Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Komal Aggarwal, Ravi Patel & Rohit Ravi (2020): Uptake of telepractice
among speech-language therapists following COVID-19 pandemic in India, Speech, Language and
Hearing, DOI: 10.1080/2050571X.2020.1812034
Introduction
MoHFW has provided guidelines for the application
The declaration of a pandemic due to the spread of of telepractice for healthcare providers focusing on
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has led to several issues such as patient privacy, professional
drastic changes in service delivery by healthcare pro- and ethical norms, referrals, counselling and overall
fessionals. Various professionals have adapted to chan- healthcare management (MoHFW, 2020).
ging times and are providing their services via Keck and Doarn (2014) reviewed the application of
telepractice during this pandemic (Arneson, Tucker, telepractice technology applications in speech-
Mercier, & Singh, 2020; Chua et al., 2020; Moccia language therapy. It found the application of teleprac-
et al., 2020). The Government and Professional Associ- tice for various clinical specialities such as child speech
ations have also stepped forward by updating guide- and language disorders, voice disorders, cranio-facial
lines or relaxation of licensing for telepractice anomalies, neurogenic communication and dysphagia.
(American Speech-Language and Hearing Association It was also found that the majority of services used a
(ASHA), 2020a; Facher, 2020; Ministry of Health and hybrid model combining synchronous and asynchro-
Family Welfare (MoHFW) 2020). Facher (2020) states nous technologies to have optimal decision-making
that despite being in the early stages, this world and to overcome any infrastructural barriers. Synchro-
health crisis has advanced even the United States of nous means the use of real-time technologies with
America’s telemedicine by about 10 years. This shift audio and video connections using internet-based
from in-person consultations to remote consultations videoconferencing for consultation, assessment, coun-
has become the need of an hour for speech-language selling and treatment. Asynchronous methods use
therapists (SLTs) across the wide range of disorders store and forward methods for information that can
they deal with (ASHA, 2020b, 2020c). Social distancing be accessed by the clinician and/or the client separ-
is being implemented globally and using telepractice ately at any point of time. These include audio/video
has been adopted as the most viable alternative. It recordings of patient complaints for viewing and ana-
ensures that essential healthcare can be provided lysing at a later point of time. It also includes audio/
without compromising patient or clinician safety. The video recordings of techniques/therapy that are
database. The participants required approximately 10 facilitator with the therapy client was always required
min to answer the survey questions. by 44.0% of participants, not required by 38.0% and
occasionally required by 18.0%.
The participants were asked their source for learning
Data analysis
about telepractice. Sources ranged from their faculty/
Descriptive statistics were used to summarize continu- colleague/friends, social media, scientific papers and
ous variables, while discrete variables were summar- the internet, with only 10.0% reporting receiving
ized using frequency and percentage. For open- formal education on telepractice (Figure 1).
ended questions, common themes were tallied. The
responses obtained in the study were analysed using
Attitudes towards telepractice
SPSS 20.
SLTs were asked, ‘Do you feel online sessions are more
stressful than face-to-face sessions?’ 52.0% responded
Results
as stressful, 31.0% as not stressful, while 9.0% were
Ninety-seven SLTs responded to the survey, of whom unsure. Forty-nine percent of participants responded
84 consented and met the criteria to participate. The that they would prefer to use telepractice even after
remaining 13 were not practising telepractice. All the the lockdown was over, 34% responded that they
respondents were SLTs working across a range of set- would use it sometimes and 17.0% did not prefer to
tings and had needed to shift their practice to teleprac- use it. The SLTs were asked about their attitude
tice due to national lockdown. towards telepractice using a five-point rating scale;
The mean age of the participants was 27 years, strongly disagree, disagree neutral, agree, strongly
range between 21 and 53 years. The number of agree. The details have been tabulated in Table 2.
female professionals was almost double male pro- There was a mixed opinion on whether telepractice
fessionals (Table 1). can compensate for in-person sessions; 35.5% agreed
that telepractice could compensate; while 33.4% dis-
agreed and 31.7% were unsure. More than 69.0% of
Practice aspect of telepractice
participants believed that telepractice would help in
The total number of sessions taken per day varied the better prognosis of their cases. Eighty-one
between 1 and 7 per day (mean 2.9 ± 1.6), while percent of participants felt the need for promotion of
the assessments conducted varied between 1 and 3 telepractice. Over 90.0% of participants felt that edu-
(mean 1.3 ± 0.5). The maximum number of sessions cational institutes should impart training at the
taken by the SLTs at the time of this study were college level as a part of the curriculum, while 79.0%
more than 11 sessions (48.8%). Twenty-nine (34.5%) felt the need for a standard operating protocol for tele-
SLTs took 1–5 sessions, 14 (16.7%) took 6–10 ses- practice in India.
sions. Seventy-five (89.3%) gave individual sessions, The last two questions were open-ended questions
while nine (10.7%) SLTs gave group therapy. SLTs to identify the most preferred platforms used for tele-
were asked to report how often they saw a variety practice and the challenges faced. In terms of the
of cases; only 9.0% said always, 61.9% reported some- most preferred platforms used for telepractice, multiple
times, while 32.0% reported no variety in caseload. platforms were being used. The most commonly used
The majority of caseload was paediatric (85.0%) fol- platform was WhatsApp video call (82.0%), followed
lowed by adult (15.0%) and then geriatric (19.0%). by Zoom (58.0%) and Skype (36.0%) (Figure 2).
In terms of the distribution of the disorders, the The final question in the survey, was the challenges
majority reported treating child language disorders faced during telepractice. Most clinicians faced mul-
(75.0%); followed by fluency disorder (45.2%); voice tiple challenges, with the most common being
disorders (31.0%); neurogenic language disorder network issues (38.0%) followed by lack of cooperation
(29.8%) and neurogenic speech disorders (25.0%). A or difficulty to make the child sit during teletherapy
(Figure 3).
Table 1. Demographic details of participants.
Mean ± SD Range Discussion
Age (in years) 27.14 ± 5.6 21–53
Number (percentage) The fast spread of the global pandemic of COVID-19 led
Gender Male 25 (29.8) to changes in the health sector to prioritize not just
Female 59 (70.2)
Work setting Clinic 45 (53.6) public health but also healthcare professionals’ assess-
Academic institutions 14 (16.7) ment and interventions. The potential for telepractice
Hospital 14 (16.6)
NGO 04 (4.8) to be used in disaster and public health emergencies
Schools 04 (4.8) has been established previously (Lurie & Carr, 2018).
Home visit 03 (3.6)
The present COVID-19 pandemic has encouraged and
4 K. AGGARWAL ET AL.
increased non-traditional modes of healthcare, such as telepractice due to the potential reduction of income
e-visits, remote visits, virtual healthcare, and tele-moni- they would face during the nation-wide lockdown
toring (Tahan, 2020). Likewise, SLTs have also faced a where face- to-face therapy sessions were not possible.
major challenge while providing healthcare using tra- In the present study, the major caseload of these
ditional face-to-face therapy. SLTs’ prolonged, direct professionals was paediatric populations, followed by
contact and close proximity to the airway has put adult and geriatric. The same distribution was noted
them at risk of contracting and spreading the virus in the 2017 survey where almost 46% provided services
(Gunjawate, Ravi, Yerraguntla, Rajashekhar, & Verma, to the paediatric population, followed by adults and
2020). This has led to a shift to telepractice. Professional geriatrics (Mohan et al., 2017). However, it was not
bodies for SLTs have encouraged the adoption of tele- possible to ascertain whether there was an overall of
practice services to improve services’ availability and the participants in both these surveys. In addition,
reduce patient contact. Several relevant educational with respect to the distribution of caseload, child
materials and guidelines for professional practices language disorders were most prevalent as compared
have been made easily accessible (ASHA, 2020b, to speech sound disorders being most common pre-
2020c). viously (Mohan et al., 2017). This draws attention to
In an attempt to curb the spread of COVID-19 in the popularity of use of telepractice services for paedia-
2020, a nation-wide lockdown was implemented in tric population among the SLTs.
India. This led to considerable disruption of traditional There was a mixed opinion among the SLTs about
face-to-face therapy services. A previous survey among whether telepractice could compensate for the lack
Indian SLTs and Audiologists in 2017 highlighted both of in-person care. This could be due to the uncertainty
an acute shortage of these professionals and the need about the outcomes, efficacy, and monetary gains with
for better access to telepractice in improve service the shift in practice. Over 69% agreed that online
accessibility. In 2017, only 12% of the respondents speech-language therapy sessions would help in the
were involved in telepractice (Mohan, Anjum, & Rao, prognosis of cases. This is very closely related to the
2017). In the current survey, 84 out of 97 SLTs reported findings of the previous study, where 90% respondents
that they currently used telepractice, reflecting a rapid considered tele-practice as a viable option for service
adoption of this method of practice. In the present delivery (Mohan et al., 2017). More than half of the par-
survey more than half of participants were private ticipants reported online sessions to be more stressful
therapists, allowing for the possibility that such clini- than face-to-face sessions. This could be attributed to
cians may have had a greater uptake in use of the sudden uptake and shift to online platforms after
the in-person services closure due to the lockdown. A It has gained popularity due to ease of access, not
facilitator was always required for 44% of the partici- requiring extensive infrastructure, and being economical
pants, likely due to the predominance of child clients. (De Benedictis et al., 2019; Giordano et al., 2017). Zoom
A facilitator in this context is a person who helps the was the second preferred option adopted by the clini-
client while attending an online session. The facilitator cian for service delivery as it gives free 40 min video
is usually a parent or caregiver, who may not be trained call. Facebook messenger was the least preferred
to perform the assigned task, or be proficient enough because of the need to use personal accounts or
to use technology, which could be challenging. At create a new account. At the time of this study, there
the same time, the presence of a facilitator might was a lack of any legislation or guidelines available on
ensure that therapy is smoothly conducted. telepractice using phone, video on internet-based appli-
The most frequent sources for learning about tele- cation in India (MoHFW, 2020). There is a need for having
practice were faculty/colleague/friends and social further legislations or guidelines that ensure the use of
media and internet. Only 10% referred to their curricu- secure networks, data privacy, and professionals norms
lum for learning about telepractice, which can be while using telepractice.
related to the lack of emphasis on telepractice in the Regina Molini-Avejonas, Rondon-Melo, De La
curriculum (Rao & Yashaswini, 2018). Closely related Higuera Amato, and Samelli (2015) systematically
to the need for inclusion of telepractice training in reviewed 103 papers in audiology and speech-
the curriculum, more than 90% SLTs agreed to the language sciences in telehealth to conclude that tele-
need for institutions to train their students for teleprac- health does pose an advantage over non-telehealth.
tice. More than 92% expressed the need to make stan- However, certain barriers, such as technology, lack of
dard operating protocols for telepractice as compared training, acceptance, regulations, and recognition,
to 72% in previously (Mohan et al., 2017). This could need to be resolved. In the present study, the most
be due to hands-on usage of the telepractice in the common problem reported was network issues. This
present study that has made the SLTs realize this can be attributed to network issues that are being
need. Training in the use of synchronous and asynchro- faced in India due to the overconsumption of data cur-
nous telepractice by SLTs with respect to platforms rently (Hindustan Times, 2020). Many parents and care-
used, availability of resources, hands-on training, regu- givers are still sceptical of the new mode of therapy,
lations, data privacy issues and how to overcome the which might account for why so many participants
challenges. reported that they had difficulty cooperating and con-
The most commonly used platform for telepractice vincing parents. In addition, the majority of the case-
was WhatsApp video call, followed by Zoom and load in the present study was child language
Skype. Most SLTs were using multiple platforms based disorders leading to another difficulty that the partici-
on the need and comfort of the patients. WhatsApp pants reported was in demonstration.
has emerged as one of the more conventional of com- The findings of the present study shed light on the
munications in India since it is both freely available uptake of telepractice by SLTs in India following the
and easy to use (Indian Express, 2019). Also, WhatsApp COVID-19 pandemic. This pandemic has led to a
has been increasingly used in healthcare as a communi- global influence and is likely to continue for a while.
cation tool between public and healthcare professionals. It has become imperative that healthcare is shifted
6 K. AGGARWAL ET AL.
Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups, 1(18), 19– and Social Media Study Group of the Italian Society of
29. doi:10.1044/persp1.SIG18.19 Neurology. (2020). Assessing disability and relapses in mul-
De Benedictis, A., Lettieri, E., Masella, C., Gastaldi, L., Macchini, tiple sclerosis on tele-neurology. Neurological Sciences:
G., Santu, C., & Tartaglini, D. (2019). Whatsapp in hospital? Official Journal of the Italian Neurological Society and of
An empirical investigation of individual and organizational the Italian Society of Clinical Neurophysiology, 1–3.
determinants to use. PLOS ONE, 14(1), e0209873. doi:10. Advance online publication. doi:10.1007/s10072-020-
1371/journal.pone.0209873 04470-x
Facher, L. (2020). Trump administration loosens Telehealth Mohan, H. S., Anjum, A., & Rao, P. (2017). A survey of teleprac-
regulations to combat coronavirus. STAT. Retrieved from tice in speech-language pathology and audiology in India.
https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/trump-telehealth- International Journal of Telerehabilitation, 9(2), 69–80.
restrictions/. doi:10.5195/ijt.2017.6233
Fritz, M. A., Howell, R. J., Brodsky, M. B., Suiter, D. M., Dhar, S. I., Polit, D. F., & Beck, C. T. (2006). The content validity index: Are
Rameau, A., … Kuhn, M. A. (2020). Moving forward with you sure you know what’s being reported? Critique and
dysphagia care: Implementing strategies during the Recommendations. Research in Nursing and Health, 29(5),
COVID-19 pandemic and beyond. Dysphagia. doi:10.1007/ 489–497. doi:10.1002/nur.20147
s00455-020-10144-9 Raman, N., Nagarajan, R., Venkatesh, L., Monica, D. S.,
Giordano, V., Koch, H., Godoy-Santos, A., Dias Belangero, W., Ramkumar, V., & Krumm, M. (2019). School-based language
Esteves Santos Pires, R., & Labronici, P. (2017). Whatsapp screening among primary school children using teleprac-
messenger as an adjunctive tool for telemedicine: An over- tice: A feasibility study from India. International Journal of
view. Interactive Journal of Medical Research, 6(2), e11. Speech-Language Pathology, 21(4), 425–434. doi:10.1080/
doi:10.2196/ijmr.6214 17549507.2018.1493142
Gunjawate, D. R., Ravi, R., Yerraguntla, K., Rajashekhar, B., & Ramkumar, V., Nagarajan, R., Shankarnarayan, V. C.,
Verma, A. (2020). Impact of coronavirus disease 2019 on Kumaravelu, S., & Hall, J. W. (2019). Implementation and
professional practices of audiologists and speech- evaluation of a rural community-based pediatric hearing
language pathologists in India: A knowledge, attitude screening program integrating in-person and tele-diagnos-
and practices survey. Clinical Epidemiology and Global tic auditory brainstem response (ABR). BMC Health Services
Health. doi:10.1016/j.cegh.2020.07.009 Research, 19(1), 1. doi:10.1186/s12913-018-3827-x
Hindustan Times. (2020). India’s Internet consumption up Ramkumar, V., Rajendran, A., Nagarajan, R.,
during Covid-19 lockdown, shows data. Retrieved from Balasubramaniyan, S., & Suresh, D. K. (2018). Identification
https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/india-s- and management of middle ear disorders in a rural cleft
internet consumption-up-during-covid-19-lockdown- care program: A telemedicine approach. American Journal
shows-data/story-ALcov1bP8uWYO9N2TbpPlK.html. of Audiology, 27(3S), 455–461. doi:10.1044/2018_AJA-
Indian Express. (2019). WhatsApp now has 400 million active IMIA3-18-0015
users in India. Retrieved from https://indianexpress.com/ Rao, P. K. S., & Yashaswini, R. (2018). Telepractice in speech-
article/technology/social/whatsapp-now-has-400-million- language pathology and audiology: Prospects and chal-
active-users-in-india-confirms-company-5854881/. lenges. Journal of Indian Speech Language & Hearing
Keck, C. S., & Doarn, C. R. (2014). Telehealth technology appli- Association, 32(2), 67.
cations in speech-language pathology. Telemedicine Regina Molini-Avejonas, D., Rondon-Melo, S., De La Higuera
Journal and e-Health: the Official Journal of the American Amato, C. A., & Samelli, A. G. (2015). A systematic review
Telemedicine Association, 20(7), 653–659. doi:10.1089/tmj. of the use of telehealth in speech, language and hearing
2013.0295 sciences. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 21(7), 367–
Krumm, M., & Syms, M. J. (2011). Teleaudiology. 376. doi:10.1177/1357633x15583215
Otolaryngology Clinics of North America, 44, 1297. Soldatova, L., Williams, C., Postma, G. N., Falk, G. W., & Mirza, N.
Lurie, N., & Carr, B. G. (2018). The role of telehealth in the (2020). Virtual dysphagia evaluation: Practical guidelines
medical response to disasters. JAMA Internal Medicine, for dysphagia management in the context of the COVID-
178(6), 745. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.1314 19 pandemic. Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery.
Miles, A., Connor, N. P., Desai, R. V., Jadcherla, S., Allen, J., doi:10.1177/0194599820931791
Brodsky, M., … Langmore, S. E. (2020). Dysphagia care Tahan, H. M. (2020). Essential case management practices
across the continuum: A multidisciplinary dysphagia amidst the novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)
research society Taskforce report of service-delivery crisis. Professional Case Management. Publish Ahead of
during the COVID-19 global pandemic. Dysphagia, doi:10. Print. doi:10.1097/ncm.0000000000000455
1007/s00455-020-10153-8 Tucker, J. K. (2012). Perspectives of speech-language pathol-
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. ogists on the use of telepractice in schools: The qualitative
(2020). Telemedicine practice guidelines enabling registered view. International Journal of Telerehabilitation, 4(2), 47–60.
medical practitioners to provide healthcare using telemedi- doi:10.5195/ijt.2012.6102
cine. Retrieved from https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/ World Medical Association. (2009). Declaration of Helsinki.
Telemedicine.pdf. Ethical principles for medical research involving human
Moccia, M., Lanzillo, R., Brescia Morra, V., Bonavita, S., subjects. Jahrbuch für Wissenschaft und Ethik, 14(1).
Tedeschi, G., Leocani, L., … & Digital Technologies Web doi:10.1515/9783110208856.233