Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T
An overview of the state of he availability and quality of water in forest hydrology, and for embedding
knowledge about forest and water in many regions of the world are this knowledge and the research find-
interactions and salient issues in more and more threatened by ings in policies. Similarly, there is a
forest and water policy. overuse, misuse and pollution, and it need to develop institutional mecha-
is increasingly recognized that both are nisms to enhance synergies in dealing
strongly influenced by forests. Moreover, with issues related to forests and water
climate change is altering forest’s role as well as to implement and enforce
in regulating water flows and influen action programmes at the national and
cing the availability of water resources regional levels.
(Bergkamp, Orlando and Burton, 2003). In the past, forest and water policies
Therefore, the relationship between were often based on the assumption that
forests and water is a critical issue that under any hydrological and ecological
must be accorded high priority. circumstance, forest is the best land
Forested catchments supply a high pro- cover to maximize water yield, regulate
portion of the water for domestic, agri- seasonal flows and ensure high water
cultural, industrial and ecological needs quality. Following this assumption, con-
in both upstream and downstream areas. serving (or extending) forest cover in
A key challenge faced by land, forest and upstream watersheds was deemed the
water managers is to maximize the wide most effective measure to enhance water
range of multisectoral forest benefits availability for agriculture, industrial
without detriment to water resources and domestic uses, as well as for prevent-
and ecosystem function. To address this ing floods in downstream areas.
challenge, there is an urgent need for Forest hydrology research conducted
a better understanding of the interac- during the 1980s and 1990s (summarized
tions between forests/trees and water, for by Bruijnzeel, 2004; Calder, 2005, 2007;
awareness raising and capacity building Van Dijk and Keenan, 2007) suggests
Key terms
Discharge (or water flow): volume of water passing through a given point at a given time
Recharge: refill of a groundwater aquifer
River basin: the complex system of watersheds and subwatersheds crossed by a major river
and its tributaries while flowing from the source to the mouth
Upstream/downstream linkages: the environmental, socio-economic and cultural flows,
Ian Calder is Professor, Centre for Land Use synergies exchanges and conflicts between the upper and lower parts of a watershed
and Water Resources Research, Newcastle
University, United Kingdom. Watershed (or catchment): the geographical area drained by a watercourse – a concept
Thomas Hofer is Forestry Officer (Conservation applied to units ranging from a farm crossed by a creek (a microwatershed) to large river
and Hydrology), FAO Forestry Department, or lake basins
Rome.
Sibylle Vermont is Science Officer, Federal Watershed management: any human action aimed at ensuring a sustainable use of water-
Office for the Environment, Berne, Switzerland. shed resources
Patrizio Warren is Social Science Consultant,
FAO Forestry Department, Rome.
a rather different picture. Although biophysical interactions between forests STATE OF KNOWLEDGE ON
the important role of upstream forest and water into policies. The International FORESTS AND WATER
cover in ensuring the delivery of high- Expert Meeting on Forests and Water, Recent forest hydrology has focused
quality water has been confirmed, earlier held in Shiga, Japan in November 2002 in on three topics that are particularly rel-
generalizations about the benefits of preparation for these events, highlighted evant for policy-making: the comparative
upstream forest cover on downstream the need for more holistic consideration advantages and disadvantages of forest
annual and seasonal flows were generally of interactions between water, forest, cover in maximizing downstream water
fallacious and misleading. Studies have other land uses and socio-economic fac- yields; the role of upstream forests in
shown instead that, especially in arid or tors in complex watershed ecosystems. maintaining water flows during the dry
semi-arid ecosystems, forests are not the During the past five years, the Shiga season; and water-quality preservation.
best land cover to increase downstream Declaration has become a key reference This section summarizes findings in these
water yield. Moreover, solid evidence for the development of a new generation three areas (based on Hamilton, 2005).
has shown that in tropical ecosystems of forest and water policies (see article In the past, policy-making was often
the protective role of upstream forest by Zingari and Achouri, this issue). based on the assumption that the more
cover against seasonal downstream This article summarizes the state of cur- trees, the more water. Current forest
floods has often been overestimated. rent knowledge about forest and water hydrology research challenges this
This is especially true in connection interactions in watershed ecosystems. It assumption. The forest ecosystem is in
with major events affecting large-scale summarizes some key issues that have fact a major user of water. Tree canopies
watersheds or river basins (FAO and emerged from discussion among forest reduce groundwater and stream flow,
CIFOR, 2005). hydrologists, other water-sector experts through interception of precipitation
The International Year of Freshwater and policy-makers in the years since and evaporation and transpiration from
2003 and the third World Water Forum the Shiga Declaration, the third World the foliage. As both natural and human-
(Kyoto, Japan, 2003) helped drive the Water Forum and the International Year established forests use more water than
incorporation of this understanding of of Freshwater. most replacement land cover (including
agriculture and forage), there is no
Upstream and question that forest removal (even partial)
downstream, there
is a need for more
increases downstream water yields.
holistic consideration Consequently, removal of heavy water-
of interactions demanding forest cover has sometimes
between water, forest,
other land uses and
been suggested, especially in semi-arid
socio-economic areas, as a means of preventing or miti-
factors (forested gating drought. However, such a policy
watershed in India,
irrigation in the Syrian
should be weighed against the conse-
Arab Republic) quent loss of the many other services
FAO/19044/R. Faidutti
FAO/FO-5535/T. Hofer
ment regimes.
Another difficulty is a gap between
research and policy, which persists at
least in part because of a general failure
to communicate results of hydrological
• In addition to sediment, various ISSUES IN CURRENT FOREST AND research effectively to policy-makers
types of pollution – depending on WATER POLICIES and to challenge conventional assump-
nearby land use and drainage to the Following the International Year of tions with scientific evidence. To address
watercourse – can also impair water Freshwater 2003, discussion among these issues, in 2006 the International
quality. Potential pollutants include forest hydrologists, other water sector Union of Forest Research Organizations
excessive concentrations of organic experts and policy-makers has focused (IUFRO) created a Task Force on Forests
matter (leading to water eutrophica- on three core issues: incorporation of and Water Interactions. Its aim is to pro-
tion) and agricultural or industrial forest hydrology knowledge in water mote consensus in the forest hydrology
chemicals. Forest is certainly an ap- policies; inclusion of forest-sector con-
propriate ground cover for drinking- tributions in integrated water resource Riparian forest buffer
water–supply watersheds, because management policies; and payment for zones can greatly reduce or
forestry activities (with the excep- forest- and water-related environmental eliminate non-point source
pollution from domestic,
tion of intensively managed planta- services. industrial and agricultural
tions) generally use no fertilizers or use (Suriname)
pesticides and avoid pollution from
domestic sewage or industrial pro
cesses. In addition, non-point source
pollution (i.e. pollution from many
diffuse sources) from domestic, in-
dustrial and agricultural use can be
greatly reduced or even eliminated
by maintaining adequate riparian
forest buffer zones along water-
courses. Such zones, however, will
not prevent groundwater contamina-
tion. Moreover, where atmospheric
pollutants are captured by trees be-
cause of their height and aerodynamic
FAO/FO-0788/Noebauer
done in the past five years by regional in many regions of the world. New and
Payments for environmental and global bodies such as the Ministerial innovative technical solutions for bal-
hydrological services in Mexico Conference on the Protection of Forests ancing the use of the many services pro-
in Europe (MCPFE), the International vided by forests and needed by society
To counteract deforestation and water Network of Basin Organizations (INBO), – including those related to water – need
scarcity, Mexico created a programme the Latin American Network of Techni- to be developed and promoted to policy-
of payments for hydrological environ- cal Cooperation in Watershed Manage- makers, enabling informed decisions
mental services in 2003. The programme ment (REDLACH), the Mekong River about integrated forest and water man-
provides economic incentives for avoiding Commission (MRC), the Convention agement in an era of global change.u
deforestation in areas with severe water on Biological Diversity (CBD), FAO’s
problems but where commercial forestry, in Committee on Forestry (COFO), FAO’s
the short or medium term, could not match Regional Forestry Commissions and the
the opportunity cost of land-use conversion UNECE Timber Committee.
to agriculture or cattle ranching. The pro- This cooperation needs to be further
gramme provides direct payments to land- developed and strengthened at the Bibliography
owners with forest in excellent condition; national and regional levels, for instance
it pays for watershed conservation and for through the exchange of technical exper- Bergkamp, G., Orlando, B. & Burton, I.
management and restoration of temperate tise and experience across countries 2003. Change: adaption of water resources
and tropical forests associated with water and regions. There is a need for more management to climate change. Gland,
supply to communities. It is funded through applied research on forests and water, Switzerland, World Conservation Union
a portion of water fees collected under the as well as strengthened partnerships (IUCN).
Federal Rights Law. The programme pays among research, educational, finan- Bruijnzeel, L.A. 2004. Hydrological functions
400 pesos (US$36.9) per hectare for cloud cial and political institutions. Sound of tropical forests: not seeing the soil for
forest and 300 pesos (US$27.7) for other comparative valuations are needed for the trees? Agriculture, Ecosystems and
types, and allows payments for up to 200 ha forest services (hydrological and non), Environment, 104: 185–228.
per beneficiary. In 2007, about 480 000 ha including their contribution to forest Calder, I.R. 2005. Blue revolution – integrated
were covered under the programme through people’s livelihoods, production of land and water resources management.
879 contracts (Martínez, 2007). biofuels, maintenance of biodiversity London, UK, Earthscan. (2nd ed.)
and aesthetic and recreational value. Calder, I.R. 2007. Forests and water – ensuring
These needs are even more pressing with forest benefits outweigh water costs. Forest
and the International Year of Freshwater climate change adding to the complex- Ecology and Management, 251: 110–120.
2003, modern scientific understanding ity of the forest–water relationship and Center for International Forestry Research
of forest and water interactions has been influencing forestry and water policies (CIFOR). 2007. Forests and floods,
progressively permeating international
and national environmental policies.
This process has at last partially over- Water supply and urban forest maintenance
come what Hamilton (1985) termed the in Lausanne, Switzerland
four “M”s (myths, misunderstandings,
misinterpretations and misinformation) The city of Lausanne, located on the shore of Lake Geneva in Switzerland, has 136 000
surrounding this topic in policy circles. inhabitants. The city owns some 16 km2 of forests which provide about 8 percent of its
New perspectives on water and forest drinking-water. Funding from a combination of timber sales, subsidies and income tax
interactions have enabled a clearer does not fully cover the forest management expenses (about €15 per year per inhabitant),
understanding of what forest can (and especially when particular emphasis is given to protection of water resources. Accordingly,
cannot) do to deal with the challenges a communal fund for sustainable development was established in 2001 with an initial
the world will increasingly face in terms contribution of roughly €3 million. Further funding comes from €0.009 per kilowatt-hour
of the availability, quality and manage- sold on the electricity network, €0.0003 per kilowatt-hour from gas sales and €0.01 per
ment of water resources. cubic metre of water, as well as 1 percent of the annual profits of the city’s industrial
On this basis, closer and more fruitful services, with no increase in expense to the consumers. Only part of the fund is used to
cooperation between water management promote and manage the forest, which allows flexibility, especially for multiyear projects.
experts and foresters has begun, as wit- In addition, forest and water supply services work closely together.
nessed by the work on forests and water
revisited. POLEX electronic policy alert, Thematic study for the Global Forest Martínez, J. 2007. Payment for environmental
14 November. Resources Assessment 2005. Rome, FAO. services in Mexico. Presented at a side
FAO & CIFOR. 2005. Forests and floods: (Draft) event at the 26th session of the Subsidiary
drowning in fiction or thriving on facts? Hofer, T. & Messerli, B. 2006. Floods Bodies of the United Nations Framework
RAP Publication 2005/03. Bangkok, in Bangladesh: history, dynamics and Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC),
Thailand, FAO Regional Office for Asia rethinking the role for the Himalayas. Bonn, Germany, 11 May 2007.
and the Pacific. Tokyo, Japan, United Nations University United Nations Economic Commission for
Global Water Partnership Technical Press. Europe (UNECE) Convention on the
Advisory Committee (TAC). 2000. International Commission for the Protection Protection and Use of Transboundary
Integrated water resources management. of the Rhine (ICPR). 2001. Rhine 2020 Watercourses and International Lakes.
TAC Background Papers No. 4. Stockholm, – Program on the sustainable development 2007. Recommendations on payments for
Sweden, Global Water Partnership. of the Rhine. Conference of Rhine Ministers ecosystem services in integrated water
Available at: www.gwpforum.org/gwp/ 2001. Koblenz, Germany. Available at: resources management. New York &
library/TACno4.pdf www.iksr.org/index.php?id=336 Geneva, UN. Available at: www.unece.
Hamilton, L. 1985. Overcoming myths about International Union of Forest Research org/env/water/publications/documents/
soil and water impacts of tropical forest land Organizations (IUFRO). 2007. Research PES_Recommendations_web.pdf
uses. In S.A. El-Swaify, W.C. Moldenhauer spotlight: how do forests influence water? Van Dijk, A.I.J.M. & Keenan, R. 2007.
& A. Lo, eds. Soil erosion and conservation, IUFRO Fact Sheet No. 2. Vienna, Austria. Planted forests and water in perspective.
pp. 680–690. Ankeny, Iowa, USA, Soil Available at: www.iufro.org/science/ Forest Ecology and Management, 251(1-
Conservation Society of America. task-forces/water/publications 2): 1–9. u
Hamilton, L. 2005. Forests and water.