Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assessment of The Level of Pesticide Use, Safety Practice Compliance and Health Hazards Among Rice Farmers in Ishiagu
Assessment of The Level of Pesticide Use, Safety Practice Compliance and Health Hazards Among Rice Farmers in Ishiagu
INTRODUCTION
Modern farming relies on many chemicals such as fertilizers, pesticides and crop
Pesticides are chemical substances that derive their name from the French word
“Peste”, which means pest or plague and the Latin word “caedere”, to kill
(Akunyili and Ivbijaro, 2006). Pesticide therefore can be defined as any chemical
or mitigating the effect of any pest of plants and animals. They include herbicides,
National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control, 1996). Pesticides
are widely used in most sectors of the agricultural production to prevent or reduce
losses by pests and thus, can improve yield as well as quality of the produce, even
post- harvest losses by combating damage from pests and ensuring sustainable
food production with improved yield and greater availability of food throughout
the year. For example, without the use of pesticides in rice and cocoa production,
about 45 percent of total production would be lost to pests and diseases (Tijani,
security in Nigeria have led to increased health and environmental concerns and
studies rarely take into consideration their effects on the environment and on
Dey et al., (2013), pesticides are applied to the environment with the aim of
suppressing the impact of plant and animal pests and to protect agricultural and
and human health, the importance of using safe pesticides has assumed global
Pesticides can also improve the nutritional value of food and sometimes its safety
(Boxall, 2001; Narayanasamy, 2006). There are also many other kinds of benefits
that may be attributed to pesticides, but these benefits are often unnoticed by the
general public (Cooper and Dobson 2007; Damalas, 2009). Thus, from this point of
Crop farmers use a wide range of pesticides at different levels to reduce losses
from pests and diseases. However, despite the popularity and extensive use of
pesticides by farm households, serious concerns about the health risks arising from
the exposure when mixing and applying pesticides or working in treated fields and
residues on food and in drinking water for the general population have been raised
(Maroni, 2006; Soares and Porto, 2009). These activities have caused a number of
accidental occupational poisonings, and even the use of pesticides routinely can
pose serious health risks to farmers both in the short and the long run and can
risks of exposure due to the use of toxic chemicals that are banned and/or restricted
inappropriate spraying equipment, inadequate storage practices, and often the reuse
of old pesticide containers for food and water storage (Ibitayo, 2006; Asogwa and
Dongo, 2009).
high throughout the world in the last decade in contrast to other dangerous
occupations (International Labour Organization ILO, 1997). Agricultural farm
developed countries such as the US, farmers and farm workers comprise only 3
percent of the workforce, but they account for as much as 8% of all work-related
consume, which are responsible for as much as 1.1 million (70 percent) of the total
agriculture. Pesticides are known to find their way in the blood systems of human
beings through four major routes which are the mouth, nose, intact skin and the
pesticides may be acute or delayed (chronic) in those who are exposed. Several
adverse health effects are known to result from exposure to pesticides including
Poorly regulated and unsafe use of pesticides coupled with the absence of adequate
education has led to increasing pesticide impact on public health and, in particular,
on the health of farm workers (Tijani, 2006a). At the same time, the indiscriminate
following revelations about high levels of DDT in the environment and human
breast milk (Osibanjo, 2002). Deyet al., (2013) posited that the public health
effects of pesticides have long been known and the undesired effects of chemical
pesticides have been recognized as a serious public health concern during the past
decades. However, the methods for safe storage, handling and application of
pesticides are not widely used in most developing countries (Dinham, 2003),
seedling to storage and is responsible for 15-100% and 10-60% of the pre and
Shiferaw, Prasanna, Hellin, & Bänziger, 2011). Pesticides use all over the
less labour intensive and has a higher output per a hectare of land, for the
improvement of crop yield, protection of crop quality and its reliability, as well as
reducing the production cost. Aside from pesticides being used in agriculture,
Though the benefits of pesticide use are enormous, research has shown that its use
is associated with some important environmental and health damages (Kumari &
Reddy, 2013; Mahmood et al., 2016). The World Health Organization estimates
that there are three million severe acute poisonings worldwide each year and out of
in developing countries such as Nigeria. The risks are really high on those
who are exposed to the pesticides occupationally, but the demand for maize
would cause the intensification of pesticide use inevitably due to the invasion
of pest and demand for high-quality yields (Popp et al., 2013; Okoffo et al.,
The main aim of this study is to assess the level of pesticides use, safety practices
iii. Determine the effect of pesticides on the rice farmers’ health in the study
area.
iv. Suggest effective measures that will improve pesticides safety practice
during cultivation and storage. Achieving sustainable food security for the
burgeoning population can only be achieved through the proper use of pesticides to
as to avoid health hazards associated with abuse in usage of pesticides. Hence, the
The study covers the assessment of the level of pesticide use, safety practice
compliance and health hazards among rice farmers in Ishiagu. The field operations
and analysis will be carried out in Ishiagu, Ivo Local Government Area of Ebonyi
State, so the results obtained are limited to this scope. The estimated time required
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Agricultural and Household Pest – their Varieties, Classes and Damages
they do
A pest is any animal or plant harmful to humans or human concerns. The term is
particularly used for creatures that damage crops, livestock, and forestry or cause a
practiced, pests have attacked, destroying part or even all of the crop. In modern
usage, the term pest includes animals (mostly insects), fungi, plants, bacteria, and
viruses.
Pests are known to have negative impact on crop production as well as on human
health (Tinyami et al., 2014). The word “pest” describes an organism that damages
insects, fungi, and bacteria that lead to a loss of crops or reduction in crop yield
relative to potential yield that would be possible in a world without pests (Sexton
et al., 2007). Pest attack in agriculture is usually observed both on the field and
during period of storage of agricultural crops most especially in cereal production.
Shamser et al. (1976) reported that the attack by various insect pests causes
damage to plant foliate, stems, buds, flowers, fruits and seeds resulting in
considered as pests are plants or animals that carry disease, cause disease or
rodents, herbs, shrubs, mites and annelids. Pest may also be referred to as
organisms that destroy crops or man-made structures. In its broadest sense, a pest
because they cause reduction in yield and quality of output. They also act as vector
of diseases and cause injuries to man and animals (Cotton et al., 2000; Gore and
Schal, 2007). Pest differs by region and what is common in one region of the
country, may not in other regions. The word pest also refers to myriad of
household invading creature including: mice, roaches, termite, bedbug, fleas, wild
bird, spider and snake. Pest constitute nuisance, annoys and transmit epidemic
A large number of insects such as cockroaches, bed bugs, flies, rodents, birds and
mites occur in the human environment. Many of these are considered pest because
of their economic, medical or aesthetic influence on the quality of life (Gore and
Schal, 2007). This group of animals are adapted to the habitat and conditions
further developed to provide living and recreation space for people and pest. In
some location, human structures and activities may interfere with natural
environment and this will disrupt the natural equilibrium of the environment and
thus make a hitherto non-pest to become a pest, creating pest problem (Samways,
1989). The urban population is expected to increase the importance of urban pest
include mosquitoes, housefly, rodent, flies and termite among others. Mosquito
was reported as most importance and abundance in urban, sub-urban and rural
environment (Yap and Foo, 1984). With the increasing problem caused by the
urban pest, there is a need for their control which is generally archived by chemical
control and integrated control (Tidwell et al., 1994; WHO, 1986; Mars, 1993;
Rozendaal, 1997; Castle et al., 1999). Other convectional measures include surface
Household insecticide products (HIPS) and repellent, coil and aerosol are major
household insecticide products that are readily used by consumers (Yap and Foo,
1984; Yap 1996, 1999; Yap et al., 2003a). In 2010, the World Health Organization
estimated that there were 216 million cases of malaria; about 660,000 people died
from the disease, most of whom were children under the age of five
significantly higher, as precise statistics are unavailable in many rural areas, and
many cases are undocumented. Malaria is commonly associated with poverty, and
Despite a clear need, no vaccine offering a high level of protection currently exists.
Likewise, House flies are considered to be polyphagous species, which means that
they can feed on a wide variety of food material (West, 1951). They acquire their
nutrients mostly from animal dung, human food and garbage (Bernard, 2003).
House flies, can act as very effective disease vectors because of their behavior and
production and 90 thus ensure food security. Traditional techniques had been used
manipulation of planting dates, the setting of 92 traps and the selection of resistant
varieties.
synthetic 94 pesticides. This has been found to provide means of reducing pest
populations massively in a 95 more effective and large-scale manner than had ever
been possible before. However, this has 96 not brought an end to the pest problem.
dangers of pesticide use which is becoming more evident and the high cost and
develop within a relatively short period of time. These strains have been
and weeds. Thus complete reliance on pesticides for crop pest management does
not appear to be a promising strategy for food security. This led to studies on
alternative approaches which are not totally new but integrate all available
Cultural control
The use of cultural control in pest management involves changes in the cultural
practices for the crop production in such a way that creates unfavourable
conditions for the development of pest populations (Taylor 1976). They are usually
the most economical of all pest control measures and are widely applicable and
compatible with other control methods. They are numerous and varied and a few
that have been used successfully in the control of pests of some major crops in
Crop rotation
Soil-borne pathogens that infect plants of one or few species can sometimes be
reduced in the soil by planting for 2–4 years crops belonging to species not
attacked by the particular pathogen. The losses due to Sclerotia rolfsii on tomato
can be reduced when cereals are planted after tomato in a rotation (Wokocha
1988). Crop rotation with other non-host crops causes reduction in soil seed bank
Time of planting
Early sowing of groundnut reduces the incidence and severity of groundnut rosette
virus infection. Maize and sorghum can escape stem borer (Busseola fusca) attack
if sown early. Sesame planted early at the onset of rains had low incidence of gall
late sown than early sown crops (Nweke 1978). Early planting reduces the severity
Sanitation
Partial burning of sorghum stalks immediately after grain harvest was found to kill
95% of the Busseola fusca larvae without damage to the stalks (Adesiyun & Ajayi
spoilage of vegetables, fruits, tubers etc. (Erinle & Karikari 1988). The Cotton
‘close season’ law ensures that all cotton plants and debris are destroyed by
Tillage
(Akobundu 1987). Ploughing after harvest also 148 destroys stubble, weeds and
other alternative hosts of Stem-borer. Tilling soils infested with 149 grasshopper
eggs exposes them to desiccation and predation by insects and birds. This has 150
Intercropping
Mixed cropping and intercropping are known to reduce insect pest infestations. A
sorghum intercrop with pigeon pea markedly reduces the incidence of the soil-
borne wilt disease (Fusarium udum) of pigeon pea, even at high pathogen levels in
the soil. Intercropping cowpea 164 with cereals lowers the population of insects on
cowpea.
Trap cropping
Trap cropping uses a mixture of dwarf pigeon pea and sunn hemp (Crotolaria
juncea) planted all around the cowpea field in advance so that they flower long
before the cowpeas and attract thrips which cause 60% damage to cowpea. In a
sorghum and millet intercrop, the inability of Busseola fusca adults to effectively
utilize millet for oviposition reduces larval infestation of sorghum stems. Soybean,
cowpea, cotton and bambarra groundnut, when grown in rotation with a host
1999). Garden egg (Solanum gilo) acts as trap crop when planted around a desired
crop in order to control grasshoppers (Zonocerus variegatus) since the nymphs like
to congregate on garden egg 189 (Ozolua 1989). The insects can then be controlled
Mechanical barriers
vertical sides in front of advancing larvae of army worm, Spodoptera exempta, has
been found to be effective in preventing their movement into unifested areas
(Anonymous 1984). Hermatic or air tight storage reduces the degree of infestation
Biological control
One of the success stories of a biocontrol approach in Nigeria is that against the
84%. Apoanagyrus lopezi was found to be the most effective natural enemy of
cassava mealy bug. Ajayi (1985) identified insect pests of pearl millet, Pennisetum
including six predators and 32 parasitoids. The control of gall midge by natural
enemies has also been reported (Chadha 1975). The development and use of fungi
products are now available for the control of various insect pests including thrips
anisopliae and Beauveria bassiana indicated good activity against apterous adults
resistances to several pests have been developed for many crops. This has been a
e.g., IITA and ICRISAT. For example, groundnut breeding work at IAR and
SAMNUT 10, 11, 14, 16, 17 and 18 were released. SAMNUT 10, 11 and 16 are
resistant to both chlorotic and green rosette virus diseases and are moderately
cultivars MDR8-15 and MDR8-19 were resistant to virus diseases, rust and
leafspots (Salako 1987). Host plant resistance is an important method for the
control of root knot nematodes. In Nigeria, Babatola and Idowu (1990) identified
provides protection of the crop is a very valuable gift to the resource-poor farmers.
The most common and useful method of classifying pesticide is based on their
classification that gives the clue about the efficacy, physical and chemical
Based on chemical composition, pesticides are classified into four main groups
general, modern pesticides are organic chemicals. They include pesticides of both
synthetic and plant origin. However, some inorganic compound is also used as
pesticides. Insecticides are important pesticides that can be further classified into
several sub-classes
1. Insecticides – insects
2. Herbicides – plants
4. Bactericides – bacteria
5. Fungicides – fungi
6. Larvicides – larvae
Biodegradable:
The biodegradable kind is those which can be broken down by microbes and
Persistent:
While the persistent ones are those which may take months or years to break
down.
Another way to classify these is to consider those that are chemical forms or are
Chemically-related pesticides:
Organophosphate:
Carbamate:
Similar to the organophosphorus pesticides, the carbamate pesticides also affect the
Organochlorine insecticides:
They were commonly used earlier, but now many countries have been removed
environmental effects and their persistence (e.g., DDT, chlordane, and toxaphene).
Pyrethroid:
Sulfonylurea herbicides:
The sulfonylureas herbicides have been commercialized for weed control such as
Biopesticides:
The biopesticides are certain types of pesticides derived from such natural
Consumers’ behaviour
Great care should be taken during storage, transportation and pesticide use.
management can suppress pests (Damalas, 2016; Farrar et al., 2018). Health belief
model (HBD) can be the right choice regarding farmer’s behaviour (Sharifzadeh et
al., 2019). Such problems can be solved by following means of external and
internal stimuli, and launching of new policies and monitoring strategies for safe
use of pesticides (Bhandari et al., 2018; Rezaei et al., 2018). External stimuli
include the provision of required knowledge, guidance and proper training can help
itching and headache, can modify the farmer’s choice of pesticide use.
Pesticide Storage
Pesticides are critical for crop production enhancement, but they can be dangerous
avoid safety issues during their storage (Saleem and Haq, 2002; Tariq et al., 2007).
Pesticide storage place must be isolated from the populated and sensitive areas like
water bodies and residential areas. Pesticides store must not be accessible by
food or beverage storehouse. Stored pesticides must be kept dry, in the shade and
distant from chances of fire. Do not carry them in a vehicle that is also used to
transport food.
i Stores should be constructed away from sensitive areas like residential and
iii Design of the stores should be sound that it can contain spillage and leakage.
v Use of any kind of flame and smoking should be prohibited in the area.
viii Make sure that stores have appropriate first aid facilities, clothing place,
During transportation
Pesticides should be transported with great care because any leakage may lead to
serious environmental and health hazards in addition to the pesticide wastage. Such
i Packing material and containers should be sound enough to avoid any kind
of rupture or leakage.
iii During transport, different kinds of pesticides should not be mixed or other
insecticides or fertilizers.
vi Use protective gloves and proper clothing during the loading and unloading
vii Traces of pesticides should not be present on the outer surface of the
container.
viii During transportation, ensure that lids of the container are tightly closed.
ix Avoid fire, smoking, eating and drinking during pesticide handling
the safe use. These principles have been listed below, which may help to get
ii Do not allow children to make contact with pesticides and keep them away
iii Keep irrelevant people away from the area where pesticides are being
applied.
v Observe the weather conditions that may affect the pesticide applications,
especially wind velocity, which may cause drift. This may blow away the
pesticides making it useless for the field as well as harmful for the areas
vi Rain is also an important factor that can wash out pesticides from the field,
viii Do not siphon with mouth even from an empty container. Use clean water to
xiii Do not use pesticides without training and children (under 18) are prohibited
After pesticide application, make sure that the treated area is clean and does not
contain any pesticide waste, container or envelope and equipment is empty and
clean. Never reuse empty envelops, pesticide packing and containers for drinking
and eating purposes for animals or people. All empty containers should be
i Wash and puncture metal canes and drums and bury them.
ii Wash and puncture plastic containers, burn them and bury.
iv Plastic bags should be burnt in the areas away from dwellings, crops and
stores etc.
v Use mask during burning and keep children away from its smoke.
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The area of the researchers study is within the geographical location of Ishiagu in
Ivo Local Government Area of Ebonyi State. Ishiagu town is located in Ivo LGA
of Ebonyi State between latitude 5° 54’ – 5° 59’ N and longitudes 7° 30’ – 7° 35’
E. The area (about 25 sq.km), is situated in the SW tip of the Abakaliki Basin on
lying sedimentary terrain with some intrusions of different episodes. The Ishiagu
rifting of the Lower Benue Trough during the early Cretaceous separation of
Africa and America [6]. The Pb-Zn deposits in Ishiagu area appear to be the
southern limit of mineralization in the Benue Trough and the Pb-Zn mineralized
zone extends over a distance of 500 km in a narrow belt from Ishiagu in the lower
Benue Trough to Zurak in the upper Benue Trough, likewise the extent of igneous
intrusions in the Benue Trough. Majority of the geologic and topographic features
of the area align in the NW-SE direction, and conform to orientation of the folds
The instrument used for data collection was the questionnaires which is close
ended questions that was submitted and gained approval of the researcher’s
supervisor.
collected in the same manner. The relevant variables of the study were effectively
in Ishiagu.
Multi-stage sampling technique was used to collect the data involving a four -
stage sampling procedure. Three (3) wards were selected from the rural wards in
the Ishiagu in stage one. In the second stage, two (2) communities were randomly
third stage, twenty (20) residential buildings were randomly selected in each of the
communities making a total of 120 residential buildings. One farm household was
selected each of the residential building making a total of 120 respondents. Data
used for the study were collected with the aid questionnaire. Data were collected
The researcher collected the data from the respondent’s one on one. The researcher
utilized the two effective method of data collection; these are the oral interview
and the questionnaire. Oral interview because of its advantages of giving more in
depth information.
However, the questionnaires were personally distributed and the researcher made
the collection. This is to enable their opinion without been bias on the role of
Simple table, frequency and percentages were adopted in the presentation and
analysis of data generated for the study. These statistical tools were used because
they were suitable means of breaking down and analyzing the generated data. The
X2 = ∑(O-E)2
Where O = Observed
frequency
Expected
E =
frequency
∑ = Summation
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1 Summary
This study assessed the level of pesticides use, safety practices compliance and
health hazards among rice farmers in Ishiagu. Results from the study revealed
much misuse and abuse of pesticides, which may have contributed to their health
discomforts ranging from skin irritation, headache, vomiting, eye irritation and
nausea after using pesticides. This was attributed to the low level of education of
users coupled with a lack of formal training in pesticide use, poor extension
services, inadequate education and safety systems. The Tobit model results showed
that exposure, frequency of exposure and pesticide cocktails were the most
area.
5.2 Conclusion
There are several pests that affect the food crops in Nigeria, some of which have
been 294 described in this paper. Their effect is a major constraint to crop
production which then affects food security. There are hazards, high cost,
development of resistance by pest etc. associated with the use of pesticides. There
is a need to focus more on several cultural practices, use of biopesticides and IKS
practices; they should be involved in the formative stages rather than after major
5.3 Recommendations
The study indicates that the rice farmers of Ishiagu are not more conscious about
the proper use of pesticide, so this kind of injudicious use of pesticide causes
So, to protect the aquatic environment as well as reduce the occupational health
hazard of the rice farmers, the DAE (Department of Agricultural Extension), DoF
programs for providing effective training on use and adverse effects of pesticides.
by the use of different print and electronic media. If possible then amend “The
Pesticide Act” and include the environmental protection issue as well as proper
guideline to the pesticide user. After all, this study was confined in three villages in
a single union. More studies are needed throughout the country to elucidate the