Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RAILWAYS
Architectural perception on derelict railways
(A case of Ernakulam old railway
Submitted by
NASLA
RLAREBC027
Guided by:
Ar. Archana
BACHELOR OF ARCHITECTURE
UNIVERSITY OF CALICUT
ERANAD KNOWLEDGE CITY COLLEGE OF ARCHITECTURE,
CHERUKULAM, MANJERY - 676122
NOVEMBER 2021
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that this dissertation report is a Bonafide record of work done by Nasla
(Reg: RLAREBC027), student of Eranad Knowledge City College of Architecture,
Manjeri under the guidance of Ar. Archana. This report is submitted to the University of
Calicut in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree of
BACHELOR OF ARCHITECTURE.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to express my sincere gratitude towards my guide, (Ar.Archana) for his/her
valuable inputs and comments which has been helpful in carrying out the Dissertation
and shaping the contents of this report.
I would also extend my gratitude towards the authorities, officials and local people who
provided with me their help in conducting the study and analysis without any hesitation.
I also thank my friends for their valuable advice and suggestions to improve my work.
I would also like to thank my family for their endless time and support
NASLA
Reg: RLAREBC027
How to deal with abandoned railways that have been rendered useless or redundant by the
process of rapid urbanization and technological advancements in rail transportation has been a
pressing issue in the process of urban planning. It is thus a prevalent issue to attempt to fully
display their potential values and possibilities. Evaluate different alternatives of brownfields,
these integrated ecological, social, political, economic, recreational, accessibility, and
brownfield site-based indicators. The reuse of abandoned railways gives us a way to rebuild
urban public transport system based on traditional tracks, as well as a way to transform the city
center into an urban regeneration corridor.
The study revealed that the principles are the basic parts and simple recommendations
that may be employed in various circumstances when the goal is to establish a
sustainable and green system. However, because the local environment is so different,
we cannot just repeat an example. Instead, the local potential, such as the historical and
cultural background, should be completely used. The transformation should not be
isolated, but should always be linked to its surroundings.
Abstract 2
Research question 7
Research aim 7
Research hypothesis 7
Research objectives 7
Methodology 8
Literature review 11
CASE STUDY 17
CONCLUSION 26
References 27
Websites 28
Converting the railway into new rail transit systems, renovating the urban land
surrounding them for economic and leisure purposes, and building new public space
systems for the city are three common options for utilizing railways. It has been
demonstrated that different reuse tactics will have diverse positive benefits on urban
space, such as improved traffic patterns,
■ To analyze how they relate to the physical environment and socially, how it connects
to the inner city and historical value, and that can be reformulated to adopt a strong
pattern of sustainable social development.
The study investigates the origin of railway station buildings and their
characteristics and also identifies them as a unique typology and environmental and
ecological aspect of these railways.
With the acceleration of urbanization and the extent of cities, abandoned infrastructure
has increasingly become a key issue influencing city development. Using railways as an
example - the subject of this thesis - there are currently almost one hundred abandoned
rails throughout China's major cities. These abandoned railways once contributed to the
city's economic function and were part of the city's transport system, making them an
important aspect of the city's history. However, due to a lack of maintenance and
meticulous planning, they eventually became a place concealing dirt and dust, as well as
a roadblock and a blind angle of waste, developing as a negative space of the city.
Because they have been abandoned and ignored for a long time, abandoned railways
may provide a slew of new problems for urban growth and citizens' lives.
(1) They hinder urban traffic: Some defunct railways run through the city center, directly
connected to the present traffic route; additionally, the higher tracks make it difficult for
vehicles to pass and make rear-end collisions more likely.
(3) They have an impact on people's lives: The raised tracks not only impede city public
access but also pose a significant hazard to their safety, particularly for bicycles and
children who play on them. Furthermore, the weeds and debris harm the ecological
environment of the nearby communities.
How does the revival of the brownfield railway lead to sustainable development?
The research attempt to analyse and identify how the retrieval reconstructs the public
environment by establishing a strong pattern of sustainable development.
1. identifying and understanding the potential development models that can help in
sustainable redevelopment of brownfields
2. to study how retrieval rebuilds the public environment by creating a strong pattern of
sustainable development.
3. to study different indicators, mainly environmental and social relation with this
railway
5. suggest appropriate land use and landform solutions for the railway brownfield.
Type of research
● Analysis
● conclusion
● Live case study
● Analysis
● Conclusion
According to reviewed research, there are three types of reuse modes for disused
railways: traffic facilities, tourist and commercial attractions, and public areas for
people. The railway transportation research aspects that lead to urban regeneration.
(Syms P (2000) Urban regeneration: a handbook. Reg Stud 34:896–897)
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
From: Reuse of Abandoned Railways Leads to Urban Regeneration: A Tale from a Rust
Track to a Green Corridor in Zhangjiakou
Some authors discussed the restoration of the abandoned railway as a green public space
from the standpoints of ecological value and landscape design, while some
acknowledged how the reuse result encourages the quality of community life for people.
The most prevalent environmental reuse strategy in the world has been to convert
abandoned railways into multifunctional paths for walking, cycling, horse riding, ice
There have also been some successful cases of vacant railways being repurposed for
tourism and commercial purposes. Abandoned railways have become a tourist attraction
as a remnant of industrial culture. In Paris, for example, the Osei Museum was created
from a long-abandoned railway station. The Little Billy Railway in Australia and the Jiji
Town Railway Trip Line in Taiwan are both well-known examples of repurposed tourist
routes. It was recommended that in the situation of the Hijaz Rail system in the Middle
East, reduce and recycle plans must take advantage of both the historical importance and
the linear benefits that are available inherent in railway lines. (Olendzki A (2008) A
railway ‘route’ as a linear heritage attraction: the Hijaz railway in the Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia. J Heritage Tour 3:159–175).
The Hijaz Railway Line has been revived as a tourist route, preserving a significant
feature of Islamic culture. Historical attractions and main tourist attractions were built
along the converted line. Italy. investigated the scientific and cultural impact of
historical buildings somewhere along the Middle East Railway Trunk Line in China, and
also the connection among buildings and the qualities of society and culture in the
region, to guide the preservation of cultural and historic building structures along the
Middle East Railway Mainline. So, several areas across the abandoned railway lines in
China have been converted into prominent cultural and commercial centers, such as
Qianmin Street in Beijing's old city. In some of these cases, vacant land across a
decommissioned railway line that has been transformed as a cultural, tourist, and
commercial project has become an essential part of the urban features and helps bring
economic advantages to the community.
The study was based on the regeneration of the Virginia Creeper Trail (VCT) from
vacant railways in the United States in the research on the Virginia Creeper Rail Trail.
Bowker et al. monitored and approximated the local economy's direct, indirect, and
Many scholars are interested in the idea of repurposing derelict railways as new
transport systems in cities. It is sometimes proposed that derelict railways be converted
into urban railway networks, such as light rail, urban tram lines, suburban trains, or
urban motorways with a mix of present transportation systems. Many urban trains were
built in tandem with cities, ensuring that they are always in the heart of the city, where
there is a reasonably huge population. The derelict rails in Tianjin City's Binhai Area are
a well-known case in China. This has been planned that present railway tracks be
converted into transit lines to construct new railway systems for improving traffic
patterns in Tianjin City's newly built districts. In Tianjin, it would create a "one ring and
three lines" suburban railway system.
Another case study in China demonstrated how to repurpose derelict tracks from the
defunct Zhejiang-Jiangxi Railway station in Shangraw City. Several derelict lines might
be set up for future urban railway construction, although others could be designated for
urban expansion, according to one proposal. The Yiwu portion of the derelict
Zhejiang-Jiangxi Line was the subject of similar research. Due to the current state of the
surrounding urban transportation infrastructure, estimates of upcoming urban growth,
and future transportation requirements, the transformation of the derelict railway into a
rail corridor has also been recommended. Eizaguirre-Iribar et al. highlighted the traffic
potential of derelict railways as cycling lanes, and their researchers examined non-motor
vehicle availability of linear railway infrastructure at various scales.
Abandoned railways are repeatedly detected in urban areas and may have detrimental
consequences for the urban area. They have an impact on regional development, vehicle
traffic, the ecology, and people's quality of life. Abandoned railways are frequently cited
by transportation authorities as a source of road congestion because they obstruct
vehicles and partition urban areas other researchers have found that abandoned railways
result in reduced property prices and fewer future developments and that they are
frequently urban poverty that leads to a low-quality urban environment surrounding
[Wang J, Xiang Y, Luo Y (2010) Urban abandoned railway planning strategy based on
the concept of green corridor. Northern Horti cult]. These derelict railways are
frequently disregarded and left in many Chinese cities.
The above literature review provides three transformation modes: as a public area,
as a transportation hub, as a location for commercial and tourism revitalization, and also
Xiaguan is a historical district in Nanjing that was previously a transit hub for both
waterways and railways. The West Line Station was closed to passengers in 2012, and
most portions of the railways have been derelict, causing social, aesthetic, and
environmental issues on the railway and in the adjacent communities. Taking into mind
the local context, a design plan was developed to ameliorate the current situation. The
design suggestion was motivated by the Greenway approach principles as well as
examples from other cases examined. The case study revealed that the principles are the
basic aspects and simple recommendations that may be employed in various
circumstances when the goal is to establish a greenway. However, because the local
environment is so different, we cannot just repeat an example. Instead, the local
potential, such as the historical and cultural background, should be completely used. The
transition should not be isolated but to always connect with the surrounding areas. This
was the goal of the design plan for the renovated abandoned railway, which would
eventually become a minor section of the greenway system in Xiaguan District and even
Nanjing.
This study aims at making a design proposal for the revival and transformation of the
area around the abandoned Nanjing West Railway Station, following the principles of
the Greenway approach, and that makes use of local culture and history to create a lively
district that connects back to the rest of the city and establish a local greenway system.
How the greenway concept and its working principles can be used in the transformation
of an abandoned railway area in Xiaguan District, Nanjing?
Nanjing Xiaguan District Xiaguan District, one of Nanjing's six administrative regions,
is located in the northern portion of the city (Figure 1-1, 1-2). It has a total size of
around 30.91km2, which includes 24.29km2 of land territory and 6.62km2 of river
territory. Roughly 300,000 people are living there, and 6 neighborhoods with 57
communities are administered.
Fig.1-1 The location of Xiaguan District in Nanjing and the main city area (source:
Nanjing Planning Department, 2010)
With the development of highways and railways, the water transport of the Yangtze
River was heavily impacted and began to decline, leaving the valuable waterfront along
the river occupied with factories and piers that were nearly abandoned and dusty yards.
Some railways in Xiaguan were also abandoned in conjunction with the extension of the
railway lines. As a result of the loss of traffic supremacy, regional urban functions were
weakened, and Xiaguan's economic and social development entered a bottleneck era and
was gradually marginalized. As a result, it requires extensive renewal.
Challenges
Most of the railway in Xiaguan District has been abandoned; however, the track
remains, but weeds and debris have taken over (Figure 1-4). The surrounding road
network is disorganized (Figure 1-5), the housing quality and environment are
deplorable, and many historic structures are in disrepair (Figure 1-6). The streetscape is
disorganized and monotonous, and several fish markets along the roadway harm traffic
and the environment; some illegal shantytowns have sprouted up near the train tracks
(Figure 1-7). The most basic public infrastructure and environmental qualities are
deplorable, contributing to a lack of regard for the site's history and culture.
Opportunities
Xiaguan, on the other hand, has an excellent position because it is near to the Yangtze
River, and the Huimin River, which is connected to the Yangtze River, flows through
this district. It will create an opportunity for riverfront green space. Close to this
location, there are also several public green places, such as natural scenery, urban parks,
and the city wall with vegetation on both sides, which can be linked via the greenway.
From a cultural standpoint, Xiaguan has a rich history, and several historical buildings
and monuments have been preserved, which may serve to the greenway design in
expressing Xiaguan 's history and culture.
Greenways provide at least three important benefits (Fabos, 1995), and some indirect
benefits are also reflected in the long run.
Greenways protect the ecologically significant natural systems: mostly along rivers,
coastal areas, and ridgelines; maintain bio-diversity and provide for wildlife migration.
When applied to the derelict railway transition, greenway linearity can improve the
linkage of natural features in the landscape, boost habitat connectivity, and improve the
flow and transfer of nutrients, species, and energy, so minimizing landscape
fragmentation (Xiang, 1996). Furthermore, the greenway construction may connect the
landscape along the railway, widening the area is covered by the greenway to establish a
stable, continuous urban green network system, enhance the ecological environment of
the city, and contribute to the city's sustainable development.
Greenway systems not only provide a far better and more delightful natural
environment, but also significant recreational options in metropolitan and rural areas for
walking, hiking, bicycling, swimming, and boating, among many other outdoor
recreational activities. As an alternative transportation corridor, greenways can connect
origins and destinations while providing magnificent scenery along the way, allowing
Thus, the derelict railway segment centered on recreational and culture will make fully
rational use of urban land and construct more green buildings to serve local inhabitants
with a green exchange open space. Parts of the railway can be used to prevent ecological
erosion, preserve the original remains, and so become a popular trail for backpackers,
photographers, and hikers.
The abandoned railway experienced the economic growth and historical evolution of a
city and a region, and it carries a generation's history and culture. As a result, throughout
the transition process, we can use the greenway concept to either maintain it, which will
invoke the citizens' memories of urban history, or to give it a new meaning, which may
draw more young people and tourists from other locations, promoting local cultural
exchanges.
After the transformation and renewal based on greenway theory, the new railway
improves the overall image of the city and expresses the urban culture. Through a
combination of the surrounding land-use planning, enriching the tourism resources of
the city to attract the residents and visitors from other places, stimulating the
consumption of local transport, catering and accommodation it contributes to the
economic development of the urban district.
Sustainability: This principle was not as evident as the others, but it can be conveyed
through sustainable ecosystem, sustainable culture and history, and sustainable
community and living. Because designing a green and sustainable on an abandoned
railway is ad time-consuming process, this idea should be studied in the long term
through all of the variables of the local context. What we can do now is strive to make
the new planning properly fitted to local conditions, examine the flexible aspects as
much as possible in the designing process and prepare for them, and, most importantly,
maintenance may significantly contribute to sustainable growth. The transformation of
the abandoned railway included multidisciplinary viewpoints such as urban planning,
urban rail transit, rail technology, landscape ecology, and ecological restoration, as well
as being heavily influenced by the complicated local context such as topography,
vegetation coverage, and public participation.
WEBSITES
[1] https://ekc.edu.in/photos
[2] https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/10/12/4347/htm-Development of a Standard
Brownfield Definition,
Guidelines, and Evaluation Index System for Brownfield Redevelopment in
Developing Countries: file:///C:/Users/User/Downloads/brownfieldsguide.pdf
[3] file:///ClUsersiUser/Documents/cleaning_up_brownfield_sites.pdf
https://casestudies.uli.org/tag/brownfield/