(UNDER COMPETITION ACT, 2002)

STATE LEVEL SEMINAR

ON
‘COMPETITION POLICY AND LAW’
BANGALORE
30-01-2009
By
AUGUSTINE PETER
ECONOMIC ADVISER
Competition Commission of India
!" # $ # %& #
 ' ( )
*+ " ,- *. *+ " /, # #% . ,#, , 0
,- * "%& ! / #" *%1 # 20 #
/ 33 * #" 4 * !/ %" ,#!
*+ " ,- * % # 2 %5 * / 20 #
#" * * ! 20
1 * 33 % #%0 # *,/ %" ,#. * !, *%
,% " ,# #/ , * " ,# 6,* # % *,- "1
" * ,#, , 0 !" " !67 ,8 *# #" !" " "
* #" - "1 ,"1 * #" * * ! !
* *. " ,#!. %5 ! " ,#!
 (

9 * % 2 /8 *! 33 %": ! "1 ", %1

!",#
9(* ! " 8 : , % #/ 9* ,3 * !,#:
* / # % *" # % ! !
( *! *, %1 !, / # % *" #
% ! !
!! !! #" 1 ! ", 2 #!" "1 2 #%1
*+ ! " 20 "1 - # 8,
# #/ "1 2 #%1 *+ ! ;"1
*,8 ! ,#! ,3< "1 , " " ,# %".
 * 8 #"
*+ "

* 8 #" *+ "
 #/

!"
 ( (
'
1 *+ " / 3 # " ,# ! *8 ! "1
3, ,- # * ,! !
" 1 ! * !"* %" "" #" ,# ", "1,!
*,/ %"! ,* ! *8 % ! - 1 %1 1 8
%" ,# , " " ,#
1 ! % ,24 %" 8 ,3 , " " ,# = - !
", / #" 30 ! " " ,#! - 1 * #
#" * * ! ,* *, ,3 #" * * ! ! !
*% ! # *+ " ,- * ", "1 / "* #"
,3 %, " " ,#&
1 * 8 #" *+ " ! / 3 # / - "1
* 3 * #% ", "1 %, " " ,# %,#!"* #"!
"1 " !" 2 "- # *,/ %"! #/
 = > '
? @
= > '
8 #" *+ " ! 2 ! / ,#

8 #" *,/ %" *+ "A #/

8 #" , * 1% *+ "
 = >
( ' B
#

" * # " ,# ,3 ! 2!" " " 2 "0 ,3

*,/ %"!
#/ ! / ! 2!" " " 2 "0B !1 3" ,3
/ #/ ", %, "# *,/ %" ,# * %
*!
0 ! / ! 2!" " " 2 "0B !1 3" ,3
*,/ %" ,# ", " / #/
 = >
( ' B
%",*! ", 2 %,#! / * / - 1
/ " * # # * 8 #" *,/ %"
*+ "
(10! % %1 * %" * !" % ,3 *,/ %"
#/B ! ,3 *,/ %"
(* %
,#! * * 3 * #% C *%
8 / #%
!! 3 % " ,# ,3 #/ !"* *,/ %"!
 = >
7 7 (? ' B
#
 = >
7 7 (? ' B
$
%
# & "

' (

)
* + ,
(
 = > '
= > ( ' *- .
/00/,
1 2#
3 4. --1 (
+

-
!" 5
-
 = > '
= > 7 7 (?
' ; . <
# / " * ## 9 8 #"
7 , * 1% *+ ":. !
* 5 * / ", %,#! / *
#
' (
)
(
6
'
-
)
+
@ @
!"

!"
2 4
 7

3
% 5
% 5
-
 7

!
-
3 5
%
-
 '
(
8
2% % ) 1 4*% 9 % )
6 1 ,

:
5
5
5
 '
= B
1 .3 +
$ - -
:
3
.
. :3
+

:
6 - -
" .
.
: .
3 " .
:
 '
= B
- - 5
:1

+ *
,
.
+
.
+

:
 '
= B
3

4 :1
4 .
4
:
6 3 .
. 9
;< := > ;0 > .
. <>
3 :
 '
= B D
6 - -
3 *
, 3
* +
,
1 . 3 4 "
" 5 .
*- ,
1 . - -

1 ;? ? @ .
+
3
6 9 - - :
 = > '
= > (
'
#

% +
 = > '
= > 7 7 (? '

'

(
 = > '
= > 7 7 (?
'
#

"
 ? E( ? =
( = ; (<

6 A% 3 B

B
C

C
D .
:
 ((=E

"
(

B #/ ! / ! 2!" " " ,#

B 0 ! / ! 2!" " " ,#
B (," #" %, " " ,#
6
"

1
%%) 1 .

6
 9 ?= == E:
1

26 $ 4. A
9
1 -

** : : ,
 9 ?= == E:
8 . ( A 9
C
D.
C

D
6

6
 * 8 #"
*+ "
 #/

!"
@ @

!"

!"
.
2 4.
 =

#/

-
-
* 8 #" *+ "

* 8 #"
*+ "
#/

.
-
-
 B

3
% 5
% 5
-
7

!
-
3 5
%
-
 B
B

1
.
'

'

A
 = =
1 % &6 7 .
1 -

& D
 = =
! $ 6
1 A% - -

5
(

+ -
+ - 4

+ $
 = =

8 +1 .$
8 %
 = = E
? = B B
6 $
- -
8 +1

) .

)
;? ? = ) 8

E
% . 8 +1 4 :
 = = E

E %
? = B8 + 1
B
* . . . :,
- .E
% -
- :
6

:6
E %
 = = E
6 - ? =- B . B
.
( . + + +
.

% .
.
( +
6 8 +1 E % .
:
 = = E
? = B B D
6 - -
. 8 +
1 E %
8 +1 4 . E
% + :
3 . -
:
6 -
:
$ . - * .
, ( E %
8 +1 :
1 8 +1
+ :
8 +1 - . ( .
% - :6 - 4 :
%

&
% 2

%
-
FF
? ' E

FF
- - - &%% & ,8& #
: : :