Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ene
FEAR OF STIGMATIZATION AND LACK OF CONFIDENTIALITY AS FACTORS
AFFECTING VOLUNTARY COUNSELING AND TESTING SERVICES IN
BRAITHWAITE MEMORIAL SPECIALIST HOSPITAL, PORT HARCOURT.
BY
Abstract
Voluntary Counseling and Testing (VCT) is an essential component of comprehensive AfDS
prevention and treatment programmes. VCT enables people to learn their HIV status in the most
informed and supportive way possible. Counseling is done before the test to educate them about
HIV infection and afterward to help them respond appropriately to the results. The study
investigated the effects of stigmatization and lack of confidentiality on voluntary counseling and
testing services in Braithwaite Memorial Specialist Hospital (BMSH), Port Harcourt Rivers State.
The sample size consisted of 100 health personnel and non health personnel drawn from the VCT
centre BMSH Port Harcourt Rivers State using simple random sampling technique to compute
the sample size. Cross-sectional descriptive survey design was adopted for the study. Two
research questions were answered. Questionnaire was used for data collection, a modified iikert
scale of, agree and disagree was used. It was validated by the researcher's supervisor and two
other lecturers in the School of Public Health Nursing Port Harcourt. Split half method was used
to determine the reliability of the instrument and reliability co-efficient on full test of 0.69 was
obtained. Data obtained was analyzed using the descriptive statistics of frequency distribution
tables, percentages and graphs for demographic data and to answer research question. The result
showed that all the variables investigated do not affect VCT services in BMSH Port Harcourt. It
was recommended among others that massive awareness and enlightenment campaign by
governmental and nongovernmental organization should continue and be sustained so that the
gains of previous campaigns would be consolidated.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
Ene
risk reduction. Those who test negative receive prevention counseling and those who test positive
receive referrals to prevention, care, support and treatment programs. VCT also encourages and
provides support for disclosing one's HIV status to sexual partners. Reports by UNGASS, (2010)
show that Nigeria has an estimated 3.6 percent of its population living with HIV and AIDS. Fear
of Stigmatization and Lack of Confidentiality
Although HIV prevalence is much lower in Nigeria than in other African countries such as South
Africa and Zambia, the size of Nigeria's population (around 149 million) meant that by the end of
2009, there were almost 3 million people living with HIV (UNGASS Report, 2010). Furthermore,
the UNGASS Report posits that approximately 192,000 people died from AIDS in 2009. With
AIDS claiming so many lives, Nigeria's life expectancy has declined significantly. World Health
Organization (WHO), (2008) reports that in 1991 the average life expectancy was 54 years for
women and 53 years for men. In 2009, these figures had fallen to 48 for women and 46 for men
(CIA, 2010). Nigeria has a national prevalence of 5.8%. Abuja's rate grew from 7 to 10% from
1999 to 2001 due to ignorance about personal risk of HIV and of benefits of Voluntary Counseling
and Testing (VCT). There is no standard VCT centre in the city. Available testing services may
be coercive, costly or lack strict confidentiality, increasing fear of stigma and beneficiaries include
migrant workers, traders, motorist, tourist, sex workers and pregnant women in the city (Centre
for the Right to Health, 2010). Wigley (2004) also notes that in 1993, Family Health
International (FHI) supported two on-going VCT sites in Nigeria through its USAIDFunded
Impact Project. These two centres in Lagos and Kano were the first stand alone VCT facilities in
Nigeria. The Lagos center is operated by the Salvation Army, a global philanthropic organization
that has worked with the Nigerian government on AIDS programs since 1992, with plans to
expand to 22 sites in 2004. However VCT centers have opened up in teaching hospitals, specialist
hospitals and other specially designated sites all over the country today. Studies on HIV voluntary
counseling and testing in developing countries to prove the efficacy and cost effectiveness of
providing voluntary counseling and testing for HIV-1 in developing countries were reported in
the new issue (July 8, 2000) of the British Medical Journal - The Lancet. The efficacy study,
headed by Thomas J. Coates, director of the AIDS Research Institute at the University of
California, San Francisco, enrolled 3,120 individuals and 586 couples in Nairobi, Kenya, Darees
Salam, Tanzania, and Port-of-Spain Trinidad.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
Ene
unfriendliness, coercive, high cost or lack strict confidentiality and increasing Fear of
Stigmatization and Lack of Confidentiality
fear of stigma. The problem of this research therefore, is to investigate the impact of stigmatization
and lack of confidentiality on VCT services in Braithwaite Memorial Specialist Hospital (BMSH),
Port Harcourt.
Research Questions
The following research guestions were formulated to guide the study.
1. Is fear of stigmatization a factor affecting voluntary counseling and testing services in
Braithwaite Memorial Specialist Hospital, Port Harcourt?
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
Ene
Testing: This is laboratory examination of blood specimen of people to show if Human Immuno
Virus is present or absent in it.
Fear of Stigmatization and Lack of Confidentiality
HIV/AIDS
According to Basavanthappa (2008), Amadi (2002) and Lucas and Gilles (2003), AIDS, the
Acguired Immuno-Deficiency Syndrome (sometimes catted "slim disease, Basavanthappa, 2008)
is a newly described, usually fatal illness caused by a retrovirus known as the Human
Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) which breaks down the body's immune system leaving the victim
vulnerable, to a host of life threatening opportunistic infections, neurological disorders, or unusual
malignancies.
Origin
Infectious diseases had ceased to be a major problem in developed countries till a decade or two
ago but with the advent of AIDS in the early 80's, the situation changed dramatically. Retro-virus
and their cancer causing potential are not new to scientists. Reverse transcriptase was discovered
in 1970. However, up to mid 70s another infectious retrovirus was found in human beings. In
1980, the first human retrovirus HTLV-1 was isolated which causes a rare, highly malignant
cancer called adult and T-cell leukemia, that is endemic in parts of Japan, Africa and Caribbean
islands and spreading to other regions as well, two years later, HTLV-2 was found out. Both
viruses cause immune depressions and therefore, when AIDS cases were first discovered, the
initial hypothesis was that the cause of AIDS could be a close reactive of HTLV1, the hypothesis
did not prove correct, however, the search in this direction led to the discovery of HIV as the cause
of AIDS (Basavanthappa, 2008).
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
Ene
Fear of Stigmatization and Lack of Confidentiality
• Learn to recognize the signs of opportunistic infections so individuals can get treated
promptly.
• Find out what resources are available within the community to help people manage their HIV
status.
• Find out about prophylactic drugs. These drugs do not cure HIV/AIDS, but can prevent the
individual from getting some opportunistic infections that are common with people living
with HIV/AIDS, for example, tuberculosis and some kinds of pneumonia.
• Access Nevirapine. This is a drug available at a number of hospitals and clinics that lessens
the chance of a pregnant mother passing the virus onto her baby.
VCT can motivate those who are not infected with HIV to stay HIV antibody negative, and to
accept those who are infected (Angaza Project Tazania, 2001). Angaza Project Tazania, (2001)
notes the following about voluntary counseling i-n HIV and AIDS.
Pre-Test Counseling:
This is the kind of counseling done before an individual decides whether they want to have the
HIV antibody test. Some of the issues the counselor will discuss with the individual are:
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
• The individual's personal history.
• Whether the individual has any health problems.
• What the individual's risk of being HIV infected is.
• What the individual knows about HIV/AIDS.
Revised Guidelines for HIV Counseling, Testing, and Referral. Technical Expert Panel
Review of CDC HIV Counseling, Testing, and Referral Guidelines, (1999).
A review of these guidelines is necessary because other countries adapt their VCT guidelines based
on it. It presents a more elaborate discussion of all that VCT entails. These guidelines replace
CDC's 1994 guidelines, HIV Counseling, Testing, and Referral Standards and Guidelines, and
contain recommendations for public- and private-sector, policy makers and service providers of
human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) counseling, testing, and referral (CTR). To develop these
guidelines, CDC used an evidence-based approach advocated by the U.S. Preventive Services
Task Force and public health practice guidelines. The recommendations are based on evidence
from all available scientific sources; where evidence is lacking, opinion of "best practices" by
specialists in the field has been used. This revision was prompted by scientific and programmatic
advances in HIV CTR, as well as advances in prevention and the treatment and care of HIV-
infected persons. These advances include; a) demonstrated efficacy of HIV prevention counseling
models aimed at behavioral risk reduction; b) effective treatments for HIV infection and
opportunistic infections; c) effective treatment regimens for preventing perinatal transmission; and
d) new test technologies. Although the new guidelines include many aspects of the previous ones
(for example, encouragement of confidential and anonymous voluntary HIV testing, need for
informed consent, and provision of HIV prevention counseling that focuses on the client's own
risk), the new guidelines differ in several respects, including
• giving guidance to all providers of voluntary HIV CTR in the public and private sectors;
• acknowledging providers' need for flexibility in implementing the guidelines, given their
particular client base, setting HIV prevalence level, and available resources;
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
• recommending that CTR be targeted efficiently through risk screening and other strategies;
and
Research Methodology
Research Design
The design of the study was cross-sectional descriptive survey. Cross sectional descriptive survey
design was used in this study to investigate the socio-economic factors affecting voluntary
counseling and testing (VCT) services at the Braithwaite Memorial Specialist Hospital, Port
Harcourt. The design was considered appropriate for this study because the researcher seeks to
collect data once from a sample drawn from the study population for a short period and describe
certain features of the sample. The thrust here is that certain features of the variables under
investigation in the study are merely described as they are at that particular time and the findings
from the sample are generalized to the population from which the sample are drawn.
Validity of Instrument
In order to ensure the face and content validity of the questionnaire, a draft of the questionnaire
was given to the researcher's supervisor and two other lecturers of the School of Public Health
Nursing, Port Harcourt. To ensure the effectiveness of this exercise, the researcher provided the
lecturers with clear guidelines on what to do in a letter that accompanied the questionnaire. The
purposes of the study as well as the research questions of the study were included. This helped the
lecturers to determine which items actually elicited the information they were intended to elicit.
In addition to this, there was 'specific instruction' to the lecturers to review the items in terms of
their clarity, appropriateness of the language and expression to the respondents, including the
appropriateness of the instruction to the respondents. At the end of questionnaire, space was
provided for comments the lecturers may wish to make regarding the overall adequacy of the
instrument. Thereafter, the items were modified along the lines suggested by the comments of
these lecturers and thus adjured to be valid.
Hospital. This group was not used in the final study. Information received from the
Fear of Stigmatization and Lack of Confidentiality Ene
responses was used for modification of the questionnaire items and to improve the reliability of
the research instrument. The field test was also meant to acquaint the researcher on what possible
problem that may likely be encountered during the distribution and collection of data from the
respondents.
Reliability of Instrument
Reliability for internal consistency of the instrument was done using Split Half method. For this
purpose, the 10 questionnaires served to the General Outpatient (GOPD) Department of
Braithwaite Memorial Specialist Hospital were also used. These were retrieved after being filled
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
for calculation. The 10 questionnaires retrieved were split into two equal halves of odd and even
numbers. These were coded and first correlated using Pearson Product Moment Correlation
Coefficient. Then, the reliability on full test was done using Spearman Brown formula; rf = 2*
reliability on half test/ 1+ reliability on half test, rf = 2* r V2 / 1+ r Vi.
The reliability of the entire instrument was 0.69. The Reliability Coefficient value so obtained was
high enough to guarantee the use of the instrument for this study.
frequency distribution table, and graphs percentages for demographic data and to answer the
research questions .
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
Total 78.00 100.00
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Male Female
Gender
Frequency
Percentage
Table 1 / Figure 1 present the gender of the respondents. It shows that the male respondents were
30 in number which is 38% of the entire sample size while the female respondents were 48 in
number, representing 68 % of the sample size. This indicates that there were more females than
males respondents in the sample of investigation.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
30
25
20
15
10
0
18-22 23-27 28-32 33-37 38-42 and
above
Age
Frequency
Percentage
Table 2 / Figure 2 show the age distribution of the respondents as well as the percentage they
represent in the sample. It can be seen that the age bracket of 38- 42 and above appeared most in
the sample with 26% that is to say that the majority of the respondents are experienced and can
give some reliable information to enable this investigation, while respondents within the age range
of 18-22 were the least in the sample with a percentage of 13%.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
based on Qualification
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Secondary Tertiary
Qualification Frequency
Percentage
Table 3 / Figure 3 show the distribution of the educational qualifications of the respondents, it can
be observed from the table that most of the respondents had secondary education (51%) and the
rest tertiary education (49%). The disclosed information about the respondents' qualification and
age attests to the fact that reliable information could be gotten from them to facilitate this
investigation.
Fig. 4. A Bar Chart Showing the Distribution of the Respondents based on status
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
(health personnel or client)
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Doctors Nurses Laboratory Counselor Others Clients
Staff
Status (Health personnel or client) Frequency
Percentage
Table 4 / figure 4 indicate that the majority (64%) of the respondents was clients, and (13%)
nurses. This is very encouraging in this study because it is usually quite difficult to get clients
in VCT centres to respond to interviews or fill out questionnaires due to fear of stigmation if
their identity is revealed. In this case however, they had to be reassured of anonymity, and that
it is to generate data that will be used to improve services in the centre.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
2 Many clients have learnt of their HIV and 58(74.36) 20(25.64) 78
AIDS status through voluntary counseling
and testing (VCT) services in this centre.
Table 5 shows that the all (100.00% ) respondents indicated that VCT is a useful tool in HIV and
AIDS care and prevention strategies, many clients learnt of their HIV status in the centre and that
not only patients from the hospital were counseled and tested in the centre. They were undecided
in their responses that fear of stigmatization has limited the response to voluntary counseling and
testing (VCT) sen/ices in this centre. Also they (54.54%) disagreed that fear of stigmatization has
resulted in unsatisfactory patronage of VCT services provided in the centre.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
AGREE (%) DISAGREE TOTAL
Items
(°/o)
7 This centre is open and so lacks privacy. 39(50.00) 39(50.00) 78
References
Amadi, C.I. (2002). Principles of epidemiology and disease control. Nigeria: C. Ushie and
Associates.
Amusa, B., Joel, O. 1, Anyamele, C., Okoro, O. D., Shobande, J. & Pius, U. (2004, July).
Challenges of voluntary counselling and testing among young people in Lagos, Nigeria.
Basavanthappa, B. T. (2008). Community health nursing (2nd ed.). New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers
Medical Publishers (P) Ltd.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012
CIA World Factbook. (2010). http://www.cia.gov/library/ Publication/ the – world –
facebook/geos/ni.html.
Hornby, A.S. (Ed.). (2006). Oxford advanced learner’s dictionary of current English (7th Ed.).
Oxford: Oxford University Press. http://www. Crhonline.org
Kallings, L. O. (2008). The first postmodern pandemic: 25 years of HIV and AIDS. Journal
International Med 263 (3): 218-43.
Lucas, A. O. & Gilles, H. M. (2003). Short textbook of public health medicine for the Tropic (Rev.
4th ed.) Malta: Macmillan.
Sepkowitz, K. A. (June 2001). AIDS—the first 20 years. New England Journal, 344 (23): 176472.
UNGASS. (2010). UNGASS country progress report: Nigeria.
http://www.unaiids.org/en/countiresresponses/countries/Nigeria.asp.
UNAIDS, WHO. (December 2007). 27 AIDS epidemic update (PDF). www.fhi.org. Wigley, M.
(2004). Improving counseling and testing services in Nigeria: lessons learned. Arlington,
USA: Family Health International (FHI) Institute for HIV/AIDS.
World Health Organisation (WHO). (2008). WHO African Region Report: Nigeria.
http://www.who.int/countries/nga/area/hiv/en/index.html.
African Journal of Professional Research in Human Development in Africa, Vol. 8, No. 4, December, 2012