You are on page 1of 6

ARTICLE IN PRESS

Perspective

Transitional Leadership:
Leadership During Times of
Transition, Key Principles, and
Considerations for Success
Alexander Norbash, MD, MS

Rationale and Objectives: To suggest a methodical approach for refining transitional management abilities, including empowerment
of a growing leader, leading in an unfamiliar organization or leading in an organization that is changing.
Materials and Methods: Management approaches based on the body of work dealing with leadership studies and transitions and
dealing with leadership during times of transition and change management were consolidated and categorized.
Results: Transitional leaders can benefit from effective leadership training including defining and prospectively accruing necessary ex-
periences and skills; strengthening information gathering skills; effectively self-assessing; valuing and implementing mentoring; formulating
strategy; and communicating.
Conclusions: A categorical approach to transitional leadership may be implemented through a systems-based and methodical ap-
proach to gaining the definable, and distinct sets of skills and abilities necessary for transitional leadership success.
Key Words: Leadership; change; transition; management.
© 2017 The Association of University Radiologists. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

INTRODUCTION concerned, typically not having had to bear such responsi-


bilities. In such cases, new section heads may need to learn

S
ection chiefs and department chairs are often re-
about new domains of knowledge such as mentoring systems
cruited for leadership positions as external candidates.
and approaches. New department chairs similarly need to
These leaders try to adapt to increased responsibility
learn about a new and expanded domain of financial
while trying to understand an unfamiliar organization. Es-
management, in addition to assuming responsibility for
tablished leaders may also find their own familiar organization
strategy setting in areas that they may be unfamiliar with. A
changing, either intentionally or unintentionally. These all can
department chair who is a neuroradiologist still assumes
be considered examples of transitional leadership.
responsibility for the institutional strategy where musculo-
Section chiefs, such as a neuroradiology section chief,
skeletal imaging is concerned, necessitating effective and
may step into a position requiring strategic direction setting,
expanded delegation. Delegation itself is an essential task for
service schedule formulation and maintenance, professional
leaders who may have received little formal attention in
development of their sectional faculty, and interfacing with
new leaders’ preceding posts.
non-neuroradiologists where policy and process are con-
Promotions in the case of both section chiefs and depart-
cerned. Department chairs will often be responsible for the
ment chairs can happen internally or externally. An individual
same responsibilities on an expanded departmental rather
promoted internally may be seen as being given systemic en-
than sectional scale, in addition to having greater budgetary
dorsement for an existing strategy and culture, whereas new
and financial responsibilities. New section heads may be
imported leaders may believe they carry a more substantial
challenged by the increased responsibility they face where
change mandate. Similarly, an internal promotion may be seen
scheduling and the professional development of others are
as undervalued and therefore securing a lesser recruitment
package. Presumably, an outsider in most instances necessi-
Acad Radiol 2017; ■:■■–■■
tates a higher minimum activation energy than an insider to
From the University of California, San Diego, School of Medicine, 402 Dickinson
Street, Suite 454, San Diego, CA 92103. Received September 23, 2016; revised motivate the outside candidate’s move to a new institution
January 1, 2017; accepted January 5, 2017. Address correspondence to: A.N. and possibly a new geographic location. To an even greater
e-mail: anorbash@ucsd.edu
degree, a temporary or ad interim position is considered limited
© 2017 The Association of University Radiologists. Published by Elsevier Inc.
All rights reserved.
in negotiating ability, because the negotiation position is even
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acra.2017.01.005 weaker than a permanent internal candidate.

1
NORBASH Academic Radiology, Vol ■, No ■■, ■■ 2017

Whether leaders or their organizations are in transition, with the passage of time. As financial margins in academic
certain principles and considerations are supported by the lead- radiology departments have diminished, the cross-funding op-
ership body of knowledge. These considerations include portunities for education and unreimbursed research have been
introspection and thought, information gathering and anal- threatened (8). The unique value of academic radiology de-
ysis, and an understanding of group psychology and effective partments is best demonstrated where translational research
communication and engagement (1–7). These tasks and ap- is concerned, specifically referring to the early and facilitated
proaches can be integrated into a series of actions timed far adoption of research initiatives directly into patient care.
in advance of seeking a leadership role, during the assess- At the same time as translational research is optimized and
ment phase, soon after assuming a new role, and for long- facilitated, academic systems are finding the need to explore
term security in a new leadership role (Table 1). and succeed at adaptive models including partnerships, ex-
Introspection is needed when self-assessing one’s skills and panded relationships, mergers, and acquisitions. Much of the
disposition. Information gathering and analysis is needed when present work involves system combinations where academic
learning about leadership, when performing a reconnais- medical centers are integrated with or asked to work along-
sance of the environment, and when securing the right human side community hospitals. Integrating such different cultures
resources. An understanding of group psychology and effec- and businesses is neither natural nor straightforward.
tive communication and engagement is necessary when Community hospitals do not focus on translational re-
correctly positioning oneself as a leader between upper man- search and do not have a history of recognizing and valuing
agement and one’s charges, when setting clear priorities, and the research mission. As such, because the added cost and in-
when focusing on the professional fulfillment of one’s charges. efficiency of discovery and education are not universally
In this report, “led entity” is intended to refer to the part appreciated, the community-based partners cannot readily rec-
of an organization that is led by the transitioning leader, and ognize or assess the essential nature of translational research.
“housing organization” refers to the larger organization in which To succeed in this space, academic medical centers will need
the led entity is contained. As an example and from the per- to more transparently demonstrate the value of discovery and
spective of a transitional leader who is a radiology department translation where clinical care and population health are con-
chair, the led entity is the radiology department, and the housing cerned, and to communicate it with their new nonacademic
organization is the larger academic medical center. For an partners.
interventional radiology chief, the led entity is the interventional
radiology section, and the immediate housing organization is
the radiology department. The led entity and housing orga- INTROSPECTION AND THOUGHT
nization do not always have the same hopes and expectations Appropriate Self-assessment
for the transitional leader.
Arguably, the degree of difficulty in managing the tripar- Honest introspection is necessary when assessing essential skills
tite academic radiology units and departments has increased and disposition and one’s own suitability for a job. Leadership

TABLE 1.

When to Act What to Do


Before seeking a leadership role Secure leadership training.
Gain essential skills and experiences to be competitive.
Assess your own abilities to lead.
Assemble a panel of mentors.
While assessing a leadership opportunity Perform an organizational reconnaissance.
Assess the organization's STARS* state and leadership need.
Identify whether you possess the essential skills and disposition to succeed.
Soon after assuming a new leadership role Build your own leadership team.
Connect with line managers to establish control.
Define a strategic intent.
Establish major priorities and goals.
For long-term security in a new leadership role Establish mentoring systems for the employees.
Assure the quality and success of your line managers.
Ensure professional development of employees as a top priority.

The table includes individual considerations for a transitional leader, in each of four time spans. One set of considerations is appropriate
before seeking a leadership role. A second set is intended for consideration as a leadership opportunity is being assessed. A third set is
intended for implementation soon after assuming a new leadership role, and a fourth and final set of tasks is suggested for long-term
security.
* Start-up, turnaround, accelerated growth, realignment, sustained success (Watkins (4)).

2
Academic Radiology, Vol ■, No ■■, ■■ 2017 LEADERSHIP DURING TIMES OF TRANSITION

transitions are among the most challenging times in a pro- Reconnaissance


fessional’s life, and it is helpful to develop insightful skills in
Learning about an organization happens through organizing
developing mindfulness (1).
to learn and to understand the culture, the management, and
There are a number of character traits and values the emerg-
the employees. Organizing to learn necessitates identifying the
ing leader should reflect on and consider developing. Emerging
best sources of information, understanding how the learning
leaders should consider their own disposition and motiva-
process can be accelerated, and figuring out what needs to
tion and their ability to delegate. Leaders should consider their
be learned (4).
ability to multitask, absorb, and act on large amounts of in-
Effective leaders provide increasing autonomy to front-
complete information, and to engage in “open awareness”
line managers, carefully considering hierarchy and structure,
where an individual perceives events and experiences sur-
while maximizing information gathering and processing. Ef-
rounding himself or herself in a nonjudgmental manner (1,2).
fective and strategic leaders and organizations pool and leverage
The emerging leader should possess self-control and empathy
distinctive competencies to the greatest degree possible. Ad-
(2) while recognizing that part of the job almost by neces-
vanced organizational forms are also known as entrepreneurial
sity involves dealing with conflict (1).
networks (5).
Integrity, outstanding communication skills, self-awareness,
Organizational transformation includes three approaches: re-
and focus are highly valued in leaders (1–4). Successful leaders
structuring, revitalization, and renewal. Restructuring includes
accept responsibilities for their failures. The denial of falli-
downsizing and overhauling both processes and structures to return
bility or fault by a leader can only adversely affect the perception
to profitability, which also includes the realization that individu-
the organization has of the leader. Denial of fallibility ulti-
als more often than not have to be let go. Revitalization refers
mately contributes to a dysfunctional culture of unfairness and
to improving on core competencies to address an erosion or a
finger-pointing (1).
diminished position before restructuring is necessary. Revital-
ization may include developing or acquiring competencies, creating
INFORMATION GATHERING AND ANALYSIS alliances, and building opportunities. Renewal consists of con-
Learning About Leadership
tinuous engagement and increasing efficiency, building new
capabilities, and rejuvenating strategies (5).
Leadership training includes didactic education and formal train- Characteristics of leaders and successful leadership have been
ing, as well as experiences and skills, and should be secured analyzed and assessed, with varying frameworks applied to these
in advance of leadership investiture. There is a tendency for observations. One framework describes adaptive leadership,
leaders to employ previously successful strategies in new cir- where effective leaders in a critical and fast-moving instance
cumstances, situations, and roles; leadership training suggests may as one example need and choose to be authoritarian rather
examining and understanding a new environment before re- than inclusive as may otherwise be their tendency and prac-
flexively employing familiar approaches and techniques that tice. This framework suggests that leaders can adapt to the
may fail (4). Problems may superficially appear similar yet situation and behave in a differing variety of manners as situ-
demand dissimilar solutions. ations dictate such need.
Leadership training similar to a technical or clinical disci- Another type of framework describes archetypes of lead-
pline consists of a dedicated body of knowledge. Leadership ership and how these archetypes may relate to the context of
training includes not only study but also skills and experi- failure or success in an organization. This latter framework
ences that refine and reframe the leader’s behavior and reactions tends to describe leadership traits without assuming that a leader
(1). The time to learn about leadership and to accrue the es- can necessarily adapt dramatically to situational needs. Such a
sential experiences and skills is before one is called upon to framework intends to describe character traits of the primar-
exercise those skills and abilities. ily fixed-affect leader, with an understanding of how the leader
Formal leadership training often includes a combination of may consequently fit or succeed. One eight-archetype frame-
curricular training whether web-based or in a classroom setting, work describes strategists, change catalysts, transactors, builders,
in addition to accrual of competencies through increasing re- innovators, processors, coaches, and communicators (9). A “strat-
sponsibilities. Suitably inclined management and business egist” provides vision and sees leadership as a chess game. A
schools, the armed forces, and corporations typically provide “change catalyst” is passionate where re-engineering and cre-
leadership training, although the format can vary. Leader- ating a new direction or turning around an organization are
ship training can be provided through degree- or certificate- concerned, and relishes the opportunity to leave his or her
based management training. Large corporations, some of which personal signature on an organization. A “transactor” is a
employ more than 100,000 employees, have made consid- dealmaker and thrives on negotiations. A “builder” sees lead-
erable investments in creating widely recognized in-house ership as entrepreneurial and has the talent and determination
formal leadership training and certification programs. In most to forge new solutions while thriving on creativity. An “in-
instances of leadership training, the accrual of competencies novator” is driven by creativity on that which is new and focuses
includes team building, organizational thinking, communi- on extremely difficult problems. A “processor” focuses on systems
cation, and the professional development of others (1). and structures, and is driven by the pursuit of efficiency and

3
NORBASH Academic Radiology, Vol ■, No ■■, ■■ 2017

transparency. A “coach” is focused on the development of There is a need to build consensus, to ensure that the orga-
individuals to realize their potential, creates a high-performance nization and its members assume ownership of problems, and
culture, and understands how to motivate individuals. A “com- to ensure that collective change is enabled through consen-
municator” is an influencer and sees the effectiveness in their sus and a change mandate (4).
role in stage and message management. An organization facing accelerated growth is rapidly ex-
Depending on the state of the transitioning organization, panding and enjoying tremendous success along with growing
there may be different demands on the entering leader. At pains. Such an organization needs systems and structures that
certain key points in their evolution, organizations face tran- allow it to continue scaling up, as its needs to surpass the systems
sitions. There are five common transition states for an and structures that allowed it to reach its current state (4).
organization that characterize the nature of these organiza- An organization characterized by sustained success is stable
tions at a specific point in time. This characterization determines and successful, and has been led by a highly regarded leader
both the range of successful strategies and the leadership style with a healthy culture and effective systems and processes. The
that a leader should employ. These five states include start- challenge to a new leader entering sustained success is the chal-
ups, turnarounds, accelerated growth, realignment, and lenge of living in the shadow of an overshadowing predecessor
sustaining success. Not all of these transitional states are nec- with successful processes and people who will be skeptical of
essarily experiences by organizations; these states can be exited change. Managing evolution and transformation is necessary
and re-entered, and these states do not have to occur in any in any organization or industry; such evolution is complicat-
particular order. The acronym for these states is “STARS” ed by much of the previously successful structure and
(4). Start-ups, accelerated growth, and sustaining success possess management team being in place, and being accustomed to
growth challenges and demand different leadership styles com- their own collective historical success (4).
pared to turnarounds and realignments, both of which warn There is a tendency in managers to employ SWOT anal-
organizations of potential failure. yses when considering new or unfamiliar situations. In health-
A start-up is an organization that is launching a newly es- care settings, a simple and historic SWOT analysis may be
tablished business. The new business may be recognizable or underpowered (11). SWOT, a long-standing management and
extremely novel. In such instances, there is a need for the leader strategic planning acronym, refers to “strengths, weaknesses,
to generate creative ideas, to bring their creation into being opportunities, and threats.” Strengths and weaknesses are con-
through the application of talent, determination, and trans- sidered internal to the organization, whereas opportunities and
actions. Start-up leaders also need to provide vision and threats deal with and refer to external factors and agents. There
articulate it effectively to ensure future growth. As a start- are four premises involved in determining the suitability of
up takes root and eventually grows successfully to a sustained SWOT analyses in management instances, and these prem-
organization, the organization may well need a leader as coach ises do not apply to health care. The four organizational
and, ultimately with an increasing scale and scope of success, premises and conditions include strategy being led from the
a leader as processor, developing essential systems that can carry apex of an organization rather than including lower level man-
an organization into maturity. agers, the organization being autonomous rather than
An organization facing turnaround is in crisis. Typically, interdependent, the organization having clear rather than fuzzy
a turnaround involves unexpected or abrupt change. In such demarcations, and finally having a clear and rational hierar-
an instance, there has been poor performance that jeopar- chy and framework determining decision making rather than
dizes the existence of the entity, and the unexpected or abrupt being led by intuition and vision or being affected dynami-
change is essential to continued financial or organizational sur- cally by prospectively unanticipated variables.
vival. The leadership style that succeeds in such an organization Given the dynamic nature of health care, where dynamic
is autocratic or heroic leadership (10). The leader has to imbue and potentially shifting partnerships contribute to success and
the organization with a sense of confidence and hope, while failure, a more successful and accurate modified or alterna-
changing the trajectory of the led-unit, through applying new tive SWOT framework likely should include the nature and
solutions and structures. This leadership style demands rapid expectations of stakeholders. Where health care is con-
action, leaps of faith on the part of the organization where cerned, stakeholders are numerous and not necessarily fully
following the leader is concerned, and high levels of confi- inside the walls. Stakeholders’ expectations also play a central
dence and decisiveness from the leader (4). part in strategic analysis. The appropriate method for strate-
A realignment state refers to a previously successful orga- gic planning in health care likely needs to include rational
nization that is failing to live up to its potential. Such an planning, in addition to a focus on stakeholder expectations,
organization is in need of being re-energized and fine- contextual factors, and a full understanding of how various
tuned, although the need for significant change may not be resources can help determine or serve to derail success.
self-evident to all. The new leader’s job includes convincing
the organizational constituencies that there are significant and Securing the Right Human Resources
urgent problems demanding solutions. Realignment demands
stewardship rather than heroic leadership, because much of Appropriate human resources are essential for success. This
the leader’s work includes establishing the need for change. includes one’s own management team. This also includes

4
Academic Radiology, Vol ■, No ■■, ■■ 2017 LEADERSHIP DURING TIMES OF TRANSITION

resources that are beneficial when a crisis occurs or assis- future. Time and energy should be dedicated to establishing
tance is sought. Such examples of resources include securing these relationships, and there should be an intent to inte-
standard operating procedures for dismissing faculty, for cre- grate the members’ feedback effectively into the new leader’s
ating corrective plans or assembling performance improvement strategy and tactics (14).
plans, for identifying and assembling a contact list with in-
dividuals in faculty affairs or in hospital and university
administration who expect to be involved with corrective plans UNDERSTANDING GROUPS AND ENGAGING
and dismissal proceedings. It helps to know who to ask for EFFECTIVELY
help in a variety of circumstances, and also to assemble a panel
of mentors outside the organization and a list of potential Effective Positioning
troubleshooters once significant challenges are encountered. If the transitional leader identifies with or aligns too closely
It is helpful to meet such future troubleshooters before they with management, they risk losing effective connection with
are actually needed. Such resources include formal organiza- their charges. Alternatively, if the transitional leader is iden-
tional officers such as the chief medical officer, the chief tified too closely with their employees, then they may lose
operations officer, the vice president responsible for radiol- the confidence of their employers. Effective positioning
ogy operations, and the vice president for human resources. demands determination of a safe and successful middle
It is also helpful to have met with appropriate legal counsel, ground (5).
human resources departments and representatives, and infor- Investiture and hiring takes place through senior manage-
mal institutional sages and resources who may be the sources ment. This authority is of little value, however, if the employees
of significant informal authority. It is also wise to identify and fail to recognize the transitional leader. To have ongoing
gain familiarity with potential and essential allies. support for their decisions, to effectively engage their em-
Building the right leadership team includes identifying po- ployees, and to mobilize the actions necessary to achieve
tential assets internal and external to the organization that their goals, leaders have to earn the trust of their employees.
can help assemble a loyal core of change agents. Such a team Employees expect fair and appreciative work environments,
has to be quickly assembled to ensure early success (4). Middle and expect to have their voices heard (5,7). A successful leader
managers are subordinate to the senior or executive manage- is able to transactionally satisfy all essential stakeholders and
ment and are responsible for at least a definable layer of staff. employees (5).
Senior or executive managers are considered the highest man-
agement layer of an organization. An example of a middle
manager is the technical director for a radiology department Setting Clear Priorities
who may oversee, among many other managers, a magnetic
resonance imaging technologist manager and CT technolo- Effective transitional leaders formulate and clearly commu-
gist manager and a fluoroscopy technologist manager, and nicate major initiatives. Failure or success during the transitional
the technical director himself or herself reports to a health period is critical to predicting overall failure or success in the
system vice president for essential services. In such an in- job, and failing to set expectations sets the leader up for failure
stance, the magnetic resonance imaging, CT, and fluoroscopy (1,14). Within the first 90 days, it is important for the new
technical managers are considered line managers, and the leader to rapidly and effectively onboard or acquire the nec-
vice president for essential services is considered a senior or essary knowledge to become an effective organizational
executive manager. Without at least 75% of middle manag- member, create a management team, verbalize and clarify ex-
ers on the leader’s side and helping lead necessary change, pectations, and engineer and ensure early wins (13,14). Effective
the transitioning leader is courting failure (6). Alignments dialogue is a hallmark of successful organizations (15). Once
and alliances are necessary for both protection and growth. collateral is established through early successes and the grad-
Alliances may be within the walls of the housing organiza- ually increasing confidence of the organization in the new
tion or external to the walls (4). leader, mistakes will then be more easily forgiven (4).
In the event that a new leader enters an unwelcoming Establishing major priorities consists of identifying the pri-
organization, it is important for the new leader to demon- orities that are prerequisites for success. These should be small
strate control. Predecessors do not consistently create effective in number, clearly within the wheelhouse of the organiza-
succession plans or willingly transition out of a leadership tion and leadership, with a high likelihood of achievement,
position (12). Constant and continuous initial communica- and accomplished within the first year (4). Major priorities
tion with line managers is of critical importance early on, as may not be self-evident, and in fact may need to be derived
is the demonstration of humility by the leader in addition to through a strategic planning process. In defining a strategic
an overt desire and willingness to learn from line managers. intent, the leader must initially develop a verbalized vision
Showing vulnerability establishes credibility in such in- for a better or optimized future that is optimistic and realis-
stances. It is also important to allow members of the team a tic, and has to effectively communicate this vision to the
chance to share concerns and to give feedback, which ulti- organization and employees. The strategy should clearly lead
mately allow them to be part of the crafted vision and new to realizing the verbalized vision (4).

5
NORBASH Academic Radiology, Vol ■, No ■■, ■■ 2017

When a transformation is taking place, changes can be ac- may need to address the need to be more communicative and
celerated and better tolerated where employees perceive their inclusive, to support generativity, and to intentionally promote
voice in such transformations. Employee participation at an and foster activities and behaviors that are conducive to
early phase, including employee participation in charting strat- mentoring. Related activities may include retreats, seminars,
egy, helps to accelerate change and secure a greater degree meetings, and structural and formal related award systems.
of stability once crises are resolved (5).
Early wins should be celebrated; while thanking the em-
CONCLUSIONS
ployees increases employee confidence in change management,
celebrating wins serves to remind the organization that they A transitional state may refer to a new leader himself or herself,
have invested in and selected the right leader. Celebrating early an organization that is new to the leader, or an organization
victories energizes the ranks, builds credibility, and estab- that is changing. Transitional leadership benefits from intro-
lishes collateral for the new leader (4). spection, information gathering, an understanding of group
psychology, and effective communication. Introspection and
thought is necessary to honestly self-assess one’s skills and dis-
Focusing on the Professional Fulfillment of Your
Charges position. Leaders learn about leadership techniques and skills
in advance, and also learn about the organization and envi-
Successful leaders value and promote autonomy and creativ- ronment in which they are to lead. Leaders secure the necessary
ity, and suppress their micromanagement. Successful leaders resources to succeed, and engage their organization toward
focus on results and set goals. Creativity and innovation are positive change and securing competitive momentum. Suc-
promoted as employees are held accountable to goals. Indi- cessful transitional leaders appreciate that they are empowered
viduals take pride in results they achieve through creative and validated by their employees, and that the professional
expression as they simultaneously increase their engagement fulfillment of their employees is of paramount importance to
(7). their own security and success.
Employee involvement ranges across a spectrum of en-
gagement. Three categories include resistance, acquiescence,
REFERENCES
and empowerment. If employees do not easily identify with
goals, they are reluctant and therefore counterproductive. If 1. Itri JN, Lawson LM. Ineffective leadership. J Am Coll Radiol 2016; 13:849–
855.
opposition can be deactivated, employees may acquiesce as 2. Goleman D. The focused leader. Harv Bus Rev. 2013; Reprint R1312B.
an intermediate form but will engage incompletely and spo- 3. Brody WR, Fishman EK, Horton KM, et al. Learning about leadership by
radically. If the professional fulfillment of employees becomes making mistakes. J Am Coll Radiol 2016; 13:1109–1110.
4. Watkins MD. Picking the right transition strategy. Harv Bus Rev 2009;
an evident priority, employees reach empowerment and believe 87:46–53.
they are partners in a culture of participation. In an empow- 5. Chakravarthy B, Gargiulo M. Maintaining leadership legitimacy in the tran-
ered system, there is greater autonomy, and there is vertical sition to new organizational forms. J Manage Stud 1998; 35:437–456.
6. Kotter J. Leading change: why transformation efforts fail. Harv Bus Rev.
support for decisions and the decision-making process from 2007; Reprint R0701J.
the bottom to the top of the organization (5). 7. Rajiah P, Bhargava P. Motivational leadership: tips from the business world.
Mentoring systems and approaches also hold the promise J Am Coll Radiol 2016; 13:585–589.
8. Rawson JV, Baron RL. Balancing the three missions and the impact on
of both facilitating career development of junior faculty and academic radiology. Acad Radiol 2013; 20:1190–1194.
also improving communication within the department (16). 9. Kets de Vries MFR. The eight archetypes of leadership. HBR online. Avail-
Metrics can be utilized to measure successful mentoring, such able at: https://hbr.org/2013/12/the-eight-archetypes-of-leadership.
Accessed February 20, 2017.
as effective and timely academic advancement, the number 10. Schaeffer LD. The leadership journey. Harv Bus Rev. 2002; Reprint R0210B.
of publications per junior faculty, or effectively securing grant 11. van Wijngaarden JD, Scholten GR, van Wijk KP. Strategic analysis for
funding. Ingredients of the mentoring system may need to health care organizations: the suitability of the SWOT-analysis. Int J Health
Plann Manage 2012; 27:34–49.
include structure and culture. Structural elements include a 12. Kets de Vries MFR. The dark side of CEO succession. Harv Bus Rev.
mentoring oversight committee, a mentor matching process, 1988; Reprint 88107.
a separate process outlining expectations for the mechanics 13. de Janasz S, van der Graaf K. It’s all about day one. Harv Bus Rev. 2013;
Reprint R1306G.
of the mentoring itself such as frequency of meetings and 14. Schaffer RH. Four mistakes leaders keep making. Harv Bus Rev. 2010;
mentoring contracts, a mentoring evaluation methodology that Reprint R1009G.
measures the satisfaction of the advisees with the mentors, and 15. Charan R. Conquering a culture of indecision. Harv Bus Rev. 2006; Reprint
R0601J.
an overall process intended to measure the success and ef- 16. Illes J, Glover GH, Wexler L, et al. A model for faculty mentoring in ac-
fectiveness of the mentoring program itself. Cultural elements ademic radiology. Acad Radiol 2000; 7:717–724.

You might also like