Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Carmen Cuadrado , Gyongyi Hajos , Carmen Burbano , Mercedes M.
Pedrosa , Gema Ayet , Mercedes Muzquiz , Arpad Pusztai & Eva Gelencser (2002) Effect of
Natural Fermentation on the Lectin of Lentils Measured by Immunological Methods, Food and
Agricultural Immunology, 14:1, 41-49, DOI: 10.1080/09540100220137655
( Original manuscript received 1 August 2000; revised manuscript accepted 24 August 2001)
The effects of natural fermentation upon the lectin in the seeds of Lens culinaris cultivar
Magda 20 were investigated. Suspensions of lentil flour were allowed to ferment naturally at
different lentil flour concentrations ( 79, 150 and 221 g l–1) and temperatures ( 28, 35 and
42°C). During fermentation, samples were taken at daily intervals (0, 24, 48, 72, and 96 h)
and lentil lectin activity was measured by haemagglutination test. With the progress of
fermentation there was a rapid decline in haemagglutination activity in all the batches. The
largest decrease occurred between 0 h and 24 h of fermentation in all the conditions. The
lectin concentration showed the maximum reduction at 72 and 96 h, under the fermentation
conditions of 79 g l–1 and 42°C, when the initial lectin content measured by ELISA was
reduced by 98 and 97.8%, respectively. The changes in lentil lectin were also followed by
SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting. The results confirmed those
obtained by ELISA and indicated that the lectin almost disappeared after 72 h of natural
fermentation under the optimum conditions of flour concentration and temperature.
INTRODUCTION
Fermentation is one of the oldest and most economical methods of processing and preserving
food. Foods are fermented for many reasons, including the enhacenment of nutritive value
and improvement of sensory characteristics such as odour and taste. In some parts of the
world large amounts of fermented food are produced to serve as an essential part of the diet.
Legume-based fermented foods originated centuries ago in these areas and are often referred
to as indigenous fermented foods. They are popular because changes in their flavour, aroma
and appearance are regarded as desirable and this is reinforced by improvements in their
ISSN 0954-0105 (print )/ISSN 1465-3443 ( online )/02/010041-0 9 © 2002 Taylor & Francis Ltd
DOI: 10.1080/09540100220137655
42 C. CUADRADO ET AL.
nutritive value, due to the partial or complete elimination of antinutritional factors ( Reddy &
Salunke, 1989).
Lentils ( Lens culinaris ) are a rich source of easily available and cheap protein both for
human and animal nutrition, and due to their essential amino acid profile, they can
complement cereal proteins in the diet. Unfortunately, as other legumes, lentils contain non-
nutritive factors which limit their acceptability as staple food. However, some of them, such
as phytic acid ( Cuadrado et al., 1996 ) and phenolic compounds and trypsin inhibitors ( Tabera
et al., 1995) can be greatly reduced in amounts by natural fermentation.
Lectins are natural carbohydrate reactive proteins which occur widely in plants. Most
plant-based food/feedstuffs contain appreciable amounts of lectins, some with striking
biological activities on the gut (Pusztai, 1991). As lectins react with the surface epithelium
of the digestive tract, they can cause antinutritional, mild allergic or other subclinical effects
in higher animals and humans (Pusztai et al., 1997 ). Although lentils are utilised by animals
with moderate efficiency, when some isolated lectins are incorporated in diets for rats, there
is a growth retardation and the activities of intestinal proteolitic enzymes, intestinal
disaccharidases and hepatic dehydrogenases are considerably reduced ( Jindal et al., 1982 ).
Also, the transport of sugars and amino acids by brush border membrane vesicles is
considerably impaired in vitro by the lentil lectins (Utal et al., 1990 ). Thus, to make these
foods safe, either the lectins themselves or their activity need to be eliminated or their
amounts reduced before consumption ( Pusztai, 1989). Although in general lectins are more
resistant to heat-denaturation than other plant proteins, legume lectins can be inactivated by
moderately prolonged cooking. However, as heat-processing is expensive and potentially
damaging, it is usually kept to a minimum even with legumes, particularly when the product
is to be used in animal nutrition ( Pusztai & Bardocz, 1996). Unfortunately, there is very little
published information on the effects of fermentation on lectin content. Reddy and Pierson
( 1994 ) have reported that the lectin content of beans can be reduced up to 95% in Tempeh
and other fermented foods which also involved additional heat-treatment as cooking or
steaming. To date there is no information about the effects of fermentation on lentil lectin.
The aim of the present work was to study the changes produced by different conditions of
natural fermentation ( time, temperature and flour concentration) in the amounts and properties
of lentil lectin to obtain a flour with higher nutritive value than the raw legume.
Microbial Analyses
Total viable counts ( TVC) were determined on PCA ( plate count agar) ( Adsa-Micro) and
lactobacilli were enumerated on double-layer MRS agar ( Adsa-Micro) both incubated at
EFFECT OF NATURAL FERMENTATION ON THE LECTIN OF LENTILS 43
Temperature Concentration
Batches ( °C) ( gl–1)
F1 28 79
F2 42 79
F3 28 221
F4 42 221
F5 35 150
F6 35 150
F7 35 150
32°C for 2 days. Identification of microorganisms was carried out according Harrigan and
McCance (1979).
Haemagglutination Activity
Haemagglutination activity was estimated as a measure of the lectin content of the samples
using the method described by Grant ( 1991 ). Trypsin treated rat erythrocytes were used in the
haemagglutination test. One unit of haemagglutinating ( lectin) activity ( HU) was defined as the
amount ( g) of sample in the last dilution which caused agglutination of 50% of the blood cells.
For comparison purposes the activity of the samples was calculated as HU kg–1 of dry matter.
Statistical Analysis
Analysis of variance was made to study the effect of fermentation process itself by comparing
control ( raw) and fermented samples on the lectin content and haemagglutination activity. Also
the significance of time of fermentation was studied by analysis of variance and t-test.
changes in pH were observed in the present study. This decline in pH during fermentation is
known to act as a bacteriostatic and preservative factor against bacteria associated with
spoilage and against nondesiderable and pathogenic microorganisms which cannot proliferate
under these conditions ( Wang & Hesseltine, 1981)
Figure 1 shows the effect of time, temperature and lentil flour concentration during natural
fermentation on the lectin activity of lentils measured using haemagglutination tests. The
reproducibility of the fermentation process was high since similar results were obtained in
batches F5, F6 and F7 fermented at identical conditions ( 35°C, 150 g l–1). These data were
combined and presented as mean and standard deviation (Fx ). With the progress of
fermentation there was a rapid decline in haemagglutination activity in all the batches. The
largest decrease occurred between 0 and 24 h of fermentation in all the conditions. After 96 h
FIG. 1. Effect of natural fermentation upon the lectin activity expressed as haemagglutination units ( HU)
per kg of dry matter of lentil flour suspensions F1, F2, F3, F4 , and Fx ( mean and standard deviation
data of F5, F6 and F7).
46 C. CUADRADO ET AL.
of natural fermentation the minimal haemagglutination activity values were obtained under
the fermentation conditions of 79 g l–1 and 42°C ( F2). In our previous work ( Cuadrado et al.,
1996 ) the influence of natural fermentation on the inositol phosphate content was analysed
to establish the effect of different conditions of temperature and broth concentration. From
the results it is concluded that 79 g l–1 and 42°C are the most effective fermentation
conditions to reduce the total inositol phosphate content of the meal ( 63% of reduction at
72 h). Tabera et al. ( 1995 ), using the same lentil variety and fermentation procedure, reported
a slight increase of total protein content after 4 days of fermentation in comparison with the
raw lentils, and a 62.5% reduction of trypsin inhibitor activity after the same fermentation
period at 42°C and 79 g l–1. The same conditions were also found to be the optimum to reduce
lectin activity in the present experiment.
The loss in lectin or haemagglutination activity detected could initially be due to either
changes in the part of the lectin protein structure which is responsible for the sugar binding
capacity and haemagglutination properties of LCA or as a result of the proteolytic degradation
of the lectin protein, the LCA content of the meal was reduced. Therefore, a more detailed study
was carried out with the fermented samples that showed the strongest reduction in
haemagglutination activity ( F2, 79 g l–1 and 42°C) to know the cause of such reduction.
Haemagglutination assays are at best semi-quantitive methods to determine the presence of
lectins. Moreover, some lectins may have their agglutination activity affected by high level of
sugars in the extract, or by the presence of compounds which damage red blood cells before
agglutination occur (Peumans & van Damme, 1996). Taking this into account and that the
measurement of lectins in a natural product require sensitive and specific methods, a competive
indirect ELISA technique has been developed, using specific polyclonal antibodies (PABs), to
quantify the lectin concentration in lentil samples. Indirect ELISA methods are more precise
than direct for assaying low concentrations of antigens ( Hajos et al., 1996).
Table 2 reports the lectin content of raw and F2 fermented samples quantified by
competitive indirect ELISA. The reduction of lectin concentration (LCA) in the fermented
samples is also reported as a percentage of the initial content ( raw seeds). The data in fact
indicated that a significant decrease in the LCA content occurred throught the fermentation
time ( 0–96 h). This decrease was parallel to that observed in haemagglutination units ( HU)
for the same fermented samples ( Figure 1). These results showed that a major reduction in
the lectin concentration occurred in the first 24 h of fermentation and that the greatest
decrease was achieved by 72 and 96 h of fermentation when the initial lectin content was
reduced by 98%, respectively.
Similar to following enzymatic modifications in proteins ( Hajos et al., 1996), changes in
the lentil lectin during fermentation were studied by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis
FIG. 2. Densitometric evaluation of the band corresponding to the b-chain ( 18 kDa) of lentil lectin ( LCA) on
the basis of immunoblotting patterns of raw and fermented lentil samples after SDS-PAGE separation.
The proteins were reacted on nitro-cellulose membrane with anti-LCA rabbit IgG. Raw lentil, 100%
relative LCA content ( Peak 1); fermented lentil samples: 0 h, 77% relative LCA content ( Peak 2); 24 h,
58% relative LCA content ( Peak 3); 48 h, 37% relative LCA content (Peak 4); 72 h, 13% relative LCA
content (Peak 5); 96 h, 3% relative LCA content (Peak 6); lentil lectin standard, LCA ( Peak 7).
and immunoblotting. The pure lentil lectin used as standard showed two spaced bands of 8
and 18 kDa in SDS-PAGE in agreement with evidences that lentil lectin consisted of two light
a-chains and two heavy b-chains ( Fliegerová et al., 1974; Foriers et al., 1981 ). The
immunoblots of the pure lentil lectin showed only one band of 18 kDa which should
correspond to the b-chain. Figure 2 shows the immunoblotting patterns of transblotted raw
and F2 fermented samples after SDS-PAGE separation and the densitometric evaluation of
the band corresponding to the b-chain of lentil lectin ( LCA). From this densitometric
evaluation a peak area for each sample is obtained, which enable to calculate the percentage
of LCA of each sample relative to the raw lentils. These results confirmed those obtained by
ELISA and indicated that the lectin was partially degraded after 24 h (58% of LCA) and
almost disappeared after 96 h ( 3% of LCA) of natural fermentation at 42°C and 79 g 1–1. On
the bases of the SDS-PAGE patterns of F2 fermented samples related to the raw flour there
was evidence of proteolisis during fermentation in some bands between 31–18 kDa. Data
previously published (Tabera et al., 1995 ) indicated that the total protein content estimated
by N content did not decrease under these fermentation conditions. Probably, the different
methodology used can explain these results.
The present study clearly shows that the lectin content ( LCA) of the lentil meal was
essentially completely removed using a natural fermentation procedure and that this occurred
without any additional heat-treatment. The scarce information on the influence of fermentation
on lectin content indicated that fermentation with microorganisms with additional controlled
heat treatment, as cooking or steaming, decreases lectin activity from beans ( Reddy & Pierson,
1994 ). However, based on the present and previous findings for other antinutritive factors
( Tabera et al., 1995; Cuadrado et al., 1996 ) it can be concluded that the natural fermentation
itself, without any additional heat-treatment, is a powerful method capable of improving the
nutritional value of lentils by reducing the level of non-nutritive compounds.
Trugo and von Baer ( 1998 ) indicated that immunological methods are a more specific and
sensitive approach for the quantitative measurement of lectins than erythrocyte agglutination
tests. Our results show that the immunochemical assays used in the present work have adequate
sensitivity to detect residual amounts of lentil lectin in products processed for food use.
48 C. CUADRADO ET AL.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was supported by the INIA ( Project SC97–057) and by OMFB and FM of
Hungary and it is a part of COST-98 Action ( EU). The authors wish to thank the INIA for
awarding postdoctoral grants to CC and MMP and EU/COST 98 for Short Term Scientific
Missions to CC. The highly skilled assistance of Mrs Kissne-Valentin Eva, Betty Zarai and
Mr Istvan Makk is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
BAYNE, C. K. & RUBIN, I. B. (1986 ) Practical Experimental Designs and Optimization Methods for
Chemists. VCH Deerfield Beach, Florida.
CUADRADO, C., AYET, G., ROBREDO, L. M., TABERA, J., VILLA, R., PEDROSA, M. M., BURBANO, C. &
MUZQUIZ, M. ( 1996 ) Effect of natural fermentation on the content of inositol phosphates in lentils,
Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung, 203, 268– 271.
CUADRADO, C., BURBANO, C., GELENCSER, E., GRANT, G. & PUSZTAI, A. ( 1997 ) Large scale purification of
lectin from lentil seeds and determination of the lectin content in processed lentils, in COST 98 –
Effects of Antinutrients on the Nutritional Value of Legume Diets, Vol. IV ( BARDOZC, S., MUZQUIZ, M.
& PUSZTAI, A., Eds). Office for Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, pp.
82– 88.
FLIEGEROVÁ, O., SALVETOVÁ, A. TICHÁ, M. & KOCOUREK, J. ( 1974 ) Studies on phytohemagglutinins. XIX.
Subunit structure of the lentil isophytohemagglutinins, Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, 351,
416– 426.
FORIERS, A., LEBRUN, E., VAN RAPENBUSCH, R., DE NEVE, R. & STROSBERG A. D. (1981 ) The structure of
the lentil ( Lens culinaris ) lectin. Amino acid sequence determination and prediction of the secondar y
structure, The Journal of Biological Chemistry, 256, 5550– 5560
GRANT, G. (1991 ) Lectins, in Toxic Substances in Crop Plants ( D’MELLO, J. P. F., DUFFUS, C. M. &
DUFFUS, J. H., Eds). The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, pp 49– 67.
HAJÓS, G., GELENCSÉR, E., PUSZTAI, A., GRANT, G., SAKHRI, M. & BARDOCZ, S. ( 1995 ) Biological effects
and survival of trypsin inhibitors and the agglutinin from soybean in the small intestine of the rat,
Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry, 43, 165–170.
HAJÓS, G., GELENCSÉR, E., PUSZTAI, A. & BARDOCZ, S. ( 1996 ) Measurements of the antinutrient contents
of legume samples, in Cost 98 – Effects of Antinutrients on the Nutritional Value of Legume Diets,
Vol. I ( BARDOCZ, S., GELENCSER, E. & PUSZTAI, A., Eds). Office for Publications of the European
Communities, Luxembourg, pp. 130–134.
HARBOE, N. & INGLID, A. ( 1973 ) Immunization, isolation of immunoglobulins, estimation of antibody titre,
in A Manual of Quantitative Immunoelectrophoresis, Methods and Application s ( AXELSEN, N. H.,
KROLL, J. & WEEKE, B., Eds). Scandinavian Journal of Immunology, Suppl. 1, 1590–1595.
HARRIGAN, W. F. & MCCANCE, M. E. ( 1979 ) Métodos de Laboratorio en Microbiolo g´õ a de Alimentos y
Productos Lácteos. Ed. Academia, León, Spain.
JINDAL, S., SONI, G. L. & SINGH, R. ( 1982 ) Effect of feeding of lectins from lentils and peas on the
intestinal and hepatic enzymes of albino rats, Journal of Plant Foods, 4, 95–103.
PEUMANS, W. J. & VAN DAMME, E. J. M. (1996 ) Prevalence, biological activity and genetic manipulatio n
of lectins in foods, Trends in Food Science and Technology, 7, 132–138.
PUSZTAI, A. ( 1989 ) Lectins, in Toxicants of Plant Origin, Vol. III ( CHEEKE, P. R., Ed.). CRC Press, Boca
Raton, Florida, pp. 29–71.
PUSZTAI, A. (1991 ) Plant Lectins. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
PUSZTAI, A. & BARDOCZ, S. ( 1996 ) Biological effects of plant lectins on the gastrointestinal tract: metabolic
consequences and applications, Trends in Glycoscience and Glycotechnolog y, 41, 149–165.
PUSZTAI, A., GELENCSER, E., GRANT, G. & BARDOZC, S. ( 1997 ) Nutritional manipulation of immune
competence in young non-ruminant animals, in Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition ( GARNSWORLHY,
P. C. & WISAMAN, G., Eds). Nottingham University Press, Nottingham, pp. 29–43.
RAGAEE, S. M., EL-BANNA, A. A. DAMIR, A. A., MESSALAM, A. S. & MOHAMED, M. S. ( 1985 ) Natural lactic
acid fermentation of lentils, Microbiologie Aliments Nutrition, 3, 181–184.
REDDY, N. R. & PIERSON, M. D. (1994 ) Reduction in antinutritional and toxic components in plant foods
by fermentation, Food Research Internationa l, 27, 281– 290.
REDDY, N. R. & SALUNKHE, D. K. ( 1989 ) Fermentation, in CRC Handbook of World Food Legumes:
Nutritional, Chemistry, Processing, Technology and Utilization, Vol. III ( SALUNKE, D. K. & KADAM, S.
S., Eds). CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, pp. 77– 218.
TABERA, J., FRIAS, J., ESTRELLA, I., VILLA, R. & VIDAL-VALVERDE, C. (1995 ) Natural fermentation of lentils.
Influence of time, concentration and temperature on protein content, trypsin inhibitor activity and
phenolic compound content, Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung, 201,
587– 591.
EFFECT OF NATURAL FERMENTATION ON THE LECTIN OF LENTILS 49
TRUGO, L. C. & VON BAER, D. (1998 ) Analytical methods for the analysis of antinutritional factors in
legume seeds, in Recent Advances of Research in Antinutritional Factors in Legume Seeds and
Rapeseeds (JANSMAN, A. J. M., HILL, G. D. & VAN DER POEL, A. F. B., Eds). Wageningen Pers,
Wageningen, pp. 11– 28.
VIDAL-VALVERDE, C., FRIAS, J., PRODANOV, M., TABERA, J., RUIZ, R., & BACON, J. (1993 ) Effects of natural
fermentation on carbohydrates, riboflavin and tripsin ihnibitor activity of lentils, Zeitschrift für
Lebensmittel Untersuchung und Forschung, 197, 449– 452.
UTAL, A. K., VERMA, K., SONI, G. L. & SINGH, R. ( 1990 ) Effect of pea and lentil lectins on in vitro
absorption of nutrients, Indian Journal of Experimental Biology, 28, 93– 95.
WANG, H. L. & HESSELTINE, C. W. ( 1981 ) Use of microorganisms cultures: legume and cereal products ,
Food Technolog y, 35, 79– 83.