Professional Documents
Culture Documents
309
Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000 L J. Seidman et al.
biological-environmental factors associated with increased cally relevant variables because hypoxia or more acute
risk of schizophrenia. These factors are mainly associated instances of anoxia have a particularly pernicious effect
with the pregnancy period or the birth process itself and are on the hippocampus (Hedner 1978) and basal ganglia
usually called OCs (McNeil 1991). In fact, schizophrenia is (Lou 1996), two of the brain structures considered to be
considered to have the strongest association with OCs of all abnormal in schizophrenia (Shenton et al. 1997). Thus,
adult onset psychiatric disorders (Jablensky 1995). The conditions that adversely affect the fetal blood supply of
obstetric risk factors most consistently observed in the pre- oxygen—either of prolonged duration (chronic fetal
histories of people who later develop schizophrenia are hypoxia) or severe acute episodes—constitute subsets of
labor and delivery abnormalities (Verdoux et al. 1997), win- PPCs that may be of particular developmental importance
310
Prenatal/Perinatal Complications and Cognitive Functioning Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000
al. 1994; cf. Breslau 1995). Breslau et al. (19%) demon- were no significant associations of IQ with labor, delivery,
strated that LBW children scored lower on tests measur- or neonatal variables, or with early pregnancy events that
ing various aspects of language (syntax, semantics, can produce acute fetal hypoxia. On the other hand, they
phonology) and spatial, fine motor, tactile, and attention found that antenatal disorders and conditions that can pro-
abilities. Moreover, a linear trend (a gradient relationship) duce subacute or chronic fetal hypoxia correlated with
between birth weight and cognitive functioning has been low IQ scores. These conditions and disorders included
observed, with IQ (Breslau et al. 1994; Hack et al. 1994) maternal gestational anemia, hypotension, hypertension,
and other neuropsychological measures (Breslau et al. multiple births, and fetal growth retardation.
1996). While the current literature is not conclusive, Zornberg et al. (2000) have argued that PPCs associ-
311
Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000 L.J. Seidman et al.
sity-affiliated medical centers participated in this national obtained from the mother at intake and the 7th year. Study
study, including two in New England (Harvard Medical physicians prepared diagnostic summaries following the
School and Brown University). The NCPP entailed a single- 1st and 7th year.
study design involving the systematic collection of data In the New England cohort, standardized measures of
through the prospective observation and examination of cognitive abilities were acquired on 11,889 children at
over 50,000 pregnancies through the first 7 years of life. approximately age 7. Of those assessed, 98.1 percent were
Obstetrical intake occurred between January 2, 1959, and tested between 6.75 and 8 years of age. A few children
December 31, 1965. Cases were selected on the basis of a were tested when they were as young as age 6 or as old as
sampling frame defined for each study center (Broman et al. 11. In many cases, the sample included multiple children
312
Prenatal/Perinatal Complications and Cognitive Functioning Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000
WRAT tests
Reading A measure of single word 6ral reading (raw score)
Spelling A measure of written spelling (raw score)
Arithmetic A measure of written calculations and number knowledge (raw score)
ITPA auditory-vocal association test A measure of analogical reasoning using an oral sentence completion tech-
nique (raw score)
Bender Gestalt Test for Young A measure of visual-motor integration, copying figures with a pencil, using the
Children Koppitz scoring system (total score: distortions, rotations, integrations, per-
severations)
Tactile finger recognition test1 A measure of tactile perception (total number of fingers recognized)
Note.—ITPA - Illinois Test of Psycholinguists Abilities; WISC . Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children; WRAT - Wide Range
Achievement Test
1
From the Reitan-lndiana Neuropsychological Battery.
al. 1989). These analyses indicate that the administration 2. Postterm birth with preeclampsia.
and results of cognitive assessments in the New England B. Neonatal neurological abnormalities in full-term baby
NCPP cohorts are consistent with, and as reliable and without seizures.
valid as, other published normative samples. 3. Hyperactivity (suspected or definite).
4. Hypotonia (suspected or definite).
PPCs. We used three variables as measures of PPCs:
LBW (weight less than 2,500 grams at birth), probable The following operational definitions were used:
hypoxic-ischemic complication (HI-P; see below), and
chronic hypoxia (see below). • SGA: lowest 10th percentile of birth weight for each
We classified participants as demonstrating HI-P week of gestational age.
according to signs of abnormal fetal and neonatal devel- • Postterm birth: 42 or more weeks of gestational age.
opment obtained during a neonatal neurological examina- •Preeclampsia: clinical rating of mild to severe
tion and/or based on the presence of a pattern of condi- preeclampsia, based on blood pressure readings, protein-
tions suggesting compromise to intrauterine growth and uria, and edema.
development. Participants were coded as evidencing HI-P • Meconium staining and uterine bleeding (during any
if they were bom at 37 weeks or more of gestation and trimester): clinical rating based on obstetrician report
met at least one of the following four criteria, which can • Hyperactivity and hypotonia: clinical rating based on
be grouped under two categories, A and B: pediatric neurological examination at birth.
A. Patterns of disordered growth and development dur- This classification approach is a minor modification of
ing a pregnancy with complications. recent work by our group (Zomberg et al. 2000).
1. Small for gestational age (SGA), with preeclampsia, Possible chronic hypoxia was defined as it was in
meconium staining of the amniotic fluid, or uterine previous analyses from the NCPP (Naeye and Peters
bleeding. 1987) and our previous work (Buka et al. 1993, 1998).
313
Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000 L J. Seidman et al.
314
PrenataiyPerinatal Complications and Cognitive Functioning Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000
tors, with one PPC in the model and when all PPCs Discussion
were controlled simultaneously. Table 4 displays the
results for the 13 individual test scores when all PPCs
were controlled simultaneously. Because the PPCs were In this study, we evaluated the relationship between two
dichotomous and because the outcomes were standard- classes of risk factors for schizophrenia—PPCs and neu-
ized to have a mean of 0 and variance of 1, the beta ropsychological functioning at age 7—in a large, prospec-
coefficients in tables 3 and 4 can be interpreted as the tive, longitudinal study of pregnancy, birth and develop-
estimated effect in standard units resulting from one ment, and neuropsychological outcome. A principal
PPC while holding the other PPCs and confounders components analysis of 13 test variables led to three fac-
315
Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000 LJ. Seidman et al.
'c ** # « j *
SES and other sociodemographic confounders. LBW may
-0.1 79**
-0.225**
-0.185**
-0.176**
-0.154**
m S ~
-0.211"
I
1
1
1
a>
LO
CM
LO
CM
CO
CM
LO
CM
CO
CM
CO
CM
illness.
•a .2 LU O O O O
X q q The results are also consistent with predictions made
O, O, 2 2
£ by Zornberg et al. (2000), who hypothesized that pre-
J *
sumed hypoxic insults^—based on measures of fetal and
:lent
* *
o
-0.1 13*'
-0.0 72*'
-0.0 78*'
-0.0 94*'
u
-0.0 86*
LO
iroi
107*
133*
153*
182*
CO S u *
o
*3 LO chronic hypoxia variable. Nevertheless, our results indi-
O
«S E CO
j cating a significant relationship between chronic hypoxia
?
CO
s
a
o
and cognition are consistent with that reported by Naeye
and Peters (1987).
Itiv
r*-
ies
:ies
g CO V
1
CO
© CD LU y o. LBW) than other neuropsychological functions. While it
CD c c •5 <n E :
CO CD CO
8
is true that there was some ordering of effects, with acade-
E CO
-9 E CO •9 § ^ mic achievement skills and perceptual-motor abilities
ptual-m tor;
"S
ptual-m tors
imic acl eve
|ery
•S 8 5
2 CD ffi o
^. more strongly associated with LBW and HI-P than were
• ^
a. o "r- CL o 5 o V
o
i mode
r mode
l-conce
en
! 8
Q. 8. 2 8 CO
cu s of tests and resulting factors provides a more differenti-
•§ ated picture than overall IQ, the significant associations
o o o
o
CD
8. 8 i ? CD
CL
I .1
Ion
o CO
between all three measures of PPCs with all three neu-
CD c\i CO cj CO
CO
0>
.Q
S
S
o
CO
O
t5
CO
o
CO
o
CO
CO
CD
C
o
CO
o
T5 T3 ?
O
"1
CO •S
3 O
ropsychological factors suggests relatively generalized
deficits, consistent with the literature (Breslau 1995;
v
Usi
Usi
oc
LL LL LL LL LL LL Breslau et al. 1996). Nevertheless, it must be recognized
316
Table 4. OC predictors of age 7 cognitive functioning tests after adjusting for confounders1
Probable Hypoxlc-lschemic
Complication Chronic Hypoxla Low Birth Weight
Regression effects using all 3 OCS Beta Beta Beta
per model for Individual Herns coefficient (SE) coefficient (SE) coefficient (SE)
Factor 1
WRAT reading -0.090** (0.029) -0.049 (0.026) -0.163**** (0.032)
WRAT spelling -0.125**** (0.029) -0.042 (0.025) -0.145**** (0.032)
WRAT arithmetic -0.126**** (0.029) -0.087*** (0.026) -0.185**" (0.032)
WISC digit span -0.099** (0.031) -0.047 (0.027) -0.123*** (0.034)
Factor 2
WISC vocabulary -0.035 (0.028) -0.039 (0.025) -0.106*** (0.031)
WISC comprehension -0.094** (0.031) -0.111"** (0.027) -0.004 (0.034)
WISC information -0.002 (0.030) • -0.070** (0.026) -0.158**** (0.033)
ITPA auditory-vocal association -0.113**** (0.029) -0.061* (0.026) -0.112*** (0.032)
WISC picture arrangement -0.061* (0.030) -0.025 (0.027) -0.215"** (0.033)
Factor 3
Tactile finger recognition -0.001 (0.031) -0.079** (0.027) -0.121*" (0.034)
Bender Gestalt visual-motor 0.137"** (0.030) 0.085** (0.027) 0 . 1 6 0 " " (0.033)
WISC digit symbol/coding -0.127**" (0.032) 0.011 (0.028) -0.050 (0.035)
WISC block design -0.086** (0.030) -0.076** (0.027) - 0 . 1 4 5 " " (0.033)
Note.—ITPA = Illinois Test of Psycholinguists Abilities; OC <= obstetric complication; SE = standard error; WISC = Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children; WRAT - Wide Range
Achievement Test.
1
Values are adjusted for socioeconomlc status, race, mother's age at birth, age of child at assessment, and National Collaborative Perinatal Project site.
*p < 0.05; "p < 0.01; '"p < 0.001; ""p < 0.0001
i
CD
£
z
o
that this inference is tentative because it is based on a sin- pendently or interactively (with genetic vulnerability)
gle evaluation at age 7. It is possible that patterns of asso- increase the risk of schizophrenia.
ciation between these PPCs and neuropsychological func- This investigation was designed as a prelude to
tions may change with normal or abnormal development. analyses of the independent and interacting relationship of
For example, as verbal-conceptual abilities become PPCs and family history of psychosis on cognitive func-
increasingly essential in adolescence, a previously latent tioning at age 7. In future analyses we plan to compare the
vulnerability may emerge and be more strongly associated impact of these three PPCs on the neuropsychological
with PPCs. This type of model has been proposed by functions obtained in the factor analysis in interaction
Weinberger (1987) to explain the emergence of frontal with family history of psychotic illness. We intend to
318
Prenatal/Perinatal Complications and Cognitive Functioning Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000
ment of children. Clinical Neuropsychologist, 3:353-368, Goldstein, J.M.; Seidman, L.J.; Buka, S.L.; Horton, NJ.;
1989. Donatelli, J.A.L.; Rieder, R.O.; and Tsuang, M.T. Impact
Buka, S.L.; Goldstein, J.M.; Seidman, L.J.; Zornberg, of genetic vulnerability and hypoxia on overall intelli-
G.L.; Denny, L.R.; and Tsuang, M.T. Chronic fetal gence by age 7 in offspring at high risk for schizophrenia
hypoxia and other obstetric risk factors for psychotic ill- compared with affective psychoses. Schizophrenia
ness: A replication study. [Abstract]. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 26(2):323-334, 2000.
Research, 29:14,1998. Hack, M.; Taylor, H.G.; Klein, N.; Eiben, R.;
Schztschneider, C ; and Mercuri-Minich, N. School-age
Buka, S.L.; Goldstein, J.M.; Seidman, L.J.; Zornberg,
319
Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000 L J. Seidman et al.
rity and perinatal hypoxic-haemodynamic encephalopa- Rifkin, L.; Lewis, S.; Jones, P.; Toone, B.; and Murray, R.
thy. Acta Paediatrica, 85:1266-1271, 1996. Low birth weight and schizophrenia. British Journal of
Marcus, J.; Hans, S.L.; Nagler, S.; Auerbach, J.G.; Mirsky, Psychiatry, 165:357-362, 1994.
A.F.; and Aubry, A. Review of the NIMH Israeli Kibbutz- Robertson, C.M.T., and Finer, N.N. Long-term follow-up
City Study and the Jerusalem Infant Development Study. of term neonates with perinatal asphyxia. Clinical
Schizophrenia Bulletin, 13(3):426-438, 1987. Perinatology, 20:483-498, 1993.
McNeil, T.F. Obstetric complications in schizophrenic Russell, A.J.; Munro, J.C.; Jones, P.B.; Hemsley, D.R.;
parents. Schizophrenia Research, 5:89-101, 1991. and Murray, R.M. Schizophrenia and the myth of intellec-
320
Prenatal/Perinatal Complications and Cognitive Functioning Schizophrenia Bulletin, Vol. 26, No. 2, 2000
321
Announcement
AEP BOOQ European Psychiatry:
G R O W I N G TOGETHER IN DIVERSITY
The 10th Congress of the Association of European Psychiatrists (AEP) will
convene in Prague, Czech Republic, October 28 through November 1, 2000.