You are on page 1of 8

Industrial Management & Data Systems

E-business success at Intel: an organization ecology and resource dependence perspective


Dien D. Phan
Article information:
To cite this document:
Dien D. Phan, (2002),"E-business success at Intel: an organization ecology and resource dependence perspective",
Industrial Management & Data Systems, Vol. 102 Iss 4 pp. 211 - 217
Permanent link to this document:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/02635570210423253
Downloaded on: 17 June 2015, At: 07:25 (PT)
References: this document contains references to 22 other documents.
To copy this document: permissions@emeraldinsight.com
The fulltext of this document has been downloaded 2224 times since 2006*
Users who downloaded this article also downloaded:
(2002),"Intel’s e-business strategy", Strategic Direction, Vol. 18 Iss 11 pp. 9-11 http://
dx.doi.org/10.1108/02580540210794085
Donald G. Norris, (1993),"“Intel Inside” BRANDING A COMPONENT IN A BUSINESS MARKET", Journal of Business &
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

Industrial Marketing, Vol. 8 Iss 1 pp. 14-24 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/08858629310027560


Enrico Colla, Paul Lapoule, (2012),"E-commerce: exploring the critical success factors", International Journal of Retail &
Distribution Management, Vol. 40 Iss 11 pp. 842-864 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09590551211267601

Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by emerald-srm:198285 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service
information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please
visit www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of
more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online
products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication
Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.

*Related content and download information correct at time of download.


E-business success at Intel: an organization ecology
and resource dependence perspective

Dien D. Phan
Nicole Maria Stata Professor of MIS, University of Vermont, Burlington,
Vermont, USA

Keywords and MIS research in recent years (Phan, 1990).


Internet, Business development, Introduction Similar to the approach that biologists used to
Value chain, Supply chain
Electronic business (e-business) today plays explain the evolution and proliferation of
Abstract a major role in the world economic growth different species in the environment,
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

Electronic business (e-business) thanks to the rapid advance in information organizational theorists use the ecological
today plays a major role in the world technology (IT). As ITs develop, novel ways of theory to explain the formation and growth of
economic growth, thanks to the
rapid advance in information
business process redesign emerged, creating organizations in the environment. Although
technology. Recent estimates from turmoil in the industry. Organizations today they do not agree on a specific approach to use
Forester Research show that by frequently redesigned their processes in in studying organization life-cycle, major
2003 the value of e-commerce of US ways that provide new competitive ecological studies on organizations in the past
and Europe will reach US$3 trillion,
advantages. Success breeds imitation, and decade have been centered around three basic
the number of households in the
USA that have PCs will reach 64 invites more entries to e-business. There are approaches: developmental approach,
million, those that have access to many spectacular successes, but there are selection approach, and macroevolutionary
the Internet will reach 60 million, also many failures. As technology continues approach (Carroll, 1984). The developmental
and the number of mobile phones
to develop, organizations are in constant approach theorists argued that organization
will reach 69 million. There are
many spectacular successful search for new e-business technology and structures change over time, the form of
e-businesses but there are also available resources to gain competitive change being shaped by structural pressures
numerous failures. Presents a study advantages. Even the well-established and constraints. They also argued that
of e-business success at Intel Corp. software giant Microsoft is aware of that. organizations are highly adaptive. The
Intel reached $1 billion value in
e-business in its first month of
Chairman of Microsoft, Bill Gates, has a fear selection approach theorists argued that
deployment in July 1998. For the that Microsoft is about two years away from organizations were primarily not adaptive,
year of 2000, Intel's profits climbed failure, and that somewhere out there is a but largely inertial. Theorists using this
to $10.5 billion to become the fifth formidable competitor, unborn and approach believe that only the best
most profitable company in the USA,
unknown, who will use better business organizations will survive. Finally,
up from the eighth rank last year.
Concludes with lessons learned and models to put companies like Microsoft into macroevolutionary approach theorists
success factors. obsolescence. Turban et al. (2000) believe that focused on the change over time in a
the hottest and most dangerous new business community of organizations or industry
models out there are using e-business. rather than individual organizations. By
In 1998, Intel approached e-business as a focusing on large-scale changes in a
new way of doing business, and management community of organizations, they tried to
The author would like to wanted customers to know that Intel was describe the rise and fall of organizations
thank Mr Than Trong Phuc, serious with e-business. Intel created a self- within an industry.
General Manager of Intel service extranet called E-Business Program Because organizations are not internally
Corp., Vietnam for the which focused on procurement and customer
precious information on self-sufficient, they require resources from the
supports for its products. Access to the site environment, and thus become
Intel's success.
was restricted to Intel's authorized business interdependent with those elements of the
partners and customers. environment with which they transact.
Pfeffer (1982), and Pfeffer and Salancik (1978)
argued that organizations develop internal
Literature review and external strategies which seek to
Studying the effects of environment on minimize the uncertainty arising from
organizations in organizations has received a dependence on the environment for resources.
Industrial Management & To minimize transaction costs
Data Systems great deal of attention in organization theory
102/4 [2002] 211±217 (Williamson, 1981), organizations will seek
# MCB UP Limited low-cost strategies where feasible. In order
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
[ISSN 0263-5577] for the USA to compete effectively against
[DOI 10.1108/02635570210423253] http://www.emeraldinsight.com/0263-5577.htm
Japanese firms in the Keiretsu system in the
[ 211 ]
Dien D. Phan 1990s, Ferguson (1990) suggested that the US 3 Multimedia content and network
E-business success at Intel: computer industry be networked into a high- publishing (i.e. WWW, HTML, XML, Java,
an organization ecology and CGI, etc.).
resource dependence tech chain industry.
perspective As the technology advances and the 4 Network information superhighway
Industrial Management & computer industry develops and grows, (i.e. Cable TV, Internet, telephone,
Data Systems market niches open and close frequently, wireless media, etc.).
102/4 [2002] 211±217
creating rapid changes in the industry. The
prevalence of technical innovations may be E-business success factors and challenges
regular, sporadic, or only once; these Evolution in e-business processes has
patterns of change have different established a new value chain that links the
implications for organizational populations. core business with sales and distribution
When they occur often, a niche may open up channels and supply chains. The new value
and organization competes to take the chains, in turn, created tremendous demands
advantage of cost savings and market on high-speed data communications. Studies
penetration that often results in better profits have shown that, by applying new network
and market shares. technologies, companies can operate more
Porter (1985) developed the value chain efficiently, extend traditional to electronic
model which highlights interdependence markets, and create larger inter-
activities in the business where competitive organizational virtual structures that are
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

strategies can be best applied and where composed of the company and its customers,
information systems are most likely to have distributors, and suppliers. To succeed,
strategic impacts. As IT developed, novel companies will need to evaluate innovative
ways of business process redesign emerged. strategies that capitalize on both the power of
Organizations today frequently redesigned the Internet and the change in consumer
their processes in ways that provide new demands from both traditional and electronic
competitive advantages in which e-business markets. In order to manage resource inter-
is viewed as the most attractive solution. dependence, e-commerce companies are
Andy Grove, chairman of Intel, boldly stated required to develop more responsive, and
in 1998: ``Within five years, all companies will deeper and broader relationships with
be Internet companies or they won't be customers, suppliers, and distributors
companies'' (Intel Corp., 2000). (Scarborough and Spatarella, 1998).
There are basically six categories of Furthermore, the supply chains within
e-business: Business to Business (B2B), e-commerce companies also continue to
Business to Consumer (B2C), Consumer change. The changes include the conversion
to Business (C2B), Consumer to Consumer of information systems from the legacy
(C2C), Non-business, and Intra-business. vendor centric model to the Web-based
Without face-to-face, all e-business customer centric model and how delivery
transactions are done electronically by using channels are operated. Businesses need to be
computer and communication networks. sure that customers and suppliers can gain
Applications of e-business are classified into access to their Web sites to gain important
three categories: product information for decision making.
1 Electronic markets: Buying and selling Information also will give customers and
goods and services or electronic markets. suppliers the ability to receive and ship
2 Inter-organizational systems: Facilitating products or services at the right price, time,
inter- and intra-organization flow of place, and speed. The major barriers to
information, communication, and customers' and suppliers' access to the Web
collaboration. is ease and speed of access. Other barriers
3 Customer service: Provide customer include risk, privacy, confidentiality, and
service, help, handling complaints, security. Customer expectations about
tracking orders, etc. (Senn, 1996). convenience, speed, competitive price, and
service are also key factors in the success of
The infrastructure of e-commerce can be e-business (Hammel and Sampler, 1999).
built on the existing information technology. Studies by Mougayar (1998) and Raisch
Kalakota and Whinston (1997) suggest that (2001) suggested the following success factors
four infrastructures are necessary in for e-business:
implementing electronic commerce . Cater to buyer e-business behavior and
applications: customer personalization.
1 Common business service (i.e. security, . Maintain first-mover advantage, ensure
authentication, electronic payment, and quick time to market.
electronic catalog, portals, etc.). . Create right digital infrastructure.
2 Messaging and information distribution . Reduce operational cost and leverage
(i.e. EDI, e-mail and HTTP, etc.). outside innovation.
[ 212 ]
Dien D. Phan . Control risk while allowing innovation. service extranet called E-Business Program,
E-business success at Intel: . Conduct necessary education and training which focused on procurement and customer
an organization ecology and support for its products. Access to the site
resource dependence to employees, management and customers.
perspective . Review current distribution and supply was restricted to Intel's authorized business
Industrial Management & chain model to maximize company's gain. partners and customers.
Data Systems . Understand customers' and partners' As illustrated in Figure 1, the roles and
102/4 [2002] 211±217 responsibilities of teams that participated in
expectations from the Web.
. Improve products and services offered by the early development of the e-business
e-business. system at Intel were:
. Extend current systems to expand business. . A project planning team, which consisted
. Track new competitors and market shares. of customer, technical and logistical
. Develop new Web-centric marketing perspectives was created to define the
strategy. scope and objective of the project.
. Help to create company's own virtual . Business analysts were brought in during
market place. the early stages to help define the business
workflow and assess how information is
given to customers.
Intel's e-business development . Intel's sales and marketing staff were
assigned to define how best to work with
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

Intel Corp., located in Santa Clara, customers via the e-business system.
California, is the world's largest producer of . Intel's planning and logistics group was
integrated circuits chips in the world today. also included on the planning team to help
Founded in 1968 to build semiconductor the IT department build a solution that
chips, Intel invented the microprocessor integrated with existing business systems.
more than 25 years ago. Today, the company . The IT department was positioned as an
has evolved from a processor manufacturer ``enabler'' of business. Its role was to
into a supplier of network and server integrate e-business technologies and to
hardware, Internet hosting services, and prepare for implementation.
other e-business components. Its
technological leadership ranges from Intel's mission and goals
microprocessor design to advanced Intel's early mission was to design and
manufacturing and packaging, and it deploy a worldwide e-business solution to
maintains production and research facilities strengthen its current business. The mission
around the world. was accomplished by deploying an
Most of its business is in the PC market. infrastructure that worked with existing
Intel is under intense competition from other business processes rather than requiring
chip makers such as Advanced Micro widespread change. The intent was to use
Devices (AMD), Cyrix, Texas Instruments, the Internet to expand existing business,
Motorola, and IBM. In the past, Intel market current products and exploit sales
customized catalogs and sent them to its channels.
potential customers along with product With over 50 percent of its revenues and
availability information. Until summer 1998, many customers coming from outside of the
this process was done entirely on paper. USA, the benefits of a global e-business
However, when large customers such as Dell system for Intel was too great to be ignored.
Computers and Cisco Systems started to use With over $25 billion annual sales in 1998
the Web to do their business in 1996, they and a world wide network of business
pressured Intel to do the same. partners, resellers, and original equipment
In 1997, Intel began to investigate the manufacturers (OEM), Intel needed to
feasibility of building the e-business system. improve its efficiency by automating its B2B
The project started with the virtual processes. Traditional business processes at
worldwide e-business team. Because of the Intel at that time was too slow and thus the
project emphasis on customer market needs, decision was to deploy a Web-based order
the team gave Intel's sales and marketing management system.
the responsibility to drive the project
forward. Strategies
Rather than attempt to build the entire
E-business project organizational structure business infrastructure from ground zero,
In 1998, Intel approached e-business as a new Intel was conservative and focused on a
way of doing business and management relationship with direct customers, including
wanted customers to know that Intel was OEMs and distributors online. ``We picked
serious with e-business. To better manage the one thing we could build very quickly and
resource dependence, Intel created a self- deploy to our customers'', said Sandra
[ 213 ]
Dien D. Phan Morris, Vice President of Marketing Group toward more efficient and productive tasks.
E-business success at Intel: at Intel. These conservative strategies Additionally, sales people seldom needed to
an organization ecology and include broaden and deepened sales hand-deliver confidential product
resource dependence
perspective outreach, targeted middle-tier companies, information as they had done in the past. The
Industrial Management & and customized Web sites to personalize stakes for the success of the pilot program
Data Systems information delivery. were great. With this customer segment, Intel
102/4 [2002] 211±217
was dealing with at least one billion dollars
Broaden and deepen sales outreach
per quarter of order processing right from
The first goal of e-business solution was to
the start.
extend the reach of Intel's sales force. To do
this, Intel automated its order management Improve customer service by delivering
and information delivery system. The personalized information
greatest opportunity for efficiency gains in Intel took great efforts to convert its system
1997 was with the customers who were not and data from the old vendor-centric model to
already electronically connected to Intel. By the new customer-centric model. The goal
converting the ``unwired'' to ``wired'', Intel was to improve customer service by
replaced the traditional phone and fax as a personalizing information delivery and then
means of communication with PC-based on- automating information delivery and routine
line communication tools. sales tasks.
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

Because management, procurement, sales


Target middle tier for greatest efficiencies
and marketing, and engineering all have
Rather than aiming at a large number of
different informational needs, Intel
small customers who accounted for 70
customized its Web sites within customer
percent of total number of accounts world
accounts. Being able to deliver personalized
wide at the beginning, Intel wanted to go
information online allows Intel to support
step-by-step by aiming the pilot program at
multiple levels of the customer organization
the middle-tier customers who accounted for
in a manner that best meets an individual's
only 25 percent of total accounts in 35
needs. This makes it easier for every
countries. However, Intel's conservative goal
customer to do his/her own research and to
was not so easy. Maintaining a consistently
take the appropriate actions.
high level of one-to-one contact for a large
Customers visiting the Intel extranet Web
number of middle-tier customers was
site will find their name and specific
difficult. These medium-sized customers
applications available to them based on their
typically are not invested in EDI as a
personal profile. The user profile allows a
backend system. The benefits of this pilot
customer to obtain confidential information
program to customers and Intel were
that is important to that customer. The
numerous. By providing access to real-time
customer in this example can be a general
information, Intel will allow them to be more
manager with access to pricing and
knowledgeable of Intel products and future
availability, order placement, backlog status,
direction for better decision making. In
committed delivery dates, or the information
addition, customers will feel more connected,
desk.
have access to more Intel resources, and have
closer contact. E-business deployment
For Intel, connecting this large customer The initial e-business pilot system launched
segment electronically brought multiple in 1998, was a one-stop, 240 shopping sites for
benefits. The company was able to move customers throughout the world.
resources away from the phone and fax Personalized data and applications are
tailored to users' needs to provide an
Figure 1 individualized experience.
Intel's initial e-business project organization structure
System architecture
In order to simplify the system maintenance
and supports, Intel decided to standardize the
e-business architecture to one hardware
vendor, one operating system, and
minimized the number of database and
application vendors. This architecture was
flexible and scaleable to help manage the cost
of ownership as the system grows:
. Servers. Intel's initial e-business system
infrastructure was built around three
main clusters of Internet servers: Web-
servers, database servers, and data
[ 214 ]
Dien D. Phan analysis servers. Standardizing on one . Intel moved $1 billion in revenue to its
E-business success at Intel: hardware vendor simplifies maintenance online e-business system in the first 15
an organization ecology and
resource dependence costs, makes growth easier, and allows days, surpassing the company's initial
perspective Intel to interchange components as launch goal of moving $1 billion in the
Industrial Management & necessary without compatibility issues. first three months.
Data Systems . OS and Databases. Intel's e-business . The company was able to eliminate most
102/4 [2002] 211±217
system is standardized on one operating faxes to its customers worldwide. For
system. In the database area, Intel has Taiwan alone, it claimed that it
limited it to two vendors. eliminated 45,000 faxes per quarter. Intel
. Application development. Intel provides a revenues from Web orders are projected at
number of applications that serve specific 90 percent of Intel revenues by 2001.
needs and has made a great effort to use . The company quickly ``ramped'' $1 billion
off-the-shelf applications. of online orders per month in 1998.
. Independent customer surveys rated
Deployment problems and challenges
Intel's e-business at 94 percent satisfaction
For transaction security, Intel sites let
level.
customers place and track orders using
standard Web browsers with Secure Socket
Layer (SSL) encryption. However, the 128-bit
Lessons learned and success
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

technology was banned from export by US


law. To enable a strong encryption factors
technology world wide, Intel encouraged its Despite thorough planning by Intel's
customers to acquire third-party 128-bit worldwide team, the most significant payoff
encryption application that was developed from deploying the e-business solution was
outside of the USA. how much the company learned. Key success
To increase network throughput, factors are:
compressions were used. Intel found that, . Tailor to customer's needs. The first
with SSL, encrypted file transfers are very and most important key learning is to
sensitive to packet loss. When packet loss focus on the customer. In order to move
rate exceeds 15 percent, the download times into e-business, Intel converted its
for encrypted pages skyrocket. It was critical systems from the vendor-centric model to
for Intel to reduce the packet loss rate. Intel customer-centric model.
also found that most of the transmission . Avoid unfamiliar market and risks. Intel
problems for customers were located in the e-business systems was aimed at its
connections between customer sites to end current market with solid revenues and
offices and tandem offices of the telephone earnings. Unlike the recent Federated's
companies. The solution is to reduce the Fingerhut fiasco (Business Week, 2000),
number of elements that needs to be Intel's management refrained from
transferred through the network. This was expanding e-business to unfamiliar
done by redesigning the Web pages to store markets or acquiring new e-business
reusable artifacts such as graphics, menus, partners.
and icons at customer sites, so that only . Follow conservative and traditional
compressed data will be transferred. Intel management principles. Unlike most
also urged customers to upgrade its network dot-coms, Intel managed its e-business
connections to ISP servers with high conservatively by the books. It managed
bandwidth pipes, and high-speed network costs carefully and kept everything under
and routers. control.
. Deliver personalized Web content. Web
Results content must be accurate, current, and
On 1 July 1998, Intel officially began taking appropriate for each individual customer.
orders from OEM and distribution Intel continues to work closely with sales-
customers using a new series of forces to ensure that customers are
personalized Web sites. The new e-business getting what they need and are coming
system enabled approximately 200 of Intel's back to the site.
customers in almost 30 countries to place . Quality focus. It is necessary to anticipate
orders for Intel products, check product frequent changes in both internal and
availability and inventory status, receive external behaviors and processes. Intel
marketing and sales information, and moved into e-business on a continuous
obtain customer support ± all in real time, and iterative cycle of improvement. For a
24 hours a day, seven days a week. Major global company like Intel, connectivity
successes at Intel e-business deployment are can be a real challenge throughout the
cited below: world, especially in parts of Europe and
[ 215 ]
Dien D. Phan Asia. Intel frequently tested the
E-business success at Intel: connectivity with customers in the real Conclusions
an organization ecology and production environment. Because
resource dependence With the rapid advance in technology, novel
perspective performance can vary significantly in ways of business process redesign, which
Industrial Management & different countries, Intel went the extra include e-business, emerged, thus creating
Data Systems mile to bring customers' connections up to turmoil in many US industries.
102/4 [2002] 211±217
the global standard. Organizations today frequently redesigned
. Robust and flexible e-business systems their processes in ways that provide new
architecture. A robust and flexible system competitive advantages. Success breeds
will allow e-business to move ahead imitation, and invites more entries to
quickly. By separating front-end e-business in many combinations. However,
functionality of the Web site from the back e-enterprises must manage their business
office systems, applications can be conservatively and avoid rapid expansion
developed for customers with frequent into unfamiliar markets, or acquiring other
updates without being affected by e-businesses that do not have solid revenues
enterprise-type applications. This is and earnings. Besides good communication
because enterprise applications commonly access speed and security, traditional
required longer development cycles. management styles, such as focus to the
customers, high quality service, and
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

. Use the best security protection schemes:


To avoid costly Web site shutdown, Intel training, also play a major role in the success
protected its e-business systems with the of e-business.
best security schemes and encryption The strategies and success factors
available. This is because e-business discussed in this paper can serve as a menu
systems use new technologies and for e-business managers to choose in order to
components that are often not thoroughly develop and improve their e-business
tested. Intel went to great lengths to find operations.
ways to implement the 128-bit encryption
worldwide despite that the US References
Government prohibited the export of this Business Week (2000), ``Federated's Fingerhut
encryption. fiasco'', Business Week, 18 December,
pp. 198-202.
A comparisons of e-business success factors Carroll, G.R. (1984), ``Organizational ecology'',
between the success factors mentioned by Annual Review of Sociology, August.
the literature and Intel's study, is presented Ferguson, C.H. (1990), ``Computer and the coming
in Table I. While the literature did not of the US Keiretsu'', Harvard Business Review,
mention network connection quality and July-August, pp. 55-70.
security, these factors are important to Hammel, G. and Sampler, J. (1999), ``The
Intel's success. e-corporation'', Fortune, 7 December,
pp. 81-92.
Intel Corp. (2000), available at: www.intel.com/
Table I eBusiness/estrategies/enabling/January.
Comparison of success factors between the literature and Intel's study Kalakota, R. and Whinston, A. (1997), Electronic
Factors Literature Intel Commerce: A Manager's Guide, Addison
Wesley, Reading, MA.
Customer focus, personalization Y Y
Mougayar, W. (1998), Opening Digital Markets,
First-mover advantage, ensure quick time to market Y Y McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.
Right digital infrastructure Y Y Pfeffer, J. (1982), Organization and Organization
Operational cost control Y Y Theory, Pitman, Boston, MA.
Control risk while allowing innovation Y Y Pfeffer, J. and Salancik, G.R. (1978), The External
Education and training Y Y Control of Organizations: A Resource
Distribution and supply chain Y Y Dependence Perspective, Harper and Row,
Customer expectations management Y Y New York, NY, pp. 92-184.
Products and services reevaluated Y Y Phan, D.D. (1990), Information Systems Project
Human resources Y Y Management: A Resources Dependence
Extension of current systems Y Y Perspective, PhD Dissertation, University of
Competitors and market shares tracked Y Y Arizona, Tucson, AZ.
Web-centric marketing strategy Y Y Porter, M. (1985), Competitive Advantage,
Virtual marketplace participation Y Y Free Press, New York, NY.
E-business management style Y Y Raisch, W.D. (2001), The Marketplace:
Quality of network connections for partners/customers ± Y Strategies for Success in B2B, McGraw-Hill,
Security ± Y New York, NY.
Scarborough, M. and Spatarella, J. (1998),
Notes: Y = used and/or required; ± = not applicable nor required ``Getting behind the business of electronic

[ 216 ]
Dien D. Phan commerce'', Journal of Cash Management, Intel Corp. (2001), available at: www.intel.com/
E-business success at Intel: Vol. 18 No. 4, pp. 42-6. eBusiness/casestudies/snapshots/
an organization ecology and Senn, J.A. (1996), ``Capitalization on electronic
resource dependence intel_p.htm, 10 January.
perspective commerce'', Information Systems Rosen, M. (2000), ``Software portals'', Software
Management, Summer. Magazine, October-November, p. 22.
Industrial Management &
Data Systems Turban, E., Lee, J., King, D. and Chung, H. (2000), Schadler, T. (2000), ``The future of e-trade'',
102/4 [2002] 211±217 Electronic Commerce: A Managerial Forester Research, January.
Perspective, Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle Tarn, J.M., Wen, H.J, Tang, H. and Han, B. (2000),
River, NJ.
``E-commerce: rationales for business
Williamson, O. (1981), ``The economics of
adoption and adaptation'', Proceedings of the
organization: the transaction cost approach'',
American Journal of Sociology, No. 87, 2000 International Conference of Pacific Rim
pp. 548-77. Management, 4-6 August, pp. 140-5.
Than, P.T. (2000), ``Intel Corporation: the
Further reading e-business payoff'', Proceedings of the
Business Week (2001), ``Corporate scoreboard'', IT@Edu2000 Conference, Ho Chi Minh City,
Business Week, 26 February, p. 60. Vietnam, 6-7 January, p. 202.
Downloaded by New York University At 07:25 17 June 2015 (PT)

[ 217 ]

You might also like