Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Background: Congenital rubella syndrome (CRS) is a variable constellation of birth defects related to intrauterine rubella infection which
may result in visual, hearing, intellectual and cardiac impairments.
Objective: The objective of this study is to describe the clinical manifestations in patients presenting with CRS at the Korle Bu Teaching
Hospital using the World Health Organization criteria.
Methods: A retrospective analysis of the medical charts of 16 children under 16 years old who presented with CRS at the Lions International
Eye and the National Cardiothoracic Centres of the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital from 2012 to 2015, was done. Ocular, cardiac and other
systemic clinical and laboratory findings were documented for each patient using predesigned forms.
Results: Sixteen cases of CRS were recorded over the period (2012-2015) comprising 9 males and 7 females. The median (interquartile range)
age at diagnosis was 4.0 months (2.0-7.0 months), age range at diagnosis was 1.0-24.0 months. The main ocular manifestations were; cataract
10 (62.5 %), microcornea 10 (62.5 %), microphthalmia 9 (56.3 %), nystagmus 7 (43.8 %) and strabismus 4 (25.0 %). The main cardiac defects
included patent ductus arteriosus 12 (75.0 %), pulmonary stenosis 5 (31.3 %), ventricular septal defect 5 (31.3 %) and small branch pulmonary
artery 5 (31.3 %). Systemic conditions recorded included hearing defects 7 (43.8 %), microcephaly 7 (43.8 %), failure to thrive 5 (31.3 %)
and mental retardation 2 (12.5 %).
Conclusion: Cataract, microcornea and microphthalmia were the main ocular manifestations in children presenting with CRS at the Korle
Bu Teaching Hospital. Patent ductus arteriosus and hearing defects were the main cardiac and systemic defects among children presenting
with CRS at the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital.
Keywords: Congenital rubella syndrome, rubella cataract, microphthalmos, patent ductus arteriosus
224 Copyright © 2021 University of Ghana College of Health Sciences on behalf of HSI Journal. All rights reserved.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Congenital rubella syndrome at the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital, Ghana
Abaidoo et al., 2021. https://doi.org/10.46829/hsijournal.2021.12.2.2.224-229
patent ductus arteriosus (PDA), ventricular septal defects, height less than the 3rd percentile. Mental retardation was
pulmonary artery or valvular stenosis, and secundum atrial not assessed with IQ tests but was based on microcephaly,
septal defect [7, 8]. The CRS is rare in developed countries i.e. head circumference below 3rd percentile. The roles of
with established rubella immunization programmes [9]. The toxoplasma, rubella, cytomegalovirus and herpes simplex
CRS however, appears to be endemic in low middle-income virus were ruled out through clinical examinations without
areas such as most African countries where little or no any specific laboratory tests.
rubella immunization coverage exists [10]. From 2000 to
2014, the number of rubella cases reported in Africa Data collection
increased from 865 cases in seven African countries to 7402 Data on systemic history and clinical examinations for each
cases in 44 countries. As of 2014, some countries in Africa patient such as birth weight, age at presentation, sex,
were yet to introduce routine rubella vaccination important neonatal problems on patients documented by a
programmes [11]. A study by Oduro-Boatey et al. recorded paediatrician, antenatal history of the mother such as
8 cases of CRS within three months in 1998 at the Child mothers’ date of birth, age at gestation, presence of
Health Department, of the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital maculopapular rash and fever during pregnancy, trimester
(KBTH) in Ghana [12]. In August 2013, compulsory of gestation at maternal illness, and confirmation of rubella
rubella vaccination was introduced nationwide in Ghana. in mother were all recorded on a pre-designed case record
However, Ghana is yet to implement a national surveillance form. All patients were seen by a paediatrician, paediatric
ophthalmologist, an “Ear, Nose and Throat” specialist and
Copyright © 2021 University of Ghana College of Health Sciences on behalf of HSI Journal. All rights reserved.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. 225
Congenital rubella syndrome at the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital, Ghana
Abaidoo et al., 2021. https://doi.org/10.46829/hsijournal.2021.12.2.2.224-229
Copyright © 2021 University of Ghana College of Health Sciences on behalf of HSI Journal. All rights reserved.
226 This is an Open Access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Congenital rubella syndrome at the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital, Ghana
Abaidoo et al., 2021. https://doi.org/10.46829/hsijournal.2021.12.2.2.224-229
7
Number of patients
56.3%
56.3%
6
6.3%
6.3%
0
FFO FFL 6/24 6/36 6/60 PL
Presenting Visual Acuity
Figure 1: Presenting visual acuity of children with CRS at the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital.
FFO, following objects; FFL, following light; PL, perception of light; RVA, right visual acuity; LVA, left visual acuity
(n = 5, 31.3%) and mental retardation (n = 2, 12.5%). A life-threatening defect [7]. The paucity of published data on
total of (n = 12, 75%) had multiple conditions. Four (33%) the current trend of CRS in Ghana makes the findings from
out of the 12 had a combination of cataract, this study significant evidence to support literature on CRS
microphthalmia, microcornea, nystagmus, PDA, in the country. Over these four years (2012-2015), 16 cases
pulmonary stenosis, hearing defects and microcephaly. of CRS were seen. This may be an underestimation since
Four (33%) out of the 12 had a combination of cataract, data from the paediatric department and the ENT clinics of
micro cornea and PDA. Three (25%) had a combination of the hospital were not added (due to challenges with the
cataracts, nystagmus, pulmonary stenosis, hearing defects, medical records of patients, mostly unavailable or
microcephaly and failure to thrive. The maternal median incomplete ocular or cardiac evaluations). In Africa, data
age at gestation was 29.5 years (24 - 33.8 years). on CRS are limited and even the few existing studies on
Maculopapular rash during pregnancy was seen in 2 CRS have also reported small numbers of clinically
(12.5%) of the mothers. Two mothers (12.5%) had a febrile diagnosed CRS cases [10,12-16].
illness during pregnancy. Two (12.5%) mothers had the
Our series of 16 cases is larger than what was documented
maculopapular rash and fever during the second trimester
by Oduro-Boatey et al. who recorded 8 cases of CRS in
and one had a fever in the first trimester. None of the
1998 in the Child Health Department of the same tertiary
mothers reported receiving rubella vaccination. Nine
facility for this current study using the WHO guideline for
(56.3%) of 16 patients had laboratory confirmation of CRS
confirmed CRS [12]. Our data for CRS was also higher than
(IgM and IgG) in addition to ocular or cardiac findings or
the 7 clinically confirmed cases documented in a 5-year
both. The rest of the patients’ (43.7%) diagnoses were
series by Otaigbe et al. [15] in a tertiary health facility in
clinically confirmed using the WHO definition (Table 3).
Nigeria. These few numbers show that in most developing
countries rubella is not a common reportable disease. The
DISCUSSION condition which is usually mild with subclinical symptoms
Congenital Rubella Syndrome remains a significant cause may even result in misdiagnoses by clinicians [17]. Thus,
of preventable ocular, cardiac, hearing and neurological even with a high index of CRS suspicion, misdiagnosis may
morbidities in the paediatric population and a concern for occur due to a lack of clear clinical signs of the condition in
public health practitioners with its attendant social burden most mothers and infected babies. Moreover, most
[2]. The CRS may affect any organ of the body. However, developing countries do not have national rubella
its burden chiefly results in congenital ocular and cardiac elimination and surveillance strategies in place to enhance
complications with cardiac complications being the most the detection of this under-reported condition. Our findings
Copyright © 2021 University of Ghana College of Health Sciences on behalf of HSI Journal. All rights reserved.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. 227
Congenital rubella syndrome at the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital, Ghana
Abaidoo et al., 2021. https://doi.org/10.46829/hsijournal.2021.12.2.2.224-229
show cataract, microcornea and microphthalmia as the [29]. Lawn et al. [18] reported 6 cases out of 18 cases of
major ocular complications associated with CRS. Oduro- CRS involving the heart in Ghana. The outcome of their
Boatey et al. also identified cataracts as the chief ocular echocardiography confirmed pulmonary stenosis in 3 of the
complication associated with CRS in Ghana [12]. In 6 cases and PDA in 2. Congenital heart diseases were found
another hospital-based study in the Ashanti region of in 75% of our patients. Other studies reported 85.7% [15]
Ghana, all the infants with CRS had cataracts [18]. A global and 40 – 50% [30] from Nigeria. The retrospective design
review by Webster mentioned cataracts as one of the of this study with its inherent limitations, coupled with the
complications of CRS affecting 25% of all cases of CRS small numbers of this rare but important cause of morbidity
[5]. According to Givens et al., cataract is one of the and mortality in the paediatric age, especially in developing
significant ocular complications in CRS cases [19]. In countries where rubella vaccination and surveillance is
another study, cataract was seen as the most common virtually non-existent, may be limitations. However, this
ophthalmic complication mostly occurring unilaterally current study has contributed to the documentation of the
[20]. In another study in India, paediatric cataract was clinical presentations of CRS in Ghana specifically and
identified as an ocular complication with high sensitivity Sub-Saharan Africa generally. It may also add to baseline
for the detection of CRS [21]. studies conducted in Ghana looking at the clinical profile
of CRS, and together serve as the foundation for future
The CRS may affect all ocular structures in general, either
surveillance of CRS as Ghana has presently introduced
in isolation or a combination with other ocular
Copyright © 2021 University of Ghana College of Health Sciences on behalf of HSI Journal. All rights reserved.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. 229