Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Predictors of Employees Early Retirement
Predictors of Employees Early Retirement
Background Adjusting work life and encouraging older employees to continue at work has become a common
challenge as the workforce ages. Gender differences in retirement decisions have largely been over-
looked in previous studies, despite the fact that retirement as a life course event and the experience of
retirement can be gender dependent.
...................................................................................................................................................................................
Aims To explore which personal and work-related psychological factors predict early retirement intentions
among older women and men and to investigate the stability of these predictors through use of lon-
gitudinal data.
...................................................................................................................................................................................
Methods This research is based on an 11-year follow-up study of ageing Finnish municipal employees. Data on
1101 employees’ early retirement intentions were analysed with binary logistic regression analysis in
separate longitudinal and cross-sectional models.
...................................................................................................................................................................................
Results Gender differences in early retirement intentions were detected both at baseline and at follow-up.
Negative perceptions about work and low work and general life satisfaction were associated with early
retirement intentions among women. For men, good self-rated work ability and perceived good health
were negatively associated with early retirement intentions. In addition, negative perceptions about
work predicted early retirement intentions among men.
...................................................................................................................................................................................
Conclusions Adverse work- or health-related factors detected in middle age predicted subsequent early retirement
intentions.
...................................................................................................................................................................................
Key words Early retirement intentions; gender; negative perceptions about work; work ability.
...................................................................................................................................................................................
The Author 2009. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Society of Occupational Medicine.
All rights reserved. For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oxfordjournals.org
M. E. VON BONSDORFF ET AL.: EARLY RETIREMENT INTENTIONS IN FINLAND FROM 1981 TO 1992 95
poor work ability [20,21], high work demands [6] and in detail elsewhere [26,27] and are summarized briefly
other organizational and managerial factors [6]. Older here. In this study, we focused on self-reported survey
employees’ early retirement decisions might depend on data collected at baseline in 1981 (n 5 6257) and the
spousal and familial factors [8, 22] in a way that women follow-up in 1992. The research process is presented
tend to retire earlier [14]. The financial situation of the in Figure 1. At follow-up in 1992, 1101 individuals
older employee, in the form of pay, benefits and retire- (18%) were still working either full or part-time. Informa-
ment income, can influence early retirement intentions. tion regarding retirement and mortality was obtained
Researchers have suggested that employees with higher from national registers. Appropriate permissions were ac-
wages and incomes during retirement are more likely quired from the authorities. In this study, we focused on
to retire early [16]. the 1101 individuals who were working in 1992 and had
Employees’ functional capacity has been shown to de- responded to the question on their retirement intentions.
teriorate and symptoms of strain to increase as individuals For details of the study sample, see Table 1.
age [23]. Due to these changes, it is essential to maintain The outcome of this study, early retirement intentions,
Methods
This study is based on a broad multidisciplinary follow-
up study that focused on health, work, lifestyle and retire-
ment among employees in the municipal sector. It was Old age Disability
Working (1992) pension (1992) pension (1992)
conducted in years 1981, 1985, 1992 and 1997 by the
Finnish Institute of Occupational Health. The design
and methodology of the current study have been reported Figure 1. Study flow chart.
96 OCCUPATIONAL MEDICINE
Gender ,0.001
Women (%) 55 61 61 51
Men (%) 45 39 39 49
Type of work ,0.001
Physically demanding (%) 42 34 35 54
Mixed physical and mental work (%) 31 23 40 23
Mentally demanding (%) 27 43 25 23
Spouses work activity ,0.001
Spouse working (%) 57 67 51 59
Self-rated work ability, range 0–10, with higher score indicating better work ability; perceived health, range 1–5, with lower score indicating better health; work satisfaction,
range 0–5, with lower score indicating higher work satisfaction; negative perceptions about work, range 0–10, with lower score indicating less negative perceptions, and
general life satisfaction, range 1–5, with lower score indicating higher general life satisfaction.
a
Plus–minus values are means (standard deviation) presented for continuous variables and percentages for categorical variables.
b
All employees were working in 1981.
c
A total of 314 participants did not respond to the follow-up questionnaire and 395 participants died during the follow-up period.
d
Discrete variables are analysed with chi-square test and continuous variables with independent sample t-test and analysis of variance.
lifetime best. The scale varied from 0 to 10, with 10 in- intentions from baseline to follow-up was explored with
dicating work ability at its best. Studies have found that correlative analysis. Comparisons of discrete baseline
this single-item question concerning employees’ estima- characteristics were performed using chi-square tests.
tions of their work ability is correlated highly with the en- For continuous variables, analysis of variance was used.
tire Work Ability Index, and thus constitutes a reliable All tests were performed as two-tailed in SPSS 15.0
measure of self-rated work ability [29]. (SPSS, Inc.) with the significance level P,0.05.
Demographic variables in this study included age and
gender. Type of work (physical, mental and mixed phys-
ical and mental work [30]) was also controlled for. Phys-
Results
ical work included, among others, auxiliary work,
installation work and domestic aid work. Mixed physical Our study population comprised 1101 municipal employ-
and mental work included transport work, dumping ees who were still working at the time of the follow-up in
ground work, kitchen supervisor work, dental care work 1992. The baseline characteristics are presented in Table
and nursing work. Mental work covered administrative 1. Statistically significant differences according to em-
and office work, technical supervision, physician’s work ployment status in 1992 were detected at baseline for
and teaching work. Some studies have suggested that all variables. Respondents who were still working in
early retirement might be a household decision and that 1992 were younger and typically employed in mentally
spouses can play an important role in the decision-making demanding work, when compared to all respondents at
process [8,22,14]. Hence, we asked the respondents baseline. Nearly 54% of the respondents, who had retired
about their spouses work life involvement and asked them due to disability, had been employed in physically de-
to indicate whether or not they had a spouse and if the manding work. The majority of the respondents still
spouse was working. working in 1992 were women (61%). Gender differences
Binary logistic regression analysis was used to calculate were detected in type of work among these respondents,
the odds ratios (ORs) and the 95% confidence intervals since .40% of the men and nearly 30% of the women
(CIs) for predictors of early retirement intentions. The were employed in physically demanding work.
outcome, early retirement intentions, was measured in In 1992, out of the 1101 respondents still working,
1992. The stability of the predictors of early retirement some 783 (73%) stated that they had early retirement
M. E. VON BONSDORFF ET AL.: EARLY RETIREMENT INTENTIONS IN FINLAND FROM 1981 TO 1992 97
intentions. Early retirement intentions were common For women, in the first model, adjusted with age, type
among both women (70%) and men (80%). A closer ex- of work and spouses work activity, negative perceptions
amination showed that in 1981 the mean age for employ- about work increased the odds of early retirement inten-
ees with early retirement intentions was 46.9 years tions (OR 5 1.25, 95% CI 5 1.09–1.45). In the second
(SD 5 1.8) and for employees with no early retirement model, adjusted with age, type of work and spouses work
intentions 47.4 years (SD 5 2.0). Early retirement inten- activity, good self-rated work ability decreased the odds of
tions varied only little according to the type of work. early retirement intentions (OR 5 1.22, 1/0.82, 95% CI
Nearly 78% of the respondents working in physically de- 5 0.69–0.97). Furthermore, low work satisfaction and
manding and 77% working in mentally demanding jobs negative perceptions about work increased the odds of
stated that they had experienced early retirement inten- early retirement intentions 1.61 (95% CI 5 1.16–2.23)
tions. and 1.64 (95% CI 5 1.41–1.91) times, respectively.
The results of the logistic regression analyses for early Low general satisfaction with life decreased the OR for
retirement intentions are presented in Table 2 (longitudi- early retirement intentions (OR 5 1.45, 1/0.69; 95%
Table 2. ORs and 95% CIs from logistic regression models for the odds for early retirement intentions as the reference group
Women Men
a
Models 1 and 3 5 longitudinal model; independent variables measured in 1981 and dependent variable measured in 1992.
b
Models 2 and 4 5 cross-sectional model; all variables, excluding age, type of work and spouses work activity measured in 1992.
c
Measured in 1981.
d
Reference group.
*P , 0.05, **P , 0.01, ***P , 0.001.
98 OCCUPATIONAL MEDICINE
intentions among employees with perceived poor health tor. These sectors differ from each other in terms of in-
was higher (OR 5 1.88, 95% CI 5 1.26–2.79). In addi- stitutional factors, such as retirement legislation, labour
tion, negative perceptions about work increased the agreements and pension schemes. However, knowledge
odds of early retirement intentions 1.63-fold (95% CI 5 of the particular characteristics of the municipal sector
1.32–2.01). also enabled us to control for institutional factors to a cer-
In order to determine the stability of the predictors of tain extent.
early retirement intentions from baseline to follow-up, The high percentage of employees considering early
we performed correlative analysis (Pearson correlation) retirement can partly be explained by the relatively high
on the continuous variables. The results for both women mean age at follow-up in 1992 (58.4 years, SD 5 1.9).
and men indicated that self-rated work ability, perceived Unlike in other longitudinal studies [17–19], we wanted
health, work satisfaction, negative perceptions about to explore predictors of early retirement intentions both in
work and general life satisfaction, measured at base- a longitudinal and cross-sectional setting. This approach
line and the follow-up, were correlated. For women, allowed us to evaluate the stability of these predictors over
19. Shultz KS, Wang M. The influence of specific physical of Ageing Workers. Elsevier International Congress Series No
health conditions on retirement decisions. Int J Aging 1280, 2005; 3–8.
Hum Dev 2007;65:149–161. 25. Börsch-Supan A. The 2005 Pension Reform in Finland. Work-
20. Tuomi K, Huuhtanen P, Nykyri E, Ilmarinen J. Promotion ing Paper 2005:1. Helsinki: Finnish Centre for Pensions,
of work ability, the quality of work and retirement. Occup 2005.
Med 2001;51:318–324. 26. Ilmarinen J, Tuomi K, Eskelinen L, Nygård C-H,
21. Gould R, Polvinen A. Work ability in late career. In: Huuhtanen P, Klockars M. Background and objectives
Gould R, Ilmarinen J, Järvisalo J, Koskinen S, eds. of the Finnish research project on aging workers in
Dimensions of Work Ability. Results of the Health 2000 municipal occupations. Scand J Work Environ Health 1991;
17(Suppl):7–11.
Survey. Helsinki: Finnish Centre of Pensions, The Social
27. Seitsamo J. Retirement Transition and Well-being—A 16-year
Insurance Institution, National Public Health Institute
Longitudinal Study. People and Work Research Reports 76.
and Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, 2008; Helsinki: Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, 2007.
139–150. 28. Tuomi K, Ilmarinen J, Jahkola A, Katajarinne L, Tulkki A.