Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—With the advancement of information technology, mobile service resulted in the explosive growth of mobile
the wireless network and mobile device continue development, Internet users. In addition, more students and teachers use
which make people can acquire new knowledge with unlimited tablet computers or smart phones to read electronic books or
time and space. Moreover, learners could interact with people electronic journals. This phenomenon indicates that mobile
or things in real time to truly experience the learning content library has become learners’ main resources of acquiring
and situation. Therefore, learning was no longer limited to knowledge.
classroom and time frame. As long as learners had mobile In view of this, this study took mobile services as main
devices in hand and wireless network access, they could be idea and used Android operation system to develop a
properly guided and receive feedbacks in learning activities
“Mobile Library APP System” that used the library of the
according to their learning status and learning environment.
Recently, a great number of libraries sense this trend and start
National University of Tainan as its information source. The
to introduce mobile information technologies in library aim of this system was to allow students and professors
services. They release mobile application services compatible easily searching for desired books and relevant information
with Internet browsing with mobile devices which allow users and to provide users with more convenient and practicable
linking with libraries and searching for desired information information services.
quickly. Therefore, this study developed a “Mobile Library In the past, mobile libraries emphasized providing a great
APP System” and analyzed the usage status, level of amount of electronic books and resources to their users.
satisfaction. The experiment results showed that students’ level However, with the development of mobile service and the
of satisfaction of “Mobile Library APP System” had positive increase of user population, it was inadequate for libraries to
correlation, which indicated the system could certainly help merely provide great quantity of e-resources. A successful
them to improve their work efficiency, such as shortened time information system needs to take other elements into
spent in searching for books and decreased cost of obtaining consideration, such as system quality, users’ willingness,
electrical resources. They also showed the willingness to satisfaction and so on.
continue using the system in library relevant activities. Therefore, to increase use rate of a mobile library, this
study aimed to provide references for future mobile
Keywords- Mobile Library; APP; Mobile Library APP information systems’ evaluation and improvement of
System
libraries by analyzing use statues, satisfaction and success
model of “Mobile Library APP System.”
I. INTRODUCTION
Recently, with the popularization of wireless Internet and
mobile devices, more users use mobile devices to browse
web pages without time and space limitations. According to
Horizon Report in 2012, the maturity of third generation
44
IV. METHODOLOGY
This study used the informational system success factors
of DeLone & McLean (2003) as the theoretical framework.
It used the four constructs, “Information Quality, System
Quality, Service Quality, User Satisfaction” to evaluate and
analyze the college students’ use statues, satisfaction and
other relevant factors when they used the “Mobile Library
APP System.”
This study evaluated and analyzed college students’ use
status, satisfaction and other relevant factors of the “Mobile
Library APP System” by using questionnaire. Therefore, to
develop a valid and reliable questionnaire, this study
consulted previous studies carried by scholars and experts to
design the questionnaire content (Balaban et al., 2013; Wang
& Wang, 2009). Upon completing the first draft of the
questionnaire, fifteen members of college faculty were
invited to conduct pre-test of it. Part of wording in first draft
was amended according to pre-test results and suggestions of
Fig. 1. The functional architecture of mobile library app the faculty. The purpose was to produce more complete and
system. comprehensive questionnaire and let interviewees understand
the questions before officially issuing it.
The system used Android open source code to develop a The content of the questionnaire of this study can be
service system of mobile communication library application. categorized into five perspectives: personal data of
It can be installed in tablet PC or smart phones. Thorough interviewees, information quality, system quality, service
Mobile Library APP System, the faculty and students of the quality, and user satisfaction. The operational definition of
university can easily check the book status, new book notice, individual perspective in this study is illustrated in Table 2.
the individual book-borrowing and returning records and The Likert scale was adapted in the questionnaire: (1)
carries on reserving. Users could fasten the searching process strongly disagree, (2) disagree, (3) neutral, (4) agree, (5)
to find their desired books or to use relevant services. The strongly agree.
user interface of the system is illustrated in Figure 2. It
comprises system interface of information and functions of Table 2. The operational definition of each construct.
“News, Online Catalogs, New Book Notice, View Your Construct Operational definitions
Record, Floor Information, Opening Hours, Contact Number,
Regulations, and Library History” and so on. User’s evaluation on the information
content and quality of the “Mobile Library
Information Quality
APP System” is correct, complete and
easy to be understood.
User’s evaluation on the overall system
System Quality operation and reactions of the “Mobile
APP Service System” is stable.
User’s evaluation on the overall service of
Service Quality the “Mobile Library APP System” is
thought, effective and timely.
User’s evaluation on his/her emotional
User Satisfaction status and level of satisfaction after using
the “Mobile Library APP System.”
V. RESULTS
The "Mobile Library APP System" developed in this
empirical study used college students of National University
of Tainan as the major experiment subjects. Therefore, the
interviewees of the questionnaire in this study were
undergraduate and graduate students who actually used the
"Mobile Library APP System." The time period that they
filled in the questionnaire was between 16th December 2013
and 15th January 2014. In total, 300 questionnaires were sent
Fig. 2. User interface design of mobile library app system. and 254 returned, in which 48 of them were invalid and 206
45
valid. The effective response rate was 68.7 %, which was Humanities and Social Sciences 44 21.4
used as the research sample of this study. The structural
equation modeling is adapted in this study to test the cause- Science and Engineering 91 44.2
and-effect relation between constructs of the research model. Environmental Sciences and
11 5.3
Partial least square method is used as the analysis tool. Ecology
Therefore, this study adapts the statistics analysis software, Performance and Visual Arts 4 1.9
SmartPLS 2.0 M3 developed by Ringle, Wende & Willi
(2005) to analyze data. The analysis results are as follows.
Total 206 100.0
A. The respondents profile analysis
Interviewees’ personal data filled in valid questionnaires B. Reliability analysis
are illustrated in Table 3. The 206 valid questionnaires show In reliability analysis, the Cronbach α coefficient was
the following information. Gender: male accounts for 47.1%, used to test the internal consistency of each construct. The
female 52.9%. Age group: 20-30 years old accounts for greater the α is, the higher the correlation is and the higher
38.8%; 20 (including younger than 20) 61.2%. Grade: the internal consistency. The evaluation criteria of
second year in graduate school (including higher grade) Cronbach’s α coefficient is: when α is more than 0.7, the
accounts for 9.7%; first year in graduate school 2.4%; senior reliability is great; when α is less than 0.35, the reliability is
student (including higher grades but not studying in graduate poor (Nunnally, 1978). In Table 4, it is showed that the
school) 13.2%; junior student 21.8%; sophomore 15.5%, Cronbach α coefficient of this study is between 0.881 and
freshman 37.4%. Department: education accounts for 27.2%; 0.919; both are more than standard value. The data indicates
humanities and social sciences 21.4%; science and every construct of this study has internal consistency and
engineering 44.2%; environment sciences and ecology 5.3%; high reliability.
performance and visual arts 1.9%.
Table 4. The reliability of each dimension
Table 3. Demographic statistics of the respondents. Number Standard Cronbach’s
Construct Mean
Frequency Percentage of items deviation alpha
Information
Gender 4 4.061 0.745 0.894
Quality
Male 97 47.1 System
4 4.087 0.736 0.881
Quality
Female 109 52.9 Service
4 3.943 0.777 0.919
Total 206 100.0 Quality
User
4 3.948 0.698 0.883
Satisfaction
Age (by years)
C. Validity analysis
Under 20 126 61.2 In validity analysis, this study tested convergent validity
21-30 80 38.8 which was the degree of inter-correlation between
theoretically related items in the measurement (Lee et al.,
Total 206 100.0
2007). The dimension items of composite reliability is
composed of all items, which indicates the internal
Grade consistency of dimension items. Fornell and Larcker (1981)
suggested that the value of the composite reliability should
second year in graduate school
20 9.7 be greater than 0.7. Table 5 shows that for the items in this
(including higher grade)
study this ranges between 0.918 and 0.943, indicating
first year in graduate school 5 2.4 excellent internal consistency. The average variance
senior student (including higher extracted of dimension items is used to compute the average
grades but not studying in 27 13.2 variance predictive power of a dimension item to every item
graduate school) in dimension items. Fornell and Larcker (1981) suggested
junior student 45 21.8 that the value of the average variance extracted should be
sophomore 32 15.5 greater than 0.5. Table 5 shows that the results in this study
this ranged between 0.737 and 0.805, and thus all the items
freshman 77 37.4 in this study had excellent convergent validity.
Total 206 100.0
College
Education 56 27.2
46
Table 5. The validity of each dimension. tasks smoothly when system operational problems were
Average encountered. Therefore, in regard of “service quality,” this
Number of Composite
Dimensions Variance study suggests reinforcing training of user service personnel
items Reliability
Extracted and providing barrier-free service functions in the system in
Information order to increase users’ level of satisfaction and willingness
4 0.927 0.760
Quality of continuous use.
System Quality 4 0.943 0.737 This study investigated the Mobile Library APP System
with information system success factors by DeLone &
Service Quality 4 0.918 0.805 McLean (2003), based on the experiment results, the system
can be really help the faculty and students of the university
User to quickly searching books information or e-resources. This
4 0.919 0.740
Satisfaction
indicates their level of satisfaction with the system is strong
D. T-value and £-value analysis and willingness of continuous use in future library relevant
activities.
Table 6. T-value and β-value analysis. On the wholes, most students are satisfied with the
Dimensions ͊-value T-value process of using “Mobile Library APP System” to search for
book information or conduct activities relevant to mobile
Information Quality > User Satisfaction 0.20 2.72
library. They also show the willingness of continuous use
and would recommend classmates to use the system. They
System Quality > User Satisfaction 0.24 2.80 also hope to use “Mobile Library APP System” to complete
assignments.
Service Quality > User Satisfaction 0.04 0.57 In addition, among previous studies in library relevant
fields, there are empirical studies which conduct in-depth
discussions on information systems (Wang, Ke & Lu, 2012;
Shih et al., 2011; Tanya, 2011). Therefore, although this
VI. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION study included merely students in National University of
Tainan as experiment subjects and analyzed 206 valid
This study mainly developed a “Mobil Library APP questionnaires, the data analysis showed positive results.
System” for college students, used information system Therefore, the results are representative which the main
success factors to verify their use statues and satisfaction contribution of this study. In the future, the findings of this
with the system. Based on the analysis of experiment results, study can serve as the foundation for further exploration on
this study developed the “Mobile Library APP System” was mobile library.
helpful to college students when they were searching books
or information relevant to books and their willingness of
continuous use. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
In Table 6, “Information Quality > User Satisfaction”, This study is conducted under the “Cloud computing
this study found out that, for college students, “information systems and software development project (3/3)” of the
quality” of the Mobile Library APP System had significant Institute for Information Industry which is subsidized by the
influence on “user satisfaction” (β=0.20, T=2.72). This Ministry of Economy Affairs of the Republic of China.
indicates that, college students generally think information
quality, such as information icons and useful search results,
would affect their level of satisfaction and willingness of REFERENCES
continuous use of the system. [1] C. Fornell, and D. F. Larcker, “Evaluating structural equation
In Table 6, “System Quality > User Satisfaction”, this models with unobservable variables and measurement error,”
study found out that, for college students, “system quality” Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 18, pp. 39-50, 1981.
of the Mobile Library APP System had significant influence [2] C. M. Ringle, S. Wende, and A. Will, “SmartPLS-Version
on “user satisfaction” (β=0.24, T=2.80). This means that 2.0,” Germany: University at Hamburg. Retrieved February
college students generally think system quality, such as 20, 2005, from http://www.smartpls.de.
speed of system response and level of system stability, [3] C. Tanya, “Google Scholar acceptance and use among
would affect their level of satisfaction and willingness of graduate students: A quantitative study,” Library &
Information Science Research, Vol. 33, pp. 293-301, 2011.
continuous use of the system.
[4] C. Y. Wang, H. R. Ke, and W. C. Lu, “Design and
In Table 6, “Service Quality > User Satisfaction”, this performance evaluation of mobile web services in libraries: A
study found out that, for college students, “service quality” case study of the Oriental Institute of Technology Library,”
of the Mobile Library APP System did not have significant The Electronic Library, Vol. 30, No. 1, pp. 33-50, 2012.
influence on “system use” (β=0.08, T=0.85) and “user [5] G. J. Hwang, C. C. Tsai, and S. J. H Yang, “Criteria,
satisfaction” (β=0.04, T=0.57). This indicates that, college strategies and research issues of context-aware ubiquitous
students generally think user service personnel of the Mobile learning,” Educational Technology & Society, Vol. 11, No. 2,
pp. 81-91, 2008.
Library APP System were not able to effectively assistant
users in eliminating obstacles and to help them complete
47
[6] G. Parsons, “Information provision for HE distance learners [13] M. Enrique, and D. Blazenka, “Development of an electronic
using mobile devices,” The Electronic Library, Vol. 28, No. 2, Portfolio system success model: An information systems
pp. 231-244, 2010. approach,” Computers & Education, Vol. 60, pp. 396-411,
[7] G. S. Dianna, and A. E. Judith, “Development and initial 2013.
evaluation of the Clinical Information Systems Success [14] M. K. O. Lee, C. M. K. Cheung, and Z. Chen, “Understanding
Model (CISSM),” International Journal of Medical user acceptance of multimedia messaging services: An
Informatics, Vol. 82, No. 6, pp. 539-552, 2013. empirical study,” Journal of the American Society for
[8] H. J. Chen, “Linking employees’ e-learning system use to Information Science & Technology, Vol. 58, No. 13, pp.
their overall job outcomes: An empirical study based on the 2066-2077, 2007.
IS success model,” Computers & Education, Vol. 55, pp. [15] P. B. Seddon, “A respecification and extension of the DeLone
1628-1639, 2010. and McLean model of IS success,” Information Systems
[9] I. Balaban, E. Mub, and B. Divjak, “Development of an Research, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 240-253, 1997.
electronic Portfolio system success model: An information [16] R. O. Mason, “Measuring information output: A
systems approach.” Computers & Education, Vol. 60, pp. communication systems approach,” Information and
396-411, 2013. Management, Vol. 1, No. 5, pp. 219-234, 1978.
[10] J. C. Nunnally, “Psychometric theory,” New York. Mcgraw- [17] W. H. DeLone, and E. R. McLean, “The DeLone and McLean
Hill, 1978. model of information systems success: a 10-year update,”
[11] J. L. Shih, G. J. Hwang, Y. C. Chu, and C. W. Chuang, “An Journal of Management Information Systems, Vol. 19, No. 4,
investigation-based learning model for using digital libraries pp. 9-30, 2003.
to support mobile learning activities, The Electronic Library, [18] W. T. Wang, and C. C. Wang, “An empirical study of
Vol. 29, No. 4, 2011. instructor adoption of web-based learning systems,”
[12] L. B. Janet, “The Library for the Mobile Patron. Computers in Computers & Education, Vol. 53, pp. 761-774, 2009.
Libraries,” Vol. 29, No. 5, pp. 33, 2009. [19] W. Weaver, “The Mathematical Theory of Communication,”
Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1949.
48