Assessment Aspect Indicators 50 60 70 80 90 Ensure that all of arguments Completely are relevant to the topic and Clear in some Mostly clear No argument Unclear in clear and have been both explicitly and parts but not and orderly in given most parts orderly appropriately linked back to over all all parts presentation the topic during speech. Use of Arguments: Few but not Many reasons Most relevant Matter (50%) No reasons Some relevant Reasons are given to support relevant given: fairly reasons given given reasons given viewpoint. reasons given relevant in support Few but no Many Most relevant Have evidence, example, Some relevant No supporting relevant examples/facts supporting quote or statistic to help examples/facts examples/facts supporting given; fairly examples and support each argument. given examples/facts relevant facts given Team work and Contribution No Less Less Many Contributes to discussion contribution contribution to contribution is contributions most in team given team given – tend to are given and be self-centered fairly help the team Manner (50%) Presentation Style: No style Few styles or Few styles or All style All style Tone of voice, use of feature is used over style overt style features are features are gestures, and level of and not features are features are used, and used well enthusiasm are convincing to convincingly used but not used but they almost convincingly audience. convincingly were used convincingly convincingly