Criteria Advance (4) Proficient (3) Developing (2) Beginning (1)

Has impeccable Has high quality Has satisfactory Has scarce

and near-perfect form and style form and style enthralling factor
Aesthetic or form and style that agreeably that fairly pleased that poorly
Visual Impact and that aesthetically pleased the the beholders pleased the
Appeal catches the eye of beholders beholders
beholders
Employs and Employs and Employs and Employs and
mixes mixes mixes unusual and mixes unusual and
Hybridity and unconventional unconventional materials materials
Distinctiveness and unique and unique mediocrely limitedly
materials materials
exceptionally adequately
The pigment’s The pigment’s The pigment’s The pigment’s
tint, shade, and tint, shade, and tint, shade, and tint, shade, and
Color Harmony tone are exquisite, tone are relatively tone are fairly tone lacks
consistent, and blended and coordinated and variation and
appropriate diverse varied unity
The painting The painting The painting The painting fails
outstandingly finely highlights somewhat to highlight
highlights intricate and highlights intricate and
Artistic Details intricate and striking details intricate and striking details
striking details, striking details
even the tiny ones.