Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/228265055
CITATIONS READS
8 6,285
1 author:
Jasvir Sura
Chaudhary Ranbir Singh University (JIND)
9 PUBLICATIONS 32 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Jasvir Sura on 05 June 2014.
Co-authored by
Dr. Karam Pal, Chairman (Finance Area), Haryana School of Business, Guru
Jambheshwar University of Science and Technology, Hisar (Haryana) -125001, Haryana,
India.
Ph.: +91935429029 e-mail: karampalsingh@yahoo.com
Jasvir S. Sura, Lecturer, Department of Business Management, Kurukshetra University
Post Graduate Regional Centre, Jind (Haryana), 126102, India.
Ph.: +919466778222 e-mail: gju_js@rediffmail.com.
Dr. Karam Pal who is presently working as Chairman (Finance Area) in Haryana School
of Business, Guru Jambheshwar University of Science and Technology, Hisar (Haryana)
has 16 years teaching experience at Post-Graduate level in different universities. Dr. Pal
specializes in Banking & Finance, Stock Market Operations and Taxation Law. He has
authored four books and published more than 50 research paper in the Journals of
National/International repute.
Abstract
The burden of indebtedness in rural India is exceptionally enormous. Despite major
structural changes in credit institutions and forms of rural credit in the post-Independence
period, the exploitation of the rural masses in the name of credit facility is one of the
most pervasive and persistent features of rural India.
The objectives of this paper are to assess the growth pattern of RRBs; to examine the
credit distribution and geographical distribution of RRBs. The analysis period of the
study is from inception (1975) to till (2005) date.
The overall position of RRBs in India is not quite encouraging. The poor credit-deposit
ratio is still making dent on the improval functioning of RRBs. Since the RRB is
supposed to be a bank for poor people, it’s presence in all the states of country especially
in underdeveloped States can make things better. The government should spread the
branches of RRBs at grass root level to provide such banking service to the really needy
rural people. Moreover, it is the responsibility of the bank management and the
sponsored bank to take corrective measures to raise the credit-deposit ratio of the bank
that would make RRBs relevant in the rural India.
Key Words: Bank Management, RRBs, CD Ratio, and Growth, Sponsored Banks, Credit
Distribution.
At the same time, it is also a known fact that the burden of indebtedness in rural India is
exceptionally enormous. Despite major structural changes in credit institutions and forms
of rural credit in the post-Independence period, the exploitation of the rural masses in the
name of credit facility is one of the most pervasive and persistent features of rural India.
Historically, there have been four major problems with respect to the supply of credit to
the rural India. First, the supply of total formal credit to rural people has been
inadequate. Secondly, rural credit markets in India themselves have been very imperfect
and fragmented. Thirdly, the distribution of formal sector credit has been unequal,
particularly with respect to region and class, caste and gender in the countryside. Formal
sector credit needs specially to reach backward areas, income-poor households, people of
the oppressed castes and tribes, and women. Fourthly, the major source of credit to rural
households, particularly income-poor working households, has been the informal sector.
Informal sector loans typically are advanced at very high rates of interest. Further, the
terms and conditions attached to these loans have given rise to an elaborate structure of
coercion – economic and extra-economic- in the countryside.
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
Given the issues and problems involved, the declared objectives of public policy with
regard to rural credit in the post-Independence period are, “to ensure that sufficient and
timely credit, at reasonable rates of interest, is made available to as large a segment of the
rural population as possible” (Rangarajan 1996, p.288). The policy instruments to achieve
these objectives are to be, first, the expansion of the institutional structure of formal-
sector lending institutions; secondly, directed lending, and thirdly, concessional or
subsidized credit (ibid). The policy is thus aimed not only at meeting rural credit needs
but also at pushing out the informal sector and the exploitation to which it subjected
borrowers. Rural credit policy in India envisaged the provision of a range of credit
services, including long-term and short-term credit loans to rural households. All these
developments in this field offer the scope of detailed investigation and study.
In view of above, an attempt is made here in this paper to examine Efficacy of Regional
Rural Banks (RRBs) in India. The paper is divided into four sections. The review of
literature is quoted in first section, objectives and research methodology are discussed in
the second section of the paper, in third section the result and discussion are presented
and finally the major findings and conclusion and suggestions are in the fourth section of
the paper.
different commercial banks. These banks covered 11 districts of five states. The first
five Regional Rural Banks has been shown in Table: 1.
After the establishment of RRBs, another source for providing banking facilities in rural
areas on a large scale came into existence with the underlying objectives as given in the
preamble of RRBs Act of 1976,“…..to develop the rural economy in providing for the
purpose of development of agriculture, trade, commerce, industry, and other productive
activities in the rural areas, credit and other facilities particularly to the small and
marginal farmers, agricultural labourers, artisan and small entrepreneurs and for matter
connected therewith and incidental thereto.”
The literature available in the field under reference is very limited in nature and scope.
The literature obtained by investigation in the form of reports of the committees/
commissions working groups established by the Union Government and RBI, the
research studies/ articles of researchers/ bank officials/ economists and the comments of
economic analysts and news is reviewed here in this section:
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
Patel and Shete (1980) of the National Institute of Banking Management made a
valuable analysis of performance and prospects of RRBs. They also gave a comparative
picture of performance in deposits, branch expansion and credit deployment of the co-
operative banks, commercial banks and RRBs in a specified area. This was an eye opener
for many researcher engaged in this field of rural credit.
Financial Express, (1986) published a study on RRBs viability, which was conducted by
Agriculture Finance Corporation in 1986 on behalf of NABARD. The study revealed that
viability of RRBs was essentially dependent upon the fund management strategy, margin
between resources mobility and their deployment and on the control exercised on current
and future costs with advances. The proportion of the establishment costs to total cost and
expansion of branches were the critical factors, which affected their viability. The study
further concluded that RRBs incurred losses due to defects in their systems and as such,
there was need to rectify these and make them viable. The main suggestions of the study
included improvement in infrastructure facilities and opening of branches by commercial
banks in such areas where RRBs were already in operation. However the main limitation
of the study was that its generalizations were based on the study of only two RRBs,
namely, the Mala Prosha Gramin Dharwar (Karnatka) and The Royal Seems Gramin
Bank (Andhra Pradesh).
Kumar Raj (1993) carried out a study on the topic “Growth and Performance of RRBs
in Haryana.” On the basis of the study of all RRB of Haryana, it is found that there was
an enormous increase in deposits and outstanding advances. The researcher felt the need
to increase the share capital and to ensure efficient use of distribution channels of finance
to beneficiaries.
A.K. Jai Parkash (1996) conducted a study with the objective of analyzing the role of
Regional Rural Banks in Economic Development and revealed that RRBs have been
playing a vital role in the field of rural development. Moreover, RRBs were more
efficient in disbursal of loans to the rural borrowers as compared to the commercial
banks. Support from state Governments, local participation, proper supervision of loans
and opening urban branches were some steps, which should be taken to make RRBs'
further efficient.
Pallavi Chavan (2004) has examined the growth and regional distribution of rural
banking over the period 1975-2002. Chavan’s paper documents the gains made by
historical underprivileged region of east, north-east, and central India during the period of
social and development banking. These gains were reversed in the 1990s: cutbacks in
rural branches in rural credit-deposit ratios were steepest in the eastern and north-eastern
state of India. Polices of financial liberalization have unmistakably worsened regional
inequalities in rural banking in India.
Objectives of the Study: The main objective of the study is to evaluate the growth of
Regional Rural Banks of India. The specific objectives are given as:
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
To assess the growth pattern of RRBs; to examine the credit distribution of RRBs; to
evaluate the geographical distribution of RRBs; and to recommend some workable
suggestion to augment the performance of RRBs in India.
Nature and Sources of Data: The present study is of analytical exploratory nature and
makes use of secondary data. The relevant secondary data are collected from IBA
publications especially the performance highlights of selected regional rural banks,
publications of National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) and
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the annual reports of the banks concerned. The journals
like the Banker, and the Journal of Indian Institute of Bankers. Business India etc have
also been referred to obtain the relevant information.
Reference Period: The study is confined to Regional Rural Banks comprising of 196
banks operating in India. For, analysis the present study makes the use of simple tables,
ratios and time series data from inception (1975) to till date (2005)
Thus, just after passing 12 years since its inception there was as many as 196 RRBs
operating with 13353 branches covering 363 districts till the end of 1987 onwards the
number of RRBs is constant but the number of branches has increased to 14446 as on 31st
March 2004 and districts covered have also been increased to 518. The reason for
increasing districts is mainly because of bifurcation and trifurcation of old district in
various states.
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
The RRBs had been conceived to develop rural economy by providing credit and other
facilities for the purpose of development of agriculture, trade, commerce, industry, and
other productive activities to the targeted poor people in the rural areas. However, with
the advent of financial sector reforms in early nineties, the RRBs were allowed to extend
credit facilities to rural non-target group also to a limited extend.
During the operation of three decades, the RRBs in India have recorded a significant
growth in mobilization of deposits and disbursement of credit of Rs. 62143 crore and Rs.
31817 crore respectively till the end of 331st March 2005. In terms of credit-deposit
ratio, it increased from 50 percent in 1975 to, as high as, 165 percent in 1978. But after
that, it shows declining trend, which came down to 51.2 percent in 2005.
The C/D ratio trend shows that it was sharp increase before liberalization ear of Indian
economy but after 1987 it was on decline trends, which take marginal increase in the year
2005. However, there is no significant correlation between the C/D ratio of RRBs and
Overall Banking Industry
Table 3: Growth of deposit, credit and C.D. ratio of RRBs and Banking Industry
As the end of Total deposit Total advances C/D ratio C/D ratio (%)
Rs/Crore Rs/crores (%)of RRBs of Banking
(RRBs) (RRBs) Industry
Dec-1975 0.2 0.1 50 ---
,, 1976 0.72 7.02 91 ---
,,1977 33.04 42.35 128 ---
,,1978 74011 122.02 165 ---
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
Table 3A: Correlations between RRBs C/D Ratio and Overall Banking Industry
RRBs BI
RRBs Pearson Correlation 1.000 .586
Sig. (2-tailed) . .017
N 16 16
BI Pearson Correlation .586 1.000
Sig. (2-tailed) .017 .
N 16 16
* Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed)
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
100
90
80
70
c/d Ratio
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
,,1990
,,1991
,,1992
,,1993
,,1994
,,1995
,,1996
,,1997
,,1998
,,1999
,,2000
,,2001
,,2002
,,2003
,,2004
,,2005
years
It observed from table 3 that RRBs has achieved a commendable progress in terms of
deposit mobilization and fulfilling the credit requirements of rural people during the 30
years of their existence. But the banks have to take efforts to extend more credit to the
rural people as it is found that only 51.2 percent of their deposits have been provided as
loan and advances as on 31st March 2005.
Depending on the context and applications, the term performance may have different
connotations. Keeping in consideration the varied activities being performed by rural
regional banks, any appraisal of their performance may become meaningful with its
underlying objectives. In the present study, for the performance of Regional Rural Banks
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
an attempt has been made in terms of certain defined, parameters, like growth pattern of
RRBs; the credit distribution of RRBs; and the geographical distribution of RRBs.
Till the birth of RRBs in India, branches of commercial banks and co-operative banks in
thousand numbers were operating in the rural areas. But despite of such large network of
bank branches, the credit needs of rural India was quite inadequate. As a constituent
extensive of commercial banking network, the RRBs have achieved tremendous growth
in term of number of bank and its branches. It has extended its service to every nook and
corner of the country covering 487 districts in 26 states. Out of the 26 states, Uttar
Pradesh has the highest number of 36 RRBs followed by Madhya Pradesh with 19, and
Bihar with 16 RRBs, and these three states constitute 36 percent of the total RRBs in
India However, the distribution of bank is not same in different states. The highest bank
number of are in Uttar Pradesh with 36 banks and the RRBs are yet to its activities in
Delhi, Goa, Sikkim and all Union Territories. Moreover, the overall position of RRBs in
India is not quite encouraging. The poor credit-deposit ratio is still making big dent on
the desired functioning of RRBs. Since the RRB is a bank for poor people, it’s presence
in all the states of country especially in underdeveloped states and Union Territories is
strongly realized. The government should spread the branches of RRBs to grass root
level to provide banking and credit service to the needy people in rural India. Moreover,
it is the responsibility of the bank management and the sponsored bank to take the change
for corrective majors to raise the credit-deposit ratio of the bank. The gap between C-D
ratio of commercial banks and RRBs need to be minimized and with the result the rural
India tends to gain benefit of credit policy in the rural.
Jasvir S. Sura, JIMS-8M, The Journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Vol-11(4), Oct. - Dec.2006, pp. 4-12.
REFERENCES
1. Agarwal, B.P. 1982. Commercial Banks in India, Classical Publishing Company,
New Delhi.
2. Agarwal, R.K.1991.Evaluation of Working of Regional Rural Banks, Mittal
Publications, New Delhi.
3. Ahmed, R.1998. Rural Banking and Economic Development, Mittal Publications,
New Delhi.
4. Ansari, Md. A. 1988. Working of RRBs in Eastern UP, Anmol Publication, New
Delhi.
5. Banking Statistics, quarterly Handout, 1997 to 2004.
6. Dhingra, I.C.1992. Rural Banking in India, Sultan Chand and Sons. New Delhi.
7. Financial Express April 24, 1986
8. Kalkundrickars, A.B. (1990), Regional Rural Banks and Economic Development
(Delhi) Daya Publishing House.
9. Kumar Raj "Growth and Performance of RRBs in Haryana" 1993, Anmol
Publications, New Delhi.
10. NABARD (National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development), 2000. “Task
Force on Supportive Policy and Regulatory framework for Micro Finance in
India, summary and Recommendations’. www.nabard.org/what/what.htm
11. Naidu. L.K. (1988), "Bank Finance for Rural Artisans" (New Delhi) Ashish
Publishing Housing.
12. Patel K.V. and Shete, NB "RRB performance and prospectus, " Prajanan, Jan-
March 1980 pp. 1-40.
13. Ramachandran, V. K, and Swaminathan, Madhura (2002), “Rural Banking and
Landless Labour Households, Institutional Reform and Rural Credit Markets in
India,” Journal of Agrarian Change,2, 4, Oct., pp 502-544.
14. RBI, Report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India, 1997 to 2002.
15. Report of the Ghosh Committee to Consider Final Accounts of Banks, RBI
Publications, Mumbai.
16. Report of the Khusro Committee to review the Agricultural Credit System in
India, RBI Publications, Mumbai.
17. Report of the Narasimham Committee (1) on the Financial System, Nabhi
Publications, New Delhi, 1993.
18. Report of the Narasimham Committee (2) on the Banking Sector Reforms, Nabhi
Publications, New Delhi.
19. Report of the Shetty Committee to review of System of Lending under
Consortium Arrangement, RBI Publications, Mumbai, 1992.
20. Reserve Bank of India (RBI) , 1991. Report of the Committee on the Financial
System (chaired by M. Narasimham). Bombay: Reserve Bank of India.
21. Sinha Roy, B.P. 1994, RRBs in West Bengal, Mittal Publications, New Delhi.
22. Statistical Tables Relating to Banks in India, 2004-05.