Skill competition

Refrigeration and Air Conditioning

Rating Criteria S/O Weight

1. Safety S 1.5
2. Speed O 1.5
3. Aluminum brazing S/O 2
4. Piping installation O 4
5. Insulation O 1

S = subjective
O = objective

1. Safety (1 to 10) Weight

a. Use of hand tools 0.3

b. Housekeeping 0.3
c. Proper handling of oxy-acetylene 0.4
d. Accident took place 0.5

2. Speed ( 1 or 10 )
a. Aluminum brazing speed 0.5

b. Piping installation 1

3. Aluminum brazing skills

a. Uneven distribution of filler metal 1 - 10 0.4
b. Overfilled joint 1 or 10 0.4
c. Over heated joint 1 or 10 0.4
d. Melted aluminum tubes 1 or 10 0.4
e. Correct setting of brazing equipment 1 or 10 0.4

4. Piping installation
a. Accuracy in measurement 1 or 10 0.8
b. Piping deformations an appearance 1 or 10 0.8
c. Uneven distribution of filler metals 1 - 10 0.8
d. Overfilled joints 1 or 10 0.8
e. Correct setting of brazing equipment 1 or 10 0.8

5. Insulation
a. Accuracy in measurements 1 or 10 0.25
b. Insulation for fittings 1 - 10 0.25
c. Waste materials 1 - 10 0.25
d. Proper cladding using polyethylene tape 1 - 10 0.25