Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Introduction.........................................................................................................................3
6. Conclusion........................................................................................................................17
7. References.........................................................................................................................18
2
1. Introduction
The purpose of this report is to propose strategy to “Walt Disney” on how to build brand
image and create brand awareness of Disney characters in China market using Keller’s brand
equity model, compare and contrast the strategies used by Walt Disney in the India and China
market, evaluate the decision of Walt Disney to adopt localization approach in emerging
markets and evaluate the reasons of declination and low revenue for Walt Disney’s profits in
emerging markets compare to America. In the case study, it mentioned that although Disney
have high brand awareness levels in worldwide, but only 25 percent of total revenues came
from outside United States which means they need to come out with “one size fits all”
approach to build brand awareness and image to extend their market in other countries.
“Disneyland” is a huge amusement park featuring rides and shows where all the characters
and stories are based on the films made by “Walt Disney” (Schreiber, 2020).
3
2. Brand Awareness and Brand image in China Market
Firstly, brand awareness is defined as the recognition level of consumers towards the brand
elements of a particular company’s brand such as brand name, logo, slogan, packaging and
other brand elements where it also connect with company’s product or service to allow the
consumers able to differentiate themselves from competitors (Zimmer, 2019). Brand image
is defined as the perception of consumers towards a certain brand based on the interactions
and experience of the company with the public which is developed over a certain time period
and it does not necessarily need to be buying or using of their products and services
(Kaemingk, 2019). Keller’s Brand Equity Model, also called as Customer-Based Brand
Equity (CBBE) consist of four-level pyramid which are brand identity, brand meaning, brand
response and brand relationships. According to the model, brand awareness can be obtain in
the brand identity level and brand image can be obtain in the brand meaning level (Ellefsen,
2018).
4
2.1 Brand Awareness
There are many ways for Walt Disney to create brand awareness in China market, but the
challenge is will Walt Disney able to create effective brand awareness as they want in China
market. It is important for Walt Disney to present accurate depiction, consistent, and clear
brand identity for their target audience because brand identity is the most important part for a
company to further up the pyramid. Before going to the strategy, a few efforts should be
done. First, Walt Disney should focus on the trouble spots or interests that matter to them.
Secondly, make sure all channels chose to market on are stable and consistent. Last but not
least, make sure the platforms placed are the platforms that frequently used by the target
For the strategy to create brand identity from the Keller’s Brand Equity Model, Walt Disney
can create brand awareness by implement marketing activities to associate their Disney
characters with interest things in the related usage in the category in China. For example,
Fanta is able to create brand awareness all over the world by sponsoring summer beach
volleyball events which the events are related to their business which is to rehydrate after a
workout (Ellefsen, 2018). Another strategy for Walt Disney to create brand awareness for the
Disney characters in China is to let the customers to know the unique value of Walt Disney
through social media, or any other channels where the target customers can be found and able
to reach in the China market (Barnhart, 2018). “Glossier”, a cosmetics and skincare company,
is able to create brand awareness and brand identity from the Keller’s Brand Equity Model
for the brand through this strategy by creating innovative Instagram campaigns. This is
because the founder of Glossier, Emily Weiss is also a skincare and cosmetics user and she
also engage with customers on social media. Thus, she know what is the best channel and she
5
able to identify a unique selling point for her brand to reach her target audience (Framption,
2020).
Other than that, complementary partnerships with local company will also help Walt Disney
to create brand awareness in the China market (Walgrove, 2020). This is because these
companies already have their own customers’ base which Walt Disney can partners with
them to create brand awareness in China market which the brand identity of Keller’s Brand
Equity Model will be achieved because the customers will be able to see Walt Disney when
they see the local company who partnered with Walt Disney (Matthews, 2019). For example,
Barn”, a furniture company where they create a win-win situation for both of the companies
where they share their customers’ base with each other and create brand awareness for
themselves (Ijidola, 2018). Last but not least, offline campaigns can also be done by Walt
Disney to create brand awareness in the China market. Although this is the age of the
smartphones and internet, traditional ways of advertising still can be effectively obtain brand
brochures, posters, billboards, print materials and direct mail (Design Rush, 2020). For
example, Adidas create an offline campaign called “Jump with Derrick Rose”. This campaign
is to allow their customers to bring shoes with Derrick Rose signature home for free if they
manage to swipe the shoes down from where Derrick Rose jump mark in London. Adidas is
able to create brand awareness by creating memorable experience for their customers.
Therefore, Adidas was able to obtain brand salience and brand identity from Keller’s Brand
6
2.2 Brand Image
Brand image also referred as the personality of a specific brand in the customers’ mind
(Pahwa, 2021). Brand image is very important for a company because it will significantly
impact the company and the brand if did not done it properly. Positive brand image may
bring more sales while negative brand image will bring negative consequences. Companies
should make sure the brand image they present or shown to their target audience is realistic
and achievable (MBA Skool Team, 2020). According to Keller’s Brand Equity Model, brand
image have two parts which are brand performance and brand imagery (Bhasin, 2019). Brand
performance are highly associate with the tangible aspect which are quality, usability, and
durability of the brand’s products. Brand imagery is defined as how well the brand satisfy the
social and psychological needs of the customers which are perceived value, social status and
For the strategy for Walt Disney to build brand image of Disney characters in China market,
Walt Disney can implement differentiation branding strategy to build brand image since
differentiation strategy is the most effective strategy for a company to build brand image
because it allows the customers to have different experience which also means offering a
superior quality to the potential customers which is different from competitors (Herosmyth,
2020). Example for brand performance, the operating system of Apple are trusted and loved
by the customers because of the features, reliability, service and more (Bhasin, 2019). For the
example of brand imagery, the “Think Different” slogan done by Apple to send a message to
potential customers that Apple is making products that are very innovative and creative that
help their customer’s dreams come true (DominguesFrans, 2018). Both strategies have
effectively increase the value of Apple’s products and effectively build positive brand image
for the brand performance and brand imagery of Keller’s Brand Equity Model for themselves
7
from the inside out. In the end, Apple is able to obtain more customer loyalty than their
competitors (Perch, 2020). Other example such as Tesla directly enter the market by offering
luxury electric vehicles and instantly obtain a high-end brand image in the automotive
industry without competing with electric low-end hybrids by making unique features for their
vehicle and achieve brand performance in Keller’s Brand Equity Model (Roberts, 2018).
Another strategy for Walt Disney to build brand image in China market is to meet the target
audience where they are and deliver the message they expect to hear, it can be very effective
to build brand image if a company is able to find the right channel to reach the target
audience with the right message because they will be the first customers cares about what you
have to say and the first who able to find the value of the products and brand, rather than just
try to reach them through multiple channels (Forbes, 2017). For example, during the 2014
World Cup, Adidas and Nike, each of them created a campaign of its own to reach its target
audience. Adidas created a campaign called “win or lose” while Nike created a campaign
where only football fans who follow the sport would understand the jokes. In the end, Nike
able to improve its brand image in the brand imagery of Keller’s Brand Equity Model
because the message delivered by Nike was more specific to its target audience (Piontek,
2019). However, Disney also done a mistake that significantly affect their brand image in the
China market which is the live-action remake of Mulan, the Chinese character of Disney.
Disney failed to obtain the right information of the culture of China and they make
questionable themes and design choices for the film which are dislike by the Chinese
audiences (Wong, 2020). For example, Mulan is a character that is not living in Tang
Dynasty, she is from the Northern Wei story, but the make-up and the costumes of the
character is using totally different historical period. It looks very strange and weird for the
character. Other than that, the movie also use building from another dynasty which is the
Song Dynasty which totally make no sense to appear in the story (Li, 2020).
8
3. Strategies of Walt Disney in China and India.
In the China market, Walt Disney come out with a glocalized strategy for the Shanghai
getting the details directly from the Chinese government and choose the strategies to suit the
China market. This is because China have strict restrictions for foreign organizations want to
operate in China including media platforms (Denyer, 2016). CEO of Disney, Robert Iger
claimed that they wanted to build a China’s Disneyland instead of building a Disneyland in
China (Levine, 2016). This is a new emotional branding strategy done by Disney for
Disneyland in China to emotionally comforting Chinese visitors through new rides and
attractions specifically build for the China market instead of directly cloning them from
existing Disneyland. Walt Disney implement a lot of different experience strategies for
Disneyland in Shanghai to fit into the China market such as using Mandarin as the main
language in the park, offers Chinese food and beverages. One of the example of Disneyland
emotional strategy is through “The Garden of the Twelve Friends”, which the twelve friends
are representing the twelve Chinese zodiac but with Disney characters such as Remy from
Ratatouille as the rat, Tiger from Winne-the-Pooh as Tiger and more. (Cheung & McCarthy,
2019). These strategies implemented by Disneyland Shanghai have successfully for them to
generate positive results in a short period of time after its opening in 2016 (Huang, 2017).
In the India market, Walt Disney implement strategies to enter the India market by making
films, animation, messages and products which are compatible with the culture to suit the
customers preferences in India market to obtain brand awareness and brand image such as
Bollywood films, local-language production, television broadcast and more. Walt Disney
choose to focus on entertainment and media to help it build brand awareness and increase the
9
fan base in India (Frater, 2013). Unfortunately, the adaptation strategy had failed to generate
positive results and bring losses for Walt Disney in India. Thus, Walt Disney cease film
production in India market and it will now only focusing on distribution of the studio’s
Hollywood slate and consumer products business in the India market starting from year 2016
In conclusion, Walt Disney was able to generate positive results in China market even though
China restrict Walt Disney access to all media platforms. Walt Disney used the same strategy
in both China and India which is adaptation strategy but it failed to generate positive results
through this strategy in India market. This is because Walt Disney is able to obtain more
details of the China market from the support of government of China before it enter the
market while Walt Disney enter the India market only focus on media and entertainment.
10
4. Disney’s Decision of Localization in Emerging Markets
Disney’s have adjusted each of their Disneyland theme park located in Hong Kong, Paris and
Tokyo to suite the local tastes and cultures. The adjustments in these markets will differ from
each other in terms of layout, food and rides to attract audiences and let the customers to feel
like at home while having fun in Disneyland (Tang, 2012). In each of the Disneyland in
different countries, they will celebrate every major events, traditions and holidays of different
cultures in different countries to make them feel like home in Disneyland (Tschinkel, 2019).
For example, “running of the bulls” traditions in Tokyo Disneyland where crowds of all ages
run inside the park the moment the gates open (Lasher D., 2018). Holiday celebration events
such as celebrations of “Chinese New Year” in Hong Kong Disneyland through merchandise,
traditional decorations and festive entertainment (Jones, 2019). Other than that, the foods and
beverages offers in each Disneyland will be different from others to suite the local tastes. For
instance, Tokyo Disneyland offers “Miso”, milk tea and more localize flavour of popcorns
for the Japan market (Wang, 2014) and Hong Kong Disneyland offers special Disney “dim
sum” with Disney’s characters design to suite the taste preferences of the market (Dillion,
2020).
The main language for Disneyland in different markets will also differ with each other. For
example, Disney change their main language to Japanese for Disneyland in Tokyo (Fung,
2013, as cited in Zhao, 2014) while Disneyland in Hong Kong use three different language
which are Mandarin, Cantonese and English because they are targeting three types of
customers (Fung & Lee, 2009). The details and design elements of the property of
Disneyland will also be differ in each markets (Tschinkel, 2012). For example, Hong Kong
Disneyland use traditional Chinese elements and “feng shui” into its design. Hong Kong
11
Disneyland build the main gate positioned in a north-south direction because according to
“feng shui”, north-south direction will bring maximum prosperity for them and a lot of red
will be used in the park because red is considered as lucky colour in Chinese culture (Holson,
2005) and there will be no clocks available in the gift shops because it will means “going to a
funeral” in Cantonese and Mandarin (Tang, 2012). Other than that, shields will also available
for guests from snow, wind and rain in both Disneyland in Tokyo and Paris because of
different weathers in these countries (Tschinkel, 2019). Last but not least, Walt Disney will
also create localized versions of products to suite the local preferences in other countries. For
example, Tokyo Disneyland offers “cute” limited editions products and put it into a “lucky
secret bags” because Japanese have the shopping habits of buying limited and secret gift bag
(Zhao, 2014).
12
5. Reasons of Low Revenue and Declination in profits
There are many reasons why Walt Disney's revenue and profits in emerging markets have
fallen compared with the America market. This is because every market has different culture
of their own where Walt Disney are not able to adapt successfully in these emerging markets
For Hong Kong Disneyland, one of the main reasons of declination of profits is the ticket
price (Xinhua, 2014, as cited in Guo, 2014). Hong Kong Disneyland had increased the prices
of their one-day entrance fees fifth time since the park opened in 2005. The ticket for adult
admission will cost $64 and $46 for a child in year 2019 which is considered as the most
expensive ticket price in Asia for such small theme parks while the ticket price will only cost
$58 for adult and $38 for a child in Tokyo Disneyland, (Tsang, 2019). The other reason is the
population of Hong Kong is very low, just about 7 million people and the issue of Hong
Kong currency with China currency also made Hong Kong become less attractive to visitors
from mainland China (Niles, 2017) while over half of its visitors are coming from mainland
China (Thomala, 2020). Last but not least, the anti-government protests started on year 2019
have significantly driven tourists to stay away to avoid the city’s ongoing pro-democracy
protests (Liu, 2019). All these issues have bring losses for Hong Kong Disneyland over these
years. Hong Kong Disneyland already have fifth consecutive year of losses from year 2015 to
year 2019 and have a net losses of $13.5 million (HK$105 million) in year 2019 due to these
13
Figure 1: Financial statements of Hong Kong Disneyland for the fiscal year 2019.
Sources: https://hkcorporate.hongkongdisneyland.com/pdf/AnnualBusinessReview19.pdf
There are many reasons that driven the low and declining profits for Disneyland in Paris.
Firstly, most of the attractions in the park are outdated and does not seem to have properly
maintained due to limited financial flexibility. Other than that, the management of the park
also failed to keep up with technical innovations to satisfy diverging interests of customers
(Neate & Farrel, 2014). Secondly, the reason of cultural differences also significantly affect
the profits of Disneyland in Paris because they tend to Americanize the European habits
(Yue, 2009). There were many mistakes that made in the operations of Disneyland Paris
which are disliked by the Europeans. For example, Disneyland Paris have the policy of no
alcohol in its parks which is same with Disneyland in other markets such as California,
Tokyo and Florida. This policy had shocked the French because a wine for lunch is a part of
regular beverage in their daily life and a must for them (Novela, 2017). Another mistakes
made by Disneyland Paris is they failed to realize the Europeans breakfast norms. They
downsize the restaurants in the park because they were told that Europeans generally did not
eat a big breakfast at a set time every day and they prefer eat their breakfast while wander
14
around the parks like the Americans (UKEssays, 2018). In the end, large numbers of people
have crowd the restaurants for substantial breakfasts but there was not enough seats for them
to enjoy the meals which caused the lines to be very long (Yue, 2009). Thirdly, the terrorist
attacks of Paris in 2015 also significantly decrease the number of visitors for Disneyland
Paris in the following year. According to Catherine Powell, the president of Disneyland Paris
said that the terrorist attacks had reduced 10% of total visitors and 7% drop of the total
revenue in 2016 (Sharkov, 2016). Last but not least, the French labour laws also a reason why
Disneyland Paris have low revenue and declination of profits. Before Walt Disney opened the
Disneyland Paris, they estimated that 13% of their revenues will be the cost for the labour.
But in reality, 24% and 40% of the total revenues are the labour cost in 1992 and 1993
respectively which heavily increase the debts of Disneyland Paris because they
Disneyland already have loss for more than a decade since it opened in year 1992 to year
2017 and have a net losses of $201 million (€166 million) in year 2017 due to these reasons
(Tessa, 2019).
15
Figure 2: Financial statements Disneyland Paris for the fiscal year 2017.
Sources: https://www.theparkdb.com/results/download_misc_file/1600102087_1_t.pdf
16
6. Conclusion
In conclusion, although expanding business to new markets is an opportunity for global brand
to expand their customer base, but every markets are different in terms of culture, lifestyle,
buying behaviour, environment, laws and more. International market research should be done
by global brand before entering a new market to obtain the information of the customer
preferences. It may help to determine opportunity in the market and how the product or
service best fit. Adjustments should be done properly to cater the local culture in the market
to decrease the risk of failure and increase the profitability of the business (Brown, 2016).
Information collected by Walt Disney are not completely accurate in some of the markets
which driven them to implement wrong localization approach and cause failure for Hong
17
7. References
Barnhart B., (2018). 12 Ways to Boost Brand Awareness on Social Media. Retrieved online
Bhasin H., (2019). Keller’s Brand equity Model – CBBE Model by Keller. Retrieved online
Brown L. N., (2016). International Market Research for New Market Entry. Retrieved online
https://www.inspiratti.com/international-market-research-new-market-entry/1015/ [Accessed
on 9-5-2021]
Cheung M. & McCarthy W., (2017). “Authentically Disney, distinctly Chinese” and faintly
https://research-repository.griffith.edu.au/rest/bitstreams/4aac1797-0f5f-423a-b382-
Denyer, S. (2016). China’s scary lesson to the world: Censoring the internet works. The
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/chinas-scary-lessonto-the-world-
censoring-the-internet-works/2016/05/23/413afe78-fff3-11e5- 8bb1-f124a43f84dc_story.html
[Accessed on 21-4-2021]
Design Rush, (2020). 15 Effective Brand Awareness Strategies: The Ultimate Guide To
Dillion K., (2020). Cute Disney Dim Sum at Hong Kong Disneyland. Retrieved online
18
DominguesFrans, (2018). How Apple Positions and Differentiates their BRAND. Retrieved
online https://dominguesfrans.wordpress.com/2018/10/30/apples-brand-positioning-and-
Ellefsen B. T. R., (2018). Building Strong Brands with the Customer Based Brand Equity
https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbescoachescouncil/2017/04/20/16-unique-strategies-to-
Framption S., (2020). What Is Customer-Based Brand Equity? Breaking Down the Brand
[Accessed on 5-5-2021]
Frater P. & Ramachandran N., (2016). Disney Confirms Plan to Quit Indian Filmmaking.
Frater P., (2013). Disney’s Bollywood Boom: Why the Mouse Re-Focused Local Production
Frater P., (2020). Hong Kong Disneyland’s Latest Losses Blamed on Politics, Not Virus.
Fung A. & Lee M., (2009). Localizing a global amusement park: Hong Kong Disneyland.
19
Fung/publication/240536563_Localizing_a_global_amusement_park_Hong_Kong_Disneyla
nd/links/54f2cf6f0cf2b36214b2d6a6/Localizing-a-global-amusement-park-Hong-Kong-
online https://www.herosmyth.com/article/9-perfect-brand-examples-why-it-pays-
Guo W, (2014). What Affects Theme Park Performance: A Comparative Case Study of
[Accessed on 20-4-2021]
https://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/25/business/worldbusiness/disney-bows-to-feng-shui.html
[Accessed on 22-4-2021]
Huang Ge., (2017). Shanghai Disney harvests first-year success – Global Times. Retrieved
Ijidola V., (2018). 6 Amazing Brand Awareness Campaign Examples & Ideas. Retrieved
Jones M., (2019). Hong Kong Disneyland Chinese New Year 2019. Retrieved online
2021]
Kaemingk D., (2019). What is Brand Image and how do you measure it. Retrieved online
20
Kuboto Y., (2008). Tokyo Disney Resort faces declining visitor base. Retrieved online
https://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/15/technology/15iht-disney.1.11993601.html [Accessed
on 24-4-2021]
Lasher D., (2018). 15 Things Disneyland In The US Did Much Better (10 Japan Nailed).
Levine A., (2016). Bob Iger: Shanghai Disney isn't just Disneyland in China. Retrieved
online https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/experience/america/2016/06/23/bob-iger-
https://medium.com/writ-150-at-usc-fall-2020/the-failure-of-disneys-mulan-in-china-
Liu Y., (2019). Hong Kong Disneyland left empty amid protest. Retrieved online
https://www.inkstonenews.com/business/protests-cause-sharp-drop-hong-kong-tourist-
Matthews D., (2019). How Building Partnerships Improves Brand Awareness. Retrieved
online https://salespop.net/marketing/how-building-partnerships-improves-brand-awareness/
[Accessed on 6-5-2021]
https://www.mbaskool.com/business-concepts/marketing-and-strategy-terms/7351-brand-
21
Neate R. & Farrel S., (2014). Disneyland Paris forced to ask for €1bn emergency rescue.
Niles R., (2017). What does Hong Kong Disneyland need to reverse its slide? Retrieved
Niles R., (2019). Attendance up, but revenue down at Tokyo Disney. Retrieved online
Novela S., (2017). Case Study Disney in France for Cross Culture Management. Retrieved
online https://bbs.binus.ac.id/ibm/2017/06/case-study-disney-in-france-for-cross-culture-
Pahwa A., (2021). What Is Brand Image? – Importance & Examples. Retrieved online
Papirfly, (2019). Customer brand equity and understanding Keller’s brand equity model.
Perch D., (2020). Brand Identity and Elements of Apple. Retrieved online
Piontek K., (2019). How to strengthen your brand with your marketing strategy. Retrieved
2021]
22
Pozzebon S., (2014). Why Euro Disney Is A 22-Year Money-Losing Failure. Retrieved
online https://www.businessinsider.com/euro-disney-announces-1-billion-crisis-plan-2014-10
[Accessed on 6-5-2021]
Pritchett A., (2017). The Real Reason Why Attendance at Disney Parks Has Dropped.
Roberts H., (2018). 12 Examples of Great Brand Positioning Strategy (2019 Update).
Schreiber B. A., (2020). Disneyland | History & Facts | Britannica. Retrieved online
2021]
Sharkov D., (2016). Disneyland Paris Posts Record Losses in Year After Terror Attacks.
Shaw A. A., (2018). Brand Image Examples and Importance. Retrieved online
Tang P., (2012). BBC – Travel – Different Disneylands around the world. Retrieved online
http://www.bbc.com/travel/story/20121213-different-disneylands-around-the-world
[Accessed on 14-4-2021]
23
Tessa H., (2019). Disneyland Paris Returned Profit First Time in a Decade! Retrieved online
https://chipandco.com/disneyland-paris-returned-profit-first-time-in-a-decade-346721/
[Accessed on 8-5-2021]
Thomala L. L., (2020). Hong Kong Disneyland attendance 2019 | Statista. Retrieved online
https://www.statista.com/statistics/236183/attendance-at-the-hong-kong-disneyland-theme-
Tsang D., (2019). Struggling Hong Kong Disneyland raises one-day entrance fees by 3 per
cent, the fifth price increase at the park since it opened in 2005. Retrieved online
https://www.thestar.com.my/news/regional/2019/04/24/struggling-hong-kong-disneyland-
Tschinkel A., (2019). 10 of the biggest ways Disney parks around the world are different.
UKEssays, (2018). Why Did Euro Disney Fail But Disneyland Successed History Essay.
Walgrove A., (2019). How to Increase Brand Awareness: Full guide & Strategy. Retrieved
Wong N., (2020). What Disney’s Mulan got wrong about Chinese culture. Retrieved online
https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/leisure/2020/09/25/what-disneys-mulan-got-
Yao J., (2017). Research on marketing strategy: case study of Disneyland. Retrieved online
24
Yuan W., (2019). Disney’s Glocalization in Shanghai: the emotional branding strategy.
2021]
4-2021]
Zhao R., (2014). Localization of Walt Disney’s Parks and Resorts. Retrieved online
https://ruiqianzhaoeportfolio.files.wordpress.com/2014/03/localizationdisneyland.pdf
[Accessed on 16-4-2021]
Zimmer M., (2019). The Importance of Brand Awareness (and How to Build It). Retrieved
online https://info.zimmermarketing.com/blog/the-importance-of-brand-awareness-and-how-
25