Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Arshad Ashraf , Rozina Naz & Rakhshan Roohi (2012) Glacial lake
outburst flood hazards in Hindukush, Karakoram and Himalayan Ranges of Pakistan:
implications and risk analysis, Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, 3:2, 113-132, DOI:
10.1080/19475705.2011.615344
1. Introduction
Global climate change has influenced the snow and glaciated environment of the
Hindukush-Karakoram-Himalaya (HKH) region of Pakistan, which contributes
more than 50% of the total flow of the Indus River system. As a result of this
situation the frequency of glacial hazards has increased in this part of the Himalayan
region. Sudden breach of the unstable moraine ‘dams’ results in discharges of huge
amounts of water and debris – known as glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs ) – that
often have catastrophic effects downstream. Even the small glacial lake associated
with hanging glaciers poses a high potential for breaching resulting in a GLOF. At
least 20 GLOF events recorded in the Himalayan region in the last seven decades
resulted in heavy loss of human lives and their property, destruction of infrastructure
as well as damage to agricultural land and forests. In the past 50 years, the general
clockwise from the west are Swat, Chitral, Gilgit, Hunza, Shigar, Shyok, Indus,
Shingo, Astore and Jhelum. The lakes are classified into Erosion, Valley trough,
Cirque, Blocked, Moraine Dammed (Lateral Moraine and End Moraine Dammed
lakes), and Supraglacial types.
Clear water absorbs relatively little energy with wavelengths of less than about
0.6 mm. High transmittance typifies these wavelengths with a maximum in the blue-
green portion of the spectrum. However, as the turbidity of water changes (because
of the presence of organic or inorganic materials), transmittance, and therefore
reflectance, changes dramatically (Mool et al. 2001). Glacial lakes can be identified
clearly in the band combinations of Pan, 7, 6b and 5, 4, 2 (Red, Green, Blue) due to
their distinct true colour and contrast with the surrounding features. In the winter
season image the glacial lakes can be identified on the basis of their smooth texture
and varying grey tone due to their semi-frozen ice surface. In the false colour
composite of 5, 4, 3 (RGB), the water bodies, like lakes in blue colour, can be
differentiated from the shadow areas appearing black in this band combination.
Using Digital Elevation Model (DEM) data with a remote sensing image, decision
rules for integrated analysis in GIS can be assigned i.e. if the slope is not too
pronounced and the texture smooth, then such areas are recognized as frozen glacial
lakes.
After digitization of the lake boundaries, the segments were checked and the
glacial lakes were numbered using point identifiers. The numbering of the lakes
starts from the outlet of the major stream/river and proceeds clockwise round the
basin. Reference longitude and latitude are designated for the approximate
centre of the glacial lake by creating a digital point map over the screen digitized
glacial lakes. The area of the glacial lake is determined from the digital database
after digitization of the lake from the image data and topographic maps. The
drainage direction of the glacial lake is specified as one of eight cardinal directions
(N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W and NW). For a closed glacial lake, the orientation is
specified according to the direction of its longer axis (Mool et al. 2001). The
required attributes of the lakes were derived or entered in the attribute database in
the GIS.
For the identification of potentially dangerous glacial lakes, the glacial lakes
associated with glaciers such as Supraglacial, Valley, Cirque and/or dammed by
Flood hazards in HKH Region 119
Lateral Moraine or End Moraine with an area larger than 0.02 km2 have been
considered and they have been defined as major glacial lakes. Moraine Dammed
glacial lakes, which are still in contact or very near to the glaciers, are usually
dangerous. These End Moraines are loose and unstable in nature. The advance
and retreat of the glacier affect the hydrology between the glacier and the
lake dammed by the moraines. Sudden natural phenomena, with a direct effect on
a lake, like ice avalanches or rock and lateral moraine material collapsing on a
lake, cause moraine breaches with subsequent lake outburst events. The phys-
ical conditions and criteria for identification of potential GLOF lakes, as men-
tioned by Mool et al. (2001), Bajracharya et al. (2007) and ICIMOD (2011), may
include:
. The rise in water level in glacial lakes dammed by moraines creates a situation
that endangers the lake to reach a breaching point.
. Activity of Supraglacial lakes – the lakes formed over glacial surface: as time
passes, groups of closely spaced Supraglacial lakes of smaller size at glacier
tongues merge and form bigger lakes that may become potentially dangerous.
. The potentially dangerous status of Moraine Dammed lakes can be defined
by the conditions of the damming material and the nature of the mother
glacier.
. The valley lakes with an area bigger than 0.1 km2 and a distance less than 0.5
km from the mother glacier of considerable size are considered to be
potentially dangerous. Cirque lakes even smaller than 0.1 km2 associated (in
contact or distance less than 0.5 km) with steep hanging glaciers are considered
to be potentially dangerous.
. A Moraine Dammed lake, which has breached and closed subsequently in the
past and has refilled again with water, can breach again.
. Physical conditions of the surrounding area such as potential rockfall/
slide (mass movements) sitedaround the lake which can fall into the lake
suddenly, hanging glacier in contact with the lake, snow avalanches of large
size around the lake which can fall into the lake suddenly, neo-tectonic and
earthquake activities around or near the lake area, presence of large mother
glacier can cause the lake to be potentially dangerous. The actively retreating
and steep hanging glaciers on the banks of lakes may also be a potential cause
of danger.
Figure 2. Types of glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes in the Hindukush-Karakoram-
Himalaya (HKH) Region. Majority of GLOF lakes belong to End Moraine Dammed type.
Available in colour online.
Table 3. Summary of glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes at various aspects.
Erosion type the concentration of which is higher in the Himalaya Range than in the
other ranges (figure 4). Similarly, Cirque type lakes are dominant in this mountain
range, indicating a higher recession of glaciers due to environmental changes. The
Moraine Dammed lakes are predominant in the Karakoram Range, which is
evidence of the existence of more valley- type glaciers causing the development of the
moraine environment and ultimately melt-water lakes behind their moraines. The
occurrence of high numbers of supraglacial lakes in this mountain range also
provides a clue to the presence of large size glaciers here. In addition to high relief,
unstable deposits along the valley sides have made the slopes prone to mass
122 A. Ashraf et al.
movements in Karakoram. The termini of a number of glaciers lie close to the valley
floors and have advanced across it in the Late Pleistocene, and probably also in the
Neo-glacial (Roohi et al. 2005). Consequently, there have been a number of
interruptions to the drainage of the main rivers such as Hunza, Shimshal by ice or
debris dams besides landsliding and rockfall, causing frequent blocking of streams
and formation of dammed lakes. Although these blocked lakes are higher in
Karakoram than in other ranges but they are often short-lived and so their numbers
are usually low.
The potential GLOF lakes are dominant in the Himalaya Range indicating the
influence of global climate change in this mountainous range. Figure 5 shows a few
of the potential GLOF lakes referred to as A, B, C, D and E in the three mountain
ranges. Lakes B, C and D were surveyed, which indicated evidences of cyclic refill
and breach history thus making them susceptible to creating outburst flood hazards
in future. Lake A, visible in the FCC of 5, 4, 3 (RGB) of the Landsat-7 ETMþ image
is located in Chitral basin, Hindukush near the Afghanistan border. It has an area of
about 0.052 km2 and is in contact with the glacier that has an area of 1.75 km2.
Lakes B and C, seen in a semi-frozen state, have drainage linked to Shyok River near
a small town Bara in the eastern Karakoram Range. The lakes nourished by large
valley glaciers were identified due to their smooth surficial texure in the
panchromatic image of the winter season. Lake D, seen in FCC of 5, 4, 2 (RGB),
is an End Moraine Dammed lake draining into Hunza River in central Karakoram.
It was outburst several times during 2007 and 2008, probably due to the influence of
global warming in this glaciated area. Lake E in the FCC of 3, 1, 2 (RGB) of the
SPOT XS image is an End Moraine Dammed lake in contact with a large valley
glacier in the Astore basin, western Himalaya. It has an area of about 0.16 km2 and
was found to be growing at a rate of 0.74 hectares/year (Ashraf et al. 2008).
About 54% (28) of GLOF lakes lie within an elevation range of 4000–4500 masl
and 29% (15) within 4500–5000 masl (figure 6). About 12% of lakes (6) exist within
the 3500–4000 masl range. A maximum of 14 lakes in the Himalaya Range and 7
lakes in the Hindukush and Karakoram Ranges are situated above the 4000–4500
masl elevation range. Details of the physical characteristics of the GLOF lakes in the
three ranges are given in tables 4–6.
The Hindukush Range comprising of Swat River basin, Chitral River basin and
part of Indus sub-basin, contains 711 glacial lakes covering a surface area of about
Flood hazards in HKH Region 123
Figure 5. The glimpses of potential Glacial Lake Outburst Flood (GLOF) lakes in the
Hindukush-Karakoram-Himalaya (HKH) Region. A: An End Moraine Dammed lake in
Chitral basin, Hindukush Range. B, C, D: These lakes in Shyok basin and Hunza basin,
Karakoram have a recycle history of refill and breach. E: An expanding lake in Astore basin,
Himalaya Range (Source: A–D Landsat ETMþ images of 2001 and E SPOT image of 2005).
Available in colour online.
Figure 6. Glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes at different elevation ranges of the
Hindukush-Karakoram-Himalaya (HKH) Region. Most of the potential GLOF lakes lie
within the 4000–4500 masl elevation range.
38.3 km2. There are 393 major lakes, among which 11 lakes are characterized as
potential danger of GLOF. In Swat River basin, major lakes possess about 94%
of the total lake area of the basin. The Valley lakes are relatively high in numbers.
124
Table 4. Characteristics of potential glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes in Hindukush Range of Pakistan.
Associated Distance to
Serial no. Lake no. Lake type Area (km2) glacier glacier (m) Situation
1 Swat_gl 28 End Moraine 0.22 Swat_gr 21 – In contact with large glacier source
2 Swat_gl 189 End Moraine 0.27 Near large glacier of hanging nature
3 Chitr_gl 61 End Moraine 0.05 Chitr_gr 108 – in contact with large glacier
4 Ind_gl 125 Cirque 0.14 Ind_gr 213 In contact with hanging glacier
5 Ind_gl 162 Cirque 0.27 Ind_gr 313 In contact with hanging glacier
6 Ind_gl 47 End Moraine 0.11 Ind_gr 166 Near large glacier of hanging nature
7 Ind_gl 160 End Moraine 0.12 Ind_gr 311 Near large glacier of hanging nature
A. Ashraf et al.
8 Ind_gl 41 End Moraine 0.17 Ind_gr 165 505 Near glacier of hanging nature
9 Ind_gl 135 End Moraine 0.24 Ind_gr 263 450 Near large glacier of hanging nature
10 Ind_gl 147 End Moraine 0.28 Ind_gr 295 388 Near large glacier of hanging nature
11 Ind_gl 130 Valley 0.11 Ind_gr 245 472 Near hanging glacier
Table 5. Characteristics of potential glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes in the Karakoram Range of Pakistan.
Associated Distance to
Serial no. Lake no. Lake type Area (km2) glacier glacier (m) Situation
1 Gil_gl 550 End Moraine 0.10 Gil_gr 191 464 Near large glacier source
2 Gil_gl 590 End Moraine 0.19 Gil_gr 366 – In contact with large glacier of hanging nature
3 Gil_gl 505 End Moraine 0.21 Gil_gr 79 820 Near large glacier of hanging nature
4 Gil_gl 336 End Moraine 0.21 Gil_gr 22 225 Near large glacier of hanging nature
5 Gil_gl 469 End Moraine 0.27 – 375 Near massive glacier
6 Gil_gl 399 End Moraine 0.73 Gil_gr 28 – In contact with large glacier of hanging nature
7 Gil_gl 589 Valley 0.20 – 412 Near several hanging glaciers
8 Gil_gl 611 Valley 0.29 – 159 Near several hanging glaciers
9 Hunza_gl 6 End Moraine 0.12 Hunza_gr 119 175 Near large glacier
10 Ind_gl 290 End Moraine 0.13 Ind_gr 470 In contact with large glacier of hanging nature
11 Shyk_gl 60 End Moraine 0.08 Shyk_gr 345 In contact with large glacier of hanging nature
12 Shyk_gl 62 End Moraine 0.09 Shyk_gr 355 In contact with large glacier
Flood hazards in HKH Region
13 Shyk_gl 45 End Moraine 0.13 Shyk_gr 293 In contact with large glacier
14 Shyk_gl 65 End Moraine 0.21 Shyk_gr 361 Large glacier source
15 Shyk_gl 64 Valley 0.11 Shyk_gr 360 432 Preceded by a lake and large glacier
16 Shyk_gl 51 Valley 0.17 Shyk_gr 305 435 Large glacier source
125
126
Table 6. Characteristics of potential glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes in the Himalaya Range of Pakistan.
Associated Distance to
Serial no. Lake no. Lake type Area (km2) glacier glacier (m) Situation
Figure 7. Potential glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) lakes in the glaciated Hindukush-
Karakoram-Himalaya (HKH) ranges of Pakistan. Available in colour online.
128 A. Ashraf et al.
in the Shigar River basin, due to extensive glaciated coverage i.e. about 30% of
the basin, glacial lakes are less in number and size, and major lakes are only 20%
of the total basin lakes. Most of the glacial lakes are of Supraglacial type. There
is no lake identified as potentially danger of GLOF in this basin. In Shyok River
basin, about 47% lakes are characterized as major lakes among which End
Moraine Dammed type are dominant. Six lakes are identified as potentially
dangerous associated mostly with large source glaciers. In the Indus sub basin
part of Karakoram Range, out of 43 glacial lakes, 23 are characterized as major
lakes and only one lake of End Moraine Dammed type is identified as potentially
hazardous of GLOF (table 5).
The Himalaya Range comprised of Shingo, Astore, Jhelum River basins and part
of Indus sub-basin east and south of the Indus River contains 822 glacial lakes
covering a surface area of about 40.4 km2. There are 443 major lakes in the range,
among which 25 lakes are characterized as potentially danger of GLOF. In Shingo
river basin, about 58% of the glacial lakes are characterized as major lakes, among
which dominant lakes belong to Erosion and Valley types. There are 5 potential
GLOF lakes consisting of three End Moraine Dammed, and one each Cirque and
Valley type lakes (table 6). In Astor River basin, 64 lakes are characterized as major
lakes, the majority of which belong to Cirque and Valley types. Nine lakes are
identified as potentially danger of GLOF consisting mainly of Cirque and End
Moraine and one Valley lake. All the potentially dangerous Cirque lakes are situated
at the toe of the hanging glaciers. This situation is susceptible as the ice mass of
hanging glaciers can slip and plunge into the lake at any time, resulting in surging
and breaching of the lake’s dam causing a glacial lake outburst flood. In Jhelum
River basin there are 95 major lakes, most of which belong to Erosion and Cirque
types. Five lakes are identified as potentially danger of GLOF concentrated mainly
in the central and northern parts of the basin. These lakes are generally in contact
with hanging glaciers or a large glacial source. In the part of the Indus sub-basin of
Himalaya, among 145 major lakes, 6 lakes are identified as potentially dangerous.
Most of these belong to End Moraine Dammed type and are associated with large
glaciers of hanging nature (table 6).
4. Conclusion
. Digital image analysis integrated with GIS application has revealed the
formation of about 2420 glacial lakes in the Hindukush-Karakoram-Himalaya
(HKH) Region of Pakistan, among which 52 lakes are characterized as
potentially dangerous GLOF hazards. Among 52 potential GLOF lakes are
identified in HKH region, 25 of which lie in the Himalaya Range, indicating
the prevalence of global change influence on this mountainous range.
. About 62% of these lakes belong to the End Moraine Dammed type and 25%
to the Cirque type. About 54% of GLOF lakes lie within the elevation range of
4000–4500 masl and 29% within 4500–5000 masl. A maximum of 14 lakes in
Himalaya and 7 each in Hindukush and Karakoram lie over the 4000–4500
masl range.
. GLOF events are becoming a threat to the livelihood of the glaciated HKH
region of Pakistan, probably due to the influence of global warming in this
region.
Flood hazards in HKH Region 131
. The communities of the northern glaciated region are highly vulnerable to
natural hazards as no formal coping and preparedness mechanism exists at
village levels. The local communities usually respond to such events on a self-
help basis.
. There is a need to create awareness of flood hazard preparedness and risk
reduction among target communities and key stakeholders, impart specialized
training and capacity building in hazard mitigation and risk management.
. Climate change needs to be studied more systematically in order to cope with
the degree of its impact on the glacial environment, especially in GLOF-
susceptible areas. Detailed investigations of hot spot GLOF lakes should be
undertaken in different river basins.
. In the face of the increase in global warming, there is a need to perform hazard
and risk assessment analysis, and develop risk mitigation strategies to provide
a comprehensive policy framework. As non-structural measures, hazard
assessment and monitoring of GLOF areas are required through the utilization
of techniques such as remote sensing and hydrodynamic modelling coupled
with ground surveys for better risk mitigation and early warning.
Acknowledgments
The all out support of International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development
(ICIMOD), Asia-Pacific Network for Global Change Research (APN), United
Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the global change SysTem for
Analysis, Research, and Training (START) for undertaking the glacier resource
inventory and UNDP, Pakistan for community based risk assessment and the
response survey is highly appreciated as without this the present work would not
be possible. The database development and mapping support by members of the
Water Resources Research Institute, National Agricultural Research Centre,
Islamabad is also gratefully acknowledged. The authors are also grateful to two
reviewers of the manuscript for rendering valuable comments and suggestions for its
improvement.
References
ARCHER, D.R., 2001, The climate and hydrology of northern Pakistan with respect to
assessment of flood risks to hydropower schemes. Report by GTZ/WAPDA.
ASHRAF, A., ROOHI, R., AHMAD, B. and MUSTAFA, N., 2008, Depleting Glacier Resources of
Northern Himalaya, Pakistan. In Proceedings of a National Conference on Water
Shortage and Future Agricultural Challenges and Opportunities, Islamabad, 26–27
August, pp. 40–45.
BAJRACHARYA, S.R., MOOL, P.K. and SHRESTHA, B.R., 2007, Impact of Climate Change on
Himalayan Glaciers and Glacial Lakes: Case studies on GLOF and associated hazards
in Nepal and Bhutan. ICIMOD, Kathmandu, Nepal.
FOCUS, 2008, Preliminary Assessment Report on Aerial Reconnaissance Survey of Ghulkin
Glacier Lake Outburst. UNDP, Pakistan.
GOUDIE, A., 1981, Fearful landscape of the Karakoram. The Geographical Magazine, 53,
pp. 306–312.
GUNN, J.P., 1930, Report of the Khumdan Dam and Shyok Flood of 1929. Government of
Punjab Publication, Lahore, Pakistan.
ICIMOD, 2011, Glacial Lakes and Glacial Lake Outburst Floods in Nepal. ICIMOD,
Kathmandu, Nepal.
132 A. Ashraf et al.
KAZMI, A.H. and JAN, M.Q., 1997, Geology and Tectonics of Pakistan. (Karachi: Graphic
Publishers).
KHAN, M.I., 1994, Glaciology: Glacier and Avalanche Research. Akhwan publisher,
Peshawar, Pakistan.
LIGG/WECS/NEA, 1988, Report on the First Expedition to Glaciers and Glacier Lakes in the
Pumqu (Arun) and Poique (Bhote-Sun Kosi) River Basins, Xizang (Tibet), China,
Sino-Nepalese Investigation of Glacier Lake Outburst Floods in the Himalaya (Beijing:
Science Press).
MEYER, P., ITTEN, K.I., KELLENBERGER, T., SANDMEIER, S. and SANMEIER, R., 1993,
Radiometric correction of topographically induced effects on Landsat TM data in
an Alpine environment. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 48,
pp. 17–28.
MILLER, K.J., 1984, The International Karakoram Project: Proceedings of Conferences in
Islamabad and London (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
MOOL, P.K., BAJRACHARYA, S.R. and JOSHI, S.P., 2001, Inventory of Glaciers, Glacial Lakes,
and Glacial Lake Outburst Flood Monitoring and Early Warning System in the
Hindukush-Himalayan Region, Nepal. ICIMOD in cooperation with UNEP/RRC-
AP, Kathmandu, Nepal.
RAJ, K.B.G., 2010, Remote sensing based hazard assessment of glacial lakes: a case study in
Zanskar basin, Jammu and Kashmir, India. Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, 1,
pp. 339–347.
ROOHI, R., ASHRAF, A., MUSTAFA, N. and MUSTAFA, T., 2008, Preparatory Assessment Report
on Community Based Survey for Assessment of lacial Lake Outburst Flood Hazards
(GLOFs) in Hunza River Basin. WRRI-NARC and UNDP, Pakistan.
ROOHI, R., MOOL, P.K., ASHRAF, A., BAJRACHARYA, S., HUSSAIN, S.A. and NAZ, R., 2005,
Inventory of Glaciers, Glacial Lakes the Identification of Potential Glacial Lake
Outburst Floods Affected by Global Warming in the Mountains of Himalayan
Region, Pakistan. ICIMOD, Nepal & PARC, Pakistan.