You are on page 1of 52

The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

By

Mohammed Alzajali

A Dissertation

Submitted to

Coventry University

Submitted for BA(Human Resource Management)

Under the Supervision of Dr.RandhirAuluck

August 2013

Abstract
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

This research is based on the plausible relationship between the leadership

and the motivation of employees which can be created in result of proper leadership

skills. The myth of born leaders was discussed in the research and apart from that it

was also focused that how motivation can be gained from the leadership behaviour.

Motivational factors were discussed so that it can be said as how important

leadership is for the motivation of employees. Leadership theories came to the

discussion to show which style of leadership is more useful for an organization to

further promote motivation.Findings also showed that effective leadership styles

such as, transformational and situational leadership approaches could constitute an

important factor to increase employee motivation. Suggestions for future leadership

practice and further studies are included in the study.

(2)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Acknowledgements

Having chosen a topic on Flexible working, working on this dissertation was

one of the most challenging parts of my academic life. Without the support,

guidance, and patience of various people in my life, the dissertation would not have

come to completion. The following are just some of those I owe my gratitude to in

completing this dissertation:

 The first is my supervisor, who, in spite of his professional and academic

commitments, accepted to supervise my work. His knowledge, commitment,

and wisdom motivated and inspired me.

 My friends and colleagues, with whom I undertook the same course,

continued to inspire and motivate me in spite of their academic, professional,

and social commitments

 All my tutors who, by teaching me, enhanced my understanding of accounting

principles and their real life application to businesses

 To my parents who, through their continuous support, believe and

encouragement, helped me complete the work. They unselfishly and lovingly

cared for me.

I dedicate this dissertation to all of them

(3)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Table of Contents

(4)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION

1.1 Introduction

Organizations achieve goals through effective management of available

resources. More often than not, success is pegged on how effectively resources are

managed. The often available resources at the disposal of managers include human

resources, financial resources, informational resources, and physical resources.

Human resources have assumed a fundamental role in assisting organization

achieve success in their endeavors. Conventionally, human resources departments

bring together people with varying skills, abilities, and knowledge. These must be

effectively managed if the organization is to achieve success in its endeavors.

Effective contribution of employees to the organization largely depends on the quality

of human resource management.

Multiple researches have explored Human Resource Management (HRM)

development from its historical context and emphasize existence of a raging debate

between it and management of personnel. According to Lado & Wilson (2009)

historical developments have largely shaped the modern understanding of Human

Resource development. They further emphasize that human resource development

is an international issue and attracts extensive research and controversies.

Further Lado & Wilson (2009) defines human resource management as the

process of managing the workforce within the organization. This process is tasked

with attraction, recruitment, assessment, training as well as reward of staff. At the

same time, human resource management includes an oversight role on

organizational culture and making certain the organization complies with the

employment and labor laws. In organizations where staff wish and are permitted

from a legal perspective to hold collective bargaining discussions, the human

(5)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

resource department acts as the basic liaison with the staff representatives.

On the other hand, Kleiman (2000) mentions that HR originates from the 20th

century human relations movements where researchers documented ways through

which business can increase their value via workforce strategic management.

According to Kleiman (2000) these functions were back then limited to management

of payrolls and administration of benefits. Nonetheless, with the advent of

globalization, consolidation of companies, technological advancement, and extensive

research, human resource in the modern world has turned to focus on other strategic

areas such as looking at prospective mergers and acquisitions, management of staff

talent , planning for succession, handling industrial and issues, as well as bridging

diversity and inclusion issues.

In many start-up corporations, HR is largely done by trained experts.

However, in larger corporations, this work is assigned to dedicated departments and

staff who specialize in functional leadership and human resource tasks.

Consequently, there have emerged training programs in higher learning institutions

purely meant to train managers on duties as human resource leaders.

1.2 Background

One of the outcomes after the recent development in the world is

globalisation. Globalisation is pointing towards the fact that different parts are so

closely interrelated that they gives an impression as if the world is a one big nation.

The possible reason that could be given is that, an earlier difference in different parts

of the world, on the basis of culture and nations is diminishing with the passage of

time, quality is the new concern for the business world, it may sound simple to have

quality but it has diverse meanings which are based on the situation in which it is

getting dealt with (Cohen & Eimicke, 1995). Variety in application of quality leads

(6)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

toward the confusion whose responsibility is it for implementation of quality policies

as these days quality needs to be maintained in each and every part of an

organisation in order to survive in the market. Quality has association with every

aspect of life these days, it can have the application on the way we approach certain

problems and in terms of organization, and how management is approaching

towards the employees. Management approach towards employees can be taken as

the way to handle the work force in an organisation (Cohen & Eimicke, 1995).The

aspect of quality from the employees’ point of view can be taken as level of

motivation in them. As mentioned the application of quality differs with different

situation but the end result would be similar which is productivity or efficiency. In an

organisation quality can be perceived in a different way by different people but the

outcome of having quality in the organisation would probably be the success of an

organisation. The outcome of quality for an organisation will be in several way which

leads from reduction in wastage to increase in the reputation and even to the level of

increase in the revenue of an organization. One aspect of quality for an

organizationis the motivation in the employees who are responsible for realisation of

a plan for an organisation.

Organisational success can be ensured by implementing different policies

and practices, leadership at the top of an organization is an important constituent for

success. Some of the corporate failures as well as loss situations were turned

around by handful of people with their ability to lead from the front by converting

demoralisation to motivation (Weinstein, 2002). Motivation can be created by wide

array of policies but the most common assumed to be the monitory benefit but it can

never be limited to just benefit rather having quality throughout the organisation can

also bring motivation as quality lead to productivity and any individual would be

(7)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

happy to work for an organization that is having a good market standing and position

and would like to remain associated with such organization for as long as possible

(Satish, Deshopande, &Golhar, 2010). This research aims to identify how the

leadership could help in motivating employees in an organization which in turn would

help in maintaining quality in entire organisation.

1.3 Company Profile

Emirates General Petroleum Corporation (Emarat), commencing operations in

1981, is a state-owned downstream marketing and distribution entity. Located in

Dubai, United Arab Emirates, the Corporation owns and operates 180 retail outlets, 8

ground and aviation products and terminals and the largest natural gas pipeline

network in Northern Emirates.

Excellence in customer service results from a strong and dedicated team that

is well prepared to take up the challenges of a competitive global environment where

the only hope that an organization can make a difference or an impact is with the

quality of service. A strong and dedicated team of employees and support staff is

nonetheless a result of only the right level of motivation. The assignment evaluates

how the right leadership can trigger the right level of motivation for the employees to

work better and contribute to the overall productivity of the organization. Leadership

in boosting motivation indicates on the managers, the floor managers, service

managers, customer support managers etc. and the role they play at Ramada in

running a successful customer oriented set up. The following chapters talk about the

relationship between motivation and its connection with leadership while at the same

time how situations can be improved in the organization with the right level of

motivation.

(8)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

1.4 Statement of Problem

“Leadership styles influences the performance of an employee and so the

organisation which is possible after creating motivation, this is the reason for which

leadership plays a bridge role between performance and motivation of employees.”

There are quite a few researches done to identify the reason for performance

improvement but not much has been done so far to find the relationship of motivation

that is created due to leadership and performance of the company. This research will

develop a relationship between leadership and in result of it created motivation.

Globalisation results in broadening of operation beyond the borders where the

organisation initially started and the resultant challenge of this move is that

complexities created as an organisation have to employ local employees. In order to

remove the complexities and to keep the situation in control it is leaders in the

organisation who are supposed to play their role properly. Quality as concern for the

companies need to be managed properly and to gain the quality instead of individual

competence the competence of the whole organisation should be kept in

consideration. To attain the competence of whole organisation each and every

individual is important which means the motivation of each and every individual

should be the aim of an organisation. Apart from that organisational performance is

also the result of coordination among the employees which can also be properly

done if they are motivated to work for an organisation. Technical knowledge is

important for organisational performance but the support of management and

administration of employees is an important factor to consider, where the support

and management is pointing to motivation in employees (Weinstein, 2002). Some of

the reasons for not having good performance by an organisation are that while

(9)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

monitoring the performance some of the essential measures might get neglected like

motivation.

In order to effectively gauge the effectiveness of motivation, it’s important to

have the employees believe in it. As stressed by Satish, Deshopande,

&Golhar(2010), to convince the employees forthe importance of organisational goals,

management must be convinced and committed to the reason of its programs and

be responsive to requests for improvements from their workforce; employees should

receive praise for their efforts; the environmental and wages conditions must be

good. All these factors lead to motivation of employees. Existence of these factors is

directly related to the level of effectiveness by the leadership in an organisation.

1.5 Research Aims and Objectives

This research will be based on the following research aims:

 To determine the key variables in deciding how employee motivation is

effected by leadership.

 The way managers ensure that they have motivated employees by their

leading attributes.

Apart from research aim the research is undertaken to clear the following objectives:

 To identify the effect of employee motivation on the company performance

and organizational environment.

 Identify the specific influence a leadership can make that will motivate the

employees to enhance their performance in their company.

 To investigate how the company directors can help to ensure motivated

employees, effect of performance appraisal (manager assessing how

employees perform) and reward on employee motivation.

1.6 Research Questions

(10)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

In order to clarify above mentioned objectives the research will clarify

following questions:

 What makes an employee motivated and what effects the motivation can have

on entire organisational setup?

 What role leadership of an organisation can play to keep the work force

motivated and confined to one direction?

 How the level of motivation in an organisation can be enhanced?

1.7 Research Hypothesis

Leadership plays a significant role in motivating employees to perform better in

organizations like Ramada

Leaders can make a difference in the productivity of the organization by triggering

motivation levels in employees

1.8 Research Significance

The research is significant as it can inform different organisations how they

can be beneficial by developing effective leadership in their respective organisations.

The outcome of the research would help organisations in assessing how the

outcome from the organization can be improved by focusing on some of the factors

which normally taken as for granted. Moderating control on the employees can be

possible if the leadership can assess the practicality of the situation and can deal the

employees working according to the given situation. This study can be used by wide

array of organisations no matter big or small as the importance of leadership for an

organisation can never get ignored. The outcome of the research can be utilised by

the decision makers and with this they can improve the quality of the decision made

by them. Decision makers can understand how performance can be improved

according to the adaptability of a leader according the prevailing circumstances.

(11)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Quality is regarded as the most important factor for an organisational success and

that can be ensured by keeping the work force associated with the organization in

the long run. The additional aspect of long association of work force with the

organisation is the result of motivation. Criticality of performance is the outcome of

modernisation where competition is getting stiffer and the importance of each and

every element in an organization is increasing which leads to reliable performance.

The research could serve as a guideline to understand how attitude of employees

can be changed if they will be motivated to work for an organisation and what role

leadership plays in the level of motivation of the work force.

Leadership differs from practice. Business entities use leadership as a tool for

advancement of its goals. It is widely held that leadership has potential of influencing

people as well as revealing the best of their potentials. Great past leaders have had

an influence and drive in the way their organizations operate both positively and

negatively. Effective leadership is often about deriving the best a business can

achieve and being able to deal with the challenges faced by businesses in their day

to day operations. Good leaders not only guide those under them but also motivate

and help them do away with their fears when engaging in business operations. In

essence, a good leader will help instill confidence and a sense of security to those

under their leadership. One cannot deny the importance of leadership within

business organizations and in its absence; any organization would no doubt run into

trouble. Consequently, effective leadership is necessary for the success of any

business organization.

Leadership and motivation concept remains one of the most widely studied aspects

in advancement of management theories as well as practices. In essence,

leadership concept has existed for a long time and has been evaluated from one

(12)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

generation to another. Consequently, where there is no standard definition of

leadership, it can be termed as a transformational process within an entity which

affects the way the workforce operates. More often than not, workforce behaviour is

a product of candid and efficient leadership. Evidently, the source of strategic and

competitive advantage differences within organization is the different kinds of leaders

and leadership approaches applied by these organizations. Leadership vision as well

as efforts can result into extensive variations in the way organizations manage their

operations as well as how the organizations position themselves within the market.

In a similar manner, project feasibility as well as risk factors faced by the

organization largely depends on leaders/leadership approach adopted by the

organization.

1.9 Scope of the Study

This research will assess the role of leadership in motivating employees and

increasing the performance by considering both theoretical aspects of leadership as

well as employee motivation and the practical application of it. Apart from clarifying

value and vision for an organisation leadership can also help in keeping the

employees intact with an organisation.

1.10 Definition of Key Terms

Leadership factors:

Capability to give direction to an organisation by adapting, focusing and

applying the critical traits in both day to day management and in time of crisis could

lead to strategic competence (Weinstein, 2002).

Motivation factors:

(13)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Capability on large scale to develop sense of attachment among employees

of an organisation which is pivotal to the success of an organisation and for

development of employees(Weinstein, 2002).

(14)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW OF LITERATURE

People working within organization find motivation when they work towards goals

which have a personal meaning to them. Achieving these goals require some activity

which might be increasingly tough yet easy to attain. Put differently, people like

challenges, nonetheless, they have to feel that the goals they pursue are achievable in

order to remain motivated. A good way to accomplish this is by setting personally

meaningful goals, making the goals a possibility, offering performance feedback, and

alignment of the goals with personal self-esteem.

In general, human behaviour is a reflection of individual differences just as it is a

reflection of the similarities between individuals. The differences between individuals

are a result of various influences and traits (Triandis, 1994). For instance, a personality

characteristic places emphasis on individual variations which make every individual

unique in their own way. The human biological make-up concentrates on functionality of

humans due to evolution and inheritance and this is the system which influences human

behaviour (Tangney, Stuewig, & Mashek, 2007). Additionally, rewards and punishments

are part of the environment and they influence human behaviour as well. Cognitive

approach to understanding human behaviour focuses on how human thinking and

memory affects behaviour (Triandis, 1994). Any leadership and human resource

management theories are subject to contradictions given that these theories have lots of

exceptions. It is of great importance to consider these theories as general statements

confirmed via observational studies and applicable solely to level that they are reflective

and largely influenced by personal behaviors. It is typical of human behaviors to worry

about the best ways through which they can motivate employees more.

(15)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Leadership:

According to Western (2003) leadership is more of a product of social growth and

grows with time. It like other intangibles cannot be felt but is experienced within team

behaviors. In Buchanan & Huczynski (2007) leadership is defined as the process of

influencing others in order to attain a particular goal. All organizations feel a need for

leadership. However, only true leadership and mentorship can satisfy the compelling

hunger for organizations to attain their goals as a team. Yukl (2012) in creating a

distinction between leaders and managers notes that whilst managers work with sub-

ordinates, leaders work with followers. When strong leadership is not present, this can

be of detriment to the organization ad compromise its growth in addition to contributing

to failure to attain the organization’s objectives. Effective leadership combines all

resources and uses them in advancing development of the organization. Additionally, it

is through leadership that strong teams can be formed and challenges faced by the

organization can be overcome irrespective of how dynamic the business environment is.

Morality and human resource management levels by implying leaders and

followers are raised via the implication theory. Effective leadership in such organizations

requires multiple characteristics which help the organization grow and also helps in

offering subordinates the right guidance. By definition, leadership can be termed as the

act of guiding people towards a pre-defined and common goal. Consequently, it serves

no purpose if the organization is unable to achieve its objectives. As a result, the

leadership style a business entity adopts should aptly incorporate all the factors which

results into the organization’s success. Leadership should be transactional, visionary,

transformational, creative and strategic. Sustainable organization is only achievable if all

(16)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

these are incorporated into leadership. There exists a continuum of possible leadership

behaviors as well as leadership styles which may help in successfully running of an

organization. Nonetheless there is no harm in employing all the leadership approaches

in order to strategically achieve the organizations end objectives given that all have the

potential to achieve the same. Additionally, leadership approaches are important in

motivating employees and subordinates to engage in the right things which are of

benefit to the organization. Leadership styles also set apart organizations from its

competitors through development of special paths upon which the company is

constructed.

Notably, Sadler (2003) management is a rational process which calls into play

various abilities including verbal and non-verbal reasoning while leadership involves

more emotional intelligence and intuitiveness. Also worth defining is a leadership plan

which refers to the plan of action which allows leaders to define business approaches

and tactics which help them gain competitive advantage. It is often expected that a

leader within an organization is well aware of the challenges and strengths of the

business and hence well-poised to comment and create sustainable future plans.

Leadership also calls for ethical behaviour which secures personalities, societies as well

as environments and hence offers potential for increased good within the organization

(Israel & Hay, 2006). Further this assists the organization in achievement of its long-

term objectives. Effective planning implementation offers promising results and is

considered a sound strategy for the business. Such offers a classical example of

transformational style of leadership where leaders assist in transformation of employee

behaviour, in addition to boosting morale and level of personal interaction. When a team

(17)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

has a limited number of people, it gets easier for the leader to leader to personally

interact with them and hence produce positive reformations within their work

environments.

Human resource management

Human resource management is a psychological factor that arouses a certain

person to do a certain act in order to achieve a pre-determined goal. Human resource

management refers to that factor or a driving force that compels people to do something

or take some action. “The connection between employee human resource management

and corporate performance seems obvious, yet evidence suggests that employers have

some way to go in creating a truly motivated workforce” (Fargus, 2000) Human resource

management as discussed in the previous chapter is very important if we think of how it

can contribute to the achievement of organizational goals. Human resource

management is a quality that is very much needed by the leaders to display because

they are the right people for the job. Leaders as discussed previously in the literature

review have certain kind of control on the actions of the employees. “Management is a

rational process calling into play abilities such as verbal and numeric reasoning,

leadership is more intuitive involving emotional intelligence” (Sadler, 2003). At the same

time, leaders spend a lot of time with their subordinates especially in an organizational

set up. Hence they are the best people to motivate the employees and bring them

forward to contribute more towards organizational goals.

There are two types of human resource management

a) Extrinsic human resource management

(18)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

b) Intrinsic human resource management

“Extrinsically motivated behaviours are those in which an external controlling

factor can be readily identified” (Cameron, 2006).Extrinsic human resource

management includes external factors that bring out the desire in the employees to

perform better for the organization at their job and it is triggered by rewards and other

external attributes like pay, incentive, commission etc. It is not the will of the employee

or the internal subconscious but the external forces that control the employees’

behaviour towards doing a particular task.

“Intrinsic human resource management refers to the reason why we perform

certain activities for inherent satisfaction or pleasure” (Brown, 2007) Intrinsic human

resource management arises from inside. It is the inner desire of one’s own self to

perform better at their job and excel at it. There are people who like to perform their

tasks right down to the minutest of the details only because it gives them a sense of

accomplishment and perfection at mastering their own responsibility. They do not

require any external human resource management like pay, commission, perks,

benefits etc. to do what they are supposed to do.

Herzberg’s Two Factor Theory

Herzberg’s two factor theory is another classic example of human resource

management. In this theory, Fredrick Herzberg has divided human resource

management into two parts – extrinsic or intrinsic which have been discussed above.

“The dehuman resource management of employees with inefficient reward system

depends on intrinsic and extrinsic rewards” (Reio and Callahon, 2004).

(19)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

However the theory is extended to their uses in an organizational context. The two

classifications of the motivating drivers are

a) Hygiene factors

b) Motivating factor

Hygiene factors are the factors that do not directly result into the human resource

management of the employees to perform better but it there absence that if registered

by the employees causes a certain level of dissatisfaction. Common examples of

hygiene factors include perks, fringe benefits etc. that if not present along with the

remuneration paid to the employees will result in a total dissatisfaction however their

presence will not motivate the employees to work any better. Organizations must focus

on providing the employees with hygiene factors in order to retain them for a longer

period of time and not expect them to improve their performance for the same.

Motivating factors on the other hands are factors that encourage the employee to work

better. These include work recognition, self-esteem, responsibility etc. that motivate the

people to come forward and work for more achievement and recognition.

Thus theory proves that when it comes to motivating the employees the

management needs to carefully evaluate the purpose of human resource management.

If it is to improve performance only them motivating factors are enough however if they

are looking to reduce the employee attrition then they must focus on hygienic factors to

stop the employee from leaving the organization.

Leadership and Human resource management – The connection

(20)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Leaders are those who could not only manage the company, its assets and

procedures effectively but also they can encourage and elevate the quality of each and

every person working in an organisation (Fairholm, 1997). This can make it easier to

understand that leaders and human resource management are interrelated factors in

the organisation. As already mentioned that leaders can elevate the performance and

this elevation of performance comes with entailing the human resource management in

employees. In terms of effective leadership there are certain constituents that bring the

situation where the leadership can be termed as effective and one among those is if

employees are effectively motivated (Einstein, 1945). The aim of leadership is to make

other follow which is also the main goal of an individual as a leader or it can be said that

leaders are responsible to identify the direction of an organisation and to make other

move in the same direction. It can be regarded as the main aim of leaders which is

following the footsteps of leader. If the leader can develop that trigger in work force

which makes them believe that their success is in the organisation success then that

organisation is no doubt will be successful in the corporate world. This will remove

personal goals or even if they will not be removed they will become secondary and the

primary aim in such a situation will be the attainment of organisational goals.

The relationship between employee’s human resource management and

leadership is getting changed as now it is the democratic as well as liberal leadership

which is thought to develop human resource management in employees (Hicks, 2003).

The given concept is different to what prevails in the past as earlier autocratic

leadership was deemed to be success key.

(21)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Generally employees want to be closer to their leader and if this is possible then

they feel more motivated as they can learn more and they can stay near to the

individual who they idealise in their day to day life in an organisation. Flexibility in the

leadership style and the access of the work force to them is highly human resource

managemental factor in the organisation which if felt by a leader then the given flexibility

can only be developed by leader which could bring long lasting prospects. If the same

aspect of flexibility will be considered in an autocratic leadership then it is not possible

(Hicks, 2003). Keeping all the consideration it is proven from the fact that leadership is

not something that is by birth rather is a style of managing group of people which can be

established. The success that comes after teaching someone how to be a leader vary

as it is also dependent on the will of someone to learn and apart from that the internal

abilities should complement the learning procedure which if do so then an individual can

be an effective leader.

It is an understood concept that human resource management comes from the

leadership and they bring human resource management with the visionary abilities they

are having, they bring the human resource management from the way they are

delivering the daily tasks to employees, they bring human resource management by the

way they explain the issue and their entailed human resource management can give

direction to the work force in the organisation (Yukl, 2012). There is a need of

identification that what attribute of a leader brings human resource management in the

work force. In case if the employee are prudent and stubborn then it is not possible to

motivate this kind of employees rather they can motivate themselves if they want. The

only thing that can be done by the leader is that he can create the atmosphere which is

(22)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

suitable for such people to get human resource management ad to realise that goals

are integral rather than anything else they are going for (Chan & Chan, 2005). One of

the hindrances in human resource management creation process is when the

employees will come of the point that the leader is not bother about them and they are

getting neglected by the person who should have to be responsible for them.

Transformational leaders bring about enhanced confidence, insight, understanding of

capabilities, understanding structural factors as well as greater sense of personal

obligation and control on the followers (Gonzaga University & Greenleaf, 2005, pp. 18).

The followers will also be empowered to recognize and contribute their work with

diversity in an informed and enriched working atmosphere, which results in better

effectiveness of services (Russell & Stone, 2002, pp. 151). Rather than demonstrating

leadership, it is learning and working together process where both the leader and

follower involve in a particular task (Gonzaga University & Greenleaf, 2005, pp. 8).

Rather than criticizing, it adopts a corrective approach where the follower engaged in an

error is corrected to do the right thing. This offers encouragement which is an important

tool by ensuring that the followers build confidence in them and learn to correct their

wrongdoings without fear of being victimized for the same (Gonzaga University &

Greenleaf, 2005, pp. 13). This boosts confidence and instils credibility about the ideas

and vision of the transformational leader (Gonzaga University & Greenleaf, 2005, pp.

17).

In totality under the light of discussion done with theoretical aspects, extrinsic

human resource management can be created by monetary benefits which are not even

long lasting but the main human resource management of the work force is intrinsic

(23)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

human resource management which can be regarded as self-human resource

management. This type of human resource management can only be created by the

leadership qualities of the leader in an organisation and this human resource

management is even long lasting for an organisational success. In this regards not all

leaders could be successful rather the best style of leadership for human resource

management could be bureaucratic leadership.

(24)
CHAPTER THREE: METHODOLOGY

The following chapter will focus on the techniques that had been used to

achieve the aims and objectives of the given topic. Different research techniques had

been used to complete the research and the research techniques that had been

used were for the sole reason of finding the relationship between the leadership in

an organisation and its underlying effects among which motivation is one of them.

The quest to add extra knowledge from the already existing knowledge is

defined as results and is believed to results into more clear perception of concepts.

Samia (2013) consequently defines research methodology as the approach or

technique adopted in making a research exercise successful. More often than not,

research process involves query for answers, information and data in a logical

manner in order to fill existing knowledge gaps. Such an endeavor often focuses on

investigations and queries aimed at bringing together an array of information with the

intention of locating new facts which cover for exiting knowledge gaps. Research can

either be qualitative or quantitative. The study titled, “the impact of ’is nonetheless

purely qualitative and like other researches seeks to answer a specific research

question. The study in essence focused on analysis of the customer service roles in

estimation of the client satisfaction levels at conclusion of their stay duration.

Research Paradigm and Theoretical Framework

It is important to begin by understanding that various terminologies are

applied to this research to help eliminate confusions and doubts which may arise due

to word usage. The most commonly terms applied are research methodology and

research methods. Whilst the term, ‘research methodology’ is used in definition of

the approach employed to accomplish the research, research method primarily


The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

addresses the single technique employed by the researcher to get information and

run data analysis. The research methodology applied to this research incorporates a

range of factors and constraints as well as moral choices which can be employed in

the research (Dawson, 2012). Consequently, the methodology of research covers a

range of issues including objectives, research questions, the methodology employed,

findings, data collection, and the conclusion of the research. Research questions,

objectives, as well as aims are listed above and as a result we move to the other

aspects such as collection of data, research evidence, research analysis, and finally

conclude the chapter.

Research methodology applied in the research can adopt either Interpretivism

or positivism approaches. The conclusion to the research can be arrived at on basis

of the scientific methodologies and approaches employed in the research. This is

what constitutes positivism approach to research. Interpretivism philosophy on the

other hand undertakes careful description of data collected by throughout the

research, and these form bases of findings interpretation. In instances where an

investigator wants to undertake thorough description and interpretation of the

findings, the most appropriate model is Interpretivism. In any form of qualitative

research, the portion for analysis is entirely based on investigators analysis ability

without incorporation of biases as well as evaluation of comprehensive responses

received from the respondents. The employee’s feelings, both in positive and

negative environments can be well analyzed using qualitative data. In this research,

Interpretivism concept is used due to its suitability for the kind of research. It offers

an avenue for the investigators to obtain detailed responses and undertake

additional evaluation. Additionally, it offers room for an enlarged speech freedom.

This helps in deduction of better picture in relation to consumer experiences.

(26)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Research Methods

The research utilized varied respondents to enhance cross-sectional analysis of

varied opinions. Similarly, the respondents were spread across time-frames to take

into consideration the ever-changing consumer opinions. Group discussions,

questionnaires and interview schedules are well aligned to the researches aims and

objectives. Open ended questions were designed to allow for data analysis

quantification. This further helped in regulation of varied responses from the

researches respondents. When conducting researchers, there always are a range of

options from which to choose but these are narrowed down to qualitative and

quantitative research options as earlier mentioned. Each has its own unique

frameworks and hence their suitability varies from one research to another. While

quantitative researches often revolves around usage of figures and hence allow for

quantification qualitative research is more descriptive and has little to do with figures.

More often than not, statistical tools are employed in quantitative analysis to help

draw conclusions. According to Rana and Perry(2006) and Sharlene et al, (2013)

this approach basically aims to use figures and statistical output to reinforce its

conclusions and hence requires lots of mathematical input and operations. It is in this

approach where hypothesis are set to forms basis of the researches findings. The

hypothesis are accepted or rejected on basis of the mathematical figures obtained.

More often, these hypothetical figures are tested using statistical approaches (Rudi

et al., 1997; Jennifer, Anne & Habib, 2011).

Qualitative research on the other hand deals with descriptive perspective of the

research. Figures are often not involved in qualitative research. Analysis of such

often depends on the nature of the research and the opinion of the researcher. In

(27)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

simple terms, this research approach employs more words than it does figures and is

more about researcher’s perceptions, , ideas, emotions, feelings and behaviors, to

mention but a few. Consequently, researcher ability to observe and comprehend the

responses is of extreme importance. Care must also be exercised in writing of

responses. This is the only way ambiguities, confusions and false deductions can be

avoided.

In the current research, qualitative research approach is the most viable. Studying

levels of employee motivation requires building of interpersonal relationships

considering the abstract nature of motivation as a term. Consequently, qualitative

research is more viable and appropriate. Qualitative research additionally offers

respondents a feasible option for detailed discussion of ideas as well as provides

greater insight into the responses and hence facilitates realistic interpretation. Due to

the fact that the factors included are not easy to quantify, qualitative research is

more applicable. Additionally, it is worth mentioning that this approach allows for

extensive detail to be obtained and providers to the readers. Flick(2011) notes that

analysis of several cases offers more insightful information to help readers

understand the conclusions.

In the case of the current research work, the data collected from the 150 employees

at Emirates Petroleum Corporation has been used to perform a qualitative research

aiming to interpret their responses to better understand the possible relationship

between leadership and motivation. The responses are collected in a detailed

manner so they can be evaluated to necessitate findings and draw conclusions.

A questionnaire with 10 independents questions was prepared with responses

recorded as ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ to keep it simple to the respondents. The questionnaire has

(28)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

been added at the end of this research work for reference. However most of the

employees discussed their answers beyond the one worded answer in order to

better explain to the interviewer about their choices. Interpretivism enabled the

interviewer to better analyze the responses, jot down the discussion details and draw

conclusions on the basis of the same. The employees were offered confidentiality for

their responses in order to follow the right research ethics. Personal interviews were

organized with the employees at their own convenient time in the organization where

they were free to talk in familiar surroundings. Personal interviews enabled the

interviewer to answer any questions that the respondent may have or in case any

question looked ambiguous to them. The response rate was 100% as all employees

that were reached responded to the survey. The survey was taken up with the

managerial staff by the junior staff as to understand how their leaders affected their

working style and to what extent their leaders motivated them to work better. The

respondents were interviewed personally by the interviewer through pre appointed

meetings in the office premises that ensured the validity and reliability of the data.

(29)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

(30)
CHAPTER FOUR: DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS

Following is a detailed analysis and result of the questionnaire based research work.

1. I feel like I am a part of this organization

Respons

e
Yes 38
No 12

No
24%

Yes
76%

Fig 1. Employees feeling a part of the institute

24% of the employees feel they are not a part of this institution. However this is not a

majority opinion, it can be inferred that these 24% employees are not motivated
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

enough to feel that they are significant to the organization and this may affect their

productivity. This is a case of low morale in employees which can be corrected with

the right style of leadership.

2. I have good relations, open and honest communication with my

supervisor

Respons

e
Yes 41
No 9

Chart Title
No
4%

Yes
96%

Fig 2: Open honest relations and communication with supervisor

18% of the employees have issues with communicating with their supervisors. This

is again a small number however significant enough to cause distress among the

(32)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

employees that may hamper their performance. For this the managers can ensure

that regular open communication time slots are allotted to the employees so that

they may attend it and communicate freely with the supervisor.

3. My supervisor provides me both negative and positive feedback about

my work

Respons

e
Yes 48
No 2

Chart Title

No
38%

Yes
62%

Fig 3. Feedback from supervisor

Only 2 out of 50 employees at Ramada at not happy and satisfied with the feedback

system and the rest do get proper feedback on their performance. This is a good

number however when clubbed when question number (2) it shows that in the

organization, it is easy for managers or supervisors to give a feedback for employees

but not vice versa.

(33)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

4. I am more concerned about financial benefits than non-financial benefits

Yes 30
No 20

Impact of financial and non financial benefits on motivation

No
40%

Yes
60%

5. My supervisor often spends quality personal time with me

Respons

e
Yes 18
No 32

(34)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Spending quality time with supervisor

Yes
36%

No
64%

64% of the employees feel that they experience no personal bonding or quality time

with the supervisors. This obviously indicates that most of the leaders or managers

in this case do not follow a transformational leadership style that can bring about any

change in the motivation levels of the employees. This situation needs to be rectified

by organization of events that can help bond between supervisors and subordinates.

6. I feel I am able to achieve all my goals on time with ease

Respons

e
Yes 36
No 14

(35)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Achievement of personal goals

28%

14
72%

28% of the employees feel that they are unable to achieve their goals on time and

with quality. This means that they are not guided in the right direction and that even

though they are provided feedback on how they perform, there is no remedial

suggestion offered to them by the supervisors.

7. I am unable to discuss my issues with my supervisor

Respons

e
Yes 30
No 20

(36)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Interaction with supervisor

40%

20
60%

60% of the employees hesitate in discussing personal issues with their supervisors.

It indicates that about only 40% can benefit from the role of the mentor that a leader

has to play and the rest 60% are unable to improve their performance following

healthy discussions with the supervisor.

8. My supervisor treats me with respect and recognition for my

achievements

Respons

e
Yes 35
No 15

(37)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Respect and recognition for achievement

30%

15
70%

70% of the employees feel they are sufficiently praised and recognized for the good

work that they do. However this indicates that the leaders do not pay attention to the

weak performers but only butter up the good ones. This is not an ideal style of

management and can lead to serious issues in future like employee attrition.

9. I would like to discuss my supervisor’s incorrect method with his/her

supervisor

Respons

e
Yes 19
No 31

(38)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Reporting to supervisor's authority

31
38%

62%

Interestingly, 62% of the employees would not like to discuss their supervisors with

super-supervisors. This may also be due to the fact that their faith has left them

when it comes to believing in the management and that things may be improved if

given a chance. This is a bad state of affairs and the higher level management must

look into the issue.

10. I feel motivated and charged in the presence of my supervisor

Respons

e
Yes 31
No 19

(39)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Satisfied with supervisor's attention

38%

19
62%

Again a significant number 62% of the employees feel motivated and charged in their

supervisor’s presence but it is the 38% of the employees that the superiors or the

leaders should focus upon since they too are responsible for contributing to the

organization’s work related performance.

Data analysis conclusion

The findings of this research are no different from previous researches

findings. However, they offer some insightful information which helps fill the gap in

the current literature. Amongst the important points emerging include:

 Employees need motivation and appreciation from their superiors. This is best

expressed by 70% of the respondents who express the importance they

attach to being appreciated.

 Leaders are critical to motivation of employees with 68% of the respondents

feeling motivated by actions of their supervisors.

(40)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

 Employees value financial forms of motivation more than non-financial ones

with 60% saying they value financial feedback more.

 Employees attach importance to whether or not the kind of treatment they are

accorded makes them feel as part of the organization.

In general, the findings confirm that motivation of employees is an important

aspect that no organization can afford to ignore.

(41)
CHAPTER FIVE: RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSION

In the present market scenario, all the companies try their best to expand their

business by giving cut throat competition. This is possible only when company

possess the most talented and efficient staff to work with dedication and sincerity.

Also, there must be various ways to retain such staff for the growth and development

of the business. One of the most crucial ways to retain such dedicated staff is

‘Motivation’.

It is also called as key towards staggering success of an organization. Motivation

means the encouragement provided to the employees to foster and boost the morale

of the employees in order enhance their quality of work. It is always said that ‘work

make fun gets done’. Therefore, it is very vital for an employee to perform their work

without any reluctance in order to impart their services in the most systematic

manner. Motivations can be tangible and intangible. The superiors must inculcate a

habit of creating and maintaining positive work environments by rewarding the

employees for their sincere works. They should develop very policies of providing

additional incentives which serve as the best reward.

It is always said that an ideal person is a person who takes every advices and

suggestions in the positive way to come to a final decision. Likewise, even superiors

should welcome each and every suggestion from the employees to unveil them that

they perform a vital role in developing a particular business. Thus, such contributions

on the part of employees reveal them their importance. Also, superiors can gain

some new things which may serve the best role for the development of their

business.
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

Thus an organization is formed with employees and can achieve the glory of success

only with the help of such radiant and dynamic staff. It is always said that ‘a journey

of thousand miles begins with one step’. Let the entire staff begin that one step

together to accomplish all the goals of an organization.

5.1 Conclusion

Where leadership lacks, the organization and its employees lack in direction and

hence there is increased possibility of an organization lacking in vision and strategic

capability. Similarly, where there is no motivation, employees are likely to not to give

the best at work and hence compromise overall productivity at the company.

Nonetheless when these two are effectively put into use, leaders can successfully

guide employees and hence ensure success of the organization. Success is

basically achieving by understanding the basic leadership elements including

motivation theories and appropriately suing them. In the recent times, many

researchers have looked at various leadership theories relevant to various corporate

scenarios. A major theory developed largely researched is the transformational

theory where leaders offer guidance based on value and purpose. Basically, this

theory requires that leaders show high levels of integrity, encourage others, support

them, inspire them, and effectively communicate with them for the good of the

organization. Additionally, according to this theory, leaders should offer employees a

stimulating environment, commend employees where necessary, derive the best of

employee abilities, and set goals which are realistic, and train employees to focus on

team goals.

It is worth noting that motivation of employees is a goal-oriented trait which helps

individuals to attain their objectives. Further motivation drives individuals to put more

effort towards achievement of their goals and those of the organization. Ultimately, it

(43)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

is necessary that both employees and subordinates have both leadership and

motivation characteristics. A leader who is effective needs to possess extensive

knowledge of the elements which motivate others. This way an organization can

achieve success.

5.2 Recommendations

1. There are several types of incentives in which bonuses take away the major

credit for the employee’s best performance. It is mainly given when an

employee meets all the targets in the most qualitative manner. Also, many

companies provide perquisites to their employees. These are the privileges

that are given to the employees in the form of spectacular office, car parking

facilities, best washroom amenities, half days and so on. This perks make the

employees happy and they are in a better position to work with mind and

heart. Also, many companies keep several events to entertain their

employees such as sports events and other kinds of competitions. There also

superior can motivate their talent by providing awards. Such events are the

best platform to show their skills and talents which develops high confidence

in personnel.

2. Most of the employees are not so keen interested in such tangible

motivations. They desire and grapple to achieve the topmost position in their

offices. Therefore promoting the personnel to the high post on the basis of

their experience and skills can be the best way to enhance their work. This

can enhance the image of the personnel. Such personnel if motivated in such

manner often come up with flying success. There are many other tangible

incentives such as providing a car for their commutations, laptops to work and

(44)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

increase their knowledge, mobiles for contacts and so on. Thus, tangible

incentives play a significant role in retaining the talented personnel.

3. The superiors can also provide motivation by providing educational facilities to

an employee. This not only fosters their morale but also makes the employee

highly educated and makes them achieve the best position in their work

environment. This kind of motivation must be adopted by superiors in order to

enhance the employee’s knowledge.

4. Another way to boost employee’s morale is by providing intangible incentives.

It includes certificates and trophies provided to an employee for work

performed in the most diligent manner. Mostly this type of incentives does not

serve the purpose of fostering the morale of an employee. But superiors can

always this style of motivation along with tangible incentives.

5. More often employees get upset and lose all the interest for their work as do

not get any opportunities or challenges to prove themselves. Therefore,

employees must get the opportunities and tasks to perform which serves them

as a great challenge. Such challenges if faced in the most amazing manner,

develop high confidence in the personnel and this how the environment can

be made lively and happy. Many people are habituated with competing with

other people and this is they eloquent their talent. Therefore, superiors can

ideally form groups in order to perform various tasks and activities. This will

develop the team building quality and leadership quality in the personnel. So

this how, the whole work can be performed and completed like a game in the

most efficient manner. This in turn, increases the sale of product of the

company which leads to increasing profits and image of the company in the

competitive market.

(45)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

6. The companies should conduct training and development programs to

acquaint their employees about the work they need to perform in the best

possible manner. The superiors should give a clear picture of all the visions

and goals so that even can contribute to accomplish such goals efficiently.

Also, superiors should make employees understand that ‘procrastination is a

thief of time’ and so it is their prominent role to complete all the assignment

given to them in a timely manner. They must also be trained to perform their

work with loyalty and uttermost sincerity.

7. At last, superiors must take regular feedbacks in order to get unveiled about

the work performed by employees. The employees with brilliant records shall

be rewarded and the employees with negative records shall be trained and

warned to enhance their quality and contribute their best for achieving the

goals of an organization. Accordingly, clear guidelines must be provided to

them in order to work without any hesitations. Also, superiors must welcome

their queries to strike of all the agitations and hesitations.

(46)
References

1. Brown, L. (2007) Psychology of Motivation. Nova Publishers.

2. Buchanan and Huczynski (2007), ‘ Organisational Behaviour: an introductory

text’, Pearson Educated, Limited

3. Cameron, J. (2006) Rewards and Intrinsic Motivation: Resolving the

controversy.

4. Eisenberger, R., and Cameron, J. (1996). Detrimental Effects of Reward,

American Psychologist, Vol.51, No.11, pp.1153-1166.

5. Fargus, P. (2000) Measuring and improving employee motivation. Financial

Times. Prentice Hall.

6. Flick U. (2011) “Introducing research methodology: A beginners guide to

doing research project” Sage Publications Ltd. London.

7. Israel M. & Hay I. (2006) “Research ethics for social scientists” Sage

Publications Ltd. London

8. Northouse, P. 2010, Leadership: Theory and Practice, Sage Publication,

California

9. Rana and Perry, 2006, Research design and data analysis in realism

research, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 40 Issue: 11/12, pp.1194 –

1209, Available at: http://ezproxy1.hw.ac.uk:2085/journals.htm?issn=0309-

0566&volume=40&issue=11/12&articleid=1579196&show=html

10. Reio, G, T. &Callahon, J. L. (2004). Affect, Curiosity, and socialization-related

Learning; a path analysis of antecedents to job performance, Journal of

Business and Psychology, Vol.19, pp3-22.


The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

11. Rudi H.P.M. Arts, Anuj, Gerald M. Knapp, (1997). "Estimation of distribution

parameters of mixed failure mode data, Journal of Quality in Maintenance

Engineering, Vol. 3 Iss: 2, pp.120 – 135,

12. Sadler, P. 2003, Leadership, Kogan Page, London.

13. Samia, 2013, Research Methodology and Methods of Data Collection ,

Technological Change and Skill Development in Sudan, Springer-Verlag

Berlin Heidelberg, Online at:

http://ezproxy1.hw.ac.uk:2132/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-32811-

4_4/fulltext.html

14. Sharlene, Biber and Amy J. Griffin, 2013, Internet-Mediated Technologies and

Mixed Methods Research: Problems and Prospects, Journal of

Mixed Methods Research, vol. 7, 1: pp. 43-61. Available at:

http://ezproxy1.hw.ac.uk:2639/content/7/1/43.full.pdf+html

15. Western, S. 2008, Leadership: A critical Text, Sage Publication, California

16. Williams, S.D. (2004). Personality, Attitude, and Leader Influences on

Divergent Thinking and Creativity in Organizations, European Journal of

Innovation Management, Vol.7, No.3, pp.187-204.

17. Williams, S.D. (2004). Personality, Attitude, and Leader Influences on

Divergent Thinking and Creativity in Organizations, European Journal of

Innovation Management, Vol.7, No.3, pp.187-204.

18. Yukl (2012), ‘Leadership in Organisations’, Prentice Hall 8 th Edition

19. Ashmos, D.P., &Duchon, D.(2000). Spirituality at work: A conceptualization

and measure. Journal of Management Inquiry, Vol.9 (2), pp.134–145.

20. Conger, J.A.(1994). Spirit at work: discovering the spirituality in leadership.

San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

(48)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

21. Fairholm, G.(1997). Capturing the heart of leadership: Spirituality and

community in the New American workplace. Westport, CT: Praeger.

22. Hicks, D.A. (2003). Religion and the workplace: pluralism, spirituality,

leadership. New York: Cambridge University Press.

23. Lachance, J.R. (2000), ‘International symposium of the International Personal

Management Association’’, Public Personnel Management, Vol. 29 No. 3.

24. Triandis (1994). Culture and social behavior. McGraw-Hill Book Company

25. Tangney, J. P., Stuewig, J., & Mashek, D. J. (2007). Moral emotions and

moral behavior. Annual Review of Psychology, 58, 345

26. Bolden, R., Gosling, J., Marturano, A., & Dennison, P. (2003). A Review of

LeadershipTheory and Competency Frameworks. Centre for Leadership

Studies, University of Exeter. Retrieved March 12, 2010, from

http://centres.exeter.ac.uk/cls/research/abtract.php?id=29.

27. Burns, J. (1978). Leadership. New York: Harper & Row.

28. Mittelman, W. (1991). Maslow's study of self-actualization: A reinterpretation.

Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 31(1), 114–135

29. Chan, A., & Chan, E. (2005). Impact of Perceived Leadership Styles on Work

Outcomes:

30. Case of Building Professionals. Journal of Construction Engineering &

Management, 131(4), 413-422.

31. Russell, R. F., & Stone, A. G. 2002. Review of Servant Leadership Attributes:

Developing a practical model. Leadership & Organization Development

Journal, 23(3/4), 145-157.

32. Gonzaga University & Greenleaf, R. 2005. Servant Leadership. The

International Journal of Servant-Leadership, 1(1), 3-27.

(49)
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

33. Cianci, R., & Gambrel, P. A. (2003). Maslow's hierarchy of needs: Does it

apply in a collectivist culture. Journal of Applied Management and

Entrepreneurship, 8(2), 143–161.

(50)
APPENDIX

Questionnaire

Dear Respondent,

Please take out a minute of your valuable time to participate in a survey meant to

fulfill my academic purpose of conducting a research on the topic ‘The impact of

leadership on employee’s motivation within the organization” Your responses will be

kept highly confidential and will not be used elsewhere for any other purposes.

Please start by filling your personal profile details

Name: ______________________________________

Designation at Ramada: ________________________ Age:

__________________________

Immediate Supervisor: _________________________Designation:

____________________

Sex: _______________ Contact No:

_____________________________________________

___________________________________________________________________

________

Please answer the following questions in YES or NO

1. I feel like I am a part of this organization

Yes No

2. I have good relations, open and honest communication with my supervisor

Yes No

3. My supervisor provides me both negative and positive feedback about my

work

Yes No
The Impact of Leadership on Employees Motivation within the Organization

4. I am more concerned about financial benefits than non-financial benefits

Yes No

5. My supervisor often spends quality personal time with me

Yes No

6. I feel I am able to achieve all my goals on time with ease

Yes No

7. I am unable to discuss my issues with my supervisor

Yes No

8. My supervisor treats me with respect and recognition for my achievements

Yes No

9. I would like to discuss my supervisor’s incorrect method with his/her

supervisor

Yes No

10. I feel motivated and charged in the presence of my supervisor

Yes No

Thank You !!!

(52)

You might also like