Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in football -
assessment, diagnosis
and prognosis
This article provides an update on the current available evidence on the assessment,
diagnosis, and prognosis of hamstring injuries in soccer. After a detailed insight into
the epidemiology, functional anatomy and injury mechanism for hamstring injuries,
a detailed clinical examination – which is supported by clinical evidence, clinical
experience and innovative practice – is demonstrated. Finally the recent Munich
classification system is presented to improve clarity of communication for diagnostic,
therapeutic and prognostic purposes.
BY WaYne Gill BSc, McSP Additionally, the SM has expansions extending to the knee
joint capsule and the medial meniscus (Fig. 1; Video 1)(6).
ePideMioloGY
Injury to the hamstring muscle group is frequently reported Function
to be the most common injury in professional football The hamstrings are biarticular (2-joint) muscles spanning
representing 12% of all injuries (1). It has been reported the hip and knee joint with multiple attachments that allow
that 83% of hamstring injuries affect the biceps femoris, them to affect function throughout the pelvis and lower
whereas 10% and 5% affect the semimembranosus and extremities. The principle activities of the hamstring group are
semitendinosus, respectively (2). A 25-player squad can hip extension and knee flexion. However, the BF short head
expect five hamstring muscle injuries each season, resulting crosses only the knee joint and is therefore only involved
in 90 days and 15–21 matches missed per club per season in knee flexion. Additionally, with the knee in flexion the SM
(3). It’s been reported that 18 days and 3 matches are missed and ST can medially rotate the tibia, whereas the BF laterally
per hamstring strain, with a 12% re-injury rate (3). Re-injuries rotates the tibia. The hamstrings are predominantly made up
can lead to diminished athletic performance and frustration of type II fast twitch fibres and are innervated by the tibial
for the player (4). Injuries will also have a negative impact branch of the sciatica nerve. However, the BF short head is
on the morale, performance, and results of the team, which dually innervated by both the tibial and peroneal portion of the
can have huge financial implications for the club (4). Thus, sciatic nerve (7). Functionally, the muscle group provides knee
hamstring strain injuries remain one of the most challenging support during the early stance phase, propulsion during the
injuries facing sports medicine practitioners. mid to late stance phase and they control knee momentum
during the swing phase (8). Studies of running biomechanics
anatoMY have found the hamstrings are active for the entire gait with
The hamstring muscle group includes the semitendinosus peaks in activation during the terminal swing and early stance
(ST) and semimembranosus (SM) medially and the biceps phases (9,10). During the terminal swing phase the hamstrings
femoris (BF), short and long heads, laterally. All muscles are required to contract eccentrically to decelerate the
attach proximally to the ischial tuberosity, except the BF flexing hip and extending knee in preparation for heel strike
short head, which originates at the linea aspera and lateral (11). Furthermore, using electromyography (EMG) analysis it’s
supracondylar line of the femur (5). The ST attaches to the been reported the BF is maximally activated between 15° and
medial surface of the superior tibia, SM to the posterior part 30° of knee flexion, whereas the ST and SM are maximally
of the medial condyle of the tibia and the oblique popliteal activated between 90° and 105° of knee flexion (12). This
ligament, while the BF attaches to the fibular head. The BF indicates that the BF participates strongly during the terminal
also has strong fascial connections to the peroneus longus swing phase of running. Additionally, during the early stance
at the fibula linking it to the action of the ankle and foot (6). phase the hamstrings have to absorb considerable force as
a result of high ground reaction forces (10,11). Furthermore, of the gait cycle and are most heavily activated (11,14). This
the thoracolumbar fascia (TLF) via its extensive muscular eccentric breaking force is often the point of muscle failure
attachments functionally connects the hamstrings to the as the lengthening demands placed on the muscle exceed
lumbar-pelvic spine and the upper torso (6). the mechanical limits of the muscle. This is postulated to be
due to non-uniform lengthening of sarcomeres attributed
injurY MechaniSM to sarcomere length instability. There is some uncertainty
It has been reported that 70% of hamstring injuries in elite as to whether hamstring injuries most typically occur as a
football players occur during high speed running and the result of the accumulation of microscopic muscle damage, or
rest with stretching, sliding, twisting, turning, passing and as a result of a single event (11). It seems feasible, however,
jumping (13). The presence of high eccentric forces during that both may contribute. For example, the accumulation
the stance and swing phases likely contributes to the high of microscopic damage as a result of repeated sprints
rates of hamstring injuries during maximal speed running. The may cause a ‘weak link’ and leave the muscle tissue in a
terminal swing phase is considered the most hazardous as vulnerable state and more susceptible to injury during a
the hamstring muscle tendon units are at their longest length single traumatic event, such as kicking a ball (11).
exaMination
history
Most soccer players with hamstring strain injuries present
with a sudden onset of posterior thigh pain resulting from
a specific action, most commonly high speed running (3).
Players will often describe the occurrence of an audible
pop or tearing sensation. However, a more gradual onset of
hamstring pain may be more suggestive of a referred source,
or what is commonly termed back-related hamstring pain
(15). The lumbar spine especially at the L5/S1 levels, and the
online
if you have a current subscription, login at www.
sportex.net to view this video or download the
mobile apps which are free to subscribers with
online access.
© Primal Pictures 2013
Biceps femoris
Semitendinosus
Semimembranonosus
www.sportEX.net 17
HAMSTRInG InJuRIES tuberosity, in addition to measuring the total length of the
painful region (15). Palpation also serves detect (superficial
REMAIn onE oF THE or larger) tears, perimuscular oedema and any increase in
MoST cHALLEnGInG muscle tone (18). The examiner can also palpate the gluteal
muscles to determine the presence of any MTPs which
InJuRIES FAcInG SPoRTS may also refer pain into the hamstring region. Additionally,
Palpation
Palpation of the posterior thigh is useful for identifying the
specific muscle and location injured through pain provocation,
as well as determining the presence/absence of a palpable
defect in the musculotendinous unit (15). The point of maximal
Figure 2: Knee flexion (90°) using hand-held dynamometer
pain can be determined and located relative to the ischial (HHD)
Figure 3: Knee flexion (45°) using HHD Figure 4: Knee flexion (15°) using HHD
Figure 5: Hip extension performed with knee extension Figure 6: Hip extension performed with knee flexion
Strength
Hamstring strength can be evaluated in both the supine and
prone positions. With the player in the prone position manual
muscle testing (MMT) can be used to assess the isometric
knee flexion strength initially at 90° (Fig. 2), then 45° (Fig. 3),
and finally 15° (Fig. 4) of knee flexion. Additionally, the use
of a hand-held dynamometer (HHD) can provide objective
measurements and identification of any strength deficits at
different knee flexion angles between the injured and non-
injured side (30). With adequate stabilisation the HHD is a
valid and reliable method of assessing hamstring strength (31,
32). Also, the concentric and eccentric hamstring strength
can be assessed using manual resistance applied by the
hands of the clinician. To place more emphasis on the BF it’s
suggested the knee should be externally rotated, whereas
internal rotation would bias the medial hamstrings (15).
Because the hamstring muscles extend the hip, it’s been
www.sportEX.net 19
recommended that hip extension strength be assessed with
full knee extension and also knee flexion (15). The elevated
taBle 2: Mri claSSiFication
and Mean recoVerY tiMeS
single leg bridge test is a quick and simple way of assessing [Adapted from Ekstrand et al., 2012 (2)]
hip extension and can be performed with the knee fully
Mri return to
extended and also flexed (Figs 5, 6; Video 2). collectively, Findings
classification training (days)
the aforementioned strength tests will provide the examiner
Grade 0 no visible pathology 8
with subjective and objective markers which can be used
Grade I oedema but no 17
to monitor the progression and recovery throughout the
architectural distortion
rehabilitation process.
Grade II Architectural distortion 22
(partial tear)
lumbar spine and pelvis Grade III Total muscle or tendon 73
The pelvis provides a dynamic link between the trunk, rupture
vertebral column and the lower limbs and has been
described as the keystone for both movement and support
(33). Therefore, asymmetry or dysfunction within pelvic taBle 3: Munich claSSiFication SYSteM
structures can alter movement patterns resulting in less and Mean recoVerY tiMeS
efficient movement, and alterations in joint forces and [Adapted from Ekstrand et al., 2013 (43)]
muscle function (34). Due to the anatomical and functional Muscle classification return to
relationship with the pelvis the hamstrings may be vulnerable training (days)
to injury. Excessive anterior tilt of the pelvis due to sacroiliac Functional Delayed onset of 4.5
joint (SIJ) dysfunction will increase the muscle length and disorders muscle soreness
tension within the hamstring muscles, thus predisposing them Spine-related
to injury (35,36). The function of the SIJ may be assessed neuromuscular 7.0
muscle disorders
by a number of kinetic tests, including the stork test (also
Fatigue induced 7.9
known as the Gillet test) and the forward flexion test (37).
Muscle-related
Additionally, the position of the pelvis should be examined to
neuromuscular muscle 13.8
determine the presence of any postural asymmetries which disorders
may also indicate a true or apparent leg length discrepancy Structural Minor partial muscle 17.3
(38,39). The lying/sitting test is a clinical method frequently disorders tears
used to differentiate between a true and apparent leg length Moderate partial muscle 35.5
discrepancy (40). The active straight leg raise (ASLR) test tears
has recently been used as a screen of lumbar spine stability Subtotal/complete muscle
to assess the control of lumbar rotational movements in the injury/tendinous avulsion 56.3
transverse plane (41). Good control without anterior pelvic
tilt is required and excessive anterior pelvic tilt typically spine, SIJ, and the pelvis should be included as part of the
accentuates the lumbar lordosis and can be a sign of poor injury assessment.
stabilisation of the pelvis by the abdominal muscles (6, 30).
Therefore, a thorough biomechanical evaluation of the lumbar diaGnoSiS
The diagnosis is based on the clinical history, examination
findings, and the use of imaging modalities such as
taBle 1: claSSiFication oF acute MuScle diSorderS and
ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). An early
injurieS [Adapted from Mueller-Wohlfart et al., 2013 (18)]
post-injury ultrasound between 2 and 48 hours has been
Type 1: 1a: Fatigue induced advocated as it can provide helpful information about any
overexertion- 1b: Delayed onset of muscle existing disturbance of the muscle structure, particularly if
Functional related disorder soreness (DoMS) there is any haematoma (18). However, MRI is considered
muscle superior for evaluating injuries to deep portions of the
disorder Type 2: 2a: Spine-related neuromuscular
Indirect muscles, or when a previous hamstring injury is present,
neuromuscular disorder
muscle disorder as residual scarring can be misinterpreted on an uS image
injury 2b: Muscle-related neuromuscular
disorder as an acute injury (42). Furthermore, due to its increased
sensitivity in showing subtle oedema, measuring the size
Type 3: Partial 3a: Minor partial muscle tear (length and cross sectional area) and site of injury including
Structural muscle tear 3b: Moderate partial muscle tear any tendon involvement, MRI is more accurate (42). Thus,
muscle injury
Type 4: (Sub) total Subtotal or complete muscle tear an MRI examination within 24–48 hours of the injury event
tear should be performed (2,18).
Tendinous avulsion
Direct classification
muscle contusion or laceration currently the most widely used classification for hamstring
injury injuries is an MRI based graduation defining four grades:
grade 0, no visible pathology; grade 1, oedema but no
www.sportEX.net 21
b
british journal of sports medicine 2004;38:502–504 42. connell D, Schneider-Kolsky M, et al. Longitudinal study comparing
17. Asher S. The concise book of trigger points, 2nd edn, pp148– sonographic and MRI assessments of acute and healing hamstring
159. loftus publishing 2008. isbn 1556437455 (£14.49). Buy injuries. american journal of roentgenology diagnostic imaging
from Amazon http://spxj.nl/IckABx and related sciences 2004;183(4):975–984
18. Mueller-Wohlfahrt H, Haensel L, et al. Terminology and 43. Ekstrand J, Askling c, et al. Return to play after thigh muscle
classification of muscle injuries in sport; The Munich consensus injury in elite football players: implementation and validation of the
statement. british journal of sports medicine 2013;47:342–350 Munich muscle injury classification. british journal of sports
19. Rolls A, George K. The relationship between hamstring muscle medicine 2013;47:769–774
injuries and hamstring muscle length in young elite footballers. 44. comin J, Malliaras P, et al. Return to competitive Play after
physical therapy in sport 2004;5:179–187 hamstring injuries involving disruption of the central tendon. the
20. Dixon J, Keating J. Variability in straight leg raise measurements. american journal of sports medicine 2013;41(1):111–115
physiotherapy 2000;86(7):361–370 45. Gibbs n, cross T, et al. The accuracy of MRI in predicting
21. ylinen J, Kautiainen H, Hakkinen A. comparison of active, recovery and recurrence of acute grade one hamstring muscle
manual, and instrumental straight leg raise in measuring hamstring strains within the same season in Australian Rules football players.
extensibility. Journal of strength and conditioning research journal of science and medicine in sport 2004;7(2):248–258
2010;24(4):972–977 46. Warren P, Gabbe B, et al. clinical predictors of time to return
22. McHugh M, Johnson c, Morrision R. The role of neural tension in to competition and of recurrence following hamstring strain in
hamstring flexibility. scandinavian journal of medicine & science elite Australian footballers. british journal of sports medicine
in sports 2012;22:164–169 2010;44:415–419.
23. capra F, Vanti c, et al. Validity of the straight leg raise test for
patients with sciatic pain with or without lumbar pain using magnetic
resonance imaging results as a reference standard. journal of
manipulative physiology therapy 2011;34:231–238 ThE AuThor
Th
24. Gajdosik R, Lusin G. Hamstring muscle tightness: reliability of the Wayne spent 10 years as a professional footballer playing for
active knee extension test. physical therapy 1983;63(7):1085–1090 Blackburn rovers, Blackpool, Tranmere rovers and oldham
25. Gajdosik R, Rieck M, et al. comaprison of four clinical tests for Athletic before retiring in 2004 due to injury. In 1999 he completed
assessing hamstring muscle length. journal of orthopaedic sports
an hNC in sports science and in 2008 he graduated from the university
physical therapy 1993;18(5):614–618
26. Kornberg c, Lew P. The effect of stretching neural structures of Salford with a first class honours degree in physiotherapy. Following his
on grade one hamstring injuries. journal of orthopaedic sports graduation he worked at Portsmouth FC for 4 years which included being
physical therapy 1989;10:481–487 involved in the FA Cup final in 2010. In 2012 he joined Fulham FC and is
27. Miller K. The slump test: clinical applications and interpretations. currently studying for an MSc in Sports Physiotherapy at Bath university.
chiropractic technique 1999;11(4):157–163
28. Turl S, George K. Adverse neural tension: a factor in repetitive
hamstring strain? journal of orthopaedic sports physical
therapy 1998;27:16–21 n Describe the function of the hamstrings during the gait cycle.
29. cacchio A, Borra F, et al. Reliability and Validity of three pain n What is the most common injury mechanism for hamstring
provocation tests used for the diagnosis of chronic proximal injuries?
hamstring tendinopathy. british journal of sports medicine
n Which clinical tests would you use to assess hamstring
2012;46:883–887 DISCUSSIONS
30. Mendiguchia J, Brughelli M. A return to sport algorithm for acute muscle flexibility and neural tension?
hamstring injuries. physical therapy in sport 2011;12:2–14 n Describe the different types of functional and structural
31. Kelln B, McKeon P, et al. Hand-held dynamometry: reliability of disorders associated with the Munich classification.
lower extremity muscle testing in healthy, active, young adults.
journal of sport rehabilitation 2008;17:160–170
32. Trudelle-JacksonE, Jackson A, et al. Interdevice reliability and
validity assessment of the nicholas hand held dynamometer. journal
of orthopaedic
rthopaedic & sports physical therapy 1994;20(6):302–306
33. Lee D. The pelvic girdle: an approach to the examination
continuing education
and treatment of the lumbopelvic-hip region, 3rd edn, pp41–61.
churchill livingston 2004. isbn 0443073732 (£38.75).
c
Multiple choice questions
Buy from Amazon http://spxj.nl/1auEqp4 This article also has an eLearning test which
34. Sahrmann S. Diagnosis and treatment of movement can be found under the eLearning section of our
impairment syndromes, pp74–84. mosby 2002. isbn
0801672058 (£47.00 print, £35.25 kindle). Buy from
website.
Amazon http://spxj.nl/1gBw6Jn Tests from April 2013 onwards can be done on
35. cibulka M, Rose S, et al. Hamstring muscle strain treated by most digital devices.
mobilizing the sacroiliac joint. physical therapy 1986;66(8):1220–1223 1. Login to our website, click the online Access
36. Hennessy L, Watson A. Flexibility and posture assessment in button in the main menu bar and the go to the
relation to hamstring injury. british journal of sports medicine
1993;27(4):243–246
eLearning section (you must be logged in).
37. Wurff P, Hagmeijer R, Meyne W. clinical tests of the sacroiliac 2. click on the quiz you wish to do. Successful
joint – part 1: reliability. manual therapy 2000;5(1):30–36 completion results in a stored certificate under the My Account area of
38. Herrington L. Assessment of the degree of pelvic tilt within a our website. This can be downloaded or printed at any time as evidence
normal asymptomatic population. manual therapy 2011;16:646–648 of continuing education for many national and international membership
39. Gurney B. Leg length discrepancy. gait posture 2002;15:195–206
40. Bemis T, Daniel M. Validation of the long sitting test on subjects
associations.
with iliosacral dysfunction. journal of orthopaedic & sports
physical therapy 1987;8(7):336–345
41. Liebenson c, Karpoowicz A, et al. the american academy of
physical medicine and rehabilitation 2009;1:530–535
tHis Quiz is
accessible free witH a subscription tHat includes
online access to tHis journal.