Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00542-019-04596-9 (0123456789().,-volV)(0123456789().
,- volV)
TECHNICAL PAPER
Abstract
This paper proposes a silicon-based micro-electro-mechanical systems (MEMS) tuning fork gyroscope designed for high-g
shock environments. The results obtained by a shock experiment demonstrate that MEMS gyroscopes can still work well
after a load of 30,000 g is applied to the y-axis. This MEMS gyroscope is double symmetrical and connected by middle
coupling beams. The results obtained by mathematical analysis and finite element analysis revealed that the designed solid
stoppers are helpful in improving the gyroscope’s shock resistance. The high aspect-ratio structures were fabricated by an
efficient fabrication process using a silicon-on-glass wafer. To investigate the mechanical characteristics of the fabricated
gyroscopes, the silicone’s fracture strength and Young’s modulus were obtained by conducting tensile tests. The working
frequencies of the gyroscope were designed as 4000 Hz, and the driving and sensing modes in the test were 4095 Hz and
4137 Hz, respectively.
123
Microsystem Technologies
helpful in relieving stress at the corner of the structure, as Fig. 1, the structure is bilaterally symmetric and mainly
has been reported in a previous paper (Tao et al. 2014), and consists of a Coriolis mass pair and several driving and
improving the shock-resistibility of the MEMS gyroscope detecting combs. The Coriolis mass (blue) is driven by a
to 10,000 g, although the latter approach only slightly differential capacitor (red) parallel to the z-axis, and the
improves the anti-overload performance (Zhou et al. 2014). detection comb is a set of two differential capacitors (pink)
Adding a stopper to a moving structure is another widely parallel to the x-axis. The Coriolis mass is connected to the
used optimization method, wherein both elastic and solid combs by a u-beam parallel to the x-axis (dark blue), and to
stoppers are used. For example, the two-lever stopper has a the frame by eight pairs of u-beams parallel to the z-axis.
significant effect on improving the gyroscope’s anti-over- Moreover, based on the major structure, the anchors
load performance. were designed as stoppers along the x- and z-axis to further
In particular, the MEMS gyroscope, which is used in increase the anti-shock performance of the gyroscope, as
cannons, is an important element for controlling the pre- shown in Fig. 1. In the shock environment, the deflection
cision of striking. However, because the maximum launch of the beams can be effectively suppressed by the stopper.
overload of the cannon is 20,000 g, current gyroscopes When there exists an input angular velocity on the
cannot meet the cannon’s anti-overload requirements. gyroscope plane, the Coriolis mass will move in the z-axis
Therefore, in this paper, a silicon-based MEMS tuning fork under the influence of the Coriolis force. Owing to the
gyroscope used for a cannon platform is proposed, and electrostatic effect, the input angular velocity will be
standardized experiment proved its performance in high converted into the output voltage in the detection mode.
shock platform. We equipped our gyroscope with solid- Thus, the angular velocity can be detected. The size of the
stoppers, which are designed specifically for high-g shock proposed MEMS gyroscope is 6.5 9 2.7 mm2, and ensures
platform. The responding frequency is a key factor in the gyroscope’s effectiveness after a shock of 20,000 g.
realizing the high performance of the MEMS gyroscope. Additionally, the driving and detection modes of the
Therefore, the structure is designed to get the performance gyroscope exceed 4000 Hz to ensure its application to a
result by combining mathematical analysis and FEA. Its cannon platform.
shock resistance was calculated by conducting an overload
simulation using FEA software. Moreover, the proposed
MEMS gyroscope was fabricated using bulk silicon micro- 3 Fabrication
fabrication technology, and the mechanical properties of
silicon were obtained through tensile testing. A shock According to the specific structure of the gyroscope and the
experiment was conducted using a Split-Hopkinson pres- bulk silicon process, the process flow and method of fab-
sure bar. The dynamic performance of the fabricated ricating the MEMS gyroscope were designed as shown in
MEMS gyroscopes was measured after the shock experi- Fig. 2.
ment to verify its anti-shock ability. Boron diffusion is performed using low-resistance sili-
con to improve the electrical performance of the differen-
tial capacitor. The diffusion process is presented in
2 Device design and working principle Table 1. The surface of the silicon substrate is cleaned
using concentrated sulfuric acid #1 liquid and NH3, and
In this study, a double-vibrator structure was designed to H2O to remove the residual impurities on the surface.
suppress the gyroscope’s common-mode interference error Additionally, the SiO2 on the silicon-based surface is
and improve the measurement accuracy. As shown in
123
Microsystem Technologies
removed using BOE. The preparation of Si is carried out by In this study, the micro-samples were taken from the
sputtering Al on the side of the silicon substrate as an same batch of the silicon wafers used in the fabrication
interface for electrically connecting the gyroscope to the process. The cross-sections of the tested micro-samples
test circuit. To perform photolithography on the side of the were 0.3 9 0.08 mm2, 0.4 9 0.08 mm2, 0.5 9 0.08 mm2,
Al, the positions of the drive and detection modules are and 0.6 9 0.08 mm2, respectively. The lengths of the tested
selected (2.a). DRIE is used so that the structure can release micro-samples were 1.5 mm and 2.4 mm, respectively. The
the movable comb (2.b). Next, the surface photoresist and cross-sections and lengths of the micro-samples were freely
metal Al are removed (2.c) and the ionic activity of the combined, and eight groups of tests were conducted. One of
silicon-based structure surface is enhanced by Plasma (2.d). the stress–strain curves of the micro-samples is shown in
Then, a glass with Au (2.e) is prepared and deposited onto Fig. 4. Young’s modulus and the fracture strength of the
the surface. A device-level package of the silicon-based silicon were obtained according to the micro-samples’
structure and glass substrate is prepared using an anodic stress–strain curves. By computing the average of the test
bonding process (2.f). Metal Al is puttered on the other side results obtained for the eight groups, we obtained the
of the silicon substrate, and the structure of each mecha- average Young’s modulus of the silicon material as E = 127
nism of the silicon-based gyroscope is patterned using the GPa, and the average fracture strength as r = 726 MPa.
photolithography process (2.g). The structure is released by
DRIE (inductively coupled plasma etching technology) to
realize device processing (2.h) (Fig. 3). 5 Analysis
123
Microsystem Technologies
123
Microsystem Technologies
123
Microsystem Technologies
123
Microsystem Technologies
Fig. 10 Split-Hopkinson
pressure bar for shock
experiment
Signal Signal
Computer Tachymeter
analyzer amplificaon
Barrel
Grang
Grang base
Air valve Bullet Proving lever
Shim
Air pump
1
10 4 calculation, and 3.57% higher than that obtained by FEA.
0.5
The perceived frequency was 4158 Hz, which is 1.15%
0
higher than the perceived frequency obtained by numerical
-0.5 calculation and 3.22% higher than that obtained by FEA.
The test frequency and theoretical frequency were slightly
Shock load(g)
-1
-1.5 different, owing to the model and error of the simulation
-2 (Fig. 9).
-2.5
-3 5.3.2 Shock experiment
-3.5
-4 To evaluate the shock reliability of the MEMS gyroscope,
-4.5 a shock experiment was conducted using a Split-Hopkinson
200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
t(us) pressure bar. The experimental platform is shown in
Fig. 10. Moreover, Fig. 11 shows the curve of the maxi-
Fig. 11 Curve of the maximum shock load mum shock load in the process of the shock experiment,
123
Microsystem Technologies
123
Microsystem Technologies
30,000 g is applied, and therefore the MEMS gyroscope Funding The research is supported by the State Key National Project
satisfies the requirements. (6141B021310).
References
6 Conclusions
Acar C, Shkel A (2008) MEMS vibratory gyroscopes: structural
This paper proposes a tactical-grade MEMS gyroscope for approaches to improve robustness. Springer
use in a high-G shock platform. We enumerated the anti- Cao HL, Li HS, Lu X et al (2013) Temperature model or a vacuum
shock methods and improved the shock resistance by packaged MEMS gyroscope structure. Key Eng Mater
562–565:280–285
designing a gyroscope with a high working frequency and Cao Y, Xi Z, Yu P et al (2016) Optical measurement of the dynamic
solid stoppers. Both mathematical analysis and FEA were contact process of a MEMS inertial switch under high shock
used to design the MEMS gyroscope with high shock loads. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 64:701–709
reliability. The key geometric parameters, stiffness, reso- Gao LZ, Zhang XM, Wang Y (2015) Performance testing of MEMS
gyroscope for rotating ammunition. J Test Meas Technol
nant frequencies, and shock resistance were determined by 29:118–122
mathematical analysis. Moreover, a finite element simula- Gao Y, Li H, Huang L, Sun H et al (2017) A lever coupling
tion was conducted, and the mathematically predicted mechanism in dual-mass micro-gyroscopes for improving the
resonant frequencies were determined to be approximately shock resistance along the driving direction. Sensors 17:995.
https://doi.org/10.3390/s17050995
identical to the FEA results, which validates the frequency Lee JM, Chang UJ, Chang JC et al (2016a) High-shock silicon
formula derived in this study. accelerometer with an over-range stopper. J Mech Sci Technol
The designed MEMS gyroscope was fabricated using an 30:1817–1824
efficient fabrication process that employed a silicon-on- Lee JM, Chang UJ, Chang JC et al (2016b) High-shock silicon
accelerometer with a plate spring. Int J Precis Eng Manuf
glass (SOG) wafer. To investigate the mechanical charac- 17:637–644
teristics of the fabricated gyroscope, the fracture strength Li J, Broas M, Makkonen J et al (2014) Shock impact reliability and
and Young’s modulus of the silicon were obtained through failure analysis of a three-axis MEMS gyroscope. J Microelec-
tensile tests. By using well-established test procedures, the tromech Syst 23:347–355
Lin R, Li W, Zhao J et al (2013a) Optimization research on anti-high
resonance characteristics of the fabricated MEMS gyro- shock ability of quartz MEMS gyroscope. Piezoelectr Acous-
scope were evaluated to verify that the gyroscope satisfies toopt 35:56–58
the requirements for application to tactical navigation Lin RL, Li WY et al (2013b) Optimization research on anti high
systems. The working frequencies of the gyroscope in the shock ability of quartz MEMS gyroscope. Piezoelectr Acous-
toopt 35:56–58
driving and sensing modes were 4095 Hz and 4158 Hz, Lu Y, Wu X et al (2010) Optimization and analysis of novel
respectively. A shock experiment was conducted using a piezoelectric solid micro-gyroscope with high resistance to
Split-Hopkinson pressure bar to investigate the usability of shock. Microsyst Technol 16:571–584
the MEMS gyroscope in high-shock environments. After Ni YF, Li HS, Huang LB, Yang B (2011) Shock analysis on dual-
mass silicon micro-gyroscope. Adv Mater Res 338:401–405
the shock was applied, the Allan variance analysis of the Ni Y, Li H, Huang L et al (2014) On bandwidth characteristics of
sample signal demonstrated that the shock resistance of the tuning fork micro-gyroscope with mechanically coupled sense
MEMS gyroscope’s bias stability was 30 °/h. The MEMS mode. Sensors 14:13024–13045
could maintain a tactical grade performance level after a Niu CF, Liu SP, Wang ZY (2012) Estimate of flying projectile
attitude based on MEMS gyroscope measurements. Appl Mech
shock of 30,000 g was applied. The model and simulation Mater 236–237:236–241
analysis method described in this paper are also applicable Qiu X, Yang Z, Sun Y et al (2017) Shock-Resistibility of MEMS-
to other micro-electro-mechanical system. Stopper can based inertial micro switch under reverse directional ultra-high g
effectively restrain the deflection of micro-beam in impact acceleration for IOT applications. Sci Rep 7:45512
Si C, Han G, Ning J et al (2014) Shock resistance design of a high-
environment. Aiming at the movable parts of micro-elec- performance MEMS tuning-fork gyroscope. Micronanoelectron
tromechanical system, a suitable stopper is designed at its Technol 51:302–307
anchor point to limit the displacement of movable parts, Tao YK, Liu YF, Dong JX (2014) Flexible stop and double-cascaded
which can significantly improve the anti-impact ability of stop to improve shock reliability of MEMS accelerometer.
Microelectron Reliab 54:1328–1337
micro-electro-mechanical systems. Wang K, Zhang X, Tian J (2016) A rolling angle measurement
The experimental results confirmed the high shock algorithm based on fusion of two-axis accelerometer and MEMS
resistance of the proposed MEMS gyroscope for use in a gyroscope. J Xian Technol Univ 36:726–730
high-G shock platform. Moreover, the proposed MEMS Yang B, Wang X, Hu D et al (2017) Research on the non-ideal
dynamics of a dual-mass silicon micro-gyroscope. Microsyst
gyroscope can be useful in a wide range of applications, Technol 23:151–162
including military and aerospace systems such as cannons, Yoon SJ et al (2015a) Tactical grade MEMS vibrating ring gyroscope
guided missiles, smart munitions, and launching systems. with high shock reliability. Microelectron Eng 142:22–29
123
Microsystem Technologies
Yoon SJ et al (2015b) Design and analysis of MEMS vibrating ring Zhou J et al (2014) Design and fabrication of a micromachined
gyroscope considering high-g shock reliability. Korean Inst gyroscope with high shock resistance. Microsyst Technol
Electr Eng 64:1440–1447 20:137–144
Zhang Z et al (2015) Design, simulation and fabrication of triaxial
MEMS high shock accelerometer. J Nanosci Nanotechnol Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
15:2952–2957 jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Zhang Y, Zhou B, Song M et al (2017) A novel MEMSGyro north
finder design based on the rotation modulation technique.
Sensors 17:973
123