Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Biotech Histochem Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Nyu Medical Center on 10/12/14
We describe the history of the histochemical stains that contributed most to the development of
modern pathology during the last two centuries. Histochemical stains are presented in a list, which
provides the essential information about year, country and main use of each to enable the reader
to follow the chronological and geographical history of histochemistry. In addition to the histori-
cal evaluation of histochemistry development, we investigate how many classical histochemical
stains survive in a modern laboratory of pathology and how often they are used for diagnostic
practice compared to immunohistochemical (IHC) techniques. A ratio of about one histochemical
reaction to 13 IHC reactions was tabulated. Finally, our data make it possible to define different
cultural approaches to the terminology of histochemical and IHC stains: the former were based
on eponyms, which link the stain with the name of its inventor, while the latter use a more imper-
For personal use only.
In a modern laboratory, a pathologist commonly where and when these stains were developed, it is
handles no more than 20 histochemical stains; he/ possible for the reader to follow the most important
she often prefers to use more modern immuno- steps in the history of histochemistry and to obtain
histochemical (IHC) techniques that have almost essential information about the principal uses of
replaced histochemical stains in diagnostic and these stains.
research practice. Our clarification of past practices should be
Histochemical stains have been the basis of compared with the current use of HC techniques:
modern pathology, and have supported the devel- the advent of IHC has revolutionized the approach
opment of this discipline from the second half of the modern pathologist for diagnosis of diseases.
of the 19th century until the 1960s. New genera- We investigate here how many classical histochemi-
tions of pathologists, trained during the IHC era, cal stains survive in a modern pathology laboratory
are unaware of the fundamental role played by and how often they currently are used in diagnostic
histochemistry in the progress of pathology. We practice.
describe here the histochemical stains that contrib-
uted most to the development of modern pathology Material and methods
during the last two centuries and we present them
in a list that may be useful to current students of The principal histochemical stains that have been
medicine and pathology. In addition, by analyzing used through the years for surgical pathology were
identified by perusing classic handbooks of his-
Correspondence: Fabio Pagni, Department of Pathology, tochemistry (Lillie 1954, Gurr 1962). All of the origi-
University Milano Bicocca San Gerardo Hospital, 20900 Monza, nal papers that first described each technique then
Italy. Phone: 0039 039 2332559, fax 0039 039 2332548, e-mail:
fabio.pagni@unimib.it
were identified, together with the year of publica-
© 2014 The Biological Stain Commission tion, the affiliation of the authors and the primary
Biotechnic & Histochemistry 2014, 89(2): 81–90. field of application of each histochemical stain. The
DOI:10.3109/10520295.2013.822559 81
stains were grouped according to the country where October 31, 2012) we found that the total number
they were developed, regardless of the nationality of of histological cases per year was 23,450. Figure 4
the developer (e.g., George Papanicolaou was born shows the use of histochemical stains during this
in Greece, but his stain was classified as belonging period; data are plotted on a logarithmic scale. The
to the USA group). We also indicated the major field total number of histochemical applications was
of application for each stain. We focused especially 126,431, while during the same period, IHC reac-
on hematoxylin because of its important role in tions numbered 20,954. Excluding hematoxylin-eo-
many different histochemical stains. All these data sin and Papanicolau staining that account for about
subsequently were analyzed to evaluate the number 90,000 and 30,000 reactions, respectively, and are
of eponyms that have been used for each dye. used mainly for general tissue staining and gyne-
Finally, we accessed the information system of cological smears, we found a histochemistry:IHC
the Department of Pathology of San Gerardo Hos- ratio of approximately 1:3. If we exclude the
pital, University of Milano Bicocca, Monza, Italy, to routine Giemsa stain, mainly performed to detect
obtain a list of the histochemical stains used during Helicobacter pylori in chronic gastritis specimens, the
the period from November 1, 2011 to October 31, ratio was 1:3 histochemistry:IHC.
Biotech Histochem Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Nyu Medical Center on 10/12/14
we researched hematoxylin separately (Table 2) ogy in mind. The first attempt to guarantee the
and identified another 11 variants; we gave a brief constancy and reliability of stains was made by the
description of each. We then tabulated all 80 stains German company, Grübler Co., but the real estab-
by year of discovery, first description and country. lishment of a biological dye supply industry began
In 58 of 80 cases (73%), the name of the inventor has with the creation in the USA of the “Commission on
become the most common name for the stain. Standardization of Biological Stains” in 1922 (Conn
Figure 1 lists the number of dyes discovered in 1925), currently known as the Biological Stain
each decade from the 1850s to the 2010s; there are Commission.
two peaks, one between 1890 and 1930, and the other Standardized dyes played a fundamental role
between 1950 and 1960. The first peak accounts for in the development of modern surgical pathol-
52% and the second for 25% of the histochemical ogy by helping to confirm two primary theories
stains we studied. Figure 2 reports the country in of the pathogenesis of diseases: the “theory of
which each stain was developed; the USA and Ger- membranes” postulated by Marie François Xavier
many were the most productive countries in this Bichat (1771-1802) and the “cellular pathology”
regard: 31 stains (39%) came from the US, 22 (27%) of Rudolf Virchow (1821-1902) (Zampieri 2012).
from Germany, 8 (10%) from Italy and 5 (6%) from the According to these theories, diseases are derived
UK, while the remaining stains (18%) were developed from alterations of tissues and cells, respectively.
in another eight countries (Canada, Sweden, France, The application of these theories made it possible
Spain, Hungary, Nigeria, Russia, Czech Republic). to acquire a general knowledge of the histological
Initially, Germany and other European countries and cytological features of normal and pathologi-
developed the greatest number of stains, but they cal tissues and cells. New tinctorial methods were
were overtaken by the USA during the 20th century. implemented, progressively moving from mono-
Figure 3 shows the major fields of applica- chromatic techniques, especially hematoxylin, to
tion using a radar chart that shows a prevalence two-dye sequential staining, e.g., hematoxylin-
of general (owing to primarily to hematoxylin) eosin, then to the so-called trichrome techniques,
and connective tissue stains. Neuropathology and of which the first was Mallory’s technique in 1900
hematopathology were the most productive disci- that was designed to demonstrate a wide range
plines for the development of new stains. of tissue constituents in contrasting colors (Titford
Finally, by analyzing the data from our labora- 2009). The idea of selectivity of certain chemical
tory for a one year period (November 1, 2011 to compounds for certain tissue components was
Histochemistry in pathology 83
Table 1. (continued)
Table 2. Introduction of new hematoxylin stains listed in chronological order; place of introduction, the mordanting metal
ion and comments on use are given also
Bohmer (Bohmer 1865) 1865 Germany Aluminum The first hematoxylin described
Heidenhain (Heidanhain 1885) 1885 Germany Iron Cytological stain for thin sections, to achieve
better detail. It stains tissues black and gray,
For personal use only.
Fig. 1. Time course of introductions of new histochemical stains as listed in Tables 1 and 2. Numbers per decade are
noted on the chart.
the basis of not only modern pathology, but also this field and a Nobel Prize winner in medicine
modern pharmacology and chemotherapy. For in 1908, developed the use of some dyes in this
example, Paul Ehrlich (1854-1915), a pioneer in direction; he used methylene blue and trypan red
For personal use only.
Fig. 2. Illustration of geographical locations in which new histochemical stains as listed in Tables 1 and 2 were devised
and first used.
Histochemistry in pathology 85
Biotech Histochem Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Nyu Medical Center on 10/12/14
Fig. 3. Major fields of application of the 80 stains listed in Tables 1 and 2, presented as a radar chart.
to treat malaria and trypanosomiasis, respectively that hematological stains (Romanowsky and its
(Coleman 2006). variants, Giemsa, Wright and May-Grunwald)
The period between the 1880s and 1930s marked were developed initially for studying infectious
the birth and early development of histochemistry. diseases, particularly for detecting malaria infected
Geographically, development occurred primarily blood cells (Barcia 2007, Krafts and Pambuccian
For personal use only.
in Germany. In the USA, microscopists initially 2011, Dolan 2011, Dunning and Safo 2011). More
employed natural dyes such as carmine, indigo, specific methods were implemented mainly in the
alizarin and hematoxylin, but they also used the field of neuropathology (Nissl 1894, Bielschowsky
first synthetic pigments such as eosin and Prussian 1902, Rio-Hortega 1917, Holzer 1921, Weil 1928)
blue (Coleman 2006). These early histochemical for studying connective tissue with Azan-Mallory
techniques were directed mainly toward identifying (Heidenhain 1915) and trichrome staining tech-
single components of tissues: iron (Perls 1867), lip- niques (Masson 1929), and for identifying specific
ids with Sudan III (Daddi 1896), mucus with muci- components of tissues, e.g., lipids with oil red O
carmine (Mayer 1896), calcium (von Kossa 1901), (French 1926), nucleic acids (Feulgen 1914), amy-
mycobacteria (Ziehl 1882, Neelsen 1883), spirocheta loid with Congo red (Bennhold 1922), melanin with
(Whartin and Chronister 1920) and Gram-positive Masson-Fontana (Fontana 1912) and bile (Fouchet
bacteria with Brown-Brenn’s stain (Brown and Brenn 1917). The first description of the Papanicolau
1931). Considering the prevalence of infectious dis- method (Papanicolau 1928), the basis of modern
eases during that period, it is worth recalling cytopathology, also belongs to this period.
Fig. 4. Use of histochemical stains from November 1, 2011 to October 31, 2012 in the Dept. of Pathology, San Gerado
Hospital, Monza, Italy.
From the 1940s onward, relatively few significant ing technique. This transition occurred during the
histochemical staining techniques emerged. Some second part of the last century, when there was a
fundamental stains, however, such as the trichrome shift from a morphologically based approach to a
method (Gomori 1939) for endocrine granules and functionally based approach.
the periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) technique (Hotchkiss The invention of IHC techniques belongs to the
1948) for mucus, were developed during the period. early forties when Coons first described the “immu-
The definition of the classic globules of mucus in the nological properties of antibodies containing a fluo-
“signet-ring cells” of gastric carcinoma produced by rescent group” (Coons et al. 1941). In more recent
PAS staining, which has become an essential diag- years, not only IHC techniques, but also the grow-
nostic tool for this tumor, is still used today. ing involvement of molecular biology in diagnosis
For personal use only.
The second peak period produced some clas- has accelerated the decline of histochemical stains.
sic histochemical stains for myelin (Kluver and IHC techniques therefore provide what we may
Barrera 1953), mycetes (Grocott 1955), mucin with define as a functional stain that enables quantifica-
Alcian blue PAS stain (Mowry 1963), neurosecretory tion of cell activity that was impossible before its
tumors (Grimelius 1968), as well as the majority development.
of myopathology histo-enzymatic stains includ- Before the introduction of IHC, a pathologist
ing naphthol ASD acetate esterase (Gomori 1953), was considered a morphologist of tissues and
ATPase (Padykula and Herman 1965) and succinate cells, and his/her devotion to this field reached its
dehydrogenase (Lojda 1965). height in the search for a more perfect hematoxylin
During the 1980s, the use of histochemical stains stain (Coons et al. 1941, Allison 1999, Titford 2005,
began to decline owing to the revolutionary devel- Avwioro 2011). This stain became so important
opment of IHC. Only a few histochemical stains for surgical pathology that it maintains the role of
still are used; the easy to use stains are especially “queen of stains” also during the IHC era. We identi-
favored. Most of the special histochemical stains fied 11 formulations, most of which originated from
that had mainly a descriptive goal or required dif- US, German and Italian investigators, but interest in
ficult interpretations were largely abandoned. By this dye has never disappeared; the latest contribu-
our analysis, 13 IHC stains are used for every one tion came from two Nigerian authors (Iyiola and
histochemical stain. Generalizing from the results Avwioro 2011).
of the activity in our department (curiously, the
founder of our hospital, St. Gerard, was a member
Conflict of interest statement. The authors declare
of a 12th century wealthy family of dyers) (Riva
no conflict of interest with regard to the contents of
and Cesana 2012), we can suggest that a few dyes
this paper.
(hematoxylin-eosin, Papanicolau, and Giemsa)
still are widely used because of their role as gen-
eral staining methods. Reticulin, Perls, azan, PAS/ References
PAS-D, and Ziehl-Neelsen survive in pathology
departments for evaluating bone marrow fibrosis, Allison RT (1999) Haematoxylin from the wood. J. Clin.
iron deposits, liver biopsy fibrosis, mucopolysac- Pathol. 52: 527–528.
charides and mycobacteria, respectively. Others Avwioro G (2011) Histochemical uses of haematoxylin: a
(Grocott, Orcein, mucicarmine, Congo red) are review. J. Pharm. Clin. Sci. 1: 24–34.
Histochemistry in pathology 87
Barcia JJ (2007) The Giemsa stain: its history and applica- Fontana A (1912) Verfahren zur intensiver und raschenFär-
tions. Int. J. Surg. Pathol. 15: 292–296. bung des Treponema pallidum und anderer Spirochäten
Bennhold H (1922) Eine spezifische amyloidfarbung mit [A method for rapid and intense staining of Treponema
Kongorot [Specific staining of amyloid with Congo red]. pallidum and other spirochetes]. Derm. Wochnsch. 55:
Munch. Med. Wochensch. 69: 1537–1538. 1003–1004.
Bielschowsky M (1902) Silberimprägnation der Achsen- Fouchet A (1917) Méthode nouvelle de recherche et de
cylinder [The silver impregnation of axis cylinder]. dosage des pigments biliaires dans le sérum sanguin
Neurol. Zblatt. 21: 579–584. [New method of testing and determination of bile pig-
Bodian DA (1936) A new method for staining nerve fibers ments in the blood serum]. C. R. Soc. Biol. 80: 826–828.
and nerve endings in mounted paraffin sections. Anat. French RW (1926) Notes on technic: fat stains. Stain Tech-
Rec. 65: 89–97. nol. 1: 78.
Böhmer F (1865) Zur pathologischen Anatomie der Giemsa G (1902) Farbenmethoden fur Malariaparasiten
Meningitis cerebromedularis epidemica [On the anatomic [Staining methods for malaria parasites]. Zentralbl. Bakte-
pathology of epidemic cerebromedularis meningitis]. riol. 31: 429–430.
Aerztl. Intelligenzb. 12: 539–550. Gill GW, Frost JK, Miller KA (1974) A new formula
Brown JH, Brenn L (1931) A method for the differential for a half-oxidised haematoxylin solution that neither
Biotech Histochem Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Nyu Medical Center on 10/12/14
staining of Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria in overstains nor requires differentiation. Acta Cytol. 18:
tissue sections. Bull. Johns Hopkins Hosp. 48: 69–73. 300–311.
Brown RC, Hopps HC (1973) Staining of bacteria in tissue Goldner J (1983) A modification of the Masson trichrome
sections: a reliable gram stain method. Am. J. Clin. Pathol. technique for routine laboratory purposes. Am. J. Pathol.
60: 234–240. 14: 237–243.
Cajal SR (1913) Un nuevo proceder para la impregnación Golgi C (1873) Sulla struttura della sostanza grigia del
del la Neuroglia [A new procedure for impregnation of cervello (Comunicazione preventiva). [On the structure of
neuroglia]. Bol. Soc. Esp. Biol. 2: 104–108. the gray matter of the brain (First communication)]. Gazz.
Carazzi D (1911) Eine neue Hämatoxylinlbsung [A new Med. Ital. Lomb. 33: 244–246.
haematoxyin]. Z. Wiss. Mikr. 28: 273–274. Gomori G (1939) A differential stain for cell types in the
Cole EC (1943) Studies on haematoxylin stains. Stain pancreatic islets. Am. J. Pathol. 15: 497–499.
For personal use only.
Krafts KP, Pambuccian SE (2011) Romanowsky staining fur Blutpraparate [Panoptic universal staining for blood
in cytopathology: history, advantages and limitations. preparations]. Med. Klein. 4: 12–44.
Biotech. & Histochem. 86: 82–93. Perls M (1867) Nachweis von Eisenoxyd in gewissen
Kurnick NB, Ris H (1948) A new stain mixture; aceto- Pigmenten [Detection of iron oxide in some pigments].
orcein-fast-green. Stain Technol. 23: 17. Virchow’s Arch. Pathol. Anat. Phsiol. Klin. Med. 39:
Kurnick NB (1950) Methyl green-pyronin; basis of 42–48.
selective staining of nucleic acids. J. Gen. Physiol. 33: Rio-Hortega P (1917) Noticia de un nuevo y facil metodo
243–264. para la coloración de la neuroglia y del tejido conjuntivo
Leishman W (1901) Note on a simple and rapid method [Notice of a new and easy method for staining of neuro-
of producing Romanowsky staining in malarial and other glia and connective tissue]. Trab. del lab. de inv. biol. de la
blood films. Br. Med. J. 2: 757–758. Univ. de Madrid 15: 367–378.
For personal use only.
Lieberkuhn N (1864) Über Knochenwachstum [On bone Riva MA, Cesana G (2013) The charity and the care: the
growth]. Arch. Anat. Physiol. Wiss. Med. 31: 598–613. origin and the evolution of hospitals. Eur. J. Int. Med. 24:
Lillie DR (1954) Histopathologic Technic and Practical His- 1–4.
tochemistry. The Blakiston Co., New York. Romanowsky D (1891) Zur Frage der Parasitologie und
Lison L (1934) Sur des nouveaux colorants histologiques Therapie der Malaria [On the problem of Parasitology
spécifiques des lipides [On new histological stains spe- and Therapy of Malaria]. St. Petersburg Med. Wochenschr.
cific for lipids]. C.R. Soc. Biol. 115: 202–205. 16: 297–302.
Lojda Z (1965) Remarks on histochemical demonstration Rosen G (1993) A History of Public Health. Johns Hopkins
of dehydrogenase II. Fol. Morphol. 13: 84–96. University Press. Baltimore.
Mallory FB (1900) A contribution to staining methods. Schmorl G (1928) Die pathologisch-histologischen Unter-
J. Exp. Med. 5: 15–20. suchungsmethoden [The pathological and histological
Marinozzi V (1961) Impregnazione argentica delle sezioni examination methods]. FCW Vogel. Leipzig.
ultrasottili per la microscopia elettronica [Silver impreg- Schoenberg DG, Schoenberg BS (1979) Eponym: the
nation of ultra-thin sections for electron microscopy]. stain in the brain: Golgi, Cajal, Nissl, and Weigert. South.
Rend. Ist. Sup. Sanit. 24: 558–566. Med. J. 72: 44–46.
Masson PJ (1929) Some histological methods: trichrome Sevier AC, Munger BL (1965) Technical note: a silver
stainings and their preliminary technique. J. Tech. Methods method for paraffin sections of neural tissue. J. Neuropathol.
12: 75–90. Exp. Neurol. 24: 130–135.
May R, Grünwald L (1902) Über Blutfärbungen [On Spicer SS (1965) Diamine methods for differentiating
Blood Stains]. Zentbl. Inn. Med. 23: 265–270. mucosubstances histochemically. J. Histochem. Cytochem.
Mayer P (1891) Ueber das Färben mit Hämatoxylin [On 18: 211.
staining with haematoxyin]. Mitt. Zool. Stat. Neapel. 10: Steedman HF (1950) Alcian blue 8GS: a new stain for
170–186. mucin. Q. J. Microsc. Sci. 91: 477–479.
Mayer P (1896) Uber schleimfarbung [On mucus stain- Sweat F, Puchtler H, Rosenthal SI (1964) Sirius red F3BA
ing]. Mitt. Zool. Stat. Neapel. 12: 303. as stain for connective tissue. Arch. Pathol. 78: 69–72.
Michaelis L (1901) Ueber Fett-Farsbstoffe [On fat dyes]. Titford M (2005) The long history of haematoxyin. Bio-
Arch. Pathol. Anat. 16F-IV: 263. tech. & Histochem. 80: 73–78.
Movat HZ (1955) Demonstration of all connective tissue Titford M (2009) Progress in the development of micro-
elements in a single section; pentachrome stains. AMA scopical techniques for diagnostic pathology. J. Histotech-
Arch. Pathol. 60: 289–295. nol. 32: 9–19.
Mowry RW (1963) The special value of methods that color Truant JP, Brett WA, Thomas W (1962) Fluorescence
both acidic and vicinal hydroxyl groups in the histochem- microscopy of tubercle bacilli stained with Auramine and
ical study of mucins. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 106: 402–423. Rhodamine. Henry Ford Hosp. Med. Bull. 10: 287–296.
Histochemistry in pathology 89
van Gieson (1889) Laboratory notes of technical methods Weigert C (1904) Eine Kleine Verbesserung der haematox-
for the nervous system. NY Med. J. 50: 57–60. ylin-van Gieson-Methode [A small improvement in the
Vassar PS, Culling CF (1959) A Fluorescent stains with van Gieson’s haematoxylin method]. Z. Wiss. Mikrosk. 21:
special reference to amyloid and connective tissues. Arch. 1–5.
Pathol. 68: 487–494. Weil A (1928) A rapid method for staining myelin sheaths.
Verhoeff FH (1908) Some new staining methods of wide Arch. Neurol. Psych. 20: 3923.
applicability. Including a rapid differential stain for elastic Wissowzky A (1876) Ueber das Eosin als reagenz auf
tissue. JAMA 50: 876–877. Hämoglobin und die Bildung von Blutgefässen und
von Gerlach J (1858) Mikroskopische Studien aus dem Gebi- Blutkörperchen bei Säugetier und Hühnerembryonen
ete der menschlichen Morphologie [Microscopic studies in the [On eosin as reagent for hemoglobin and on the formation
field of human morphology]. Ferdinand Enke, Erlangen. of blood vessels and blood cells in mammals and chicken
von Kossa J (1901) Ueber die im Organismus kunstlich embryos]. Arch. Mikrosk. Anat. 13: 479–496.
erzeugbaren Verkalkungen. [On artificially produced cal- Wright JH (1902) A rapid method for the differential
cifications in the organism]. Zieg. Beitr. Pathol. Anat. 29: staining of blood films and malarial parasites. J. Med. Res.
163–202. 7: 138–144.
Warthin AS, Chronister AC (1920) A more rapid and Zampieri F (2012) Da Morgagni alla Patologia Molecolare.
Biotech Histochem Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Nyu Medical Center on 10/12/14
improved method of demonstrating spirochetes in tissues Teorie e Modelli dell’Anatomia Patologica [From Morgagni
Warthin and Starry’s cover-glass method. Am. J. Syph. 4: to the molecular pathology. Theories and models of Ana-
97–103. tomic pathology]. Libraria Padovana Editrice. Padova.
Weigert C (1898) Ueber ein zur Farbung elastischer Fasern Ziehl F (1882) Zur Färbung des Tuberkelbacillus [Stain-
[On staining elastic fibers]. Centbl. Allge. Pathol. Anat. 9: ing the tubercle bacillus]. Deut. Med. Wochensch. 8:
289–292. 451–452.
For personal use only.