5.
33 Comparison of Reclangular and Circular
ln this section, a conmparison between rectangular and circular Wae
Waveguid
presented. waveguides is
[Link] dominant TE mode is TE1o in a rectangular waveguide but T
circular waveguide. The dominant TM, mode in a rectangular WaeE in a
TM whereas it is TMo1 in a circular waveguide. waveguide is
2. Let us consider that a rectangular waveguide of dimension axb, whera
re a =
and a circular waveguide of radiusR have the same periphery L. Therefore
2(a+b)=L
or a = L/3
L
(5.420)
and 27TR L or R = 27T (5.421
The corresponding dominant-mode cut-off frequencies are as follows:
c Rectangular = 2a 2x=0.667L
(5.422
21 27tR L
and
NcCircular ke1l kelR
_
1.84 =0.543L (5.423)
Therefore, the cut-off frequency is lower in a circular waveguide, provided the
periphery is the same for both the waveguides.
3. Attenuation is larger in a rectangular waveguide than a circular waveguide.
WAVEGUIDES AND FINLINES 281
4 The volume of the material used in a circular waveguide is more than that used
in a rectangular waveguide. Therefore, a circular waveguide is costlier than a
rectangular waveguide.
5. A circular waveguide is much more difficult to bend than a rectangular
waveguide.