Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hero or Villain?
This paper will look at the effect of water in both the HTS and LTS. For HTS it will discuss the
impact of boiler failures, and over-reduction with too little steam. It will also consider the effect of
steam on LTS (including the impact on methanol by-production) and good quench system designs
7
6 Fe3O4 • A major boiler failure can cause physical da
5
4 mage to the HTS catalyst through the thermal
3 shock of relatively cold water hitting warmer
2 FeO catalyst and the impact of water droplets on the
1
0 Fe upper portion of the catalyst bed.
300 350 400 450 500 550 600 • A more gradual leak will cause deposition of
boiler solids on the catalyst surface as water
Temperature(°C)
evaporates. These solids normally contain silica
or phosphates and deposit on the top of the cata-
100 lyst bed. They block off catalyst pores and ac-
tive sites resulting in a loss of catalyst activity.
Fe3O4+H2 > 3FeO+H2O Such deposition can form a crust that substan-
10
tially increases the pressure drop and impacts on
K H2O/H2
1
FeO+H2>Fe+H2O the plant throughput and efficiency. Eventually
the pressure drop from the crust will be suffi-
0.1 cient for the hydraulic forces to crush catalyst
Fe3O4+4H2>3Fe+4H2O particles and the bed will quickly fail. The ef-
0.01 fect of a small undetected boiler leak on the HTS
300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700
pressure drop is illustrated in Figure 3.
Temperature (°C)
50 Start of bed
Over-reduced HTS catalyst also catalyses side reac-
Pressure Drop (psi)
crushing
tions such as Fischer-Tropsch and methanation reactions. 40
This results in increasing levels of hydrocarbons such as 30 Start of persistent
CH4, C2H6, etc and oxygenates. If over reduction is not boiler leak
20
identified and reversed, it can lead to weakened pellets
(due to the phase changes) and carbon laydown in the 10 Crust builds up
pellets. This structural damage is not reversible and will 0
on top of bed
lead to a step change in pressure drop across the bed fol- 0 10 20 30 40 50
lowed by a gradual increase in pressure drop. Time on Line (months)
Copper was added to HTS catalysts in order to in-
crease the resistance of HTS catalysts to over reduction. Figure 3. Effect of Boiler Leak on Pressure Drop
The first commercially available catalyst containing cop-
per was available from Johnson Matthey Catalysts in In order to minimize the damage to the catalyst by
1987 when KATALCO 71-3 was launched (reference 1). boiler leaks, Johnson Matthey Catalysts recommend the
installation of a protective layer on the top of the HTS
catalyst, either KATALCO 23-0 or DYPOR 607. Both
3.2 Boiler Leaks
of these products have a high surface area to trap silica
Many conventional ammonia plants that were and solid deposits, protecting the active catalyst beneath.
built in the late 1960s and 1970s have been substan- Case Study 1 (at the end of this paper) shows the ef-
tially revamped over the years so that current capacity fect of a boiler leak on the operation of a large ammonia
is far above the original design. These increases in plant operating with KATALCO 71-series catalyst.
plant rate have had a corresponding increase in the av-
Temperature (°F)
4.1.1 Condensation 0
Fresh Freshly Reduced Fresh Freshly Reduced
Condensation on LTS catalysts occurs during nor- reduced & steamed reduced & steamed
mal operation of the plant when the conditions at the
Figure 6. Effect of Post Pellet Treatment on Cata-
inlet of the LTS converter are too close to the dew
lyst Strength.
point. The main effect of condensing steam on LTS
catalysts is a reduction in catalyst strength. In order to
reduce the effect of condensation on catalyst strength, Condensing water on LTS catalysts can also have a
KATALCO 83-3 series catalysts under go a post pellet significant impact on the catalyst activity. Poisons such
treatment step. As illustrated in Figure 5, new struc- as chlorides trapped at the top of the catalyst bed can be
tures are formed in the catalyst pellets during this step, washed down the catalyst bed, resulting in poisoning of
increasing the catalyst strength. The difference in cata- the remaining active catalyst beneath the previously
lyst strengths are shown in Figure 6. This additional poisoned zone. All commercially available LTS cata-
strength gives increased resistance against crushing of lysts suffer from this phenomenon, including alkali
the catalyst and a subsequent increase in pressure drop. doped catalysts as the chloride species are water solu-
ble. Some commercially available guard bed materials
formulated to trap chlorides are also susceptible to this
problem. As an example, a European ammonia plant
6.1 Case Study 1 cided to vacuum the damaged catalyst from the vessel
and to restart the plant with a partially filled reactor.
An example of an ammonia plant with a boiler fail- Pressure to quickly resume production precluded a full
ure is taken from a large ammonia plant that started up catalyst change or even a top up of the residual charge.
in 1998 with Johnson Matthey catalysts throughout the Over 40% of the catalyst was discharged and the
front end, including KATALCO 71 series in the HTS. space velocity increased from 5,400 hr-1 to 9,000 hr-1.
Soon after the plant began operation a routine set of Despite this increase in space velocity the charge of
data was collected to allow the catalyst performance to KATALCO 71-3 has continued to operate and to pro-
be characterized. At Johnson Matthey Catalysts the vide efficient CO conversion. The skimmed catalyst is
first step in characterising catalyst operation is to estab- achieving almost complete conversion, as dictated by
lish a consistent material balance across the ammonia the thermodynamic equilibrium, with a CO slip of
plant. This is done using a Johnson Matthey data fitting around 2.5%. After the skim the catalyst pressure drop
program known as CATPER, which is available to has returned to a more normal 0.7 bar (10 psi). The
Johnson Matthey catalyst customers via our website. current part charge is expected to stay in operation until
This program is used to adjust measured plant data until there is a convenient opportunity for a plant shut-down.
a suitable overall match is obtained between the raw
plant measurements and the self-consistent calculated 6.2 Case Study 2. Exotherm during
material balance. For the data from the new plant there HTS Catalyst Commissioning
was difficulty in matching the plant measurements as
the data from the shift section of the plant indicated that During the initial commissioning of a bed of
the steam ratio was higher than expected. Adjusting the KATALCO 71-3 in a large American ammonia plant
steam ratio to match the data in the shift section led to the operator reported observing an exotherm of 250°C
anomalies in the reformer section. It soon became clear (450°F). This temperature increase, from 260°C
that a leak in the waste heat boiler would account for (500°F) to 510°C (950°F), occurred very rapidly over
the apparent mass and heat balance discontinuity. only a few minutes. The exotherm occurred when the
Further monitoring of the HTS catalyst perform- plant operator was introducing steam into the catalyst
ance indicated a gradual but continual increase in the and there was no process gas present. It was confirmed
pressure drop. This seemed to be consistent with a that there was no synthesis gas in the steam and so any
boiler leak that was depositing boiler solids on the sur- explanations involving hexavalent chrome reduction or
face of the catalyst. other reduction reactions were ruled out as the root
When the catalyst pressure drop increased above cause of the observed exotherm. Furthermore, the
1.5 bar (22 psi) the plant operators shut-down the plant KATALCO 71-3 catalyst was confirmed to have only
to investigate the problem. As expected, a boiler leak trace levels of hexavalent chrome. Fortunately, subse-
was found and repaired. The top of the catalyst bed quent operation showed that the activity and strength of
was found to be covered with a crust and there was evi- the catalyst were unaffected by the rapid exotherm.
dence of some broken and damaged catalyst. It was de-