Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Background: The aim of this study was to perform a systematic review
and meta-analysis on available data about glucose-6-phosphate
dehydrogenase enzyme deficiency (G6PDD) status in Iranian neonates
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
of G6PDD are more serious in newborns, it is G6PDD among Iranian neonates. To have an
necessary to determine the presence of this genetic acceptable and real prevalence, we included the studies
disease early in this age group. screening for G6PDD in newborns, but we excluded
Health care systems around the world consider a from further analyses conducted only on the subjects
screening program as an important and efficient step in with jaundice/hyperbilirubinemia or any other specific
the reduction of hospitalization caused by favism (a disease. We included the later studies for assessment of
form of hemolytic anemia caused by contact with complications of G6PDD and genetic factors
broad beans) and also kernicterus. Most of countries potentially associated with the disease. The other
have this program in neonates [10, 11]. In Iran, there is a exclusion criteria were the following:
newborn screening program for G6PDD and it is 1. Reviews, case reports, editorials, letters and
managed by the Ministry of Health and Medical comments,
Education [12]. We aimed to perform a systematic 2. Duplicate articles,
review and meta-analysis on the available data about 3. Studies conducted on subjects other than
G6PDD prevalence in Iranian neonates screened for the neonates,
disease. In addition, it was tried to collect the 4. Articles without clear methodology or results, and
information related to the genetic factors associated Full-texts were not available.
with G6PDD and complications which occur following Study selection and data extraction: Two
the disease. These data should be useful for clinicians authors (MZ, VZ) assessed the Titles and Abstracts
and other health professionals planning for better independently for eligibility. Besides, the full-text of
management of G6PDD in Iranian newborns. the potential articles was evaluated in the next step.
When there was a discrepancy, it was resolved by
consensus with a third author (YZ). Two authors (MZ,
Methods EZ) extracted data independently. The following data
Information sources and search strategy: A were collected: first author's name, study period,
literature search was conducted in the electronic publication date, study location, number of population
databases of Embase, PubMed, Web of Sciences, (total and by gender), prevalence of G6PDD among
Scopus and Google Scholar for articles published from screened neonates, prevalence of complications in
inception to 1 December 2018. After searching the newborns with G6PDD. Duplicate articles were
related terms in the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) excluded and one with more details or larger sample
database, finally, the keywords included “glucose-6- size was selected.
phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency” OR Quality assessment: The checklist by Hoy et al.
[15]
“Glucosephosphate Dehydrogenase Deficiency” OR was used for evaluating the risk of bias, which has
“Glucose 6 Phosphate Dehydrogenase Deficiency” OR nine questions with two potential responses (Yes/No).
“G6PD deficiency” AND “Iran” OR “Iranian”. The The range of scores is between 0 and 9. Higher scores
search was limited to Title/Abstract. The word “Iran” are representative of higher risk of bias.
was limited to Affiliation as well. Furthermore, the Study outcomes and statistical analysis:
current study searched literatures from Iranian After collecting the necessary data, they were analyzed
databases, including Magiran and Scientific using STATA software (StataCorp, College Station,
Information Database (SID), using the Persian TX, USA). The pooled estimate rate of G6PDD
equivalent of the above-mentioned keywords. Hand prevalence was presented as percent and 95%
searching was also performed on the reference lists of confidence interval (CI). The complications of G6PDD
the relevant review articles and studies finally included in the present study were jaundice (in neonates with
in the current study to identify additional sources. G6PDD) and kernicterus (in G6PDD cases presented
377 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
with jaundice). Additionally, the sub-group analyses
were performed by gender (male and female) and study
date (<2007 and ≥2007). Splitting the study date into Results
<2007 and ≥2007 was mainly based on the distribution A total of 656 articles were initially found by
of the number of reports in each period category. When searching the databases, of which 198 papers were
the study date was not mentioned, the year of study excluded after evaluating title/abstract. After assessing
publication was used instead. Prevalence of G6PDD full-texts of 35 articles, 19 studies were excluded.
was compared according to gender by using an odds Different steps of systematic review were indicated in
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
ratio (OR) with a 95% confidence interval (CI). I2 PRISMA chart (Figure 1). Overall, 16 studies were
statistic and χ² test were used for checking the included in the systematic review for final analysis and
statistical heterogeneity. Random effects model was their details were summarized in table 1.
used for meta-analysis. Forest plots were provided to
summarize the results of meta-analyses.
378 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
Table 1. Charactritics of the studies reproting prevalence of G6PDD among Iraninan newborns screened for the disease
Prevalenc Prevalenc
Publication Study Risk of Number Number Number Prevalence
Region Author e e
date date bias score (total) (boys) (girls) (%, girls)
(%, total) (%, boys)
Zahedpasha
Babol 1999 1995 1/9 2046 1035 1011 8.3 12.5 4.1
(54)
Bushehr Movahhed (55) 2003 1998 1/9 415 218 210 8.4 12.8 1.9
2011-
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
Fars Daliri (56) 2017 1/9 383463 199536 183927 15.6 16.3 14.9
2015
Isfahahn Iranpour (57) 2008 2006 1/9 2501 1307 1194 3.2 5.1 1
Mohammadzad
Mashhad 2009 2006 1/9 2570 1307 1263 0.8 1 0.5
eh (58)
2007-
Mazandaran Kosaryan (59) 2011 1/9 115622 59430 56192 5.8 - -
2010
Rafsanjan Alidalaki (60) 2007 2004 1/9 1018 523 495 5 5.7 4.2
Rasht Khalili (61) 2007 2001 1/9 1197 605 585 6.4 9.8 3.1
Rasht Keihanian (62) 2016 - 1/9 1474 757 717 6.6 11.4 1.7
2012-
Sari Kosaryan (63) 2014 1/9 365 174 191 7.5 7.5 0
2013
2007-
Semnan Nazari (64) 2011 1/9 9353 4820 4533 3.2 5.5 0.8
2010
Shahrekord Norbahksh (65) 2013 2011 1/9 1240 633 607 2.3 2 2.6
Ansari-
Sistan and
Moghaddam 2017 - 1/9 140 68 72 8.4 11.8 5.6
Baluchestan
(66)
Abolghasemi
Tehran 2004 1999 1/9 2000 1006 994 2.1 3.6 0.6
(17)
2008-
Tehran Khalesy (16) 2012 1/9 450 245 205 2 3.3 0.5
2009
Tehran Kazemi (18) 2013 2009 1/9 1226 585 641 2.2 2.1 2.3
379 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
Table 2. Rate of jaundice in neonates with glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency and kernicterus in
those presented with jaundice in Iran
Complication Author Number of subjects Prevalence of complication (%)
Jaundice Abolghasemi (17) 42 42.9
Kazemi (18) 27 70.3
Khalesy (16) 9 66.7
Kernicterus Aletayeb (19) 112 4.5
Boskabadi (20) 59 6.8
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
Study % %
ID Prevalence
Prevalence (95%(95%
CI) CI) Weight
Weight
-5 0 16
380 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
Study % %
ID Prevalence (95%
Prevalence (95% CI)CI) Weight
Weight
Boy
Abolghasemi (2004) 3.60 (2.45,4.75)
3.60 (2.45, 4.75) 3.51
3.51
Alidalaki (2007) 5.70 (3.71,7.69)
5.70 (3.71, 7.69) 3.47
3.47
Ansari-Moghaddam (2017) 11.80 (4.13, 19.47)
11.80 (4.13, 19.47) 2.82
2.82
Daliri (2017) 16.30 (16.14,16.46)
16.30 (16.14, 16.46) 3.53
3.53
Iranpour (2008) 5.10 (3.91,6.29)
5.10 (3.91, 6.29) 3.50
3.50
Kazemi (2013) 2.10 (0.94,3.26)
2.10 (0.94, 3.26) 3.51
3.51
Keihanian (2016) 11.40 (9.14,13.66)
11.40 (9.14, 13.66) 3.45
3.45
Khalesy (2012) 3.30 (1.06,5.54)
3.30 (1.06, 5.54) 3.45
3.45
Khalili (2007) 9.80 (7.43,12.17)
9.80 (7.43, 12.17) 3.44
3.44
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
-10 0 19.5
Study %%
ID Prevalence (95%
Prevalence (95% CI)CI) Weight
Weight
<2007
Abolghasemi (2004) 2.10
2.10 (1.47, 2.73)
(1.47, 2.73) 6.33
6.33
Alidalaki (2007) 5.00
5.00 (3.66, 6.34)
(3.66, 6.34) 6.28
6.28
Iranpour (2008) 3.20
3.20 (2.51, 3.89)
(2.51, 3.89) 6.33
6.33
Khalili (2007) 6.40
6.40 (5.01, 7.79)
(5.01, 7.79) 6.28
6.28
Mohammadzadeh (2009) 0.80
0.80 (0.46, 1.14)
(0.46, 1.14) 6.34
6.34
Movahhed (2003) 8.40
8.40 (5.73, 11.07)
(5.73, 11.07) 6.11
6.11
Zahedpasha (1999) 8.30
8.30 (7.10, 9.50)
(7.10, 9.50) 6.29
6.29
Subtotal (I-squared = 97.5%, p = 0.000) 4.74
4.74 (2.77, 6.70)
(2.77, 6.70) 43.96
43.96
.
≥2007
Ansari-Moghaddam (2017) 8.40
8.40 (3.81, 12.99)
(3.81, 12.99) 5.70
5.70
Daliri (2017) 15.60 (15.49,15.71)
15.60 (15.49, 15.71) 6.34
6.34
Kazemi (2013) 2.20
2.20 (1.38, 3.02)
(1.38, 3.02) 6.32
6.32
Keihanian (2016) 6.60
6.60 (5.33, 7.87)
(5.33, 7.87) 6.29
6.29
Khalesy (2012) 2.00
2.00 (0.71, 3.29)
(0.71, 3.29) 6.29
6.29
Kosaryan (2011) 5.80
5.80 (5.67, 5.93)
(5.67, 5.93) 6.34
6.34
Kosaryan (2014) 7.50
7.50 (4.80, 10.20)
(4.80, 10.20) 6.10
6.10
Nazari (2011) 3.20
3.20 (2.84, 3.56)
(2.84, 3.56) 6.34
6.34
Norbahksh (2013) 2.30
2.30 (1.47, 3.13)
(1.47, 3.13) 6.32
6.32
Subtotal (I-squared = 99.9%, p = 0.000) 5.93
5.93 (1.39, 10.47)
(1.39, 10.47) 56.04
56.04
.
Overall (I-squared = 99.9%, p = 0.000) 5.46
5.46 (2.02, 8.90)
(2.02, 8.90) 100.00
100.00
-15.7 0 15.7
Figure 4. The overall pooled prevalence of G6PDD in Iraninan newborns by study date
381 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
Study % %
ID OR (95%
OR (95% CI) CI) Weight
Weight
.00184 1 543
Figure 5. Pooled Odds Ratio (OR) for G6PDD in boys compared with girls
382 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
the United States, [26] 4.5% in India, [27] 6.1% in papers represented that infants with G6PDD are about
Thailand, [28] 2.4% in China, [29] 7.8% in Brazil, [30] 4 times more at risk of hyperbilirubinemia compared
4.3% in Egypt, [31] 4.4% in Tunisia [32] and 2% in Saudi with G6PD-normal infants [42].
Arabia [33]. Variable prevalence between different The current research also discussed kernicterus - a
countries and regions can be explained by differences major complication of G6PDD. It is clear that G6PDD
in ethnicity and genetic distribution between contributes to kernicterus via at least 2 mechanisms:
populations. Many G6PD gene mutations are firstly, severe hemolysis results in rising total bilirubin
responsible for deficiency of the enzyme, including levels and subsequent accumulation of bilirubin in the
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
Mediterranean, Chatham, Cosenza, and G6PD A and brain. Secondly, G6PDD results in a reduced buffering
so on. In a systematic review, only one article was capacity against bilirubin-induced reactive oxygen
found that reported on the prevalence of G6PD species [43, 44]. The second mechanism may explain why
mutations among Iranian newborns [23]. G6PD-deficient infants develop kernicterus at even at
In a recent meta-analysis concerning Iran, the lower levels of total bilirubin. The risk of kernicterus in
prevalence of Mediterranean, Chatham, and Cosenza G6PD-deficient infants with total bilirubin serum
molecular mutations was estimated 78.2, 9.1 and 0.5% levels above 20 mg/dL (342 µmol/L) appears to be
[34]
in G6PD-deficient people, respectively . more severe than that associated with rhesus disease.
Mediterranean G6PD has a high prevalence in other Thus, in the presence of G6PDD, even more aggressive
tropical and subtropical regions [24]. Its prevalence is treatment of these infants is probably indicated [45-48].
similarly high in neighboring countries, such as Saudi The incidence of kernicterus in Iran has risen in recent
Arabia (80%), Oman (74%), Turkey (77%), India years because of a variety of factors: firstly, newborns
(60.4%), United Arab Emirates (55.5%) and Pakistan are often discharged from the hospital within 24 to 48
(76%), as well as in Mediterranean coast countries [34]. hours of birth, but total bilirubin levels often peak 4 to
This mutation is mainly associated with favism [35, 36]. 5 days after birth. Secondly, the lack of proper
Chatham mutation is responsible for G6PDD class II monitoring at home allows the undiagnosed
presenting with severe hemolytic anemia; however, it development of kernicterus [49-52].
has lower prevalence compared with the Mediterranean One limitation of this systematic review was the
mutation [37-39]. restricted number of studies evaluating complications
Our subgroup analysis showed a 3-fold higher rate of G6PDD. The current study suggests the planning of
of G6PDD in boys than in girls and risk of G6PDD, a new screening studies, and follow-up of the G6PDD
result that was consistent with previous research (40). cases to record the frequency of jaundice and
Considering that inheritance G6PDD has an X-linked kernicterus. Another limitation was the high
pattern, it is expected to see this disease more in male heterogeneities between the studies, despite analyzing
infants than in female ones. Homozygous males with only the population-based screening studies. However,
class I mutations usually develop chronic non- because the individual articles were epidemiologic
spherocytic hemolytic anemia, whereas females who surveys, we would expect high heterogeneity [53].
are heterozygous for G6PD can carry severe mutations In conclusion, the prevalence of G6PDD in Iran is
but may remain symptomless [41, 42]. similar to most countries. Jaundice and kernicterus are
Neonatal screening for G6PDD is implemented in the major complications of G6PDD. Therefore, it is
many Asian, African, Mediterranean and Middle necessary to provide good care for patients with
Eastern countries where G6PDD is common. Screening G6PDD, and it is recommended for those hospitals to
is associated with a reduced incidence of severe provide the result of G6PD testing as soon as possible
hyperbilirubinemia and kernicterus. In countries where after delivery, ideally before discharging newborn
G6PDD is historically less common, the increase in children.
global population movement has raised the question as
to whether G6PDD screening should be implemented
throughout the world [31, 41]. Acknowledgment
There was only one article about the relation We are grateful to the Clinical Research
between G6PD mutations, jaundice and its treatment in Development Committee of Amirkola Children's
Iranian neonates; Zahedpasha et al [24]. Reported that Hospital and Student Research Committee of Babol
there were no significant relationships between major University of Medical Sciences for their contribution to
mutations and icterus. A recent meta-analysis on five this study.
383 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
11. Arain YH, Bhutani VK. Prevention of Kernicterus in
Funding: None. South Asia: role of neonatal G6PD deficiency and its
Ethical Approval: This study obtained ethics identification. Indian J Pediatr 2014; 81(6): 599-607.
committee of Babol University of Medical Sciences 12. Kosaryan M, Nasehi MM, Karami H, et al. Neonatal
(IR.MUBABOL.REC.1398.052). screening for G6PD deficiency in Mazandaran
Conflict of Interest: None declared. Province, Iran 2007-2010. Iran J Blood Cancer 2011;
2(4): 113-6.
13. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, Group
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
384 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
neonates in province of Mazandaran, North of Iran, 36. Laosombat V, Sattayasevana B, Chotsampancharoen
2012. Razi J Med Sci 2014; 21(124): 64-70 [Text in T, Wongchanchailert M. Glucose-6-phosphate
Persian]. dehydrogenase variants associated with favism in
24. Zahedpasha Y, Kachouri MA, Niaki HA, Farhadi R. Thai children. Int J Hematol 2006; 83(2): 139-43.
Comparison of molecular mutations of G6PD 37. Vulliamy T, D'urso M, Battistuzzi G, et al. Diverse
deficiency gene between icteric and nonicteric point mutations in the human glucose-6-phosphate
neonates. Int J Mol Cell Med 2013; 2(1): 14-20. dehydrogenase gene cause enzyme deficiency and
25. Zahedpasha Y, Ahmadpour M, Niaki HA, Alaee E. mild or severe hemolytic anemia. Proc Natl Acad Sci
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
385 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86
exploratory study. Arch Pediatrs Adoles Med 2001; test and quantitative enzyme assay in detection of
155(12): 1357-63. G6PD enzyme deficiency. J Gorgan Uni Med Sci.
49. Olusanya BO, Ogunlesi TA, Slusher TM. Why is 2015;17(3): 108-13 [Text in Persian].
kernicterus still a major cause of death and disability 60. Alidalaki S, Negahban BT, Houlakouei M, et al.
in low-income and middle-income countries? Arch Investigation of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase
Dis Child 2014; 99(12): archdischild-2013-305506. deficiency in Rafsanjan, Autumn 2004. J Rafsanjan
50. Watchko JF. Identification of neonates at risk for Univ Med Sci 2008 [Text in Persian].
hazardous hyperbilirubinemia: emerging clinical 61. Khalili D, Jafroodi M, Sajedi S, et al. Survey of the
Downloaded from caspianjp.ir at 19:24 +0430 on Tuesday August 24th 2021
insights. Pediatr Clin North Am 2009; 56(3): 671-87. prevalence of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase
51. Ives K. Preventing kernicterus: a wake-up call. Arch deficiency in Rasht-Iran. J Guilan Uni Med Sci 2007;
Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2007; 92(5): F330-F1. 16(63): 51-6 [Text in Persian].
52. Bhutani V, Johnson L. Kernicterus in the 21st 62. Keihanian F, Basirjafari S, Darbandi B, Saeidinia A,
century: frequently asked questions. J Perinatol 2009; Jafroodi M, Sharafi R, et al. Comparison of
29(Suppl 1): S20-4. quantitative and qualitative tests for
53. Zamani M, Derakhshan M, Zamani V, glucose‐6‐phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency in the
Shokri‐Shirvani J. The prevalence of Helicobacter neonatal period. Int J Lab Hematol 2017; 39(3): 251-
pylori infection worldwide knowns and unknowns. 60.
Authors' reply. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 2018; 47(9): 63. Kosaryan M, Mahdavi MR, Jalali H, Roshan P. Why
1331-2. does the Iranian national program of screening
54. ZahedPasha Y. The prevalence of G6PD deficiency newborns for G6PD enzyme deficiency miss a large
in the newborns of Babol, 1995. J Babol Univ Med number of affected infants? Pediatr Hematol Oncol.
Sci 1999; 1(4): 19-25 [Text in Persian]. 2014;31(1):95-100.
55. Movahhed A, Farrokhi S. Incidence Rate of G6PD 64. Nazari H, Habibeh Najar H, Emadi A, et al.
Deficiency in Newborns in Bushehr/Iran. Iran J Prevalence of G6PD deficiency in neonates referred
Pediatr 2003; 13(1): 55-8 [Text in Persian]. to Semnan University of Medical Science´s screening
56. Daliri S, Asadollahi K, Rahimi N, Sayehmiri K. Lab. Medical Laboratory Journal. 2011;5(2):66-70
Incidence of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase [Text in Persian].
deficiency in malaria-prone regions of Fars province. 65. Norbahksh Smk, Kasiri k-A, Jalil A, Hashemzade m.
Tehran Univ Med J 2017; 75(9): 669-74 [Text in Determining the frequency of glucose-6-phosphate
Persian]. dehydrogenase deficiency in newborn infants in
57. Iranpour R, Hashemipour M, Talaei S-M, et al. Shahrekord. J of Shahrekord Uuniversity of Medical
Newborn screening for glucose-6-phosphate Sciences. 2013;15(5):30-7 [Text in Persian].
dehydrogenase deficiency in Isfahan, Iran: a 66. Ansari-Moghaddam A, Adineh HA, Mohammadi M,
quantitative assay. J Med Screen 2008; 15(2): 62-4. et al. Prevalence of glucose-6-phosphate
58. Mohammadzadeh A, Jafarzadeh M, Farhat AS, et al. dehydrogenase (G6PD) defiiency in malaria endemic
Prevalence of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase region of Iran (Sistan and Baluchestan Province):
deficiency in neonates of Northeast of Iran. J Clin Epidemiological profie and trends over time. Asian
Med Res 2009; 4(8). Pac J Trop Dis 2017; 7(10): 587-91.
59. Kosaryan M, Mahdavi M, Jalali H, Roshan P.
Comparison of fluorescent spot test, decolorization
386 | P a g e Caspian Journal of Pediatrics, March 2020; Vol 6(No 1), Pp: 376-86