Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Osteochondroses
Franklin Danger, MD1 Christopher Wasyliw, MD2 Laura Varich, MD3
1 Department of Radiology, Florida Hospital, Orlando, Florida Address for correspondence Laura Varich, MD, Division of Pediatric
2 Division of Musculoskeletal Imaging, Department of Radiology, Imaging, Department of Radiology, Florida Hospital, 601 E. Rollins
Florida Hospital, Orlando, Florida Street, Orlando, FL 32803 (e-mail: Laura.Varich.MD@flhosp.org).
3 Division of Pediatric Imaging, Department of Radiology, Florida
Hospital, Orlando, Florida
Abstract The osteochondroses are a group of disorders that affect the epiphysis or epiphyseal
equivalent segments of the immature skeleton. These disorders are believed to be
primarily the result of traumatic or vascular pathology, often in the setting of overuse,
Keywords and are usually self-limited. Their imaging findings are based on the time of the study
► osteochondrosis within the natural course of the disease process. Early findings may best be demon-
The disorders classified as osteochondroses may at first seem a small segment of the chondro-osseous junction at the
a heterogeneous group of loosely related disorders, but the articular surface of the epiphysis, and more commonly result
conditions have much commonality. Osteochondroses affect in significant or long-term sequelae.
the immature skeleton, follow similar natural courses, have The osteochondroses affect epiphyses or epiphyseal
similar imaging findings, are most often treated conserva- equivalents (apophyses, carpal, and tarsal bones) in specific
tively, and end with self-limited disease progression that locations. Individual sites of osteochondroses were described
halts at skeletal maturity. Differences in the disorders are in the early 1900s, soon after Roentgen’s discovery of radio-
based on affected sites and potential etiologic factors. graph technology,1 and each is named after its discoverer(s).
Differing terminology and classification within the litera- The lesions that involve apophyses are believed to be trau-
ture continue to confuse the discussion of osteochondroses. matic in origin, related to asymmetric growth of the osseous
The terms “osteochondrosis,” “osteochondritis,” and “apo- and myotendinous structures resulting in traction injury,2
physitis” are often used interchangeably, and this lack of and pathologic microtears and other evidence of trauma
semantic uniformity can be problematic. In addition, there is have been identified.2 The etiology of the epiphyseal lesions
inconsistent inclusion of various osteonecrotic entities with is more highly debated, with one or multiple contributing
heterogeneity in age of onset, clinical progression, and factors including endocrine, genetic, traumatic, and vascular
prognoses. This article uses only the term “osteochondroses” causes as well as rapid growth.3
in discussing the conditions that meet the general criteria Patients with osteochondroses present in childhood or
presented in the previous paragraph and does not include adolescence with pain and disability.4 In general, the osteo-
progressive osteonecrosis that occurs in adulthood (such as chondroses affect boys more frequently than girls, likely due
Kienböck’s disease) or lesions of osteochondritis desiccans to increased exposure to trauma and overuse injuries.4
(OCD). Differentiation between the osteochondroses and The imaging findings identified in patients with osteochon-
OCD is critical because the osteochondroses appear at a droses vary depending on the stage of pathology at the time of
younger age, involve the entirety of the epiphysis or apo- imaging. The initial pathologic stage involves necrosis of bone
physis, and are self-limited, rarely requiring surgical treat- and cartilage, followed by revascularization and granulation
ment. In contrast, OCD lesions present at an older age, involve tissue formation. Next, osteoclast resorption of necrotic tissue
Issue Theme Pediatric Musculoskeletal Copyright © 2018 by Thieme Medical DOI https://doi.org/
Imaging; Guest Editors, Ramesh S. Iyer, Publishers, Inc., 333 Seventh Avenue, 10.1055/s-0038-1627094.
MD and Matthew Cody O’Dell, MD, MPH New York, NY 10001, USA. ISSN 1089-7860.
Tel: +1(212) 584-4662.
Osteochondroses Danger et al. 119
and subsequent osteoid replacement with formation of repetitive trauma with imaging abnormality noted anterolat-
mature lamellar bone occurs.3 Much of our understanding of erally at the articular surface. In OCD, the disease is progressive
the pathologic process of osteochondroses comes from the with findings of sclerosis, focal lucency, flattening, and intra-
study of Legg-Calvé-Perthes disease (LCP). As the osteochon- articular bodies.7 Additionally, surgery is a common treatment
drosis most frequently imaged, LCP has been extensively for OCD, in contradistinction to Panner disease.
characterized in the radiologic literature, allowing this specific Symptoms of Panner disease are usually mild, with lateral
condition to serve as a guide to the imaging stages of osteo- pain and limited extension of the elbow the most common
chondroses in general. Evolution of the disease process is most complaints.2 In Panner disease patients, the entire ossifica-
often evaluated by radiographs or magnetic resonance ima- tion center may show evidence of fissuring, lucency, frag-
ging (MRI). In the early stages of the osteonecrosis, radiographs mentation, and change in countour4,7 by radiography
may demonstrate abnormal sclerosis; however, radiographs (►Fig. 1a). MR imaging often demonstrates heterogeneous
may also appear normal, in which case the pathology may be signal intensity related to a combination of sclerosis and
better detected by MRI. The weakened necrotic bone, if sub- edema (►Figs. 1b, c). Panner disease is a self-limited process,
jected to stress, will then undergo fragmentation and collapse. and complete healing usually results following rest and
Later disease stages will demonstrate evidence of healing with conservative management.
revascularization noted on MRI,5 followed by remodeling of
bone architecture, variable reconstitution of the normal mor-
Scheuermann Disease
phology, and return to normal MR signal intensity.5
In many patients with osteochondroses, symptoms resolve In Scheuermann disease, osteonecrosis of the thoracic spine
Fig. 1 A 7-year-old male basketball player with Panner disease. (a) Frontal radiograph of the elbow demonstrates fragmentation and sclerosis of
the capitellum (arrow). (b) Coronal T1-weighted and (c) T2-weighted MRI images demonstrate bone marrow edema (low signal intensity on T1
and high signal intensity on T2) (arrowheads) intermixed with areas of sclerosis (very low signal intensity on both sequences) within the
capitellum (arrows). (Images courtesy of Dr. Cody O’Dell.)
Sinding-Larsen-Johansson and Osgood- tendon and edema of the fat superficial and deep to the
Schlatter Diseases patellar tendon (►Fig. 4a, c). MRI may reveal thickening and
edema of the patellar tendon, infrapatellar bursitis, and
Sinding-Larsen-Johansson (SLJ) and Osgood-Schlatter (OS) anterior soft tissue swelling26 (►Fig. 4b, d). Prognosis for
diseases are grouped together here because both represent both OS and SLJ patients is excellent because both conditions
overuse injuries that affect the incompletely ossified struc- are self-limited. Conservative management is standard,
tures at both the origin and the insertion of the patellar involving a combination of rest, ice, analgesics, and flexibility
tendon. Both processes affect boys more commonly with OS exercises. In the rare patient in whom intratendinous bone
disease predominantly presenting between 10 and 15 years fragments persist adjacent to the tibial tubercle after skeletal
of age; SLJ presents at 9 to13 years.26 maturity (►Fig. 4e), surgical excision of the ossicles may be
Traction on the patellar tendon results in microtears at the required.2
insertions on the inferior patella and tibial tubercle causing
small avulsions of the cartilaginous attachments.27 The avulsed
Kohler Disease
cartilage fragments may ossify, and heterotopic ossification
may develop in the region of microtears.27 Patients with both Kohler disease affects the tarsal navicular, is more common
conditions present with anterior knee pain worsened by run- in boys, and usually is diagnosed between 2 and 8 years of
ning or jumping.26 Point tenderness may be elicited over the age.4 Kohler disease is unilateral in 75% of cases.3 Of note,
inferior pole of the patella (SLJ) or tibial tubercle (OS). similar findings of sclerosis and collapse can be seen in
Radiographic findings include a fragmented appearance asymptomatic individuals, and thus the disease process
of the tibial tubercle (OS) or inferior pole of the patella (SLJ), may be radiographically indistinguishable from the normal
with thickening of the proximal (SLJ) or distal (OS) patellar variant appearance.
Sever Disease
Sever disease involves the calcaneal apophysis and results
from repeated Achilles tendon traction2 or from compression Fig. 5 A 6-year-old male soccer player with Kohler disease. Lateral
from axial loading.29 Typically bilateral and asymmetric,2 radiograph of the foot demonstrates sclerosis and flattening of the
tarsal navicular (arrow).
Fig. 6 A 12-year-old female gymnast with Sever disease. (a) Lateral radiograph demonstrates sclerosis of the calcaneal apophysis (arrowheads).
(b) Sagittal MRI in the same patient demonstrates increased T2 signal intensity within the apophysis (arrowheads) and fluid signal intensity
within the physis (arrow) consistent with edema.
Sever disease affects adolescents 12 to 15 years of age. High may be helpful in demonstrating edema of the calcaneal
Fig. 7 A 15-year-old female runner with Freiberg disease. (a) Oblique radiograph demonstrates flattening and irregularity of the second
metatarsal (MT) head (arrowhead). (b) Computed tomography scan in the same patient obtained 2 years later shows further flattening and
fragmentation of the MT head (arrows).
a significant female predominance. The etiology is likely 12 Murray PM, Weinstein SL, Spratt KF. The natural history and long-
multifactorial, with trauma, vascular insufficiency, genetic term follow-up of Scheuermann kyphosis. J Bone Joint Surg Am
predisposition, and altered biomechanics as proposed causes 1993;75(02):236–248
13 Ristolainen L, Kettunen JA, Heliövaara M, Kujala UM, Heinonen A,
of the disease.32 Freiberg disease affects the second and third
Schlenzka D. Untreated Scheuermann’s disease: a 37-year follow-
metatarsal heads most commonly; involvement of the fourth up study. Eur Spine J 2012;21(05):819–824
and fifth metatarsals is rare.32 The disease process is classically 14 Graat HC, Schimmel JJ, Hoogendoorn RJ, van Hessem L, Hosman A,
unilateral, but bilateral disease is identified in up to 10% of de Kleuver M. Poor radiological and good functional long-term
cases.4 outcome of surgically treated Scheuermann patients. Spine 2016;
41(14):E869–E878
Clinical findings in Freiberg disease include localized
15 Barker DJ, Hall AJ. The epidemiology of Perthes’ disease. Clin
pain worsened by weight-bearing, point tenderness, and
Orthop Relat Res 1986;(209):89–94
swelling.4 16 Jaramillo D. What is the optimal imaging of osteonecrosis,
Early findings may include widening of the metatarsopha- Perthes, and bone infarcts? Pediatr Radiol 2009;39(Suppl 2):
langeal joint. However, such findings may be absent on plain S216–S219
radiography, and MRI may therefore be more sensitive for 17 Shah H. Perthes disease: evaluation and management. Orthop
Clin North Am 2014;45(01):87–97
diagnosis early on, demonstrating hypointensity of marrow
18 Gill KG. Pediatric hip: pearls and pitfalls. Semin Musculoskelet
on T1-weighted images, and either low or high signal intensity Radiol 2013;17(03):328–338
on T2-weighted or short tau inversion recovery sequences.28 19 Dillman JR, Hernandez RJ. MRI of Legg-Calve-Perthes disease. AJR
Surrounding soft tissue edema may also be demonstrated by Am J Roentgenol 2009;193(05):1394–1407
MRI. Later in the pathologic process, cortical irregularity, frag- 20 Malizos KN, Karantanas AH, Varitimidis SE, Dailiana ZH, Bargiotas