You are on page 1of 22

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/258207606

Using Local Cuisines when Promoting Small Caribbean Island Destinations

Article  in  Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing · May 2013


DOI: 10.1080/10548408.2013.784161

CITATIONS READS
106 1,203

4 authors:

Gerald Kock Michael Scantlebury


Department of Economic Affairs, Commerce and Industry Grand Valley State University
5 PUBLICATIONS   203 CITATIONS    27 PUBLICATIONS   203 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Bendegul Okumus Fevzi Okumus


Florida Department of Health University of Central Florida
3 PUBLICATIONS   1,062 CITATIONS    220 PUBLICATIONS   9,488 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Evolution of the Intellectual Structure of Human Capital Research: a Co-citation Analysis View project

Innovation View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Gerald Kock on 03 March 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


This article was downloaded by: [201.229.8.29]
On: 03 March 2014, At: 07:41
Publisher: Routledge
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House,
37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing


Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/wttm20

Using Local Cuisines when Promoting Small Caribbean


Island Destinations
Fevzi Okumus , Gerald Kock , Michael M. G. Scantlebury & Bendegul Okumus
Published online: 09 May 2013.

To cite this article: Fevzi Okumus , Gerald Kock , Michael M. G. Scantlebury & Bendegul Okumus (2013) Using Local
Cuisines when Promoting Small Caribbean Island Destinations, Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 30:4, 410-429, DOI:
10.1080/10548408.2013.784161

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10548408.2013.784161

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained
in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and
should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for
any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of
the Content.

This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 30:410–429, 2013
Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
ISSN: 1054-8408 print / 1540-7306 online
DOI: 10.1080/10548408.2013.784161

USING LOCAL CUISINES WHEN PROMOTING


SMALL CARIBBEAN ISLAND DESTINATIONS
Fevzi Okumus
Gerald Kock
Michael M. G. Scantlebury
Bendegul Okumus

ABSTRACT. This study compares how four Caribbean small islands—Aruba, the Dominican
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

Republic, Jamaica, and Martinique—use their authentic cuisines to promote their destinations.
Brochures, catalogs, websites, and other promotional materials for each destination were content ana-
lyzed. Although all four destinations seem to use their authentic cuisines for tourism promotion, key
differences exist among these islands in their marketing and promotional strategies. Martinique appears
to use its local cuisine most aggressively, using a combination of locally prepared foods, cocktails,
rum, fruits, and vegetables to visually portray this aspect of the country’s heritage. Jamaica, in contrast,
uses mainly fruit and vegetable imagery. The study findings suggest a need for these four Caribbean
island destinations to develop expertise in culinary tourism, followed by promotion through brochures,
catalogs, websites, and other marketing materials.

KEYWORDS. Local cuisine, culinary tourism, marketing, tourism, food, sustainable tourism,
Caribbean islands, content analysis

INTRODUCTION The availability of local cuisines and residents’


eating and drinking habits at a destination can
Destinations offer product portfolios consist- be one of the pull factors for tourists in the
ing of tangible and intangible products and ser- destination selection process (Au & Law, 2002;
vices. Local authentic cuisine(s) can be one of Boniface, 2003; Cohen & Avieli, 2004; Hall &
the key elements of a tourism product or an Sharples, 2003; Kivela & Crotts, 2006; Long,
attraction in itself. This can add value to the 2003). Simply put, local cuisines at a destina-
image and contribute to the success of a destina- tion can be utilized in promoting the uniqueness
tion (Boyne, Hall, & Williams, 2003; Fox, 2007; of the destination.
Henderson, 2009; Ignatov & Smith, 2006; Long, In recent years, the use of local cuisines
2003; Okumus, Okumus, & McKercher, 2007). has assumed a greater importance in destination

Fevzi Okumus, PhD, CHE, is in the Rosen College of Hospitality Management at The University of
Central Florida, 9907 Universal Boulevard, Orlando, FL 32819, USA (E-mail: fevzi.okumus@ucf.edu).
Gerald Kock, MSc CHE, is with the Faculty of Hospitality & Tourism Management Studies at the
University of Aruba in Oranjestad, Aruba (E-mail: gerald.kock@ua.aw).
Michael M. G. Scantlebury, PhD, is Associate Professor in the Department of Hospitality and Tourism
Management at Grand Valley State University in Allendale, MI, USA (E-mail: scantlem@gvsu.edu).
Bendegul Okumus, PhD, is an Adjunct Professor at Valencia State College, Orlando FL, USA (E-mail:
bokumus@valenciacollege.edu).
Address correspondence to: Fevzi Okumus, PhD, CHE, at the above address.

410
Okumus et al. 411

marketing (Boniface, 2003; Bessiere, 1998; du Momsen, 2008). However, small island destina-
Rand & Heath, 2006; Fox, 2007; Hall & tions tend to offer similar tourism products and
Sharples, 2003; Henderson, 2009; Horng & services and subsequently face challenges in dif-
Tsai, 2010; Ignatov & Smith, 2006; McKercher, ferentiating themselves from their competitors
Okumus, & Okumus, 2008; Kivela & Crotts, (Croes, 2006; Lim & Cooper, 2009). Moreover,
2006; Smith & Xiao, 2010). This is because small islands do not often have the resources
food consumption in tourism can be either the and expertise to promote their destinations by
peak (core) experience or the supporting expe- specifically highlighting their unique products
rience for tourists depending upon specific cir- and services (Lim & Cooper, 2009). Therefore,
cumstances (Ritchie, Tung, & Ritchie, 2011; it is believed that empirical findings and discus-
Quan & Wang, 2004). sions on how far local cuisines are reflected and
Information technology and the Internet offer used in promoting small island destinations can
opportunities in marketing and promoting desti- help tourism officials and tourism companies
nations. Such marketing efforts can be enhanced in these small island destinations to find bet-
through illustrating attractive local cuisines with ter ways to promote their destinations through
related promotional methods such as brochures, using their local cuisines.
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

booklets, websites, and other promotional mate- This article is divided into four main parts.
rials (Horng & Tsai, 2010; Okumus et al., It begins with discussing culinary tourism
2007; Wan, 2002). In other words, the con- and culinary tourists, using local cuisines
tent of brochures, booklets, and websites may in promoting a destination, and promoting
play a crucial role in directly and indirectly culinary tourism through published materi-
influencing the perceived image of the destina- als and websites. The second part provides
tion (Choi, Lehto, & Morrison, 2007; Doolin, background information about four Caribbean
Burgess, & Cooper, 2002; Govers & Go, 2005; island destinations. The third section provides
Horng & Tsai, 2010; Woodside, Vicente, & detailed information about the methodology
Dugue, 2011). Although there have been stud- employed for this study. The following sec-
ies focusing on the use of these materials tion presents the research findings and the
for promoting tourism destinations (Doolin, final section discusses the research findings
Burgess, & Cooper, 2002; Echtner & Prasad, and summarizes conclusions emerging from this
2003; Gretzel, Yuan, & Fesenmaier, 2000), study.
empirical evidence regarding the extent to which
local cuisine is reflected and used in promoting
small island destinations is still scarce. Given
LITERATURE REVIEW
this, the article aims to investigate and eval-
uate how four Caribbean countries—namely, Culinary Tourism and Culinary Tourists
Aruba, Martinique, the Dominican Republic,
and Jamaica—use their local cuisines in promot- Hall and Mitchell (2005) refer to culinary
ing their destinations. The sample represents the tourism as visiting primary and secondary food
four main colonial heritage backgrounds of the exhibitions, food festivals, restaurants, and loca-
region—namely, Dutch, French, Spanish, and tions to specifically taste and experience food.
English. These four countries are also the most Boniface (2003), Hall and Sharples (2003),
competitive based on their share of Caribbean Ignatov and Smith (2006), Kivela and Crotts
tourism arrivals. This study is one of the first (2006), and Long (2003) provide similar defi-
of its kind in providing and discussing empir- nitions for culinary tourism—which is referred
ical findings with regard to how small islands to as food, gourmet, and gastronomic tourism.
use their local cuisines in promoting their In their definitions, these authors claim that
destinations. culinary tourism goes beyond just dining out.
The tourism industry is important for many It is the enjoyment of gourmet foods and the
small island destinations in terms of eco- appreciation of the good life leading to posi-
nomic development (Croes, 2006; Scheyvens & tive memorable experiences. Overall, culinary
412 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

tourism is seen as a diverse and complex set with food-related information. The tourists in
of positive food and drink experiences. For the third group do not consider food to be a
example, Ignatov and Smith (2006) define culi- very important part of their holiday, but if there
nary tourism as “trips during which the purchase are opportunities, they may participate in some
or consumption of regional foods (including activities related to food and drink. Finally,
beverages), or the observation and study of tourists in the final group have no interest in
food production (from agriculture to cooking food and drink, and providing them with infor-
schools) represent a significant motivation or mation will have no impact on their behavior.
activity” (p. 237). Based on their empirical study in Canada,
There is a need to differentiate between Ignatov and Smith (2006) proposed three seg-
tourists who consume food as a part of the ments of culinary tourists: food tourists, wine
travel experience and those tourists whose activ- tourists, and food and wine tourists. According
ities and behavior are motivated and influ- to their findings, the food tourists group was
enced by an interest in food (Hall & Sharples, the largest segment and had a higher pro-
2003). Following this, there have been a num- portion of females than other segments. The
ber of attempts to classify tourists in relation wine-oriented visitors were more evenly propor-
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

to their approach towards the consumption of tioned between male and female, had similar
food and drink while on vacation. For exam- average ages and educational attainment, but
ple, in a study of the attitudes of tourist toward reported higher incomes. Food and wine tourists
regional and local foods (Enteleca Research were predominantly male, older, and had higher
and Consultancy, 2000), tourists are grouped incomes and educational levels. The trip moti-
into five segments: food tourists (6–8%), inter- vations and activities of each segment dif-
ested purchasers (30–33%), the un-reached fered; for example, the food and wine segment
(15–17%), the un-engaged (22–24%), and showed the greatest diversity of motivations and
laggards (17–28%). Hjalager (2002) offered activities.
four groupings that are categorized as: recre- In yet another study, McKercher et al.
ational, existential, experimental, and diversion- (2008) collected data from 769 tourists visiting
ary tourists. Recreational tourists are conser- Hong Kong. The authors categorized partici-
vative and seek food and drinks similar to pants into one of five food segments based on
their own culture and traditions. Existential their response to the question: “I would consider
gastronomic tourists seek food and drink experi- myself to be a culinary tourist, someone who
ences that will not only help them to learn about travels to different places to try different foods.”
food and drinks, but also about the local culture. About 10% of respondents strongly agreed
Experimental gastronomic tourists try trendy with this statement, and these were labeled
food and drinks and use newly designed cafes as “Definite” culinary tourists by the authors.
and restaurants that serve innovative menus Another 30% agreed with this statement and
and chic service. The diversionary gastronomic they were categorized as “Likely” culinary
tourists try to escape from the routineness of tourists. About 21% of those who answered
everyday life with regard to shopping and cook- on the mid-point of the scale were referred
ing. They expect to have plenty of food without to as “Possible” culinary tourists. A further
much hassle, but do not prefer exotic food. 30% disagreed with this statement, and were
Boyne et al. (2003), on the other hand, iden- named “Unlikely” culinary tourists. Finally, the
tified four different types of culinary tourists. remaining 9% who strongly disagreed were
For the first group, food is an important fac- labeled “Non” culinary tourists. Surprisingly,
tor in the vacation decision-making process, and McKercher et al. (2008) found no differ-
this group actively searches for detailed infor- ences among the five culinary tourist categories
mation on the available local cuisines and the with regard to education and income level,
availability of different foods and drink in the gender profile, travel experience, travel party
area. Tourists in the second group also regard size, length of stay, trip duration, and average
food as important, but need to be presented expenditure.
Okumus et al. 413

Using Local Cuisines in Destination central feature of the tourist attraction of some
Marketing destinations.
With active promotion and specific market-
Destinations need to differentiate themselves ing efforts, tourists’ buying behavior may be
from their competitors through highlighting influenced positively toward buying and con-
their unique tangible and intangible products suming foods and drinks in a destination. For
and services (Buhalis, 2000; Cox & Wray, example, Telfer (2000) found that the Tastes of
2011; Faulkner, 1997; Sims, 2009). By using Niagara Program in Southern Ontario, Canada,
and promoting local cuisines, destinations can resulted in positive outcomes for that area. The
differentiate themselves in the eyes of poten- strategic alliances established among all stake-
tial customers (Boyne et al., 2003; du Rand, holders such as food producers, processors,
Heath, & Alberts, 2003; Hashimoto & Telfer, distributors, hotels, restaurants, wineries, and
2006). However, when using local cuisines in chefs were successful in promoting Niagara’s
promoting a destination, it is essential that the regional cuisine. They improved communica-
needs and expectations of potential tourists be tion among partners through the use of publicity
evaluated. As noted above, for some travel- materials and this contributes to the vitality of
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

ers, trying local foods may be the main or the entire region. Boyne et al. (2003) provided
one of the most important reasons for trav- another example from Scotland. During 2000,
eling; whereas for some travelers, local food Argyll and the Islands Enterprise (AIE) under-
and drinks may play a minimal or no role in took a survey of visitors who had purchased the
their travel decisions and experiences (Boniface, regional guidebook. Their study results revealed
2003; Henderson, 2009; McKercher et al., 2008; that visitors who had read the guidebook were
Quan & Wang, 2004; Ryu, Lee, and Kim, 2012). ready to spend more money on meals that used
Food and beverage experiences at a desti- locally produced food, were keen to eat out more
nation can be an important source of satis- often, would buy local groceries, and indicated
faction for visitors (Bessiere, 1998; Boniface, that the region’s food would be a positive fac-
2003; du Rand et al., 2003; Frochot, 2003). tor in their decision to make a return trip to
For example, Hu and Ritchie (1993) found the island. Their study found that this initia-
that after climate, accommodation, and scenery, tive increased the number of visitors, income
food was the most important attribute in the and profits of businesses, and the length of the
way tourists perceive the attractiveness of a tourism season. Similarly, Nicholson and Pearce
destination; whereas Jenkins (1999) ranked dif- (2000) found that two food and beverage fes-
ferent foods and drinks ninth, with hospitality tivals in the South Island of New Zealand in
and the friendliness of local inhabitants com- 1998 successfully attracted a significant number
ing second in the destination selection process. of young female tourists.
In their study Rimmington and Yuksel (1998)
found that food ranked fourth as a contributor to
Promoting Culinary Tourism Through
tourist’s satisfaction, and was the most impor-
tant factor in the decision to visit Turkey again.
Websites and Published Materials
In another study, Yuksel (2001) found that both Destination marketing and management
first time and repeat visitors identified the qual- organizations (or tourism offices) use guide-
ity of food as one of the main reasons for them to books, brochures, booklets, and webpages to
visit Turkey again. On the other hand, Acheson promote their destinations (Tsang, Chan, &
(1990) claimed that “food plays little or no part Ho, 2011). Images; content information; and
in the choice of a holiday destination, except other material included in official guide-
for individual travelers to countries like France, books, brochures, booklets, and websites can
Italy, or more distantly India, where it may be an be crucial in influencing potential tourist’s
integral part of the holiday experience” (p. 81). decision-making behavior. As noted by Ye and
Supporting this, Kivela and Crotts (2006) claim Tussyadiah (2011), offering unique experiences
that cuisines available in a destination can be the is key when promoting a destination. The most
414 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

effective way to achieve this is to provide status, education, and lifestyle (Frochot, 2003).
visual and written cues of such experiences in When promoting local cuisines, issues might be
guidebooks, brochures, booklets, and websites. addressed explicitly or implicitly. For example,
Technological advances, especially websites, Frochot (2003) content analyzed regional
offer unique advantages in promoting destina- brochures for 19 regions in France, and found
tions since they not only attract potential visitors that country dishes and raw products appeared
interested in a specific destination, but they more frequently, whereas images of chefs and
also help them find detailed information about people preparing and experiencing food were
different attractions and activities offered in a underrepresented. Frochot found that status
destination (Doolin et al., 2002). In other words, and lifestyle related to food were not highly
websites and online materials are a step for- presented in regional brochures in France.
ward from traditional broadcast media, as they Okumus et al. (2007) compared how Turkey
allow consumers to interact with the website and Hong Kong use food in their marketing
content, while the website captures information activities and found that both destinations used
about the consumer’s preferences and intentions their cuisines in promoting their destinations.
(Doolin et al., 2002; Gretzel et al., 2000; Hills However, Hong Kong was found to be mar-
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

& Cairncross, 2011; Woodside et al., 2011). For keted and promoted more as a culinary desti-
example, Ignatov and Smith (2006) suggest that nation than Turkey. In a similar study, Horng
all culinary segments can be reached through and Tsai (2010) explored how Hong Kong,
newspaper stories and ads by working with pro- Japan, Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, and Thailand
fessionals. They further note that promotional used their cuisines in promoting their destina-
materials on culinary tourism should be tailored tions. They found that all six countries used
to different culinary groups. Food related pro- similar culinary marketing techniques on their
motional materials should emphasize family and websites. Following the methodology devel-
friends, and wine related promotional materials oped by Okumus et al. (2007), Horng and Tsai
should highlight romance and high quality expe- (2010) used a framework to analyze their find-
riences. According to Ignatov and Smith (2006), ings that had six main areas: cuisine and food
wine tourists may use the Internet and online culture, featured foods and recipes, table man-
materials more than food tourists. ners, culinary tourism, restaurant certification,
Government tourism websites are most often and restaurant guide. The authors found that the
used as a research tool by tourists seeking infor- Korea Tourism Organization’s website offered
mation as a part of their destination selection more detailed information about local delicacies
process. Therefore, in an effort to provide com- and food products, and provided more informa-
prehensive information about the destination tion about traditional Korean table manners with
and to cater to the information needs of culinary detailed descriptions and images.
tourists, the design of government websites has This first section of the article has discussed
become one of the key tools to present and pro- culinary tourism and culinary tourists, destina-
mote culinary related information and images tion marketing through culinary tourism, and
to tourists (Horng & Tsai, 2010). Websites are promoting destinations through published mate-
accessible 24 hours a day and they can be eas- rials and websites. The following section will
ily and regularly updated without significant review tourism development in the four selected
expense. The content of government tourism Caribbean countries.
websites is important in the promotion of culi-
nary tourism since it directly influences the per-
ceived gastronomic image of the destination and TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN FOUR
creates a virtual experience for culinary tourists CARIBBEAN ISLANDS
(Horng & Tsai, 2010).
Culinary tourism can be promoted in a The four Caribbean countries—Aruba,
way to encourage tourists to achieve desires the Dominican Republic, Jamaica, and
relating to relaxation, excitement, escapism, Martinique—were selected for this study
Okumus et al. 415

TABLE 1. Tourism in Aruba, Jamaica, Dominican Republic, and Martinique

Aruba Dominican Republic Jamaica Martinique

Arrivals 772,073 3,398,374 1,700,785 503,107


Cruise passengers 481,775 384,878 1,179,504 71,683
Average length of stay (nights) 7.6 9.3 9.6 13.5
Tourism receipts (US$, millions) 808,400 3,792,200 1,910,000 305,200
GDP at factor cost (US$, millions) NA 18,653,200 7,976,500 NA
Bed capacity 7,966 64,898 27,711 8,261
Room occupancy rates (%) 77.80 72.20 63.20 60.50
Land area (km2 ) 180 48,442 11,424 1,060

Source: Caribbean Tourism Organization (2011).

believing that they share certain commonalities, date from 1822, and independence was finally
both in their overall characteristics and to a attained in 1865. A traditional producer of
certain extent, their level of competitiveness in sugar, coffee, and tobacco, tourism develop-
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

terms of tourism arrivals. Table 1 highlights the ment received government attention in the
characteristics of the four chosen Caribbean 1970s; and today, according to the World
countries. These countries are representative of Travel and Tourism Council (2011b), the
the former Dutch, British, Spanish, and French total contribution of travel and tourism to the
colonial empires in the Caribbean. The modern GDP of the Dominican Republic is 18%. The
scientific era of Caribbean tourism can be said tourism sector is responsible for 16% of the
to have emerged in the post-1960s period. This country’s employment. The cultural influences
early tourism referred to by Burman (2007) is of the Dominican Republic are less diverse
reflective of the travels of the colonial elite in than Aruba, but they have much stronger West
the 19th century as they sought to encounter the African and Spanish influences.
pleasures of the colonies. Although all four of Jamaica attained full independence within the
the selected Caribbean countries experienced British Commonwealth in 1962. Jamaica’s cul-
colonial rule, their present tourism experiences tural influences are highly diverse; indigenous
are a result of their respective geopolitical and populations, West African, Spanish, British,
socioeconomic history. East Indian, and Chinese all within a physical
Aruba was discovered by the Spanish space where cultural interaction can coalesce.
in 1499 and acquired by the Kingdom of Although the roots of Jamaica’s tourism pre-
the Netherlands in 1636 (Central Intelligence dates the 1880s, with a few small inns and
Agency [CIA], 2011). The cultural influences lodging houses, the formation of the Jamaica
of Aruba include the original indigenous peo- Tourist Association in 1910 represented the start
ples, the Dutch, limited African enslaved pop- of the institutionalization of the industry and
ulations, Caribbean influences associated with the start of formal tourism marketing (Jamaica
the oil refinery, and North and South American Tourist Board, 2011). Independence ushered in
influences associated with the development of an expansion of tourism as the government
tourism. According to the World Travel and passed the Jamaica Hotel Aids Law to sup-
Tourism Council (2011a) the total contribution port the industry. In 2011 the World Travel and
of travel and tourism to Aruba’s GDP was 73%, Tourism Council (2011c) reported that travel
while the sector was responsible for 75% of the and tourism contributed 24% of GDP and 23%
country’s total employment. of the country’s total employment.
The Dominican Republic had a pre- Martinique, on the other hand, is a part of
Columbian population of Taino indigenous France, having representation in the Parliament
people prior to the settlement of the country by of France and is administered under French
Columbus in 1492 (Fuller, 1999). Struggles for Law. Agriculture, sugar cane, rum, bananas, and
the independence of the Dominican Republic light industry are the planks for the Martinique
416 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

economy (Discover Martinique, 2011). The to the early colonists and continue to be ade-
cultural history of Martinique was severely quate for local use and even for export today
impacted by the 1902 eruption of Mount Pelee (McWilliams & Heller, 2003). This was rein-
that destroyed Saint Pierre, the original capital forced by studies done in the early 1990s by the
city, and resulted in more than 27,000 casu- Caribbean Development Bank (CDB, 1991) and
alties from the molten lava and inhaling the the CARICOM Export Development Project
volcanic gasses. More than 5,000 people left (CEDP, 1991), which surveyed the hotel sec-
the island for work on the Panama Canal tor in 13 Caribbean countries and identified
construction project in 1905. Volcanic activity opportunities for increasing hospitality sector
from the 1929–1932 period negatively impacted linkages with the regional agricultural and man-
the banana plantations, and subsequent hur- ufacturing sectors. Although no published aca-
ricanes in 1951 (Hurricane Dog) and 1963 demic research has been located by the authors
(Hurricane Edith) added to the negative impacts. relating specifically to agro-tourism in the
Currently, the travel and tourism sector of Caribbean, the Caribbean Tourism Organization
Martinique accounts for 10% of GDP and 11% in collaboration with Inter-American Institute
of total employment (World Travel and Tourism for Cooperation on Agriculture (IICA), the
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

Council, 2011d). Caribbean Food and Nutrition Institute, Pan-


The Caribbean region—with its brand image American Health Organization, and the World
consisting of sunny tropical islands naturally Health Organization have been very active in
decorated with exotic flora and fauna, and stimulating the linkages (Caribbean Tourism
surrounded by blue seawater and gentle breezes Organization, 2006; Harvey, 2011).
(Jayawardena, 2002)—could truly benefit
from these enhanced marketing strategies.
These islands can greatly benefit from using METHODOLOGY
such marketing strategies as part of their
sustainable tourism programs. Although these For this research study, a case study approach
islands face constraints common to many small (Yin, 2003) was chosen believing that it would
island destinations such as size, vulnerability provide an in-depth investigation and eval-
to external shocks, and natural disasters, the uation of these four destinations’ efforts of
region has performed relatively well due to its using local cuisine in promoting their des-
reliance on tourism for growth (Meyer, 2006). tinations. Four Caribbean countries—namely,
However, regardless of being a well-defined Aruba, the Dominican Republic, Jamaica, and
destination with its unique sand, sea, and Martinique—were chosen as cases for this
sun characteristics, the Caribbean has been study. General and specific foods and drinks
experiencing a decline in its share of the global related brochures, catalogs, websites, and other
travel market since 2003, finding itself at the promotional materials for each destination were
center of an increased competition to attract content analyzed. Content analysis is “a tech-
visitors (Conway & Timms, 2010; Douglas & nique for gathering and analyzing the content of
Mills, 2004). text” (Neuman, 2003, p. 219). It can be based
The region is situated in the tropical on written or visual materials including book-
zone, enabling crops suited to warm and lets, newspapers, magazines, brochures, adver-
humid climates to flourish much of the time tisements, films, official documents, video-
(McWilliams & Heller, 2003). The crops that tapes, photographs, and websites that may
thrive in much of the region include sugar- offer detailed and rich information about the
cane, bananas, coconuts, pineapples, citrus, and researched topic (Jenkins, 1999). This method is
peppers. Rice, breadfruit, cacao, mangoes, cof- non-reactive since the process of placing words,
fee, and various spices have also proved to messages, or symbols in a text to communicate
adapt well to the islands when they were intro- to a reader occurs without influence from the
duced by people from Europe and Asia. Plant researcher who analyzes its content (Neuman,
foods of great variety generally were available 2003). It has been used in numerous previous
Okumus et al. 417

studies in the tourism field (Choi et al., 2007; the national tourism organization (NTO) of
Echtner & Prasad, 2003; Hudson & Miller, each country. In order to eliminate bias among
2004; Govers & Go, 2005; Kemp & Dwyer, different islands, the brochures were requested
2003; Nickerson, 1995; Wan, 2002). In simi- without identifying the specific reason for the
lar studies on culinary tourism, Frochot (2003), information requested. The official websites
Horng and Tsai (2010), and Okumus et al. aiming to market and promote each island
(2007) have also utilized the content analysis included some short films and advertisements
method. about each destination. These short videos were
This research lent itself to a multi-stage also content analyzed. Once all materials were
content-analysis approach following Finn, received and collected, the classification and
Elliot-White, and Walton (2000), Grbich enumeration process was conducted (Grbich,
(2007), Hsieh and Shannon (2005), Hodson 2007). First, a list of all the collected mate-
(1999), and Neuman (2003). First, the research rials were compiled, counted, and classified.
aims were identified and a coding scheme In addition, the addresses of relevant website for
was developed based on an in-depth literature each NTO were identified and all promotional
review (du Rand et al., 2003; Frochot, 2003; materials were collected from these websites
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

Horng & Tsai, 2010; Ignatov & Smith, 2006; for each destination. Table 2 provides a list-
Kivela & Crotts, 2006; Okumus et al., 2007). ing of the brochures, booklets, and website that
Informed with the literature, the coding scheme were analyzed. It is important to emphasize that
(theoretical framework) had three main closely the brochures, booklets, and websites designed,
interrelated areas: (a) main cuisines and food produced, published, and disseminated by offi-
culture promoted in each destination; (b) range cial national tourism offices or similar official
and diversity of the texts and images of food, organizations in each destination were chosen
beverages, dining, farming, and festivals in each with the belief that such official communica-
destination; and (c) the current role of food tion would be the most common media used by
and drinks in marketing these four destinations. destinations to market and promote their entire
Under each of the above three areas, the authors destination experience to potential tourists.
identified five sub-categories related to texts— In the third stage, the contents of relevant
which were “Food Related,” “Beverages,” websites and collected brochures and book-
“Dining,” “Farming,” and “Festivals”; and for lets were analyzed and cross-tabulated by each
the image specific category, three sub-categories researcher. In this stage, following the coding
were identified—which are “Food Related,” scheme developed earlier in Stage 1 based on
“Beverages,” and “Dining.” One of the reasons an in-depth literature review (Frochot, 2003;
for creating sub-categories was that images Horng & Tsai, 2010; Ignatov & Smith, 2006;
used to promote tourism relied heavily on Okumus et al., 2007), the authors first catego-
pictorial symbols in order to attract tourists rized the collected materials under “Observed
to particular destinations. These interrelated Text” and “Observed Images” and later tried
areas were specifically selected under the belief to identify (a) main cuisines and food culture
that by looking at these areas as documented promoted in each destination; (b) frequency,
in brochures, booklets, and websites, the intensity, and space allocated for the provided
intended research objectives could be better images and text related to foods, beverages, din-
accomplished. ing experiences, farming, and festivals/events
In the second stage, general and food and in each destination; and (c) the current role
drinks related brochures and booklets were col- of food and drinks in marketing these four
lected from the national tourism organizations destinations.
of the four destinations. To perform a con- The total number of images and text is pre-
tent analysis on the dominant representations sented in Table 3. The assessment included only
of local cuisines of the four Caribbean coun- destination specific food related advertisements
tries, general as well as food and drinks related and excluded those relating to the overall pur-
brochures and catalogs were requested from pose of promoting a destination. A count of the
418 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

TABLE 2. Brochures and Catalogs Received From Destination Marketing Organizations

Aruba Dominic Republic Jamaica Martinique

Catalogs received
Aruba Bonbini La Cotica National Jamaican One Love Les iles ala Carte
Aruba Quick Reference Guide Tourism Guide Jamaica Attractions Color me Martinique
Aruba Family Experience Dominican Republic and Tour La Martinique Fleur des Caribe’s
Aruba Your Adventure Starts Vacation Planner Site map Martinique Heritage Trail
Here Site map (downloaded) Martinique–So Much in an Island
Aruba Gastronomic Martinique Bonjour
Association Martinique Land of Rum
Dine Around Program Sales Guide Martinique
Site map (downloaded) Site map (downloaded)

Note. Table created by authors using the information received from the corresponding country’s national tourism
organization (http://www.aruba.com, http://www.visitjamaica.com, http://www.dr1.com, http://www.martinique.org).

TABLE 3. Total Text and Images of the Four Destinations


Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

Aruba Dominican Republic Jamaica Martinique Total

Observed text 64 82 71 89 306


Observed images 9 25 14 41 89
Percentage 18.48% 27.09% 21.52% 32.91% 100%

Note. Table created by authors using the information received from the corresponding island’s national tourism organization.

NTO’s brochures and catalogs resulted in a total or electronic materials were translated into dif-
of 395 text and images; Martinique having the ferent languages.
largest percentage of all four islands. Each of
these categories were then divided into differ-
ent sub-categories, as the main purpose of this FINDINGS
study was to compare and contrast the use of
local cuisine and indirect food and beverage Table 4 presents the research findings related
related content used in the marketing of these to text specific attributes and Table 5 presents
four Caribbean tourism destinations. the research findings related to image specific
In Stage 4, the initial results of the con- attributes. The research findings for each desti-
tent analysis were compared and if there was nation are presented below.
a lack of congruity between the categories,
the materials were content analyzed again col- Martinique
lectively. In the final stage, the results were
summarized, synthesized, and the findings of Martinique, with its French Colonial back-
the research were finalized. Important similar- ground, had the largest number of occurrences
ities were observed among brochures of the of both specific text references (total 89) and
four countries as well as between brochures, images (total 41) promoting their cuisine
booklets, and websites in terms of the material (Table 3). This surpassed the occurrences
covered and issues emphasized for each coun- found in the collateral material provided by
try. It was apparent that the same materials, the other three countries—Aruba, Jamaica, and
themes, images, and photos were used without the Dominican Republic. However, two text
modification in different communication media references indicated Martinique’s relationship
(brochures, booklets, and websites). In addition, with the “Caribbean Cuisine,” while only
it was further discovered that the same written three text references mentioned Martinique’s
Okumus et al. 419

TABLE 4. Text Specific Attributes for the Four Sub-Categories “Food Related,” “Beverages,”
“Dining,” “Farming,” and “Festivals”

Text specific attributes

Aruba Dominican Republic Jamaica Martinique Total

I. Food related
Caribbean cuisine 2 2
Authentic cuisine 1 42 5 3 51
Authentic local dishes 36 7 11 34 88
International dishes 1 2 3
Local pastries/desserts 10 2 12
Local fruits and vegetables 2 10 4 16
Local seafood 1 1 1 3
Local herbs and spices 1 2 3
Local coffee 1 4 5
Specific dishes 1 1
Influence local cuisine 1 1
Organic cuisine 1 1
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

History local cuisine 2 2


Fusion of local cuisine 2 2
Chefs highlighted 1 1

II. Beverages
General 3 1 4
Wines 3 3 3 1 10
Beers 1 1 2 4
Rum (making of) 1 4 9 14

III. Dining
List of restaurants 8 9 13 30
Dining experience 6 1 3 10
Special programs 2 2

IV. Farming
Organic farming 1 1
Agriculture 9 9
Horticulture 7 7
Agri-tourism 2 2
Agri-hotels (farm inns) 2 2

V. Festivals
Local food-related festivals 1 6 7
Food & wine festivals 1 9 10
Museums 1 1
Cookbooks 1 1 2

Note. Table created by authors using the information received from the corresponding country’s national tourism
organization.

“Authentic Cuisine” (this compared to 42 text reference), “History of Their Local Cuisine”
references from the Dominican Republic’s (two text references), “Fusion of Their Local
printed materials), and a total of 34 text mes- Cuisine” (two text references)—Martinique
sages referring to “Authentic Local Dishes,” outperformed the remaining three Caribbean
compared to 36 text references from Aruba’s countries, where no related text references were
printed materials. Specifically related to observed in their printed materials.
the authenticity of their cuisine—namely, Unique about Martinique is their approach
the “Influence on their Local Cuisine” (one to the promotion of their “local authentic food
text reference), “Organic Cuisine” (one text related festivals” (six texts) in conjunction with
420 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

TABLE 5. Image Specific Attributes for the Four Sub-Categories “Food Related,”
“Beverages,” and “Dining”

Image specific attributes

Aruba Dominican Republic Jamaica Martinique Total

I. Food related
Caribbean cuisine 1 1
Authentic local dishes 1 2 3 6
International dishes 3 1 4
Local pastries/desserts 2 2
Local fruits & vegetables 2 8 5 15
Local herbs and spices 2 2
Local seafood 3 3 6
Local coffee 1 1
Video on website 1 1

II. Beverages
Wines 3 2 2 1 8
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

Local beer 1 1
Rum (making of) 1 7 8
Cocktails 1 1 8 10
Coconut drinks 2 2

III. Dining
List of restaurants 10 1 11 22

Note. Table created by authors using the information received from the corresponding country’s national tourism
organization.

the number of restaurants (13 text references) to the island of Jamaica, which had a total of
illustrated in their material (Table 4). This eight images illustrating their “Local Fruits and
clearly indicates the island’s more enlight- Vegetables.” The number of images promoting
ened approach toward securing the competitive their local restaurants (11 images) was similar
advantage by promoting the alliance between compared to the number of images in the printed
local growers and restaurateurs with their mar- materials of the Dominican Republic.
keting campaign compared to the other islands Other examples on the printed materials
in the Caribbean. Surprisingly, Martinique was included the “Martinique So Much in an Island”
the only island promoting “Agri-Tourism” (two brochure, which included texts that promote the
text references) and “Agri-Hotels/Farm Inns” “delights of French and Creole cuisine,” classi-
(two text references), where none of these con- fying the cuisine of Martinique as “authentically
cepts were highlighted in the brochures of Caribbean with a fusion of indigenous, African,
the remaining three destinations. In addition, European and Asian influences.” The brochure
Martinique was the only destination promoting also focused on two different “great” cuisines
a food commodity related museum. that the island offers. One highlighted upscale
As it relates to image specific attributes, restaurants, and the second highlighted their
Martinique had a stronger focus on beverages “Creole” cuisine, which can be found through-
compared to food related images. In this case, out the island and its total of 365 restaurants.
the focus was on the production of their local The island classifies “Creole” as organic cui-
rum (seven images), and other local cocktails sine produced from local ingredients such as
(eight images). In the food related area, “Local fish, shellfish, pork, beef, coconut, bananas,
Fruits and Vegetables” recorded the second and other farm produced fruits and vegetables.
highest number of images, a total of five images For example, specific Creole items highlight
(Table 5). However, this was lower compared Martinique’s West African origins including
Okumus et al. 421

the famous “Accras,” which are golden codfish site map included references to “Creole dishes,”
fritters. According to the brochures, “Accras” “Flavors of Martinican cuisine,” and related
kept the same name and form, but the ingredi- links corresponding to the printed materials.
ents have changed compared to the traditional Some of the visual illustrations on the website
African recipe. were of Martinique’s local dishes.
Another brochure, “Color Me Martinique,” The above mentioned findings and the mag-
which also included a DVD, highlights food nitude of promoting their local cuisine can be
related tours and attractions such as rum fac- related to Martinique’s colonial connection with
tories, sugar plantations, the “Culinary Week France, a country known for its wonderful del-
in Sainte Marie,” which featured an interna- icacies of great bread, cheese, and charcuterie.
tional cooking competition and artisans selling Interestingly, as mentioned in the brochures,
Creole fruits perceived as exotic, vegetables and few other Caribbean islands have that particu-
prepared jams, cakes, and other food related lar uniqueness with their cuisine. One particular
products. This brochure also included the pro- aspect is the promotion of the Martinican atti-
motion of their Agricultural Fair, which is an tude toward cooking. A popular perception is
exhibition of local agricultural products, food, that food is not merely a necessity, but cook-
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

and music. The DVD content, which besides ing is one of the most critical joys of life and
promoting several areas of the island, included an “art form.” This reinforces the belief that
a food related image in almost every segment, Martinique is one of, if not, the richest melting
and most of these images are of local products. pot of Caribbean cuisine.
The “Sales Guide Martinique” was another
brochure that provided an abundance of text The Dominican Republic
references and images relating to cuisine.
Examples of these text references included the According to the research findings, the
promotion of Martinique’s Agri-Tourism and Dominican Republic, with its Spanish Colonial
Farm Stays concept; the island’s Gastronomy heritage, had the second largest number of
(Tourism and Good Food); Creole cuisine appe- occurrences of both specific text references (a
tizers, main courses, desserts, and digestives; total of 82 references) and images (a total of
the Banana Museum, which presented the entire 25 images) relating to the promotion of their
history of this fruit; the “Rum Route,” which local cuisine (Table 3). This surpassed both
illustrates the history of rum and sugarcane; Jamaica and Aruba, irrespective of the limited
“Patte d’or,” which is their annual Easter crab collateral material received. However, the con-
festival; and the “Trempage show” highlighting tent of the Dominican Republic’s materials was
a culinary competition focusing on “Trempage,” concise and had a strong focus on promoting
which is a typical Creole dish. Images in this its “Authentic Local Cuisine.” This was rep-
brochure included local herbs and spices, local resented in both the text format and images.
citrus and other local fish dishes, and exotic This concept had a total of 42 text references,
cocktails. which outperformed the other three countries—
One particular brochure/booklet included Jamaica with five text references, Martinique
in the package was “Martinique: Land of with three text references, and Aruba with only
Rum.” This is a 34-page document highlight- one text reference. More specifically, much
ing the history and production of the coun- emphasis was on examples of their local dishes.
try’s assorted rum products. This was illus- In their national tourism guide “La Cotica,”
trated with both extensive text references (nine several examples—such as “Ají” (Pepper),
text references in number) and photographs “Barbacoa” (Barbeque), “Batea” (Small Tub),
(seven illustrations) related to the history of “Bija” (Anatto Fruit), “Bohío” (Hut), “Burén”
rum in Martinique. The official website of (Flat Griddle), and “Casabe” (Cassava)—were
the Martinique Tourism Authority (http://www. mentioned. Also, two pages of a similar maga-
martinique.org) also had an array of information zine were dedicated in more detail about their
related to their authentic cuisine. The website’s local gastronomy where an abundance of other
422 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

local dishes were mentioned with its corre- which according to the content portrays Jamaica
sponding history and origin. as the island of “land of wood and water.”
Surprisingly, the Dominican Republic was Jamaica is also known for its Blue Mountain
the only country promoting local coconuts as coffee, which has a reputation as one of the most
part of their images (two images). This is expensive and sought-after coffees in the world.
a common food commodity in the Caribbean It is no surprise that the Jamaica Tourist Board
countries. Coconuts were extensively used in took this opportunity to include this exclusive
Caribbean cuisine, such as in curry and peanut beverage as part of their marketing strategy.
sauces, and in Jamaican rice and peas, as well as A total of four text references and one image
in deserts such as macaroons and grater cakes, were included in their promotional materials.
just to mention a few. More specifically, the In addition, Jamaica’s local herbs and spices
Dominican Republic’s NTO webpage had an were extensively promoted in their campaign.
abundance of specific verbal references related Another interesting approach is the promo-
to what the island’s cuisine has to offer. This tion of the island’s organic farming (one text
included specific texts related to their traditional reference), local agriculture (nine text refer-
dishes, dessert specialties, which included spe- ences), and horticulture (seven text references).
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

cific recipes related to their desserts; and bever- This could also be related to the island’s geo-
ages, such as the “mamajuana,” which is known graphical characteristics. Another component
as a “miracle” potion developed by local Taino of the promotional materials received by the
Indians in the past. Of particular interest was the researchers was the focus on local “Food and
fact related to how women take pride in prepar- Wine Festivals” and “Agricultural Shows” with
ing these traditional dishes in the Dominican a total of nine text references. Only Jamaica
Republic, where culinary specialties vary from and Aruba mentioned the promotion of such
region to region. festivals in the collateral materials.
Compared to the other three countries,
Jamaica Jamaica illustrates a strong cultural history doc-
umenting the foods that Jamaicans eat. The
Similar to the Dominican Republic, only promotion of local agriculture, horticulture, and
two printed materials (brochures and catalogs) organic farming gives Jamaica a competitive
were received from the official tourist bureau advantage. Two of the brochures received from
of Jamaica (Table 2). The “site map” of their the Jamaica Tourist Board were the “One Love
official website was also downloaded for inves- Jamaica,” and “One Love Jamaica Attractions &
tigation based on the methodology previously Tours.” These highlighted the country’s his-
described earlier. The study findings indicate tory, culture, geography, resorts, flora and fauna,
that Jamaica, with its British Colonial heritage, shopping, and other attractions on the island.
had the third largest number of samples with This brochure also included an array of text
both specific text references (a total of 71 ref- references and images relating to their locally
erences) and images (a total of 14) related to produced food. There was a focus on the his-
the promotion of their local cuisine (Table 3). tory behind the eating habits of Jamaicans,
However, regardless of the limited amount of and how “jerking” was used as a method of
printed materials, some attributes stood out in spicing and cooking pork underground so that
their marketing campaign. For example, com- the smoke would not be seen and where the
pared to the other three countries, Jamaica meat can be preserved. Today, jerked products—
seemed to place a great deal of emphasis pork, chicken, and fish—were found at locations
on the promotion of their “Local Fruits and throughout the country. The strong cultural her-
Vegetables” (Table 4). A total of 10 text refer- itage connection with Africa and how different
ences and eight images are part of the printed fruits were brought from that continent are also
and digital information. This could be related illustrated both in text references and images.
to the volcanic geographic characteristics that Fruits and vegetables like “Ackee,” “Yams,”
run all through the eastern third of the country, “Pickapeppa,” and “Cassava” were extensively
Okumus et al. 423

mentioned throughout the text. In general, international cuisine is available to all guests.
Jamaica, with its diverse cultural background, The images include those of happy guests
possesses a melting pot of different cooking and Caribbean nationals enjoying the cuisine
techniques and exotic fruits and vegetables pro- that is available at their respective Caribbean
duced in the country. destinations.

Aruba
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The study findings indicate that, Aruba, with
its Dutch Colonial heritage, had specific text ref- This study aimed to compare how four
erences (a total of 64 references) and images (a Caribbean small islands use their local cuisines
total of 9 images) relating to the promotion of to promote their destinations. Based on the
their local cuisine (Table 3). This surpasses the study findings, it can be concluded that of
other three countries—Martinique, Jamaica, and the four islands, Martinique had the largest
the Dominican Republic. Regardless of the lim- number of instances of both specific text ref-
ited number of texts and images compared to the erences and images related to the promotion
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

three other islands, Aruba had the highest num- of their local cuisine. The amount and num-
ber of texts (36 total) with the promotion of their ber of pieces of information received in the
“Authentic Local Dishes”; this compared to the form of printed materials from Martinique’s
34 text references from Martinique, 11 from NTO surpassed those of the other three coun-
Jamaica, and 7 from the Dominican Republic. tries. Not only did Martinique surpass the other
It is important to highlight this finding, as countries with the total count, but the specifics
Aruba’s geographical characteristics, compared related to the authenticity of their cuisine—
to the other three countries, is almost entirely namely, the history, classification, fusion, and
flat, with a very dry climate. influence affecting their cuisine—outperformed
Surprisingly, Aruba is the only country pro- these same characteristics of the other countries
moting their local chefs with significant empha- in the study. The promotion of organic farming
sis on promoting local restaurants through the and agri-tourism indicates that Martinique will
local Aruba Gastronomical Association (AGA) have a competitive edge over the other coun-
and its special dining programs. As it relates to tries. However, it should be noted that each
image specific attributes, Aruba is very limited island has its individual strategy of promoting
in its use of the specific images used in pro- their local cuisine. Aruba, for example, had an
moting their local cuisines. Ironically, the Aruba entire page dedicated to specific images and
materials were inconsistent with the amount of text references related to the composition of
text references presented related to this field. the country’s authentic cuisine. Moreover, their
The Aruba NTO webpage had whole pages ded- continuous efforts in organizing food and wine
icated to specific images and text references festivals should indicate their awareness of the
related to what the island’s cuisine has to offer. importance of promoting their local cuisine as a
A unique feature of the Aruba materials was strategy to diversify their tourism portfolio. The
the organization of food and wine festivals. This quality of the content of their promotion strat-
clearly indicates that promoting their local cui- egy as it relates to local cuisines should not be
sine is an important marketing strategy. Overall, undermined.
Aruba’s NTO webpage had a very comprehen- Jamaica had similar results to Aruba and the
sive approach to promoting their local cuisine. Dominican Republic. Jamaica, with its strong
Although the focus of this research is the use and diverse cultural history portraying what and
of local cuisine in the promotion of tourism to how Jamaicans eat, has also provided a sub-
the four selected Caribbean island destinations, stantial number of images and a significant
the research materials all document the avail- amount of text related to their local cuisine.
ability of international cuisine for guests who In particular, their promotion of agriculture,
would rather not enjoy the local cuisine. This horticulture, and organic farming also puts the
424 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

island in a competitive mode when it comes to such authenticity is available in every dining
future approaches of promoting agri-tourism as establishment in each country. In fact, food and
a strategy for economic development and diver- beverage options from different countries and
sification. Even though limited information was cultures are offered in the four study destina-
received from the Dominican Republic’s NTO, tions since not all tourists may like to try local
the content of the printed materials is concise cuisines.
with a strong focus on promoting their local This research does not endeavor to indi-
cuisine. Several local dishes were highlighted cate that culinary tourism is the most impor-
both in text format and images. Their combina- tant aspect of destination marketing for these
tion of music, history, culture, and their cuisine four countries and therefore should dominate all
can be a major contributor in developing loyal collateral marketing materials, brochures, and
customers. websites. The study findings rather imply that
Overall, the quality and depth of informa- collateral materials should reflect the combina-
tion provided in the materials provided by the tion of dining offerings available so that unique
NTOs were not all to the same professional memorable experiences abound. Although it
standard. Nor was the same level of sophistica- might be expected that first-time visitors will
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

tion evident in the construction of the images be more inquisitive about the cuisines available,
used in the materials. In addition, interesting repeat visitors and gastronomic tourists might
texts and images were presented, but very lim- well be less apprehensive about local cuisines.
ited information was given about its authentic- Some visitors are more concerned with portion
ity, historical background, and origin of food size, inexpensive cost, and the ready availabil-
commodities. In particular, brochures, booklets, ity of food and beverage. Visitors with these
and webpages on sub-regions of the destina- motivations are very at home in the all-inclusive
tion gave very limited or superficial description accommodation establishments, many of which
about local and regional cuisine. This is disap- include local food items as choices on their
pointing to the authors, since the Caribbean is menus.
a region that offers diverse regional cuisines, It might be expected that each of the destina-
which in turn could be promoted to enhance and tions in the study would have a strong historic
diversify its tourism portfolio. The information and cultural bond with their colonial metropoli-
provided for each country’s authentic cuisine tan countries. The fact that Martinique remains
tended to list different types of food and was a Department of France, lends itself to just such
far from promoting the destination as a culinary a strong connection. The Caribbean countries
tourism haven. Based on this finding, it can be selected in this research sought to provide a
suggested that each of the case study destina- balance of the different colonial backgrounds
tions needs to go beyond just listing different of each island. Although the cuisine of the
types of food and drinks they have, but further Dutch, Aruba; French, Martinique; and Spanish,
explain and illustrate what type of exemplary the Dominican Republic, maintains strong influ-
and local food and drink experiences that they ences of their colonial heritage, this is much less
can offer to their visitors. so in the British, Jamaican tradition. This may
Kivela and Crotts (2006) note that tourists be the result of the strong African influence,
often dine out in search of new tastes and along with the influences of post-emancipation
culinary experiences, or when they discover a migration of Indian and Chinese workers. What
new vineyard, they may also encounter disap- is evident is that there is richness in the cuisine
pointment because of the manufactured image. of each of the countries in the study that is a
Therefore, it is important to offer unique result of the mingling of the traditions of the
gastronomy. According to the research find- peoples who currently reside in that country.
ings, the four countries studied offer local Ignatov and Smith (2006) propose three seg-
cuisine experiences and they do emphasize ments of culinary tourists—which are food
authenticity, which is important (Fox, 2007; tourists, wine tourists, and food and wine
Sims, 2009). However, this does not mean that tourists; they further note that promotional
Okumus et al. 425

materials on culinary tourism should be tailored variations in cuisine. What is more significant is
to different culinary groups. Food related pro- the social class divides that can be represented
motional materials should emphasize family and in the local cuisine. The food of the working
friends, and wine related promotional materi- class, the items consumed, and the methods of
als should highlight romance and quality expe- preparation in many instances can be traced
riences, whereas wine tourists may use the back to the period of enslavement. The social
Internet and online promotional materials more elite’s consumables are much more closely akin
than food tourists. The destination collateral to their social counterparts in the metropolitan
material available for content analysis in this areas. In effect there is a duality of food culture
current research study was not sufficiently dif- in the Caribbean that was not sufficiently rep-
ferentiated to determine if it is targeted as a resented or articulated in materials provided for
specific segment. The fact that these were the this research by the NTOs.
materials disseminated in a general call by a Finally, it is truly evident that communica-
person interested in obtaining information for tion technology provides the effectiveness of
a vacation, would tend to indicate the non- websites. Information sharing, data collecting,
specialized nature of the materials. This finding transaction and relationship building as articu-
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

implies that perhaps destinations should develop lated in Wan (2002), does provide a significant
collateral materials to target a specific segment opportunity to incorporate cuisine and local cui-
of culinary tourists. sine in destination promotion. Although all four
The development of food and dining festi- destinations use their local cuisine in promot-
vals supports du Rand and Heath’s (2006) sug- ing their destinations, it is evident that there
gestion that in order to market and pro- is still a need for them to develop expertise
mote destinations for culinary tourism, destina- in culinary tourism and promoting it through
tions need to develop and offer food tourism brochures, catalogs, websites, and other promo-
unique enhancers and experiences. These food tional materials to be able to reach the right
enhancers should touch positively on the visi- culinary segment. This is the first study of its
tor’s overall cultural experience, social status, kind that discusses culinary tourism and how
cultural identity, communication, and sharing. Caribbean Islands promote their destinations by
While Harvey (2011) indicates that such food using their local cuisines. It is hoped that the
and dining events are being conducted, it is not research findings and above discussions help
clear to the extent that they are being actively destination marketing and management officials
promoted by Caribbean NTOs. In other words, as well as generate further research projects in
the four study destinations should focus more this area.
on promoting food and dining festivals when
promoting their destinations. Limitations and Future Research
Frochot (2003) notes that food tourism
can be conceptualized as allowing tourists to This exploratory study has a number of limi-
achieve desires relating to relaxation, excite- tations, which are worth noting. When carrying
ment, escapism, status, education, and lifestyle. out this study, every attempt was made to collect
When promoting local cuisines, issues might all relevant and recent brochures and book-
be addressed explicitly or implicitly. For lets from the case study destinations. Although
example, Frochot (2003) found that country the main ones were collected from each of
dishes and raw products appeared more in the four countries, some other brochures and
regional brochures in France, whereas images booklets or magazines might have been inad-
of chefs and people preparing and experiencing vertently missed. In addition, although there
food were underrepresented. Frochot’s research are similarities between these four Caribbean
found that status and lifestyle related to food countries, there are also differences in terms
were not highly presented in regional brochures of culture, colonial background, geographic
in France. The small size of the Caribbean characteristics, and location. By using the
countries tends to de-emphasize sub-regional framework employed in this study, a future
426 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

study can be undertaken comparing the remain- their main reason to travel. Future studies per-
der of the Caribbean countries. By investigating haps should ask the respondents whether their
the different marketing strategies using local sole reason for choosing the destinations is to
cuisine of islands in the Caribbean, the findings experience the local foods and drinks. If there
can assist tourism stakeholders with suggestions is a significant portion of the participants who
in designing effective promotional materials in strongly agree with this statement, it can be
order to obtain a share of the market of culinary concluded that there is a niche segment for culi-
tourists. This could in turn raise the profile of nary tourism. It is possible that not many people
the local cuisine and its products and influence travel to a specific destination to experience a
consumers’ attitudes. In addition, the applica- cuisine.
tion of this content analysis technique was to There is still limited evidence about what
assess, validate, and verify the message, which type of food related information tourists seek.
destinations were using to market themselves. Asking potential tourists or incoming tourists
Although many Caribbean tourism destinations to the Caribbean about this topic may pro-
endeavor to deviate from the sea, sand, and sun vide further insights about what type of food
image that they portray, in reality are the images and drinks related information should be pro-
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

used to promote the destination compatible with vided in brochures, booklets, and webpages.
that desire? In addition, one can further investigate the travel
Foods and drinks offered at a destination can decision-making behavior of tourists (Martin &
be an important element of the destination expe- Woodside, 2012) who primarily go on holiday
rience and they can be a significant motive for to the Caribbean in search of a local cuisine.
travel. However, it is recognized that not all vis- This can assist not only in designing promo-
itors may be sufficiently adventurous as to want tional materials, but also targeting the right
to consume local cuisine at each meal during segments of these four destinations. Finally,
their vacation. So while it may be appropriate to future work may utilize social media—such as
display local cuisine in collateral material, vis- Trip Advisor, Facebook, and Twitter, along with
itors may want to be assured that international blogs—in obtaining comments and learning of
cuisine is available. This raises the question the gastronomic experiences of tourists when
of what might be an appropriate ratio of local they visit tourist destinations. Photos uploaded
to international cuisine in destination images, by tourists which portray foods and drinks in
along with an appropriate ratio of gastronomic a destination can also be content analyzed in
experiences to other destination experiences. future food research.
This would also relate to the specific target audi-
ence of the communication. For example, in the
Literature Review section of this article, discus- REFERENCES
sions were provided on culinary tourists types.
One may not fully agree with such specific clas- Acheson, D. (1990). Food—The vital ingredient. In
sifications as they are generally based on the Handbook of tourism. London, United Kingdom:
Horwarth and Horwarth, MacMillan Press.
assumption that a tourist may travel to a desti-
Au, N., & Law, R. (2002). Categorical classification of
nations with the sole purpose of trying different tourism dining. Annals of Tourism Research, 29(3),
foods and drinks. It is generally accepted in 819–833.
tourism research that if a respondent agrees to Bessiere, J. (1998). Local development and heritage:
a degree with the statement “I would consider Traditional food and cuisine as tourist attractions in
myself to be a culinary tourist, someone who rural areas. Sociologia Ruralis, 38(1), 21–34.
travels to different places to try different foods” Boniface, P. (2003). Tasting tourism: Travelling for food
they can be classified as a culinary tourist. This and drink. Aldershot, United Kingdom: Ashgate.
Boyne, S., Hall, D., & Williams, F. (2003). Policy, sup-
assumption has not been extensively questioned. port and promotion for food-related tourism initia-
People may travel to try different foods and tives: A marketing approach to regional development.
drinks, but they may not consider themselves Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, 14(3–4),
as culinary tourists because this may not be 131–154.
Okumus et al. 427

Buhalis, D. (2000). Marketing the competitive destination the Caribbean. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing,
of the future. Tourism Management, 21(1), 97–116. 17(2–3), 269–293.
Burman, J. (2007, June). Heritage tourism in the du Rand, G., & Heath, E. (2006). Towards a framework for
Caribbean: Global collective memory in two guises. food tourism as an element of destination marketing.
Paper presented at Collective Memory and Collective Current Issues in Tourism, 9(3), 206–234.
Knowledge in a Global Age—An Interdisciplinary du Rand, G., Heath, E., & Alberts, N. (2003). The role
Workshop, London, United Kingdom. of local and regional food in destination marketing:
Caribbean Development Bank. (1991, December). A South African situation analysis. Journal of Travel
Purchasing patterns of the hotel sector in the B.V.I. and Tourism Marketing, 14 (3–4), 97–112.
and the O.E.C.S. countries—Final report. Bridgetown, Echtner, C. M., & Prasad, P. (2003). The context of third
Barbados: Ernst & Young. world tourism marketing. Annals of Tourism Research,
Caribbean Tourism Organization. (2006, March). 30(3), 660–682.
Agriculture and Tourism Partners in Development— Enteleca Research and Consultancy. (2000). Tourists’
Report on the Agro-Tourism Workshop, St. Kitts & attitudes towards regional and local foods. Retrieved
Nevis, 3–5 October 2005. Retrieved from http://www. from http://tourisminsights.info/ONLINEPUB/
onecaribbean.org/content/files/Agrotourism FARMING%20AND%20FOOD/FOOD%20PDFS/
WorkshopReport2005.pdf tourist%20attitutes%20to%20local%20foods.pdf
Caribbean Tourism Organization. (2011, February). Faulkner, B. (1997). A model for the evaluation of national
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

Caribbean tourism—State of the industry 2011. tourism destination marketing programs. Journal of
Retrieved from http://www.onecaribbean.org/ Travel Research, 35(3), 23–32.
content/files/CaribbeanTourismStateIndustry Finn, M., Elliot-White, M., & Walton, M. (2000).
Feb272011. pdf Tourism & leisure research methods. Essex, United
CARICOM Export Development Project. (1991, Kingdom: Pearson Education.
December). Purchasing patterns of the hotel Fox, R. (2007). Reinventing the gastronomic identity of
sector—Final report .Bridgetown, Barbados: Ernst & Croatian tourist destinations. International Journal of
Young. Hospitality Management, 26(3), 546–559.
Central Intelligence Agency. (2011). The world factbook: Frochot, I. (2003). An analysis of regional positioning and
Aruba. Retrieved from https://www.cia.gov/library/ its associated food images in French tourism regional
publications/the-world-factbook/geos/aa.html brochures. Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing,
Choi, S. Lehto, X., & Morrison, A. (2007). Destination 14(3–4), 77–96.
image representation on the web: Content analysis of Fuller, A. (1999, May). Tourism development in the
Macau travel related websites. Tourism Management, Dominican Republic: Growth, costs, benefits and
28(1), 117–129. choices. Retrieved from http://kiskeya-alternative.
Cohen, E., & Avieli, N. (2004). Food in tourism: Attraction org/publica/afuller/rd-tourism.html#tourdev
and impediment. Annals of Tourism Research, 31(4), Govers, R., & Go, F. (2005). Projected destination image
755–778. online: Website content analysis of pictures and text.
Conway, D., & Timms, B. F. (2010). Re-branding alter- Information Technology and Tourism, 7(1), 73–89.
native tourism in the Caribbean: The case for “slow Grbich, C. (2007). Qualitative data analysis. London,
tourism.” Tourism and Hospitality Research, 10(4), United Kingdom: Sage.
329–344. Gretzel, U., Yuan, Y. L., & Fesenmaier, D. R. (2000).
Cox, C., & Wray, M. (2011). Best practice marketing for Preparing for the new economy: Advertising strate-
regional tourism destinations. Journal of Travel and gies and change in destination marketing organizations.
Tourism Marketing, 28(5), 524–540. Journal of Travel Research, 39(2), 146–156.
Croes, R. (2006). A paradigm shift to a new strategy for Hall, C. M., & Mitchell, R. D. (2005). Gastronomic
small island economies: Embracing demand side eco- tourism: Comparing food and wine tourism expe-
nomics for value enhancement and long-term stability. riences. In M. Novelli (Ed.), Niche tourism:
Tourism Management, 27(3), 453–465. Contemporary issues, trends and cases (pp. 73–88).
Discover Martinique. (2011). Discover Martinique: Oxford, United Kingdom: Butterworth-Heinemann.
History. Retrieved from http://www.in-west-indies. Hall, C. M., & Sharples, L (2003). The consumption
com/martinique/discover/history.htm of experiences or the experience of consumption?
Doolin, B., Burgess, L., & Cooper, J. (2002). Evaluating An introduction to the tourism of taste. In M. Hall,
the use of the web for tourism marketing: A case L. Sharples, R. Mitchell, N. Macionis, & B. Cambourne
study from New Zealand. Tourism Management, 23(5), (Eds.), Food tourism around the world: Development,
557–561. management and markets (pp. 1–24). Oxford, United
Douglas, A., & Mills, J. E. (2004). Staying afloat in the Kingdom: Butterworth-Heinemann.
Tropics: Applying a structural equation model approach Harvey, E. (2011). Rural livelihoods and agrotourism.
to evaluating national tourism organization websites in Paper presented at the 11th Caribbean Sustainable
428 JOURNAL OF TRAVEL & TOURISM MARKETING

Tourism Workshop, Lloyd Erskine Sandiford Centre, of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 24(6),
Barbados. 855–872.
Hashimoto, A., & Telfer, D. (2006). Selling Canadian culi- McKercher, B., Okumus, F., & Okumus, B. (2008). Food
nary tourism: Branding the global and regional product. tourism as a viable market segment: It is all how
Tourism Geographies, 8(1), 31–55. you cook the numbers! Journal of Travel and Tourism
Henderson, J. (2009). Food tourism reviewed. British Food Marketing, 25(2), 137–148.
Journal, 111(4), 317–326. McWilliams, M., & Heller, H. (2003). Food around the
Hills, J., & Carirncross, G. (2011). Small accommo- world: A cultural perspective. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
dation providors and UGC websites: Perceptions Prentice Hall.
and practices. International Journal of Contemporary Meyer, D. (2006). Caribbean tourism, local sourcing
Hospitality Management, 23(1), 26–43. and enterprise development: Review of literature(Pro-
Hjalager, A. (2002). A typology of gastronomy tourism. Poor Tourism Working Paper No. 18). London, United
In A. Hjalager & G. Richards (Eds.), Tourism and Kingdom: Overseas Development Institute.
gastronomy (pp. 21–35). London, United Kingdom: Neuman, W. (2003). Social research methods: Qualitative
Routledge. and quantitative approaches. Boston, MA: Allyn and
Hodson, R. (1999). Analyzing documentary accounts. Bacon.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Nicholson, R., & Pearce, D. (2000). Who goes to events:
Horng, J., & Tsai, C. (2010). Government websites for pro- A comparative analysis of the profile characteristics of
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

moting East Asian culinary tourism: A cross-national visitors to four South Island events in New Zealand.
analysis. Tourism Management, 31(1), 74–85. Journal of Vacation Marketing, 6(2), 236–253.
Hsieh, H., & Shannon, S. (2005). Three approaches Nickerson, N. P. (1995). Tourism and gambling content
to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health analysis. Annals of Tourism Research, 22(1), 53–66.
Research, 15(9), 1127–1288. Okumus, B., Okumus, F., & McKercher, B. (2007).
Hu, Y., & Ritchie, J. (1993). Measuring destination attrac- Incorporating local and international cuisines in the
tiveness: A contextual approach. Journal of Travel marketing of tourism destinations: The cases of
Research, 32(2), 25–35. Hong Kong and Turkey. Tourism Management, 28(1),
Hudson, S., & Miller, G. A. (2004). The responsible mar- 253–261.
keting of tourism: The case of Canadian mountain Quan, S., & Wang, N. (2004). Towards a structural model
holidays. Tourism Management, 26(2), 133–142. of the tourist experience: An illustration from food
Ignatov, E., & Smith, S. (2006). Segmenting Canadian experiences in tourism. Tourism Management, 25(3),
culinary tourists. Current Issues in Tourism, 9(3), 297–305.
235–255. Rimmington, M., and Yuksel, A. (1998). Tourist satisfac-
Jamaica Tourist Board. (2011) Tourism development in tion and food service experience: Results and impli-
Jamaica—A synopsis. Retrieved from http://www. cations of an empirical investigation. Anatolia, 9(1),
jtbonline.org/tourism_jamaica/Pages/Tourismin 37–57.
Jamaica.aspx Ritchie, J. R., Tung, V., & Ritchie, R. J. (2011). Tourism
Jayawardena, C. (2002). Mastering Caribbean tourism. Experience measurement research: Emergence, evo-
International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality lution and future directions. Intenational Journal of
Management, 14(2), 88–93. Contemporary Hospitality Management, 23(4), 419–
Jenkins, O. H. (1999). Understanding and measuring 438.
tourist destination images. International Journal of Ryu, K., Lee, H., and Kim, W. (2012). The influence
Tourism Research, 1(1), 1–15. of the quality of the physical environment, food,
Kemp, S., & Dwyer, L. (2003). Mission statements and service on restaurant image, customer perceived
of international airlines: A content analysis. Tourism value, customer satisfaction, and behavioral intentions.
Management, 24(6), 635–653. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality
Kivela, J., & Crotts, J. (2006). Tourism and gastronomy: Management, 24(2), 200–223
Gastronomy’s influence on how tourists experience Scheyvens, R., & Momsen, J. (2008). Tourism in small
a destination. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism island states: From vulnerability to strengths. Journal
Research, 30(3), 354–377. of Sustainable Tourism, 16(5), 491–510.
Lim, C. C., & Cooper, C. (2009). Beyond sustainability: Sims, R. (2009). Food, place and authenticity: Local
Optimizing island tourism development. International food and sustainable tourism experience. Journal of
Journal of Tourism Research, 11(1), 89–103. Sustainable Tourism, 17(3), 321–336.
Long, L. M. (2003). Culinary tourism. Lexington: The Smith, S., and Xiao, H. (2010). Culinary tourism supply
University Press of Kentucky. chain: A preliminary examination. Journal of Travel
Martin, D., & Woodside, W. (2012). Structure and pro- Research, 46(1), 289–299.
cess modelling of seemingly unstructured leisure- Telfer, D. (2000). Tastes of Niagara: Building strate-
travel decisions and behaviour. International Journal gic alliances between tourism and agriculture.
Okumus et al. 429

International Journal of Hospitality and Tourism World Travel and Tourism Council. (2011c). Travel and
Administration, 1(1), 71–88. tourism’s economic impact 2011, Jamaica. London,
Tsang, N., Chan, G., & Ho, K. (2011). A holis- United Kingdom: Author.
tic approach to understanding the use of travel World Travel and Tourism Council. (2011d). Travel and
guidebooks: Pre, during, and post-trip behavior. tourism economic impact 2011, Martinique. London,
Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, 28(7), United Kingdom: Author.
720–735. Ye, H., & Tussyadiah, I. (2011). Destination visual image
Wan, C. (2002). The web sites of international tourist and expectation of experiences. Journal of Travel and
hotels and tour wholesalers in Taiwan. Tourism Tourism Marketing, 28(2), 129–124.
Management, 23(2), 155–160. Yin, R. (2003) Case study research design and methods.
Woodside, A., Vicente, R., & Dugue, M. (2011). Tourism’s Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
destinations dominance and marketing website use- Yuksel, A. (2001). Managing customer satisfaction and
fulness. International Journal of Contemporary retention: A case of tourist destinations, Turkey.
Hospitality Management, 23(4), 552–564. Journal of Vocational Marketing, 7(2), 153–168.
World Travel and Tourism Council. (2011a). Travel and
tourism’s economic impact 2011, Aruba. London, SUBMITTED: November 4, 2011
United Kingdom: Author. FINAL REVISION SUBMITTED:
World Travel and Tourism Council. (2011b). Travel and
May 7, 2012
Downloaded by [201.229.8.29] at 07:41 03 March 2014

tourism’s economic impact 2011, Dominican Republic.


London, United Kingdom: Author. ACCEPTED: August 8, 2012
REFEREED ANONYMOUSLY

View publication stats

You might also like