Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clostridium butyricum could produce hydrogen from a sweet potato starch residue upon supplementation of
nitrogen sources. A repeated batch culture using a mixed culture of C. butyricum and Enterobacter aerogenes
produced hydrogen with a yield of 2.4 mol Hz/mol glucose under a controlled culture pH of 5.25 in a medium
consisting of the sweet potato starch residue and 0 . 1 ~ Polypepton without addition of any reducing agents.
Rhodobacter sp. M-19 produced hydrogen from the supernatant of the culture broth obtained in the re-
peated batch culture containing C. butyricum and E. aerogenes when 50 pg/1 NazMoO4.2H20 and 20 mg/1
EDTA were added to the supernatant and it was cultured under a controlled culture pH of 7.5. A high yield of
hydrogen of 7.0 mol H z / m o l glucose from the starch remaining in the starch residue was attained in two-step
repeated batch cultures containing C. butyricum and E. aerogenes, and by Rhodobacter sp. M-19.
[Key words: hydrogen, hydrogen production, sweet potato starch, starch residue]
The annual yield of sweet potatoes for the production C. butyricum (20). If the starch remaining in the sweet
of starch is about 2.1 × 105 tons in Kagoshima prefecture potato residue is available for hydrogen production by a
in the southern part of Japan. About 8 × 104 tons of a mixed culture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes, and a
sweet potato starch residue which contains about 80% culture broth which contains organic acids is also availa-
water is also produced as a by-product of starch ble for hydrogen production by the photosynthetic bac-
manufacture. The sweet potato starch residue contains terium, the starch residue can be utilized as a raw mate-
starch, fibers consisting of cellulose and hemicellulose, rial for effective hydrogen production. In this study, a
ash, moisture and other substances. The starch residue method for high-yield hydrogen production from the
was formerly used for citric acid fermentation by Asper- sweet potato starch residue by C. butyricum, E. aero-
gillus niger (1). However, at present, most of the starch genes and Rhodobacter sp. M-19 was established.
residue is discarded since the amount of citric acid pro-
duced domestically has decreased. Therefore, new
methods for converting the starch residue to other useful MATERIALS AND METHODS
substances are greatly desired. Microorganisms and preparation of cell suspensions
Recently, microbial hydrogen production by anaerobic C. butyricum IFO13949 was precultured anaerobically at
bacteria (2-11) and photosynthetic microorganisms (12- 36°C for 18 h in a GP medium (pH 6.5) consisting of
19) has been extensively investigated since hydrogen is 1.0% glucose, 2.0% Polypepton, 0.2% KHEPO4, 0.05%
considered to be a future clean source of energy. Among yeast extract, 0.05% Mg2SO4.7H20 and 0.1% L-cys-
the anaerobic bacteria, Clostridium butyricum produces teine-HC1.H20, a reducing agent. After centrifugation
hydrogen from starch at a high yield of about 2 mol H2/ of 8 ml of the precultured broth at 8500 x g for 10 rain,
mol glucose (11). Although C. butyricum is suitable for harvested cells were washed with physiological saline and
high-yield hydrogen production from starch, the addi- suspended in 8 ml of the saline to give a cell suspension
tion of an expensive reducing agent such as L-cysteine is of C. butyricum (0.75 g dry cells//). E. aerogenes strain
required since the bacterium is very sensitive to slight HO-39 (10) was precultured aerobically at 30°C for 12 h
amounts of oxygen in the culture medium. In our previ- in a modified GP medium (pH 6.5) which contained no
ous study, it was found that a mixed culture of C. L-cysteine. HCI. H20. A cell suspension of E. aerogenes
butyricum and Enterobacter aerogenes removed oxygen (4.8 g dry cells//) was prepared in the same manner as
from the reactor and produced hydrogen from starch that of C. butyricum. Rhodobacter sp. M-19 (20) was
with a high yield of more than 2 mol HE/mOl glucose cultured anaerobically in an R medium at 30°C under il-
without the need to add any reducing agents to the medi- lumination at 5000 Ix using an incandescent lamp (type
um (11). However, there have been few reports on hydro- K-RD40W, National Electric Co., Tokyo). The R medi-
gen production by a mixed culture from actual organic um was composed of 50 mM butyric acid, 2.8 mg/l H3BO4,
waste which contains starch except for a study on the 0.75 mg/1 NaEMoO4.2H20, 0.24 mg/l ZnSO4.7H20,
photoproduction of hydrogen from raw starch-rich algal 2.1 mg/l MnSO4.4H20, 0.04 mg/l Cu(NO3)2-3H20,
biomasses by a halophilic bacterial community (14). Fur- 50 mg/I CaC12, 20 mg/l EDTA, 11.8 mg/l FeSO4-7H20,
thermore, we previously reported that hydrogen produc- 200 mg/l MgESO4.7H20, 1.0 g/l yeast extract, 0.15 pg/l
tion of about 6.6 mol H2/mol glucose could be attained biotin, 0.15 l~g/l vitamin B1, 0.15 pg/l p-aminobenzoic
from starch using a mixed culture of C. butyricum and acid, 0.15pg/l nicotinic acid, O.15pg/1 nicotinamide,
Rhodobacter sp. M-19, since the photosynthetic bacteri- 1.25g/l (NH4)2SO4 and 100mM sodium phosphate
um produced hydrogen from organic acids produced by buffer (pH 6.5). A cell suspension of Rhodobacter sp.
M-19 (2.5 g dry cells//) was also prepared in the same
* Corresponding author, e-mail: yokoi@cc.miyazaki-u.ac.jp manner.
58
Vot. 91, 2001 HYDROGEN PRODUCTIONFROM STARCH RESIDUE 59
Hydrogen production by C. butyricum and E. aer- was performed without pH control in starch residue me-
ogenes in batch cultures For hydrogen production by dia to evaluate whether the bacterium could produce
a monoculture of C. butyricum in a batch culture, 8 ml hydrogen from the starch remaining in the sweet potato
of a cell suspension and 192 ml of a starch residue medi- starch residue as a carbon source. Although 124mi of
um containing 0.1% L-Cysteine.HC1.H20 were put in a hydrogen was produced by C. butyricum in a basal
250-ml stirred reactor. In the case of a mixed culture of starch residue medium consisting of 0.5% sweet potato
C. butyricum and E. aerogenes in a batch culture, 11 ml starch residue, 1.0% Polypepton, 0.2% KH2PO4, 0.05%
of the cell suspension of C. butyricum, 1 ml of that of MgSO4-7H20, 0.05% yeast extract and 0.1% L-cys-
E. aerogenes and 188 ml of the starch residue medium teine-HC1. H20, the bacterium could not produce hydro-
containing no L-cysteine.HCl.H20 were put in the gen from the starch residue not supplemented with any
stirred reactor. After replacement of the gas phase of the other medium components.
reactors with argon, the cells were cultured anaerobically To identify the medium components necessary for
at 37°C at a controlled pH of 5.25 with stirring. Gas hydrogen production from the starch residue by C.
evolved was collected and the volume was measured in butyricum, hydrogen evolution was observed in media
an inverted measuring cylinder over a 20% NaOH solu- which contained 0.5% starch residue, 0.1% L-cys-
tion. teine. HCI. H20 and one of each of the medium compo-
Hydrogen production in a repeated batch culture by nents of the basal starch residue medium. Hydrogen was
C. butyricum and E. aerogenes After the completion not produced from the starch residue supplemented with
of a batch culture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes in 0.2% KH2PO4 or 0.05% MgSO4.7H20. However, the rel-
200ml of the starch residue medium without L-cys- ative hydrogen production from the starch residue sup-
teine.HCI.H20 in the 250-ml stirred reactor which was plemented with 1.0% Polypepton or 0.05% yeast extract
carried out anaerobically at 37°C at a controlled pH of was 103% and 20% that in the basal starch residue medi-
5.25 with stirring, 100 ml of the culture broth was drawn um, respectively, indicating that addition of a nitrogen
out using a peristaltic pump. Then, 100 ml of the fresh source to the starch residue is essential for hydrogen pro-
starch residue medium was added to the remaining 100 duction (data not shown).
ml of the culture broth in the reactor and cultured for To determine the optimum nitrogen source for hydro-
a further 24 h. In this way, a repeated batch culture was gen production, the bacterium was cultured in media
performed at 24-h intervals. consisting of 0.5% sweet potato starch residue, 0.1% L-
Hydrogen production in a repeated batch culture by cysteine-HCI-H20 and 1.0% Polypepton, casamino
Rhodobacter sp. M-19 The culture broth obtained in acids, urea, (NH4)2SO4 or NH4C1. Among the nitrogen
the repeated batch culture of C. butyricum and E. aer- sources, the highest level of hydrogen production was
ogenes was centrifuged at 8500xg for 15 min. After cen- obtained with Polypepton. However, hydrogen was not
trifugation, 50 pg/l Na2MoO4.2H20 and 20 mg/l EDTA produced in the media to which urea, (NH4)2SO4 or NH4CI
were added to the supernatant to prepare a culture medi- was added (data not shown).
um (medium S) for Rhodobacter sp. M-19. Two ml of Organic acids such as acetic, butyric and lactic acids
a cell suspension of Rhodobacter sp. M-19 and 48 ml are produced as by-products concomitant with hydrogen
of the medium S were put in a glass tube reactor (i.d. evolution from sugars by C. butyricum (20). Since ac-
2 × 20 cm), and the head space of the reactor was re- cumulation of the organic acids causes a decrease in the
placed with argon gas. After carrying out a batch cul- culture pH and inhibition of hydrogen-producing activ-
ture at 35°C for 5 d with stirring under illumination at ity of the bacterium, pH control of the culture is neces-
50001x by the incandescent lamp, 40 ml of the culture sary. Figure 1 shows the effect of controlling the culture
broth was drawn out using a peristaltic pump. Then, pH on hydrogen evolution from 0.5% sweet potato
40 ml of the medium S were poured into the reactor and starch residue supplemented with 1.0% Polypepton by
cultivation was continued for a further 5 d. A repeated the bacterium in batch cultures. Hydrogen evolution was
batch culture was performed at 5-d intervals. high in the pH region from 5.0 to 5.5 and the optimum
Sweet potato starch residue The sweet potato pH was 5.25.
starch residue used in this study is a dried residuum When hydrogen is produced from sweet potato starch
which was obtained after extraction of the starch from residue, it is desired to minimize the amount of Polypep-
sweet potatoes and drying in a starch-manufacturing
process. The dried sweet potato starch residue contained 200
49.0% starch, 14.2% moisture, 5.2% ash and other com-
ponents. Most of the other components were proteins
(about 3%), fats (less than 1%) and fibers which originat- 150
ed from the peels and tubers of the sweet potatoes and
consisted of cellulose, hemicellulose, pectin substances
and lignin. ~ 100
Analytical methods Analyses of NH4 +, acetic acid,
butyric acid, lactic acid and starch in the culture broth
and hydrogen in the evolved gas were performed as ~ 50
described previously (20).
0 i i
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 4 5 6 7
Hydrogen production from a sweet potato starch pH
residue by a monoculture of C. butyricum At first, FIG. 1. Effect of culture pH on hydrogen production by C.
hydrogen production by a monoculture of C. butyricum butyricum from sweet potato starch residue.
60 YOKOIET AL. J. BloSCi.BIOENO.,
200 6 i0o
, (A)
5 80
150
60
,...,
100
40
o 50
2 20
0 I I I I I
l
4 0 50 100 150 200 250
Time (h)
-A- 100
--A- (B)
80
~2
_,>
o 60
40
0 I I I
~ 20
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
Polypeptone (%) 0~
0 50 100 150 200 250
FIG. 2. Effectof the concentration of Polypepton added to the
sweet potato starch residue on hydrogen evolution (O), NH4+ pro- Time (h)
duction in culture broth (O) and hydrogen yield (A). FIG. 3. Hydrogen production from sweetpotato starch residue in
repeated batch cultures by a monoculture of C. butyricum (A) and by
ton added to the medium. The effects of Polypeptone a mixed culture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes (B).
concentration on hydrogen evolution, hydrogen yield
and NH4 + production by the bacterium in a batch cul- uneconomical in a hydrogen production process. The
ture at pH 5.25 in a medium consisting of 0.5% sweet authors previously reported that a mixed culture of C.
potato starch residue, Polypepton and 0.1% L-cys- butyricum and E. aerogenes could produce hydrogen
teine. HCI. H20 are shown in Fig. 2. The hydrogen yield from starch at a high yield of more than 2 mol H2/mol
(tool H2/mol glucose) represents the molar ratio of glucose without the need to add any reducing agents to
hydrogen evolved to glucose contained in the starch of the medium since E. aerogenes, a facultative anaerobe,
the sweet potato starch residue added to the medium. removed oxygen and generated anaerobic conditions in
The hydrogen yield is not, however, a molar ratio of the the reactor (11). Therefore, the production of hydrogen
hydrogen evolved to the net glucose contained in the from a sweet potato starch residue by a mixed culture of
starch of the sweet potato starch residue consumed in C. butyricum and E. aerogenes was examined. Table 1
the culture. Almost equal amounts of hydrogen and high shows the parameters relating to hydrogen production
hydrogen yields of about 2.4 tool H2/mol glucose were from 0.5 to 1.0% sweet potato starch residue supple-
obtained at concentrations of Polypepton above 0.1%. mented with 0.1% Polypepton with pH control at 5.25
However, hydrogen evolution and hydrogen yield by a monoculture of C. butyricum and by a mixed cul-
decreased markedly when the concentrations was less ture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes in batch cultures.
than 0.05%. NH4 + concentration in the culture broth The monoculture was performed in the presence of 0.1%
increased with increasing Polypepton concentration. There- L-cysteine.HCl. H20. The volume of hydrogen evolved
fore, the addition of 0.1% Polypepton to the starch increased with increasing starch residue concentration in
residue was necessary for hydrogen production by the the medium for both cultures. Although hydrogen could
bacterium. be produced by the mixed culture without the addition
H2 production from a sweet potato starch residue by a of a reducing agent, hydrogen production and hydrogen
mixed culture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes yield for the mixed culture were less than those for the
Since the hydrogen-producing ability of C. butyricum is monoculture. It is known that C. butyricum and E. aer-
markedly inhibited by a slight amount of oxygen, the ogenes produce hydrogen from glucose at yields of
addition of a reducing agent such as L-cysteine. HCI. H20 about 2 and 1 mol H2/mol glucose, respectively (9, 10). It
to the culture medium is an absolute requirement. The appears that the hydrogen yield for the mixed culture
use of reducing agents which are relatively expensive is might be lower since C. butyricum was not predominant
TABLE 1. Hydrogen production from starch residue by monoculture of C. butyricum and by mixed culture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes
Monoculture of C. butyricum Mixed culture of C. butyricum and E. aerogenes
Starch residue
(%) Hydrogen evolveda Hydrogen yield Hydrogen evolved Hydrogen yield
(ml) (mol H2/mol glucose) (ml) (mol H2/mol glucose)
0.5 151 2.4 105 1.7
0.75 203 2.2 136 1.5
1.0 268 2.2 N.T. b N.T.
a Volumes of hydrogen evolved from 200 ml of a culture medium.
b Not tested.
VOL. 91, 2001 HYDROGEN PRODUCTION FROM STARCH RESIDUE 61
9. Yokoi, H., Maeda, Y., Hirose, J., Hayashi, S., and Takasaki, Miyake, J.: Characteristics of a photosynthetic bacterium
Y.: H2 production by immobilized cells of Clostridium butyri- Rhodobacter sphaeroides RV for hydrogen production. J.
cum on porous glass beads. Biotechnol. Lett., 11, 431-433 Marine Biotechnol., 4, 34-37 (1996).
(1997). 16. Heguaug, Z., Suzuki, T., Tsygankov, A.A., Asada, Y., and
10. Yokoi, H., Ohkawara, T., Hirose, J., Hayashi, S., and Miyake, J.: Hydrogen production from tofu wastewater by
Takasaki, Y.: Characteristics of hydrogen production by acidur- Rhodobacter sphaeroides immobilized in agar gels. Int. J.
ic Enterobacter aerogenes strain HO-39. J. Ferment. Bioeng., Hydrogen Energy, 24, 305-310 (1999).
80, 571-574 (1995). 17. Asada, Y. and Miyake, J.: Photobiological hydrogen produc-
11. Yokoi, H., Toknshige, T., Hirose, $., Hayashi, S., and tion. J. Biosci. Bioeng., 88, 1--6 (1999).
Takasaki, Y.: H2 production from starch by a mixed culture of 18. Fedorov, A.S., Tsygankov, A. A., and Hall, D.O.: Hydrogen
Clostridium butyricum and Enterobacter aerogenes. Biotech- production by Rhodobacter sphaeroides immobilized on poly-
nol. Lett., 20, 143-147 (1998). urethane foam. Biotechnol. Lett., 20, 1007-1009 (1998).
12. Ike, A., Saimura, C., Hirata, K., and Miyamoto, K.: Environ- 19. Singh, S.P., Srivaslava, S.C., and Pandey, K.D.: Hydrogen
mentally friendly production of H2 incorporating microaigal production by Rhodopseudomonas at the expense of vegetable
CO2 fixation. J. Mar. Biotechnol., 4, 47-51 (1996). starch, sugarcane juice and whey. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 19,
13. Ike, A., Toda, N., Tsujii, N., Hirata, K., and Miyamoto, K.: 437-440 (1994).
Hydrogen photoproduction from CO2-fixing microalgal bio- 20. Yokoi, H., Mori, M., Hirose, J., Hayashi, S., and Takasaki,
mass: application of halotolerant photosynthetic bacteria. J. Y.: H2 production from starch by a mixed culture of Clostridi-
Ferment. Bioeng., 84, 606--609 (1997). um butyricum and Rhodobacter sp. M-19. BiotechnoL Lett.,
14. Ike, A., Murakawa, T., Kawaguehi, H., Hirata, K., and 20, 895-899 (1998).
Miyamoto, K.: Photoproduction of hydrogen from raw starch 21. Miyake, J., Man, X.Y., and Kawamura, S.: Photoproduction
using a halophilic bacterial community. J. Biosci. Bioeng., 88, of hydrogen from glucose by a co-culture of a photosynthetic
72-77 (1999). bacterium and CIostridium butyricurn. J. Ferment. Technol.,
15. Nagamine, Y., Kawasugi, T., Miyake, M., Asada, Y., and 62, 531-535 (1984).