Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TALENT ACQUISITION
WITH
COMPETENCY ANALYSIS
IN
BY
MAYURI MANDAR LOTLIKAR
ROLL NO. 2020086
MMS-II (SEM-III)
YEAR 2020-2022
The project was completed for “XYZ” under the guidance of ABC
I further that the said work has not been submitted in the part
or in full, to any other university.
Date:
DECLARATION
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
At the outset of this project, I would like to express my profound thanks to a few
people without whose help, completion of this project would not have been
possible.
First and foremost, I would like to express sincere thanks to XYZ for giving me
this opportunity to work with them.
The list is endless but to name a few special people, I would like to thank
Dhananjay Kataria for being extremely supportive and guiding me throughout my
internship and giving me constant motivation and expert advice.
I would also like to thank the entire HR Department for providing me their
precious time and making this internship a successful learning experience.
I would also like to thank Prof. ABCfor being an excellent mentor and helping me
whenever I approached him/her.
Last but not the least; I take pride in thanking my parents Mr. Mandar Lotlikar &
Mrs Neha Mandar Lotlikar, siblings and friends for their much-valued support.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Human Resources are the most important assets of an organization. The success or
failure of an organization is largely dependent on the calibre of the people working therein.
Without positive and creative contributions from people, organizations cannot progress and
prosper. In order to achieve the goals or the activities of an organization, therefore, they need to
recruit people with requisite skills, qualifications and experience. While doing so, they have to
keep the present as well as the future requirements of the organization in mind.
Recruitment is defined as, “a process to discover the sources of manpower to meet the
requirements of the staffing schedule and to employ effective measures for attracting that
manpower in adequate numbers to facilitate effective selection of an efficient workforce.” In
order to attract people for the jobs, the organization must communicate the position in such a way
that job seekers respond. To be cost effective, the recruitment process should attract
qualified applicants and provide enough information for unqualified persons to self-select
themselves out.
Talent Acquisition’s will work from resumes or by actively soliciting individuals
qualified for positions. A TA's job includes reviewing candidate's job experiences, negotiating
salaries, and placing candidates in agreeable employment positions. Competency-Based
Assessment is arguably one of the most popular talent acquisition processes where the four
pillars of success of any applicant – ability, skill, potential, and performance are judged on the
same page.
Identifying competencies is one of the best tools that can effectively predict performance
enablers and helps an organization to manage talent, customize development intervention at a
mass level, and articulate a unified, scientifically valid understanding of high potential talent
pool. When a competency management framework is in place, the valuable data gained can give
leadership a basis for strategic decision making. With the ability to track, measure, and evaluate
each individual’s competencies, your company can take inventory of your current workforce and
make informed decisions about recruitment next steps. The purpose of this paper is to explore the
utility of an organization-wide competency framework, linking competency ratings at selection
to later development needs and job performance.
INDEX
1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.2 Objectives 11
5.3 Findings 60
6 CONCLUSION 61
7 RECOMMENDATIONS 62
8 ANNEXURE 63
9 BIBLIOGRAPHY 66
1. INTRODUCTION
1
What Is Talent Acquisition for a Future-Focused Company?
Talent acquisition is defined as the process of developing a full-fledged strategy to attract and
recruit top talent. It’s important to note that talent acquisition and recruitment aren’t
synonymous. Recruitment is just one aspect of talent acquisition, that has to do with the selection
and hiring of a candidate to fit a job vacancy. Talent acquisition, on the other hand, has a far
broader ambit.
The definition of talent acquisition spans employer branding, recruitment marketing, the process
of recruitment itself, which includes candidate relationship management, an onboarding plan
that involves succession planning and talent development, and continuous strategic alignment
with C-level goals.
The entire recruiting and talent acquisition process is undergoing a major upheaval with the
changing preferences of the young workforce and the rising demand for cutting-edge skills – for
example, cloud competencies, digital marketing, or artificial intelligence (AI). And proving this
is the 2019 State of Talent Acquisition Report by Mettl reveals that 74% of companies surveyed
are still struggling to hire top talent.
2
An essential best practice for talent acquisition managers today is to treat candidates like
consumers. In other words, lessons from digital marketing can be instrumental when looking to
build a robust talent acquisition function. Let’s explore the talent acquisition process in this
context.
1. Inbound marketing
As a talent acquisition manager, the goal is to attract the best talent out there without actively
seeking them out. This means building a strong employer brand, initiating recruitment marketing
campaigns, and keeping an eye on inbound leads that will soon convert into hired employees.
To enable inbound recruiting in the talent acquisition process, create a smart recruitment website,
encourage referrals, and leverage candidate-focused content to create an “employer brand”
narrative.
3
2. Outbound marketing
Any successful brand leverages a smart mix of inbound and outbound marketing to acquire
consumers. So, it should be looking at social channels, paid job ads, and automated email
campaigns to advertise for a job post actively. Use this step to ramp up the recruitment efforts
with intelligent job descriptions. Together, inbound and outbound initiatives will generate many
“leads” or applicants.
At this stage, talent acquisition diverges from regular marketing. We aren’t looking to hire just
anyone who wants to join the company. We verify, screen, and assess a candidate’s performance
against various parameters. This includes:
Culture is probably the most important for organizations now. For example, if the organization
prioritizes regular work hours and physical attendance, a candidate with a history of remote
working and flexible operations may not be a good fit, even though they bring the desired skill
set to the table.
4
The first three steps in the talent acquisition process lead to “converting” the applicant into a
finalized hire. This is where the individual recruiter takes charge of the candidate experience and
the candidate journey and negotiates salary, benefits, and other expectations.
However, if the talent acquisition strategy has helped in creating an attractive employer brand
that’s in sync with the applicant’s professional targets, the applicant-to-recruit ratio will remain
high.
A talent acquisition strategy also accounts for a strategic onboarding process, though this process
is carried out by HR and immediate managers. The onboarding process involves preliminary
training and continuous reviews for the first few weeks.
5. Continuous improvement
This is probably the most critical step of the process, ensuring the talent acquisition mechanism
becomes more effective with every recruitment cycle. A recent Jobvite study found that 30% of
new hires leave within 90 days of joining a company!
This means that regular reviews are necessary for this critical early period to sustain engagement.
Also, the feedback gathered from “converted” applicants can offer insights into how to improve
the hiring experience.
These five steps make up the talent acquisition process. Remember, this is a cyclical function –
by its very definition, talent acquisition continues even if there are no open vacancies. Inbound
marketing, brand building, and data reviews are ongoing processes that lead to the hiring of
quality talent.
5
Once you’ve read this definitive guide on what is talent acquisition, it’s clear that manual efforts
aren’t enough. For example, key steps such as inbound and outbound marketing, data extraction,
technical skill assessment, and recruitment marketing could be made far simpler with the timely
intervention of intelligent technologies.
Fortunately, there are several solutions out there that help to simplify the entire talent acquisition
process, with the timely intervention of technology and a flexible SaaS model. So, as we look at
standing out in a tight labour market and attract the brightest talent, remember that the definition
of talent acquisition is unique and perfectly fluid to meet the requirements of the organization.
What’s required is a razor-sharp focus on individual necessities, coupled with a regular check-in
on the latest winning ideas to arrive at a solution that is up to date, individualized, and effective.
Competencies are nothing but a combination of skills and attributes that determine how well the
potential employees are positioned to succeed in their jobs within the organization. Competencies
can broadly be broken down into two components:
6
1. Skills, knowledge, and qualifications
2. Behavioural characteristics and personality traits
Competency-based recruitment is a very simple concept that involves hiring candidates that are
not only the most qualified for the position you’re trying to fill, but who have a proven track
record of achieving optimal and outstanding results in their given field of interest. These are
candidates who can actually prove that their work efforts have made a substantial difference in
serving the best interests of their past employers. Competency-based recruitment approaches
generally rely on a series of assessments that are designed to help prospective employers and
recruiters identify candidates who possess valuable skills, training, experience, and response
mechanisms that can help them deal with the everyday tasks the specified position requires. It’s
meant to help level the playing field for applicants while also helping job recruiters weed out the
unlikely candidates in favour of those who are more deserving of, and qualified for, the job in
question.
There are several advantages to competency-based hiring. Here are five reasons why
competency-based hiring is necessary for successful talent acquisition:
7
3. Thrive in an uncertain environment: We live in a VUCA world where
vulnerability, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity threaten business longevity. By
implementing a competency-based approach to recruiting, it can leverage the
employees’ skills and talent in times of uncertainty or unanticipated change. Since
competencies are readily transferable across work situations, competency-based
hiring can help the organization function effectively even during a crisis.
Greater value in recruitment process by making it easier for you to choose the best
candidates for the position
Create a more consistent and focused hiring model that highlights the pros and cons
each candidate has to offer
8
Eliminates biases from one candidate to another and allows you to make a fair and
carefully considered decision based on the person’s personal and professional
attributes
Reduces the chances of having negative employee turnaround rates by guaranteeing
that only the right people are hired for each position
Provides top notch platforms and standards for companies to receive and react to
constructive feedback from potential candidates
Improves and supports the predictive hiring model which allows employers to
effectively make decisions about what they expect from potential candidates based on
the performance of past employees who occupied that role within the company.
Now that we’ve established what competencies are and their components, here are three ways to
identify candidates’ core competencies in the hiring process:
The way we look at talent is gradually changing and a competency-based approach to hiring can
helped us get up to speed in these changing times. We’re hiring for roles that came into existence
a little less than five years ago. As technologies transform business models, the rate of disruption
will only accelerate, which makes it crucial for organizations to focus on what really matters –
their talent. And identifying the core competencies that will drive the competitive advantage in
the years to come should be a significant part of the growth strategy.
Regardless of the size of the organization or business vertical, competency-based hiring is the
answer to getting the right people with the right capabilities to further the organization’s growth
in a hyper-competitive business environment.
1.2. OBJECTIVES
The hiring decision assesses three components: knowledge, skills and competencies. Candidates
must possess professional knowledge and institutional knowledge to perform on the job, and they
must have the functional and technical skills required of the role.
One component runs the risk of getting overlooked, due to the difficulty talent acquisition
professionals have faced in identifying and measuring it: competencies, the attitudes and
behaviour patterns that form the foundation for how well the candidate will use their knowledge
and skills to do the job.
Competency based systems can be integrated throughout the various cycles of the recruitment
and selection process. The benefits range from eliminating bias in the hiring process to decreased
employee turnover rates. Competency based recruitment and selection systems are empowering
recruiters and hiring managers with the information needed to make smarter hiring decisions.
RESEARCH is a careful investigation or inquiry especially through search for new facts in any
branch of knowledge. The project is a systematic presentation consisting of the enunciated
problem, formulated
11
hypothesis, collected facts of data, analysed facts and proposed conclusions in form of
recommendations. Here the research methodology for the study including the research design,
target population and sample design will be taken into consideration. In addition, data collection
instruments and procedures as well as the data analysis are elaborated in this sub chapter.
Exploratory mixed methods design has been used in the current study via combining the
qualitative and quantitative methods. This kind of research has the primary objective of
development of insights into the problem. It studies the main area where the problem lies and
also tries to evaluate some appropriate courses of action.
First, the researcher explored the research topic qualitatively with limited participants and then
made the intended tool based on quantitative findings.
The statistical population in qualitative survey included Interviewee experts who had executive
experiences at macro decision-making levels and were referred to as knowledgeable experts. A
questionnaire was prepared based on the components.
Thematic coding was employed to analyse qualitative data via con-tent analysis. In the
quantitative section, descriptive and inferential statistics methods were used. Relations among the
variables were determined using exploratory factor analysis and the components were ranked by
means of confirmatory factor analysis.
Primary Data:
Primary data was collected through survey method by distributing questionnaires to HR Talent
Acquisition’s and recruiters also the Functional Managers who are the interviewers.
The questionnaires were carefully designed by taking into account the parameters of my study.
The following is the information of the knowledgeable experts who participated in the data
collection:
A. Gender
13
B. Experience In Interviewing
14
Secondary Data:
Data was collected from web sites, going through the records of the organisation, etc. It is
the data which has been collected by individual or someone else for the purpose of other
than those of the particular research study. Or in other words we can say that secondary
data is the data used previously for the analysis and the results are undertaken for the next
process.
A Research Instrument is a tool used to collect, measure and analyse data related to the
research’s interests. This research utilizes Google Form to collect primary data. Google
form is an application in the form of a template or worksheet that can be used
independently or together for the purpose of obtaining user information. This application
works in Google Drive cloud storage along with other applications such as Google sheets,
Google Docs, and other enrichments. This template is very easy to understand and use,
and is available in many languages
To get the appropriate data needed, the Questionary Survey was divided in two parts.
Terms for using only have a Google account only for processors or form makers.
Part 1 will ask for the profile of the respondents. The tool for profile was made in such a
way that it collects the respondents practical experience in interviewing candidates.
15
Part 2 of the research instrument consists of is the standardized questionnaire tool to
determine the level of importance of competency used by the interviewers while
interviewing their respective candidates. Adding to this what is the Talent acquisition
method they use for recruiting is been taken into consideration too. It consisted of 6
major questions with its responding boxes with multiple choice answers where
present.
16
1.4.4. Research Design
A research design is the arrangement of the condition for collection and analysis of data
in a manner that aims to combine relevance to the research purpose with economy in
procedure. A research design is the specification of methods and procedure for acquiring
the information needed to structure or to solve problems. It is the overall operation pattern
or framework of the project that stipulates what information is to be collected from which
source and be what procedures.
17
In this research design the following is been considered:
Neutrality: Initially researcher may have to make assumptions about the data expected to
collect. The results projected in the research are free from bias and neutral. Understanding
multiple respondents’ opinions about the evaluated scores and it is considered with those
who agree with the derived results.
Reliability: With conducted research, the researcher involved expects similar results.
Hence the design indicates how to form research questions to ensure the standard of
results. The expected results will be reached if the design is reliable.
Validity: There are multiple measuring tools available. However, the only correct
measuring tools are those which help a researcher in gauging results according to the
objective of the research. The questionnaire developed from this design will then be valid.
Generalization: The outcome of design will apply to a population and not just a
restricted sample. A generalized design implies that your survey can be conducted on any
part of a population with similar accuracy.
The above factors affect the way respondents answer the research questions and so all the
above characteristics are balanced.
A complete interaction and enumeration of all the Interviewers for multiple interview
rounds was not possible so a sample was chosen that consisted of 32 respondents
including HR Recruiters and Talent Acquisition managers who are responsible for taking
the initial and final round of interviews and also the Functional Managers who are
responsible to take the functional or managerial and technical rounds of interviews. In
both cases the respondents have been interviewing candidates for their respective multiple
organizations respectively. The research was taken by necessary steps to avoid any biased
while collecting the data.
18
Limited Access to Information
Limited Time for the study.
Access to Literature
Data Collection Process
Limited Sample Profile
Recruit and perform talent acquisition activities such as resume & phone screens, candidate
interviews.
Sourcing with resume databases, job portals and social media/professional network hiring
such as Naukri, LinkedIn, etc.
Initial phone screening of candidates to judge communications and background.
Short listing the candidates as per functional heads requirements and then scheduling up the
interviews.
Maintaining and updating excel database of potential, prospective and rejected candidates.
Assess candidate information, including resumes and contact details, using their Applicant
Tracking System – LEVER
19
Scheduling Interviews on LEVER and booking calendar of the functional heads taking
interview as well as the candidates.
Sending Selection or Rejection Mails according to the interview feedbacks.
Arrange pre-employment testing, background & references screenings.
Maintain applicant tracking system, recruiting reports and other staffing administration
functions as needed.
Responsibilities
o Identify and onboard web publishers and establish a relationship with them
o Outline and execute effective lead strategy in order to maintain the revenue growth and
hit revenue targets
o Expand the relationship with existing and new publishers by proposing solutions to
their needs
o Serve as the link of communication between publishers and internal team
o Prepare regular progress reports and forecast reports in order to ensure revenue growth
o Sales / Business Development Experience would be good to have
o Flexible timings
o Open-door policy
o Regular office parties
20
o Being a part of a quickly growing company full of smart and logical doers
o You are given full authority to propose an idea and how you want to implement it
Dear Candidate,
This is to bring to your kind notice that we have an opening for the post of Publisher
Sales Associate with XYZ
URL:
Location: Gurugram, India
Designation: Publisher Sales Associate
Experience: 4+ Years
Essential Qualities:
Excellent Communication Skill, Positive attitude, passionate, highly motivated.
Should come from online, yellow pages, space selling and should have a good idea about
online sales/marketing.
Job Responsibility:
o Identify and onboard web publishers and establish a relationship with them
o Outline and execute effective lead strategy in order to maintain the revenue growth and
hit revenue targets
o Expand the relationship with existing and new publishers by proposing solutions to
their needs
o Serve as the link of communication between publishers and internal team
o Prepare regular progress reports and forecast reports in order to ensure revenue growth
o B2B or B2C Sales / Business Development Experience would be good to have
If your candidature suits the mentioned profile then kindly send us the following details:
1. Your updated resume in MS Word format.
2. Present CTC
3. Expected CTC
4. Notice Period
Best regards,
Mayuri Lotlikar
21
Talent Acquisition
Sourcing candidates through Naukri – Job Portal
NAUKRI PORTAL:
Naukri.com, India’s No. 1 job site and the flagship brand of Info Edge introduced the concept
of e-recruitment in India. Since its inception in 1997, Naukri.com has seen continuous growth
while outperforming its competitors in every sphere. Naukri.com is a recruitment platform
that provides hiring-related services to corporates/recruiters, placement agencies and to job
seekers in India and overseas. It offers multiple products like Resume Database Access,
listings and Response Management Tools. With more than 4, 75,000 jobs live at any point
and over 60 million CVs, Naukri.com serviced over 76,000 corporate clients in 2017-2018.
The company operates 56 offices in 42 cities in India and overseas offices in Dubai, Riyadh,
Abu Dhabi and Bahrain.
1 SEARCH
1.1 ADVANCED SEARCH- Advanced Search is the most comprehensive search form. It has
various search parameters such as: Keyword Text Designation Details Experience UG/PG
Qualification Salary Year of passing out Location Details Institute Name Functional Area
Affirmative Action Industry Area Women Candidates Employer Special Ability Candidates
22
1.2 IT SEARCH- IT Search is specially designed for your IT (Information Technology)
hiring needs. Using IT Search, you can find IT candidates with specific years of experience in
each of the various IT skills. IT search is combined with Advanced Search to let you specify
other search parameters. For example, IT Search allows you to specifically find candidates
with more than 2 years’ experience in Core Java AND have more than 5 years’ experience in
C++.
1.3 ROLE SEARCH- Role Search allows you to search for candidates by ‘role’. In an
organization people may work in multiple departments or functional areas but may be
assigned different roles. For example, accounting may have an Accountant, Taxation
Manager, Chartered Accountant etc. Role Search allows you to search for candidates by these
roles in a given Functional Area.
1.4 MY SEARCH- My Search can be used to customize search options and add search
parameters that you use the most or remove the search parameters that may be irrelevant for
your needs.
23
Result Page helps you save resume to a Folder, contact candidates or export selected CVs to
eApps. Save to Folder – Saves selected resumes to the folder Send Mail – Sends email to
selected candidates Send SMS – Sends SMS to selected candidates Export to eApps –
Exports selected resumes to eApps
24
Today, LinkedIn is a top source to identify potential job candidates. LinkedIn is home to over
700 million users. This means that, as an employer, the platform will provide access to a
large pool of talent right from the get-go. It’s optimized for recruiting. The platform also makes
it easy for businesses to search for potential candidates for their open positions. With convenient
features such as InMail and Messaging, LinkedIn makes communication between employers and
candidates a breeze.
But what sets LinkedIn apart as an excellent place for sourcing candidates is that it allows
hiring managers to review a candidate’s skills, qualifications, and employment history via
their profiles—often eliminating the need to contact them and request this information. This
makes the process of scanning resumes and screening individuals easier than ever.
To search resumes on LinkedIn and find strong candidates faster, there are a few important
steps you’ll need to follow:
On LinkedIn, we can filter your search results for people, jobs, events, content, companies,
and more. But for LinkedIn to return the best possible job candidates from your search,
they’ll need to use the Advanced search function—and the People tab, more specifically. This
will allow to set a handful of parameters that yield more relevant search results.
With a clear set of primary job requirements, we can start to enter parameters for your
candidate search results. Some of the fields we’ll want to fill out include title and industry.
This simple check alone will return thousands of candidates, so then we will take our search a
step further by entering parameters that line up with your list of job requirements. Target
25
location, schools, past companies, and non-profit interests to create a more focused candidate
search.
After entering the parameters for the People search, LinkedIn should return a list of
candidates that meet your requirements. At this point, we can begin to view candidate
profiles and identify ideal matches for your job opening. Along the way, we might find that
we’re receiving a certain type of candidate that doesn’t quite fit the role we need to be filled
—perhaps an incorrect job title, industry, or location.
When done right, a LinkedIn Recruiter search brings your organization’s ideal candidates
right to you.
One of the greatest benefits of using LinkedIn is the ability to source both active and passive
candidates. What is the difference between an active candidate and a passive candidate?
Active candidates
As the name suggests, an active job seeker is a person who is actively looking for work. This
often includes people who are unemployed, unhappy at their current jobs, or simply looking
for new opportunities. These candidates are typically easy to identify—not only because they
are the first to respond to job posts but also because, on LinkedIn specifically, the platform
allows candidates to share that they are open to work. Current employers aren’t able to spot
this designation, as candidates have the option of signalling to recruiters privately.
Passive candidates
The passive candidate isn’t looking for new opportunities. Typically, this means that they are
happily employed and content with their role. But these types of candidates may be open to a
conversation with a recruiter or organization. Of course, we may need to take a
more relationship-based approach to recruiting if we hope to persuade a passive candidate to
join your organization.
26
Alternatively, find candidates that aren’t on LinkedIn
While LinkedIn can be a gold mine of quality job candidates, it is still only one
network. Recruiters have both the time and resources to dig deeper during the search process,
tapping into all types of networks to widen your search for top talent. Referrals are regarded
as the best source of hires, and recruiters can help your business secure more referrals—both
by leveraging their connections and by helping you strategize to encourage employee
referrals internally.
T
Employer’s commonly use phone interviews as a way to screen job candidates to find out if
they meet the job requirements. This method can be beneficial for finding and inviting only
qualified candidates to attend additional in-person interviews.
27
Benefits of Conducting a Phone Interview
Phone interviews are an essential part of the modern hiring process, offering convenience for
both the jobseeker and Hiring Manager alike. While in-person interviews will remain an
essential part of the hiring process, most applicants have come to expect an initial phone
screening prior to an in-person visit.
Being able to conduct a phone interview offers the following advantages.
Convenience in scheduling: It’s much easier for someone to find 30-minutes to conduct a
phone interview than to find the time to go into an office for an in-person interview.
Higher volume screening: By starting the interview process with a phone interview, you are
able to filter through a higher volume of candidates in a shorter period of time.
Decreased travel expenses: It’s not uncommon for multiple people to be a part of a phone
interview. If different members of your organization are in different locations, a phone
interview quickly becomes the most convenient solution.
To prepare for a phone interview, start by doing some research on the individual who you
will be interviewing. We recommend reviewing their resume, LinkedIn profile, the job
description, and any other supplemental information provided. This will come in handy later
when you are preparing phone interview questions to ask.
If possible, conduct your phone interview in a quiet space. Conducting a phone interview
while in a public or noisy space is not advisable. You could be interrupted, and it could be
viewed as disrespectful to the interviewee. These background noises might be okay for you,
but they may be distracting to the applicant. This could cause them to stumble in what
otherwise could have been an excellent interview.
While there is definitely some value in preparing general interview questions to ask all of
your applicants, candidate-specific questions are highly advisable. Candidate-specific
questions allow you to dig deeper into the information on their resume. It also shows the
applicant that you have done your homework, and that you’re seriously considering their
request to work for you.
Basic Interview Questions asked to Candidates:
(KPIs), and reports designed to tell you how your recruitment funnel is performing. This
includes data on applicants, hires, campaigns, and budget. These metrics can help the
organization improve the sourcing of the best candidates for roles, reduce recruitment costs,
and develop new talent acquisition strategies that have a positive impact on the entire
business.
The answers to these questions alone don’t tell us much. But using recruitment metrics to
analyse all this data together can generate a wealth of insight into the entire recruitment
process. Here are four reasons why employer should invest in a recruitment metrics tracker.
1. “See” problems
2. Analyse your hiring funnel
3. Refine your recruitment strategy
4. Improve the efficiency and effectiveness of your recruitment
29
Applicant Tracker followed:
30
Applicant Tracking System
Applicant tracking system software provides recruiting and hiring tools for companies. Among
other functions, these systems collect and sort thousands of resumes. When applicant applies for
a job online, the resume doesn’t typically go directly to a recruiter or hiring manager. It’s first
being processed by an ATS. Whether that human recruiter ever sees your resume could depend
on how well your resume is optimized for ATS algorithms.
Top employers hire for several jobs at a time and receive hundreds of resumes for any given opening.
Because applying for a job online is easier than ever, many of these applicants are unqualified and figured
“it was worth a try.” Applicant tracking systems keep all these resumes in one place, helping recruiters
and hiring managers stay organized as well as EEOC compliant. In theory, these systems also save time
by automatically surfacing and highlighting top candidates. In reality, ATS do help hiring professionals
narrow their applicant pool.
Most large corporations utilize applicant tracking systems. The researchers have found that 98%
of Fortune 500 companies use ATS while a Kelly OCG survey estimated 66% of large
companies and 35% of small organizations rely on recruitment software. Even job sites like
Indeed and LinkedIn have their own built in ATS. There are dozens of different ATS, each with
their own features, strengths, weaknesses, and quirks. Here are just a few of the top ATS:
31
BrassRing iCIMS Jobvite Lever
Applicant tracking systems collect and store resumes in a database for hiring professionals to
access. Resumes may also be stored long after the original job you applied for is filled. Corporate
recruiters or hiring managers can then search and sort through the resumes in a number of ways,
depending on the system they’re using.
Viewing Applications: Some recruiters still choose to glance at every job application that comes
through their applicant tracking system. In this case, most take a quick glance at the applicant’s
past highlights, job titles, and companies. They can make a determination about whether they
want to learn more in about 6 seconds. It’s important to make sure your top skills and
qualifications are easily identifiable.
Automatic Rankings: Some applicant tracking systems can automatically compare your resume
to the job description. For example, Taleo calls this feature “Req Rank,” which ranks each
applicant based on how well their resume scores based on the job description.
Instead of reviewing each and every application, the recruiter can focus squarely on candidates
the ATS has identified as a great match.
During the Great Recession, employers were flooded with applications and wanted features that
discouraged and filtered out unqualified candidates. This resulted in many of the bloated
32
application processes and indiscriminate filters found in ATS today. Unfortunately, improving
unemployment rates won’t mark the end of ATS.
While outdated systems are still in use at some large companies, we are seeing new ATS being
developed for the modern age. As employers fight for the best talent, candidate experience is
becoming more of a priority. Automation and ranking systems aren’t going away; they’re just
becoming more technical as recruiting software begins leveraging AI.
LEVER:
Like its competitor Greenhouse, Lever came out of Silicon Valley in 2012 and offers cleaner
design and a more user-friendly interface for recruiters and applicants compared to older ATS
institutions like Taleo. Lever allows hiring teams to collect applicants and move them through
the interview and offer stages.
Netflix Shopify
Yelp Twitch
33
Coursera Medium
Headspace Upwork
Eventbrite Quora
• Build an employer brand and institute a painless application process with custom job sites.
• Source candidates instantly, up referral numbers, and get the entire team involved in recruiting
through the Lever Chrome Extension.
• Get faster feedback from hiring managers with two-way email sync, so they never have to leave
the tools they love to use.
• Schedule and re-schedule interviews with ease through Lever’s calendar sync, drag drop
workflow, and automatic reminders.
• Institute interview kits with custom feedback forms to make it simple for interviewers to find
everything in one place, while ensuring the delivery of an impressive candidate experience every
time.
• Never be more than 2 clicks away from the numbers that matter most - inform a data-driven
recruiting strategy with real-time metrics tracking.
Lever Portal:
34
Sample List of Job opening on Lever:
35
Every candidate has their own candidate profile, which is your single source of truth: all
relevant information will be found here! The candidate's contact information will be found on the
right side. The candidate's opportunities (job postings) will be listed in the top right corner, and
details about whichever opportunity is selected in the corner will be displayed in the centre of the
screen: how far has this contact made it through your recruiting pipeline for this particular
opportunity? how did you recruit them for this opportunity?
Scroll down to see a candidate's activity log:
Any notes, email conversations, resume information and interview history will be recorded on
the candidate profile, organized by the relevant opportunity. There are even a few shortcut
buttons at the top so you can jump straight to the information you need.
36
Understand the Candidates Pipeline:
All candidates who are actively being considered for an opportunity live somewhere in your
pipeline. Lever offers a single, unified pipeline to help you keep your recruiting process
consistent across your organization. A unified pipeline allows your team to generate consistent
metrics - for instance, comparing the recruiting performance for one department to another. Your
pipeline is broken into 3 pipeline segments:
Lead (prospects you're reaching out to),
Applicant (applicants who are reaching out to you) and
Interview (candidates you're meeting with).
Within each segment are your organization's pipeline stages. Candidates progress from stage to
stage until they're either hired at your organization or moved into your archive.
The Lever account is full of candidates who are associated with one or more opportunities.
Candidates may be considered for multiple opportunities at the same time, in which case they'll
show up in your pipeline multiple times.
Scheduling interviews just became a lot easier! Lever's default interview plans allow you to
assign an interviewer, event duration and feedback form to each stage of your interviewing
process. Set a template once, and Lever will take it from there!
Open a candidate's profile in Lever and click the Schedule (calendar) icon.
37
In the Find Interviewers field, search for and select one or more interviewers. Select a time
and a duration for the interview. Then, click the SCHEDULE button to navigate to the next
slide.
38
Emailing Feedback to the Interviewed Candidates:
Selection Mail:
39
4. INTERNSHIP JOB RESPONSIBILITIES:
COMPETENCY ANALYSIS
To make hiring a fool proof process, recruiters conduct in depth analysis of candidate’s
capabilities using online aptitude tests. Industries and service sectors such as manufacturing,
banking and accounting, computer programming and even air traffic control make use of online
aptitude test platforms to analyse job specific knowledge and skills of candidates.
40
How Aptitude Tests Can Aid Recruitment?
Aptitude tests have emerged to be one of the most effective recruitment tools that enable
organizations to identify candidate skills and talents. As the pandemic has changed the way
companies operate, hiring decisions based on candidates’ resumes or phone screening will not
provide accurate insights. This allows organizations to hire quality resources even while
operating remotely.
41
42
Shadowing Functional Rounds of Interview
Shadowing means attending the functional interview with the functional head
and the candidate to understand what and where the candidates are going wrong
and getting to analyse the candidate better. Shadowing the interview gives a
brief idea about how the functional round takes place, what kind of questions
are asked, why these questions are asked and how the answer of the candidate is
analysed to gauged if the candidate is to be send ahead or not.
This helps while recruiting the new set of candidates in future as we get a clear
picture of the expectations of the Functional Manager from the right candidate.
43
Understanding this can help reduce the wrong candidate for the role and hence
reduce rejection rate which eventually saves time, cost and efforts of the
company.
A reference check is when a hiring manager, employer, or recruiter contacts a job candidate’s
former workplace to get more information on the candidate’s performance and skills. The
purpose of a reference check is to ensure the candidate has the qualifications needed for the
role the employer is trying to fill.
In today’s workplaces, a reference check can go one of two ways: You’ll either confirm that
the candidate has all of the fantastic skills and experience they say they do, or you’ll uncover
something disappointing.
To cut through any lies and exaggerations — and find honest, qualified candidates — you
need to include reference checks in your applicant screening process. Here’s our guide on
how to do it quickly, easily, and painlessly.
Usually, the hiring manager will conduct a reference check with the candidate’s former
manager or direct supervisor. But that’s not always the case.
For example, if the candidate is vying for a supervisor role, the hiring manager may get
better insight into how good of a leader they are by speaking to the employees they
previously managed.
44
-Once you’ve confirmed the candidate is who they say they are, with the experience and
background they say they have, it’s time to check their references.
-Request a list of references from the candidate, confirm you have their consent to reach
out to them, and contact one to three of them to get their insights into the candidate.
-By including reference checks in your hiring process, you’ll be able to confirm your
candidate’s qualifications, clarify any questions you have about their job experience, and
hopefully, have the confidence you need to hire them without any second guesses.
45
Reference Check Page:
46
Frequency Percent
Male 12 37.5
Female 20 62.5
Total 32 100
Frequency Percent
Less than 1 year 11 34.4
1 - 5 years 13 40.6
5 - 10 years 5 15.6
10+ years 3 9.4
Total 32 100
48
Structured interview is the one involving a fixed set of questions. The interviewer comes
prepared in advance with a particular questionnaire. The dependency is on the interview pattern,
that must be carried out with uniformity. Unstructured interview is the one where the interviewer
initiates casual conversation with the candidate. There is no pattern or fixed format set in
advance that allows the interviewer to indulge in informal discussion mixed with interview
questions. Here, 75 percent respondents that is 24 of them follow structured interview process
where as the rest 25 percent that is the 8 of them follow unstructured interview process.
Hence, with structured interviews employing a one-size-fits-all approach, the process can
become cold and impersonal that directly affects the selection of the right candidate with right
experience. On the other hand, unstructured interviews are highly personalized and allow the
candidate to act to the spontaneity of the event. The pre-developed systematic approach of the
former directs towards logical reasoning and testing whereas the casual and unrehearsed nature
of the latter brings out the best skills and competencies of the candidates. The difference between
structured and unstructured interviews lies in the questions being asked. When mass hiring like
campus placements, structured interviews are the ones to be expected as these are more formal
and standardized. On the contrary, unstructured interviews are best suitable for assessing
candidates when hiring for specialist roles. These allow room for creative exploration, are more
flexible and invite more inclusive, free-flowing conversations.
49
One method of developing the competencies is by conducting Behavioural Event Interviews.
The objective of a Behavioural Event Interview (BEI) is to get very detailed behavioural
descriptions of how a person goes about doing his or her work. The interviewer's job is to
elicit complete stories that describe the interviewee's specific behaviours, thoughts, and
actions in actual situations.
As per the research, majorly interviewers use BEI method for interviewing that is 17 of them
which means 53.1 percent use BEI type interview while 28.1 percent that’s is 9 only use is
sometimes. There are 18 percent i.e., 6 who do not use this interview technique.
50
Open-ended questions are questions that allow someone to give a free-form answer. Closed-
ended questions can be answered with “Yes” or “No,” or they have a limited set of possible
answers. An interviewer might ask an open-ended question for a variety of reasons. Generally,
they will ask an open-ended question to get a sense of your personality and to see if you will fit
into the company culture. They might also ask this kind of question to see if you have the
qualities and experience needed for the job.
Here in the survey, we come to know that 29 out of 32 respondents that is 90.6 percent use prefer
open ended questions which gives a brief scope of understanding candidates overview while
there are 3 respondents that consists of 9.4 percent who use close ended questions in the
interview.
Traditional interview questions are broad, allowing the candidate to select an example of a
work situation that fits the question asked. On the other hand, competency-based interview
questions are specific. They require you to provide examples in response to questions that are
51
essential for the company and the position for which you are interviewing. A popular method
of doing this is the STAR approach (S- Situation, T- Task, A-Action, R- Result).
Regarding the survey, its noted that there are 75 percent who with time have shifted to
competency-based approach while interviewing that consists of 24 respondents. And 25
percent that is 8 respondents still follow the traditional based interview.
Table 3.3: The extent to which various factors are considered in recruiting new staff
Regarding the extent to which various factors are considered in recruiting new employees,
the respondents said that ability to coping to different situations is an important factor to
consider with a mean of 4.4 out of 5 (see table 3.3). Effective and fluent communication
52
together with good customer focus and public relations needs strategic thinking and
innovation too that are also considered as important with a mean of 4.3 and 4.2 each
respectively. Ability for time management is also not overlooked when recruiting new
staff. It had a mean of 4.1. The ability to be relate well with others demonstrates teamwork
Other factors considered include demonstrate attentive listening to customers & clients and
information gathering plays an important role. These two factors are equally considered
with a mean of 3.8. Knowing your weakness gives a scope of improvement hence it as
The findings implied that the most important factor to be considered when undertaking
competence-based recruitment and selection was the ability to manage time well.
53
Competency Based Help Predict Successful Job Performance
Hiring a candidate is crucial as you need to ensure that the employee adds value to the
organization, the employee understands the needs and values of the organization and abides by
them and strives for progress. Here’s what the interviewers think about the same, 12.5 percent
that is 4 strongly agree and majorly 59.4 percent that are 19 agree. On the other hand, there are
9.4 percent that is 3 and 1 percent i.e., 1 who disagree and strongly disagree respectively. There
are 5 that comprises of 15.6 percent who are neutral for the same.
5.3. FINDINGS
According to the Survey, Recruitment differs from company to company for each
category.
According to the Survey, the company do utilize competencies for the recruitment
process and for finding the talent candidate.
54
According to the Survey it is observed that the company are utilizing the structured
interview in order to make interview process more efficient.
6. CONCLUSION
This study was carried out with the objective of determining the competency-based
recruitment and selection practices adopted by organizations. It can be concluded that the
results from the findings of the questionnaire demonstrated that competency-based recruitment
procedures were paramount in selecting new hires. The respondents recognized that
competency-based recruitment procedures can work hand in hand with traditional recruitment
and selection procedures. The competency-based approach to recruitment and selection was
considered important in the recruitment and selection stage of Human Resource Management
processes.
The research also found that adopting a competency-based recruitment and selection
system is a results-oriented process. It makes it easier to concentrate on the results expected of
a successful or exemplary performer (Guinn, 1998). In addition, the competency-based
recruitment and selection technique gave the recruitment staff the opportunity to focus less
attention on approximations of competence such as educational level or years of experience
that have little connection to verifiable results. Also, competency-based recruitment plays an
important role in attracting individuals who possess characteristics that might be difficult, if not
impossible, to acquire by training or development efforts. A competency-based approach
encourages managers and other decision makers to clarify the verifiable, measurable results
they expect from successful performers before a selection decision is made.
Competency-based selection, according to the respondents provides some insight into
whether or not a new hire will be a good fit with the institutions culture. A competency-based
recruitment and selection process provides applicants with opportunities to outline, explain,
and demonstrate their qualifications in competency-based terms. Potential candidates will not
be confronted during the selection process with questions that have little or no bearing on their
ability to produce desired work results
From the findings, it was noted that competencies predict effective performance, result in
valid selection criteria, recognize the transferability of employees' skills and are flexible to
meet the changing needs of future requirements. Furthermore, the competency model covers
55
all aspects of what it takes to be successful in a job by examining not only knowledge and
skills required but the personal attributes required as well.
7. RECOMMENDATIONS
The recruitment and selection process are one of the most important and costly investments an
organization can make. Risks can be high and the cost of a bad hire can have tremendous
impact in time, money and company culture. In addition to the above discussed and detailed
conclusions, the following recommendations should be taken into consideration in their
competency-based recruitment and selection:
The organizations need to provide time and money to carry out the individualized
competency identification and assessment for those targeted to receive training.
The organizations should provide strong, long-term support for the projects and act
as role models for the process. Required resources need to be available over the
long term. Managers will face increased workloads as a competency-based
approach requires them to provide new hires with additional and more effective
feedback as well as accept responsibilities for addressing performance obstacles.
While this study was able to provide additional insight into the use of competencies and its
relationship to an effective recruitment and selection process in organizations, it also revealed
areas that would benefit from further research. These are:
Future research could thus focus on the other functions such as compensation and benefits. By
doing so, a better and fuller understanding of the effects of core competencies on an
organization’s performance may be achieved. Secondly, this study recognized the importance
56
of measuring the performance of the employees according to their core competencies, hence,
there is a need for further study on the benefits of the competency-based performance
management systems.
8. ANNEXURE
QUESTIONNAIRE
57
PART B: DETAILED INDIVIDUAL INTERVIEW STYLE ANALYSIS
a) Yes []
b) No []
c) Sometimes []
58
b) Competency Based Interviewing []
Very
Aspect Little Moderate Large large
Not at all extent extent extent extent
a) Strategic thinking
b) Innovative
d) Time management
e) Accurate
Weakness
f) Information
gathering
g) Coping
mechanisms
h) Demonstrate
attentive listening
a) Strongly disagree []
b) Disagree []
c) Neutral []
59
d) Agree []
e) Strongly Agree []
9. BIBLOGRAPHY
Books
McClelland, D.C. (1973), Testing for Competence rather than for ‘Intelligence’.
American Psychologist, 26, pp. 211 –242.
Prahalad, C.K. & G. Hamel (1990),The Core Competence of the Corporation.
Harvard Business Review, May-June, 79-91.
Rodriguez, D., Patel, R., Bright, A., Gregory, D. and Gowing, M. K.
(2002) ,Developing competency model to promote integrated human resource
practices, Human Resource Management, 41, pp. 309 –324.
Roos, J. & G. von Krogh (1992), Figuring out your Competence Configuration.
European Management Journal, 10, 4, 422-427.
Rothwell, W.J. (1996),ASTD Models for Human Performance Improvement:
Roles, Competencies and Outputs. Alexandria: American Society for Training
and Development.
Sandberg, J. (1994) ,Human Competence at Work: An Interpretive Approach
(Go¨ teburg: Bas).
Websites
https://www.toolbox.com/hr/recruitment-onboarding/articles/what-is-talent-
acquisition/
60
https://recruitingdaily.com/the-recruiters-playbook-for-competency-based-hiring-
in-2020/
https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/pages/0315-competencies-
hiring.aspx
https://blog.clearcompany.com/5-unique-benefits-of-competency-based-
recruitment-and-selection
https://flylib.com/books/en/2.309.1/
competency_based_employee_recruitment_and_selection.html
https://slideplayer.com/slide/14018816/
https://flylib.com/books/en/2.309.1/
competency_based_employee_recruitment_and_selection.html#fastmenu_10
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330331377_Competency-
based_recruitment_and_managerial_succession
61