Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By
Ir. Dr. Gue Chang Shin
csgue@gnpgroup.com.my Date: 11th December 2021
© G&P Professionals Sdn Bhd Quality Services - Our Commitment
Introduction
Take Away…..
© G&P Professionals Sdn Bhd Quality Services - Our Commitment
Contents
➢Introduction
➢Procedures – Inception to Verifications
➢Design & Construction
Pop
➢Common Misconceptions Quizzes
➢Construction Issues
➢Case Studies
➢Summary
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Introduction
When To Use Pile Foundations?
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Contents
➢Introduction
➢Procedures – Inception to Verifications
➢Design & Construction
➢Common Misconceptions
➢Construction Issues
➢Case Studies
➢Summary
Site f’
Desk Study c’
Reconnaissance Subsurface SPT ’N’
Investigation
Interpretations
Optimisation of Soil
Parameters
Value
Engineering
Qs = skin friction
Qb = end bearing
Overburden Soil Layer
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Pile Structural Capacity Qall = Allowable pile
⚫ Concrete Pile capacity
Qall = 0.25 x fcu x Ac fcu = characteristic
strength of concrete
fy = yield strength of steel
⚫ Steel Pile
Ac = cross sectional area
Qall = 0.3 x fy x As of concrete
As = cross sectional area
of steel
⚫ Prestressed Concrete Pile
Qall = 0.25 (fcu – Prestress after loss) x Ac
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Pile Geotechnical Capacity
Semi-Empirical Method – Correlations with SPT’N’
Qsu Qbu
Qu,Geo = fs x As + fb x Ab
Qu,Geo = Ultimate geotechnical capacity of the pile
fs = Shaft resistance (as x SPT’N’), where as is the friction
factor
As = Surface area of pile shaft
fb = Base resistance of pile
Ab = Cross sectional area of pile base
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Single Pile Capacity Design
Based on Modified Meyerhof (1976)
Pile Geotechnical In In Cohesionless
Capacity Cohesive Soil Soil*
Ult. Shaft Friction 2.5N 2.0N
(Qsu)
Ult. Base capacity 250N or 9su 250 – 400N
(Qbu)
su = Undrained Shear Strength N = SPT’N’
*Note: Correlations for driven piles. Research by G&P indicates the correlations
may be too conservative for jack-in piles
Beware of base cleaning for bored piles!!
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
• Base cleaning of bored piles
– Difficult and no practical
means of verification
during construction
• Minimal base contribution in
bored pile design, unless
proper base cleaning can be
assured and verified (or base
grouting, etc.)
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Borehole
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Variation of soil profile at the site.
What to do?
Hard Layer
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Variation of soil profile at the site.
Zoning and Grouping of Piles
27 m
15 m
21 m
12 m
12 m with preboring 10 m
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
RC Square Piles
⚫Size : 150 to 400mm
⚫Lengths : up to 12m
⚫Structural Capacity : 25 to 185Ton
⚫Material : Grade 40MPa Concrete
or higher
⚫Joints: Welded
⚫Installation Method :
–Hydraulic Hammer
–Jack-In
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Pre-Stressed Concrete Spun Piles
⚫Size : 250 to 600mm (1000mm near shore)
⚫Lengths : up to 12m (Typical)
⚫Structural Capacity :
62-72 Tons & 276-394 Tons
⚫Material : Grade 80 & 90MPa
⚫Joints: Welded
⚫Installation Method :
–Hydraulic Hammer
–Jack-In
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Spun Piles Vs RC Square Piles
Spun Piles have …
•Better Bending Resistance
•Higher Axial Capacity
•Better Manufacturing Quality
•Able to Sustain Higher Driving Stresses
•Higher Tensile Capacity
•Easier to Check Integrity of Pile
•Similar cost as RC Square Piles
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Pile Installation Methods
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Limits of Driven & Jack-in piles?
• Jack-in piles up to 50N
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Diesel drop Hydraulic
hammer driving hammer driving
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Jack-in piles
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Jack-in piles
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Bored Piles (Large Diameter Cast
In-Situ Piles)
• Size : 450mm to 2m
(Up to 3.0m for special case)
• Lengths : Varies
• Structural Capacity : 140Ton to 2750Tons
• Concrete Grade : 40MPa- (Tremie)
• Joints : None
• Installation Method : Drill then Cast-In-Situ
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Drilling
Bored Pile Construction
Bedrock
Advance Drilling
Bored Pile Construction
Bedrock
Drilling & Advance
Bored Pile Construction
Casing
Bedrock
Drill to Bedrock
Bored Pile Construction
Bedrock
Lower
Borepile
Bored PileConstruction
Construction
Reinforcement
Cage
Bedrock
Lower Tremie
Bored Pile Construction
Chute
Bedrock
Pour Tremie
Bored Pile Construction
Concrete
Bedrock
Completed
Borepile
Bored PileConstruction
Construction
Borepile
Bedrock
Design & Construction
Bored Pile Construction
Bored Pile Drilling Machine
BG22
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Drilling
Lowering
reinforcement
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Place tremie concrete
Completed bored pile
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
When to use which type of foundation ?
Cost Time
Site Soil
Constraint Condition
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Cost? Cost Increasing
•Hammer Driving
•Jacked-In
•Prebore Then Drive/Jacked In
•Bored piles
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
Pile Verification Test? Why Need?
▪ Verify Safety Margin of Pile Design (Limit State Condition)
▪ Verify Settlement performance (Serviceability State Condition)
▪ Load Transfer Behaviour (Optimisation / Value Engineering)
❖ Time consuming
❖ Expensive
❖ Require a big
space
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Design & Construction
VW Load Cell
Hydraulic Jack
Extensometer
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Common Misconceptions
Misconception in piling #1
Myth:
Pile Achieves Capacity When It is Set.
✓ Truth:
Pile May Only “Set” on Intermediate
Hard Layer BUT May Still Not Achieve
Required Capacity within Allowable
Settlement.
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Common Misconceptions
Misconception in piling #2
Myth:
Dynamic Formulae such as Hiley’s Formula
Tells us the Capacity of the Pile
✓ Truth:
Pile Capacity can only be verified by using:
▪ Maintained (Static) Load Tests
▪ Dynamic Tests
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Common Misconceptions
Misconception in piling #3
Myth:
Pile settlement at 2 times working load must
be less than certain magnitude (e.g. 38mm)
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Common Misconceptions
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Common Misconceptions
✓ Truth:
Jack-in piles can be used for high-rise buildings
and limestone formation
▪ With proper design and input from
experienced geotechnical engineer
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Contents
➢Introduction
➢Procedures – Inception to Verifications
➢Design & Construction
➢Common Misconceptions
➢Construction Issues
➢Case Studies
➢Summary
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Problems of
Defective pile shoe
defective pile head
& overdriving!
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Pile stacking
• Reject piles with cracks
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Failure in Soft Ground
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Presence of Cavity!
Solution
Detect Cavities through Cavity Probing then
perform Compaction Grouting
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Karstic features of Kuala Lumpur Limestone
(after Chan, S.F. & Hong, L.P. 1985)
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Pile Sitting on
Limestone with
Cavity
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Application of
Building Load
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Application of
Building Load
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Building Collapse
Pile Plunges !
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
PILING IN FILL GROUND
Important Points to Note:
•High Consolidation Settlements If Original Ground is
Soft
•Uneven Settlement Due to Uneven Fill Thickness
•Collapse Settlement of Fill Layer If Not Compacted
Properly
Results in …
•Negative Skin Friction (NSF) & Crushing of Pile Due to
High Compressive Stresses
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Effect of NSF …
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Settlement
Exposed Pile
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Conventional Foundation for
Low Rise Buildings
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Conventional Foundation for
Low Rise Buildings (Soil Settlement)
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Comparison
Building on Piles Building on Piled Strips
Fill
25-30m
Soft
Clay
Strip
System
Stiff
Stratum
Hard Layer
© G&P Professionals Sdn Bhd Quality Services - Our Commitment
Comparison (after settlement)
Building on Piles Building on Piled Strips
Fill
25-30m
Soft
Clay Strip
System
Stiff
Stratum
Hard Layer
© G&P Professionals Sdn Bhd Quality Services - Our Commitment
Construction Issues
Beware of pile length issue -
TEMPERED measuring tape
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Beware of rock coring issues
Recommended definition of rock
coring to fulfill all three (3) criteria:
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Construction Issues
Failure of supervision
Design Engineer is
Responsible for
Construction
Supervision!
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Contents
➢Introduction
➢Procedures – Inception to Verifications
➢Design & Construction
➢Common Misconceptions
➢Construction Issues
➢Case Studies
➢Summary
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Case Studies
Bistari Condominiums, KL
Concrete Raft
Fill / Alluvium
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Case Studies
Bistari Condominiums, KL
➢Alternative design has reduced the
foundation cost by more than 50%,
➢A saving of more than RM5 million.
➢An Award of Merit (1998) was given by
ACEM.
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Case Studies
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Case Studies
Ground Level
Basement 1
Basement 2
Basement 3
Original
Basement 4
Basement 5
Ground Level
Basement 1
Alternative by G&P
Basement 2
Basement 3
Basement 4
BASEMENT OMITTED
Savings :
1. RS Wall omitted
2. Piling below RS Wall omitted
3. Reduce one level basement → Still same Carparks
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Contents
➢Introduction
➢Procedures – Design to Verifications
➢Design & Construction
➢Common Misconceptions
➢Construction Issues
➢Case Studies
➢Summary
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Summary
✓Pile foundation from
inception to verifications
✓Proper Subsurface Investigation
to establish the subsurface profile
✓Selection of Suitable Pile
✓Pile Design Concepts
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Summary
✓Understand the common
misconceptions
✓Mitigate typical
construction issues
✓Importance of Piling
Supervision
✓Case Histories – Value
Engineering
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Summary
Proper Geotechnical
Input & Design Avoid Common
Pitfalls
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
Summary
Always THINK
What Can Go Wrong!
Can it be Constructed
SAFELY & Performed
as Designed?
©Intro
G&P Professionals
– Procedures Sdn
– Bhd
Design Quality
& Constr. – Misconception – Constr. Issues – Case Services
Studies - Our Commitment
– Summary
ON A FINAL NOTE
With regard to geotechnical engineering:
“There are no weak soils or rocks, there
are only weak engineers”.
▪ Colleagues at G&P
Watch now
© G&P Professionals Sdn Bhd Quality Services - Our Commitment