Review Form 1.

Journal Name:
Asian Research Journal of Arts & Social Sciences
Manuscript Number: Ms_ARJASS_86202
Title of the Manuscript: Implementation of Online Collaborative Learning Model to Empower Social Skills Reviewed from the Initial Ability of Muhammadiyah Elementary School Students
in Surabaya in the Era of Industrial Revolution 4.0
Type of the Article

General guideline for Peer Review process:

This journal’s peer review policy states that NO manuscript should be rejected only on the basis of ‘lack of Novelty’, provided the manuscript is scientifically robust and technically sound.
To know the complete guideline for Peer Review process, reviewers are requested to visit this link:

(https://www.journalarjass.com/index.php/ARJASS/editorial-policy )

PART 1: Review Comments

Reviewer’s comment Author’s comment (if agreed with reviewer, correct the manuscript and
highlight that part in the manuscript. It is mandatory that authors should write
his/her feedback here)
Compulsory REVISION comments

No Comments

Minor REVISION comments

No Comments

Optional/General comments
Some abbreviations must be declared at least one time before using them.
It is better to number the titles and subtitles to easily follow up the structure of the article.
The discussion part looks like literature review and introduction. I did not find any
differences.

PART 2:

Reviewer’s comment Author’s comment (if agreed with reviewer, correct the manuscript and
highlight that part in the manuscript. It is mandatory that authors should write
his/her feedback here)

Created by: EA Checked by: ME Approved by: CEO Version: 1.6 (10-04-2018)
 Review Form 1.6

(If yes, Kindly please write down the ethical issues here in details)
Are there ethical issues in this manuscript?

Reviewer Details:

Anonymous Reviewer, Reviewer preferred to be anonymous.

Name:
Department, University & Country

Created by: EA Checked by: ME Approved by: CEO Version: 1.6 (10-04-2018)