09/12/2021, 17:50 Coronavirus Vaccines and the Use of Aborted Fetal Cells - Institut Européen de Bioéthique

Cookies ensure the proper functioning of this service. If you continue with your visit, we assume
that you accept the use of cookies. (Learn more (/en/legal-notice.html))

I accept
Coronavirus Vaccines and the Use of Aborted Fetal Cells
Published on : 14/07/2021

At a time of accelerated development of

vaccines against Covid-19, being well-
informed is important, especially
regarding the ethics of how these
vaccines are developed and then
produced and tested. The potential use
of aborted fetuses' cell lines at any stage
of the process is key for the ethical
discernment. The Charlotte Lozier
Institute in the United States has
published, on the basis of a rigorous
analysis of the scientific literature and the
results of clinical trials, a detailed report
(https://lozierinstitute.org/update-covid-19-vaccine-candidates-and-abortion-derived-cell-lines/) of
pharmaceutical companies that do or do not use such ethically controversial cell lines. The aim is
to help the reader make informed choices regarding vaccines against the Coronavirus. 

Let us first recall what a fetal cell line (https://s27589.pcdn.co/wp-

content/uploads/2020/09/09.17.20-Fetal-Cell-Line-Fact-Sheet.pdf) consists in. It is obtained by
taking a cell from a fetus (in this case, aborted) and multiplying it into several identical cells.
These cells can be grown and multiplied for several decades, creating "cell lines", which are often
used in scientific experiments. Some fetal cell lines date back decades and are used in the
development of new vaccines. These are in particular the HEK293 and PER.C6 lines. The use of
these cells does not require new abortions, but it is based on abortions that took place in the 1960s,
1970s and 1980s. 

The question arises as to whether these fetal cell lines are absolutely necessary for the
development of vaccines, specifically the Covid-19 vaccine. The answer is no: it is possible to
develop vaccines ethically, either using no cells or using animal, chicken egg or yeast
cells. And several pharmaceutical companies are doing this. 

We need then to understand the different steps in the development in which cell lines from
aborted fetuses may be used.
 

Last update : 14/07/2021

1. Design and development phase: it consists in the conceptualization of the vaccine, preparatory
experiments, and specifications as to how the vaccine will be produced. 
https://www.ieb-eib.org/en/news/biomedical-research/medical-research/coronavirus-vaccines-and-the-use-of-aborted-fetal-cells-2029.html 1/5
09/12/2021, 17:50 Coronavirus Vaccines and the Use of Aborted Fetal Cells - Institut Européen de Bioéthique

Pharmaceutical companies and research institutes that have used cell lines from aborted fetuses in
this phase: 

- Altimmune (USA)  
- Astra Zeneca & University of Oxford (UK, USA) 

- CanSino Biologics, Inc. Beijing Institute of Biotechnology, Academy of Military Medical

Sciences, PLA of China (China) 

- Gamaleya Research Institute ("Sputnik V") (Russia) 

- ImmunityBio and NantKwest (USA) 

- Janssen Research & Development, Inc. Johnson & Johnson (USA) 

- ReiThera (Italy)  

- Vaxart (USA) 
- Anhui Zhifei Longcom Biopharmaceutical/Institute of Microbiology, Chinese Academy of
Sciences (China) 

- University of Pittsburgh (USA) 

-Walter Reed Army Institute of Research (WRAIR) (USA) 

-Imperial College London (UK) 

- Institut Pasteur and Themis and Merck (USA, France) 

- Providence Therapeutics (Canada) 

- Sanofi Pasteur and Translate Bio (USA, France) 

 

2. Production phase: the final vaccine is produced. 

Pharmaceutical companies and research institutes using cell lines from aborted fetuses at this
stage: 
- Altimmune (USA) 

- Astra Zeneca University of Oxford (UK, USA) 

- CanSino Biologics, Inc. Beijing Institute of Biotechnology, Academy of Military Medical

Sciences, PLA of China (China) 
- Gamaleya Research Institute ("Sputnik V") (Russia) 

- ImmunityBio and NantKwest (USA) 

- Janssen Research & Development, Inc. Johnson & Johnson Vaxart (USA)  

- Vaxart (USA) 

https://www.ieb-eib.org/en/news/biomedical-research/medical-research/coronavirus-vaccines-and-the-use-of-aborted-fetal-cells-2029.html 2/5
09/12/2021, 17:50 Coronavirus Vaccines and the Use of Aborted Fetal Cells - Institut Européen de Bioéthique

- Rega Institute, KU Leuven (Belgium) 

-ReiThera (Italy)  

- University of Pittsburgh (USA) 

-Walter Reed Army Institute of Research (WRAIR) (USA) 

3. Confirmatory lab test phase, before being widely distributed. 

Pharmaceutical companies and research institutes using cell lines from aborted fetuses at this
stage: 

- Altimmune (USA) 

- Astra Zeneca University of Oxford (UK, USA) 

- CanSino Biologics, Inc. Beijing Institute of Biotechnology, Academy of Military Medical

Sciences, PLA of China (China) 

- Gamaleya Research Institute ("Sputnik V") (Russia) 

- ImmunityBio and NantKwest (USA) 

- Sinovac Biotech Co., Ltd. (China) 

- Janssen Research & Development, Inc. Johnson & Johnson Vaxart (USA)  

-ReiThera (Italy)  

- Anhui Zhifei Longcom Biopharmaceutical/Institute of Microbiology, Chinese Academy of

Sciences (China) 
- Medicago (Canada) 

- Novavax (USA) 

- Vaxart (USA) 

- Moderna, Inc. avec le National Institute of Health (USA) 

- Pfizer and BioNTech (USA, Germany) 

- Providence Therapeutics (Canada) 

- Sanofi Pasteur and Translate Bio (USA, France) 

- Inovio Pharmaceuticals (USA) 
- Arcturus Therapeutics (USA) 

-Imperial College London (UK) 

- Institut Pasteur and Themis and Merck (USA, France) 

- Clover Biopharmaceuticals, Inc. (China) 

https://www.ieb-eib.org/en/news/biomedical-research/medical-research/coronavirus-vaccines-and-the-use-of-aborted-fetal-cells-2029.html 3/5
09/12/2021, 17:50 Coronavirus Vaccines and the Use of Aborted Fetal Cells - Institut Européen de Bioéthique

- COVAXX and United Biomedical (USA, Taiwan) 

- Sanofi and GSK Protein Sciences (USA, France) 

- University of Pittsburgh (USA) 

-Walter Reed Army Institute of Research (WRAIR) (USA) 

The pharmaceutical companies not using fetal cell lines in any of the three steps are (*in
orange : information still missing): 
- Beijing Institute of Biological Products/ Sinopharm (China) 

- Wuhan Institute of Biological Products/ Sinopharm (China) 

- Bharat Biotech/ Indian Council of Medical Research (India) 

- Institute of Medical Biology, Chinese Academy of Medical Science 

- John Paul II Medical Research Institute (USA) 

- Valneva and Dynavax (France, UK, USA) 

- Shenzhen Geno-immune Medical Institute (China) 

- Merck and IAVI (USA) 
- Federal Budgetary Research Institution State Research Center of Virology and Biotechnology
“Vektor” 

- Sorrento (USA) 

- University of Queensland and CSL Ltd. (Australia) 

- CureVac (Germany) 

- Genexine (Korea) 

- Kentucky BioProcessing, Inc. (USA) 

- Symvivo Corporation (Canada) 
- Israel Institute for Biological Research (Israel) 

-Laboratorio Avi-Mex (Mexico) 

-Meissa Vaccines, INC. (USA) 

- Osaka University, AnGes, Takara Bio (Japan) 

- Zydus Cadila (India) 

Ethical discernment concerning the proposed vaccines will be based on different elements: 

https://www.ieb-eib.org/en/news/biomedical-research/medical-research/coronavirus-vaccines-and-the-use-of-aborted-fetal-cells-2029.html 4/5
09/12/2021, 17:50 Coronavirus Vaccines and the Use of Aborted Fetal Cells - Institut Européen de Bioéthique

- Whether alternatives to vaccines developed on the basis of these cell lines from aborted
fetuses exist or not: if ethically developed vaccines exist and are accessible, they must be given
priority. 
- The degree of distance, in time but especially in responsibility, between the abortion in question
and the patient who is vaccinated. For example, the patient's responsibility is small compared to
that of the researcher who uses these cell lines and thus encourages the production of similar
lines. 
- The phase in the development process in which fetal cell lines were used: if the vaccine was
produced thanks to these fetal cell lines (phase 2), then its use is actually encouraging the
reproduction of fetal cells. However, cooperation is more remote when the pharmaceutical
company has only tested some copies of the vaccine with fetal cells (phase 3). 

https://www.ieb-eib.org/en/news/biomedical-research/medical-research/coronavirus-vaccines-and-the-use-of-aborted-fetal-cells-2029.html 5/5