Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gilbert, Arizona
Introduction:
Our city has a fairly large population, with 261,149 people in 2021. Given the total size
for the city, it has a relatively high population density. This makes the city packed pretty close
together, and is growing at a staggering rate, which is good for productivity and economic
growth, but not for environmental improvement. There are requirements for growing
populations, and the city is getting close to capacity, while being way over sustainable
measures. More people means more resources required to support. With the main issue for our
city being water, and the city facing droughts, it does not look great for sustainable growth. But
that is why we are drafting a city wide economic and environmental plan, to provide for a
growing population that is sustainable in nature, as well as beneficial for the citizens and the
economy. But there is hope for our city. If certain goals that we lay out are met by 2030, our city
will become a model city, not only in its climate change policies and implementations, but also in
its structural integrity, supporting a more inclusive and diverse city life, supportive of all voices
Our city is slowly becoming more diverse in its population statistics, especially compared
to the national average, but the majority of the population is still largely White. White people
make up 57% of the total population of our city. This has decreased from the data in the 2011
census which shows that they made up 61% of the population. This decline could be due to
multiple factors like rising housing prices or dissatisfaction with current environmental standards.
Population growth in the region has also been driven by increased immigration in the past
decade. The White population has a large portion of the homeownership, with 80% of White
people owning their homes. This congregates into areas without rental properties, relegating
them to mostly middle income housing which will be important later on in this proposal. This also
is enforced by their median property value, which is $398,000. They are beat on a couple
different aspects of the population, but the most surprising factor is the median household
income, which for White people is $80,110. This has gone up since 2011 by about $10,000,
which is explainable due to the inflation rate in the decade that has passed. This is trumped by
the Asian population who have a staggering median household income of $101,403, which grew
The Asian population makes up 12% of the total cities population. But due to their
median household income and to their median property value, which is $418,000, they make a
significant contribution to the economy of the city. The high property value will also group the
Asian population in the areas of middle to high class living standards, similar to that of the White
population. Also like th White population, this will provide a better standard of living, allowing for
them to pay for better access to water and to have easy access to food and other services. The
Asian population also has the lowest unemployment rate of any population in the city, with an
unemployment rate of 2.25%. They also have the second highest homeownership rates, with a
75% ownership rate. For this area, it is beneficial to the city and to the culture of the city that
The African American population makes up 5.3% of the total population, but holds the
highest poverty and unemployment rates of any ethnic group residing within our city. On top of
the high rates of unemployment and the high rates of poverty, the African American population
has some of the lowest property values, and the second lowest median household income out
of the population. This puts a lot of pressure on us as project designers to help provide a plan
that will help with the economic disparities that African Amercians are facing in our city.
2
The Hispanic population is the second largest ethnic population in 2021, making up 18%
of the total population. Like the other minority groups, their percentage of the population has
increased since 2011, which allows for more of an impact on the city due to the increase in
population and as such, an increase in voice, or their ability to raise concerns over inequality
issues. But because of the low homeownership rates and the high poverty and unemployment
rates, the Hispanic population does not have access to the high standard of living options that
the White and Asian populations can. This trend is seen across the southwest, especially with
minority groups, with large populations of Hispanic and Native American groups. While we do
not have as much data on Native American tribes, their vulnerability when it comes to climate
change is just as important, and the data we do have is grim. For example, in Maricopa county,
In the Journal of Justice and Sustainability, Wilder et al. (2016) wrote about the
connection between poverty and environmental injustice. They discuss that the majority of
people who are being affected by climate change are those who are economically
disadvantaged, and those who fall into the minority category involving ethnicity. While this is
general common sense, the impacts of this association is devastating to these communities,
which is why our plan focuses on the needs of minority groups, hoping to shrink the “climate
gap” (Wilder et al., 2016). The changes needed to facilitate this shrinkage includes reduced risk
of pollution due to housing locations, housing affordability, proper precautions taken against
heat exhaustion, and access to safe, clean water, which is one of the main focuses of our plan.
The main environmental feature of our city is that it resides in a desert. An area prone to
drought as well as flash floods, settled between mountains. The city is a breeding ground for a
lot of environmental issues, which will also be covered later. The city has a lot of issues to fight
when it comes to changing climates, on top of the growing population, which can cause issues
in implementation of policies later down the road. Because the city is in a desert, there is a
3
major difference in average temps for the year compared to that of the national average. The
national average range is 39oF– 70oF throughout the year, and our city has a range of 39oF–
106oF. It is clear that this area receives more sun during the year and has very little cool periods
as the months change. This can impact a lot of different factors in the city, like agriculture,
productivity, and even water availability. Looking at the current water situation within our city is
concerning to say the least. Because there is no dedicated reservoir due to failed attempts at
storing water, our city relies on groundwater for support in its everyday usage. The groundwater
does not leave much room for expansion within the city due to the total carrying capacity of the
groundwater. Arizona has conditions throughout the state that are similar to those of our city,
and they are facing an issue with groundwater and supporting everybody with even the base
amount of water needed. “Their current Active Management Areas (AMA) plan states that there
is not enough groundwater to support even the rights that have been grandfathered from the
previous plan.” (James, 2021) So it's very clear that our city is in for a whole plethora of issues,
which is the reason we are proposing some action plans, to help offset these issues and
Like we stated before, implementing this project in a timely manner is of the utmost
importance when it comes to curbing the effects of climate change and reducing economic and
cultural inequality as a whole. Relying on the Doughnut model, are able to draft a plan to help
reduce the environmental overshoots that have as of late been mostly ignored, and bring up the
social aspects of our city to support a sustainable future economically, environmentally, and
socially.
SWOT Analysis:
Strengths Weaknesses
● University / partnership? ● Arid climate (9 in rain/year)
● Political will (people are changing their ● Poor infrastructure
4
lawns to be more climate friendly on ● Extreme heat
their own) ● Flash flood prone
● Existing solar infrastructure ● Non-walkable
● Racial inequity
Opportunities Threats
● Solar energy expansion (bonus: peak ● Groundwater contamination
power produced during peak heat) ○ Water chemical
● Electric power incentives encouraging ○ Low-high nuclear waste
people to use their power off peak ● Heat-based illnesses increasing as
hours (night-cooling houses) heat waves worsen (economic threat)
● Running out of groundwater
While this analysis doesn’t cover every single aspect of our city, it does provide a good
starting point for our climate action plan, highlighting areas that need severe help, like the
possibility of water contamination, as well as places where we can build upon current positive
infrastructure, like the current solar farms to the east of the city. Because of the climate of the
city, a lot of the weaknesses have to do with the excessive heat that our city receives throughout
the year. These include the limited water supply, the number of heat exhaustion cases, and the
overall lack of sustainable agriculture. These are also indicators of climate change, but because
of the city's climate, these effects are heightened and more widely seen between the different
social and financial classes. Which brings us to our actual climate plan. We want to address and
implement solutions to the negative aspects of our SWOT analysis, while also expanding our
strengths as well as taking our opportunities into consideration and possible implementation.
5
Climate plan:
dissecting each section to the base concepts is necessary to explaining the purpose of the
overall goal. That overall goal is to increase the standard of living in a sustainable and
economically beneficial way. While this seems very broad, it is the focus of many climate
change plans, working specifically in supporting the minority voice and tackling issues of
environmental injustice and economic inequality, while also making changes to the current
methods of production and consumption, and altering them to continue in more environmentally
conscious ways. And while our city is not high on the list of producers in the United States, there
is a high rate of consumption due to the population and the resources needed to survive in the
arid desert environment. Providing a safe living space for current residents and for future
residents is our duty as citizens and policy influencers, and as such we should do everything in
our power to see that those standards are met. Which brings us back to our ultimate goal, that
we should better the standard of living. With all of the topics we cover in our plan, it makes our
plan a mitigation based plan, focusing on stopping any further damage to the environment,
rather than adapting to changes as they come along. While some aspects of the plan are
adaptation to the current environmental crisis, they are focused on slowing any further change
in the situation that would prove to be ultimately harmful. The reason we separated our plan into
goals was so that we can discuss the different aspects of our plan in ways that could be drawn
together, encompassing them as one ultimate goal, the final indicator of our success. This
allows for a deeper dive in the specifics of each aspect, which will be rooted in the Doughnut
model, which was the framework for our plan. We want to utilize the model, analyzing how
different social and environmental aspects can still be affected by strong influential policy.
Through our analysis, we have settled on six sub-goals that fall under the umbrella of our final
goal.
6
Final goal:
For our city, we want to meet overall goals, which will help smooth out any changes to
the current climate plan in the future due to having stepping stones in place. Our goals will
provide a cleaner environment for the citizens of our city, but they will also set a standard for
both cities in similar positions as ours, and in general, the climate change plans drafted for the
country. The hope for all climate action plans in the long term is that they have a sort of domino
effect, outside of their immediate range of influence, encouraging other policy makers to follow
suit and take part in the fight against climate change. While this puts pressure on us to provide a
comprehensive plan, the concepts expressed within our goals can be applied in other areas with
different environmental and economical issues than the ones we are facing right now. Our main
goal for our city is to establish the infrastructure to supply a sustainable water source that is
capable of supporting the current population, as well as any reasonable population growth
Why?
Wanting a better environment is not a bad thing, and as such, policy advocating for a
better environment and a better standard of living shouldn’t be labeled as useless “wokism.” The
citizens of our city have seen some of the indicators of climate change first hand, due to rising
average temperatures and shrinking water supplies, it is clear that some change is needed in
So how do we achieve this? Like we discussed earlier, this goal is multifaceted and
covers a lot of topics, which requires us to split it up and tackle issues individually. We can
7
achieve our final goal by meeting our goals set forth below within our time frame, which is to
Goal 1:
Why?
everybody within the city. With a population that has grown significantly since the 2000’s, the
water usage has increased to match it. But to provide the necessary amount of water, there
This city is facing an issue with housing, mainly in the expansion of cul de sac like
structures, further straining the already weak water infrastructure. These homes are sold at high
prices, which forces people with lower incomes to live further from the water sources, placing
them in areas of disrepair and weakened infrastructure, and those are the areas that we need to
The goal is to provide water to those who don’t have ready access to it. This may require
extensive restructuring, but to supply the necessary amount of water for survival, it will be
overall beneficial to the city to support every citizen. Having a thriving population will bring
economic benefit to the city, on top of supporting those who are economically disadvantaged.
Baseline:
8
Target 1:
● Locate areas with decreased water availability, as well as areas of increased water
availability
○ Working specifically with those in low-income housing areas and populations with
○ Work with local construction agencies to get an estimate on pricing for extra
○ There is already a trend away from green lawns, which is a good indicator of the
Target 2:
Ground work
○ Obtain funding with the WIIN grant which has specifications for disadvantaged
communities (US EPA, 2019), like those of the minority populations within our city
○ Working with the federal government to be in compliance with the Clean Water
Act of 1972
● Public outreach
○ This is going to include the previous interactions with the community, but is going
9
Implementation:
● Start construction of extended water lines to areas with limited water supply
○ This will have to pass through the traditional voter process, but with the
educational outreach program that we want to implement, the votes for the
construction should increase allow for the support to arrive to those who need it
○ Green lawns
■ While this is currently on the rise, subsidizing the alternative lawns will
○ Niche agriculture
○ Start the removal process of unnecessary water features that use too much water
Goal 2:
Why?
One of the largest effectors of climate change is global carbon pollution. And every
person and company takes part in the total global pollution. The city takes part in a small
amount of industry, with the manufacturing of various products, and while light manufacturing is
10
not one of the main proponents of climate change, it still is adding to the total global carbon
emissions. The carbon pollution from the industrial district is still going to have a negative effect
Another addition to the carbon output of the city is the lack of public transport or
walkability, causing most citizens to own a car, which individually adds to the carbon output in
greater numbers than any form of public transport. The city does have a local bus network, but
that is not enough to provide for the population as well as the travel distance between the
Baseline:
Target 1:
● Draft new layouts to provide for more walkability within the city
○ This will include working with local business to provide support for transportation
● Solar farms
○ Work with the current solar power provider to evaluate the possibility of
● Asses the current carbon output from traditional power supply stations
11
○ Start the education process on the importance of remaining carbon neutral, even
energy
● Public outreach
○ Working within the community to gage the reaction to encouraged solar housing
Target 2:
Ground work
energy
○ Expanding the reach that both of these alternatives have within the city limits
○ Drafting carbon regulation policy using frameworks provided through the UBI
○ After designing the most accessible city, construction will have to start to provide
the best possible support structure for those who currently do not own vehicles,
but as well, supporting a healthier lifestyle and the expansion of the bus system
Implementation:
● Carbon regulations
12
○ This will come in the form of a carbon tax, which limits the amount of carbon
○ Reducing the number of single occupancy vehicles will greatly reduce the carbon
○ Expanding the current bus service to cover more areas of the city
■ This will involve expanding into lower income areas to provide reliable
transport to and from work for those who are out of the current limited
route
○ The 47.2 million trees in these areas store 9.0 metric tons of carbon, and
annually remove about 297,000 metric tons of carbon and 8,760 metric tons of air
carbon output
○ Provide tax cuts for companies that reach the goal for reducing carbon emissions
● Solar power
● Wind power
13
Goal 3:
Educational outreach
Why?
This climate plan does nothing without the support of the community it is designed for. Public
outreach will help inform the community about the threats that they face due to climate change
in addition to the opportunities they have for positive change. This is a partisan issue that
divides people at a national level, so we need to appeal to a local sensibility and create a sense
Additionally, we need to make sure that the adaptation plan is serving the people. We
are wary of a “top-down” approach to climate policy which limits people’s engagement, interest,
and approval. This plan must be custom-built from the ground up, starting with the needs of the
Many people don’t see this as a local issue and therefore don’t see their role in both
perpetuating and mitigating climate change. By reaching out to the community and identifying
their needs and priorities, we can better design our approach to meet those needs. Climate
change will affect everyone, but it is our responsibility to educate people about how it affects
them personally.
Baseline:
Gilbert works they have a few things explaining what's going on and how to recycle and save
water they even had an art contest that was themed on climate issues
Implementation:
14
● The Climate Mobilization
○ This is a site that tracks where climate legislation is happening and things like
that.
○ They could have this on qr codes so people can see the climate issues near
them or donate
● Model after Tree Utah, a comprehensive community education outreach program which
offers in-class lessons about heat islands and environmental sustainability for K-12
● Teaching the kids in school about the issues is another good way
○ Having students learn more about the things that are happening in their
community
○ So does britain a local artist there took over a billboard for a bank because they
Goal 4:
Why?
15
The city currently has poor public transit and the automobile-based infrastructure is worsening
As the city is growing, traffic congestion is increasing during peak hours which is
lengthening commute times. From a broad climate perspective, this is obviously bad because it
leads to more overall pollution, but it has other less obvious negative effects. For example, a
2015 Harvard study showed that one of the biggest factors preventing social mobility in poorer
NYC neighborhoods is the length commute times in those neighborhoods. Commute times will
increase for everybody as traffic worsens, but those who rely on buses. Additionally, as heat
waves increase in frequency and severity, the already unwalkable city will become hostile to
● Driving private vehicles is responsible for 55% of household carbon footprint according
Implementation:
Investing in new public transit systems, like a subway, is extremely costly and disruptive,
especially if the community isn’t in the habit of using transit. A more prudent solution is to
expand the existing systems by purchasing and operating more buses. This will be costly up
front, but it has the potential to increase overall ridership per unit of cost (Walker). Bus
frequency is a powerful driver of ridership, especially in the long run—people are more likely to
use a bus if it is ready when they want it, and reliable (Walker). Both of which will be true with
more buses in the loop. This would also have the auxiliary benefit of reducing time spent waiting
16
Green Buses
Expanding the bus lines means more buses will be necessary. We look hopefully at the
Green Bus Tax Credit Act of 2021, a bill proposed by Rep. Jimmy Panetta which would
incentivize manufacturers of electric buses with a 10% tax credit on the sale price up to
$1,000,000. Although hope is not enough to build a policy on. We think investing in buses is still
Goal 5:
Heat adaptation
Why
Heat-related deaths and illnesses are already a harsh reality in this region. The hot weather has
always been a serious risk, and it has always disproportionately affected socioeconomically
climate change in this region is the degree to which they are worsening. In the coming years,
Arizona expected to account for nearly half of the nation’s heat-related deaths (McLeod).
The extreme heat also poses other challenges. Even healthy citizens are affected by the
heat. It’s harder to work in the heat, especially in industries characterized by outdoor labor such
as construction, an industry that makes up 11% of Gilbert’s economy. These challenges will
affect the economy, costing the US up to $200 billion yearly (McLeod). These costs will be
● There was a 62.3% increase in heat-associated deaths between 2019 and 2020
● African Americans, American Indians, and those ages 75+ have the highest rates of
heat-associated death
17
Target 1: Accurate heat-related illness reporting
● Heat related deaths are increasing, but many are going unreported.
○ Maricopa County has already adjusted but there is still progress to be made
● Current models that only evaluate risk based on temperature, which fails to account for
vulnerability
● Urban forests account for only 5.3% of the land in Arizona, but those areas contain 85%
of the state’s population, according to the Arizona Department of Forestry and Fire
Management
Implementation:
Agrivoltaics
Closely monitor the results of this experimental project at the University of Arizona to
install solar panels alongside rooftop garden plots to create “agrivoltaics”. The plants work to
absorb heat around the solar panels, keeping them at the ideal temperature, while the solar
panels strategically shade the plants and help them grow. If the energy savings turn out to be
worth the investment, this is a promising strategy for both increasing greenspace and renewable
energy.
We can again model Tree Utah. They use a grant-matching technique to leverage their
funds and capitalize on existing political will. Their tree funding grants use a 1:1 matching
strategy. In order to access a grant a group must at least provide enough funding to match the
grant value. They must also have a plan that accounts for at least 3 years to make sure it is
successful. This approach makes community tree-planting projects more affordable while
maximizing the reach of the limited funding and preventing waste. Tree Utah caps their grants at
18
References:
Beer, Jeff. “New Climate Ads Trot out Young People to Make a Case That CEOS Have Been
Ignoring for Years.” Fast Company, Fast Company, 4 Aug. 2021,
www.fastcompany.com/90661414/new-climate-ads-trot-out-young-people-to-make-a-cas
e-that-ceos-have-been-ignoring-for-years
“Eight Ways to Cut Your Health Care Costs: Medlineplus Medical Encyclopedia.” MedlinePlus,
U.S. National Library of Medicine, 23 Nov. 2010,
https://medlineplus.gov/ency/patientinstructions/000870.htm
Ferrer, Marthe de. “These Hijacked Billboards Take Aim at 'Europe's Dirtiest Bank'.” Euronews,
22 Sept. 2021,
www.euronews.com/green/2021/09/22/artists-hijack-billboards-to-protest-the-greenwashi
ng-of-europe-s-dirtiest-bank
Gregory, Katherine, and Scott Mitchell. “Aussie Comedian Receives Deluge of Donations for
World Climate Conference Billboards.” ABC News, ABC News, 29 Sept. 2021,
www.abc.net.au/news/2021-09-29/crowdfunded-billboard-at-cop26-dan-ilic-climate-chan
ge/100499974
“Help Bring Bullet Trains to North America.” High Speed Rail Alliance, 1 Feb. 2021,
https://hsrail.org/help-bring-bullet-trains-north-america?gclid=Cj0KCQiAtJeNBhCVARIsA
NJUJ2H8IIvL4qzm390orXi-DiiqVYxYhchs6OBokoQIQnGG55_9bqI4xOQaAjTqEALw_wc
B
James, I. (2021, May 18). “Our own survival is at stake”: Arizona is using up its groundwater,
researchers warn. The Arizona Republic.
https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona-environment/2021/05/13/arizona-is-d
epleting-groundwater-in-many-areas-researchers-warn/5059471001/
19
Janfaza, Rachel. “CNN to Host Climate Crisis Town Hall with Biden Administration Officials.”
CNN, Cable News Network, 21 Apr. 2021,
www.cnn.com/2021/04/19/politics/cnn-climate-town-hall/index.html
“Living in Gilbert, AZ Pros & Cons.” Storage Solutions Blog, 18 Oct. 2021,
www.storage-solutions.org/blog/living-in-gilbert-az-pros-cons/
McLeod, Kathy Baughman. “Heat Is Killing US-and the Economy Too.” Atlantic Council, 29 Oct.
2021,
https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/content-series/the-big-story/heat-is-killing-us-and-the-eco
nomy-too/
Putnam, Hanna. “It’s Not the Heat, It’s the Vulnerability: Attribution of the 2016 Spike in
Heat-Associated Deaths in Maricopa County, Arizona.” Environmental Research Letters,
2018,
https://www.maricopa.gov/DocumentCenter/View/41656/Manuscript-2016-spike-PDF.
Stratford, Olivia. Heat-Associated Deaths in Maricopa County, AZ Final Report ... 2020,
https://www.maricopa.gov/ArchiveCenter/ViewFile/Item/5240.
“The Climate Mobilization.” The Climate Mobilization, The Climate Mobilization, 30 Nov. 2021,
www.theclimatemobilization.org/?gclid=Cj0KCQiAtJeNBhCVARIsANJUJ2HUXmgeKhdH
vhpTDIWTUz0VltAH0o8kmtjZOb5foAsnQfGCrcpMGj8aAqD8EALw_wcB
“Urban and Community Forestry.” Urban and Community Forestry | Department of Forestry and
Fire Management,
https://dffm.az.gov/forestry-community-forestry/urban-community-forestry.
US EPA, O. (2019, February 13). WIIN Grant: Small, Underserved, and Disadvantaged
Communities Grant Program [Overviews and Factsheets].
https://www.epa.gov/dwcapacity/wiin-grant-small-underserved-and-disadvantaged-comm
unities-grant-program
Walker, Jarrett. “The Transit Ridership Recipe.” Human Transit, 14 Apr. 2020,
https://humantransit.org/basics/the-transit-ridership-recipe#frequency.
Wilder, M., Liverman, D., Bellante, L., & Osborne, T. (2016). Southwest climate gap: Poverty and
environmental justice in the US Southwest. Local Environment, 21(11), 1332–1353.
https://doi.org/10.1080/13549839.2015.1116063
20