al. 1976) and the studies indicate that initial rapid mineralization
Peruvian ultisol (Sanchez et al. 1983) is below rates are associated with clearing and burning, and
20%. In general, clayier soils retain a higher per- are followed by a reduction in mineralization rates
centage of organic inputs (Sorenson 1981). Fur- (Palm et al. 1996). Mueller-Harvey et al. (1985)
thermore, although leaching is thought to be a found nitrogen mineralizaton in the first year
major factor in causing losses of nutrients follow- following clearing to be 39 kg ha-1 month-1, three
ing clearing, studies on actual measurements of times higher than in the second year. Similarly,
Century ecosystem modelling 505

studies by Matson et al. (1987) found a 45% min- efficient and sustainable than slash and burn agri-
eralization rate, which was higher than the rate in culture.
a secondary forest. The results obtained for nitro-
gen dynamics in the present study closely follow
those for soil organic carbon, with an initial ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
increase followed by decline. However, Saxena &
Ramakrishnan (1986) found a two-fold increase The authors are grateful to the century ecosys-
in nitrification rates following clearing, but a tem model group, Colorado State University, Col-
decrease to less than half that in the forest follow- orado, USA for providing the model. V. Krishna
ing burning. Prasad and Yogesh Kant are grateful to the ISRO-
GBP for providing the fellowship.
Forest carbon dynamics
When virgin forests are cleared for various pur- REFERENCES
poses, the carbon pool most vulnerable to loss is
the above-ground biomass, as observed in simula- Ahlgren I. F. & Ahlgren C. E. (1965) Effects
tions for the present study. Similar findings have of prescribed burning on soil microorganisms in a
been reported by Kauffman et al. (1994) in Brazil Minnesota Jack Pine Forest. Ecology 46: 304–310.
when Amazonian forest was converted to pasture, Andreae M. O. (1991) Biomass burning: Its
history, use, and distribution and its impact on the
Saldarriaga et al. (1988) in the upper Rio Negro of
environmental quality and global climate. In:
South America during long-term forest recovery, Biomass Burning: Atmospheric, Climatic and Bios-
Toky & Ramakrishnan (1983a,b) in secondary suc- pheric Implications. (ed. J. S. Levine) pp. 1–21.
cession studies following slash and burning in Cambridge Press, Cambridge.
North-eastern India, and by Ewel et al. (1981) in Andriesse J. P. & Schelhass R. M. (1987) A
Costa Rica. monitoring study on nutrient cycles in soils used
for shifting cultivation under various climatic
conditions in tropical Asia III. The effects of
Productivity and fallow recovery land clearing through burning on fertility level.
The productivity of the secondary forest was Agriculture Ecosystem Environment 19: 311–332.
comparatively higher when compared to the Araki S. (1993) Effect on soil organic matter and
original forest of 1960. The slight increase in soil fertility of the chitemene slash-and-burn prac-
tice used in northern Zambia. In: Soil Organic
the rate of production observed for the forests in
Matter Dynamics and Sustainability of Tropical Agri-
the study area has been attributed to the faster culture (eds K. Mulongoy & R. Merckx) pp.
regrowth of species such as Holarrhena pubescens and 367–375. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Xylia xylocarpa in the study area. Similar conclu- Ayanaba A., Tuckwell S. B. & Jenasson D.
sions have been drawn in studies of shifting culti- S. (1976) The effects of clearing and cropping on
vation areas in north-east India (Ramakrishnan organic reserves and biomass of tropical forest
1993). soils. Soil Biology and Biogeochemistry. 8: 519–525.
From the results it is evident that secondary Bonde T. A., Rosswall T. & Victoria R. L.
vegetation is disrupted repeatedly due to revisit (1991a) The dynamics of soil organic matter and
periods for shifting cultivation purposes. These soil microbial biomass following clear felling and
periods are gradually decreasing to 2–5 years. cropping of a tropical rainforest soil in the central
Therefore, it may be concluded that the failure of Amazon. In: Size and Dynamics of Active Soil Organic
Matter Fraction as Influenced by Soil Management.
many current slash and burn systems is a result of
Linkoping Studies in Arts and Science. (ed. T. A.
long-term disturbance in the soil vegetation con- Bonde) pp. 63. Linkoping, Sweden.
tinuum through increased cropping and decreas- Burke I. C., Schimel D. S., Yonker C. M.,
ing fallow periods. An understanding of this Parton W. J., Joyce L. A. & Lavenroth
process, using quantitative ecosystem modeling W. K. (1990) Regional modeling of grassland bio-
with respect to vegetation dynamics, will help in geochemistry using GIS. Landscape Ecology. 4:
the design of agricultural systems that are more 45–54.
506 V. Krishna Prasad et al.

Champion H. G. & Seth S. K. (1968) A revised in shifting cultivation areas of tropical dry decid-
survey of the forest types of India. Government of uous forests. Asia Pacific Journal of Remote Sensing
India, New Delhi, pp. 297–299. 10: 27–32.
Detwiler R. P. (1986) Land use change and the Krishna Prasad V., Rajagopal T., Yogesh
global carbon cycle: the role of tropical soils. Bio- K. A. N. T. & Badarinath K. V. S. (1998c)
geochemistry 2: 67–93. Quantification of nutrient dynamics after fire
Detwiler R. P. & Hall C. A. S. (1988) Tropical in tropical dry deciduous forests (Eastern Ghats).
forests and the global carbon cycle. Science 239: Journal of Society of Indian Foresters 36: 120–124.
42–49. Krishna Prasad V., Yogesh K. A. N. T. &
Eneroth O. (1928) Referat: Beitrage Zur Kenntnis Badarinath K. V. S. (2000) Quantifying short-
der Einwirkung Des Schlagabbrennens Auf Den Boden. term carbon dynamics from land use changes
Skogshogskolan, Stockholm. using satellite data – a case study from Rampa
Ewel J., Buresh C., Brown B., Price N. & Forests (Eastern Ghats) India. Geocarto International
Raich J. (1981) Slash and burn impacts on 15: 69–75.
a Costa Rican wet forest site. Ecology 62: 816– Lal M., Bhaskaran B. & Chakraborty B.
829. (1993) Actual and anticipated changes in India’s
Follett R. F. & Schimel D. S. (1989) Effect of climate. In: Global Warming Concern for Tomorrow
tillage practices on microbial biomass dynamics. (ed. M. Lal) Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi.
Soil Science Society America Journal 53: 1091– Lal R., Kimble J. & Follett R. (1988) Pedos-
1096. pheric processes and the carbon cycle. In: Soil
Gaussen H. (1959) The vegetation maps. Institute Processes and the Carbon Cycle (eds R. Lal, J. M.
of French Pondicherry, India. Kimble, R. F. Follett & B. A. Stewart) pp. 1–8.
Gaussen H., Meher-Homji V. M., Legris P., CRC Press, New York.
Blasco F., Delcourt A., Gupta R. K. & Lal R., Sanchez P. A. & Cummings R. W. Jr
Troy J. P. (1973) Sheet Orissa. International map (1986) Land Clearing and Development in the
of vegetation and environmental conditions. Inst. Tropics. Advances in Soil Science. 13: 31–92.
Fr. Pondichery. Trav. Sect. Sci. Technical Hors Serie Matson P. A., Vitousek P. M., Ewel J. J.,
no. 19. Mazzarino M. J. & Robertson G. P. (1987)
Houghton R. A. (1991) Tropical deforestation Nitrogen transformations following tropical forest
and atmospheric carbon dioxide. Climatic Change. felling and burning on a volcanic soil. Ecology. 68:
19: 99–118. 491–502.
Jordan C., Caskey W., Escalante G., Metherell A. K., Harding L. A., Cole C. V.
Herrera R., Montagnini E., Todd R. & & Parton W. J. (1993) century Soil Organic
Uhl C. (1983) Nitrogen dynamics during con- Matter Model Environment. Technical Documenta-
version of primary Amazonian rain forest to slash- tion Agroecosystem, Version 4.0. Great Plains System
and-burn agriculture. Oikos 40: 131–139. Research Unit, Technical Report no. 4. USDA-
Kauffman J. B., Cummings D. L. & Ward ARS, Fort Collins, Colorado.
D. E. (1994) Relationships of fire, biomass and Mueller-Harvey M., Jouo A. S. R. & Wild A.
nutrient dynamics along a vegetation gradient in (1985) Soil Organic C, N, and P after forest clear-
the Brazilian Cerrado. Journal of Ecology 82: ance in Nigeria: mineralization rates and spatial
519–531. variability. Journal of Soil Science 36: 585–591.
Kotto-Same J., Woomer P. L., Appolinaire Nrsa (1994) Land use planning Atlast of East
M. & Louis Z. (1997) Carbon dynamics in slash- Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh. Land Use,
and-burn agriculture and land use alternatives of Cartography and Map Printing Group, National
the humid forest zone in Cameroon. Agriculture, Remote Sensing Agency (NRSA), Balanagar,
Ecosystems and Environment 65: 245–256. Hyderabad, India.
Krishna Prasad V., Rajagopal T., Yogesh Ojima D. S., Parton W. J., Schimel D. S. &
K. A. N. T. & Badarinath K. V. S. (1998a) Owensby C. E. (1990) Simulated impacts of
Biomass estimations and carbon storage of tropi- annual burning on prairie ecosystems. In: Fire in
cal deciduous forests (Eastern Ghats). Indian North American Prairies, Norman (eds S. L. Collins
Journal of Applied and Pure Biology 13: 153–161. & L.Wallace). University of Oklahoma Press,
Krishna Prasad V., Rajagopal T., Yogesh Oklahoma.
K. A. N. T. & Badarinath K. V. S. (1998b) Palm C. J., Swift M. & Woomer L. P. (1996)
Vegetation dynamics and organizational changes Soil biological dynamics in slash and burn
Century ecosystem modelling 507

agriculture. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment. organic matter dynamics and forest production in
58: 61–74. the Luquillo experimental Forest, Puerto Rico:
Parton W. J., Sanford R. L., Sanchez P. A. Results of simulation modelling. Biotropica 23:
& Stewart J. W. B. (1989) Modeling soil 364–372.
organic matter dynamics in tropical soils. In: Saxena K. G. & Ramakrishnan P. S. (1986)
Dynamics of Soil Organic Matter in Tropical Ecosys- Nitrification during slash and burn agriculture
tems. (eds D. C. Coleman, J. M. Oades & G. (Jhum) in Northeastern India. Acta Oecologia 7:
Vehara) Nif TAL Project, Honolulu. 307–319.
Parton W. J., Schimel D. S., Cole C. V. & Singh L., Singh K. P. & Singh J. S. (1992)
Ojima D. S. (1987) Analysis of factors control- Biomass, productivity and nutrient cycling in four
ling soil organic matter levels in Great Plains contrasting forest ecosystems of India. In: Tropical
Grasslands. Soil Science Society of America Journal 51: Ecosystems: Ecology and Management (eds K. P. Singh
1137–1179. & J. S. Singh) pp. 415–430. Wiley Eastern, New
Persson J. & Mattson L. (1988) Soil carbon Delhi.
changes and size estimates in different organic Sorenson L. H. (1981) Carbon-nitrogen relation-
carbon fractions in Swedish long-term small plot ships during the humification of cellulose in soils
experiment. Swedish Journal of Agricultural containing different amounts of clay. Soil Biology
Research. 18: 19–12. and Biochemistry. 13: 313–321.
Post W. M. & Mann L. K. (1990) Changes in soil Srivastava S. C. & Singh J. S. (1989) Effect of
organic carbon and nitrogen as a result of cultiva- cultivation on microbial carbon and nitrogen in
tion. In: Soils and the Greenhouse Effect (ed. A. E. dry tropical forest soil. Biology and Fertility of Soils.
Bouwmann) pp. 23–35. John Wiley and Sons, 8: 343–348.
Chichester. State of Forest Report (1997) State of Forest
Post W. M., Peng T., Emmanuel W. R., King Report. Ministry of Forests and Environment and
A. W., Dale V. H. & Deangelis D. L. (1990) Forests, Dehradun, India.
The global carbon cycle. American Scientist 78: Task Force. (1983) Report of the Task Force on Shift-
310–336. ing Cultivation in India. Ministry of Agriculture,
Pulliam W. M., Parton W. J., Ojima D. S., New Delhi.
Sanford R. L. & Homann P. S. (1997) Imple- Tinker B. P., Ingram J. S. I. & Struwe S.
mentation of the century Ecosystem Model for Forests. (1996) Effects of slash-and-burn agriculture
National Resource Ecology Laboratory, Colorado and deforestation on climate change. Agriculture,
State University, Colorado. Ecosystems and Environment. 58: 13–22.
Ramakrishnan P. S. (1992) Shifting Agriculture Toky O. P. & Ramakrishnan P. S. (1983a)
and Sustainable Development. An Interdisciplinary Secondary succession following slash and burn
Study from North-Eastern India. Man and Biosphere agriculture in north-eastern India. I. Biomass, lit-
Series, Vol. 10.UNESCO Publications, Paris. terfall and productivity. Journal of Ecology. 72:
Ramakrishnan P. S. & Toky O. P. (1981) Soil 735–745.
nutrient status of hill agroecosystems and recov- Toky O. P. & Ramakrishnan P. S. (1983b) Sec-
ery pattern after slash and burn agriculture (jhum) ondary Succession following slash and burn agri-
in northeastern India. Plant and Soil 60: 41–64. culture in north-eastern India. II. Nutrient
Saldarriaga J. G., West D. C., Tharp M. L. Cycling. Journal of Ecology 71: 747–757.
& Uhl C. (1988) Long-term chronosequence of Veldcamp E. (1994) Organic carbon turnover in
forest succession in the upper Rio Negro of colum- the three tropical soils under pasture after defor-
bia and Venezuela. Journal of Ecology. 76: 938– estation. Soil Science Society of America 58: 175–180.
958. Woomer P. L., Martin A., Albrecht A.,
Sanchez . P. A., Villachica J. H. & Bandy Resck D. V. S. & Scharpenseel H. W.
D. E. (1983) Soil fertility dynamics after clearing (1994) The importance and management of soil
a tropical rainforest in Peru. Soil Science Society of organic matter in the tropics. In: The biological
America Journal 47: 1171–1178. management of tropical soil fertility (eds P. L. Woomer
Sanford R. L. J. R., Parton W. J., Ojima D. & M. J. Swift). A Wiley Sayce Publication,
S. & Lodge D. J. (1991) Hurricane effects on soil New York.

You might also like